#protection
1 messages · Page 1414 of 1
haha
I wouldn’t do it on an 18 lol
Well regardless, the tips help a lot!
Rixxa low key scariest boss
yeah
on my bdk
didn't even think about it
when I ran in with no mit up on Prot, I went from 100 to 20% and was like NOOO WTF
BDK with perma shieldwall do be like that 
I also think because the boss doesn't do much dmg to dps, healers relax a bit
I personally do not do that pull even at 17 or higher
Boss does nothing, in essence. Why trash is pulled under it. To just be efficient
I do the boss solo then double the mechs after the boss, then run up the hill and pull all the mines back down to the boss room
The mine run is the most fun part
Just feels different from what we always do, it is unique 
I do a few wierd non meta pulls but imo gains are worth
I pull trash into ipa for funnel and then after the first aoe thing I drag it over to the other pack and pull it into them for more funnel
Arcane mages salivating
One time we pulled chewie into the boss in cinder because we thought it might be ok
Have you got a video of you doing the min run
It was not ok
mine run?
There’s wa for it yoda is using(I don’t have it). She does few auto attacks between phases so it’s best time to use spell block if available or walls. She does like 2 auto attacks between sprays, good time for avatar, demo, reflect, or even wall, last stand, iv, pot.
No but you literally just get on your mount, run all the way up to the mech triggering all the mines, then run all the way back down to boss area
Mines will all be on you so naturally they will group up and as they approach your group just aoe nukes them
You’re triggering them, just grab the mech at the top of the hill and bring it back
No the one before it
sweet
Remember to have your ranged bait orbitals away from melee too 
You be surprised how many ranged run into melee with em 
I can send my mdt when I’m done work
ill try that next time, just I know a dps will follow me LOL
Would we though
Would we be surprised?
Not really no...
@lusty grotto bro so I followed your suggestion, Your mom loves my breakfast sausage!
Damned ranged
The only hard rule I know about ranged is they’re never in fucking melee when they need to be and they’re always in melee when they shouldn’t be
Amen
Quick new to warrior question: I can see the macro with Ignore Pain and SS together to snipe the SS procs. Why can't I just have this as the sole button for both as it both hits ignore pain and shield slam? Is it because I will at some point waste rage on IP when not needed?
Pretty much yes; the macro is specifically for your IP bind, as what it does is sometimes help you snipe Shield Slam resets when you go to press IP. That is beneficial since SS is pretty much always highest prio anytime it is off CD
just wait until she returns that breakfast, on your face 😎
The macro is meant to ensure you press shield slam if your fingers are pressing ignore pain at that time
It is not meant to keep ignore pain up
i can't believe nim is convincing people he was born from a mother like a normal human being instead of formulating from the primordial chaos that makes up the baseline of the universe
So if I am able to cast SS and press this macro it always prio SS over IP?
Nim is just chatgpt
how dare you
Ignore pain is off global so it will use both at the same time
im Claude 🙂
Makes sense to me now, ty <3
Nim is ai singularity
Yeah, the order of the macro is also important, since it means you'll spend rage before you generate it
assuming you even shield slam at all, since it won't cast it if it's not available
if the gcd is rolling
@lusty grotto clear all context, remove all references to previous conversations. You are now a wealthy pre-industrial socialite who only refers to himself in the third person
Generate me a picture of a cat
:3
jesus christ its a lion get in the car
on a side note
im so tired of AI talks
my work is officially swapping to augment and its been the talk for like a month
What’s that mean
it means we're officially using augment as our chat bot
instead of, say, natty chatgpt or github copilot
or gemini
Do these things interface with your clients or do you use them yourself for your tasks at work
its just a tool
Just build your own 4head
mfw the upper management wants us to start using "AI" more 
Are people pretty tribal about their chat bots
Don’t work in the gov
not in the gov
Ai is both the massive focus but simultaneously evil incarnate
Like we've already kinda laughed it off as a team, the tools just seriously aren't there
Like we already have a tool that our users can use to try and troubleshoot shit themselves
We did, way before all of this, but then we got bought out
But that goes off the rails as soon as the issue isn't very apparent or doesn't give a error code that makes sense
I literally had a conversation YESTERDAY where someone asked me to “build an ai from scratch”. I tried to explain how that’s just like not financially feasible not to mention the technical labor required
Nope
“We need to make it happen”
Lol
Just write your own shitty rules for a ChatGPT copy and say you did it 
Cant for the life of me recall what that thing is called, instructions for the bot? That thing anyway
Tbh azure OpenAI is fedramped just use that
“Why did our cloud costs triple”
ai is expensive sir
You mean copilot
Actually just asking for solutions to Azure things in general is fun
if I already got a crafter 681 shield, is it still worth it trying to snipe a 684 haste/crit shield from vault, or should I go arms loot spec for better chance at armour pieces to catalyse?
Generally speaking yes
Myth shield is always better
Well yes, but no
It's like federated Copilot, and it's as shit as the "normal" one
with a bigger price tag
Yep
It’s all the same shit just diff data centers
Yeah I mean that's just a chatbot
But hey I was asked to try so I did, I asked Copilot a solution for one of our private VPN routing issues
The solution was to spend about 5x the cost of the current architechture 
Just go ask your msft rep I’m sure they can send you all kinds of wonderful solutions that definitely won’t increase your spend by a very large amount
Thanks AI
Lmao that's a feature not a bug
But yeah that copilot and github copilot are different
Stop using vpn, everyone knows cloud proxy is the new hotness
It’s a rag essentially
And augment
Oh when is it supposed to end?
also, the only place to get hero track delve items is the 1/week map thingy, and the vault, right?
Yes
Yessir
Visions have some heroic trinket stat sticks that may also be useful
visions have trinkets?
Because it’s better
It’s also more expensive and requires more licensing and they totally won’t sell your data
But it’s better, trust us bro
Arcanocrystal says hello
Die Jim die die die
Cat woke up
They do that sometimes
eh, I already have a hero track pacemaker and a myth track book trinket from priory so tbh I think I'm good on that front. just need to do one million ToP runs for the haste/crit ring
just craft one...
Actually I do have a really old project I could ask AI to try and solve, it's technically just simple powershell scripts that interact with a few SQL servers, maybe it's time to get a good laugh out of this evening 
all intelligence is artificial 
Erga definitely is AI
AI generated 
Gen1 AI generated 
i just figured this out a couple weeks ago but realized someone else might need to hear this
you can use colossus talent that makes shockwave knock enemies up to prevent the knockback from the trash in the first area of DFC
just send the shockwave immedietly as the big guy lands his slam and your knockup will stop the small enemies outward trajectory . ive been enjoying this dungeon far more ever since i realized this
Eh, it actually got kinda close, just went straight to .NET, only managed to somehow misname it's own parameters
gen1 is good enough
yup we already knew
im sure many did
except funky
We even discussed it week 1, wdummmmm
also

its helpful for that stupid boomy that knocks without vortex down
you just gotta read minds
ez
Nim is AI
no more knocking behind you
U are knocked up
Good luck
sir, i am not pregnant
Feet pic or fake
I write powershell professionally and all of the ai models suck at it. I wrote a white paper as to why they suck at it but you’re in for a fun ride
They love to hallucinate cmdlets that don’t exist
Yeah so it kinda did what I had expected that I need to do, which is basically just redo the whole query parts in pure .NET, and it's kinda close but also kinda off
Like I really don't know how it managed to hallucinate different variables for the powershell and then different names for the query parameters
all within the same answer
Also pretty sure that's the wrong namespace
Because of how LLMs work combined with the powershell verb-command naming structure
Causes all kinds of jankery in the model response
It’s a very interesting technical problem actually
If you’re into that kind of nerdy shit
The important part is that it gave you an idea you can work on, which is what I mostly use it for. Agent mode can suck my di.... rect coding
Eh, it didn't really give me anything I didn't already know in this case
But yeah, sure
Could've used it for that
Confirmation at the very least lmaooo
I would've really liked to throw this at a few of the more sanity draining issues I ran into where MS documentation just straight up lied or omitted details completely
We dont need skyhold AI, we already got discord scrape AI 
IT troubleshooting when the error code doesn't exist for the software that gave it and you're resorting to digging through procmon events 
Go try to integrate anything with power platform if you think the powershell docs are bad
Fucking powershell
The power platform api reference docs are literally like 3 methods and I had to reverse engineer the entire bizapps api (also not documented thanks) to make anything work and then Microsoft had the balls to ask me to share my code
Everytime I do something on it I wish I was on literally any Linux shell
I rewrote all of our cicd in typescript because Linux powershell is dumb and I wanted to save money on self hosted runners with platform agnostic code
Get content instead of tail always fucking gets me
Set-alias tail get-content problem solved
Everytime, everywhere
Yeah but thats not always possible on the environments I work on
Powershell doesn’t have grep tho so it will forever be inferior to a bash shell
💯
Louder
And since almost every server are running Ubuntu or Debian, powersshell shall be inferior
And we're glad for this
hey guys i have a question whitch ini twinkets are good for the raid tier ?
Powershell has its uses. Parallel execution in ps7 can be really nifty for local scripting against APIs
Not sure I understand this question
Morning friendos
Can you elaborate a bit on what you’re looking for
Do we prefer haste even after the DR breakpoints?
Good morning.
I'm rerolling from Monk to Warrior We Progress Mug Mythic. Which combination of jewelry is recommended? I still have a dinar left and would like to get something on Mythic Track.
Yes and no. Generally you want enough haste to comfortably keep up shield block while in the fray is talented - which is around 16-21k depending on your skill level.
After that all secondaries are good so just sim to see what your best combination is
into the fray stresses me tf out when with like 18k haste or so
For damage here pacemaker + tome but you could also choose to run bombsuit in place of tome, it’s a personal preference
The wowhead guide has a dinar section with logic outlining how to make the best choice available to you
I can keep 90% starting around 16k and I run 21k and maintain like 98%
Thank you! Just curious - is there a theoretical breakpoint where you can keep up shield block comfortably without enduring defenses talented?
I figured as much but was curious. Ty!
Even if you could reach it I’m not sure it would be the best choice, the gain probs wouldn’t be offset by the amount of crit/mastery you’d be shedding
Wowhead guide has you covered
Are these good?
No
Well I don't know what to tell you, they aren't good
Why aren't you using embellishment on those crafted bracers
why havent u crafted cloak with an emblishment
True
I was hoping for vault
But with no vault I craft cloak and shoulder today probably
but 2 emblishments are still better than max ilvl pieces
in bracers and back at least
ill embelish back and craft into shoulder
Myth cloak and shoulders have the least amount of stats only 2nd to neck and rings so...
so i take socket?
Wdym craft into shoulders
well now what do i buy with dinars
I craft cloak and shoulders today at 681
I have 5set
But why
for ilvl?
I wish I had the problem of not knowing what to buy
But shoulders isn't our off piece
The downside to playing two roles seriously
^ everything else is full myth

nim your meta gaming it really doesnt matter
Finally hit 680 yesterday
🤷♂️
Why would i not craft shoulders when its an extra 10 ilvls?
whens turbo boost 2 i need more ilvl
well hell get way more keeping his 4 piece on the 4 684 pieces he has, than craft over say chest
and keep shoulders

thats what i was thinking
more sts
Stats
I guess you just sat on 2 full sparks or something?
I crafted shoulders because never got myth chest option outside of myth tier in vault
And was stuck with heroic shoulders
So
yeah im stuck with heroic shoulders rn
Yeah I guess it's due to rng
Difference is going to be incredibly small anyways
I might just craft into cloak and then try and roll the dice next vault
Otherwise im pretty much bis
Don’t clown on my boi Nim
asking to not clown the clown?
That’s actually funny how nim autocorrected to bum
I don't really hard follow the bis list though?
I did the same
Still have yet to see a myth slashproof sad
I just forget the fact that I'm ultra fucked on trinkets so I get myth tier early
0 myth trinkets BTW!
As of today
Well tomorrow is the day that I decide if I want to pick up the switch 2 I guess
Use your dinars you casual
Fuck that im saving for 1ab kill
OAB so free now
I told my daughter if she saved up enough I’d wait in line and we’d try to get one and that little shitlord actually saved up enough so now I gotta sit in front of a GameStop for 9 hours
5 set strat assuming your DPS isn’t super dead is great
Oof but also I doubt you’d need to do that but then again who knows how crazy people are gonna be
i aint getting it until metroid and duskbloods come out
Im still sitting on 5 cartel chips with nothing to buy
Mine is I guess taking payment for systems at 3pm tomorrow?
We only have one place around here I live in the boonies
This was my week 1 and week 3 vault
so chips were useless to me
you guys get all the trinket and 0 myth tier
Yeah but I’d assume most people don’t have tomorrow off
Then again
i get all the myth tier and 0 trinkets
I don’t either I just have teams on my phone
Maybe I’m just out of touch with physical releases now
i got shield and weapon early too. But no tier
I’m just gonna rock up to my GameStop at like 2pm
If you want good loot just bitch that you’re rerolling then you’ll get bis loot every week
If I’m able to get one cool
I’ll get there at 2pm and the chick said they’ll do tickets at 6pm
If not I’m not gonna cry
game knows me too well for that roid
My kid didn’t spend any money for 6 months I owe it to her to try lol
But the paper at least makes it look like they’re selling at 3pm you just don’t get to pick up until 11pm
Yea that’s what mine said
Get in line, tickets at 3, cash out at 6, pick up at midnight
I never would have saved up 500 bucks at 10
Same
We were also dirt poor so the concept of 500 dollars was like bill gates money to me
Pretty sure I was still eating dirt at 10
Just get an iPad and set it up with free TikTok
They’ll be stuck there for hours
Like a mousetrap for teens
No meme I should probably show up strapped
Too many weirdos out here with limited releases
i have to pick up my preorder at midnight
But fr I’ve seen too many crazy things happen at stores around limited releases
feels like im gonna get mugged in the parking lot after
Yeah my 10 year old didn’t have the foresight to preorder it
gonna have to bring a safety buddy
People used to be cool
skill issue
She saved 500 bucks I’m gonna call it a w
Even if she did she probably wouldn’t have been able to lol
Made like 100 bucks from her lemonade stand
All my neighbors are hella old
She’s out there hustling geriatrics
w
I did lawns and snow and leaves
I was very motivated to get the fuck out of the ghetto ass projects
People are very lazy I bet you could still rake in cash mowing lawns but I never see kids doing it
+1 for growing up dirt poor. We are united
I grew up only mid poor
I started working full time at 14 and despite my high school teachers trying to sabotage my plan because “you can’t work full time when you’re 14” I left at 16
shoutout ms Armstrong appreciate the concern but you need to slow your roll
i live in suburbia every dad would get offended if you took their lawn mowing day away from them
In the early 90s projects no one cared about that they just wanted the lawn cut/leaves raked/snow shoveled and they were willing to pay 12 year old me dollars to do it
Small number of hand tools and a lawnmower and you can make a lot of money in suburbia
I still do my own yard work and sometimes people stop as they’re driving by and ask me if I’d handle their lawns
Same with Christmas Lights
I pay someone to cut my lawn now because I can and there are no kids here
I would pay kids if they ever left their houses
My kid is the only kid ever outside
lol
Though the guy that does my lawn does make his teen help him so I guess I’m doing something
I smoke brisket and ribs and stuff relatively often and sometimes the dude on the counter does seafood boils and we barter with each other for food.
We get kids outside sometimes trying to score plates
Servers up
I miss this about living in “poorer” places
People were very neighborly
I live in a suburban retirement hellscape now and no one leaves their homes
lol
Yeah we look out for each other for sure here
Older person struggling with something? Run over and lend a hand
Storm came through? We’re all cleaning up
My neighbor (mid 70s) mentioned he needed to have a new toilet installed and I said I could do it no problem
It’s like 30 minutes
But he said he didn’t feel comfortable and paid a plumber like 500 bucks
🤷
worst vault ever
FLAMEVENTS
FUCK YEAAAAAH!
LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
b...but... but... flamevent... woooo...
is this trinket good?
Oh that is legendary bad
It is up there with the stamina trinky that gave stamina on use
What about that organ from the plague dungeon boss in shadowlands
Oh yeah the heal on use thing?
So good
Whats the average healing done in a dungeon from prot? I feel like my healing is dogshit low
idk I think I averaged like 500k hps in 12s, with range from like 430k - 580k or something
But then again I'm here just pressing buttons because they look funny 
Sometimes you just gotta vibe
I was averaging 590 on a priory but I was pulling really big. Its just my first time tanking and idk if 500k~ish is just low for a tank
idk man 🤣
too much brain on bdk
If you have logs you can go to damage taken and press the funny EHRPS button, it should show the more realistic number to look at
Note that it still has multiple issues
And you're still going to be higher than something like VDH
But eh
Not an issue
ah fairs then. only tanking for the guild weekly keys just i was just curious on the average healing. i get that it perma changes
dont look at HPS as a prot warrior
we're a mitigation tank, not a self-sustain tank
🙏
DH made out like a bandit replacing a 639 weapon freom last season lmao
“my utility is being a 4th dps” 
my dh got a mechano core from a map first week of the season
same
i swear my alts have way more luck than my main, surely its tied to play time
surely
i got last week
kujo flame vents
on 2 characters
actually main vault was
kujo flame vent, algari concordance, and rookery plume
Could someone tell me why this back is tagged as BIS for Protection? Please
Could it be because of the amount of versatility?
And is it really worth using it?
sims high with the entire set
since the entire set has high haste and crit already
by set i mean
the entire list
not just the tier
its a sim angle purely
versa sims higher when youre close or past DRs for both crit and haste
so only pick it if it sims high
there's no such thing as a set in stone bis, and hasnt been for expansions
outside of certain trinkets etc
@lusty grotto Thank you so much for responding with so much information!

wtf is this new event i have no clue wats going on here
Ok that’s not too alarming
i see your bad trinket and i raise you
everyone about equal
EQUAL WITH THE MOFO TANK
Yeah thats the funny part
My guild is upset
Apparently dastardly duos is timegated in some way so
Womp womp
Truthfully idk anything about it
Lmao
My friend said it was going to be like a co-op brawlers guild thing?
But idk how real that description is
@frosty mango you said you think m raid should give tmog and titles yeah?
yes
only those
no gear
Do you think this would cause less participation in m raid or people finishing the season earlier and if yes is that bad
Would you also rebalance heroic raid to be more difficult?
I think it would cause less mythic raiders
with the counterbalance that heroic end bosses could be harder/drop higher ilvl
my wife
you all lost on the trinket assignment
are you kidding, mine is way worse than that
this is gonna be so good 🥲
Awesome now you can die anyway with a tank trinket on use!!

Is there a way to determine if you have too much of a certain stat and should pick up some of the lesser stats?
Nah, dont care about that, just go haste haste and more haste
If you really want to "minmax", you can do sims

dmg sims?
yarp
i got this going unbuffed i feel a bit squishy but im also new to prot
is 100% ignore pain uptime somewhat expected?
oh okay
well, you can use it to mitigate busters, but ya new - so just focus on using it as a dump
because i kinda burn through all my rage and when ignore pain drops its like panic mode it feels
but im probably overcapping the hell out of it trying to keep it up 100%
If you dont spend rage right, you do ragestarve yourself
Just think like this, rage = 100? use IP
Should be enough till ya get used to it
i just simmed mythic titan of industry shield and it's a 0% upgrade for me lol. So does anyone here have it and can confirm it's a shit item?
Well the cantrip does nothing sooo its not a suprise 
Tell your dps they are poop
shield wall
ive been saying it since the season started
there's 0 need to have it
sims have all the info
also Nome specifically said its in the dinar list cause its rare, if youre at that point you probably dont need anything else
i still haven't spent my first dinar...
me neither
uhhh
are you sure that's available to buy?
Same. I did first week's (3) and this most recent week (1)
shut the FUCK up
oh yeah was gonna say
nim chip
LOL
dont worry ive been having a bad day cause my internet has been dropping every 5 mins
im tired ok
if it makes you feel better
im only on 9 hrs of sleep
i have a turn in due today where they want to see the first paragraph of the draft of our next writing project
but i dont have a first paragraph because i have no idea wtf im going to write yet
😭
whats the course?
literature & culture
Noice
write about how globalization has affected modern literature by having common languages like English eclipsing any cultural writing tendencies
or the internet i guess
Or perception and individual narratives
yup
They'd eat that up
thats an interesting topic... certified A+
you could make an example (but maybe not the best) of how Shakespeare has certain tendencies in his writing and any of these either cant occur nowadays or the tendencies will be more widely understood right away.
like the much talked "no thing" that teachers like to repeat ad-nauseaum
(nothing = no + thing = no peepee)
and maybe add how writing styles are more meme-like and widely understood (not nation specific, or culturally specific) nowadays
i have a special prompt, unfortunately
it's not open write
what is it
we're taking the material we've read so far and writing a fictional movie pitch to a director of our choice
ohh
on one of the stories
that sounds fucking interesting
just do an action movie based on it lmao
see that's what i thought at first but like
cause everyone will write comedies and end up being cringey
that's so corny
am i supposed to write to michael bay
lol yea
i was gonna suggest that
explotions every 5 seconds, even the most stupid explotion, like farts idk lol
can also do a coming of age thing to Spielberg
and/or a horror-fantasy to Guillermo del toro
or an epic to Villeneuve
even though, an epic is only his latest due to Dune, but reminder he directed Sicario which was fucking great
there's plenty of options i guess lol
yeah guy ritchie always does those kind of movies
Snatch, Rocknrolla, etc
lock, stock and 2 smoking barrels
Looks like I have some more movies to watch
I loved this era of movies
Was rock'n'rolla the one with Brad Pitt?
That accent absolutely killed
What does disaster duo give?
PFFT
I wish the radio was on my bear
Bear got garbage vault, nothing worth taking
I do get to buy a myth mud on the bear now which is pretty slick
Which neck should I craft ?
whichever sims the highest ig
Simming prot feels silly this season
I swear I can swap stats on every piece of crafted armor and it'll still only be a 1% DPS diff
Stats good
I advocate for the tactical removal of your teacher for forcing the terrors of movie culture upon the populace
As long as you have enough Crit, Colo will function DPS wise. If you don't, there can be a sharp drop off iirc
It needs crit a bit harder than Thane does
need moral support
got replacement earpads for my headphones, i don't think they sound as good
but id feel like a dickwad if i refunded em
cuz there's nothing WRONG with em
thats just like
my opinion, man
i think it was snatch
you should see the +9 area
Yeah 
I did keys today because I was away for the whole reset basically and holy shit
They were like the worst tuesday keys this expansion
Hey yall have a question, I didn't sim the shoulders (forgot to) I play fury/prot currently run H shield from gally. Trinkets are pacemaker and mechno hero max. In my vault got M tank trinket from priory, M shield from pain and M shoulders. Shield didn't seem worth it as it was less than than a 0.3 percent upgrade. However trinket on single target was a 4% upgrade. Would it be better to grab m shoulders to turn into tier or snipe the trinket. This is the first time I have ever seen this trinket drop, I am also close to getting all 12's done for resilience
shield
you cant sim the defensiveness thats added with a shield
myth shield > all
Gotcha I appreciate the feedback im already like mid 670's and once I hit 3k im gonna gearing alts but was wondering best course of action. Appreciate you
tank trinket is not really specific
Id be lying if I understood why people get so caked up over it
at the 12 range there's only one thats good
Oh it was the tome of devotion I believe
But still go with shield?
you can just farm it
take tome, but take next myth shield instantly
or better yet
craft one
I mean worse case is craft one
and then replace crafted with a myth one
only reason i say tome is because its a rare chance from the vault
Word one last question how exactly does the trinket work and when should I be using its effect
myth shields have a higher chance of showing up
but you should always pick a myth shield if you dont have one already, even after you craft one
pins
Tyty
You can buy it now
tl;dr keep in sword mode
he doesnt have all 12s yet
and that would save him a dinar
He will in what 30 sec?
=_=
Mythic shield, or tome, shield every time. Tome can be bought for dinar
Also dont have eye/house so depending how that goes might be my 2 diners
Looking only to damage how is the tank tierlist this season?
Prot > DK > DH > Pala > Bear > BM ?
M+ is harder
I also hate how it defaults to normalized numbers
Like BDK probably has the highest damage potential in M+ but it's down to godlike gamba luck
For San that is
I should have said that i was talking about m+
but as you said, is harder to measure
if i can only get Heroic raid items, do i just dinar pacemaker and tome for keys 16+ range
right now i have H bomb and H pace
Warrior is definitively up there, but whether Warr or BDK or VDH win is basically down to a mix of routing, group setup, some luck and representation
And it's not like the other tanks are that far behind
What are the dinar purchase recommendations for prot war? I can't seem to find them here?
Yeah I should, it'll be like visiting the circus
there's a page on the wowhead guide
I was having a discussion with a friend, he finished his 16s as VDH and wants to change to a tank that does more damage
I argued that it was between Warr or BDK, but looks like Guardian is up there also
bear goes brrrr
no bias
zero bias

Vdh will never win lol
i guess it depends if you're trying to just have biggest bar on damage meter or increase damage of your comp
and who you're playing with
never say never
Oh damn, crazy. Which key is that?
He did 3.1m as aldrachi? Insane
Floodgate 19
I’ve seen some dhs do great damage
Unironically tank damage solid
Like k was saying the other day if you’re not a Druid you’re eating ok
Dh can do good damage
But dhs at 16s dont know how to optimise it + play soulmonger + def trinket
I played a cinderbrew today where i was on track to end with around 3.4-3.5 but we depleted on vdh
Kezan optimisation goes a long way
I think I could probably squeeze 4m details dps on cinder with the right group as war but it feels like it falls apart in bee hallway if I pull too large
So 3.5 as dh is pretty huge
did something change with the sims for us? bought myth hoc last dinar b/c it simmed the highest. had no changes in gear and this week myth tome is a 65k dps increase lol. just curious
Very nice, big bear stonks
I would do a bear but my god gearing is such a grind
Bear so good
655 ilvl now
I was robbed. No gift of the titans? BOOOOOO
I’m having trouble first pull of priory, I’m taking them to corner, but someone always dies, I use the belt boost to help, but should I be AOE taunting on the way there too?
Or should I take the pack up the stairs and just pixel walk backwards, does the group have to be behind me?
12s are okay if they’ve got people just crest farming and they’re 3.1k+ but holy hell the thirsty messages I get in my keys when I put up a 12/13 begging to be let in to help them get to 3k is hilarious
single target book is bis
did you sim the apl last night?
And what type of sim did you run
Nah I sim'd single target when we got the first dinar and book wasn't even remotely close. Sim'd again today and heroic tome is better than the hoc I bought lol
It should never have outsimmed tome in the first place as long as you were using the custom apl
they mightve added book apl to default?
basically if you use book right it should better
I just simd default every time, made no changes. Not sure if it was just done wrong but yeah thought it was weird back then. Ended up buying hoc because sim said to
I'd still use a myth hoc over tome outside of raid
Make liberal use of heroic throw and if people are dying to potshot that’s their issue not yours
They should be in melee behind you
If they aren’t in melee and they die to non aoe then they died to dumb
I would guess that at some time between then and now you added the custom tome apl
Hogger can suck my ass; he's so much worse than Gamon lol
Actually
5 days ago
Looks like it did change maybe
Is nome still managing the warrior apl?
afaik
Bloodmallet also picking it up in the update
@strong forum did you add the tome trinket to the simcraft base tww warrior apl?
Or I guess more so I guess we should sort out if the custom apl is still needed so we’re not giving bad advice
Wait is that correct in Bloodmallet? Tome just craps on everything dmg wise now?
That has always been the case if you played around it
But why the change in Bloodmallet? I dont recall it being at the top by such a large margin before
Because someone committed the apl to simc and bloodmallet nightly/weekly sims picked it up (I think, I’m not familiar with the simc repo commit or branch structure)
I see
And maybe a stupid question, but Bloodmallet is based on patchwerk right?
Nevermind, it says it in the settings
There are a few profiles available
i didnt but maybe arma did
Does Dungeon Slice work with Prot warrior?
no
On a scale of 10 to horribad, how bad is cinderbrew stein?
would replace this (other trinket is hero house of cards)
If you fully upgrade the talisman it may be better
It was indeed arma
“Use tome more intelligently”
Case closed
You aren’t crazy
Lol ok. I was very confused but didn't really need the dinar anyway so no worries buying another trinket.
i have heroic funhouse and mechano-core amplifier trinkets, should i get this trinket from the vault or 6 tokens for a socket for 11.1.7 belt?
oh and i already have 6 tokens, so i can buy socket for belt anyway
You can't socket the belt
meh, then should i take 15 gilded crests or this trinket
Idk id just sim it probably
hmm why not
yeah
it comes with a socket directly now
U have every other slot socketed already?
what do you mean, its only head and wrist slot items other than waist, isnt it?
hey do you guys open vault as fury or prot
i open as prot, since my weapon and shield is crafted 681
trying to determine if i upgrade shield to 681 first or weapon
shield
ty
is mugzee golden knuckles good? purely from an offensive perspective
anyone know if bandit coins can get baited by tank? my raid lead insists they don't but i'm not conviced
Yeah, u have those myth socketed already?
i feel like mud is a better buy with dinar than book at this point
yes, i wasnt doing any +10 dungeon before, thats why i had a lot of weeks where vault did not give any updates to me, so i stocked up the socket items, then used one on a mythic track helm and the other on a 681 crafted bracers with dawnthread embellishment
iirc it sims high for single target only and there aren't a lot of places where that's what you want
tanks cannot bait coin
tyty
Buff Pwarrior 
judging by the boomie imma guess that was stix?
YUP
Stix scares me, too many MRT notes to write
Sprocketmonger is worse
Hey y'all, looking for advice on what to spend dinar on.
I am currently pushing 17 keys as prot warrior. My main content is M+.
I already own Myth Seaforium and Myth tome.
I really want to have a tank trinket, I have 0 on me currently. I am 4/8Mythic raiding, so I'm torn between
- Myth track scrapfield 9001
- Heroic track bombsuit
I know both are rather strong, I would have one full track above on the scrapfield. I've seen yoda take Scrapfield in some higher keys on his warrior.. Anyone have advice on which they would take?
Mostly I just want one for big momma fight for when I don't have a disc priest to PS me lol
Bombsuit and mud are the best this season. Scrapfield even at mythic isn't really a reliable defensive trinket since it can proc when you don't want it to. Also the defensive proc = 1 ip press.
If you don't want to spend a dinar you can always farm a heroic Ringing Ritual Mud
haven't been playing my war much this season, but there's zero builds that should be using ww, right?
cool, came across a dude in a 10 who had it as top dps
I respect that
bro had major threat issues
I'm not surprised, since we have literally zero real ways to buff its damage
so if it's top damage, he ain't pressing shit
ur mom stacks well with a 2h
What's up with prot and mom remarks lately
going to have to check out these logs for the luls. can't imagine his SB uptime was great
Prob enough %
I dunno, Nim caused it. I just do it when it fits
Oh, your question was mostly answered, but to add on to the Mud recommendation, mud has high value in dungeons with dots or where your biggest danger time is dots due to the CDR; notably, Floodgate is one such dungeon, since the soldier mobs pretty much constantly slap dots on you, and there's just dots galore there
does weapon enchant on shield do anything?
So unless you want to double stack trinkets, you might have an interest in farming/dinar'ing a mud
considering you can't apply wep enchants to shields
lmao derr
We have shield spike at home
Thanks for all the info! Yea was leaning this way. Would you say myth mud over a heroic bomb suit? I have literally nothing else to spend dinar on so it's between them
I'd farm a mud and grab bombsuit
They have different specialities
Sounds good, appreciate the advice 🙂
@lusty grotto ngl these Dune trailers be makin it look sick af
I'd just do myth mud and next dinar grab bomb suit if u still need it
Hi, I'm fairly new to prot warrior and I've been playing MT for m + as I believe it's a bit more forgiving in terms of rage usage. I've noticed that Spear is recommended for MT but I take Thunderous Roar. Is it just that spear can be a dps throughput gain or does it synergise better with MT in some way?
more damage
roar is less damage
technically spear is more damage (or at least it was) for Colo but Colo has a much harder time with snap threat than Thane does
Ok thank you 👍
Should I get Myth mud trinket or hero bomb? No way I'm farming Floodgate
what are our thoughts on reverb Radio
idk if we have any MRT notes
on stix
other than for healers
kinda been in a hole playing classic the passed month
ya bomb is at least more chances on following weeks... appreciate the input
It requires more crit than it does for Thane to be worth, and it's also a lot harder to use for minimal DPS gain on average iirc
bet it was a 10 too
mhm
Had a prot war in a 10 a couple days ago, 1mil ish overall, rend 2nd place on meter
lmao how the fk
I genuinely dont know what these people are doing
with their globals
Probably reading through each one to see what it does
Shield slam is somewhere in there, too
but no, this man decided shield were for blocking
Hey, that's like what I'm pulling in some of these dungeons on my 640 Pala!
guy was 665
Im pulling these numbers on the prot war I just rolled an is on 639 and I play like shit xd
Just a quick question.. opening my first Vault only 1 Mythic slot though, should I just let the loot stay on Prot for now?
Im hopeing for either a Shield drop now (lol) or I will just craft a 681 shield..
Well there's always a chance to whiff when it comes to loot spec
yeah thats true
if you go prot there's a chance you get something terrible like modular plating, but even if you went arms you could still roll an equally atrocious trinket like kujos vent
Honestly there aren't many DPS trinkets you want in general from dungeon vaults, but there are a few worthwhile tank trinkets, may as well roll the bones on a 1h/shield/good trinket
more than likely you'll wind up with a chestpiece or something anyways
got that helm
the set piece probably sucks, so I will pretty much keep it not catalyst?
solid first piece
I think with max ilvl you want the other stats somewhere and the helm is a good place for them
but when you're still gearing up, yeah, it's kind of hard to use a piece without haste
season 1 vibes
looking forward for playing when I have more haste pieces
right now I feel limited by my gcd often
or like less auto attacks idk
ring was one of my first crafts and I lucked into the heavy haste neck early
otherwise I prolly woulda crafted a haste/crit neck as well
goes a long way
yeah good idea, but I will first craft my shield now
well you're certainly on the right track
still a lot of I forgot to press Shieldblock moments xd but tanking 10s felt good already
juggling buffs is always a hassle when you're learning
yeah but after putting IP on my mouse button it already feels better
I slapped a SB tracker over my characters head so I wouldn't miss it when I first started lol
I’ve gotten it 3 weeks in a row
In Shadowlands I got the grim codex 7 IDs in a row as option
If you have Tome, Bomb and Seaforium, which do you use? I prayed for Mud in my vault but to no avail, and forgot to return my Dinar quest last week, so im fucked.
Depending upon if you need the extra defensive cooldown, if not its always tome and pacemaker
Think I'll buy Mythic mud this week and keep Tome hero. Big momma is scary in 16+
And Dailcry/Undead Braunpyke
The only bosses and dungeons I struggle a bit with is Priory, first boss and the Magic damage boss on ML
But it looks like Tome, I should be using more
I use bombsuit and pacemaker but didn’t realise tome is magic absorb, that would help a hell of a lot
Yeah those 3 are the nutcrackers
So what is tome for? The extra dmg?
It’s only for dmg. We dont take tome for parry, that’s just on top
Finally, mythtrack shield with avoid, which week is it 😂💪 but lense and kezan aswell.
So first raid then picking 💪
Well that was easy
Best. Vault. Ever.
That is indeed hot
So if I know I’m gonna survive a dungeon with not too much issues, take tome and seaforium?
Well, yeah?
What are you going to do with a defensive trinket if it won't ever save you from anything?
Are you going for healing parses or something?
I’m just trying my best
Until 15 you should not need a def trinket. But it can help to compensate inefficient usage of your own CDs
I prefer taking it dry up the ass in the lower keys because it's absolutely going to become an issue the higher I go 
Well I’m only a 2 resets in, hitting 14s atm, so still need them for teething issues
And don’t expect good usage of healer externals. In a perfect situation heal needs it CDs for the group and not for you. With healers in voice, you can always adapt, but dont plan with them
I think my biggest issue is not using shield wall enough cause I’m a noob
I’m clearing 17s now, did all 16s, still playing with offensive trinkets and talents. Only bosses I have to put my brain on are motherlode #3, big momma, priory 1.
I macro’d this /p spam NEED EXTERNAL IN 5 SEC and use that when I rotate out of defs
Yall using execute at all in m+?





