#protection
1 messages · Page 997 of 1
Crit blocking is like just an rng chance for your block to reduce the damage further to a cap of 85%
You need to be able to block to critically block 🫡
I’m pugging / working on 12’s at the moment. No issues getting into groups. Things that may be at play. Do you have depleted keys in your io? Do you have a fair number of 2 chested keys? Are you fairly even across the board raising your io.
depleting keys has no relevance
it makes absolutel 0 difference
and it pisses me off when people cant complete on a homework key
for some loot
dont fucking do it
if anything, having keys depleted lets you know they have actually practiced it on X level
yep
whenever I see someone having depleted that key
it tells me that he played it
and hes not gonna be surprised
at the damage coming or whatever there can be

if I have x2 healers or tanks that have similar io
but one of them depleted that key 5 times
I'll take that one
also it shows he fucking sticked
and didnt mind to finish
instead of being a prick because it's gonna show on io
boohoo
I legit had a guy leave a key at 5% of last boss (he was a tank) so we all died because the key would be seconds overtimed
so I specced prot
yeah those people are scum
and we finished it
literally other peoples idea (full pug) for me to tank it
just so it shows on the tanks raider io page
yeah its garbage behavior
and i hope that one dude wasnt alluding to the fact that having depleted keys is bad
because its just the opposite
the people that consider it bad, are the exact type of group you want to avoid
you cant 1 shot a key up past a certain mark
Do they make you sign a charter when you wanna play ret pally ? Saying you shall never kick, or never use the CC talent you specced in ?
I believe mastery still ups chance to block, doesn't it?
Though you only get the various shield block benefits like SS damage if SB is active, so you should still press it, but
That's the DPS Code of Conduct
Palas just religiously adhere to it with zealous fervor because
Well
I highly suspec the DH population are the same kind
Overpopulated with morons because 'it's the meta spec so I'll rock playing it"
Hey, I've now seen two VDHs actually press a silence sigil.in a key while on my Shaman
That's double what I've seen so far
just like the mage pop doesnt believe on all of there whole 4 defensives
thats pretty much it
But they gotta keep alter time for the movement, bro
i was so close to leaving a key today
partially bc i was gonna be late for work
but i got so tilted
question is Ouroboreal Necklet worth? got it and was runnin a few keys that has nature dmg and im not seeing it on my details.
its almost entirely useless
yeah cuz i have alot of fire dmg so i assumed the nature shield would be helpful but i aint seeing anything xD. i got forgestorm and eragon ring and helm inchant also decoration of flame atm. i was asked to switch to tank so i dont have rageheart yet. oh well
nah its got a 1m cd on the proc, fire or nature dam not both (getting a shield from fire will prevent the nature shield and vise versa)
rageheart is overrated anyways
yeah i want dreadplate. heard its fun af. 15 sec of cant touch this
i got cheat and deco atm. spamming bracken for splinter.
dreadplateis very good
I've been using Dreadplate as of this week and it is quite noticible when I have it rolling. I very seriously doubt Granyth's keeps up at all
The mitigation is hard to track but you can easily feel it and it without question does significantly more damage
In the 10 uldaman I did earlier today it did 29m @frosty mango
not so much this week but week 2 of the season was what I was referring too, and no I didn't have any depleted keys, ~8s week 1 on that character --- playing 3 characters so it's possible that it was mostly that I had no scores on that week on that thursday I played so people were just hittin' no.
But even still, this week I've only done a couple keys on that toon and I'll sit there in queue for 2-3 minutes before people accept or occassionally get a decline.
2.7k - https://raider.io/characters/us/stormscale/Leidaraion - not high but easily enough for that key area.
-- Whereas on my holy priest I almost never get declined nor have to sit there waiting for them to decide if they want a 2.7k holy priest to heal. They accept usually right away
I dps main but I have to tank keys so I generally can’t grab bullion tank items. I’ve been trying to farm granyths and splinter but I’m at 40+ runs and haven’t seen either
About to just spend the bullion for rageheart or dreadplate
In your case it’s probably lack of keys
Just low completed count
That's is such a stupid metric to look at but I guess I get it...
It’s prominent in the raider io addon ui
And generally someone who has 100+ completed keys is a far less risky invite than someone with 20
meh, I can understand people generally thinking that. But the 11 AV I did last night where 2 of our 2.9k rated DPS didn't know you have to focus the hardened crystal on the last boss demonstrate that you ultimately truly just don't know.
I wished people interrupted/cc more its freaking brutal.
Oh they don't. At all. It's gross.
Another fun thing DPS do is immediately AOE stun a pack before it's grouped
Grade A nonsense right there
the armor doenst matter, you already take super low damage from small hits anyway so dreadplate functions as a pseudo immunity and just does more damage
The granyths has a 75% DR up to its shield value - wouldn’t that make it functionally equivalent defensively just with lower damage?
Haven’t been able to get my hands on it to figure out how it calculates the reduction
It doesn't mitigate nearly as much as Dreadplate does
No shot I'd believe that
I mean, you can't exactly track it but it feels ridiculous when you have it active.
I remember using Granyth's the first 2 weeks of the season and it was doing like 8-10m healing per dungeon
I’m less interested in how much it mitigates and more so how that 75% dr works
damage was very low
Damage I can see being poopoo
@wide charm @frosty mango so granyth's is more of a good defensive trinket than it is a offensive trinket?
I mean, yes, but also where it is positioned on wowhead's BIS trinket list for prot warrior is definitely correct. (C tier : https://www.wowhead.com/guide/classes/warrior/protection/bis-gear)
I'm going to get rageheart this comign week after reset.
its better defensively than offesnively yes
but theres better defensive options
@wide charm @frosty mango
in regards to DPS, granyth's is pretty far down.
dreadplate in dps is #1
https://bloodmallet.com/chart/warrior/protection/trinkets/castingpatchwerk5
when there are more mobs i think
I feel I don't need to equip to 2defensive trinkets. 1 defensive and 1 offensive
use dreadplates and anvil then
how come not s ignet out of curiosity?
its less reliable than anvil bc you cant extend if youre forced to drop combat
my hesitation with dreadplate is what about the movement slow ?
can it be a issue? @south zealot
it can but ive never had it be an issue
So its more of be careful when to use especialy if requires you to move out of stuff etc
Anvil is a lot easier to keep up than signet
I have both. Anvil almost never drops unless it’s nokhud and signet is a struggle
Hi cuties
Does anyone have a link to the prot warrior changes? I can't find them on wowhead but I remember seeing something about them a few weeks back
Nvm think I found it
ur a brand of orange
gottem
Mostly damage changes, Battering Ram nerfs to compensate, Enduring Alacrity doubled
team i just OMEGA inted a key
but its fine bc it was my own key and my group was insane
we wouldve 3 chested if i didnt actively try to play as bad as possible
hi guys, noob question. How do I get the heroic version of cheat death trinket from dawn (522ilvl one)?
do doti on hard mode by talking to npc in beginning
Dont worry i pull a 4 and a 14 the same way, i let god sort out the rest
what can i drop from the push m+ talent tree for disrupting shout?
bloodsurge
@grim pilot closer
if i had real potions instead of shocking discloure
monk wf and dont drop anvil the one time i did this key
easy 500k
priest got turbo unlucky that key it was actually so sad, only one of his deaths was like
really avoidable
finally last boss HOI, but this is help from stacked anvil too
the higher the key level you do, the more spell reflect does exponentially
and you can get more bc the boss has so much health
its sick
yeah i think last week i was seeing some 11m reflects eevery time
You reflecting the surge on last boss hoi?
The second boss in Nohkud is great for spell reflecting, you can do dozens of millions of dmg reflecting Wind Burst
Well damn, sorry for speaking
anyway thats the only one
the tornado?
the focused deluge, not the squal buffet
yes you reflect the tornado in the intermission phase, you press reflect and run to a tornado and you relfect the damage to one of the 4 golems
only after their shield is down
on emberon
oh interesting
Hmmm I rarely do uldaman but when I do I will look at that Nim
Or maybe I could do M0 to check it
uldaman is a big reflect dungeon
its aight
not nearly as much as nok
hard to call it big reflect dungeon when in nokhud its top dam
but yeah thats an outlier
any deaths on boss fights means youre gonna have big reflects
but if youre having deaths
Nokhud last boss is indeed like almost every spell reflect is reflect conduit, I still haven't got the full timing to reflect back to back to back, after 2/3 usually there is a gap
can you actually get every single one consistently? I feel like I always end up where it's on CD ONCE
each time
lmao
network reated
doesnt really matter, if your key boils down to you doing a reflect to time it
youre already in problems
Yea, even the ones that don't get reflected on him are inconsequential you always have shield wall and/or spell block but I was just curious. Usually I can reflect all but 1 or max 2 anyways throughout the fight
@lusty grotto you mean the fire tornado right? does the tornado must be near golem to get damaged? Earlier I tried put reflect up but no reflect sound, I must've doing it wrong.
their shield is down, we were hitting it and there is tornado nearby and I tried walk with SR up, no reflect sound but I might've not get hit by tornado too.
Is prot warrior dps insane? I’m doing so much overall on my prot compared to my dh and monk
I’m still grinding 8s and 9s to gear up and usually #1 or #2 overall
its pretty good
idk if id say insane
but its def in the upper half
LMAOOOO theres no way
a group in group finder said "tank please"
i apply
delists and immediately pulls
"vdh please"
Based
i completely respect their decision bc its a full magic damage comp
but that shit was so funny
god damn it why blizz can't buff us to be pair with VDH
no dh should be doing more for sure
monk maybe still after the nerfs
based on very little evidence at all, i feel like prot and brew are very close
dh is a bit above
moreso if you count their superior buff
i dont see in pins what to craft, wowhead says 2x shadowflame patch
yeah do that
2x shadowflame is the play
Unless you play offspec i think vers wrists can be good too
gotcha
I'm never DPSing so I have no clue : what is hard about the thunder drake in RLP ? I see tons and tons of death there...
its a fuck ton of burst damage
Debuff
thats just ppl being bad
I have noticed that ranged players WANT to stay at range at all cost, even when it makes dodging a breath 10x harder
Anyone know if there is a spark catch up mechanic?
there is
Drops?
i had to do the weekly quest before i started getting catchup
Oooooh ok
So get current weekly done then just do content
Copy
Thank you
Just picked my warrior back up from s1 abandoned and was hoping the craft would give me a boost
It might be my personal skillevel offc. On my dh I do big aoe dmg but falls back in st and end on about 200-300 overall in most dungeons, while on my war I can end on 300-400k overall.
I guess I should analyze my dh logs a bit.
which flask do u guys usually run
tepid vers
Crit
i would run crit if i still didnt have like 200 vers flasks left from what i bought in S1
bro stockpiled
jakey the type of guy to buy 300 rolls of toilet paper once covid hit
I keep forgetting to use potions in keys
xdd
as a tank
BRuh
how did u do 442 overall 💀
iirc 8 targets clap is more dam
outburst tc in aoe
generally shield slam should be your highest prio since there's always a priority target but
me and choco are just chasing overalls
u know what i like about overall as tank
when u are high on the meter
dps players panic
they dont want a tank to pass them
anyone deep diving mop remix or just that one guide on wowhead and move on?
I'm tryin but I chose fury haven't tried prot at all
ngl prot pretty insane
In remix?
What key level is this
yer
game trows stats at you
breaking 100% crit whene i hit a stunned mob and almost perma 87% haste in combat
Sick lol
Whats this panda remix about
you go through panda land with modern kit
Might swap prot
and they slap you with god modes
Also, once you level a char up, you can bungo level alts
Kinda like Diablo meets wow speed running
Since you get a stacking exp bonus that's account wide
U also get all sorts of transmogs and old mounts that were impossible to farm
its slow at first
Snowballs tho
yeah lol
am I the only one to get destroyed by mobs and bosses in instances and have no aggro generation on MoP remix?
hey ive been playing prot war on classic but i just swithced over to retail, im lvl 50 right now and strugglign with threat in dungeons, am i going to lose threat this easily at lvl 70 as well?
It’s almost impossible to lose threat at max level unless there is a massive gear disparity between you and your dps
And I mean massive
Sub max level scaling makes a lot of things wonky
Because someone could be level 10 and doing dps that’s like 30x yours due to scale factors
HOW DO i deal with magic damage in ruby?
it was a key 14
handled first pull
second pull was rough
maybe double defensive trinkets?
Spell block spell reflect
Spell block is big
Can also rage pool for ignore pain if you absolutely have to
use armor gem, upgrade gems to leggo and they give stam
IMO usually if you feel like you’re getting shredded it’s either shield block uptime low or you’re not leveraging ignore pain enough when you need it
Also those mobs can be stunned/kicked and really shouldn’t be blasting you much
do you guys fr switch talents when raiding or doing mythic dungeons and stuff?
and is it a very big setback if i dont switch
Yes and it can be yes
If you roll into m+ with raid talents that have no control options then yea you’re kinda trolling people
If you rolled into raid with m+ talents I doubt anyone would notice
about the only one that comees to mind but i dont watch alot of it
most of the other names i can think of just play m+ top end and play the meta tank, not pwar specific
Sense owns
^^ its true
any tips to handle the chomp bleed from uldaman crocos? got badly wrecked
stun them, play dwarf
they do it to often to reliably stun the cast by myself i think
helps to have an evoker to cleanse bleed too
What would you take instead?
Tanked it on 14 last night
My best tip is to run
Maybe better warriors can do some voodoo shit but fuck them crocs
Seems bout right’s
I find anvil usually outclasses ruby in most dungeons
@frosty mango when you pop dreadplate does the buff effect show you how many plates you currently have
i forget if you have dreadplate lol.
I don’t have e dreadplate. I have a 483 rageheart. Imagine trinkets dropping:/
ah right
@wide charm I think it was you who had dreadplate, when you use it does the buff effect tell you how many plates you currently have?
okay in order for the plate to explode , enemy attacks hae to be at certain threshold to damage the plate right
or does any damage count?
@wide charm
also do you have to face a certain way in order fro the plate to hit or does it always blast whatever is in front of you
It'll shoot 5 pillars out that hit 5 enemies in front of you
it shoots in front of you
Ah okay, so I got wrong information that I had to face it.
Most of your kit comes online post level 60 with shield charge, violent outburst, ravager, etc, so it's rough about that level range unless you're very used to the class
I read on Wowhead that damage has to be above a certain threshold in order for the plate to break. Is that true?
Uhh so if I understand it correctly, say it reduces 25k to make it simple
if an attack hits you for 24,999 it just does 0
so yeah it won't break a plate
however, when the trinket's duration ends all the beams fire anyways
Oh. Hmm. Good to know. Back to thinking between Dread and Anvil
@wide charm Thanks for the clarification.
yes
use both
drop anvil for another defensive option if youd like
but deadplate is pretty locked
hi dad
Hello son
Did I just read ur article on wow head or am I tripping
Depends which article
Mop remix prot
Yah
That's dope thanks for the article!

Noticed a little error I think
In the meta gem slot u have 2 listed in the article black ox and the lighting ball one
Which one u thinking?
They're both listed as options, one for early and one for late game iirc
Ah gotcha
Nome literally never makes mistakes

I've never died in a video game 
Or IRL! for matter of fact
spoilers: you died and you're in purgatory
only way out is to write wowhead guides for several years
I dont get this mate. Too slow how?
only blood dk can do it?
Ahh ok 😄
tanking the boss
just live
P2 pwar is very weak against mythic broodkeeper
P1 you just gotta manage your CDs and to be full HP for the tank buster to not drop too low during it
do i spell block
Spellblock only does smth for the tankbuster in p2 on mythic
On heroic spellblock does nothing on that boss
i'm talking mythic
our tank is not here the dk and they asked me to step in from arms
you reckon i'm gonna have a rough night huh
does my 483 last season cheat death trinket save me or does the damage outscale the fatal treshhold
What people did on early prog in s1 was have the pwar just suicide with it, but nowadays I reckon you can just play the mechanic normally
Isn't everything but the staff damage SpellBlockable (according to the spreadsheet)?
was thinking bout running cheat death and fyrak tank trinket but from last season
Sure if you're uncomfortable
also is immovable object talent worth running
The tankbuster is listed as normal block, not spellblock
You can spellblock all the random aoe effects, sure
But that's practically entirely irrelevant for tanks
The only thing that matters for tanks are the tank busters, aka the healing reduction bleed and the mythic soak tankbuster in p2
For the exact CD usages you gotta ask @shut summit as I've not done the fight on mythic myself as tank
thanks i'll see what happens , raid is now
And I'm not home so I can't check logs RQ for the cd timings
Ah gotcha
My boys where can I find some sick shield mogs
you can go into the transmog tab and look at all the uncollected shit you dont have yet 
or just go farm black temple for Bulwark of Azzinoth
looking for some general advice for m+ tanking and stats, should we just be stacking haste till the cows come home? or is the real value of haste in being able to move from HR to ItF at ~5400 haste?
bulwark of azzinoyh
Cheers
or is it a comfort thing
with the cantrip rings you want haste in every slot
thanks
Can I solo the temple at 70
yes
Perfect
Which trinket would you guys spend boullions on if you wanna optimize mostly M+, but also be strong for raid DPS?
Thinking OCE might be nice, so far i haven't really been able to push past 10s but ideally i try this season.
elementium pocket anvil was another option i considered, but didn't seem that high on the dps war list
or is a defensive trinket really important for us?
anvil is high for war dps
Anvil is literally the best dps trinket you can want as prot
Shit is bonkers
And also really good for arms
Defensive trinket is not rly important
@lament musk tanked tyrannical +17AA with full dmg trinkets + full dmg talents

ye i want anvil, prolly better than sig brand in keys
or crocs in uldaman
even if brand sims higher for arms, anvil is just much easier to upkeep
for purely defensive trinkets for high keys, would it be double on use with brackhide trinket + dreadplates?
28k dps on bosses
prot fucks

Yeah that's pretty good
xd
But double on-use defensive trinket is overkill
enter with full anvil stacks, destroy the boss, refuse to elaborate
but assuming I want the tankiest build possible, that would probably be it?
jsut so i'm sure, there's a problem with threat generation on MoP Remix? when people take aggro back on a boss like 30 seconds after start that's not normal
Yeah
cool thanks
pretty sure it did like 40k for me more than once
He pooompin
was thinking maybe it will be worth to play battle scarred when the changes go live, not sure what to drop tho
There's a build linked
"impossible to die training wheels"
Is what's it's called
Or immortal training wheels build
Smth along those lines
But
But if u take bsv thats what u have to do
How are you gonna get the point for bsv?
yeah thats the struggle
Theres no good way the talents work if u want both
That's why that build is there
It's the most bang for your buck
You can only get bsv by making serious sacrifices
And dropping SC and picking up BSV + Bolster is the best way
Without losing 5%+ dmg
EA is too overloaded to not play, Ravager is big burst of rage gen + damage
Outburst is what enables you to play at all
Indom is what let's you live
BV is huge value and rage gen
SC without Battering Ram is very little value compared to what it was before the nerf
So it's "just" a stun + rage and block uptime you lose
kinda want it for the stun but yeah without battering ram it feels kinda meh to spend that point only for the stun
So you get the block uptime from bolster
And the pseudo cheat BSV
So you "only" lose ~0.9 rage/sec and the stun
And shield charge by itself without champions bulwark is just turbo trolling
Shield charge damage isn’t too much these days right
It's good instant dmg, but yeah without Battering Ram quite whelming
Idk I never looked at SC by itself
I guess if you want to go mega defense mode damage not really super top of mind for those people apparently anyway
I would like to see this smooth build
what tinkers we rockin with for remix raids
It's linked in the pins ceezar
Ty
There's a short wowhead and probably icy veins guide on the gems we use krook
thanks
SC is such a nice button for quick burst threat also
awesome, gonna just get anvil as #3 boullion item and then pray to RNJesus I get a heroic 2H to drop one day. Worst case, I craft a 2H
On earlier discussion, could you really not justify dropping BV for BSV?
I mean Booming Voice isn't insignificant but BSV can be really good in some circumstances no?
its 8 seconds of DR every 3 minutes for what, a 10% overall damage amp?
Tradeoff just isn't justifiable
Would 2/2 bloodborne technically be more dps for single target and aoe than SC+champ's bulwark? Assuming no disrupting shout and BSV, you can go bolster + 2/2 BB.
I think it should be more damage overall, but I dunno.
was the bsv change pushed to live? ive been out of the loop
if not the no
if yes then 🤷

when it comes to what lei is saying
ive seen no mentions of changes to bsv, future patch or otherwise
except that little blurb in those notes from like 3 weeks ago
Is there something I'm missing about the first Basilisk pull in ULD? I just got absolutely disintegrated by them on a 13 after saving my Rageheart for it. Wall was on CD from the first pull. Other than Disrupting the cast and try to shockwave the bleed is there anything else I should be doing?
no for carapce
pull the 3 with tour first pull
so they die during cds and lust
its unironically easier
💯
yeah you can also LoS to group up very easily there
not like they are gonna cast on your party anyway
so im with choco on that one
i think theres value in it on nokhud
for last boss and to a lesser extent the birds
Is this immortal build in pins still lookin lol
Cheers lads good advice
Oh shit I’m blind as shit and on my phone deerrtp
does any top prot player run BSV
i dont think so
until they let us know the change has been made... i dont think its gonna be used
bro if they stealth buffed BSV out of nowhere this place would be a warzone
well they did say they were gonna put the change they did in alpha in live
is it still not fixed
starting my prot journey. how do we feel about mouseover charge. or mouseover SC?
overkill?
in m+ i run intervene, mouseover charge is good if you like mouseeovers but i made this macro to charge my target and mouseoveer intervne
#showtooltip Charge
/cast [target=mouseover,help,exists,nodead]Intervene;Intervene
/cast [target=target,harm,exists,nodead]Charge;Charge
also why champions bulwark over battlescarred?
battlescarred is bugged
also for shield block uptime
oh does it just not proc sometimes or something
opposite
itll proc when youre like 90% health sometimes
so it never actually works when youre in potential danger
once its fixed (if it isnt already, i dont know for sure)
you just dont really have points to take it
you have to give up things
usually just a good amount of rage gen and a handful % overall damage
The current build is fun af
decoration of flame 
I don't have good trinkets
trinket does not own

me neither
My other options are the 3 min cd ones, pbox, mirror and fragment
Have you tried murdering someone who does and hijacking their account?
yeah thats a great idea

haha
Anyone here experienced that problem I posted in general?
Sorry for double post... it's technically a tank thing X. X
Irritating me for 2 weeks
i cant say ive noticed
fuck i forgot how much of a massive bitch mythic sennarth is
😢
why would you want a destro with an outlaw rogue in the group
hard capped class with the biggest target count scaling class makes so little sense
they probably saw io and nothing else lol
i just dont understand
if its for damage theres better damage classes
if its for a tanky class just bring an aug
could be a friend
bringing the rogue is fine i just dont know why they ONLY want a destro warlock
Hey, I saw that group too. Unfortunately, got declined.

💀
and find the specific extra bar
bruh what a weird section to put this in
well it is
ye got it
unless you copy pasted a profile
be careful with tracking way too much
do you really need to track defensives? healers should but not us
hmm
kicks, sure
Kicks and CCs imo
stops, sure
anything else, thats a healer problem
dps cds? sure
for routing/big pulls
i do so i can know if ppl died bc theyre stupid
you can just check in logs though 😄
tilting mid dungeon is optimal
i track wall and maybe a 2nd defensive, all aoe stops, class major cd and any group survivability buttons
i only log so i can see my damage compared to other ppl
shrug
xD
oh yeah i agree most ppl track so much shit
ye its the thing i hate
theres no fucking way youre seeing if your priest pressed fade
anyone got a pure dps prot warr build for carry keys?
its in the pins but here u go
sure
thanks
if you want you can drop indomitable for bloodsurge or show of force but thats like
turbo inting your survivability
monkaGIGA
Can i see ur Ui @lusty grotto
its just naowh's ui
but 1440p
and with different class WAs
i use nome's for warrior
^^^^^
if someone dies from expectable damage and has defs ready
u can just say ratio
and pin all on him
What is everyones advice for snap threat issues in keys
Hold one of ravager, t roar, challenging shout for each pull
Alright I will start doing that as I normally have challenging shout every other pull
As for stance dancing I feel like im spending more time in Defensive stance
Tclap revenge should handle most
If you’re talking like whelps in rlp or lashers in aa, you can hold roar for it
Challenging shout is also an option if you absolutely need it
do you have gholak
Also are your dps going full mongo on pull ?
started doing real keys and got scared and sat dstance like 20% of the time :(
oh only was like 11%
i also ran splinter
what the
damn choco youve been busy
i havent touched my war since wednesday lol
too much shit
3 characters, and one mop dk whos super behind now cause i didnt farm frogs
yeah idk why my 16 aa isnt showing on rio though
5 hours of keys all timed
besides 16 halls i griefed on
@south zealot how did you handle the stormshields in NO? just tried it on a 14, went smooth as butter until that pull. granted I pulled the pat + the two stormshields so 4 in the pull because I thought, might aswell pull them all with spell block, but they are tanky af and outlived spell block
that entire area is terrifying for pwar idk, especially if kicks are bad
why do you even pull those
probably shouldnt but you have to atleast pull the patrol, so i thought, make it efficient
but ye it seems not very doable
well its doable, just
way too risky when you can make up % somewhere easier
but regardless, im not choco, idk if he pulls it or not
no thats valuable advice mate, wasnt really just looking for chocos opinion just he had very recently posted his m+ accolades so
yeah i just learned not to pull them from s1, so i just continued not pulling them 😄
ok turns out it wasnt even the stormshields that killed me im just an idiot
what happens when plan A has expired?
have a purge in the group who purges the shield so they dont tale half a dynasty to die
ideally u pull 2 into waterfall with list
lust
we had mage and priest but i dont think they could find their purge button
do like 1-2 totems and then do the pat when spellblock is back up
was lust up for you immediately on enterign the area? feels like it wouldnt be unless you pull extra in first area
For what? 👀
stormshields in NO
the stormshields melees
it is with spell block
usually do 1 totem then waterfall
depends on dps
thanks king
I'm looking at my own log.
And that's not consistent.
Wtf.
Some are blocked, one is not.

Well if you wanna go that, you got the weekly dmg key build
getting hit in the back? was the associated melee hit blocked?
Ye but plater doenst detect it
I have it blacklisted as 'Punish' and it works fine
I assume you mean whitelisted?
can you outrange the arcblades cast in nokhud?? watching Bobas and he just walks away from every one
do u guys play in battle stance or defense
Default to battle and treat defensive stance as a CD
Since tanks, particularly Prot, don't take meaningful damage outside of telegraphed scenarios.
assuming remotely proper play
whats a telegraphed scenario
"hey i'm gonna hit you really hard"
larodar reels up charge and tells you to run out of dealing damage range
you know beforehand that there's gonna be a large burst of damage coming your way, or that there's no possible way for you to deal meaningful damage due to being forced out of melee range, etc
Those are the times to dip into defensive stance
Classic doesn't really have as good a suite of defensives for tanks, even into Cataclysm. You're just more baseline tanky, and have CDs for big moments. Though Cata is the xpac that started the trend toward more modern defensive CD usage, what with giving out more defensives with CDs below "literally once an encounter"
You're a good suite of defensives for tanks
gottem
boss i can barely get out of bed somedays
that's how u stay tanky
I slept too much yesterday
Like you can't name a single video game boss in the history of ever who has attacked the hero while they were in bed.
I've played many a game where being in bed is a bad time
Hell, you get kidnapped from bed in at least one JRPG
never trust free beds, kids
is the battle stance's 3% crit chance really better than the defensive stance's 5% flat dmg
In many cases yes
It's 10% reduced damage, not 10% damage increase.
That’s what I assumed he meant
u take 20% less but deal 5% less so bstance is like 3%crit AND 5% dmg increase
or smth
Yeah, it comes out to a ~7-8% damage difference between the two
You're not inting if you play def stance all the time but you really don't need to.
Just use it as a defensive cooldown
indeed, we seem tanky enough
do u guys use rend
@plush path Please don't listen to that. No one is gonna care if you deal 5% or even 10% less damage. Use defensive stance as normal, switch to battle if you feel like you want to push numbers at a given time.
Regarding rend, thunder clap applies it automatically, as long as you have it talented.
no
TC applies it if u followed the general talent builds
lol... he asked if the damage was better in Battle Stance. We said yes. And everything else said was true as well.
And no one said that anyone was going to care if he did less damage. In fact, I said the opposite.
shame crit from BS dont give parry tho
This is not true.
you do not default to battle stance, that's how you flop lol. Default is defensive stance, then when you know you have no incomming damage or you feel safe, you can switch to battle stance.
Whatever floats
Most ppl dont do keys at levels where they should need to sit in def stance perma
So then youre just missing out on damage
Flopping comes from turning your back or not using CDs when you need to; there's no key level people had hit where you're going to die from basic melees without defensive stance up
then you're doing too small pulls.
no, you have a very different view because you play in the top > 1% of the player base
your experience is completely differnt to the general/ new player
in your scenarios yes
Well yes, so why would you teach tehm to go for damage?
you should be in d stance a lot
more in low keys there is not point or need to be in it as it wont save u from flopping ither way
Same reason we dont tell tanks to go cheat death when they do +5s
you die from making mistakes
If they want to tank and learn how to tank, why are they told to care about 8% damage. And Saying Battle stance is the standard, would mean you start pulls in battle stance too, and that's just ridiculous.
Doens't sound like you poeple should be telling tanks what to do then.
the idea is to help them get to higher keys no?
I doubt their goal is to have fun in that +5.
well not if they dont want too
alot of ppl cap out at 10s
or 10s is their goal
no point in d stancing in a 10
nothing but mistakes can kill you
sure, but I doubt those people ask for help in that +10?
i mean he was a leaf
Like if you're grinding +10, surely you're comfy with what you can push or not
so very likely a new player
so not even in 10s yet
like a tiny portion of even this channel is doing higher than 10s
The lesson isn't even damage; it's to use your tools properly
this isnt some elite high key server
this a general discussion server
and never have we said u just sit in battle stance
well if the lesson is to use your tools properly, why are you telling them that Battle stance is the Standard lol
the message we give is if u feel like u need it be in it
but thats subjective to the player
not a flat rule
his literal words was battle stance is standard. Which in my head means you pull in battle stance too, which is just delusional.
Because the default is to not waste defensives; if there's no need for a defensive, don't use it.
because battle stance is the standard for 99% of players
because they are doing content where being in d stance will literally do nothing
It's also notable in that raid is pretty much always Battle Stance, as well, even for most MYthic raiders
raid is entirely only about dmg output
Im pretty certain @strong forum last season went into 24s-25s in 10 less ilvl than everyone else. bare in mind this is levels where ppl claimed u must be in dstance all the time. and he took literally 0 damage in battle stance just by playing correctly
like i think he did 2-3 28s with cheat death trinket
there's no key leve you should be in def stance all the time
and proc'd it once?
and that doens't mean much
I'm not saying this is waht happened, but you can also play a dungoen pack by pack
^^^
you dont learn what hurts by going overkill tanky
and you certainly dont think about swapping to b-stance when you perma default to D-stance
as proven by alot of people just afking in d-stance primarily in situations where there s 0 tank dmg
not even using their trinkets for dmg
to sit on it for a bad day idk
correct
Obviously. With proper play you're not in danger, even at the start of a pull.
We aren't a druid or a paladin where not pooling on the prior pull gets you killed.
theres a difference between defaulting to D-stance and simply doing the smart play and gathering pulls
ykno
if they're here asking for such questions they're 100% not doing the content where you are
Which is evident by a lot of players playing their spec improperly but still timing high keys. M+ is more about team coordination than anything. (No shots towards you btw)
I'll shoot towards him. Imagine thinking you just die if you don't defensive stance at the start of a pull and then acting like they know everything 🙄
i was legit the only pwar on the ladder who didnt run cheat death trinket in fall27 despite it being a dungeon that LITERALLY heals the tank
cuz people dont min max
they afk default to 1 thing
Yeah, frankly I think that's why some high key tanks recommend this or that. They're actually not playing properly and they need the crutch when they fuck up.
I have watched a lot of keys of top players who reroll to the meta tank of the season just grossly misplaying when they aren't even in a bad spot.
Well, in some things, yeah lol
it was more of a joke than sarcasm
i mean u see it with disrupting shout all the time, and not form high key pushers ither
I gave it a shot
How do you even play the game without it
continues to show logs that show they dont 
like it was said b4, I felt like I was just looking for an opportunity to use it
rather than needing it
If there's one thing I know about prot warrior, it's that without disrupting shout, defensive stance, and 13.63% vers, you will fall over instantly.
Moron it’s 17.83% vers
Stupid fuck
Stop spouting bad baseless advice

sense used disrupt in his AV 
yes but as sense has said if it enbales u to do 1 pull u couldnt without it, then its a good talent
thats what hes doing there
Yeah like the lashers in there all will simultaneously cast vapors
I mean if it allowed you to do that then ya
So it gets good value
Unironically
do u guys use whirlwind in aoe?
never
no
ww is not on bars for prot
because you have thunder clap, shield slam and revenge
which is more than enough
wirldwin is 360
Thunder clap and revenge hits better and if you wanna spend rage you use IP
Based phil
ancient meme screenshot 🙏
shield slam isnt aoe tho is it
i wanted to say thunder clap and revenge
and in most aoe scenarios shield slam under outburst is a priority
up to 5-6 targets if i am not mistaken
i dont understand this sentence
Our rotation cant fit whirlwind anywhere
wdym under outburst
Revenge is whirlwind but 1000x better.
sorry im new to retail i only played prot war on classic
with the buff active
because it deals less damage than revenge, costs more rage than revenge and doesnt proc SS like revenge does.
revenge we also barely press atm
so that shows how bad WW is
He's referring to our talent Violent Outburst @plush path
Highly recommend reading one of the guides
there is a talent called violent outburst which makes your next TC or shield slam deal 200% increased damage, 100% more rage and grants ignore pain
ah i just read it i understand now
shield slam hits like a truck and is priority in aoe over thunder clap up to 5-6 targets
so you use shield slam in aoe as well
i will read every talent very soon 🙏🏿
Shield slam*
He's new so be specific XD
Slam is also not on your bars
Shield slam, yes, slam, no
what about hamstring 
i have it bound and i use it a lot on shade week
to help dps run away
especially melee
Yeah or any mobs that fixate
I used it on the gold add on priestess last season as well
how i miss piercing howl......
it's easier to take next xpac
Iirc we can in TWW though? Might be misremembering
as far as i know
i was under the impression SS was always the prio with outburst
is it better to TC with it past 6 mobs?
New class tree in tww is worse overall
i guess our rage gen is so insane that we can go for the dmg > rage?
kinda yes and no
was it 6 or 8?
i don't remember well











