#protection
1 messages · Page 1303 of 1
Specifically that boss, hard. Just like sacred flame 1st boss. After that, smooth sailing.
Generally I find 645 to be the balancing moment of being able to take part from 2-10s
it kinda depends on your group
First week. Gear check just equip 3 more heroic pieces and you should be able to keep your head above water for that boss. 10 key bee boss is similar sweatting
if they blast shit so fast you don't ever drop outa cds then it's gonna feel easy no matter the key level
if you're sweating first boss bleed for 3.5 minutes it's gonna feel bad
yeah, honestly at 650 i felt 10s werent even testing my defensive at all
Felt this way with the rookery 10, and ToP 9
top is a warrior dungeon
anyone else have issues with intial pulls feeling like you're paper? like i don't have ip or sb on because no rage. should I just start with wall on?
I like to go in raw sometimes too
charge/shield charge into pack?
If you're doing a big pull, popping some defensives before you get properly stable isn't a bad idea.
charge + avatar will give you enough rage for sb before you're in melee range, and IO will pop sw for you
Though you should have SB basically on impact.
2nd to last pack you can skip with invis, just pull the last pack into boss room, secondarily if you want to skip the last pack (I haven't tried) but I feel like there's enough room for someone to run ahead and aggro those pull it to one side of boss room and then meld while everyone is on the other side
but that's just a theory
Invis worked yea
Shield charge and shield wall revenge is my go to
oh yeah, completely forgot about the bee... the fire poddles hit hard too...
talking about this dg in specific, how are you guys handling the beer boss? I'pa ?
I still haven't figured out a way to proper position the boss... if the DPS are not melting the adds, I struggle SO MUCH positioning it..
yeah, rookery and top were dgs I felt pretty safe, I think only hard pull is the door before 2nd boss which has 2 big guys, other than that, feels pretty ok
It's gotta be the seaforium charge, right?
i do not see anything there id take over that but maybe thats just me.
Hm this or non tier hero track pieces
That. That over socketed tier with tertiaries
you have the choice : something you might never see again in your vault or something that is = to ANY piece catalysted
With tome, you track the state, and as soon as it turns to the defensive effect, then you activate it to put it back onto the dmg effect
its not something you pop as soon as you are going into damage
yeah just take a WA that glows when you need to press
This
my stat wieghts are so funny. And now that i got a mythic seaforium trinket, im just gonna get even more crit lol
Nice
time for shield charge to go brrrrrttt
Cinderbrew is very safe, either stun the bees on final sting or spell block/shield wall and they do nothing. By fire puddles I assume you mean the bee boss? Send CD's on them ez pz. As for Ipa, pull to corner and treat the room like it's a triangle, just move from one point of the triangle to the other after the adds spawn. Use stormbolt to slide by one of them if they spawn in your way.
shield's usually a safe bet if you didn't get one already
I did get a heroic shield from M+
but is it worth it over the Gallywix shield? (if I ever get it)
I crafted a weapon with ascendance just cuz it seemed like a fun craft and I can confirm it has been fun do big dam
Thats what im also thinking, I just got a 3/6 heroic weapon from M+ but I think that the weapon might be the best bet
the gallywix shield effect is just a nice freebie, you'd never trade any ilvl for it
block value too important
Wouldn't the effect be good for bosses? it seems it would do alot over a long bossfight
is the bullion we get from the .5 patch go up to myth tier?
if you're just parsing on safe content it might win out in dps? but if you're trying to live in tough keys for example, shield is our most important defensive slot
true
everyone died within two seconds after hammers came down and the ranged guys didn't kick the boss
on second boss in priory
how much of this is my fault

100% you're the tank you need to read the dungeon journal to your group before every boss
you think they can read?
dude these dungeon timers are too fucking tight
its week 1
where
Hc track chest?
But its champion
Get 4p take it from there
ok
also saves you a cata charge, while also being champion.
I know the ilevel isnt that good but take shield over tier pc right? that seems to have been the going trend today
I wouldnt in this scenario; what level keys are you doing?
are you getting gilded crests?
Nothing crazy around 2-4, still getting routes down and still 638 ilevel
I would craft a shield in your position and take tier
the free heroic craft is available via story mode
and you start getting gilded crests once you hit +6 keys
ahh ok, that is what i was thinking too
and a gilded crafted shield will only be 3 less then a mythic I level shield
I can also cata my chest piece so I will have a 2pc
that shield in your vault is way too short term to be worthwhile
huge!
Thank you so much for the feedback!
Also @vocal flame Even if you're fairly new or don't feel confident, definitely push delves. Theyre pretty easy as prot and 11s gets you the crests you need for max level crafts. That 675 shield will do a lot of work
yea, delves are sick for just starting out
Thank You! I did some delves last week and man are keys stressful lol. but slowly moving up there.
Especially since I pug them all
normal raid also not terrible
can easily slam the first 4-5 bosses in a pug; maybe get some tier
Yep. It's a good balance. Nothing beats exposure though so just keep practicing. Also since you pug, people are 100x more forgiving in keys when you tell them up front you're new and learning.
eh, I wouldnt do that
Ok cool, I have been repeating the same 3 this week and feel pretty good, onto the rest this week
And try your best to ignore the assholes, there's many of them
Yea practice helps a ton
I definitely would, some ppl sign up to rip a low key, those same ppl complain and leave if you're slow. Wastes no time to let them know ahead of time. Keeps vibes on track
Obviously to each their own though
i did the upfront thing and told people it was a learner/route learning key and it weeded out a lot, and i mean A LOT of the chaff.
Yep
that was a long time ago, maybe things have changed, but i doubt it.
Even myself included I completely change my gameplay when I'm with ppl who tell me they're new
i sometimes throw up learner tags now, and just blaze through a key lol
ive watched videos and guides just more worried if I am going to die or not so i feel better with higher ilevel doing higher keys
Explain more, maybe pull smaller, etc
this, 10000%
i dont chain pull or do fancy skips when someone is new unless they ask.
I have no clue what the pug scene is like
I just do keys with guildies or I get pinged
That'll come with practice and knowing what's dangerous and what isn't.
i rarely pug but theres a small time zone difference where ill pug and not wait
Pugs even if they're decent I don't do skips lol. Not worth it
never do skips
if u dont have a clue about the pug scene whyd you advise against being upfront about learning?
legit doesnt matter until like +14/+15
because people are assholes
Not wrong but that's why I advise it. Get em out early
rather the homie not get into a group and insta kicked
thats true, and you weed a lot of them, a LOT, by saying its a learner run.
If you're real new it's best to make your own groups anyways (imo)
But yea you do run the risk of an insta kick. But it's probably for the best.
i have one surefire key group and then my guildies, but theres a time zone difference, a smol hour of purgatory where i might pug in a gaming session.
Got the crushers. Simming 150k dps increase haha. Cant wait to try it out
Oh shit nice
im also dating a wow player, and shes my raid co tank so im actually pretty set lol
the other trick; if you have a good run with people, ask them if they want to do another key
^
Yo can I infer from the pinned message that your spec doesnt matter if you're fishing for tier set? Or rather, I can go prot and it's fine?
no reason to disband if it was a good time
Chaining runs with successful groups is big big
This is very true
ive been slowly adding good dps over the past few years, and theyve become my go to key runners
Good idea, never tried that
the next thing you do is then add people; doesnt mean you play with them all the time, but now your name is blue to them in lfg
I'm no hippie by any stretch but just being more positive as a whole needs to happen and ppl generally respond well to it too
its what people do for title pushing while pugging; helps weed people out
Yup yup
and people can be like 'oh yea, i played with him. Hes cool'
what route have you guys been using for floodgate? going straight and doing a big trashp ull, or going right towards 1st boss?
Ive been doing big trash pull with lust
not sure what the pug strat is
I make lots of notes on new btag added people so I remember who's who lol
first boss seems like it can go sideways fast
i HAVE to do that lol
"devoker who ripped threat off me in priory. good deeps."
Same lol. People ask to add me all the time and I never remember. Especially if they're on a different class next time around
Only done it once but I just grabbed stuff at a comfortable pull size and went in objective/boss order
And it was fine
"Seems solid, keep for now"
May sound silly, what's the current justification for taking Thunderous Words over Spear? Is there any extra bleeds I am not thinking of that makes it's value more?
Or "terrible player, added to be nice, remove later"
preference really
Honestly, keys with pugs sucks. It’s too reliant on dps
last night, had a slghtly undergeared chick who had more interrupts than the rest of the party combined
"kicking queen"
but roar is easier
i've been oing this, but not sure what others are doing
Hell yea
I do 9 as my first pull
and I also grab the pack just north of it
try to avoid snipers
snipers big no no
8 is my first. Boy do i do that place wrong lol. Early enough in the season where I haven't checked routes yet lol
Hahah same here
this is what I do
wth, i do 8 first also lol
i'm just trying to figurte out whats gonna be most successfull with pugs
No idea; is first boss challenging in pugs?
I just pull the snipers and big robot at the start my healer and dps hate the jump
This makes me feel better. Way closer to just what I came up with walking around the place
Why is defenders aegis a better pick over impen wall with colossus?
Are these the shield wall talents
yes
If they are then I'm pretty sure it's a matter of having two charges is really good in general for flexibility, and also since you run the avatar talent it results in more avatar as well
I'm not convinced you HAVE to run aegis but I have liked it better myself
Because they removed the rage gen from it
Ill give it a shot, this makes sense
This too
ahhh ok
It's not even just for Colo; it's better for Thane, too, because of the loss of the rage gen and SW's base CD being reduced, so the flat CDR from DA is a larger percentage of CDR than before
Hey everyone
Returning warrior tank here. Only looking to really do mythic dungeons, as I don't have much time for raids.
So, I've already done a few dungeons and mythic 0.
With ignore pain, should we be using it all the time when we can?
Is there a weak aura or something to track its uptime?
MY EYES
Isn’t signet decent
on point with all my vaults
Uptime on it is irrelevant
Generally you want to use it if you have excess rage or a big tankbuster coming up
i guess ill get the tier chest
I'd recommend revisiting one of the guides on Icy Veins or Wowhead, your preference, but to answer directly:
IP is handled mostly passively by just pressing it as a rage dump. Uptime is 100% dependant on damage profiles and doesn't tell you much
Ah I see. Did they rework it a little? Didn't it used to be like a shield?
It still is
You get applications of IP from doing your rotation properly without even needing to hit the button (Violent Outburst), and it gets fluffed by also doing your rotation and damage (Brutal Vit)
But you get a ton of it passively
I know Hekelli has a bug right now where it says to never use IP during execute windows, lol.
BECAUSE IMPENEDRABLE WALL NO LONGER GIVES SHIELD SLAM RAGE GEN
sorryt caps
It's our secondary form of rotation mitigation, with the primary form being blocking
are you guys using this to secure 2set asap or saving it to get 4set?
Do you raid in a guild
i do yes
I would check with your guild then
You can think of it like how Prot Pala's main mit is the armor from SotR, and can optionally add in self-healing with WoG as a secondary form of mit, except ours is an additional absorb
Since sending it on 2set is generally a bad idea if your guild is managing loot
why did i have to get this from the tw chest....
Unless you’re told otherwise
His raid lead's a NEEEEEEEERRRRRRRRRRD
If it's still the same guy who I went to high school with
Alright, so rotation generally, you want to charge, shield slam or thunder clap for aoe then block right?
Just trying to get back into the swing of things
I'll once again point you towards one of the guides on Icy Veins or Wowhead; your rotation priority technically will slightly depend on what hero spec you are, but both guides will address that in a basic manner
But general rotation prio is always SS > TC > Revenge, and you should never have a dead global
So you're going by "Luerce" now nerd? Haha whats up douche bag, it's Tanner from Highschool. Remember me? Me and the guys used to give you a hard time in school. Sorry you were just an easy target lol. I can see not much has changed. Remember Sarah the girl you had a crush on? Yeah we're married now. I make over 200k a year and drive a mustang GT. I guess some things never change huh loser? Nice catching up lol. Pathetic..
So you're going by "Nish" now nerd? Haha whats up douche bag, it's Tanner from Highschool. Remember me? Me and the guys used to give you a hard time in school. Sorry you were just an easy target lol. I can see not much has changed. Remember Sarah the girl you had a crush on? Yeah we're married now. I make over 200k a year and drive a mustang GT. I guess some things never change huh loser? Nice catching up lol. Pathetic..
Thanks I'll check it
im smoking gator gunk on the grassy knoll so lost in the sauce i feel like a crumb presidential pursuits put me in the primary im pulling out my secondary and blasting all these fucks back to their first trimester i'm feeding the streets with blanket statements and empty promises i'm a trench politician you get it out the mud but cant get the mud out of you your past will be your downfall and your opposition has front row seats came out the womb punched in on the clock i'm not clocking out until god takes my shift away from me every day i link up with affirmations to talk about the whats and whatnots of my future fanum taxation is theft i have so much motion that i'm a working hypothesis for why we have earthquakes my bag mysterious the way i'm getting to the bottom of it sitting adjacent to the toilet 2 IPAs in i feel like i'm in trigonometry class except i got my x solving for me what's the deal with social anxiety just guzzle your brew hit your burnt ulta pod and spit affirmations at shorty it's not that deep
Zoomer copy pastas give me such intense whiplash.
how is babby formed?
lmao idk i think its fucking funny
and im ancient
We’re so back the way he nods is so tuff that shits trim $8 phone case forex and commodities connect strawberry mint hair growth oil individualize it to a single unit it’s even easier bruzz house or bop house what I do instructions unclear body check Sydney Sweeney frat sweetheart check the water in Cupertino they’re gonna show this on Fox News bite the curb Chinese social credit I am paying WiFi for this next segment Mongolian tech extremist finger paint nothing ever happens ye sloth thinking he getting some pow envy found alive dick-tac-toe a winner academic weapon trim bro trim barbecue bacon burger Dubai chocolate good tradwife who’s getting the best head who’s getting the best radiation it’s so preppy in here sticking out your gyatt for the Rizzler Gail Lewis
lmaooo
I should get around to finishing my tactical nuke copypasta
It’s like 4 discord message limits long
rofl
do it up
thought this was dracula flow for a sec
I check back in just to see quality
At the moment I'm ilevel 612 and seemed to be getting destroyed in mythic dungs sometimes lol
i mean
ur ilvl 612
ofc ur getting destroyed
#protection message @dusky canopy your trinket karma hit me hard pls send help
ur low ilvl by last season standards
hey, i started this season about ilvl 615-ish
Trying to gear up but need to do mythic 0 really xd
heroics will get you 619s.
Surely not worse than the platinum armor shit
Do you know how much damage we take?
If 345k is a life saving amount, there is problems
bottom of the barrel is made up of multiple planks here
wood glued together
At least it gives primary stat
im so pissed at this vault im just gonna leave it there
What about the platinum plating? I think that's F Tier.
no don't
take it from me
just as bad!
I've opened like 6 vaults on my shaman so far because of things like that, Nim
its like
fine
not bad
just fine
oh wait no
thats the 3rd trinket in F tier
its ALSO terrible
Lol
That trinket is still not great; it still at least has primary
Hahah
That trinket is a delve drop no?
Rip me
nothin worse thangabage ball tbh
but we've got some rock solid trinkets this season mostly all pure damage though so if you were wanting something defensive, my condolences
I think our tier list is sleeping on Signet of the Priory. It's not just a big stat cooldown for us, but since it's BiS for a ton of people, we're also buffing anyone else using it.
first hero item of season this is the worst trinket trust me
it fuckin sucks to use
wait whoa they buffed it
it used to be 10 seconds in the air
lil bro can’t aim 💔
the masculine urge to drop all personal branding and rebrand myself to "garbage sphere" on all socials
You get a lot of damage from minigaming Tome since it's a tank trinket, and some of the other trinkets just do a lot
is there a tome WA
uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh probably maybe?
You give me that trinket I’m moving like prime Jordan windmill dunking on toddlers
I was just gonna craft myself a shitty half-ass one if I ever got a drop
lol i aint standing around for 10 seconds (this was before it was apparently buffed)
If you're going entirely solo, it's the only way to get higher level gear ignoring gearing for pvp
But you don't lose out on loot being in a group for delves, either
Tome is my other one currently 🙂 Had to do 29 runs of Priory for the fucking thing.
29 runs isn't luck, it's madness inducing.
Ty guys really helpful.
that's more runs than I did M+ at all last week
I think I ran like 7 M+ dungeons last week?
I was using Big Red Button and wanted it gone.
no, wait, i had 3 slots, so it was at least 8
yo when looting for prot do yall loot as fury if no shields
Prots in a good place right now right? I switched to monk in bfa because of how poor prot was.
Depends on if you need a 1H or not
Ye generally
dont need 1h
There's also value for going Prot lootspec for some trinkets that only drop for tank, like Tome from Priory
We feel great in my opinion. Big deeps, sturdy as hell.
Ignoring that Prot War was relatively cracked for most of BFA, especially the end All tanks are in good overall spots and capable of content
There's none that are struggling in any meaningful way; there's some that are lagging behind in DPS from time to time, but any differences will only really make differences in World First keys and you not being a BDK for mass grip in the raid fight that effectively requires you to have mass grip
Our damage actually feels meaningful right now. It's so much fun. 
We're not even like drastically popping off, either. Other tanks do close to our damage or can even go pass iirc. It's just harder to do that damage
since we just press demo, press revenge five times, bam, top of the meters
This is just fake news
Yeah, VDH also does rock solid damage. I just am not used to being able to match the Illidan cosplayers in that regard.
Prot sims and performs higher than the other tanks
Am I thinking you can just copy the string for talents and put it straight into the game?
Other tanks haven't even had their APLs set until recently. You can go and check in with Nome, too, if you want specifics
Do you just copy and paste it?
do we go 2pc-2pc?
Our last set was garbito, I wouldn't prio it at all.
Our S1 tierset was garbonzo
Go for ilvl.
It's very likely you'll swap out for ilvl, ye
how i love this fellow tank pals....1. id and some moonkin rolled on tank trinkets...:< had passed for a fellow tank..and then that....grml
aight ill wait till heroic to catalyse rn not doing 10s just yet for myth
After the nerfs, 10s are actually achievable for normies at the moment. I got one last week to my pleasant surprise.
floodgate is still rough for me it seems
Floodgate is one I actually enjoy quite a lot, fun bosses.
I'm in the minority on this, but I actually kinda dislike Motherlode. Every route I do feels wrong.
If anyone has a paste-eater ready route for Motherlode, please link it. Assume I'm allergic to invis pots.
hold w
FG is great if u not have to heal the 3rd boss
after getting 4pc how would the talents be like? just drop rav for battering ram or what?
This
This is an option
But you can keep rav if u think you need it
^^^
what (or would you) drop to get battering ram if not rav?
you just don't get ram in that case
You don’t need BR
hmm ok
It’s just good in synergy with set
They're quite similar in value once you get full tier set, though ram is technically ahead
You lose out on the benefits of Ravager, though
Like it being nice for aggro on pulling groups and what-not
how should I use the priory book trinket? like force switch it to damage when I want to do damage or switch it to magic absorb when I'm tanking magic damage?
does it always switch modes when I press it?
I would take BR and adapt to play without rav for a couple of keys
thanks guys @pallid quiver @ionic nimbus I'll test playing BR without rav to see how it feels. I don't really like rav but its good for aggro, but I'll test it, thanks =)
For vault, would you guys take a tier helm or tome of light's devotion (both myth track)
I already have tome but it is champ track
Npnp
FFFF i took heroic lock n stalk
Tome
my myth track slots were all ass
you can always cata a myth helm
tome probably bc can catalyst a tier set on any piece
Nome has a write-up little thing there
are you guys looting vault as prot this week bc of tome chance?


mine isnt even heroic
wow thanks a lot, glad I dropped it on hero then
I was leaning the other way only because you have limited catas atm and you can run priory unlimited times for the hero track tome
nice shield
But consider that your literal only source of Mythic Tome is from vault
You can get Myth helms from Myth raid if you do that
yeah it's just how important is 4pc for this and next week I guess
ok ima just come back on thursday
look at all these good vaults and then get this
yeah I agree you'll be waiting on that myth tome all season
I feel like I definitely won't get 2 pieces of tier from raid in 1 lockout
ugh
honestly, our 4p isn't revolutionary
I can't imagine +75% crit chance on shield slam is insignificant
the shield charge cdr is nice too of course
stop it
c:
It's not super great in pure ST, since it procs on you taking damage
3 myth slots vs 1
yea probably helps with shield block uptime when you go ITF
my first vault in s1 had myth track ara-kara sacbrood or w/e
:this:
do you play often
no
I do like 2 keys a week
im convinced you get loot if you arent as active in game
nobody will ever change my mind
It's better than our last tier set, but it's not revolutionary; tome will almost certainly give you more damage, particularly in raid, than 4p will
i mostly just play classic wow
i mean my vault was about the same as yours, and i am a lazy shite
Alright alright I'll first-world problems level begrudgingly take the tome
xP
just remember to play tome right
I have a WA for it already --- you do just keep the crit up AMAP right?
I let it stay in armor for the magic dmg proc in the last part of Darkflame
i ended up taking a hero tier helm
yeah i mean
thats my only choice for prot
but im thinking if signet might actually be okayish as a 2nd trinket for arms
and it is due to sims
so kinda on the fence
Depending on trinkies, I'd take the signet for now tbh
Not the worst thing out there for Prot, either
yeah ill see if i can LFR snipe a tier piece or something
guild didnt give me any last week so
feelsbadman
I don't even have a guild to raid with in general
i didn't even enter raid last week
That was probably a mistake, but I had other things to do last week
i wonder why LFR has no 1st boss
Does the map loop around or something? LFR skips around from time to time
Like Nathria skipped from 1st boss to Sludgefist iirc
prob will be first boss then straight to one armed bandit
then prob mugzee and gallywix fourth week
yeah probably
So i capped my valorstones earlier and I upgraded one of those awful trinkets lol. Rip me🤣
My brain has this same bug
Is tome a good M+ trinket?
So is it not worth it to have 2 crafted items ( embellishments) anymore?
i dont think anyone said that. you just literally can't though, not enough sparks
for m+ itself its decently good, its not perfect and you wont get 100% value out of it, but its insanely powerful on bosses and raid
Crit Enchant or Auth of the Depths 🤔
okay so ill prolly be stuck with a hero pacemaker or soemthign over it
So I'm getting absolutely eaten alive in mythic plus do I just need to get better. The magic damage dots are rough so unless I take specific group comps finding it hard
hard to say without logs, might be a healer issue. Post a log in #1347646810457636974
How are you lot finding them in general where are we sitting
Could also be not enough IP and cd usage
technically you craft on cd (after you start crafting ofc)
you lose 0 crest crafting
not particularly bad
its fort so plan your defensives
well, fort into tyr i mean
since last week was tyr into fort
Fair enough maybe it's just cd usage then, I'm running colossus so feel like I'm at least using IP etc when needed and the demolish to help maybe more last stand
we all run colossus here for the most part
nome says jump, we jump
summersault even
thoughts nim?
lmfao
spooky
do you not realize that it's much harder to get the exact trinket you want out of vault in comparison to the fact that you have multiple sources of myth track helmets that you can mostly freely change into tier?
tier is not that insane
Sure it depends on your goals, I generally only play the first 3 weeks of the season then completely stop pushing
I promise you
so getting tier earlier is very useful to me, but IDK what you mean, I took the tome lol
tier does almost nothing for you gameplay wise
did an 11 last week with only 2p
pre nerf
Where do I go it I want to see what talents other warriors are running in raid fights and M+?
o. O what do you mean? I'd imagine the damage upgrade is significant, swapping to ITF, getting more shield charges in general is useful in m+
Hero track of that trinket is really not much worse
you already ran ITF if you had the haste
What what. I don't craft on cool down?
The only significant change is you swap to battering ram over ravager
and while yes, it's a damage upgrade, that's not what is keeping you from timing keys
xD well of course not but having a good chunk of extra dmg for free is always good
you're never replacing the myth track version and you don't know if you'll ever see it again
you will see plenty of myth track armor
I really don't know why you're typing to me like this is still up for debate
I already agree with what you are saying lmao
^
Hey Lei
yo
Fuck you nerd
im too much of a pussy to open vault as prot
hell yea
yeah fuck you pash!
too many shit tank trinkets
lets argue!
because you're still defending a poor line of logic?
YEAH!!!!
This is the prot warr discord channel baby we get VIOLENT
You want a fight so bad it's fucking wild.
I've EXPLICITLY not defended it multiple times now.
How do you read this comment and then think "wtf is this guy nuts?? He is still defending his original QUESTION?
Idk I think you should take uhhh a delve trinket or something that I'm sure is in the vault
Trust
dw it'll be better than mine
first vault of the season is always scary
you dont wanna end up like @forest wyvern
has to pick socket from his first vault
wow that sucks 😦
jesus
crafting a mythic shield 2nd week is best for a heroic pug raider prot warrior who hates farming high m+ but likes delves, right??
whats the difference between mythic shield and gilded shield?
ah ok, i just assume a crafted mythic shield would have 3 less ilvls than a mythic shield drop, so gilded is the adjective used to specift its crafted
but mythic shields only drop from raid or vault by doing 10s
crafted gilded crest shield lol
to be precise, anyway im being anal about it just ignore 
😄 npnp
but yeah go for it, to answer your question
ty ❤️
its a massive defensive upgrade
Would you take the myth ring, or the heroic tier shoulders?
Just the tier of trinkets that suit my personality
6 tokens and get the gold. gear is a crutch /s
crafting doesn't waste crest anymore, so even after your second embellish you keep crafting
Honestly have no clue what to craft with my Spark. Here to ask if theres any HUGE theory craft changes from double Duskthread
every each X week if you math your crests on the next wednesday etc you get a myth track from vault and a 675 crafted gear
i dont want to end up looking good in a tank top too

what do you mean by crafting not wasting crests anymore
in season 1 before the cost change (90 ->60 gilded), you wasted crest by crafting
since 623-> 639 (upgrading myth track in season 1) was 75 crests
ah ok you mean that
and crafts are 1 lvl lower than full so you just 75-15 = 60
as a non-mythic casual pugger, ill get gilded crests from delves and keep crafting every slot then
i would just plan crest spending to have 60 crest every week you can craft / get the spark
you get 21 crests a week from delves + 10 from each map, 1 from underpin ambush, 1 from the end of delve chests, so every two weeks, its guaranteed to have more than 60 crests with just delves
Bomb suit or hero track tier legs? 😦
You can max out basically 1 mythic track item a week
it is just the week you get a new spark instead of full upgrade your myth track, you upgrade 2 lvl (30) and craft with the 60 / you will finish with the next week or what you got left from the week before
please assist with this choice warrior frens
I'm having trouble deciding. thinking tier gloves or the chest since I have crafted boots/shield
Well you surely don’t already have boots/shield crafted since we’ve only gotten 1 spark so far
What stats are on the boots
And are they myth track
I can’t remember what ilvl it starts at this tier
I mean I had them crafted last season, they aren't new crafts
boots are still hero. only managed an 8 this week
Sim says titan of industry shield
why arent you picking tier
do you already have gloves?
everything is hero and farmable
652 champ non tier gloves
and a Titan at champ level is meh
yeah probably the better pick
hero hat into cata, hero gloves that you already have into cata
4pc
yep
well no I already used a charge last week for pants. so I should take the free hero tier gloves tho
helm into cata
yeah
not yet
Just a reminder everyone of blockable and reflectable spells
and then you already have hero gloves ready for it
good point
bruh its pinned
just say 
it has been pinned since legion
I'll pin you next
😊

is myth track cinderbrew stein any good
its ok
Hey is there a reason the special effect weapon is not bis from the raid?
it has no secondaries and we as tank get less dmg from the special effect
Ah gotcha
its a 1.2% dps increase from an equivalent remixed ignition saber (at least with my current gear)
so...
not worth losing the secondaries
easy to sim it out
prot owns
ARE WE CRAFTING SHIELDS FIRST OR WHAT
🧦
🧦
So avoidance doesn't matter much, does it?
Because I keep getting pieces with it xD Up to 5%
ST, do we send Demolish on CD or full stacks only
acknowledging you'll typically have full stacks by the time it comes off
On CD it should be at full stacks, generally.
W
Damn grats
Grats! How many runs it take you?
I am 11 in and nothing
It took me 29 to get both trinkets.
like 15 runs
when is full mythic 4piece worth replacing from NP?
Doesn’t hurt but it doesn’t really make any gearing decisions for us
More impactful for non tanks
the weirdness of ilvl parses 
hmm.. mythic tier gloves... or heroic tier chest... chest bigger upgrade atm.. but thinking hands for the long game..
Are we crafting 2x Duskthread on stuff just because of how little embellishments actually give us?
Should I take champion tier shoulders to get my 2 set this week or take hero non-tier shoulders and wait until next week? Doubtful I will have another shot at a tier token this week
would be my guess
chest is our worst stat tier slot i think, but if its your best option at this point you can fix it alter
Just tried a fortified Priory run. Am I alone in thinking it's still overtuned?
jeesus thats depressing
Why depressing?
taking a cloak in your first vault
would you put helm (crit/mastery) over chest (haste/mastery)?
Just wiped on bandit with 90k HP 
yes because i already have more than enough haste and crit is good for colossus, but i mean if its your best option its your best option
but for realy you can probably just balance out your stats with your jewelery and be pretty fine
Normal cards, or become what brewmasters ought to be
Vault Q and Help Request: YES I SIMMED
I Got the following in the Vault (it would replace this):
649-Heroic-1/6-Enforcers Back Alley SHoulderplates BIS
(639-Myth-6/6- S1 Warsculptors Horned Spaulders)
649-Heroic-1/6-Candlebearer's Shroud
(645-Champ-4/8-Trashmasters Mantle) BIS
649-Heroic-1/6-Enforcesrs Back Alley Chausses BIS
(645-Champ-4/8-Galvanized oxxein legguards)
639-Champ-2/8-Reverb Radio BIS A-tier
649-Heroic-1/6-Remnant of Darkness
(649-Hero-1/6-Funhouse Lens
642-Champ3/8-Vexies Pit Whistle) BIS B-tier
After simming with different combos, simming is telling me to replace my funhouse lens (heroic) with the Champ Reverb.
My question is: Should i go with ILVL and replace one of the heroic items that are BIS replacing a lower iLVL or go with my simm suggestion and replace my heroic funhouse with a champ BIS A-tier trinket?
champ trinket sounds like an awful vault choice tbh
RIGHT!
hero track set piece is my choice, especially in the first weeks of a tier
ive been putting this off all day.. ran a bountiful and got that funhouse.. resimmed and am still like WTF.. my gut is telling me to choose the shoulders or the legs..
yeah with only 1 catalyst and the 4p being a nearly 20% dps increase, even if the individual pieces aren't a huge upgrade
that 4p will be
socket probs
Ty william for input
Checked pins,
As we reclimb the ilvl bandwagon and we drop haste to sub 20k, we swap back to shield slam extending shield block yeah?
4p acquired 
What should i take?
prolly stein or signet
kinda sucks is 2 min and haste
but it performs decently still
well its gonna be haste if your stats are typical
socket
i'd heavily advise against socket, they aren't bad
correct me if wrong but we're sending bomb suit on cd right?
Myth rank crit haste sword from vault for me, so can’t complain.
You use it when you need mitigation
so priority of the sacred flame is massively overtuned with fort holy shit
the paladins damn near 1 shot the entire group with no ccing them
The packs are nasty. There is almost no easy trash over there. I mean, easy mechanics, but too much unavoidable high damage.
Its worth to go from 4p to 2p/2p or just wait until I get the new 4p?
I think I've read here that's 2p 2p is the way to go
not even 2p 2p half the time
ilvl alone will beat out S1 tier in most cases
out S1 tier was really bad
I just got this one at 649 in the vault (my highest) https://www.wowhead.com/item=218125/reactive-webbed-escutcheon is it any good? Other option is a 632 tier helmet.
This epic shield of item level 350 goes in the "Off Hand" slot. It is looted from Hulking Raptorial Claw. In the Shields category. Always up to date.
Im sorry but that's honestly the worst item I have seen since vanilla itemization
was it enduring defense that's not needed anymore after 4 set?
i thought you could change a talent with 4 set but i don't remember which it is
Would you guys take shield myth (have max crafted shield) or champ legs for faster 4 set?
myth shield easily
Thats what i feared lol. Set item it is. Thanks anyway 😂
oh wow , fml 😄
Should i go with hands for 2p? i gotta use spark here... dont have a good shield btw
Looking at this for Mythic+ only, Eye of Kezan Normal or Bis boots Myth?
eh if i got it correctly, eyes of kezan is awful in m+ because it will drops stacks after combat, it works much better in long fights, like in a raid
so if its only strictly m+ only, then go myth boots
That's what I have read too.
Yes, Strictly m+. I am leaning to that too but whenver I do my "own predictions" Nomeratur goes "U WRONG" 😄
How to use correctly the priory trinket ? There is an optimal use of it ?
mythic shield or do i take my first set piece and basically guarantee my 4 set this week?
isnt galebreaker bis shield?
Shield would only get replaced with the dinar whe they come...
Thats EARLIEST 11.1.5
yeah i would pick myth shield tbh
Shield angle , also how do you "guarantee" 4pc this week if this will be your firt
not a bad first vault
i will almost 100% get one piece in raid bc of how we manage pieces, 2 catalyst + 1 vault = 4
Well thats not exactly what a guarantee means in my eyes but u do u
This one useful? Mainly playing m+ as prot warr
i mean i didn't read it but no stats so no
i mean you already have reflect and spell block too
It’s not good
i mean, is better than no shield for sure, but there are better ones
i thought our tier set is supposed to be really good?
14% uptime in a key seems meh
Its not bad, but who said that it’s really good?
dont think it was ever said it was really good
Are people using their 2nd catalyst charge this week on hero gear
Depends on your situation
If your not raiding hc or mythic it’s an option
Otherwise I would wait for raidloot
how does a champion track Titan of Industry compare to a 675 crafted shield?
yeah i would really wait if you are in a guild to raid HC
worse
or just spam 6 level keys for hero gear
imho spending a charge in champion gear is a huge waste
Ilvl is everything on your shield
Gally Shield got nice Dmg procc, but Not worth to loose armor
so whats the best spark usage? crafted shield if im a scrub with no acess to myth or lvl 10 keys yet?
Is this trinket worth taking over tier piece on hero track?
well you could always get this trinket in hero track
But you will postpone ur 4t possibility
by choosing it
i would think hero tier is better tbh
same
I already have a myth helmet 662 from 1st boss myth which i could catalyze, should i take trinket or still take tier with socket
@jagged pier you dps in raid or nah?
Trying to decide if it’s worth it to just send a craft on a shield since I’ll be opening vault as arms for a while
i dont and i wouldnt waste your craft yet
Sadge. I'm guessing I take the trinket because ring is one of our best sources of haste and that ring has none.
At least it means I won't need to farm trinket from priory....
(and yes, I don't have discord on my PC, so it's a phone photo)
I don't mythic raid so was hoping for my myth track piece to be the good one 🙂
Tome is at least in principle farmable
Is this trinket good or is the lack of stats just bad? It’s either between this or the first set piece for me atm 🤔
Just keep the myth helmet as it is.. take it as offpiece.. Great stats and mythic set helmet has 0 haste

hey big boys
fellow prot war needs another prot war for Sprocketmonger lockenstock on Heroic if you're down for the kill
F
other myth track choice is trashmaster back 
thats not a bad back
listed in our bis gear i think
member that is just top simming when u have it all
yea, I know
but why this is so high? due to not enough vers on other items, thus making it goood in the end?
Guys just got Modular Platinum Plating on my mythic +10 vault, I read up that its a shitty trinket but its my only mythic item for now, should I get it?
but myth cape on week 1 is kinda monka
Tbf i would rather take socket than myt trinket i wont use . U may use it for future as "free upgrade" once u get another, but still ...
I got the pacemaker from my other vault slot... but it just feels bad picking something that is "farmable", should I go with socket?
I even have hero 1/6 chest from my delves, maybe that is worth a pick for the tier bonus
Besides Logs, what Information can i look at in Details if i did well tanking?
details doesnt really tell u anything for that
no access to mythic right now. prolly next week, upgrading or crafting a shield?
one of the worst trinkets ever put into the game before the buff, i can't imagine the buff helped much
take the tier
2p>4p 
absolute dogshit
Cheers for saving me from the noobtrap trinket boys 💪🏻
guess I'll catalyse the pants
Really not happy to have the 2 ToP trinkets back. Additionally we have mechagon and Rookery trinket. Thats a proper big yikes for vaults…
And don’t forget big red button..
Best think to craft first is shield, right?
I did 1h wep so naturally I had one in the vault. I think 1h wep is biggest for dps.
Eye of Kezan any good? Just got it from a chest
prot not looking so bad after all right?
our best trinket
always was fine after the second set of changes from the ptr
Mastery?
well it procs main stat so .. i guess
the effect is good and we still want mastery
thats just what track its on
I see.
items are separated in tracks, a minimum ilvl 1/8 and a max ilvl 8/8
Crafting time ladies and gentlemen, shield incoming. I appreciate this guarantees I'll get one next week, but heyo 🙂
Mastery is not a bad stat for us. Think back to BfA, where this Bastion of Might Azerite Essence buffed hell a lot of mastery during Avatar. Big Mastery = Big Flat DPS increase
Mastery is just not covering our weak Spots, that’s why we dont want to Stack it on our gear. Big trinkets with mastery are fine
anyone know if the 2set dmg reduction from nerubar tier is better than upgrading to non-tier 645 items?
tier is 639
thanks
Spam keys to collect Hero pieces and your good
I regret signing up to be permaball on stix, my parses will never recover from this decision
just share it
Guessing you need to be a blacksmith to craft this? Im desperate for a new shield lol
Do 2000 M+ Rating this will give you at least 2p.😬
im like 2.6
but i aint gonna catalyse for 2pc
only catalyse for 4pc
i need 1 item from raid
and i can get 4pc
getting non-myth tierset is so aids
Feelsbadman
Atleast HoC, the rest sounds like socket
ye
Got a mythic non set head. Atleast a good item for Catalyst. Rest was totally awfull or hero shit…
i took ToP ring out of my vault this week which I guess I can't complain about too much. insanely good stats
Any recommendations?or I just take tokens
Gally Trinket would be my choice there
pugs were barely managing +7s so I didn't do a single +10 week 1
so sad
I wish my friends actually showed up like they said they would
Never trust in assistance.
i have set up an A team and a B team. the B team is actually better but theyre so unreliable lol.
still haven't dropped a single weapon
yeah I only have like 3 friends who play wow so
ah alright, my b
whats the best item to craft?
shield
also if i got a 658?
mhmm, prolly follow the wowhead priority list if you already got a good shield. what shield is it?
crit haste one
how often do you mythic raid or do 10's?
personally i stuck with crafted shield despite having a heroic shield, because ill soon be able to recraft it into mythic quality, and i dont think ill be getting a mythic gally kill any time soon.
same
shield is the biggest impact
per ilvl
armor is op
since I don't care I just craft shield + weapon and then switch my loot prio to dps for the rest of the season
feels so weird that armor is both an offensive and defensive stat rn since it feeds into Strength
its a wild feedback effect that really makes shields strong
Got my first 10 of the season done yesterday, DFC
The creepers are probably the single scariest mob to fight
In like any dungeon
those the stacking debuff shadow snakes?
Yeah
Even when they don't eat other adds if your group doesn't kill them quick the dot just gets out of control
I have found however that if you reflect right as the debuff timer hits 1s you can actually delay it long enough for it to fall off sometimes
i just continously press more defensives until i am victorious.
So real
when I was playing VDH I pulled like four creepers at the end
I just ended up leaping back forth XD
NOOOOOO
NEVER GO FULL CREEPER

id take the reverb radio or socket
that gally trinket is only normal
no spark dis week
but you can buy spark?
oh true
right
can buy spark

damn, whats wrong with my token vendor
did they remove spark from vendor
ye
Honestly tho that makes sense
Cause I feel like having a second mythic crafted item this early is just too good
tell that to 2H str users

getting gapped by my VDH off tank cause he has a sexy 676 weppie
and ya boi is stuck with 658
Meanwhile fury

also doesnt help first 2h is off the trash boss
which, if streams are anything to go by, aint just falling over week 2/3
not a fan of that one
i am
uptime feels weirdge
prefer pacemaker / bombsuit
bombsuit only cuz im a nub n need safety net sometimes
i like it for the haste
bombsuit is cool; was nice on my DK for week 1 key pushing
but for sure dropping it once I get a bit more I level
Fair yeah, if you dip though it turns into a really weak tank trink
but 10s at 640 was still spicey
truuuuu
exactly
I should be cramming not yapping we have a test in 34 min
It’s free 3k haste on 30% uptime
its nice to have a trinket that gives u stats if u dont dip or a shield if u do
It gives you stats regardless
better than a shield + stats if u dip
yer its not nothing
cuz it comes with mainstat
isn't that like 2/3 of a colo IP cast
yeah but for free
fair
Not implemented in sims though
lots of cool trinkets this tier
on a mainstat trinket that also grants secondary stats
at least, better then last tier
was basically, Sacbrood +whatever other poop you got
This tier’s trinkets are very weak idk
I'm not knocking it by any means, I just pref bombsuit rn cuz sometimes I fuck up bad and it makes a good bandaid
I like options
There’s some more unique ones but they’re less impactful
what
by a landslide
Low bar
I mean, theres no Spymasters
Trinkets this xpac been lame as fuck
well yeah
I miss dreadplates
Give me aegis and cache

Aegis was fucking sick
I want to blast
cache went brrr
I didn't actually play war until S1 DF
i don't actually play warr 
big FoTM reroller before that until my raid lead got mad at me and made me commit to a class
BDK S3/4 SL was so fuckin fun to me just cuz huge number
love still being a 1pc gamer
skill issue
imagine not getting fed all the zenith tier in your alt raid
couldnt be me

we started vendoring zenith last night


