#protection
1 messages · Page 1362 of 1
Ritual mud is kind of like Shroëdingers trinket. It is both good and bad simultaneously. (Also sarcasm)
I'd try to replace signet with a pacemaker
I can feel the tension
so not the broken mud trinket, got it! ( hehe )
and when you feel you need it, you'll get more value from a champ bombsuit than a myth mud
Pacemaker/tome are the best options for the most part up until prob 15ish?
Bigger ilvl number better person
I feel fairly safe in 14s but the 15s I’ve gone in on have been a little scary
Big momma on 15 did make me clench
the only 15 I've tried so far was a rookery and my group shat the bed on the hallway trash
Can’t wait to get home from work and boost my mud since roid recommended it
Oh I’ll do it
be man enough to wear the mud
what scares me is one day
some guy is gonna post a vault with a tome or pacemaker and a mud as options
and I won't be here to talk him off the cliff
What if bloodborne is their favorite game
and they have to walk around with a mythic mud for the next 4 months
the mud will be on y'alls hands
They’ll probably come in here with a log showing how they didn’t die to something
And you’ll get even more furious because they’re attributing the living to mud and not something else that happened
Which boss in LOU would be the best encounter to use each week to gauge tank performance?
All of them
They tank all of the bosses, don’t they?
I'm thinking of tracking ten metrics on one boss each week to look for improved performance
dont they have most to do on gally?
I think a lot of the meta game will be more noticeable because most of the tank mechs are pass/fail but for raid your dps output is really the only quantifiable metric
Defensive use and taunts are quantifiable but I’m not sure they are really useful because if you don’t use them you either die or you don’t
Then there’s the more impactful but less quantitative meta gaming type stuff like boss positioning and mechanics execution (like bombs on gally)
You could probably infer things like boss positioning (am I tanking it in fire) by looking at dps uptime and looking for trends but I think vod review may be an easier path there
I'm looking to replace wowanalyzer since it's not kept up for tanking. Here's what I'm looking at tracking from logs:
How do you measure the value of a metric like shield block uptime in the context of a boss fight
Does pressing shield block when nothing is hitting you instead of pressing revenge make you an objectively better player, or worse?
If your SB uptime is only 50%, you have to get better at using SB?
Blocked hits does that already
That's where blocked hit % comes in
Then why track shield block
Not in raid
uptime vs blocked hits % can indicate it's not your SB that's the problem? idk
In raid you can have way lower uptime since you don’t always tank
Blocked hits is a good one, ignore pain efficiency would be another (was it used effectively)
Defensives vs tankbusters
I think what you’re doing could be very useful but in order to get true value you will need to intersect multiple datapoints to get a true picture
Yeah, I'm trying to figure that out, too. Rage starvation is a problem when you're not active tank
And on some bosses you can’t block so it doesn’t matter on them (rik)
Was actually just about to ask about shield block and ignore pain uptime
I'm trying to be bit better and I'd imagine we would want like close to 80%?
that's why I was asking for the one boss that I should use for these metrics
Tracking ignore pain uptime is pointless because you are not establishing the efficiency of its use
Prior would use fury gear to just tank to get into keys but this seasons actually looking to build a set
Well i can say none of the first 5 in mythic
Pressing ignore pain does not make you objectively better, it would make you objectively worse because you are wasting rage
So absorption is the better metric?
Absorbed vs gained
If you gained 50m ignore pain absorb but only 10m was effective
not sure where to find that
You are pressing it at the wrong time
You don’t, it would require analysis
but are you? you still want to press it with rage you're not gonna have time to spend anywhere else
Yes but different metric to track
are you trying to build an automated tool? a lot of these things will be misleading without context
That’s why I said quantitative = // = valuable
I never have that problem, I just spam Revenge if I'm capping
even when you're going through all your offensive CDs?
You can’t spam revenge to dump your rage
Also how do you know your ignore pain would not otherwise have just been healed off via raid heals
If you ss on cd
Not automated, just a tracker spreadsheet that I can look at these metrics for one boss each week (say, Sprocket)
Tbh I think you could go an entire raid and never press ignore pain
And it would make zero difference
Not that you should, but I highly doubt anyone would even notice you didn’t
Well you'd be overcapping rage so your damage would suffer.
i think it's more practical to just check A) dps and B) is the tank dying at bad times, or are healers complaining that they're unusually difficult to heal
Up until now, my metric for tanking well (enough) in H raid was a) don't die, and b) do as much DPS as possible. This is me trying to work on specific things I'm doing wrong...effective mitigation, uptime, etc
if yes, review the log, or send it over here
honestly, casts per minute is just about the best universal metric for how well you're doing
lol well, I could, but I want to learn how to effectively use logs better myself. Instead of asking someone to do it for me
True but I just mean from a defensive value standpoint
It's not really useful to track ignore pain. You have to press it to play properly and you can't really waste it. You could potentially waste some of the absorb but that would have no impact on whether you'd press it or not.
Like the defensive value it offers is irrelevant in raid
Yeah that's probably true unless you're undergeared (assuming the encounter presents any challenge to tanks)
I don’t think healers would even notice you didn’t press it
From S1, I learned to spam IP constantly...we can't do that anymore; it has to be a more judicious use. You have to choose between IP and other rage spenders now. Right?
I main heal and our tank doesn’t even play d stance, half the time ignore pain isn’t up and honestly echo of light keeps him at 100% literally the entire fight if they don’t scuff taunts/busters
i guess when i look at a log i go through... blocked melee %, damage breakdown (are they prioritizing the right buttons), wasted rage, casts per minute and casts breakdown (usually a good indicator of prioritizing rage gen and always having buttons to press)
IMO all of your raid gameplay will eventually come back to enabling you to do more damage
So if you are consistently doing good damage and not dying
You are performing
Not... quite... the rule of thumb is still roughly the same, you spend rage on IP that you wouldn't be able to spend anywhere else. Your threshold for when you spend it should just be higher than before, esp. on colossus
Maximize rage gen, make sure you can press a button every GCD, keep up shield block, use your CDs
that's kinda it
Ah...I'm one of the stubborn ones, sticking with Thane due to playstyle and better defensive
Thane does fine damage in raid
Especially the execute build
That's what I'm using
and I'm doing 800k-ish on most bosses.
What’s your ilvl?
but at 660, I know i should be doing more
You should def post logs, that’s considerably lower than where you should be
which is why I'm trying to figure this out lol
one day somebody will actually post logs when they have issues instead of just having us guess what they are doing wrong
....one day
I just posted last nights prog on H OAB kill & Mugs pulls
you did?
I know that my dps rotation sucks because I am still relying on hekili...it helps allow me to focus on mechanics and mitigation by not having to think about my rotation quite as much
well prot rotation is like 3 buttons
do you have the logs or no, like can you provide a link to them, right here, in this chat
ah ok
thanks
oh you're thane
This just looks like a classic case of not pressing buttons enough
Which kind of makes sense if you're feeling overwhelmed and using Hekili
I'd ditch the training wheels and try and just get comfortable with the basics on a training dummy for a bit
I just studied the rotation on wowhead
Let me point you to something rather poignant Mahkarn
you're playing execute build, which means you need to captalize on that because your SS is nerfed
And then threw myself at mobs until I died or they did
So, I pop execute when it's highlighted...you're saying I need to use it waaaaay more liberally?
on a bad day you should have at least twice as many casts of execute as you do
you're running the execute build and don't want to hit execute as much as possible?
you see how that doesn't make much sense right
if I was you
I would run punish
it's not far behind with realistic RNG
lol no, I'll use it. I just thought I needed to wait until it procced or I was hurting my SS & Rev casts
I love Archon AKA providing information that is incorrect/not possible.
you prio SS if you're not going to rage cap, for sure
but you have so many fucking casts of IP
you hit IP 79 times
haha yes, exactly. I am trying to train myself to get off my IP hotkey
like if the boss is below 35%
you need to chill on IP
the highest you got got juggernaught was 6
opening myself to sure ridicule...but I'm not sure what this means?
so look at the right of your prot talent tree
the node that's either punish or juggernaut
Trust me bud I've asked some seriously dumb questions
Honestly this is one of the most helpful class discords I've ever been in
you're also pressing your tome on CD instead of only pressing it when it naturally switches to shield mode
that's just free dps you're throwing in the bin
Do not ask questions in the warlock discord. They will either whine at you are just straight up ignore you lol
this should be like 90%+ uptime
So you're saying with my playstyle, it would be better to go Punish instead? Or I need to switch my style to go after more Jug stacks?
Yes, I have it macro'd to use on cd
Did anyone here ever try to make a M+ Protection DPS spec this season (non-tanking)?
if you're doing that you're better off using a different trinket
I will
otherwise just look at your CPM on your cds, abilities
here's the top thane log on heroic bandit
I'll run a side-by-side comparative
CPM is the # here, not casts, because the fight durations are not equitable
(Casts per minute)
even with your insane IP usage, he pressed 25.6% more buttons than you did per minute
So, is it not worth tracking a baseline set of metrics each week (or on certain M+ dungeons, like, say, Workshop)?
waste of time?
if we assume a button press = dps, that's 26% dps you're losing due to not hitting your buttons
that's a gross generalization, but you get the idea
yes, makes sense
no because pwar is basically the same in every situation
you can get 95%+ parses without holding cds for anything
you can go pure zug, hit button on cd all the time and absolutely blast
nothing in the raid on heroic is even beginning to be threatening to us
Just find a log (like the one I posted) of the same encounter of somehow doing it right, and compare it to yours even just the cast CPM and ask why they did that and you didn't
haha well, Sprocket's party pack was a pita to deal with until I got my timing right
you leap away and hit SW
Yes, but I'm not clear on which metrics to look up to make that comparison. Like, CPM wasn't even on my radar from earlier in the thread
you can literally just hit your shit in a random order, and as long as you're actually hitting your shit you're going to be doing better than you are now
your main issue right now is waste
fix that, then look at optimizing
and if I was you, I would jus tgo ahead and switch to collosus while I still wasn't good at thane because it's better in basically all content this season
Yeah, I know I spend too much time away from the boss doing dumb shit like trying to kite when its not going to move. Some fundamental stuff like that
What's the major playstyle differences?
Much less thunder clap, muchmore revenge
you use IP less because the rage gen is less
And the added cooldown in Demolish
and you absolutely fucking blast in AOE
their ST is more or less the same
as soon as you add cleave in
it's over for thane
and every fight in this raid has cleave except one
I guess mug'zee is arguable
basically you can switch to colossus and swap your IP and revenge keybind and you'd be better off lol
just make sure to press demolish on CD
Ok, I'll grab a Col build, practice ST and AOE on dummies, do my weekly delves, and then try it in some M+
So I can macro it to my rage spenders like I have Avatar now?
Ah, it's an ability lol
what do you have macrod to avatar now
I use mod macros...it's...convoluted lol
It's pretty much send on cool down unless your about to get ads in the next like 10 seconds
No need to think about it, if button up press it, do a billion damage
the main thing to note with demolish is it roots you during the cast
sigh I got filtered
#showtooltip
/startattack
/cast [mod:ctrl]Rend; [mod:shift]Slam; [mod:alt]Revenge; Shield Slam
/use Avatar
/use Recklessness
/use Blood Fury(Racial)
/use 13
/use 14
/use 15
don't get yourself killed with it*
what is this monstrosity
Rend and Slam can be deleted, I never use it
cape I think
Yes I was gonna say
you need to delete whatever slot your tome is on too
yeah, 15 is the rocket pack back or w/e
because you're fucking yourself with that one
This is cursed
You'd want all your use stuff bound to like
haha...yes I am hadnicapped by doing it wrong for 15 years.
Thunderous roar
Assuming 1:30 cool down
I've given you some of the advice I can, now it's up to you
Is that like your regular shield slam button? Or?
Macroing 3 skills into one with just modifiers is cursed x.x
Or regular revenge
Understood, and I appreciate the time

yes, if I press 3 without any mod it does SS. And all the others if they are off CD
What about Revenge? You have to press alt any time you want to cast Revenge?
what's the difference between this and assigning keybinds to 3 different hotbars?
alt+3
Because if you assign to different bindings you don't have to use a modifier
the fact that all the other lines without the conditionals are going to run
Using a modifier for rotational abilities is wild
also kinda that
Prot palas being roasted in wow forums right now
if I had to use a modifier to hit revenge my fingers would look like I was 90 years old with rheumatoid arthritis
Like by all means press shift or alt or whatever you want for a cooldown, but for something like Revenge that you're pressing 15 times a minute? That just sounds terrible.
they deserve it, ppal sucks so bad they have a 30 second cheat death in their kit
imagine
paper ass tank
Playing piano to play WoW XD
Am I able to post gif in wow forums
What I do is I rebind my thumb button on mouse to CTRL key. And then I make it so first actionbar is bound to keys 1234567
Next bar is CTRL + 1234567
So if I want to do next action bar of abilities I just hold thumb on mouse. Voila!
My thumb is now 7+ abilities
I just use an mmo mouse
I used to do that before I got an MMO mouse; had one bound to ctrl and one to alt
but I do that same thing with shift in games that have shift to sprint
I put shift on my mouse
I’ll never understand people that actively use control as a modifier and even prefer it
cuz holding shift is cursed
But my rotational abilities were never on a mod, even then
Control literally a cursed key location
Yeah 👍
I use one of these, so using modifiers aren't difficult. I've got the muscle memory now
They be like yeah I'm pressing it with the side of my palm
That’s wild to prefer control over shift what in the world O_O
used it for 15 years

And I'm like how the fuck are you ONLY pressing ctrl
Did I read that right
A dude just say control better than shift
What in the world..
What in the actual fuck is that thing
Hahah
MAHKARN SAY PSYCH RIGHT NOW
In some countries you actually arrested for preferring control
Nope...it's how i roll lol
alt is a good modifier as long as you don't need to jump when using it 🙂
That's like that shit they used to sell with SOCOM or something on PS2
it looks like the pretend gameplay controllers i give my child
glad I could amuse y'all this mornin
hello can we ask some question here?
i'm impressed it's held up for 15 years!
I play wow with one of these
ML 3rd boss "Searing Reagent" is reflectable damage? can we track it with boss mods/WA ? it's hurt me alot
Not reflectable, but it will still reduce the damage
And you can spell block it
ngl this is still (somehow) better than the people who use those thumb trackball things that look like a torture device
Is there a specific way we should be simming eye of kezan? I picked up a champ level one last night, and somehow it's simming lower than a champ mechano core amplifier
i bought 1 of these for work and im seriously considering upgrading my corsair kb to a hall effect one https://nuphy.com/collections/in-stock-keyboards/products/air75-v2
hmmm thank you
you need to run like an 8 min sim
long sims
Which switches did you get

I have the huntsman analog v2 atm
I have a wooting 80he it's really nice
Has the mechanical/optical hybrid switches
wootings are A+
Wutangs
ive been looking at keychromes though
If I ever got in a fight with only my keyboard near me I'd also be good to go
idk if I'd like low profile though; what's the actuation on those things
keychron*
My hand sits heavy so I had to really lower the actuation on mine to not hit shit by accident
Is that the full keyboard just no 10key?
yeah basically
I'm thinking about getting one of those. I like having home/end and shit but I type numbers with the number row exclusively (and quickly)
So the numpad just takes up sapce
space
not having f keys would be omega cursed
i wasn't convinced on 80%s because im ancient and i like the numpad but after buying the nuphy one i'm convinced
even though the nuphy is 75
Thank you, I wouldn't have thought of that. So Eye of Kezan is really only good for fights that last longer than 5 minutes?
yeah unless you're like a data entry goon number pad is kinda useless
can always buy a standalone one too
typically yeah
def not shorter than 5
Yeah I've always just been faster with the number row. I can use the numpad decently if I want to but I rarely want to
unless you get omega rng
Part of it may be that I'm a lefty so maybe I just don't have the dexterity in that hand for it to be comfortable to me.
I know it's not great for M+ because you won't get enough time during pulls to get the stacks up
the meaningful size difference between a 60 and 80 is insigificant as far as I'm concerned and I want those extra keys
ive heard good things on priory/DFC/cinderbreww
I guess you would have to chain pull to stay in combat right?
yup
yeah similar to anvil and cataclysmic signet brand
Do the keys have a nice chonky sound Nim? They look like chonky sound keys
don't use it in keys man, you'll be that guy "but my eye!" whenever somebody needs to stop for something
yea could definitely see it doing okay in cinderbrew, i tend to stay in combat for almost the entire length of those hallways to 2nd and 3rd bosses
for like 30k dps
they def sound chunkier than my corsair reds
We love a chonky key sound
lol yea, I usually tend to run a defensive trinket in my other slot for big keys anyway. But it's a fun concept to think about how to utilize it
also imagine playing eye with a rogue in the group
yea, they will be pissed they can never stealth lol
I remember the first mechanical I ever got; that thing was like someone was constantly shaking a Yahtzee dice cup
we had a convo about rogue restealth and the damage gain they get is not really significant
so fuck em
yeah but its a key
A group in my guild the other night had a pug rogue leave mid key because they wouldn't let him stealth 😅
and you'd rather just pull fast anyway
ive only ever had corsair mechanicals ghash
I bought uh
but im sold on hall effect for sure
I forget, k90? is that a thing?
yea
I bought that and ended up giving it to my brother because I learned that I despise Corsair's software
i had a k90 that lasted forever and im using a k75 that has easily like 7 years
icue has become better, ngl
but it was fucking terrible later on
so I can delete this fucking software forever
I love my MMO mouse but it's discontinued now 😢
i just use g502s
I use the G600
but its not an MMO mouse
logitech software is also ass
I don’t have eye how fast does it drop stacks ?
Really? I love G Hub
100%
I shouldn't need software to use my fuckin mouse
I have 15 g502s
desktop to game and vice versa
and the lights will just randomly turn on and turn my 40 hour of battery life into 3
The profile switching was annoying, for sure. Like when it would auto swap if you alt-tabbed
yea
I had to turn that off
I just bought a ton because I’m scared they’ll discontinue it
lol roid
And I’ll have to use a diff mouse
ive had... uhhh like 3
@lusty grotto I'm sorry again nim... it dropped a second time
Didn't they just rerelease the 502?
i want a light switch one soon
the 502 x or some shit
Yep two big stacks in my closet
no thats the mx 518
Oh
which was also a beast, and i had like 2
I have a g502 light speed and all the ones in a closet are hero’s
Hard to find a mouse to fit my shrek sized hand
Gotta doom prep
yeah once this hero one dies, im buying the light switch one
G600 was wonderful; cheap, great buttons, but now it's gone so when mine dies, I have to do what I hate: peripheral shop
Shoulda been like me
My grandchildren will be using 502s
I have a g502x for FPS/general use and a naga pro for wow
so I have to have both shit pieces of software
oof
meanwhile my keyboard
You don’t need ghub
with 50x the number of inputs and macro capability
doesn't need software
how novel
You can load the macro to your mouse
I have a razer webcam but I don't think I've ever even opened the software
Then delete the software
He doesn't want you to fix this; he just wants you to listen
We don’t play warriors because we’re smart, right
right
man what movie is that
so somebody make a good mmo mouse please and thank you, much love, -zug
Oh it's an episode of HIMYM
"I don't want you to fix this; I just want to feel heard"
Only the smartest play warrior to be honest
This is basically how marriage works for the unfamiliar
true and based
We have all realized “why not just play training wheels tank” why bother with annoying shit in life
I had to practice a lot to be able to do that. And it's really hard sometimes when the solution is very simple.
try being an engineer in a long term relationship and figuring out how to disable the natural inclination to fix any problem that exists
The good news is, I'm single so I don't have to do it
I’ve been married multiple decades so really now I just keep chocolate on hand at all times
Keep the sorry in the back pocket too even though you probably didn't do anything wrong right?
Nope I say sorry all the time
Hells yeah
I’m from inner city Baltimore I’m about as hoodrat as you get
What do Canadians call pancakes
Oh, Baltimore, yikes
I don’t live there anymore
Not because it's Baltimore, btw. I had a bad experience.
Bootstrappsed myself into a nice fancy life
Yes so has everyone who has ever been there
Baltimore one of the most dangerous cities in the world
sorrycakes bagged milk eh
Back in the day, some WoW friends paid for me to meet up with a group of them in Wilmington
.. checks out…
And my friend picked me up from the bus station and drove like 110 on the interstate in gridlock traffic. It was terrifying.
Then my other friend drove 90 everywhere around Wilmington, even though it's like 35mph
No one hates Baltimore more than people who are from there
Having to drive on 495 and 695 regularly may qualify as actual torture
And that is the story how my butthole got destroyed
Oh they also took me to a strip club in Philly (I was still a virgin at the time) and bought me a lap dance. One of them even recorded it on his phone, so there's a video of that somewhere.
Just an overall traumatic experience
did cyrce's circlet got nerfed? just looked at it again and it gives trash stats
mine(658 ilvl) storbringer gives 163 every stat
thats certainly strange
For last boss of Floodgate; if you used berserker rage before the spark hit, would it negate the stun effect?
on my char pannel the sttats seem to match
No
no
Sadge
Take the ring off, take all the gems out
Then put it back on
And put them back in
Let’s be honest the way it handles its stat inference is dumb
I wouldn’t put it past blizz to have some weird nonsense where the stats get stuck because the gems never left the ring
But yes unplug and plug it back in is a trope but it also works
still didnt fix the issue, but the funny thing is in bag, if i take the gems out they are slightly stronger (ie: stormbringer gives 400 all stats instead of 163) but as soon as i put them back in the value is lowered again
did you destroy the ring recently
maybe it is because i faction changed recently, who knows
for the ring thing
nah
g 502 hero is the only mouse i would ever use
im going
Not enough buttons on the 502
mine is missing a pad and the others banged up, and the weel its a bit iffy
Go faster
yogi based
and its STILL better than any other mouse i ever use
Is doomguy yogi?
well except the light switch version
Yeah
there was back in the day the MS sidewinder and that was good
lol rhino
Yogi aka deathray aka doomguy
microsoft old mice are still very good
wtf
death ray, line of sight, cant be seen cant be killed
hide behind rock 🙂
I was wondering where yogi went and he’s just some new person all of a sudden
prevailing survival strategy
I know that
LOL
I know, because I just told you
I was here when that happened
maybe yogi doesnt know
no, i do not know if i will be playing doom whatever on release
i dont give a fuck currently
Yogi answering the question I asked him weeks ago
based
Doom: Skyrim?
i want to play it
Back then he just shit directly on my chest in response to the question
they need to take fuckin
i remember, ghash
duke nukem and doom guy and halo man
and put them all into starc raft
and its a shooter game
and you kill zergs n shit
I still got a different value, just this time in my favor lol, this is with new gems
666 
yeah
thats fine though
its because of the stat calculation shit, i think someone mentioned it here once
idk if it was Funky
It seems pretty funky
ok, nice
I'll go now
I think its post food nap time now
If only I wasn’t working all day forever
Then you could play dbd with me
I need a nap to prepare for our 2nd round of pulling H Mug’Zee
I leave you all with an interesting animal fact
Hippos can't swim and can barely float. They move by slow-mo galloping on the riverbed. They also sleep underwater using a subconscious action where they slowly bob to the surface, take a breath, then sink back down.
Bye

buy 20
just 1 probably
Im glad i ate before seeing this photo
i just think its,... someones got art skills
i wonder if they made the image with AI
I think it is, bc I’m zooming bc it is so weird, why it looks half a finger half a blazing hot dog poop
can we put enchants on shields or no
embellishes on crafted yes, enchants from an enchanter no
10-4
If im only pushing m+, do recommended embellishments change?
just sim them
oh its prot
Sims dont really work well with all the conditional above 90% health stuff
your uptime should be default to 80%
but honestly there's not a good embellish, they're all quite tame and close enough DPS-wise to each other it's not worth dwelling on
Embellishments are a scam being pushed by big embellish to get you to waste your gold
they do fine
but no, embelishments are just dusk/dawn
I know grips are a dk thing but I sure would like being able to transform spear into a Scorpion get over here type situation
Not really tho
Ya rly
DH have chains, pals have ranged kick on shield, monks have a good ol ring, not entirely sure if bears can vortex/typhoon without leaving bear, but as a class we're the exception to ranged pull abilities
us not having a scorpion get over here is an oversight
Vortex seems more like our spear than the other stuff you mentioned but if you’re on board with us getting scorpion get over here tech then we are in agreement
true, bear needs a better mob displacement ability as well
bears also have a 40 yard range nuke they can use to pull mobs, and we dont
and it does chunky damage depending on their hero spec
spammable too
and they have a knock
and an incapacitate
so they have around the same numbers as our mob control, except we can def talent for more
a lot more comfortably
Question: are embellishments worth spending that much gilded to craft a piece?
Finished leveling yesterday and did a couple +2s as 578, they mostly went fine but I feel like I just keep my health steady and it's healers job to heal me instead of it being on me for recovering, apart from victory strike idk if it's called like that, and sometimes I kinda notice I heal off leech but not always, is it like that? Or am I doing it wrong? I can provide a log but it's a bit early for that I guess
thats a pretty broad question
is it worth crafting at all? yes, to get ilvl up
embelishments themselves are very min-maxy this season, so it highly depends on what your playstyle is
I mean, based on the hp requirement to stay up for some of them, and the fact that they don't scale with ilvl and basically stay static, are they still impactful on the metrics?
our uptime for dawn/dusk with optimal gameplay is good
you dont typically dunk hp or stay under for long
yes they are impactful
but that number its magnitude is 🤷♂️
maintain SB up
as close to 100% as you possibly can
dont get hit in the back
log your runs, so we can point out what youre doing wrong
tl;dr embelishments: if you have a myth piece, its probably worth using over an embelished piece
otherwise, yes you want the embelished piece, typically on low stat pool slots like cloak and bracers
say I would wanna go for them, which slots are best for it? like the waist, wrist, neck, cloak, and ring all drop from the first mythic bosses, and pretty damn good ones too. early I crafted boots and wrist, both of which I got next week, so kinda iffy on my luck 😄
i answered that a line above
oh yeah, just saw 😄
for dusk/dawn: cloak=bracers=shield-if-crafted then boots/belt
those are your go-to slots for dusk/dawn
Ty ❤️ will do
my loot luck has always been screwing with me, if its a mog piece, I always roll above 90, if its smth I want, I always roll under 10, UNLESS I have spent time upgrading a piece in that slot, then I get it immediately 😄
yeah that tends to happen
btw speaking of dusk and dawn, is dusk still viable especially since crit gives us more benefits based on current tier?
both are good, pick what you like and/or sims better
I hate sims, always went for what feels fun 🙂
we have the worst ability of the tanks to restore big chunks of health when we lose it, but the best kit for preventing damage in the first place
i thought that was brew
i could never got on with the stagger thing except in mop where it was OP cos it was new
my monk never made it to max level in any expansion yet
That's what it seemed, I'll try to get used to it, so much time used to vdh so now it's strange
tbh, warrior feels to me like wow banked all in on magical/superior abilities on their champions and just kept the warrior barely there to maintain their DnD-esque roots 😄
i only did it in MoP cos it was the fresh new thing
I think I'd be WW if I played one at max level
Monk has significantly more healing than warrior with orbs yeah?
i tried all 3....brew was unique as hell with stagger, but ww was fun with having to not press the same ability twice
It isn’t a bdk but it’s def not a war in that regard from what I remember
hello I got Bomb Suit 665, PaceMaker 665, Signet 665, and Tome 678 which combination to use for M+?
Hmmmm, didn’t get a mud?
/sarcasm
Pacemaker and Tome should be the best combo for offense. If you need a defensive trinket Bombsuit is the best one there is
I think tome beats out pacemaker in offense but pacemaker doesn’t have an on use
So I guess really either sim it or pick the one you like best
huh, tome seems to be off rotation. as in it does not take an impact over the other usable trinket, you can use it whenever you wanna switch modes
can use tome and another usable trinket together if you wanna
really its kind of easy kick balls use demolish on shield jobs done
Did you mean zekvir or the current delve dude, underpin
u cant do zkevir anymore i believe
i can handle everything else, the balls just feel like absolute dump to interact with
I feel like you should at least still enter, but that's baseless conjecture on my end
The fight really is just a kick ball mechanic check. If you save all CDs for the shield, he'll eventually die
i guess
the problems im having are:
he usually starts casting recharge immediately after ads spawn
kickballs feel like crap
this feels like a struggle and not in the fun way when i did zekvir
Yeah the kickballs are irritating, I try and drag him away from them so his hitbox isn't overlapping them, can go get some during casts or pathing
crafted trinket or no
did we get a sparkthis week?
yes
No imo as annoying as it is to try and farm the right ones
there are crafted trinkets ???
Kickballs become super easy if you bind an interact key
The only hard part of that fight was the trying to kick balls he stood on
If you craft a weapon as prot warrior what embellishment do you put on it?
Just put it on bad armor slots
So Incase you get a 678 vault slot you can move it around
TY
look what i got guys 🙂 good thing we talked about it today right ?
hey I got this same thing today!
its insanely good right ? 😛
what am I missing out on
Hey guys how is warrior for pushing high keys? If I’m doing 15/16s on my bdk are they pretty chill on warrior in terms of survivability?
Friend got a +2 ToP on his fresh 613ilvl priest that we didn't feel like doing
but we get insta declined from every other 2
😔
There's a warrior in the top 200 runs but no BDK
(plus a billion demon hunters)
I refuse to play vdh lol
Good
but on bdk I have to sweat to survive some massive pulls. Is warrior the same for trash pulls or relatively chill with SB and IP
with SB
Oh and why don’t people recommend you craft a 675 wep? Is the wep ilvl not important?
harrow, tell me im not crazy
shield = block value = shield block
shield > weapon > everything else
ty, i needed that
well idk maybe you're a serial killer in your daily life
warrior's sturdy for big trash pulls but doesn't recover from mistakes/missed kicks etc well
right didn’t think about missed kicks actually
fellas how the hell do i get threat on all the lil shitters at the start of DFC. do you guys pull them first and then pull the mobs past the tunnel, or do you go past the tunnel, come back, then pull them?
actually nvm, i'm just gonna pull sleepers at the end and skip them. they piss me off
Just pull the ones near the big boy, like 2-3 packs not the 2 by the cart
Tell the hunter to MD you and go to town
if available stampeding roar/wind rush or w/e the shaman one is called, leap and zoom around the room, you can gather in 3 seconds flat
Though I just ravager far pack and double charge to the first big guy
TC+revenge as you run, hope no one gets trigger happy
Hey team, which hero talents is better for raids/dungeons atm?
colo
ty
anyone have any tips for living on Dailcry in Priory? I feel like i could barely live on a 14 with a ton of healer help
Don't scare me, thats terryfing xD
that bleed just evaporates ignore pain 😦
I'm planning on tanking m+ , just got lvl 70, and having this problem even on low lvl dungeons xD
😮 gl
Ty ty
Use spell reflect/block when the judgment is going out to take less damage and priory is the only key where I always wear a defensive on use trinket to have that extra button to hit
And even more changes!
- tell your healer to dispell you
- use shield wall at the end of the pierce armor cast
the hobgoblin change is great
kujo change is dumb
has existed since it was introduced as a dungeon
and several M+ seasons
and now it needs to be "fixed"
I'm not excited about it, but I get them not wanting it in
boss sucks
Def agree that the boss sucks
it losing 10% health doesn't offset the downtime
what change to kujo junk now
they should’ve just rethought the mechanic when they brought back the dungeon and redesigned other bosses
Do we have to proper los now?
maybe they just ran out of time
Good CD usage does drop down the healing required quite a bit
they’re removing the sweet spot idea
It’s bad design for it to exist but it’s also bad to just not get to do anything for the full channel
at least they shortened it
There is also the super hax approach of...be a dwarf and take an evoker on your run 🙂
Is it a hot take to think that damn near necessary tech like that KUJO boss is toxic?
Change is a huge win
dorf bait tbh
But I don't think the health nerf makes up for the loss of uptime, even tho I didn't know how to place kujo hahaha
They're doing it for the MDI coming up soon in a couple weeks
Where its basically just TGP now
also @lucid mica nice to see you over here from dh land. Enjoying being a steel wall of rage that punches back?
Didn't they change venting flames anyway where it's just a single hit?
Or am I imagining things
don't think so
Right now I'm just a punching ball more like a steel wall, but it's looking promising hahaha, did a couple 2s as 578 and I'm just slowly gearing up
I usually got it like 50% of the time, so hopefully it’s at least on par with that
Yeah I agree that it’s bad that it existed, it’s just kinda weird timing to change it
On the THIRD time in rotation, halfway through the season
Not wrong 😂
anyone having trouble listing keys?
won't let me list for some reason -,-
Just confirming that details is an accurate barometer for SB uptime in combat?
My blocked hits are like 70%, so I assume those are hits to the back yeah?
or sides?
Yes but uptime is irrelevant
As you said blocked hits matter more
Specifically melees
Block is a 180 degree cone, so it’s really just your back half not the sides
Ok, cool thanks. Something to work on for sure
does anyone know how the spwan positon of the 1000 pound dud on gallywix is determined?
ctrl + A on the title and delete
hmm i will try if it hgappens again
What boss is changing ?
What did they actually do?
I think they nerfed hp and fixed the sweet spot
Ah, yeah that's weird but it's not that impactful. I honestly thought it was weird that they did it with a buff in the first place.
So what are they doing now?
so traditional line of sight simply doesnt work, but whats funny about this is that things like this used to work fine like Sapphiron's blocks etc
its a hidden buff now
what other encounters have line of sight on objects that just show up?
besides sapphiron's iceblocks and that box
there are more but my brain is in brain rot right now
3rd boss of Halls of Infusion
oh true
Maybe it's something they just didn't have set up to work back then but now they do?
Oh, right
maybe it just worked on sapphiron cause it the iceblock was around a player
Is it possible that Sapphiron was the same way as KUJO and people just didn't know though?
could be
Anyway, I don't think it's really that impactful of a change; it is odd they waited so long to do it though.
Why did they have to fix it
probably because it was an advantage to players that knew about it
i can say we've known since BFA, but the fact is not everyone has played since then
That didn’t seem to be an issue however many times it’s been in the dungeon pool
Yeah like, you have to know it exists to even know to get a WA for it
Since it's already a hidden buff
Who knows, that's blizzard for ya
I mean I get the idea of it being “bad”
Why did they let Echo do like, half the shit they've done in MDIs over the years XD
But Nim said “they had to” so I thought maybe something new was going on that required the fix
I mean shit we had an entire expansion's worth of just egregious snapping before they fixed it
BfA was literally Battle for Snaperoth
that dungeon has been in play for 6 seasons
well...
actually not 6
cause mechagon was put in around season 3 of BFA
Yeah, and workshop has been M+ for 3 seasons I think? Including when it was released
yeah youre right
cause Uldir > Dazaralor > Eternal Palace
so 2 BFA seasons, 1 SL season, 1 TWW season = 4 seasons
wait no
1 BFA season
Eternal Palace technically put the dungeon in as a mega dungeon so not in keys
well then, it hasnt been so long after all
2 MDIs/TGPs
3 with this one
crazy
i guess
5 vanilla BFA dungeons are the ones with more appearances in seasons, with a total of 5 season each
FH, Underrot, ML
and AD
Waycrest
holy fuck lol
ngl I want them to put King's Rest and Tol Dagor back in rotation in the same season just to see the meltdown
Honestly, I'd rather see TD in the rotation than Arcway.
Very boring, very long, and no one wants to see another 5 boss M+ dungeon
Man
Veng feels so much stronger then prot warrior
Dumb
I dont even feel the nerfs that veng got
Yeah? Why?
Cool take. 
I'm happy being a weak warrior smashing keys with minimal damage intake.

Whatever floats your boat.
I mean
I would pref warrior
right
but
we both know
these people
will take a 3100 dh before a 3200 warrior
andits
sad
Jeah,people follow meta blindly.
Can't blame em, spell comp want the 3% dam
What makes vdh better than war exactly
Is not damage, it's not damage taken
Its utility raid buff and skips
3% for spell dam, in a meta with spellcleave
Yeah exactly, given that they do what, 4m overall dps? It adds 120k dps per dd
Wiat that math sucks
But it's not that much is all in saying
It handles alot of pulls better then warrior
Not just like
util either
its self healing is disgusting
being able to pulls that warrior would probably fall over in
Or atleast
having a much easier time
I'm guessing they don't need to worry about dying on the first boss in a priory regardless of how badly they play it? 😛
That is a lot of damage. But it is easier to think of it as: make the key combat 3% shorter
Now that is value. Then we can ask if warrior makes up for that with our dps lead.
Let's say DH grants around 400k DPS
Warrior do on avg 2m DPS, VDH does around 2m.
I dont know, seems like quite a bit to me. Especially when we talking saving seconds
I see mostly everyone wants either a boost to Rally (cap to 5) or Bloodlust/BR
Maybe Demo Shout does -30% dmg to tank and -10% dmg to group
Regardless, maybe next expac we will see a rework
And make Anger Management baseline for Warr
And they delete the left half of the Warr talent tree
Hi! Ive done all dungeons on 10 and im looking to step into 11 and 12. Dose it hurt alot more? Any advice for a new scared tank?
It's very similar 🙂
Hello guys,
Someone know the CAP on stats we aiming for ?
I mean what pulls?
I haven’t run into a pull that I’ve seen a DH do that I can’t live on my warrior
Venture co war machines on third boss in motherload
The irony when you watch VDHs just either fall over randomly or just randomly proc last resort in 16s
I did that on my warrior
War machines don’t do damage to the tank really
Is there a way to sim gear as tank? Or do we look at the most dmg?
Also what key level?
That boss fucks tanks in general
Not vdh
14 and 15
Yes the boss just hits hard
You just cover it the same way that any other tank should
Hitting hard means nothing when you can hit spirit bomb and max yourself out in 1 button press
Only added benefit is you can self sustain but so can blood dk
Someone who likes the class?
It definitely doesn’t handle melees better
Prot still needs healing where as vdh really doesnt

Idk man
Needing healing isn’t a good reason to say something is hands down worse
Paladin needed healing last season
Im not saying its not meta
https://twitch.tv/yodatv - come watch me live! I stream all the time.
Also look at that
Same pull being done in a 17 on an alt tank
He also admitted to misplaying it
He’s really not a warrior boi
My dh is pretty close to my warrior in terms of ilvl and doesn’t really feel like its head and shoulders ahead of warrior at all
The only reason I’m considering playing it is simply because it’s a brick wall trying to push past 3200io without being DH because people won’t invite you
Thats where I am at rn
Hell if warrior didn’t catch a damage nerf pretty sure it would have passed up DH or at the very least have been a dark horse pick
Oh for sure
I feel like
that would have been the 1 thing that made it really desireable
I mean
I do more dps on my prot then any other tank still
Nah
But it aint what it was
Blood dk is still stupid
I already beat my dps on bosses
Post blood nerf btw
Blizz don’t like us 😦
