#protection
1 messages · Page 1500 of 1
sweet ill have a look
If not raid and keys then you can do one then the other and compare results
requires some lvl of premium
I thought there was a version that was free? You just can't be specific and it Sims EVERY drop
for free you can sim one dungeon at once, but if you want all M+ loot its paywalled
raid is also free
smart person doesnt need to pay if you know what you are looking for
im not tellin taht ppl are dumm.. i had sub there aswell 😄 but now im okay with the free version
shield
it realy depends on what you have, what type of player you are, what content are you doing
but general consensus is to get your arms heavy
big sword and big shield
following with tier
asuming you did not get weapon or shield from your vault
nop
you can send it to weap and shield
im waiting on gilded craft in 2 weeks
used up my enchanted runed crest we got off dimensius
I rly dont know what to pick from this dogshit vault 🙁
belt or antenna if u wont raid too much i g
you can play ascendant and crit on shield
Belt i guess, at least it got socket
then belt its also good stats
isnt cursed idol really good for damage? 1:30 is every second avatar no?
its good, but during the cast you are giving your hands up
aye
I mean you can get hit, no block/dodge/parry
in aoe its not gonna shine
you take it for priority target dmg
or boss dmg which is also important in keys
aye it went top right off with tome
1/8 drop uuhhh
good thing is i guess u can just spam +6
is tome highest damage trinket for a tank?
myth track legs
yes
i have a myth soleah tech do u think i swap it for a hero tome?
100%
already spent cata charge last week 
but yeah i guess it's the pick
so you can use next week and lock the slot
was thinking about hero dimensius ring tbh to be stronger this week for raid and stuff
but idk what cosmic damage even is
Arcane, holy, nature, shadow
Isnt it cosmis specific ? Like that a special type of dmg ? Does it contin all of those ?
Oye, if we Mythic raid, we always go for wrists/belt for craft right ?
no all the weird ones like "volcanic" or "stormstrike" are combinations of the types of player damage
volcanic is fire+nature etc
But i would still go with myth legs , u get partial free upgrade on your curent ones and u can cata later
tbh i might craft boots
we're bottom prio for DH boots
and my guild has 0 plate drops so far
i'm not gonna get DH boots for a while
i didnt spend a single runed or gilded yet. I should take shield, craft 1h, upgrade shield (gilded) and upgrade caeseless (runed) right? and just accept i wont have 4p unless im lucky in raid
I would craft boots after belt and wrists
take shield, make it 720, craft weapon 720 and you can craft another 720 this week
and you will do the last upgrade next week
ty
U can trade raid items regadles of ilvl restriction right ? As long as its within 2h
yes
Good gotta abuse some friends, thanks
Hello, do i do 2+2 or wait for 4 set?

Or just try it like unless your doing mythic raiding what is the harm im running 2 2 atm but im not looking to do a world first lol
Because its probably weaker* to go 2p2p ( depends on his ilvls) and people tend to care about their character power. Its also kinda nice when other people u play with respect your time and effort by not playing meme things
quick question.. what should i craft next after shield
Just how bad is Symbiotic Ethergauze?
weapon probably
depends on the alternatives
it's not a good trinket for us in general
alternatives being tome/pacemaker from last season
try to sim it on st boss damage
holy fuck it is garbage in the sims, doesn't speak to its defensive value tho
Gauze is not worth it for damage or defensive value
also, look at how fucking majestic the sprite of that bat is
what i imagine goblin DH would look like in demon form
what embellishment should I use on crafted weapon?
tldr: keep it on sword mode, when it hits 50 stacks itll swap to shield, activate on use to swap it back. rinse and repeat
So Pacemaker is bad trinket now? Blah, just farmed it at HC version and now I read this... 😞
wouldnt say its bad
There are many trinkets worse than pacemaker, there are only a handful of better ones
Which one you think is better Curse Stone Idol vs Pacemaker? Stone Idol sims a lot more.
If you were to go off this alone, there's not much in it
Whats the other trink you're using?
I think pace is better; idol has the channel; it can do more with CDs… but there’s a inherent risk
I took myth pace over myth idol this week
I figure I’d wear pace all the time whereas for push keys idol might just be too much hassle
Yeah pace is simple and reliable, one of our best trinkets
At least, that was my thought process
The best trinket is the one you actually use, if you forget to activate an on use trinket then go for the passive one
Brand and Pace, also have Idol in bags. Brand is Champion track
Brand is very good
so like Brand+Pace is a great combo
Idol+Pace also not bad
but yea, risk to playing Idol cause of the channel time where you are left vulnerable
it is fun though
I have a myth version on my BDK
Brand+Pace is low thought high yield, Brand+Idol is more active but higher reward in theory
That'll come down to playstyle
I'm Colossus. Dont want to play Thane, no matter how damage output is high
so really, if you deciding between Pace or Idol in vaut; Pace is reliable and consistent, Idol has risk to it, but potentially could preform better
I mean if you're not looking to optimise then your trinket choice doesn't matter
^ this is also true
Since you're opting to play the objectively weaker spec from a damage perspective
I'm looking to optimize for Colossus
Then just sim it, and consider whether you want to play with a risky on-use or not
then just run a sim and pick whatever the robot says
What's the % haste we need to drop ITF?
Ok. Thank you, bros
somewhere in the realm of 20k-25k haste
sick, thanks
Unrelated but interesting to see RWF Brew running nucleus on Nexus King, will have to see if it was actually used
how do you sim ceaseless ire
Needs to be a 5 minute sim
complete noob crafting question, does the type of null stones i put into my weapon matter?
Type of null stones?
Aren’t null stones a crafting mat you get from mining
Yes
it requires 2 null stones, theyre not the same as primatic null stones maybe?
Not sure if this helps but if crafting reagents have ranks (1-3), you want the max rank of them
And put the exact item it asks for
yea thanks, idk if prismatic null stone 3 goes into the 2 slots here tho? or just the completely standard ones
The prisms are a different thing
I wouldnt say it sucks, its just a bit harder to get into
Once you know how it works you realise how dogshit the DF one was compared to what we have now
Remember if you want a shopping list in your quest panel, tick the "track recipe" box and then you dont have to keep a mental note or whisper yourself etc
o shit
When you go to the AH
wait, why drop ITF?
wouldnt the 10% haste be big value at such high haste?
am i missing an embelishment here or should i just find sm1 to craft max rank like this?
Oh wait he said drop ITF??? Honestly I saw ITF and Haste % and autofilled the rest
what carfts are ppl making shield and sword?

made me nervous
ITF gets better with more haste
Don’t drop ITF, you take ITF at 20k+ haste
Did I have it backwards? lol I always mix it up
If you want to add an effect to the wep you need to add an embellishment too
Yeah you drop HR for ITF at high haste
That's right
dawnthread lining or which one should i go for?
I always think it's the other way around for some reason
I think dawnthread is fine, but it depends on your stats
I wouldn’t put an embelly on my weapon because I’d be putting two threads in my gear and I don’t wanna recraft
Whether u need more crit or vers from duskthread
I go with vers, cause I go crit everywhere else
or whatever is lowest
need some balance in my life
Same
Maybe get the duskthread lining then
no haste option
You can put lining on weapons? I thought it was only armor
for weppy, I take the weapon grip
I go vers cuz if you get 200% vers that’s 100% DR and that’s pretty epic and based
It is only armor, yeah
hmm I need to spec into ITF then
ooo


Im still waiting for PC.... I have the cata charges and I can get it
Ngl i didnt even know this existed
but I want to Cata Pantaloons
I just googled it now lol
I forgot about it
but when I crafted my wep yesterday, I just looked at the options on the crafting table and said 'yea, weapon grip sounds good'
and went with it
Should I craft a the weapon to 720 or the shield first?
Shield first
wep second
I would avoid crafting wep if you mythic raid though
first boss drops a weppy
if not, then just send; for heroic/no mythic raiders those are really good slots to craft assuming you dont get stuff from vault
i cant have both focusing lens and wep grip/lining on 1 item (wep) right ? need to pick only 1?@plush tendon
yea, only one embellishment
ok ty
Thanks.
better shield and weapon or waist and wrist like wowhead says?
Shield and Weapon for short term boost, Waist and Wrist are long term
If you myth raid and can reliably kill first two, they drop a wep and shield. Eventaully you'll replace crafted wep/shield with myth
your short term decision can easy become a long term 😄
Its reccomended at this point in the season to go for Shield -> Weapon, unless you got a lucky vault or are reliably killing the first few mythic
why shield before weapon? and weapon with ascendance right?
Shield is the single most important item for prot warrior. More block value -> less damage taken -> more time to do big dam
Its fine yeah
I know belt and wrist are better long term... but like 6 weeks into the season I always stop crafting new gear
Because embellies are such small gains
I am now a believer in the short term gains
I wouldnt stress over embellishments
exactly, at some point you end up taking myth vault items or myth raid drops and it doesnt matter so
I want my big shield and big weapon NOW

ye but whats the biggest damage gain from emblishment
Expedites the gearing process too, if im big now things die faster
thats a sim question
100%
and helps if you are going for hardmode deathless
I want to attempt one this week
didnt get to last week

can a tank main help me abit to pick a alt tank ? how is the current tankmeta is protwar the go to pick atm?
Play a bear theyre very chill
if you want power, Prot War, Prot Pal, Brew, and VDH are all quite good
biased to Prot War in this channel
and blood+bear arent bad
We gave it a shot on monday and then a dps rooted themselves in the puddles on post and dropped dead
Vdh sucks to play and brew is boring
i really like pwar and prot pal guess i gotta flip a coin
The real piece of advice is to ignore the meta and ignore tier lists and play whatever tank looks fun to you
watching my guild do it, the fury warrior zug zug too hard and charged into boss early and got meleeed
Are you pushing bleeding edge keys or hall of fame? if not, play whatever you want
Bruhhhhhh
Hi guys, I’ve never tanked before and I’ve never player a warrior either; I was wondering if there was a guide or someone I can follow in regards to how to play protection warrior in m+ and raid and all aspects of pve etc? Any help would be HUGELY appreciated. Thank you 🙏🏽
I'm of the mind on hard mode for pirate dragon you just tank closer to boat and zerg down adds. Worked great in our run
@undone beacon how hard is it to play pwar?
It isn’t
The wowhead guide for prot warr is a great starting point. Its maintained by our very one Nomeratur
Not that hard
top 3 easiest tank to play
or top 2
I know people say bear is easier... but we splitting hairs on that convo
Keep shield block up, hit shield slam and thunder clap, dump rage into ignore pain/execute/revenge
can you spend into ignore pain a bit again ? wasnt it kinda in S2 that you rather wanted it to be spend int revenge/exe?
I meeeean bear is literally three buttons and BDK self-healing with half the commitment to playing well. Which is why i love it cuz im a brainlet
if you are playing MT, you will be pressing IP a lot
You hit ignore pain if you're going to rage cap, which happens a lot as Thane
BDK is hard to play for a lot of players
a lot of reasource to manage
boneshield, runic power, runes
Yeah including me because im literally a toddler and have -7 iq its great
but in low content, you are basically god
and then in higher content you are made of paper
plus it takes a lot of upfront damage
and theres no saving a BDK
either they play correctly or die
Is it okay to macro ignore ppain into shieldslam?
no
dont macro IP onto your SS button
you can macro SS to your IP button though
you have to embrace the carpel tunnel
So the IP spam is real?
This is a modified version of the weakaura made by Forsberg. You can find the original version here https://wago.io/3VXu
do u guys recommend this wa xd
sure, sounds fine
I have this which shows up only when I should use it https://wago.io/sn2UyJYzl
i wouldve agreed but then my first vault had a myth tome so im back to reading

My biggest question is do I send all my runed crests into rings/trinkets or into pieces of gear
Crest cap annoying AF
Putting it into armor is better ST gain, into rings/trinkets is better AoE gain
my understanding is you only send runed right now if you have 701 in that slot already
so you can finish rune crests this week
but thats like a sweaty optimization
Literally already hit gilded cap this week and havent gotten a single (natty) runed cuz im just running 12s lol
but Im just farming 10s for more 701 loot before sending those upgrades when we try to push some 14s
Yeah ideally I get a hero pants drop so i can upgrade my champ 4/8 legs to 8/8 for freeeeee
hitting the gilded cap is so easy
I do some delves, first one gives me like 17
2 more gets me to 31
then like 3-4 keys and Im done
I've decided I'm only doing delves this season for cosmetics and achievements
I love delves
map gives a free hero piece
and its great for alts where I only do 1 key on them
arenmt maps locked behind a bunch of delve progress tho
yes, delver'sj journey lvl 2
basically if you did your delves last week + a few extra, you would have lvl 2 by now
By the time I get level 2 I won’t care about maps anymore
you could do it last week too
the weekly gets u there
or 3? idk this one:
I had my first map last week yea
but did like 4x an extra bountiful delve
I just don’t be delving like that
Yo guys, can you advise, what to craft second? (I crafter shield first mythic) second is 1h ? or bracers with embe?
delves still be worth it
we should rly pin this.. 😄
especially for alts
1h weap unless you already have myth track
and, more importantly, you can buy LFR loot at the end of the delve track
which can be cataed into LFR tier
I dont have myth weapon in vault
for mog
just HC from King
I like to do 3 runs for easy crests
yeah 1h weap is big upgrade then
yep thats what I will do from this week onwards
do my 3x tier 11 delves with 1x map
I do 4 delves on my alts
then say good bye for the rest of the week
if its fungal folly
man you can get through that delve soo fast
so if they get screwed, I can take max tokens
thats how im treating my bear atm 😄 😄 that fluffy piece of furr is already at 3 pieces of hero tier
meanwhile warr is 0
need 2k IO and then can get 4 pc
the toon is literally 682 I level also
🤣
still strong enough for 10s
like ill get to him once im okay with Warr 😄
so meanwhile he gets 4set
and I can blast
I believe in the 1 key a week on alts
and then hit the crest achievements on main
to get discount
then send on alts
going from 15-10 cost for upgrades is OP
would it be best to craft weapon and shield or shield and wrist?
Cursed stone idol good for prot M+ ?
its a very cool trinket; tried it on my BDK and its a lot of crit
but the channel can be spooky
so from my testing, I wouldnt recommend if pushing
but for weeklies its fun
I went shield and sword first crafts
but I dont raid
and did get shield or sword in vault
i don't raid either
got it in my vault myth track, also got sacbrood, donno what to choose
Ill do bracers next craft week (or, if I get unlucky and get no shield/sword in vault by then maybe Ill send a ring?)
thats hard
I had Pacemaker and Idol in vault this week. I went with Pacemaker
I valued simple over the on-use
since I dont see myself using Idol when pushing
the risk during the channel just not worth it to me over the simple crit proc
yeah i guess
but you can think about what makes more sense for you
if played well, Idol will do more
no question
but sac is a equip and forget trinket and its not bad
true
the channel on Idol can be spooky
but I also see the potential
like on those shard pulls in HoA
would be straight stonks
in low keys that is the play
but a insta shockwave when first starting a pack in a real key is such a no-no
just gonna get things on DR
though Idol plus spear could be really fun
Ill have to play around with it more
Ill get a hero version at some point to try
but safe bet for me was pacemaker
its basically just equipped and forget for the rest of the tier now
brand and tome does not require lot of attention too but yeah i get your point
I dont like tome
im so done with tome
I know its strong... but id rather run Pace and Brand

or one of the other raid trinkets
im still playing my 684 one 😄
I say Im done with Tome, but if a myth version drops in my vault... ill prob suck it up and play it

Hello, are raidbots broken for prot warrior? Im constantly getting errors
you importing from addon or from armory?
addon
delete the tome custom code
would spamming M0 priory until killing baron be a decent way to get tome? or just farm it on +8 or higher for they heroic drop on the end
M0 cant be farmed
ah rip
jsut want to confirm before i waste my sparks. I have a hero shield and my lowest off piece is a veteran bracer. I should craft shield and bracers with lining on them correct?
pls, I assume legs for next week's catalyst right
Pacemaker is a big pickup
chance to get more myth legs > chance to see a specific trinket
seems peopel are crafting a 1h before a shield?
yes, or shield + weapon
Are we rolling Ascension on a crafted weapon until we have enough gilded to craft bracers with Duskthread?
im doing shield + weapon
Likely you'll wear it on every boss unless you have something notably better
crafted a weapon and maxed my hero shield to 710, should i craft bracers in this case? or craft shield
I would go legs, yes
arcanocore and tome seem to sim way better on ST
just from what I already have
pacemaker is decent, but in the end you're going to drop pacemaker anyways as soon as you get Brand & Tome
i got a hero weapon so i figure i dont need to craft that?
I would still go for the weap
Brand + Tome is your ideal combo for ST
Take what you want but I'll always point towards trinkets as the chance of seeing another pacemaker is going to be far lower than finding myth legs to make tier
Hey guys Ive got a myth one hander and a maxed hero shield, do I just craft 2 duskthreads in offpieces now?
taht is true
I was thinking about crafting the shield anyway
and with in-season buffing and nerfes happening, maybe you want pacemaker in a few weeks
very slowly, I'm in a turbo-boost CE guild
6/8 HC now
jesus, im not at that point yet 🙁
holy dmg
ya wtf am i doing wrong lol
mind sharing your build?
3 dungeons 2 delves no spark yet wtf -_-
I was hitting 2,3m average over priory +10 yesterday
so not getting close to those numbers yet lmao
did u 1 button it
ofcourse not
LMAO
but was without 4-set still, so maybe with 4-set I should get lot higher
and bad trinks 😐
just a bit lmao, all good
I did like 3.8 mil in a Priory with old 4 st (but I also pull like a monkey)
your damage will go up
hmm alr
with more practice
will pug a lot of prio's this week I think to farm the tome

You should do that next week
Because I dont have mine yet
🥲
We'll all just take turns queueing for priory
thre's more than enough tank depraved parties that need tanks
This week is my turn
guys we are getting nerfed right
Man.
Man, this 4 piece is silly.
just finished top 5 dps on loom at a 25man h raid
it was fun
sad it wont last
😢
We should shut down the prot discord in protest
we could always start sandbagging like gaslighting people like balance druids
how can we convince people this is fake?
probably
claim it was from before the DEVASTATING nerf
I have this shield, would it still be worth crafting one having in mind that the second boss drops one?
they look at tuning of RWF and MDI teams anyways to somewhat tune the classes, and they cant hold back lmao
dungeon slice, myth legs sim better than myth pacemaker
dont dungeon slice; 5 target, 1 min/1.5 min sim for aoe
also, you have to think about rarity
whats easier to get, myth legs or myth pacemaker
already pointed this out yeah
But people dont seem to care
I'm trying to sim for bosses 3-5
pacemaker is also guaranteed from turbo boost if I wanted
but maybe it's better to use it on raid trinkets idk
In three months minimum
yeah I guess 2-5k dps isn't worth passing on the pacemaker deal
I think turbo boost would be sooner no?
if pacemaker is bis for M+ at least
At the end of the day take whatever you want, but you asked for advice and I gave you my advice
I appreciate it
11.1 was Feb 25th, turbo boost dropped may 13th
$5
or a vault pic
Either way both will be an upgrade so you win no matter what, which is more than i can say on my druid
Two myth wrists two myth wrists
:sadbear:
running priory on repeat is making my brain go numb
Change up the route. Go left, then right. Keep it fresh yo
Be kind to yourself and others
use inky black, then stinky bright
yea, you arent far off
change up the dungeon
farming for specific gear is so lame

so sweaty and try hard
gross
Guys what is a good second craft if I crafted a weapon on my prot
last season I've done 100+ motherlodes and 50+ floodgates across my characters
the only thing i hard farmed last season, and never FUCKING saw\
was the motherlode schematic
but...but trinkets!
The dire state of my trinkets
This is all I have
nothing else has dropped for me
why do you hate me, game
just get good trinkets first try
also, there are plenty of dungeons with good trinkets
like, Ara, Priory, Halls, Floodgate, Gambit
all have decent trinkets
no reason to just spam one over and over again
youll go insane
I've run Ara, gambit, and floodgate so many times, those trinkets aren't real either.
Haven't seen any of them drop a single time
im just against doing the same dungeon dozens of times
unless I have homies with me
Wait, no.
I saw ONE secret technique. That went to our priest
Still running Pacemaker from last season, and the suboptimal Dimmy trinket cause nobody wanted it.
i've run like 30 between the dungeons i need for trinkets. my fk'ing alt gets myth pace maker in vault from the SINGLE 10 he did
Usually the case, alt luck is a filthy thing
Ty
its like, you do a dungeons solo for loot you have a 40% chance of getting a drop
then, depending on the dungeon you have a 1/10 (estimate odds) of getting the piece you want
Yeah solo pugging to gear is adding extra levels of difficulty I agree.
so its like a 4% chance of getting the item you want
we do get 4 sparks this week or?
Why is good after get haste get critic? more parry?
Second total spark yeah
my 4th spark is just not dropping
Generally best for damage and parry is good for m+, but all stats are close for us, just sim upgrades
lmao im so dumb just turned in the quest and got it xd
I am very aware of how absolutely awful the changes of getting the trinket are, but Man.
Relying on my guildies to get priory keys, be online, and be down to do dungeons together takes forever
I tend to go with haste>Crit>=vers>mastery
I love how we use >=
I dont have the one underneath
“they’re basically equal but I LIKE crit better”

I do try to go for the lowest key I can that still gives hero track
8 items in priory tank pool its bit rough
ok, so 5% chance each run to get tome assuming no one can trade or will trade
Hmm...doing ara kara set to fury only has 4 items.
But ara kara sucks and I hate it.
If you want to know if youve been unlucky, you do this 1-(.95)^N
N being the number of runs
I spent all my luck getting 4 piece
EX: if youve done 27 runs of Priory, you had a 75% chance of getting tome already
I’ve done 2 raids on normal and whatever lfr I am able to do and filled all vault slots and have 0 new tier and no tome lol

if i don’t get every item on the first attempt, i curse god for forsaking me
Question when does the mountain thane/colossus become available to choose? I’m like level 41-42 rn
level 71
Oh I’m nowhere near then lol
keep grinding dem levels king
is streets/gambit giving both dungeon pool loot still?
those levels are kinda quick tbh, you’ll be there soon
nah dont think so anymore
im tryin i feel like i should go back to doing dungeons bc campaign wasn’t feeding me much exp compared to them
classic dungeons are good since you usually get a few quests to turn in too
also timewalking was good last time i leveled?
timewalking is very strong for leveling
I like to mix it up with questing and dungeons
but I assume Uthal is a new player
and hes forced into dragonflight, right?
Forced into dragonflight unless you go to chromie time and choose a timeline I think
Hello, is that trinket a simbait ? It says in the tooltip that range attack trigger the trinket, or am I missing something ?
rend procs it
its not affected by the -30% damage for being a tank
rend is range, noted 😄
you can
small chance
have to run hardmode and someone has to trade it to you
from end of dungeon box
if ppl are degen enough to farm hm taz and get ppl to trade it then
fair
but i cba
itll prob be nerfed tbh
yes
I have heroic antenna in vault and a helm mythic track with gem (haste mastery, but can catalyst next week).
Currently using Ire and Tome of light devotion as trinkets. What should I pick ?
helm
u have socketed tier helm m track in vault?
Yes
I’ve heard a few people talking about some wa package known as northern sky
Anyone have any experience with it? Should I turn my raid group onto it?
i deleted that bloated shit as soon as i could
but apparently it helps raids on certain bosses yea
Is it primarily just a wa package for raid like a lot of others
Or is there extra setup or something
What’s the haste breakpoint for shield block 100% uptime
20-21k haste
Ty Ty
it has also some assignments, but they are not needed on hc or early mythic bosses
as a tank, you dont even need the ful package
do we care a bout leech or avoidance on gear? got shoulder choices with either on mythic track or a crit haste avoidance chest
i mean most likely it gets catalyzed right in a shoulder slot?
yea, but that chest (if myth track) has perfect stats
and the stats on tier chest are meh
and you cant get a haste/crit chest on myth track except vault
plus it has avoidance
like, thats giga no? someone correct me if Im wrong
Hi all, I asked on reddit and they sent me here: xD
on diff sites, the prot talents include some around execute: Red Right Hand, Heavy handed, and Massacre...
But they don't take sudden death... in my mind it would make sense to take it... the only reason I can come up with is that the proc rate is abysmal... is that right???
im new to prot but i dont have a spare gcd currently for that in M+, maybe in raid it could be used?
its opprotunity cost
its a float point with instegate u will get more out of instigate most of the time
Approximately [1.7 + Haste] procs per minute
looking at the builds on wowhead, for raid you take bloodsurge+sudden death
but in M+ you opt for Last Stand and Thunderlords
so torn on what to craft, I have a hero weapon and shield, is double dawnthread + a hero weapon we the play? or make a weapon and shield and wait on the next off piece in weeks?
I went shield and sword for my first crafts
I dont Mythic raid and those are my biggest upgrades
until vault
its not BiS, off pieces like bracers+belt will be BiS later... but I want the power now
Yeah went shield and sword for my 720’s aswell, same reason that I never do mythic raid and vault is to fickle to rely on a fast wep and shield
good enoghu for me, i dont raid either
I'll get more out of you most of the time
Fuckin gottem
so what is the main difference between dusktheread and dawnthread? liek why choose vers over crit or the other way around?
Oh man so last night im playing with friends on dead by daylight and the lobby was taking forever to fill and I end up trying to have a conversation in Spanish (I dont speak Spanish much) with some dude and finally I was like im out of Spanish and said yo quiero taco bell. The Spanish speaker said cinnamon twist dn. My friend in voice thought it was some sort of Spanish abbreviation and was like "dn?" and I knew it was my time. I was like "CINNAMON TWIST DEEZ NUTZ" and we all died laughing. It was awesome.
If you have a lot of crit, vers might be better and vice versa
Just a sim angle
and 25% crit lol
Doesn't matter. They're about equal anyway
figured
More stats is better than specific stats
I currently have 0 tier pieces, do I take veteran legs tier piece or non-tier mythic chest (mastery/crit) from vault?
Myth chest
is there such thing as too much haste lol
its not that rend is ranged, its that the mailmental procs off of bleeds
sim says its low value but obviously thats only accounting for dps
not sheild block uptime nd stuff
Can anyone explain to me how positioning the adds on Araz to absorb the damage expulsion on the pillars works? The raid damage is insane
My foolproof trinket loot stategy for floodgate did not work.
on the plus side, I now have a....decent weapon for arms?
and I'm also no longer capped on valor stones, so that's nice
Use em or lose em as they say
uh oh , looks like we're crafting a weapon 1st . Is it worth adding ASC on it ? or just make it plane nad stick with double crit/vers on off parts
Depends how soon you think you'll end up making an embellish piece and/or if you're rich
If you don't care about having to recraft later and it'll be a while before you make wrists, then might as well embellish weapon
ye atm. i have old 681 wrists and boots with double vers emb. so i'd have to remove it if im taking ASC on weapon
some1 know if Codex of the First Technique is already fixed ? or still bugged?
On Bloodmallet - 0,005% dmg increase.... & pulling from 100 yards etc... so not worth it mh ?
Codex sucks
aight thx
why are ppl asking if its fixed?
its not bugged
they changed it to be worse than it already way
Qhat is the correct way to do arakara after boss 1 where you can go left or write? I am going right and group is failing to cc the thing that turns into big bug and that is getting pulled with another big bug. The 2 big bugs do some sort of AOE and everyone in group dies
that's on the group
the allerting beetle is a primal focus in all those pulls either on right or left side
if they go off that's a group failure
both right and left side work
Which is better? The less big bugs the better
if group is pepega i am spinning shield charge storm bolt and shockwave as a last resort
i personally go left
i went right as well especially first season
Yea I burn through all those and then he turns into big bug
the cast time is 10s
With idiotos in group
Right is icky
that looks like a shoulder angle to me
if it doesn't fall in 30s we have a problem
Can pwar solo cc it?
you never insta stun it
No i wait till end
storm bolt has 30s cd shockwave has 25s with 3 targets which are the pulls that include the beetle
You've got shout, bolt, shockwave, SC, you can lock them down for a good minute or two
how do you run out of stuns?
Disruptor aoe taunt stops the guy from turning big?
intimidating
i miss the codex discussions from shadowlands
Bro what is up with ranged and pulsar
Why are you just STANDING THERE WITH THIS FLYING ORB AROUND YOU.
God damn pillow princess, doesn't wanna do ANY of the work to clear the mechanic
Idk your group either ignores it or u overlap CCs too early and make him imune
What actually happens is that a lot of times I'm trying to get aggro on everything and dogle the big guys frontal thing and interrupt that poison cast and stuns get overlapped and then 2 big bugs kill us and then the +10 depletes
Fear isn't the same DR as stun izzit?
Actually I don't have intimidated shout
Says dawn or dusk lining, is there a stat line I should get before deciding or does it not matter?
With bis you'll have a lot of Crit, which makes verse more attractive
Wowhead pwar colossos shows that talent as illegal
Hey y'all have a quick question. How important is rend in the Mountain Thane M+ rotation? I've watched like 3 videos and none of them mentioned utilizing rend in their rotation
For both weekly key and push talents
Wowhead build didn't take crashing thunder for the longest time either
Gotcha, tysm
Ohh I didn't know wowhead talents were not best. Can pls link best talents for m+ thane and colossas
?
If i have 100 hp and then I am down to 50 hp bc i took damage and then I rally, does my max hp go to 110 and current hp go to 60 (because 10% of 100 is 10)?
it's based off your maximum health, not your current health
Yes. In my example my max hp without rally = 100
My current hp = 50. Then I rally, so now my new hp current hp is 60?
It increases your hp by 10% of max and heals you for that much yes
So yes
Rally is trash cd, especially in m+. It was decent when it was 30%.
Just drop it
But what if the healing is hurting due to aoe damage? I guess that's like.. not my problem get good 
Both fear and rally are kinda niche imho , like they are cases where both of them can save someone/key , probably both situations can be prevented so pick your poison i guess
Rally has niche use as a tool to save people
But yes overall it’s kinda poo
In m+ I just consider it a shittier health pot I can apply to someone externally
It’s 2-2.5m health
Hello there
I have around 22k haste and 20k critical
Is it normal that versatility enchant on weapon, sim like a +6,8% dmg ?
I would have dumbly took haste or critical, but seems not
Gambit +12 timed in +2, first 12 of this season I'm happy 😄
Yap since your versa is "so low" it sims highest , i have it same
If you fear enemy will they go running all over or stay in place?
Prot loves all stats
Stars have diminishing returns, the less of a stat you have the more return it provides you, so as our stat budget gets high and higher we start to see stats normalize in the value they provide to us
For prot what that means functionally is that you will start to see gear with vers and mastery weighted higher depending on the gear you have currently equipped
It will break almost immediately
This is why it’s important to sim because as soon as you change your stat distribution, the relative values will change
Sims account for those scenarios (by simulating, go figure)
Ty for all your answers 🙂
Other than deleting rally should any other talents be changed from wowhead?
Technically rally isn't a heal
You lose the HP after the buff expires
Wait.. if you rally and then go up to 60 hp and 110 max hp.
Then you drop to 10hp and then rally goes away, does it instant kill you because rally going away requires -10hp?
ofc i get only the chest tier token 😄
no it wont kill you
What happens when it goes away?
Ok yes this is technically correct, it doesn’t function like last stand per se
Ohh so you can game it by going down to 1 hp so when rally goes away you don't take any of the negative effect from the rally fade minus hp
I should have clarified that probably lol
i thought if u timed a 10 u got the teleport to that dungeon or is it a 12 ?
so wtf just did a HOA in time didnt get portal
did you already have it from SL?
nah i didnt play then
HOA is bugged atm I believe
Path of the Sinful Soul
oh that would be tragic
wow that sucks ty
it was fucking bonkers in raid when it was 30% lol
completely warped heal checks
time to focus on other stats
still took haste on my crafted weap tho 
Yeah we don’t need rally when all five players in a key can wear loomithars
Loom based tank trinket, aoe 5m shield w 75% redux on 90s
Huge group value
How much worst are regular myrhic boots compared to raid dh boots?
highkey i want one so bad
Nah they increase the proc rate of your cloak effect by a % depending on what difficulty you get them from
Im pretty sure if all 5 people wore it you could basically trivialize any boss fight
Think it's like 30/40/50% for normal/heroic/mythic
And then it would be summarily nerfed
oh, what're they called?
I told my raid group that I'm calling dibs on that trinket once the healers are sorted
Interlopers something
I'll give up antenna prio for it idc
oh, completely not mentioned on wowhead
(The effect doesn't show on wowhead but it exists in-game)
Reminds me of that one DF healer trinket from Neltharion that tanks were taking for util
Yeah different story for non-tanks though since they get an actual meaningful effect
let us use the dps cape......
For real
Writ of something? The targeted absorb shield one?
Ward of faceless irr
Ire
Ward of Faceless Ire yeeee
i was too all-totem and dreadplate pilled to use it but
Or back in legion when everyone was using fel shield emitter or the giga absorb thing from Argus
always interesting when trinkets are used by those outside their intended roles
I remember rogues running Rageheart in DF
Rogues needing more defensives is crazy thinking tbh
I could use more defensives
Jakey said two shield walls is feeling iffy so I need more help
Lowkey Highkey Loom'thar's Living Silk is literally what I want for a prot warr utility. I raise my fucking BULWARK and shield my allies from harm
Yeah that's the one sadge part of going to thane. No more walls from ava
The fantasy is there
I miss it so much
and no more avatar from walls
Not to mention losing the random wall procs from tier
Makes me wonder if taking the single shield wall but SS gives big CDR will be worth again
That’s okay next expansion we can all be Evoker demon hunters
does it matter much what we craft this tier? just whatever is lowest ilvevl
Esp with burst of power procs and SS resets
In super general terms. Going for 4-set early and taking a hero tier set is recommended over a "bis" myth track ring yes?
In the long run perhaps not, but not having 4-set another week is too punishing?
up to you. are you doing stuff this week where you really want to be more powerful?
Too punishing is subjective. Depends on what content you do and how you feel about it really
we get another catalyst charge next week so you're probably not gonna need to wait too much longer
hey guys is it better to use violent outburst on thunderblasts, else shield slams?
for ST specifically really
So far, every tier ever has been shield>weapon>embellishments/low ilevel pieces
popping off lmao
shield slams in st still i'd think
for the rage gen
Embellishments have been more important in some tiers than others depending on their strength. Right now they're minimal
Outburst on SS always in ST, I think you do thunderblast if you have a tier proc and have 3+ targets?
Makes sense, thanks guys
hey, starting playing prot. its a bad idea to just macro shield block into most abilities(shield slam/thunder/cooldowns)?
Blast is 3+ targets. Since it doesn't specify, I assume it's slam otherwise in aoe
its totally fine
specially if you are starting off
It specifically says "NOT thunder clap"
SB has a duration cap
do not
do not macro it
ever
practice maintaining it
thats your bread and butter
Things that are bad habits are more bad when starting out, not less bad. Because you should be avoiding forming those bad habits.
You really should not macro shield block because while you may not overcap it, you’re going to get into a scenario where you’re sending it when you don’t need to
Can someone post the macro we should be using that uses shield slam instead of revenge if ss is available?
ive modified afenar's WA , one is when i dont have Shield block or ignore pain up
That's not a thing. You can't make macros like that
This isn’t as much of a problem in keys but in raid it will lead to both lost dps and downtime
dont focus on IP
only on SB
you IP at 70+ rage
thats it
focus on SB
Yes I saw the wowhead writer post it but I lost it
Are you thinking of the IP/SS macro?
can we have TOO much haste? is there any breakpoint
Revenge shield slam
That's not a thing and isn't even possible
at 25k+ you can probably swap off, but sims already do that for you
Nimchimp probably know
IMO it doesn’t matter if your macro ip to something like thunderclap - it’s going to cost you some dps while in execute because you’re overcapping IP and losing that rage you could have otherwise sent on execute but the dps loss is probably not that great - though the loss now with new talents is enough that I would not recommend doing it for any real content
@ninchimp
aiit im at 27 with flask without any fray stacks
ignore %
what rating
too many things mess with %
Two on-gcd abilities can't be macroed together outside of a castsequence, which are generally never a good idea
he said 27k
oh shit
das too much lmao
They need to just delete castsequence from the game it offers nothing good
I thinj I remember one spec using one recommended. Can't remember which spec
Not prot war that's for sure
Too many talk about macros feel like you ain't understanding @masteryisnotabadstat
make sure you're good with SB management and you can drop a bit or whatever
alright thanks!
naa never really had an issue on SB
aight then youre good
The macro you describe here is literally impossible to make. It's not that I don't know how to make it; it doesn't exist and could not have existed, at least not for like 15+ years
my next step spam +6 for tome
punching down 
then just need 60 more runed crests and then its myth track waiting room
I use one that does that. My brain too smol
@nimchimp can pls link the macro to cast shield slam if it is available instead of revenge I swear I saw it
Does nobody play colossus anymore?
this is 100% true
https://wago.io/Bn9mwPxCC @lusty grotto
This is a modified version of the weakaura made by Forsberg. You can find the original version here https://wago.io/3VXu
Pretty sure that's the one im using fooshaz
oh
Found it
another great pepega exchange, good job to everyone involved
I just won a chest hc token with a 15 roll, the other guy rolled 4 😄
So yayy i have 2p now
the tier set for thane is insane
thats not for revenge, you specifically said revenge
and it doesnt substitute your SS key, like it says there
Bro he's literally fucking trolling. I even asked if he meant the IP/SS macro
is that codex defensive trinket any good for prot?
No



