#protection

1 messages · Page 1072 of 1

lusty grotto
#

i also dont know what powergaming shit youve done thats so out of scope of our own players

round cliff
#

wat

lusty grotto
#

which btw use it

warm plinth
round cliff
#

now i just dont know what ur asking tbh

#

i think theres been a miscommunication

warm plinth
#

What is the question here?

zealous goblet
#

you are a hero

lusty grotto
#

you claimed you tweaked spell queue

zealous goblet
#

cherished and loved

round cliff
#

ive never tweaked spell queue

warm plinth
#

Then it should be 400ms

#

That's the default

lusty grotto
#

then how would you know this

zealous goblet
#

i think we should have spell batching again like classic wow intended

warm plinth
lusty grotto
#

we do have spell batching its "spell queueing"

round cliff
zealous goblet
#

YOU ARE DESTINED FOR GREATNESS

warm plinth
#

It's not really designed to be like

#

how you use SS

#

We have Devastator right

round cliff
#

yea thats what the question is

warm plinth
#

which can proc resets

#

The idea of the macro is if you get a devastator proc as you're pressing IP, you'll still cast SS as long as you're not mid-GCD

round cliff
#

right

warm plinth
#

If you are mid GCD then you just press SS the next global like you normally would

lusty grotto
#

just IP on the 2nd half of the gcd

#

problem solved

warm plinth
#

It's a min/max macro, not something you gotta worry about

round cliff
#

so do i need to be pressing IP when im not on gcd?

warm plinth
#

You could forego using it, and you would never notice a difference.

#

Nope

lusty grotto
#

if you seem to consistently IP on the first half of the gcd, which is wild

pallid quiver
#

Ghaaaaash, I'll be home soon, do we dungo?

warm plinth
#

You do not change how you play. You just let the macro do its job and forget it exists.

lusty grotto
#

then there's no difference like ghash says

round cliff
#

i just mash IP without thinking of where im pressing it

lusty grotto
#

then whats the problem

warm plinth
#

Same

round cliff
#

all ive noticed is while im mashing IP in my opener to dump rage i sometimes shield slam instead of smth like shield charge

#

which feels like an issue

#

of either skill or otherwise

lusty grotto
#

its not a problem

#

its a gain

#

cause youre not "thinking of where youre pressing" IP

#

so you may press it on the 2nd half of the gcd, which will eat up the proc

round cliff
#

is shield charge not higher prio than ss?

warm plinth
lusty grotto
#

otherwise it does nothing

warm plinth
#

It is, but if you press the macro and it cast SS, you were already going to be wasting GCD time

#

So better the SS cast than half half an empty gcd

lusty grotto
#

why would SC be higher prio than SS lol, what are the benefits of SC?

warm plinth
#

have half*

lusty grotto
#

does it extend SB?

#

yes

#

does it reset Wall?

#

no

pallid quiver
#

I just press SS and IP at the same time on ny own end

lusty grotto
#

how much rage does it give you comparatively?

warm plinth
#

Nim

lusty grotto
#

does it consume outburst?

warm plinth
#

His question is implying that SC is higher prio than SS. His concern is, if he presses IP during opener, and SC is off GCD, then we should be pressing SC, but his macro is pressing SS instead.

lusty grotto
#

im aware

#

i just dont see how this is a problem

warm plinth
#

He's asking if it's a problem

lusty grotto
#

first of all

#

IP during the opener?

round cliff
#

why wouldnt u press IP during the opener

lusty grotto
round cliff
#

u grossly overcap rage otherwise

#

?

lusty grotto
#

in the opener

#

hmm

warm plinth
lusty grotto
#

how early in the opener are we talking about

round cliff
#

wym

#

the opener is like 5 buttons

#

all of which generate tons of rage

lusty grotto
#

this is incredibly fucking min-maxy for someone that doesnt track where they are pressing IP in a gcd window

round cliff
#

i wasnt aware that "dont overcap rage" was minmaxxy

warm plinth
#

Idk man I think you're overreacting to a simple question

round cliff
#

i thought it was warrior rule #1

warm plinth
#

Who tracks where in the GCD window they press IP? I didn't even know that was a thing

lusty grotto
round cliff
#

maybe have less commentary

wise snow
#

i bound my numpad to IP

#

i just smash it with my hand a LOT

#

works okay

warm plinth
#

I'm sorry; I thought there was a miscommunication happening so I was attempting to get you guys on the same page.

tribal wharf
#

void pact science inc

warm plinth
#

But you're being kinda hostile for no reason

pallid quiver
#

Nim's been like this a lot the past two days

#

Maybe three

round cliff
#

save nim...

#

@warm plinth ok so to get this back on track, the original original question

pallid quiver
#

Like, on a serious care for you note, Nim, you might want to take a break from at peast this chat for a while. You're 100% more wound up than usual

lusty grotto
#

no thanks

#

this is me

#

deal with it

round cliff
#

if we're pressing IP off the gcd inbetween moves anyways, where does the sniping come into play? wouldnt it only happen if u use the macro as ur main way to press ss

#

or if u press in the later half of the gcd window consciously

pallid quiver
#

That being said, if it does end up delaying your SC, you probably hit too late in your spell queue. As you get better, you might want to drop that value so you can be more precise with your inputs. That applies to every class and spec, by the way. Rven if it does delay SC by like a GCD, that's still fine; you can press it a slight bit later and it won't kill you

celest zenith
#

Probably a silly question. But i am able to craft the epic shield with blacksmithing at max quality (no crest/embellishment or spark use). My question is, if i craft it now without the spark, can a spark/crest and embellishment be created later?

lusty grotto
#

yes

#

but

#

you cant craft without a spark

pallid quiver
#

Yeah, you can recraft embels on to crafted things, but you can't craft a pu ^^

#

hem beat me to it

tawny cypress
#

Any auto mark weakauras yet for tww?

celest zenith
#

hmm it was giving me the option to craft it without using the spark...

pallid quiver
#

So you can craft a non-spark needing piece of equipment just fine

celest zenith
#

ill check again

pallid quiver
#

but things that can get embels need sparks

lusty grotto
#

you might be looking a non-spark shield

pallid quiver
#

I have zero idea what the ilvl for non-spark equipments go to, so I can't tell you if it's cost-effective or not

#

But you're not gonna time-gate yourself if you craft a non-spark shield or piece of gear

tropic tangle
#

think with a weathered crest you can craft up to 590

lusty grotto
#

Everforged Defender def requires a spark

celest zenith
#

ok no worries thx

tropic tangle
#

but yeah, what Nim said, the shield that can actually be upgraded to 636 requires a spark

lusty grotto
#

dredger's developed defender, doesnt

icy flax
#

enjoy this screenshot

tribal wharf
#

BDK is fantastic at almost any time

#

at least for lower tiers of game play, stuff that doesnt require you to deal optimal dps to compete

round cliff
#

i tried bdk but i am too smooth brained to play it

#

i just cant get it to click but i want it to

wise snow
#

tome of lights devotion seems neato

#

read a book

#

get hit in the face a lot

tribal wharf
#

im stuck in the valor mines

#

send help

warm plinth
pallid quiver
#

i'm dying

warm plinth
#

Only in WoW can you have 2 handed cutlasses

mellow quartz
#

Does the veteran track gear require the lowest tier crests at all to upgrade?

warm plinth
#

Yeah, levels 1-4

#

But M0 drops 4/8 so

zenith vigil
#

man this week is so pointless

tribal wharf
#

startin to get back to acceptable haste lvls

zenith vigil
#

583?

#

whats that from, just chain running heroics and upgrading?

tribal wharf
#

585 when i upgrade belt x2

#

well, and equip 593 trinket instead of 2x 584

zenith vigil
#

well i mean

#

m0's will invalidate all this right?

tribal wharf
#

yup, valor mines lol

mighty valley
#

was it pointless if he had a good time

#

what’s the point of living if we’re all gonna die

tribal wharf
#

its not that serious

#

slightly less farming whenever zeros are ready

mellow quartz
#

won't we have 14 keys with the ones we get during heroic raid week? so 14 chances to get 603 drops from bountiful delves

orchid mural
#

Really missing Thunderous Roar. Hating the Spear. Hating that the 10% stam is situated where it is.

strong whale
#

what talent tree do you guys prefer for prot?

round cliff
#

theyre kinda basically the same button

orchid mural
#

except the one has a bigger range, and the other you get the 10% stam.

mighty valley
#

if you play colossus, you're both a cool iconoclast, and roar is preferred

strong whale
#

what do you play if i may ask?

mellow quartz
#

if you are asking just play mountain thane

#

also you will get a lot more info just reading the wowhead guide

daring grove
#

Who else is playing colossus here? I've been enjoying the heck out of colossus, but 585 in heroics isn't exactly punishing its weaknesses just yet.

ivory snow
#

Hey guys are there any buttons I should just flat out not have on my bar? Im trying to set this warrior up while i level so things are easy to reach and I want to avoid building muscle memeory on something useless lol

teal finch
#

I love colossus for world quests personally. I feel like thane is better for dungeons but I gotta sometimes play colossus for the big smashes.

ivory snow
#

ok

mighty valley
#

hamstring is pretty niche

simple drum
#

Thane vastly superior to play

teal finch
ivory snow
#

Without devastate is there anything i can spam or should I just throw shield slam on my 1 key and call it a day? lol

mighty valley
#

if you're managing rage well, you should be able to fill all GCDs with shield slam, thunderclap, or revenge

warm plinth
#

Unless you're overpressing Ignore Pain, you shouldn't really have empty space to need a spam button

ivory snow
#

This si coming from someone who hasnt played warrior since legion so bear with these stupid questions lol

mighty valley
#

it's all good! obv this is all stuff that's in the guides but sometimes it's easier to learn by asking

ivory snow
#

Im not to the point where reading the guides in comprehendable yet

mighty valley
#

yeah i feel you

ivory snow
#

i dont know what any of the buttons do so being told to use them is...not productive haha

mighty valley
#

yeah makes sense

#

the basics are

#

spending rage is very good for a bunch of reasons - therefore generating rage is very good

#

so other than longer offensive cooldowns, shield slam is top priority (generates the most rage. also just does good damage)

#

then thunderclap and revenge are behind it in priority since they can both reset shield slam

#

everything else is an offensive cooldown, a defensive cooldown, or a utility button

#

oh, and maintain the shield block cooldown as much as possible

#

that should be higher up lol

ivory snow
#

Alright. Im setting up bars at the moment too so its just a little much for me. im getting there though

proud dock
#

anyone have mining nodes "phase out" once u get close to them and then show back up once u fly away a bit?

lusty grotto
#

yes

#

its happened since expansions ago

#

its phasing related

proud dock
#

rip

lusty grotto
#

just ignore those nodes

#

there are way to get them, but you have to stand in a very correct spot, and sometimes theres just no correct spot at all

proud dock
#

gotcha thanks

lusty grotto
#

also nodes that are in "zone lines" suffer from this a lot

#

its been a problem since pretty much forever in the game

mighty valley
#

it's a blizzard employee who's watching you play and having a laugh at your expense

#

flipping the mining node switch to off right when you get there

lusty grotto
#

they are pretty useful to honeypot the shit out of botters and warpers

#

so its likely they are there intentionally

strong whale
#

question, should I have whirlwind on my hotbar? Or thats not needed for prot

lusty grotto
#

you should not

#

it was talked about a few lines ago

strong whale
#

oh shit my fault b didnt see that, thanks

gritty latch
#

hi i am the type of player in keys who does not really care about the group. I just go in and do some casual overgeared keys. Is warrior the best? I can just be the tankiest tank out there and chill.

lusty grotto
#

such a silly bait

gritty latch
lusty grotto
#

dn

gritty latch
lusty grotto
#

yes

mighty valley
#

if you do casual overgeared keys you can play anything

#

you do have to press a lot of buttons on this one though

lusty grotto
#

i highly recommend prot paladin

#

you will no doubt be the tankiest tank out there and chill... or whatever

#

youre welcome

mighty valley
#

hey babe wanna come over and be the tankiest tank out there and chill

zenith vigil
#

blood dk very easy

lusty grotto
#

guaranteed to work, Harrow

zenith vigil
gritty latch
#

so warrior is the tankiest tank our there

zenith vigil
#

who said that

gritty latch
#

dorki

lusty grotto
#

nah its prot pally

ivory snow
#

I wanna be the tankiest spankiest

zenith vigil
ivory snow
#

btw, making decent progress over here :)

#

What button do you guys put your charge/intercept on?

lusty grotto
#

g

zenith vigil
#

f

mighty valley
#

w

zenith vigil
#

l

lusty grotto
#

my gap closers are always G

#

even in ffxiv

#

and on any class really in WoW

ivory snow
#

Mine were always on F & shift F but I had charge on e since i only ever did levelling on the warrior

lusty grotto
#

F is my shield block and any other Active Mit

#

so iron fur, sotr, fel spikes, etc

ivory snow
#

like I play mage/lock/hpriest...so all 3 of those have diff interrupts

lusty grotto
#

all of those are C for me

ivory snow
#

have have counterspell on my mouse button, lock interrupt requires pet i never use but its on g

mighty valley
#

c is for counterspell

gritty latch
#

my interrupt is at left shift + p

ivory snow
#

P?!

gritty latch
#

so that when i press it i never miss

#

but obv i never press it

ivory snow
#

This dudes got costco hot dogs for fingers jesus christ

lusty grotto
#

hes a bad troll just ignore him

ivory snow
#

Gotcha

#

Anyways

gritty latch
#

I don't like prot pala. Too much utility that i never use in keys

ivory snow
#

I didnt like prot pala bc it felt like I was standing there doing nothing 99% of the time

#

was super hard to die though

green monolith
#

does anyone have a good violent outburst WA or something to track that?

soft tusk
#

umm.. WTF

lusty grotto
#

whats the problem

soft tusk
#

looks good!

lusty grotto
#

ok

soft tusk
#

❤️

pallid quiver
#

fairly low uptime, and the channel hurts it a lot

#

Since you can't block/etc during

soft tusk
#

pre-pot lol

lusty grotto
#

wdym

#

i suppose you can in dungeons

#

but that wont work on raids lol

#

not that theres any right now

worthy gyro
#

hi, quick question: did they take deep wounds away from heroic throw?

lusty grotto
#

anyway thats just warbound, so i usally just dump it in the warbank for alts

#

yes

worthy gyro
#

lame.

#

ty

gritty latch
#

how can prot warr be punishing for beginners?

near briar
#

is this spec any good in pvp

violet ginkgo
#

but maybe someone can explain better

lusty grotto
#

not ip uptime

#

also dont feed the troll

ivory snow
#

Is there a way to combine shield charge and charge into one macro?

pallid quiver
ivory snow
#

idk how youd even do that

pallid quiver
#

And it's harder to recover from mistakes due to not having a death strike button

ivory snow
#

yeah makes sense

#

sorry

austere oar
#

why would you do that is a more suited question

lusty grotto
#

its possible to do but highly not recommended

pallid quiver
#

Yeah, due to them being used in different cases, the only way to have them on the same button would be automating gameplay, so

#

Well, at least in a reasonable format

ivory snow
#

Listen ok, im new here and absolutely not someone who could answer that question more than 30 seconds ago

#

so im sorry for being dumb

#

lo

lusty grotto
#

no need to apologize

#

we can tell youre new

ivory snow
#

Ye

#

Ive had some help but setting up bars is proving to be far more confusing than i wanted it to be

lusty grotto
#

0 shame in it, ask away

ivory snow
#

not having all my buttons since im levelling an old toon is rough, and so is not knowing how often ill need buttons/if i should put them on easily reachable keybinds

lusty grotto
#

let me know if you need help with acronyms

#

but

#

SS, TC, SB, IP, Revenge, Execute, Charge should be in easy to reach places, spammable keys if needed be (this does not mean you will spam them)

#

Wall and Pummel as well

lean panther
#

U can try hekili

lusty grotto
#

Demo, Avatar, Spear/Troar, Stormbolt, Shockwave, Fear, Shield Charge, Challenging Shout should be in accessible places but not necesarily spammable ones (think Shift modifiers)

#

hes not asking about rotations

ivory snow
lusty grotto
#

hekili shouldnt be recommended here

#

its fine for dps

#

not good for tanks

#

Intervene, Hamstring, Last Stand, Leap should be in a lower prio bind (think CTRL or ALT modifiers)

ivory snow
#

Ok

lusty grotto
#

your prio is

ivory snow
#

sorry working on it atm while also reading

lusty grotto
#

SS > TC > Rev/Exe

#

so think about how often you will be pressing those

ivory snow
#

how often is taunt used in regular play?

lusty grotto
#

your SB uptime needs to be high as humanly possible, as close to 100% as you can

#

your IP will be used regularly to burn rage

#

i forgot about taunt

#

its used occassionally

#

but not a whole lot

ivory snow
#

trying to figure out where to put HT, Taunt, and DS

lusty grotto
#

HT as in?

ivory snow
#

throw

lusty grotto
#

im assuming DS is demo

#

just say demo

ivory snow
#

oh ok

lusty grotto
#

heroic throw is used occasionally as well so it can be added to those

ivory snow
#

yes, I planned to put the demo on a reachable bind, then have shift mod be the regular taunt

lusty grotto
#

im just going by how repeatedly we use things

ivory snow
#

right right

lusty grotto
#

keep in mind a lot of this is solved by you playing

#

and moving stuff around

#

as you see fit

#

since binds are extremely personal

ivory snow
#

Yeah of course, I have an issue with this part being the hangup for me all the time

#

playing all 3 mage specs, all lock specs, and then hpriest...im just super anal about certain placements xD

lusty grotto
#

start with the basic prio

#

and then see what you need and when after you master it

ivory snow
#

Ok. Ill just mess around with it a few days and level this toon

#

we'll see how it goes

#

thansk for your help, i hae your comments in a notepad

#

:)

lusty grotto
#

no problem at all, thats what this disc is for

jagged gust
#

Whats your hero spec Rolie?

lusty grotto
#

im thinking hes not 70+ yet

#

kinda seems like hes just starting out

#

or if old toon then probably 30s

jagged gust
#

Oh word, I always forget about that crowd

lusty grotto
#

but of course i could be wrong

#

im just going with what hes said so far

jagged gust
#

Was just asking because of the rotation, but yeah if they're not coming in to play it doesn't matter

ivory snow
#

Yeah not yet, just looking for basics to build some type of baseline for what spells i need to use often

#

54 atm, just started an old foprgotten toon

#

The blackrock bulwark always has me come back to attempt warrior :P

rigid hull
#

How do i manage rage as colossus xd

#

if im spamming revenge

#

i dont have rage for ingore pain

#

and im not clapping either to generate

lusty grotto
#

well i feel like you answered yourself

#

dont spam revenge

rigid hull
#

damn so

#

theres a rotation

#

not rotation

#

rage management i guess

#

mountain thane is like zug zug

lusty grotto
#

yes

rigid hull
#

press spells

lusty grotto
#

theres rage management, yes

main current
#

iis there any list of best items to get/farm before season starts?

rigid hull
#

do i just make the bis crafting belt? xd @lusty grotto

#

ilvl addiction....

lusty grotto
#

no

#

there is no bis right now

#

so you didnt just make it

rigid hull
#

any crafting advice

#

i havee xtra gold

lusty grotto
#

sure the crafting advice is pinned

rigid hull
#

okay

#

this?xd

#

i mean sparkless crafts

lusty grotto
#

whatever you need

#

if you wanna burn gold

rigid hull
#

some elbmishment would be fun

ivory snow
#

so i tanked a dungeon....lots of binds moved immediately lol

lusty grotto
#

you cant get an embelishment without a spark

#

so...

rigid hull
#

i see

main current
#

is it worth enchanting gear before the season?

lusty grotto
#

if the enchant is cheap as fuck, sure

jagged pier
#

with cheap ones if u want

main current
#

cool ty

ivory snow
#

\

stuck basin
lusty grotto
#

you can

#

youre right

#

but what would be the point

stuck basin
#

its not a good gold investment is another statement as its not possible - wouldnt recommend as well 🙂

lusty grotto
#

yeah i stand corrected

strong forum
#

Me no embellish

#

Me wait

lusty grotto
#

watchu pushin bud

long phoenix
#

Anybody else getting a weird fps stutter whenever they press thunder blast?

lusty grotto
#

youre the third person that has mentioned that

#

but a lot of us have no issue

long phoenix
#

damn guess imma go mess with some setting near the training dummies

#

thanks for letting me know i'm not the only one though

strong forum
#

Can't say I've noticed that

pallid quiver
#

The only stutter I feel is my brain kicking into overdrive every time I heard the thunder blast audio

#

feels real good

woeful trellis
lusty grotto
#

almost positive its addon/wa related

#

yeah ive noticed it

#

but i thought it was kind of a bug or something allowing you to just not instantly go down

glad panther
#

I have never been more hyped to play prot warr honestly, this little thunder addition is marvelous, i really like how I have a TON of frontloaded damage when pulling, so good

glad panther
#

feels exactly like that 😄

woeful trellis
#

Yeah 🤣🙌

glad panther
#

always really liked prot over any other tanks, but this gave me the edge i really missed about it

brittle fulcrum
#

is there a haste % we are shooting for?

lusty grotto
#

not at the moment

brittle fulcrum
#

kk, is prot sim up to date for damage?

lusty grotto
#

it should

#

but its up to Nome, so hopefully he can confirm

brittle fulcrum
#

thanks!

strong forum
#

Ya everything should be just fine

#

Aoe isn't turbo optimised but simming aoe is kind of a sham anyway

autumn pawn
floral trail
#

Is it true that spell block only works if shield block is up?

jagged pier
#

well no and yes

woeful trellis
jagged pier
#

like blocking it just is a random chance if u dont have SB up

#

so its -30% chance to block with no SB

violet ginkgo
#

but like always we should have SB almost up all the time right?

jagged pier
#

should, yes

#

does that always happen with most ppl most of the time, no

rigid hull
#

alright so

#

when is tclap ebtter for overall farming 💀

#

how many targets beats shield slam

#

for overall

violet ginkgo
#

define "farming"

rigid hull
#

i mean

#

more overall damaGE

jagged pier
#

it doesnt beat TC because it gives more rage so its more CDR on avatar

#

if u mean in terms of outburst

#

+2 taargets with TB probably around 5 without

#

as we lost tier set

strong forum
#

For TB it's 3

#

As seismic sets in

#

And ignores armor

#

For outburst it's 2,for natty TB it's 3

rigid hull
#

sheeesh

#

what about normal thunder clap?

#

like 8 targets?

strong forum
#

Nah should also be around 4

rigid hull
#

wtf

strong forum
#

As TC hits for alot with thane

jagged pier
#

i ment around 5 with nothing just TC forgot we now have to talk about TC in 4 seperate ways

strong forum
#

Its 8 for colossus

#

But 4 for thane

rigid hull
#

but like what about rage genration

#

it gives less rage

#

less avatar

#

less outburst

#

do i still do it

strong forum
#

Depends a bit on situation

#

Let's assume you have 4 targets and both tc and SS are ready

#

No other cds up, no avatar up

#

Then SS would be better

#

If you have avatar up, TC would be better

If you have burst of power procs, you send SS

#

Because you wanna use your burst of power procs to get TB procs

#

And generally SS

#

Because SS procs TB

runic plinth
#

New to prot tanking, is it worth using the crests to craft a shield or would it be more beneficial to use crafts to fill in gaps with gear. holding onto spark till season starts

strong forum
#

But also only if it's manual avatar

#

If you get the 4sec proc from avatar, that one doesn't buff TC or TB because UF isn't active

strong forum
#

As its your most important defensive slot

#

But there's nothing to gain by crafting right this second

#

Because a) prices are still high

#

b) no content that needs it

runic plinth
#

fair, just was wondering if it was worth crafting gear atm as got a BS with mats so the cost isnt high, would the 590 with r2 embellishments be worth it or better off just waiting till s1 starts to worry about crafts

strong forum
#

I'd wait until mythic week with spark crafts tbh lad

#

Cuz there's atleast 2 more tuning waves coming

runic plinth
#

thought so, cheers bruh appreciate it

strong forum
#

Of classes and probably also embellishs

#

Chances are tho that you'll just be using crit or vers embellish

#

Aka dusk/dawn

bronze pasture
#

I asked different AI's which WoW tank spec is the MANLIEST, and they all put prot warr at #1

strong forum
#

Or Ascension + nerub

strong forum
bronze pasture
#

😄

teal laurel
#

I haven't played a tank in like 5 years and I really don't remember warrior APM feeling like I'm playing SC in Korea

jagged pier
#

been high for a very long time

strong forum
#

Been like that since atleast legion

#

Probably longer

teal laurel
#

I'm basically just mashing SSlam/TClap like a cocaine addict playing whack a mole and praying my 3 brain cells can learn to weave in more stuff over time lol

strong forum
#

^^

teal laurel
#

On that note. I imagine just doing that, and - assuming I hold aggro. I'm doing what, 75% of my job?

#

I'm a bit ignorant to what's expected out of tanks these days

strong forum
#

Holding aggro and not dying is 90% of your job

#

Or rather, not being a liability to your healer*

#

But since they made tanking easier and easier

#

That job is gets fulfilled without a lot of effort

teal laurel
#

lol fair. I find that It would be easier in harder-than-heroic because nobody gives me even 1/100th of a second to los pull or park pulled mobs before they pop every cooldown they've ever seen in their lives and play stepmania with their DPS rotation

strong forum
#

So beyond that dealing dmg is optimisation you can do, whilst also using your CC/Utility and defensives properly

#

And that part by far the most fail at

bronze pasture
#

a bit of a niche question but.. does anyone know which would be the LIGHTEST (CPU) nameplate addon that clearly shows loss of aggro? from my testing Plater is too heavy ;/

strong forum
#

Plater is too heavy?

bronze pasture
#

yeah uses a lot of CPU

teal laurel
#

I couldn't live without plater

bronze pasture
#

tanks performance

strong forum
#

So without plater you don't have performance issues?

bronze pasture
#

yep

strong forum
#

Try threatplates or tidyplates

bronze pasture
#

frankly I think theyre all hogs 😛 i'm so disappointed that default blizz nameplates dont change colors like that

strong forum
#

For me it was just my CPU was shit, didn't matter if I had any addons on or none

teal laurel
#

And the chirp chirp noise weakaura I have for when shield drops because I'm a 30 IQ warrior

strong forum
#

Fps wouldn't change

#

So I upgraded to 7800x3d and now I live in happy fps land

bronze pasture
#

yeah I've got 7900X but I'm kind of a weirdo when it comes to performance I want ultrasmoothness always -,-

#

play with min settings :p

strong forum
#

Then...

#

It's your settings that suck

#

Unless you mean to keep 144+ at all times without a single drop below

#

Cuz then you'll never find solace

teal laurel
#

Legit how do people play without plater. The @mouseover perks you get for pummel/hammer is beyond gamechanging

bronze pasture
#

yeah I want 130+ always

strong forum
#

Yeah good luck

#

You ain't getting that out of wow and good addons

bronze pasture
teal laurel
#

The thing I had to get used to for real though is ElvUI

#

It's one of those things that you hate until you love it

strong forum
#

It's either 90-120 fps with a good UI

#

Or 140+ with default UI

bronze pasture
#

pretty much yeah

strong forum
#

That's just how it be

#

There's people out there playing with sub 30 fps in big pulls

#

So you wanting 130+

#

Is a bit uuuuhh high brow

teal laurel
#

Stop frame animation pulls are where it's at

bronze pasture
strong forum
#

Some people raided with sub 10 fps on pull in mythic raid

#

🙂

strong forum
#

Cuz even your 7900x will be pushed below 60

#

When you got 20 people during Lust pressing loads of buttons vs fyrakk or tindral with slot or particle fidelity n shit going on

#

Lowest fps I got to on raszageth on pull was 35 with 7800x3d and turbo optimised UI

#

That being said

#

Hol on I'll find the link for yo

bronze pasture
#

raids run ok for me, I have min settings and default UI and bigwigs which is faster than DBM so I usualyl have over 100 fps on raids

strong forum
#

If you want good UI stuff, xeph is your boy

bronze pasture
#

and I use my own WAs that are super efficient and minimalistic 😛

strong forum
#

Professional programmer that makes the best wow stuff

bronze pasture
#

aha nice

#

over 50% faster 😛 I love it when people realize the importance of performance 🙂

strong forum
#

He's the guy

#

He is him

#

Rewrote some of my custom code weakauras to essentially consume 0 resources

#

From being resource hogs

teal laurel
#

After learning prot warrior to some extent I feel like if I played my alt for any reasonable amount of time I'd get a brain virus and lose my muscle memory entirely for warrior lol

strong forum
#

Nah

#

Muscle memory doesn't disappear

#

I picked up a character that I didn't play in 6 years

#

And my fingers remembered where buttons used to be

teal laurel
#

I guess if you have a similar keybind methodology it helps

strong forum
#

My brain didn't but my fingers did

#

Or maybe I'm just built diffy, could also be

steel mist
#

All i know is that I hit stuff and lightning comes out of my warriors butt crack into enemies

#

like a little energizer bunny

teal laurel
#

I feel ike I'm missing something when people are around rocking max professions already. Is it just a function of dumping gold on the AH for ore/etc? lol

strong forum
#

Cux the TC/TB animation is them slamming their ass on the floor

strong forum
teal laurel
#

I meant... how.. lol. Are they jsut dumping money on mats and crafting to power level then hoping they make a profit when they monopolize?

strong forum
#

There's no hoping, it's all strategy

#

They know all the sources how to get the professions puntos

#

And then yeah, gotta spend Gold to make Gold

#

Just like IRL

bronze pasture
strong forum
#

Some people in my guild are down 200k-1.2mil gold so far

#

But it'll all be made back

bronze pasture
#

the last 30 points are expensive

strong forum
#

I myself am down 200k just to have my own gear crafted

#

Cuz I didn't wait for prices to die down

bronze pasture
#

did they make it back by charging people for crafting or just by making a ton of gear and putting it on AH?

strong forum
#

So far it's mostly only guild internally I think

#

Besides the odd public order for quests and so on

#

Will make most of the gold back by boosting anyway

bronze pasture
#

i wouldnt be able to do rank 5 spark items

#

or even rank 4

ebon geyser
#

if i do a raid on my druid for a piece of tier can the look get saved?

strong forum
#

For other druids, yes

ebon geyser
#

no for plate

strong forum
#

Que

#

You mean old raid?

ebon geyser
#

yes

strong forum
#

Any item you loot will be saved for tmog

#

Now

ebon geyser
#

i got a chest but it didnt save

teal laurel
#

What would you guys say is a respectable/obtainable ilvl for when s1 launches? 571-ish?

strong forum
#

Cuz it's warrior only tierset or smth

ebon geyser
#

the warrior chest didnt get saved

strong forum
#

Those I don't think Transfer yet

#

yet

#

I think in a future patch they wanted to include that

strong forum
#

570 should be plenty

#

I myself am 583 cuz a few 590 pieces and you can upgrade gear to 580 with just valor stones

teal laurel
#

I guess the bigger challenge is finding people to mythic with because when I tried mythics before pugs made me wanna cry

jagged pier
#

585 baby wicked

strong forum
#

As with all things wow

ebon geyser
strong forum
#

The biggest challenge is the people

#

Not the content

teal laurel
#

Is there a communally accepted go-to for guild adverts/lfg?

#

or do peeps just yolo forums/reddit/etc

jagged pier
#

if u are looking for a guild

#

put yourself up on raiderio

#

and look for guild through raiderio or wowprogress yourself

#

same with m+ teams

teal laurel
#

Raiderio, got it. That's kinda what I was curious about. 5 year hiatus everything feels arcane

barren snow
#

My guild is going to (try to) do SR for this raid, is there any item from the raid on the BiS list I should prioritize?

jagged pier
#

soft reserve

barren snow
#

I know..

jagged pier
#

shield tho

#

well u want that from mythic

#

over anything else

#

and u sharing trinkets with dps so they gunna be hot mess to contend too

#

so tier maybe from normal and hc

barren snow
#

Yeah I'm having a hard time seeing the need to SR for normal and HC..

pine storm
#

Wtf would SR even mean, either something is reserved or not. If it's not, but based on some weird induvidually made lists, it's just a wishlist prio system or something? 👀

jagged pier
lucid nimbus
pine storm
# jagged pier

I know, hence why i used the word "reserve".
It was more of a question of definition, because "soft reserve" doesn't make sense.
"Hey, i soft reserved a table at your favorit resturant tonight. We might have a table, or we might not. Depends how many other people put themselves on the list"
Just first come first serve or a coun toss with an extra step? 😄

jagged pier
#

its from classic wow

#

for pugging

#

it basically means only ppl that reserve it can role for it

solar charm
#

You people have Ignore Pain macroed into Shildbash or use it on its own?

lapis burrow
#

Use it on its own

glad panther
#

is there a working WA for Outburst tracking?

hoary pivot
#

any recommendations for prot warrior streamers to look at some m+ gameplay? and sorry if i have missed a sticky witht hat, didnt find one

strong forum
#

Mekes streams pwar gameplay on NA

#

He pops up at the top of the member list when he's streaming ->

#

Otherwise I also stream anytime I play wow on EU times

tender cove
strong forum
#

Check your addons weakauras, delete all the useless shit

tender cove
#

I have 3 weak auras, yours, dungeon and smt else.

strong forum
#

Whenever you open WA for the first time after logging in, what the number of weakauras it's loading

#

At the top

#

Otherwise, any addons?

#

Cuz I have 0 issues

tender cove
strong forum
#

Check graphic settings advanced, disable triple buffering, v-sync

#

For spell visibility select essential

tender cove
#

ok cool, thank. Had all those on or at everything

#

wth. Went from averaging at 99 fps to 155 😮

#

Over 50% improvement, thats crazy!
Thanks alot!

solar charm
#

save some Energy/hardware, cap at 60 fps 😄

strong forum
#

60 is no bueno

#

144 is bueno

solar charm
#

not heating the room because of wow is bueno for my old non-eagle eyes 🙂

jagged pier
#

running pc is cheaper than that and heat bill

raven jewel
#

I've been spending a lot of time on my prot warrior getting it levelled up, and it's honestly wild how much more durable it is than my prot paladin. It actually feels like a tank. I can basically aggro and drag entire rooms of mobs between boss fights in a dungeon, can't do that on my paladin

teal laurel
#

It's crazy how I had tank anxiety from heroics but it's borderline not even harder than normals lol

tribal wharf
#

name a more iconic duo, addon that doesnt update and then "ui is broken" msg every day

#

game of do i wait for it to get update, or uninstall addon

shrewd kelp
#

Few days back, I decided to give Prot warr and tanking try because of "need for tanks", and IAM totally in love with it :-)) probably not gonna turn back to main fury for some time 🙂

tribal wharf
#

block and critical block are oppressively defensive vs melee

#

its l ovely

coral agate
raven jewel
#

Actually having fun

shrewd kelp
fluid widget
upper spoke
#

will tomorrow's patch bring new content? i know mythic dungeons and raids will open the following week

teal laurel
#

What kind of cocaine fueled WoW bender would have one needing new content tomorrow 😂

tribal wharf
#

one fueled by boredom and nothing better to do

teal laurel
#

Make 10 more alts obviously

austere oar
#

Also able to finally finish the sojourner of hallowfall achiev

teal laurel
#

I thought that one quest for that was weekly gated

austere oar
#

There are 2 weekly ones

#

We could do the first one this week

tribal wharf
#

584's with terts what im farmin for, might do 2hs today

#

thats the pinnacle of insanity tho, 865 per 2h max

fossil moat
#

Hey guys , bis race for +++Mkeys push for warrior ?

jagged pier
#

which ever u like looking at the most

teal laurel
#

I don't think it's ever mattered, maybe an argument for dwarf because bleeds suck

obtuse scaffold
#

True! I just love them aesthetically lol

teal laurel
#

I legit might race swap to dwarf, I always pick dwarf. The one time I don't I'm worgen for warrior

#

immediately wish I picked dwarf

tribal wharf
#

some weak aura problem

#

so, it will never get fixed without outright removal lol

#

this is how you get trapped in the valor mines

coral agate
austere oar
#

I don't think you finished the sojourner of hallowfall achievement

coral agate
jagged pier
#

finsihed it days ago

tropic tangle
tribal wharf
#

if i ever get a haste cloak i will quit

#

or finish trinket collection

austere oar
#

It's gated behind 2 weekly resets and the 2nd one is coming tomorrow

wispy fulcrum
# jagged pier finsihed it days ago

this was weird for me too. I got the sojourner of hallowfall at 30th but got the loremaster of khaz algar wich requires sojourner of hallowfall at 23

warm plinth
#

Good morninggggg

jagged pier
tribal wharf
#

well............. i know for fact you cant get it through normal "just go questing bro" means in only pve

versed hedge
#

did they remove the lore hunter achievement? I swear i saw some videos around that achievement

tribal wharf
#

theres clearly more to it than that

#

but i cant be arsed to give enough of a fuck to figure it out and will let it come with the reset, grab it then lol

#

no reason for me to try hard loremaster

#

we also have another main chapter to go through i assume tomorrow, if say u wanna unlock nu-dwarf

austere oar
versed hedge
#

ty

keen leaf
strong forum
#

perfect stat spread acquired unbuffed

keen leaf
#

this mf hates vers so much he removed it

strong forum
#

not my fault crit/haste still keeps simming better

#

see thats crit/vers helmet

#

dps loss

sudden fractal
#

Only thing was waiting 24 hours during the striking steel quest

lone sable
#

Hey Friends. I am new here, and kinda new to warrior and also kinda new to retail. Do yall have any guides or anything you follow in terms of gearing up at this point? Things I found online seemed to be planned for later in the game

hoary pivot
#

@strong forum do you exclusively play colossus / roar right now? or are there / will there be thane / spear streams?

strong forum
#

i swap willy nilly

hoary pivot
#

i see

#

must have been unlucky with my picks of recent streams then

strong forum
#

ya

hoary pivot
#

i also noticed that you press revenge while shield slam is off CD a lot more than i would have expected reading the guide in that one vid - is that because survivability is just not really an issue in HCs and DPS numbers are just more fun?

strong forum
#

the pulls are very large

#

also to apply deep wounds

#

also for colossus, revenge is by far your biggest dmg button on 3+ targets

#

i should include that line

hoary pivot
#

the rotation section in the guide says "Sequence", but I guess it is really a priority list right? that one mentions revenge really low in the list, even to apply the debuff

strong forum
#

like this is your overall breakdown

hoary pivot
#

following that, i am trying to get used to dumping mostly into IP as long as my next GCD will be SS or TB/TC again

#

is that correct?

strong forum
#

ya as thane defo

#

since only SS can proc TB

#

revenge cannot

#

as colossus you turbo spam revenge however

#

which is explained further down in detail

hoary pivot
#

so CDs > SS > TB > revenge for GCD usage basically

strong forum
hoary pivot
#

as thane

strong forum
#

ya

#

the sequence table is just a quick cheatg sheet type deal

hoary pivot
#

but it is a priority, not a sequence right?

strong forum
#

ya

hoary pivot
#

the lower one, not the opener i mean

strong forum
#

ill rename that

hoary pivot
#

and it is fine that that will often lead to deep wounds not beeing up for quite some time when bouncing between TB/TC and SS?

coral rover
#

I am reading some guides online for Prot,

are you ever supposed to even use rend? (why isn't it mentioned anywhere?) same for execute, is it ever better to use execute over revenge?

lusty grotto
lusty grotto
#

and execute over revenge depends on your hero talents

strong forum
#

usually it already gets applied when gathering packs

#

as you dont have TC every single time or have enough move speed to be out of revenge range

daring grove
lusty grotto
#

needs to be talented, doesnt need to be used as said above

#

you can read the thunderclap tooltip for more info

coral rover
#

so the rotation is basically keep shield block up, slam, thunder clap, don't overcap on rage with ignore pain and revenge

#

kinda boring tbh

daring grove
daring grove
coral rover
#

ye ye

lusty grotto
#

it does sound boring when put like that but with a high APM requirement it certainly isnt

white mauve
#

plus those 1m+ shield slams are mega satisfying with the noise

#

THUNK

fluid widget
#

stupid question, why is crit so good? i feel like im missing something

lusty grotto
#

parry and damage

fluid widget
#

ah parry def was missing something. ok that make so much more sense now

white mauve
#

Any rotation is boring in isolation, enjoy the character you play and it becomes less of a chore.

lusty grotto
#

indeed

fluid widget
#

can see how it can contribute more offensively/defensively than mastery/vers

lusty grotto
#

slightly more

#

no stat is banned

#

especially while gearing

proud dock
#

in trash pulls/aoe, thunder clap is posed to be highest dmg done, right?

strong forum
#

generally yes as thane

proud dock
#

tyty

strong forum
#

but thunderblast

#

not thunderclap

#

TC should be considerably lower

#

this is my dmg breakdown from a beta key

#

notably before the dmg buffs*

proud dock
#

ok i tihnk i saw thunderblast have to check again

lone sable
# strong forum

I seem to remember your guide does not spec into thunderous Roar now?

strong forum
#

for thane, correct

#

this was merely a test with roar

#

and as you can see, roar barely does respectable dmg

lone sable
#

Yeah 👍

strong forum
#

spear does the same if not more dmg

#

BUT also grants the 25% crit dmg

#

*for thane

proud dock
#

also if a drop a spear, do mobs that were not initally in it also get dmg'd or does it only dmg mobs that were in the inital area?

lone sable
#

AND it has the really satisfying pull back

strong forum
#

only the initial

proud dock
#

F

strong forum
#

its not like vortex

#

where mobs can be affected after the fact

#

so dont send spear lightly

charred ivy
#

Rly 😮 I always just assumed if in the spear they get DMG xD

balmy narwhal
#

is there a passive ability that grants 4-5 seconds of avatar randomly? my WA shows avatar aura being active when I am in combat

lusty grotto
#

yes

#

MT has one

strong forum
balmy narwhal
#

ooh

#

thank you

strong forum
#

that avatar however does not proc another Thunderblast or reset the cooldown of Thunderclap

#

or applies the cooldown reduction of Unstoppable force to thunderclap

#

its just the 20% dmg boost, nothing else

ivory snow
#

Im gonna get better at warrior and nimchip is gonna be so proud

keen leaf
#

Nome, out of curiosity what rings do you have, I found a crit/haste one in dawn, trying to decide what to farm for my 2nd

lusty grotto
#

he has crafted

#

darkflame ring is your other pick if youre not crafting

keen leaf
#

thats smart, im dumb, I can craft 590 without sparks huh

lusty grotto
#

correct

keen leaf
#

thanks

#

you wanna know how dumb i am, im a JC, I can literally make the ring myself

smoky pollen
#

Anyone know what the % damage loss between using thunderous roar over spear is offhand?
I really hate spear.

keen leaf
#

its the same as roar if u just use an @player macro

#

just saying

zealous goblet
#

i have no plans on changing or anything, just curious, how close is colossus to performing as well as mountain thane?

smoky pollen
#

I’ll be swapping to Colossus for reclear I believe

smoky pollen
strong forum
#

nah you no longer have to stand in it

keen leaf
#

no, its the initial hit that matters

strong forum
#

but you gotta hit all the mobs with the initial hit

keen leaf
#

so group them up then slam it

strong forum
#

otherwise no damage or buff for those mobs

smoky pollen
#

Oh then I’m fine with it

#

I thought I still had to stand it

#

Mb, reading the ability explains the ability ig

zealous goblet
lusty grotto
#

farm after prog

zealous goblet
#

oh ok

lusty grotto
#

sometimes i wonder Scatter

smoky pollen
lusty grotto
#

what rock youve been living under, cause im sure classic andies also use "reclear"

zealous goblet
#

nah we say "prog" and "on farm"

#

or atleast the guilds i've been in

lusty grotto
#

🤷

zealous goblet
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

#

i'm expanding my knowledge every day

#

my brain gets more wrinkles and crinkles

#

like old man nutsack

lusty grotto
#

i feel offended cause im most def older than you

#

how dare you 😭

zealous goblet
#

it's ok i'll join you soon

#

oh also, another question outta curiosity, the talent to make thunderstrikes happen 30% more often, is that a +30% chance overall or x1.3 to whatever the base chance is

keen leaf
#

is there any reason not to use the cursed enchants

zealous goblet
#

nvm found an answer

mighty valley
#

i somehow had the impression that colossus had the advantage in large pull aoe

strong forum
#

it does offensively

#

IF you can turbo spam revenge without dying

hardy snow
#

And you can do that on hc eaaily

mighty valley
#

ah cool, this issa bosak guy just spreading misinformation on the internet

smoky pollen
#

Fax

mighty valley
#

I can’t stay mad at a hank hill avi though

smoky pollen
#

It is worth noting I also expressed I’m bad at the game so if you take my advice I can’t be held liable

mighty valley
#

i will note it

lusty grotto
#

oh him

smoky pollen
finite wharf
#

anybody have prot sims I can compare with?

strong forum
#

whatre you looking for

soft tusk
#

which warrior specc carries 2 hander?

strong forum
#

any but prot

lusty grotto
#

all but prot

finite wharf
keen leaf
#

my DK and war are both 585, my DK does a little more damage, but its close enough for margin of error if that helps

lusty grotto
#

strange considering both of those should be doing more damage

warm bloom
#

has anyone gotten the rookery shield to drop

#

i've been spamming it for two days and haven't seen it once

strong forum
#

so far ive only ever seen 1 shield frop from dungeons

jagged pier
#

ye

strong forum
#

and it was a leveling dungeon

#

not a heroic

jagged pier
#

crit haste shield i got

warm bloom
#

this is isn't normal is it

jagged pier
#

its fine its 50/50

strong forum
jagged pier
#

u get it or u dont

mighty valley
#

run the math on your odds of getting a specific item and it won’t feel that weird that you haven’t seen it

strong forum
#

i got it to drop as enha in resto lootspec

#

but didnt get a single shield drop on my warrior

#

rng do be RNG'ing

strong forum
#

well not way

#

but they should sim higher

keen leaf
#

Blood plague go BRRRR

soft tusk
#

Anyone here know anyone with the Azj-Kahet 2H Weapon that they upgraded to 606?

strong forum
#

no, that would be pretty fucking stupid to do

pallid quiver
#

my war would 100% sim higher than my DK.

my dk might still be level 70

lusty grotto
#

why would they do that

#

especially the azj-kahet one

jagged pier
#

i dont know why u would ask that in the prot channel @soft tusk probably better to go ask arms or fury

lusty grotto
#

when rookery 2h exists

misty shuttle
#

Are you guys upgrading the heroic gear

zenith vigil
#

why bother

#

m0 replace it

lusty grotto
#

you can upgrade just so you dont cap flightstones

#

up to 4/8 adventurer

#

other than that

mellow quartz
#

You can also just upgrade it to 8/8, you can’t use the crests for anything else anyway

lusty grotto
#

no reason to

#

you can just craft with the crests

#

and its just 30 per

mellow quartz
#

No clue how hard lvl 8 delves are 🤷‍♂️

mellow quartz
lusty grotto
#

i dont

#

i have crafters

#

but if anyone doesn't then sure

lone sable
#

Regarding shields… i have also been unlucky in terms of drops. Is it worth getting the crafted one, as someone who’s fairly broke? And what would that cost, ish?

jagged pier
#

U can craft a 590 one

lone sable
#

Yes i know

jagged pier
#

But cost is gunna depend on server

#

I mean just complain to crafters like i do and get 50% off

lone sable
#

^^

mellow quartz
#

Another 8 days of playing games other than wow most of the time. What a great way to launch an expansion.

lusty grotto
#

i like it

tulip warren
#

i like it too

soft tusk
#

This si how it should be

lusty grotto
#

stress free, chill, no rush alt leveling and gearing

#

and preparing for raid pushes

#

im with Max in that heroic week should be every season

#

at the very least

mellow quartz
#

Should be no limits to anything so we can play the game as we want

#

Don’t care about raiders at all, fact you can’t even attempt an m+ key for 3 weeks is insane.

lusty grotto
#

i dont care about raiders at all either

mellow quartz
#

Literally the only thing I play the game for

lusty grotto
#

except my guild

#

im primarily a M+ playert

pallid quiver
#

Personally, I think you should be banned if you don't play at least 18 hours a day, thanks

lusty grotto
#

and im still fine with it

soft tusk
#

what keybind enables friendly nameplates?

strong forum
#

if you didnt rebind, could be /

#

i think

#

on numpad

soft tusk
#

Shift+V.. figured it out haha

strong forum
#

otherwise v or shit+v

#

ye

#

but thats usually all nameplates i tihnk

vocal nimbus
#

Logging in automatically in def stance is intended and will remain so?

strong forum
#

si

#

cuz in DF when you changed spec you were just in no-stance

#

so they now just force you into d-stance with login or spec change on prot

#

and bstance as arms

#

and ig fury in zerkerstance

#

if thats still a thing

vocal nimbus
#

Not really much of a hasle but quite annoying

strong forum
#

ye

pallid quiver
#

for the record

strong forum
#

sounds plausible

pallid quiver
#

On a side note, it's very interesting how groups handle the first room of Cinderbrew

#

people just can't understand not running around and panicking if I pull half the room sometimes, so sometimes we get the full room with zero stops and zero damage

#

That dot hurts when it's stacked up to a bajillion damage per tick

#

And then if people just sit there and press buttons, everything goes super fine

soft tusk
#

I just pull the entire room. I pull it with the boss if my group are my regulars

#

What sort of problems do you usually come accross?

pallid quiver
#

If the mobs don't die or are allowed to stack that dot on you in any way, you fucking die