#protection

1 messages · Page 1128 of 1

real fossil
#

I don’t have a trinket like this yet, but it seems like no one can answer very well how the damage mitigation works

tribal wharf
pallid quiver
#

hey that's like some of the healers i've seen around

real fossil
#

The reduced damage taken trinkets I think are hard to feelycraft out and I honestly have no idea what their value or implementing is

merry sluice
neon elk
#

Am i tripping or doing something wrong , or is there not that big dps gain on wep ? (619 vs 636)

hollow sphinx
#

as I got a 2k rating - which heroset piece is recommended? got none....and we wont clear hc before season end. just joined a guild with a friend of mine for chill raids

merry sluice
#

theyre actually part of a guild i semi know

#

so ima go gremlin mode and show screenshots the gm

#

be a little quirky

mighty valley
#

how miserable does your life have to be before you start telling someone they should die because a world of warcraft dungeon didn't go well

#

get their ass

merry sluice
#

it was timed too
and none of the deaths even affected the upgrade 🤷‍♂️
which weren't evne from my fault wtf am i suppsoed to do about fixating adds when dps stand in stuipd lmfao

#

but u know how toxic fotm gotta be

mighty valley
#

"my life will be better if i switch to the current meta spec"

#

"oh no im still sad"

merry sluice
#

he was a hunter main uintil this season

mighty valley
#

i haven't played shaman for real since... wod I think

high wyvern
#

Is it +10 to get portal for M+?

merry sluice
#

yes

waxen frigate
#

Meters are just a third party display thoigh

#

Absorbs and heals work different afaik

indigo grove
#

what should i move around to go into roar?

#

iother than the spear talents

#

missing 1 point

ionic fern
#

As Colossus it's UF.

#

As MT you can't really sacrifice anything

nocturne spindle
#

||fuck intervene shits never used||

blazing condor
#

i love intervene movement

mighty valley
#

free shield too

#

also irrelevant when trying to get points for the bottom of the tree lol

rotund sluice
#

any recommendations on when to go into the fray vs heavy repur?

#

in terms of haste

nocturne spindle
#

are you trying to get 3 points to get into thunderous roar @indigo grove

#

i figured you meant howl or something

indigo grove
#

i hate spear and i just wanna pump dmg

nocturne spindle
#

you roar with colussus build

#

that might be what your seeing

mighty valley
#

roar is worse damage for thane and is looking likely to get nerfed soon too

fathom robin
#

Is there a defacto horde race for prot war? or marginal and just personal flavor/choice at this point

mighty valley
#

v marginal

fathom robin
#

okay, assumed so, however there is a large presence of dwarf for alliance, so just was checking, thanks!

vocal cave
#

If I went full degen ST I would drop indomitable for battering ram/instigate or bloodsurge?

round pendant
#

man those web bolters at the start of city of threads HURT

#

but I used spell block

#

and by the time it ran out they were still alive

#

not my fault right

#

(we wiped, lmao)

#

people not kicking either

wet bone
#

need to be kicked

round pendant
#

no kicks + low dps + double pull = deadge

#

had to start single pulling the rest of the dungeon

#

bad group so sad

neon elk
round pendant
#

Yeah that's the two packs I'm talking about

#

Didn't have the buff tho

#

I hate those profession/class buffs

knotty pelican
#

so on details. ignore pain. does it show actual absorbed damage or is it just overhealed spam?

neon elk
#

Yea they are pain and not balanced at all

sour flint
#

Hey men im curious about what neck is best. I have mostly mastery and some haste neck from SV (that i see most ppl use on archon gg) and i have crit/vers from CoT dungeon. The guide i read say the most best stat is haste/crit then vers and then mastery. Im curious about whats the best neck? I dont do any raid just m+ dungeon

remote tusk
#

Raid neck is besf because of its additional effect and metric buttload of Haste.

#

Alternative would be crafted.

sour flint
#

Thanks a lot your answer! So is recommend i craft neck if i dont like raid? both SV and COT are bad neck pretty much?

split stratus
remote tusk
#

Stonevault neck if you cant/wont craft.

lusty grotto
#

stop selecting targets that way

#

link the full log

#

DO NOT touch this

#

which boss is it

tardy burrow
#

do healing parses as a tank matter in a raid enviroment, as a prot warrior?

split stratus
#

3rt boss of Boralus, just want to make sure everything is fine

lusty grotto
#

select it here

#

NOT UP TOP

#

youre messing with the log window

#

and its giving you bogus data

shrewd plinth
#

Mainly fury warrior, newer to high key prot stuff. How do I enter a pack without rage?

quaint sinew
#

if u have no rage for defensives i use shieldwall

#

or charge demo shour

#

shout

shrewd plinth
#

Shield charge demoralizing into claps?

quaint sinew
#

or healer mana thas kinda it as far as i know

lusty grotto
shrewd plinth
#

Then ignore pain or shield block first?

lusty grotto
#

also

#

HOVER ON HITS, i told you this yesterda

#

do not hover on Avg Hits

remote tusk
#

Shield Block

lusty grotto
#

do not hover on anything else

remote tusk
#

Always

quaint sinew
lusty grotto
#

you have 40%

quaint sinew
#

but still need shield block up quick

split stratus
#

40% with 100% SB uptime on the fight

shrewd plinth
#

I had some weird packs yesterday where I’d feel good into the pull and then just pain slamming the shit out of me

lusty grotto
shrewd plinth
#

Like 20 seconds in no problems and then I’d be reaching for majors as I start just blowing up

lusty grotto
#

youre getting back hit

shrewd plinth
#

I’ll work on trying to get the defensives up in the right order, gcds feel so dynamic and very important

lusty grotto
quaint sinew
#

also i gotta question, should i save crests for crafting or nah?

lusty grotto
#

this is a block hit

bleak breach
#

I would personally

lusty grotto
#

blocked*

quaint sinew
#

i just started getting comfortable tanking +9s nd shit

lusty grotto
#

the top one is a back hit

#

youre constantly getting back hit

bleak breach
#

Can jump straight into 636 crafts instead of stuffing round upgrading rings

lusty grotto
#

thats why your effective uptime is 40%

split stratus
#

Oh thank you !! That is exactly what I was looking for

stable shard
#

guys raidbots always say haste crit but i'm starting 12's i should prio haste vers no?

bleak breach
#

I’d only upgrade myth wep/shield before crafts

lusty grotto
#

yeah sorry i couldnt take a look at last night's log

lusty grotto
#

have been super busy

bleak breach
#

Haste crit>=vers

split stratus
#

What is the radius for block ? 180deg radius in front of me ?

lusty grotto
#

yes

#

180 in front

remote tusk
#

Raidbots is dps sim

lusty grotto
#

you can strafe block

fathom robin
#

wait how do you determine it was a back hit?

lusty grotto
#

which is what most of us do

split stratus
mellow quartz
lusty grotto
#

cause he had SB up and the melee didnt get blocked

#

i circled what to look ffor

fathom robin
#

o

#

yeah gotcha

#

thanks

lusty grotto
#

also

mellow quartz
#

You just ran through the boss most likely

#

Never strafed

lusty grotto
#

If stunned, you also do not block

lusty grotto
#

if casting mandate, you also do not block

#

so those will show up there

fathom robin
#

makes sense, thanks for explaining. just starting to use logs etc.

lusty grotto
#

just send em, we got a lot of good log readers

#

ive just been ultra busy

#

that was why i wasnt as active today here

fathom robin
#

all good, thanks for the help

quaint sinew
#

so instead of immediate upgrades imma try to save guilded crests then, should i get a shield or 1hander

bleak breach
#

You can craft your normal items and hold out for shield/wep in vault depending on how many 10s you’re doing or myth raid

quaint sinew
#

i think wowhead had the bracers and belt?

bleak breach
#

Your non crafted items will go higher, that’s why you put crafts on stuff like wrists and belt that have lower stats

#

Although the embellishments kinda suck this xpac so I’d be interested as to how small the gain is of having the embellishments vs the extra few ilvl

pliant crypt
#

just trying to get some 2nd opinions
do u think if im gonna tank keys i need to rebind my backpedal?
im using S as extra keybind for now

#

or can u strafe properly and not get hit in the back

#
  • clump well
bleak breach
#

You can strafe, but I would have back pedal on a keybind

#

What do you use to strafe?

bold raven
#

yo! are ya'll doing your third craft this week?

pliant crypt
#

and camera

floral trail
#

If ignore pain absorbs 50% of incoming dps and swarmlords authority also how is the math then? or is it a priority based thing?

pliant crypt
#

yeah i feel like most good tanks i see use backpedal

#

seems like its annoying to strafe perfectly

#

and not get slapped

#

whereas on like mage i dont need backpedal at all lol

bleak breach
lusty grotto
#

for those asking what i crafted, i made belt earlier today

bleak breach
#

It is really nice defensively though and helps fill gaps

lusty grotto
#

will make bracers next

bleak breach
#

Scales with haste so the more haste you’re running the better it works

lusty grotto
#

and likely shield last

bleak breach
#

You just going dawnthread lining Nim?

mighty valley
lusty grotto
#

need to sim

#

i went dusk for belt

#

cause it was simming higher

split stratus
split stratus
#

Going to play in EZ mode right now

lusty grotto
#

bro thats fucked up

split stratus
#

That is indeed

viral cape
#

I am going to use a spark for crafting neck jewellery, what jewelery embellishment is best for Thane?

lusty grotto
#

none

#

if you craft neck, it has to be naked cause linings cant go on it

viral cape
split stratus
#

I really thought I was so bad, that I couldn't understand the 180deg thing lol

lusty grotto
#

well at least its gonna be a huge difference for you

mighty valley
#

i was really like... is this guy just looking away from the boss 60% of the time

bleak breach
#

I wouldn’t craft neck anyway, there’s either the bis raid neck off 4th or 5th boss or the 2bis that’s heavy crit haste

lusty grotto
#

there's also a perfectly good neck in Stonevault

bleak breach
#

Yep

#

Pretty easily obtainable

viral cape
#

yeah, I havent had luck with EDNA dropping key, so since I have sparks to spare, its the next logical upgrade

bleak breach
#

Either don’t use an embellishment or use the elemental damage thing for neck in that case

viral cape
#

thanks

#

Im only making it so EDNA drops neck on next run 🙂

bleak breach
#

Elemental focusing lense, that’s the one

lusty grotto
#

eh

bleak breach
#

But personally I’d just craft it without embellishment

#

You have 3 sparks now so use 2 on items with the lining

viral cape
#

kk, thats what ill do since again, its a stop gap until I get any from raid/Stonevault/the decent delve one

tribal wharf
#

so about dawn breaker i have a question again

#

the first boss with the beam and the tank buster portion, it says there is also another explosion that accompanies it and i assume hits the team

remote tusk
#

When she casts beam there will be an initial burst of big damage on all party members

#

Yes

tribal wharf
#

unavoidable stuff probably, so if i spell reflect and i take like 500k, 750k up to a million on those dw about it?, id have to check logs, could have spell blocked it

remote tusk
#

Id save Reflect for her Shadow Bolts instead

tribal wharf
#

i just kick those

#

since reflect out right stops 5 million dmg from hitting me

fervent fiber
#

is it better to buy 3 star mats?

#

to craft main hand

remote tusk
#

Ask the crafter what mats they need to do max rank

tribal wharf
#

oh, i got champion 1h DB

#

just now

hollow bolt
#

seige trash hurts :C

tribal wharf
#

which trash, but yes

hollow bolt
#

the first part, curseblades and riptide shreaders fucking mauled me

remote tusk
#

Their debuffs are kill

#

Negative haste kek

tribal wharf
#

curseblades you can spell block or reflect, shredders you need to shield block

hollow bolt
#

can u block the initial debuff?

tribal wharf
#

if you reflect the curseblade it puts the debuff back on him

hollow bolt
#

gotca, ill go into those pulls with spell reflect up i guess il

#

ill try to outranged shredders?

#

i tried side stepping them but no dice, only semeed to work if i ran away

tribal wharf
#

just shield block them, it only stops the first hit of thier ability

stable shard
#

was wondering why ive a little SB sometimes but its shield charge lul

#

so with 3 enemies i've SB perma with 1 stack, need 4sec under 3 mobs

#

wonder for HR then

#

losing the haste but definitely being perma SB

tribal wharf
#

yes, and when you get into more challenging content, you will need what you are calling now "perma block"

#

90% blocked hits is the goal we shoot for

#

we are mad if you dont do 90% blocked hits

viral cove
#

is this trinket any good or ok for prot warr def? or should i just take the big haste/small mast ring?

stable shard
#

i want to remove revenge from my bars

#

can i ?

safe quartz
#

yeah I got caught off guard by that as well on like my third pull in the dungeon. before I didn't take any dmg now I got farmed. mdt suggests its a cast time into a 10 second long phys dot pretty much.

wowhead says
Apply Aura: Periodic Damage
Value: 4 every 1 second
Mechanic: Bleeding
I didn't check for bleeding debuffs so not sure if you can dispell it. just prevent the cast from going off I suppose

tribal wharf
#

finger is total bait for us at least

#

take something else

#

between blocks reflects and parries, we dont have time to dodge attacks, frankly

tidal citrus
#

Hello, i'm 614 atm, I feel I being destroyed on +9 is that normal ?

viral cove
graceful kite
#

link a log post a clip

#

even a details death recap would be helpful

tidal citrus
tidal citrus
lusty grotto
#

first of all

#

i cant read french

tidal citrus
#

ik right

lusty grotto
#

second of all

#

logging is infinitely more useful

#

it auto translates for us

#

and gives us context

tidal citrus
#

yeah but i have not 🙂

lusty grotto
#

while txr mentioned posting a details screenshot, it really does not help

#

sometimes people log in a run youre in

#

look up your character in wcl

tidal citrus
#

the key didn't finish

lusty grotto
#

unfortunate

mighty valley
#

it does appear that you're getting railed by necrotic bolts

#

it would be a lot easier with logs but i'm guessing it's the usual answers

#

things no getting kicked, not reflecting, not spell blocking

#

ilvl isn't the problem

tidal citrus
#

k second problem 🙂 I can't get how to war tank the second boss of necrotic wake

tidal citrus
#

can't get all mob come to me; or retaunt everything

blazing condor
#

you just aoe them to get aggro

#

interrupts on casts make the casters run to you

#

thats about it

#

you can put boss in corner to help with the ads spawning close to eacother

mighty valley
#

it's really nice if a ranged can interrupt the furthest caster but as a warrior you have a lot of mobility to handle things yourself

tidal citrus
#

when i use mobility i get killed in 2s

mighty valley
#

why

#

you can move without turning your back to boss

blazing condor
#

probably putting ur back towards all the mobs

tardy burrow
#

make sure you arent getting meleed in the back, I usually charge the mages if the dps is incompetent and can't interrupt, otherwise just aoe and grab em all.
Edit: can't not can.

blazing condor
#

cant block from behind

#

for re-taunts you literally have challenging shout

#

but you dont need it

mighty valley
#

it helps if the group isn't randomly spread around the room, they can stay close which helps with initial aoe aggro

tidal citrus
#

yaeh usualy their full spread

tardy burrow
lusty grotto
#

pull boss to a corner with the back to it

#

try to have people standing at the wall

#

if you cant, then dps needs to handle kicks

#

as long as they are in range of boss, TC + TB will get threat

#

i always pull boss to that corner

#

on the upper left

#

like we did in SL

#

it wont make adds magically spawn closer though

#

if people are spread apart

waxen frigate
#

i love gaslighting

lusty grotto
#

but its easier if you just instruct them to stand in the wall

tidal citrus
#

when the breath is comming doesn't that fucked them up ?

lusty grotto
#

i mean youre not supposed to have him hugging the wall

#

just in the general area

tidal citrus
#

k

lusty grotto
#

whats this?

queen hemlock
#

Ive never had such trouble in previous expacs but as a prot warrior this season
Fort +7s are fucking killing me in medium sized pulls
I have shield block on 92% of the time but getting butt fucked

bleak breach
#

What level key you doing?

queen hemlock
#

Of course i send demo and shield wall but the two isnt up every pull
Feels like im getting my ass torn

old flame
#

Remember 7 are the old 17s (pre season 4)

#

What does your DB uptime look like?

#

SB*

queen hemlock
#

Yea but i dont really in even 20s until everyone else dies/ i became stupid with big ass pulls

#

87-92% uptime

#

Find it very hard to keep it up
Mostly due to trading the bleed for chance at rage for disrupting shout

#

Maybe
Mot actually sure

lusty grotto
#

eh

#

i dont run bloodsurge

#

so its not that

#

you know what we're gonna ask of you though

queen hemlock
#

100%? lel

lusty grotto
#

no, logs

queen hemlock
#

Oh ah
Let me check if i have any eith me now

mint idol
#

If I have mad queen's mandate, skyterror's corrosive organ, and Swarmlords authority, what is the play for keys? Is authority doing decent in keys? Seeing it on a lot of m+ tanks

lusty grotto
#

sim 5t patchwerk 1 min or 1.5 mins

#

thats about it

mint idol
#

Is the defensives on swarmlords significant? Or just considering damage on this one?

lusty grotto
#

its eh

#

just a small bonus, nothing insane about it

mint idol
#

Ill go with the sim then, thanks

queen hemlock
#

does this work?

#

grim but whole
mist
ara kara

lusty grotto
#

hmm no advanced combat logging

#

cant see gear or talents

#

block seems okay

#

anima slash, you need to reflect

#

and/or spell block

#

its destroying you

lusty grotto
#

reflect it

#

it does big damage

#

if reflect down, spell block

queen hemlock
#

thats the gear
talent wise
im using the icy veins m+ mountain thane recommended with bloodsurge swapped out for disrupt shout

lusty grotto
#

youre kinda fucked since youre orc on poisons and bleeds

queen hemlock
#

ah oke

#

whats better to tank with?>

lusty grotto
#

just wall em

#

and/or keep SR up for the DR on poisons

marble night
#

I’m a pretty big dummy new prot war.. are there any decent WA out there that scream at you when to spell reflect? For big reflects

lusty grotto
#

if youre not getting dispelled

#

same with the disease

marble night
#

Obv over course of season I’ll learn to remember them but it would help now

queen hemlock
#

sr/spellbloc/demoshout/shieldwall aye

lusty grotto
#

yeah i mean

queen hemlock
#

ive been spamming for ignore pains and somehow still meltin

lusty grotto
#

you shouldnt be having problems with this key

queen hemlock
#

more*

lusty grotto
#

are mobs eating orbs or something

queen hemlock
#

maybe 1-2?

lusty grotto
#

doesnt seem like it at least for melee

queen hemlock
#

i didnt die much in mist but

lusty grotto
#

ok which one are you having problems with

queen hemlock
#

the first pull ate my ass

#

grim batol

lusty grotto
#

just remember to SR anima slash

#

and/or spell block

queen hemlock
#

aye oke

#

does the spell reflect wa tell me to block it?

lusty grotto
#

so GB has a few mobs you need to pay attention to

#

no

queen hemlock
#

or its a must learn myself thing

#

oke

lusty grotto
#

Shadowflame Slash IS reflectable

fervent fiber
#

what embellishment on weapon?

lusty grotto
#

it is not spell blockable

fervent fiber
#

whats the name QUICK

lusty grotto
#

you have to wall and/or SR

#

theres no embelish on weapon that's worthwhile

#

read the guides

#

moving on

fervent fiber
#

damn ok thx lmao

lusty grotto
#

for reference

warm plinth
#

What's the name Nim, and be snappy about it

queen hemlock
#

ok wait sorry just to check again
the spell reflect wa wont tell me to use reflect on anima slash?

lusty grotto
#

enforcers enrage, and while everything is blockable from them, they SHOULD Be soothed

#

maybe you shouldnt rely on that dogshit WA

queen hemlock
#

or well im not sure if a spell reflect wa is even here, imma go check it out

#

ah just a tool to help me start out with

lusty grotto
#

idk why people rely on it

queen hemlock
#

i get used to the spells after awhile

#

just need a foot in the door kinda stuff

lusty grotto
#

anyway there's also bleeds and dots in there

queen hemlock
lusty grotto
#

but the two mobs you need to be on the look out

#

are both the flamerenders, and the enforcers

#

thats it

warm plinth
#

Nim, the name! Smh what's taking you so long

wide charm
#

Anyone have a good BSV weak aura?

lusty grotto
#

oh

warm plinth
#

Do as i say

#

I'm random

lusty grotto
#

Nickname about the current thing

#

🙂

#

great embelish

warm plinth
#

Oh I was teasing about the guy asking about the enchant or whatever and said quick

#

Oh lmfao

lusty grotto
#

will talk to you about Doom for days

queen hemlock
#

sorry i dont see flame render in the google docks
is it the same as dfecapitator?

warm plinth
#

Nim got me

queen hemlock
#

uses shadowflame slash as well

#

using sense's google docs as a refrence not too sure what to check

lusty grotto
#

yeah i think Sense has a mistake there

queen hemlock
#

ah oke

#

and enforcers are the fucking ogre magi that bloodlust themselves and slap fast and hard right?

lusty grotto
queen hemlock
#

ah ye the fuckers that go to town

lusty grotto
#

soothe does work, especially evokers'

warm plinth
#

If you ever have stuff to add/correct, you can dm him. Just be specific and provide proof. He'll fix it when he can. He won't bite.

lusty grotto
#

rogue/hunter/druid probably wont because if they are hitting you they gain stacks

queen hemlock
#

i mean i dont know what im looking at,
i dont attempt to correct very very compitent people lel

lusty grotto
#

and monk (which is new btw)

queen hemlock
#

ah yea
heard monk got spellrefect too

lusty grotto
#

soothe

#

not spell reflect

#

soothe for enrage effects

queen hemlock
#

oh ah

#

btws u using mdt to check the enemies in game or

lusty grotto
#

youre talking about diffuse, thats not spell reflect

queen hemlock
#

what resource you using to look

lusty grotto
#

yes

queen hemlock
#

ah oke

lusty grotto
#

MDT

queen hemlock
#

ah yea thanks thanks you answered the first time

#

is diffuse different from spell reflect?

#

60% over 100%

lusty grotto
#

you have to use it after

queen hemlock
#

ah

lusty grotto
#

not preventative

queen hemlock
#

AH

lusty grotto
#

it doesnt follow the same rules

#

so it works for Siege's last boss

#

on the circle debuffs

#

they just put it on the boss when they use it

queen hemlock
#

the tentacles or the big ass bugger in the middle

lusty grotto
#

i have no idea tbh

#

Nish might

queen hemlock
#

on that note, should i attempt SRing putrid waters then?

#

ah oke

lusty grotto
#

pretty sure it comes from the boss, so it goes to the boss

#

you should try to yes, but it doesnt prevent you from gaining it

queen hemlock
#

it doesnt? says reflectable on sense's sheet

#

oke

lusty grotto
#

read the comment

queen hemlock
#

OH AH

#

BLIND I AM

#

discord blocking the comment side, man thanks for the tips

#

but em honestly, is my shield block up time bad? not gonna lie i find myself running out of shield blocks

#

i am siding towards casting thunderclap over shield block for demoshout cds

lusty grotto
#

its decent

#

huh

#

what do you mean by that

#

did you mean shield slam

queen hemlock
#

the eh
there is a talent, thunderclap reduces demo shout cd right?

#

AH YES

#

SORRY

lusty grotto
#

you shouldnt

#

you will tclap anyway

#

your APM is weird

#

its super low

#

9.2 on arakara with SS

#

it needs to be WAY UP

#

youre revenging way too much

#

bottom prio

#

youre wasting considerable (but not massive) amounts of rage

#

use IP at 70 rage to burn it

#

do not use revenge over SS or TC/TB

#

and only to get SS resets when both SS and TC/TB are on cd

balmy crescent
#

So like

#

I charge in

#

Build rage asap

#

Spam ignore pain until I have max of it

lusty grotto
#

no

balmy crescent
#

And then I keep up shieldblock and IP?

lusty grotto
#

absolutely not

balmy crescent
#

Can u enlightenment me pls

lusty grotto
#

you charge, avatar, and put SB up

balmy crescent
#

I’m confused

lusty grotto
#

SB is your active mit, IP is a rage dump

#

keep SB up

balmy crescent
#

Ohhhhh

#

Only SB when it’s on its last seconds right?

lusty grotto
#

doesnt matter, it extends

balmy crescent
#

And Shieldslam whenever it’s up to prolonging sb

lusty grotto
balmy crescent
arctic quartz
#

i struggle with aggro

balmy crescent
#

So if I press SB twice back to back, it’s adds up both?

lusty grotto
#

yes

#

but SB duration caps

sleek wagon
lusty grotto
#

at 3 times its duration

robust urchin
#

Don't forget shield Charge grants you a stack of Shield Block absolutely free of charge

lusty grotto
#

so dont do that habitually

arctic quartz
#

did a +7 n +8

robust urchin
#

Great for first pulls

balmy crescent
queen hemlock
#

i dont know how to get it back to i spammed revenge

lusty grotto
#

revenge wont help you get agro

queen hemlock
#

oh

lusty grotto
#

it does piss damage on thane

balmy crescent
#

Oh

lusty grotto
#

more damage = more threat

queen hemlock
#

oh

balmy crescent
#

That’s good to know

queen hemlock
#

wtf really LOL

lusty grotto
#

yes, just like in DF...

scarlet stone
balmy crescent
#

I heard colossus revenge does tons and tons of dmg

merry sluice
#

tbf

lusty grotto
#

you use revenge to put Deep Wounds up at the start and then its 100% the lowest priority attack after that

robust urchin
#

I think you can get a maximum of like 34/36 seconds of Shield Block

merry sluice
#

as a bdk player
a lot of rando dks, especially in raid

#

just arent good lol

queen hemlock
#

ok guess i didnt read
i kinda thought revenge always does more damage than anything other than ss st

merry sluice
#

idk what it is about dk specifically

robust urchin
merry sluice
#

hmm?

robust urchin
#

So I'm mainly DPS and we have the second tank who's a DK I done a few m+ with him

balmy crescent
#

Why do people say that prot warriors are really bad vs magic when they have 2 cooldowns dedicated for magic defense

scarlet stone
# merry sluice ~~just arent good lol~~

What can I tell him to fix this? On queen i was having to afk to not rip aggro back even 60s into the fight, and I’m losing so much cdr on demo shout and avatar because of it.

lusty grotto
#

because they are stuck in the pre-DF era

queen hemlock
#

but man in that case would you remove the revenge talent and go for fight though the fire?
6% magic reduction

robust urchin
#

He always body pulls with the weird dot (two red lines)

robust urchin
#

And literally never puts down a death and decay before he does

balmy crescent
#

You can do that?? I’d be so down

lusty grotto
#

both talents are garbage, so pick what you need the most

robust urchin
#

Is something wrong with his brain?

merry sluice
queen hemlock
#

AH OKE

fervent lagoon
#

FaQ says focusing lense is best ST embellishment, but if im running M+ only and want to embellish my wep, is there a better option?

lusty grotto
#

no

#

for the 100th time this week

queen hemlock
#

yea i always though revenge was our best dps kit
never knew
thanks for schooling me

scarlet stone
lusty grotto
#

THERE IS NO GOOD WEAPON EMBELISH FOR M+, if you craft a weapon keep it naked

robust urchin
#

From what I can tell he's blood boiling for pulls

#

And just runs into mobs

#

Usually takes him like 7 seconds for a death and decay

merry sluice
scarlet stone
#

And the dk player is good… we push keys with him tanking. I just can’t seem to get an offtank that can hold aggro off me when I’m playing prot.

merry sluice
#

and even then drw is a choice for boneshield too

fervent lagoon
#

Brother chill, it's not like im here reading every message.. but thanks for the reply, appreciate it ❤️

merry sluice
#

DnD absolutely should be like, preplaced before u even get into melee range of mobs. and certainly not 7 seconds after entering combat

robust urchin
merry sluice
#

yeah bc he's holding onto dnd for so long

lusty grotto
#

is he playing deathbringer

merry sluice
#

dnd makes heartstrike cleave

lusty grotto
#

or sanlayn?

robust urchin
#

Even if I wait 5 seconds and then charge in I'm always aggroing

cyan bronze
#

I wonder if there’s a discord dedicated to blood dk related questions

#

That might be more helpful

robust urchin
merry sluice
#

he's losing a ton of aoe, rp, and tankiness if he's not DnDing for so long into combat

lusty grotto
#

then hes probably afk

robust urchin
#

He rerolled from guardian mid prog because guardian "was to difficult"

lusty grotto
#

lmao

#

i mean unless he was doing dotc

#

thats a fucking take

robust urchin
#

He had trouble holding up ironfur or whatever

sleek wagon
#

to be fair you need a very high IQ to play bear

lusty grotto
#

holy shit lmao

lusty grotto
#

yeahhhhh

cyan bronze
#

Maybe tanking isn’t for him

lusty grotto
#

thats a behind the keyboard problem

cyan bronze
#

And that’s okay

merry sluice
robust urchin
balmy crescent
#

Is the 2p and 4p for prot warr any good?

cyan bronze
#

He just wasn’t good at it

robust urchin
cyan bronze
#

I mean

#

What’s there to thinkkeks

merry sluice
cyan bronze
#

I mean maybe he’s really good and just doesn’t understand dk

#

Being able to live without hitting death and decay

robust urchin
#

He always complains about not having runic power

cyan bronze
merry sluice
#

in m+ i make sure my rp and boneshield is topped up at the end of a pull

and then dnd a gcd or too before i evne get into melee range

cyan bronze
merry sluice
#

and if he stands in dnd, he'll get more rp when he heartstrikes

cyan bronze
#

He has to drop it first

merry sluice
#

yeah, 7 seconds after going into combat

#

🙂

robust urchin
#

I'm gonna do a few more m+ with him (not my key he bricked my 6 grim) and see what's up

cyan bronze
balmy crescent
south zealot
robust urchin
south zealot
#

about

merry sluice
#

being in dnd also means he does 5x dmg on tombhstone or bonestorm

#

both of which are INSANE snap aggro

robust urchin
#

I know he has those claws

south zealot
robust urchin
#

Abomination or whatever

cyan bronze
#

I mean yeah

twilit burrow
#

Whys alot of prot war now going colossus vs mountain thane?

cyan bronze
#

He probably uses them immediately on add spawn on 3rd boss gb tho

south zealot
#

colossus does a fuck ton of damage

cyan bronze
south zealot
#

less tanky but soooo much dam

robust urchin
#

Frankly it's hard to tell what he uses because most of the time he appears to just be auto attacking

south zealot
#

its a lot of fun tok

merry sluice
#

abomb limb is good too, but thats 2min cd.

Abom no longer gens boneshield on its own, but it does when it grabs. which means another way to regen boneshield (as well as death grip giving boneshield)

twilit burrow
#

i guess heroic is colossus and mythic thane

scarlet stone
robust urchin
#

Like I dunno if that's on purpose but it's irritating the fuck out of me

cyan bronze
merry sluice
twilit burrow
#

last question: Thunderous roar vs spear

merry sluice
#

maybe not the highest dps tank, but in terms of burst its cracked, and a deahtbringer reaaally shouldnt struggle with threat lol

robust urchin
#

Like usually at the beginning of a dungeon when he pulls he's like instantly at 5% or something

south zealot
cyan bronze
#

ppl shouldn’t struggle with threat

#

xd

robust urchin
#

I think he actually lets himself get hit in the back

#

It's so weird

cyan bronze
#

rly not a mechanic in retail if you play your spec

merry sluice
#

probably also dropping boneshield a lot.

cyan bronze
#

I mean

#

there’s probably more things he’s doing terribly wrong than things he’s doing okay

robust urchin
#

You know what imma check out raidlogs

cyan bronze
#

he’s probably really good at releasing and running back

#

probably a master of bdk mobility at this pointkeks

robust urchin
#

Dudes irritating me so much I'm thinking about leveling a DK just to show him how to play

#

I could probably handle it

cyan bronze
#

that would be so chad of you

#

you said you don’t tank?

robust urchin
#

Not in our raid

cyan bronze
#

Or just mainly dps

robust urchin
#

I used to tank during wrath,-mop

#

I want to tank

#

But I'm not allowed

#

Cuz he got first dibs I guess

cyan bronze
#

i mean it sounds like you only have one tank in raidkeks

merry sluice
#

not allowed?

#

agh

cyan bronze
#

have you considered leaving your guild

robust urchin
#

Yeah but I'm like super casual too

cyan bronze
#

sounds like ur being made a worse player by proxy

robust urchin
#

Honestly I'm like mid at best as fury

#

I usually manage like blue parses

cyan bronze
#

i mean you can’t say that about him and bdkkeks

robust urchin
#

I'm convinced I could do a good job tanking

cyan bronze
#

he doesn’t usually manage to parse because he was dead from first tank buster tho, no?

robust urchin
#

But our "main" tank is a warrior and "comp" stuff

merry sluice
#

bdk's definitely an...interesting one

I think compared to a lot of bad tanks, bad bdks get carried by deathstrike spam in very low contnet, then walk in with no understanding of the class in higher content, and quickly get punished bc there's a lot that cna go wrong on dk that needs managing

#

so the bad dks are very visible

tribal glade
#

Hey does anyone know when and why you go into the fray talent?

merry sluice
lusty grotto
#

in raid you do

#

in M+ you shouldn't unless you think you can manage the gaps

tribal glade
#

im currently at 32 w/o it

merry sluice
#

yeah in raid since you're not tanking the full time, you can send it

robust urchin
#

He's deathbringer apparently

merry sluice
#

heroic?

robust urchin
#

Yes

cerulean dagger
#

duskthread lining only showing up once in buffs even though I have 2? is that normal? its supposed to stack no?

merry sluice
#

its definitely interesting dps he's doing on abilities there

lusty grotto
#

fly up drop down to under 80% hp

cerulean dagger
#

aight

#

good shout

merry sluice
#

wait

#

is he jsut not running soul reaper in raid, or is he using it so little its showing up below shattering bone 💀

lusty grotto
#

lmaoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

merry sluice
robust urchin
#

Sorry for small pic I'm on my phone

#

602 ilvl

#

Not sure if that matters

#

So by the reaction I can assume he needs some help

#

Or maybe we need some divine help

lusty grotto
#

i mean just not knowing nearly enough about BDKs as others in here i can say, if hes not pressing the most satisfying marrowrend youll ever have, the guy has issues

robust urchin
#

Like I don't want to be "that guy"

merry sluice
#

ofc a proper dig can't be given without like, full on log analysis, or seeing his rotation

but just on casts alone i can assume he's wasting uses of abilities like soul reaper, and consumption, maybe even bonestorm

merry sluice
#

but evne in my pull i had 30 exterminate, this guy has 4 less exterminate but 15 more marrowrends

#

which is diabolical

lusty grotto
#

today i learned

robust urchin
lusty grotto
#

man why arent you posting logs

#

are you guys doing RWF or something

merry sluice
#

yeah no i wouldnt send it here anyways
but i would definitely send it to acherus

#

if you're truly concerned

lusty grotto
#

just anonymize it

merry sluice
#

you can post it anonymous

lusty grotto
robust urchin
#

Like he keeps talking like he knows everything about bdk

merry sluice
#

understandable bc from the looks of it he's dropping CDs, and spamming marrowrend which WRECKS his RP economy, and dumps runes out of existence

robust urchin
#

Always telling people how they need this and that

#

And how this and that works

merry sluice
#

which likely then means he doesnt ahve the rp to deathstrike, so dropping coag too

lusty grotto
#

thats under settings, sorry i cropped badly

proud dock
#

got a dumb question: suppose i want to triple pull at the start of stonevault, are there any lesser known tech/tips to not get TKO'd in the back while rounding up the packs?

robust urchin
#

He also chimes in on other classes too

lusty grotto
#

strafe

#

back to the wall

proud dock
#

is there anything to detect something behind you?

#

like WA or addon?

lusty grotto
#

i wouldnt know

#

use your eyes

sleek wagon
robust urchin
#

I'm having like disassociation symptons from our m+ runs

merry sluice
robust urchin
#

At one point I literally just sat in my chair like van Gogh's painting at eternitys gate

lusty grotto
#

use compact mode you heathens

merry sluice
#

nano

#

that might be the most

#

relatable thing i've ever read after my week with pugs

merry sluice
lusty grotto
#

now i feel bad

merry sluice
#

nah 1/3

#

make fun of brod and lnx still

#

or my giant-ass glasses

robust urchin
#

This was literally me when I watched him run into a grp, no DND, no bone shield, just the weird red lines and gripping another pack and then dying and him saying "ahh I need more haste for runes"

sleek wagon
#

same

merry sluice
#

lol

#

haste is the WORST stat for deathbringer

#

like one of few instances

#

where ur better off actually avoiding a secondary

robust urchin
#

He keeps going on about it

merry sluice
#

in favor of something else

lusty grotto
#

yeah you only do 5% or some shit

merry sluice
#

deahtbringer only wants enough ahste to get 3 bloodboils in on their reaper's mark

#

anything else if of little offensive or defensive gain

ebon sandal
#

Is there a talent point or something where charge breaks root? Or is it for arms/fury

robust urchin
#

The last two IDs, I passed on heroic weapons for him and some other guy

#

I feel like I made a mistake

#

The other tank, I feel like it's slowly dawning on him

#

He's always like over aggroing because he just does his normal rotation

sleek wagon
#

intervene breaks roots in cata but not retail ;_:

robust urchin
#

And I can hear frustration in his voice

#

He at one point went "I over aggroed again apparently the new weapon didn't do much for you"

#

I almost cried

lusty grotto
#

feelsbadman

merry sluice
#

an old guild i used to be in

#

i was on my pally with a warrior co-tank

robust urchin
#

Maybe I'm just a playa hater

merry sluice
#

man's kept losing aggro by spamming whirlwind 💀

rustic latch
#

is there a replacement for spell reflect essentials

hasty palm
#

@strong forum Thanks a lot for all your advice ! My charr is fix, thanks to you ❤️

robust urchin
#

I used to over aggro in wrath by just using devastate from bear

#

I'll try and see if I can get the tank spot in s2

merry sluice
#

pug cot time wish my soul mercy

robust urchin
#

You got it champ

foggy ingot
#

I've felt good on my CoT

robust urchin
#

Didn't even bother moving

#

Or dndieng the adds

lusty grotto
#

i mean

#

hes a BDK but

#

as a tank you should get 3-4

#

its better that it goes on you so healer has an easier time

#

with healing the group

#

that shit that people do that tanks shouldnt get orbs is the wrong way to do that boss

robust urchin
lusty grotto
#

oh jesus

#

BDK pinball

robust urchin
#

Don't worry he didn't bother doing any orbs on third boss

#

I had to do most of them

#

While also trying to do most of the DPS

#

Also also

#

First boss cot

#

He fucked up the ground stuff

#

Didn't tanked the second boss together

#

First pull on the first boss we died because he literally didn't bother moving him at all until w people were dead

lusty grotto
#

so whats the lore behind him is he a friend of someone?

robust urchin
#

I told him that he casts an AOE right before that and he can use it to position himself

lusty grotto
#

why isnt he perma benched

robust urchin
#

And he said yeah I know

robust urchin
#

He only plays female pandas

foggy ingot
#

You can literally just backpedal and not get hit by the circle

robust urchin
#

And is super into anime

#

And here's my hot take

#

Ok but keep it to yourself

lusty grotto
#

jesus fuck

robust urchin
#

He always kept on about how he really wished pandas could be druids

#

And how he loves Pandas

lusty grotto
#

i mean pandas look swag

robust urchin
#

And my theory

lusty grotto
#

ngl

robust urchin
#

Is that he only rerolled BDK to be a panda

lusty grotto
#

i love when i get panda in the atomic recalibrator

robust urchin
lusty grotto
#

thats a W on his part

robust urchin
#

I'm honestly at a point where I'm just fuming with rage

#

I just can't take it anymore

#

I don't care how much he loves Pandas and anime

#

Please just talk about anything else for once

#

He's also like "helping" out another guild on our off days

#

Because he's apparently a raid leader there

lusty grotto
robust urchin
#

This might be like super toxic

#

But he sounds like every "that guy" reddit story ever

lusty grotto
#

pretty much

robust urchin
#

I guess I'm just frustrated a bit

#

Despite being casual I still feel like people should at least try and be good

#

Maybe I'm a casual elitist

#

Like I don't even have KSM yet

#

I'm like 30 points away

lusty grotto
#

ok sims are in for me

#

dawn and dusk

proud dock
#

went into a key, but reason why i asked if there was something that could alert you to something behind you was because sometimes camera angles mess up the POV and or i wanted to see if my strafe angles were fine

lusty grotto
#

not doubles 🙂

robust urchin
#

I think I should just start tanking more often and just tank my own 7 keys

#

I average like 1-1.2 mil overall DPS in most of my keys I don't think that's good for fury anyway

jagged gust
#

You really should

round geode
#

does anyone use Sikran's Endless trinket?

#

just wondering if it's worth for the parry and avoid

robust urchin
#

@merry sluice whenever you're done with your key. The DK dude goes on about how great the stonevault tank trinket is and how good swarm Lord authority is on dk

round geode
#

I have skyterror and detachable fang at 619, both great for ST, but not so great for m+

robust urchin
#

You know anything about that

lusty grotto
#

skyterror does ok in aoe

lusty grotto
#

since it jumps

#

sikran's is decent

#

just sim

round geode
#

613, nor upgraded it yet, but only costs valor

lusty grotto
round geode
#

I'm not asking in terms of dps

robust urchin
#

Honestly it's probably better then fang overall

round geode
#

silkrans gives slight utility

lusty grotto
#

its fine just sim

worn coral
#

The double guardian pack in the mists maze is really giving me trouble this week, even rotating CDs I eventually just run out of stuff and die. The anima slash is a real problem along with just the high damage output from the guardians and the fox mob. Any advice on how to deal with it?

After a wipe it’s pretty much even more of an uphill battle cause I don’t have any CDs.

round geode
#

sims utility against dps

lusty grotto
#

sikran's sims fairly ok anyway

#

yes sim

#

sikrans is a DPS TRINKET

#

and will SIM fairly high regardless

#

the parry is a nice bonus

round geode
#

and the movement speed too i guess?

fluid widget
#

sikrans is fun in aoe situations

lusty grotto
#

who the fuck cares about speed no meme

#

i mean i care, but im memeing when i say it

round geode
#

it's 30% movespeed

robust urchin
#

Sanic teh Godgheheg

lusty grotto
#

ok fine

#

dont sim

#

use the utility

round geode
#

lol i already simmed

lusty grotto
#

clearly worth over others

robust urchin
round geode
#

the dps difference is negligible, i'm tryna justify if i want to use 2 on use trinkets because I;m lazy

lusty grotto
#

brother

#

if you have your answer

lusty grotto
#

why are you even asking here

#

if the dps difference is negligible, what possible reason would you have NOT to use sikran's?

round geode
#

extra keys to hit?

lusty grotto
#

link your sim

robust urchin
#

I already feel like I have way too much stuff to press as it is

tribal glade
#

Anyone know if ovinax egg trinker is any good? basically a stat stick

robust urchin
#

transmitter as prot

lusty grotto
#

not trash, not the best

#

usable

#

i use it

tribal glade
#

Would you use it with sacbrood? or should i get a use trink

lusty grotto
#

you dont really "use it"

#

you can min max the primary i guess if you really want to

#

but either stacks any way are beneficial

tribal glade
#

I meant would you equip it with sacbrood, or should i get like mastery on use trink

lusty grotto
#

so youre never at a loss

#

whatever sims best

round geode
#

I see a lot of higher key runners starting to stack a lot of vers - is this a done thing?

south zealot
#

we are so back

icy flax
#

Holy revenge damage

south zealot
#

colossus owns

icy flax
#

What key was it what Ilvl r u

south zealot
#

10 necrotic wake 622

#

no embellishment

#

only 619 weapon as well sadge

icy flax
#

622 lmao

south zealot
#

624.6 as arms xan

icy flax
#

That's the first over 1m tankoverall

lone kiln
#

any1 got a good raid BS WA?

south zealot
#

theres some higher for sure

#

if i crafted a weapon with embelly easy 1.4m

tribal glade
#

Could you link ur talents for that build? 🙂

south zealot
#

yes but its squishier than mountain thane and i dont recommend it

#

CkEAmidFBOBFf5oKuZ7r/WeW7YEDAAAAzMzMmZGMbzsMzMz2CjBNGMmBwyYmZAzMjZ8AMjZAAAAAAAzMAALbbAGGstMjZZZZ0MzwMsMbN2wC

tribal glade
#

Yeh, but seems fun to go past 1m overall 😄

lusty grotto
#

progging rash choco?

south zealot
#

brood

lusty grotto
#

nice

tribal wharf
#

though i can understand why you might like it

odd delta
#

do you guys constantly open and close mdt during m+ runs? having trouble quickly grasping where i am on the map

lusty grotto
muted grail
south zealot
#

i dont really recommend it but its there if u wanna play colossus with itf

muted grail
#

🤌

odd delta
#

wow really liking three chest. lets me keybind pull by pull

lusty grotto
#

yeah threechest is my go to now

merry sluice
toxic pewter
#

anyone tanked mythic rasha'nan before? how does the tank swap work? seems the boss casts savage assault twice in a row as far as I can tell?

lusty grotto
#

whoa apb is on mythic rasha

toxic pewter
#

yes I finally found a guild

lusty grotto
#

nice!

toxic pewter
#

its a guild full of pugs like me LOL

#

like its kinda hillarious

#

just pug players got together and we pugging mythic and shit

lusty grotto
#

you guys are ahead of my guild lol

toxic pewter
#

you will be there in no time

#

just killed sikran tonight

#

was a fun fight

lusty grotto
#

yeah bloodbound horror is the only roadblock

#

until brood

toxic pewter
#

yah its all about the adds on brood

merry sluice
#

bdk can solo every other set of absorbs
asusming u mean third boss cot

lusty grotto
#

my guild just made a bad decision last week so we're behind as a result

mellow quartz
#

going from 11s to 12s is so nuts

merry sluice
#

my personal curse in cot is just finding dps refusing to kick the heralds lmfao

#

and someone standing in narnia on last boss

#

coag feels chill on bdk
having gone into high CoT on wariror yet but i imaigne its fiiiine

lusty grotto
#

its not an issue

#

until key levels you

merry sluice
#

you mean until my monk dies to the queen spy frontal thing

#

and alt f4s

lusty grotto
#

spell block does work there

#

heavy lifting work

merry sluice
#

i will say though
Whenever i log into grim batol on my dk, i definitely wisah I was on my prot warrior lmfao.

I feel like, even with a rogue, evoker, whatever

lusty grotto
#

xD

granite pond
#

Shadow-Binding Ritual Knife seems to sim really well for AOE - is it bait?

merry sluice
#

i basically have to go asphyxiation to stun the enforcer

#

and overseer is pray

#

jsut pray

lusty grotto
#

at least youre playing both classes that can delete tentacles

merry sluice
#

this is true. i take it veyr for granted

#

also the hatchlings

#

HOLY FUCK the hatchlings are horrifying on bdk lmfao

#

it is the one time i legit consider frontline potion as anything but a meme, for the moment DRW goes down critcake

lusty grotto
slate crow
#

Folks, if we can choose, which part of the teir set do we break?

wise zealot
#

Are we sending execute at 40 rage ideally, or is there a reason to send it below then? (outside of pooling for Ignore Pain for things like Icy Shard) Guide doesn't have anything and quick glance at the search in here yielded nothing immediately useful besides someone mentioning we should round up all the augs and execute them (based btw)

lusty grotto
bleak breach
#

Isn’t it shoulders we don’t use?

lusty grotto
#

gloves

plush tendon
#

Ive never wanted to play my Prot War more then on Rashanan

#

holy shit he slaps me around

lusty grotto
#

set sims higher without gloves

slate crow
#

Thanks for the info mate 🙂

#

I mean top io warriors are using the gloves XD but w/e the correct it's to sim

lusty grotto
#

of course they are

#

they are versa andies

#

also top io warriors week 2 doesnt mean shit

#

half the pop is asleep doing the raid

mellow quartz
#

nice and chill 6m dtps for the group lol

#

12's are another world all together

lusty grotto
#

actually... @bleak breach @slate crow

#

either piece is fine

#

nome has a weird inconsistency between the cheat sheet and the overall bis list

bleak breach
#

You can’t get crit hast shoulders from one of the m+ I’m pretty sure

waxen frigate
lusty grotto
#

i honestly dont give a shit about gloves, i got myth shoulders

#

and myth shoulders are also bis for arms

bleak breach
#

How much do you raid apb? I swear you never leave that place haha

bleak breach
fossil glade
#

for heroic ansurek, what are the proper defensives to use to live through liquefy