#protection

1 messages · Page 943 of 1

violet ginkgo
#

random I think

blazing condor
#

its me

#

i got early onset dementia and forgot how to play pwarr

rocky bough
#

Is it possible to make a macro that casts pummel, but will cast storm bolt if pummel is on cooldown?

warm plinth
#

It was the tank in my 23 TotT last night. He had an absolutely massive 54.5% blocked hits.

#

and just a biiiiiit of rage waste

restive scroll
violet ginkgo
#

btw for spellblock.. is it common to not use it at M+ or just for certain dungeon?

restive scroll
#

What kind of key levels/raid kinds are you doing?

blazing condor
restive scroll
blazing condor
#

there's always somewhere you benefit from it

restive scroll
#

Maybe not brh, that's about it

warm plinth
restive scroll
ionic fern
median tulip
warm plinth
#

Like this is Nome's wasted rage. This is what it should look like.

opal forum
#

where do you look at those logs?

warm plinth
lusty grotto
#

ya

opal forum
#

how? i was trying to see

#

and didnt super understood

warm plinth
#

What are you trying to find

opal forum
#

typicaly what he just mentioned

#

rage wasted

#

block %

warm plinth
#

Do you know how to log/access your own logs?

opal forum
#

i used to a few years ago, i didnt logged anything yet but i can see that some of my keys are logged (probly a pug)

warm plinth
#

Well

#

Start here

opal forum
#

and i would like to see the stats on those

restive scroll
#

Doesn't mean much

opal forum
#

can i not look into the already logged keys?

warm plinth
#

You can, yes

#

So

jagged pier
#

if u have some

opal forum
#

looks like i do

warm plinth
#

Blocked hits % is

Make sure your character is selected
Click Damage Taken
Hover over the number in the Hits column next to the Melee row

#

Rage waste is

Make sure your character is selected
Click Resources
Change Hit Points drop down to Rage

opal forum
#

gotcha

#

thanks!

restive scroll
warm plinth
#

If you want to see hits to your back, go to Damage Taken and before you check blocked hits, click the Shield Block icon above the table

#

That'll tell you your blocked hits % with shield block active. Any hits you didn't block means you got hit in the back

opal forum
#

thank you

lusty tiger
warm plinth
#

Nome has lightning fingers

jagged pier
#

honestly nowadays its just spam your IP key

#

done

warm plinth
#

Ngl I think the biggest problem for intermediate wars is a badly positioned ip key

#

At least in terms of wasted range

jagged pier
#

yer i had to change mine in BFA

warm plinth
#

Rage

jagged pier
#

it was shift g

#

imagine that now

warm plinth
#

Ooof

jagged pier
lusty tiger
warm plinth
#

Enjoy carpal tunnel haha

#

What is it now

jagged pier
#

g

#

was an easy swap

#

spell refelct to shift g

#

and ip to g

warm plinth
jagged pier
#

SB is f for me

#

so very easy presses

warm plinth
lusty tiger
warm plinth
#

No nitro?

jagged pier
#

im not made of money

warm plinth
#

It's $2 a month

jagged pier
#

u think i have that to spare in this UK economy

warm plinth
jagged pier
lusty tiger
#

💶

tribal wharf
#

i with jakey on this one

#

we arent nomerature

#

gaurdian and lore master of german gyms and excesize regimens

#

able to afford rent, food AND video games

lusty tiger
#

German gyms?

tribal wharf
#

hes from germany and last i checked he works at a german bank or gym

#

or both

lusty tiger
#

Those are rather different

tribal wharf
#

i think he had both of those jobs, im not sure

lusty tiger
hazy bronze
#

German banks

waxen frigate
waxen frigate
jagged pier
lusty grotto
jagged pier
#

yep first keybind i made back in day when i started to not be a clicker

#

start with one button keep moving it up

lusty grotto
#

ya mine has been that way since late vanilla

jagged pier
#

also why my keybinds are horrendous

#

and my 1 key is wasted because thats taunt

#

and has to be taunt

lusty grotto
#

my taunt is 2

#

my charge had been 1 until BFA

#

where i swapped all movement/gap closers to G on all characters

jagged pier
#

C

#

for movement

#

shift 1 for charges

lusty grotto
#

so intervene went to 1, then SC this exp

#

kind of scuffed since not often pressed, but i find that 1 is not really spammy anyway

#

now, R

#

that is a spammy key

#

5 too

jagged pier
#

that inturpt for me

#

r

median tulip
#

My taunt is on my mouse, because all my mouseover binds have to be on my mouse

jagged pier
#

because its quick and easy

lusty grotto
#

yea its a good key

#

anything around 3 and 5, including E, R, and T is very easy to press

#

maybe 2 as well

median tulip
#

Q is shockwave. E is Shield Slam, R is TClap, T is Demo Shout

#

G and H are Shield Block and Ignore Pain, respectively

opal forum
#

ive always played by pressing forward with E

#

and W R for sides

#

is that crazy

#

better hand positionning

#

am i the only one?

waxen frigate
median tulip
#

Are your fingers all the same length?!

waxen frigate
#

Or EWRD

opal forum
#

e forward
w left
r right
d backped

median tulip
#

ESDF I can respect. But WR for movement is bad and wrong.

opal forum
#

i mean

#

its just muscle memory

#

thats how ive played for ever

#

it feels the best for me

median tulip
#

My hand is cramping just thinking about it

waxen frigate
#

I don’t think I have any pics of my warr binds

#

But it’s like

opal forum
#

feels super relax for me

#

smooth

waxen frigate
#

1 SS, 2 Revenge, 3 charge, 4 TRoar, 5 TC, 6 nothing, 7 potion/on use, 8 rav, 9 heroic throw, 0 uhh nothing on prot?, -/11 avatar, =/12 I think also nothing on prot

opal forum
#

how do you even get to 9

waxen frigate
#

Mmo mouse

median tulip
opal forum
#

ok well thats different

waxen frigate
#

Oh wait 6 is shield charge now

opal forum
#

the way you said it sounds like ur actually use the keyboard one ahah

median tulip
#

I usually Shield Charge off the mouse button (which is a mouseover macro) rather than off 2

waxen frigate
#

Then for other relevant stuff is shift-1 IV, shift-= rally, alt-1 sb, alt-4 kick, alt-5 reflect, alt-6 IP, alt-8 shockwave, alt-= wall

#

Execute shift-6

median tulip
#

The 3 by 4 block at the right is the mouse buttons; the vertical 5 at the left there is the G keys on my G910

opal forum
#

i have the same mouse

#

i dont know how you manage to use

#

those ones

median tulip
#

Some of those binds are legacy; I don't actually have Berserker Rage talented, I've just never got around to removing it

opal forum
#

on ur mouse

#

impossible for me to use those buttons on the mouse

#

they are unused

median tulip
opal forum
#

i mean

#

that

waxen frigate
#

I think i have a pic of my brew binds

opal forum
#

its hard for me to press those button accuratly with my thumbs

#

like

#

i litteraly cant use them

median tulip
#

I have a G600, the buttons are pretty chunky

#

and I have huge hands

opal forum
#

i had a razer naga and now a g600

#

cant use that part of the mouse

#

i dont know what im pressing

#

i have no idea wich button is the right one

median tulip
#

The main thing is I need all those extra buttons because my left hand is kinda fucked up and I can't use modifier keys in a fight

lusty grotto
#

no-mmo mice master race

opal forum
#

i only use the ones on the extremety

#

otherwise im lost

median tulip
#

It's just muscle memory

violet ginkgo
opal forum
#

had mmo mouses since im a kid and still cant ahah

#

i had razer naga back in the days in wotlk and its been like 2/3 years i have the g600 and i have a big hand and the logitech feels better

median tulip
#

I've never had a Naga, but the G600 is sized really well for my hand

opal forum
#

same for the side buttons and the extra click on the full right of the mouse

#

the extra click is so good

median tulip
#

Yeah that G Shift is nice

opal forum
#

its always used for core ability

#

that needs reactivity

#

i put my spell reflect on it

median tulip
#

Oh I actually bind it to make a whole new set of 12 available. I have the pings macro'd to the G-Shifted keys

opal forum
#

yeah the g set you said

#

i used it like a regular keybind

#

the spell reflect on it feels so so good

median tulip
#

Spell Reflect is C for me

#

Nice easy button to access

tribal wharf
#

bear (yogi) binds for pwar

#

(the top mini bar is more of a reminder of whats off GCD, i would want to put all those on 1 bar)

lusty grotto
#

i had mad copium today

#

but no dice

#

i hate this game

#

im calling it ima get rageheart or augury the week before fated season hits

molten pollen
#

hello quick question for prot war, does thunderlord work on Disrupting shout, doesnt seem like it

crystal mauve
jagged pier
#

and only demo shout

molten pollen
#

oki thank you

molten pollen
#

why do people not use Disrupting shout btw?

lusty grotto
#

some dont need it cause they have the necessary stops on their teams

molten pollen
#

oki

crystal mauve
lusty grotto
#

it really depends on your comp

molten pollen
#

oki thank you ^^

lusty grotto
#

and if you pug or not

#

for the most part

crystal mauve
#

When it’s good, it’s suuuuper good, when you don’t need it, you didn’t sacrifice much for it so it’s ok

lusty grotto
#

what were the stats on catalyst belt?

#

i forget

#

ah big crit little haste

#

fuck i already have a myth phlegethic

#

goddamn my vault

warm plinth
#

You sacrifice a decent amount for disrupting shout 🤔

strong forum
#

you sacrifice alot for disrupting shout ye

lusty grotto
#

3 sockets YAY

tribal wharf
#

KEK

lusty grotto
tribal wharf
#

hmmm more hp you say....

lusty grotto
#

no

#

more sockets

#

cause holy shit that vault is bad

dusky canopy
#

Eggsecute

patent osprey
#

Character fully done and geared

dusky canopy
#

!!

tribal wharf
#

why do i even bother keying for vault lmao

dusky canopy
#

POG

tribal wharf
#

im probably gunna take one of those

lusty grotto
#

i

#

im just gonna

tribal wharf
#

uhhhhh which egg upsets protection more, but i wont get anned from the channel

waxen frigate
#

The stamina one

lusty grotto
#

close discord

waxen frigate
#

Is literal Garbo

#

The other is like

#

Not a hate crime at least

lusty grotto
#

hey everyone look at me

#

and then plka posts

#

M Rageheart last week

tribal wharf
#

here we go

lusty grotto
#

and Augury this week

#

feels fucking terrible man

tribal wharf
#

i found comments

#

pwar commentts even

restive scroll
waxen frigate
lusty grotto
#

ima just run normal fyraak and cry myself until raid

tribal wharf
#

Surely you jest.

warm plinth
#

I don't even remember what that trinket does

lusty grotto
#

it gives you gold

#

when you sell it

tribal wharf
#

wowhead commentors suggest it goes off every 15 seconds

#

they posted a link to a log that i can see but i cant make out details

#

they claim it did 20 m healing in a 20 key and its secretly pog for high keys

lusty grotto
#

LMAO

tribal wharf
#

no rally

lusty grotto
#

i aint doubting some dumbass posted that shit

#

its just funny

tribal wharf
#

By violintides (2,950 – 9·14) on 2023/11/27 (Patch 10.2.0)
Does anyone know the PPM for this? Is there an Internal cooldown that isn't listed somewhere? Or is it mob-specific? It feels like, since I just got one in the new M+ season, that it's proc'ing constantly. It seems like it's approximately a 15s internal cooldown, based on this in my logs from this M+
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/7vBkNArZFXHKtM6L#fight=last&type=auras&source=2&ability=429268&start=7456866&end=7516270

However, healing for 10million over the course of a 20? Feels like a hidden pog trinket for high key tanks.
Last edited by violintides on 2023/11/27 (Patch 10.2.0)

#

10 m healing for a 20, im sorry, probably all over healing

lusty grotto
#

this log doesnt even have data

#

lmaoooo

#

i gotta say well played to that person cause thats a great bait

tribal wharf
#

it says the spiders come in and melee fro about 5-10k dmg and can crit

lusty grotto
#

yeah and i can say im a brain surgeon in here

#

its bullshit

#

open the log

#

it has nothing

#

might as well put a rickroll in there

tribal wharf
#

thats what im saying

#

where log

#

wowhead commentor

lusty grotto
#

classic wowhead commentator, yea

tribal wharf
#

its probably amazing or at least okay on bdk or bear or some other tank you dont always sit at 99% hp

warm plinth
#

He's not even wearing the trinket in the log he posted lol

#

He's wearing stonescales and splinter

tribal wharf
#

is this 2000 iq yogi vault bait

#

pre placed months in advance

#

for me to fall in to trap

lusty grotto
#

seems like it

tribal wharf
#

not l ike nighmare shell is any better

#

and i have a 489 weapon but this one is terribl stats

lusty grotto
#

just socket

#

like i did on all my active chars

tribal wharf
#

eggs are expensive in 2024

lusty grotto
#

and pretty soon ill have to get the gold bags

tribal wharf
#

i have been given a gift

warm plinth
#

I can't even find a log with that trinket being used lol

tribal wharf
#

i c an be worst first 489 un hatched eggs

#

they must be hatched

warm plinth
#

take it for science yogi (don't)

tribal wharf
#

nightmare shell have leech

#

hold the fuck on

lusty grotto
#

still socket

tribal wharf
#

nah, egg

lusty grotto
#

well, chat, i tried

#

i knew it wasnt gonna work

#

but i tried

#

1 day yogi will listen to us

#

but today is not that day

warm plinth
lusty grotto
#

xD

tribal wharf
#

if unhatched was leech too that would be amazing

lusty grotto
#

nope

#

still garbo

tribal wharf
#

non egg haver

lusty grotto
#

rather have the gold bag tbh

brittle sandal
#

Hello! Im new to tanking, wanted to ask what is the "easiest" tank to learn? Druid i know but feels dull, how is warrior? Is it rather easy to learn? How do I play it? Not full story but guidelines maybe

lusty grotto
#

sure

#

icy veins should have a guide on it

warm plinth
#

hmmm

brittle sandal
lusty grotto
warm plinth
#

probably better than egg shell right lol

#

Or maybe even counterweight idk

#

My trinkets are ass

#

TO THE ROBOT

tribal wharf
#

i thinhk im just gunna take the leech egg hate egg

lusty grotto
#

🤷

#

ive said socket like 3 times now but it is what it is

#

you do you, yogi, you do you

warm plinth
#

Spores > egg shell

tribal wharf
#

on use

warm plinth
#

1300 dps better on ST keks

waxen frigate
#

Whoa that’s crazy @jagged pier

tribal wharf
#

no clowns

#

so anyways, back to which egg i shoudl choose....

blazing condor
#

Surely one day

jagged pier
#

Surely

warm plinth
#

I never jest

#

And don't call me Shirley

lusty grotto
#

airplane is such a classic

#

or is that

#

naked gun?

blazing condor
#

One of those movies

lusty grotto
#

they are all fucking great

#

police squad maybe?

blazing condor
#

Think its airplane

#

Actually idk

warm plinth
lusty grotto
#

one of my favorites

#

anything with leslie nielsen is fucking gold

jagged pier
tribal wharf
#

time to hatch some eggs

lusty grotto
#

k

waxen frigate
tribal wharf
#

could reach 1.6 million hp if i had higher ilv peices

waxen frigate
tribal wharf
#

nah, mastery

#

haste mastery HR

waxen frigate
#

Gives you HP and DR

lusty grotto
#

nish never change

vestal moat
#

colossus warrior talents up

lusty grotto
#

its time @waxen frigate

waxen frigate
#

Time to what

lusty grotto
#

to confirm or deny the leak

waxen frigate
#

Yeah it was in fact fake

lusty grotto
#

thank fucking god

#

i was reading these talents and i was like

vestal moat
#

Nothings really jumping out at me, the activatable ability sort of reminds me of the Neltharion legendary artifact ability from legion.

tribal wharf
#

do

lusty grotto
#

tf is with their fixation on shockwave

tribal wharf
#

the fuckin same

#

withe the silence thing

lusty grotto
#

but thank god i read that top left

tribal wharf
#

god damnit blizzard

lusty grotto
#

yeah idk

#

seems lackluster

tribal wharf
#

not out in timbuktoo talnets

vestal moat
#

i do like the shockwave knockup as a bit more utility in m+. but tnohing earthaterring. just seems to be a lot of stat increases. no playstyle change

waxen frigate
#

Literally all of these are lame as fuck lol

lusty grotto
#

the shockwave move is pretty decent

waxen frigate
#

The rogue one is awful

lusty grotto
#

but its not even

waxen frigate
#

For outlaw at least

lusty grotto
#

its not even a hero talent

#

so idk

vestal moat
#

i hope the shockwave thing is a knockup instead of stun, not both. dont want stun DR

lusty grotto
#

well

#

the problem is you have to go colossus for just that one

#

idk

tribal wharf
#

rogue is always omegalul until it gets kings wft warrior shout and other buffs and then is allowed to activate snd and just attack boss all game

#

then its 10 billion dps

lusty grotto
#

lots of revenge damage increases

#

:\

tribal wharf
#

where do i go to see it

lusty grotto
#

wowhead

#

or mmo-c idk

#

but yeah im with Nish

#

this is super mid

#

passive increases, super unremarkable

median tulip
#

Developer’s Note: The Warrior tree will be updated in the War Within to make the Shockwave talent more easily accessible via class talents.

tribal wharf
lusty grotto
#

oh well

#

at least its not lightsmith

#

LMAO

#

Templar sounds badass

tribal wharf
#

how about buff to defensive stance within this tree

#

if its not already i havent fully read it

lusty grotto
#

and Hammer of Light sounds pretty great

knotty pewter
lusty grotto
#

15% SS damage sounds kinda poggers at least

median tulip
#

10% to increase to Critical Blocks is a bit... Ehh.

Not bad forwhen Spell Block is up tho

lusty grotto
#

and CC immunity on Demolish could have some play

#

we will see

strong forum
#

its Basically Nelth Fury / Fyralath on use

#

but with CDR built in

vestal moat
#

THe wording reads "shockwave ALSO knocks" instead of "shockwave knocks up INSTEAD" which is what is making me nervous

lusty grotto
#

yeah pretty much

strong forum
#

and shockwave is knockup now

#

very nice

#

pretty good hero talents for aoe/m+

median tulip
#

Knockup is on a different DR to stun, right?

strong forum
#

yes

plush tendon
#

its says also though

#

wording a bit confusing tbh

strong forum
#

blizz toolitps

lusty grotto
#

it could be like warbringer

plush tendon
#

but knocking and stunning would be weird

kind glen
#

You get to be 5% bigger tho, so its best for sure

lusty grotto
#

well its a double stop so

median tulip
plush tendon
#

bis

kind glen
#

Mountain Thane who? yeah Colossi unite!

plush tendon
#

yea, Colossus seems cooler to me

knotty pewter
#

unstoppable force on tree boss dht. that would be somethin

lusty grotto
#

its def growing on me

#

i think

#

there was way too much expectation on utility, when they explicitly said these hero talents werent gonna be total game changers

strong forum
#

will see

#

so far i like colossus

#

mountain thane i half forgot what it did

#

but it was more ST oriented i think

#

and colossus is more aoe oriented

lusty grotto
#

only thing i remember about MT is the spell shield wish.com safeguard

strong forum
#

a really weak one

vestal moat
#

super weak

strong forum
#

yea

lusty grotto
#

yea

waxen frigate
#

Mountain thane looked giga

#

Colossus looks less giga

#

But that’s initial numbers, not meaningful

vestal moat
#

colossus all the way for prot for me as things stand at least in keys

plush tendon
#

Mountain Thane was a lot of Thunderclap

#

and changing damage to storm/lightning damage

lusty grotto
#

right right

plush tendon
#

this seems to have more emphasis on SS and Revenge and getting these big Demolishes

torn gulch
#

Developer’s Note: The Warrior tree will be updated in the War Within to make the Shockwave talent more easily accessible via class talents.
We wanted to call this out as the Colossus tree interacts with Shockwave in a few places.
At last

lusty grotto
#

yes, we know

jagged pier
#

Gunna get a fair few ppl saying thay

lusty grotto
#

right

median tulip
#

Yeah that it itself, regardless of which hero tree we take, is a huge buff for M+

jagged pier
#

Depends where they put it tbh

median tulip
#

Hopefully that implement that for S4

jagged pier
#

And how the change the tree

torn gulch
#

season 4 is like 1 dev and 1 intern

#

or 2 interns

plush tendon
#

at least they are differnet

torn gulch
#

kekw

plush tendon
#

can play like a storm lord warrior with Mountain Thane

median tulip
#

Hush, let me huff this hopium

kind glen
#

Bring back necro banner

lusty grotto
plush tendon
#

or a big hitter colossus dude

median tulip
plush tendon
#

naw man, I want Aftershock

kind glen
#

I was NF in SL, so I miss it

plush tendon
#

but I already think the bottom of the warrior tree shouldve been Droar/Spear/AA/Banner

#

choose 2/4

karmic plinth
#

i think condemn could have been cool Condemned

tribal wharf
#

got a nice amount of hp now

#

over 1.5 m and 69 🙂

kind glen
karmic plinth
#

feel like demolish should have just been an upgrade to shield charge / colossus smash or something not really in the mood for another keybind

pallid quiver
#

Me at first: "Well, I really do like the aesthetic and thematic feel of Mountain Thane more, bu-"

#

size increased you say

waxen frigate
#

If demolish roots you during cast

#

Cringe

pallid quiver
#

i think colossus may be the best hero talent tree

plush tendon
#

the size increase alone

#

makes it the best

pallid quiver
#

time to fit through even LESS doors

plush tendon
#

but I think they are tying visuals and stuff to each hero tree

#

like Mountain Thane abilities turn blue/lightning affects

knotty pewter
#

there should be a coordinated effort to buff that to 10% increased size

pallid quiver
#

I will take any increased size, so I agree

#

Make it even bigger

plush tendon
#

Size increase should scale with our crit chance

jagged pier
#

All fun and games till u get stuck in a door

waxen frigate
tribal wharf
#

now u see

chrome falcon
#

colossus looks pretty great

tribal wharf
#

thats why u buy the murloc toy

lusty grotto
#

just spit on the door

chrome falcon
#

shockwave stonks big

tribal wharf
#

then ur always as big as a gnome even with size

#

which a gnome cant get stuck in any doors

#

has the easiest time going through any doors

plush tendon
#

Im actually curious where shockwave ends up on the talent tree

lusty grotto
#

based on what they said

toxic pewter
#

i am goin colossus

#

i need that size

lusty grotto
#

it wont be lower than it already is, at least

toxic pewter
#

I think colossus seems cooler than thane

lusty grotto
#

sup apb

#

hows life treating you

pallid quiver
karmic plinth
toxic pewter
#

also been pvping only

#

arms warr solo shuffle

lusty grotto
karmic plinth
#

no theyd put a different capstone there

waxen frigate
#

Banner

lusty grotto
toxic pewter
#

shockwave talent shift only change we getting

#

lol

lusty grotto
#

well thats a change that brings other changes

toxic pewter
#

i will take it

lusty grotto
#

so its actually significant

toxic pewter
#

yeah it is

karmic plinth
#

id like to see aftershock in shockwaves place but that might be a bit TOO much control so maybe something boring like condemn would take its place

lusty grotto
#

unless they rebuff execute

toxic pewter
#

I wonder if we can use demolish channel while stunned

#

prob not right

lusty grotto
#

no thanks to condemn

toxic pewter
#

just during the channel

lusty grotto
#

and id rather have banner than AF

#

id rather have banner than 10 AFs

#

maybe 20

#

maybe even 100 AFs

#

we will see what happens

kind glen
#

hear me out, give us a BL

lusty grotto
#

sure

karmic plinth
#

i wouldnt be surprised if they trolled us and gave us banner but no glory

#

looking at elysian might id not be surprised if we had a nerfed version of it too

lusty grotto
#

hmmm

kind glen
#

From an ability aspect I'd like to use spear more, but TR is pretty awesome

lusty grotto
#

i mean you right a nerfed glory would def feel bad

kind glen
#

I think no glory would make it another dead talent

lusty grotto
#

but how would they nerf it

#

it might yea

karmic plinth
#

i reckon theyd go for the rage cost for extension

lusty grotto
#

or cap it

karmic plinth
#

youd hope theyd actually just go for parity with SL rage economy

karmic plinth
#

the thought hadnt crossed my mind

lusty grotto
#

idk, it wouldnt make sense to have glory in while being nerfed tbh

#

its perfect synergy

kind glen
#

I mean, I understand not wanting it up an entire dungeon, I think that was a bit much. but a useful "go go team" button would be fun thematically

lusty grotto
#

not sure why they wouldnt want that

karmic plinth
#

i wouldnt be surprised if they copied the tyrs deliverance model

#

1.5m CD for 70s uptime

#

seeing as they changed roar and spear to be 1.5m too

lusty grotto
#

only reason to baby nerf it (which will end up killing it anyway) that occurs to me is to make it easier for less skilled people or some shit

karmic plinth
#

we're porbably overdue a talent tree overhaul anyway

lusty grotto
#

well moving shockwave in itself is a mini overhaul

karmic plinth
#

while theyre there they might go the whole way

plush tendon
#

spear needs some love

#

its actually a really fun ability

#

more fun then DRoar

#

DRoar boring as poop

karmic plinth
#

i feel like spear should have been a 45s cd

plush tendon
#

Spear is siq

#

and the tether part, although troll sometimes, can be super good in certain situations

kind glen
#

The visual update too is awesome imo lol

uneven mason
#

Make spear a grip

#

Make roar a knockdown

plush tendon
#

DRoar is basically pressing a 1 min CD TClap in my eyes

uneven mason
#

You're not wrong

maiden ravine
#

being 5% bigger is bis

kind glen
maiden ravine
#

my gnome will look so ferocious

tribal wharf
#

okay for scient i run wcm 16 with 489 unhatched eggs

#

will report

vestal moat
#

keep us updated, that leech oughta be huge

kind glen
#

I play Tauren, so I'm stoked to get even more stuck

tribal wharf
#

i took the hp one instead

#

should have took the leech one :S

granite anvil
#

I kinda like the new ability and possible cheeses to mechanics, but then I remember that the other tree has magic intervene 😦

I wish that would have been a normal talent and not part of hero talents

kind glen
#

Someone with a cool colored name said the intervene kinda meh

ionic fern
#

With current tuning it's kinda meh, jeah.

#

Think it was "3x your armor".

#

I generally liked the whole thunder focused theme of MT.

#

But this tree is also looking promising and potentially more interesting gameplay wise due to a new ability.

maiden ravine
#

also, is the 15% more IP gonna be additive or multiplicative?

median tulip
maiden ravine
#

this is the avatar tree no?

kind glen
#

I was hoping additive. That would put it to 65%, correct?

maiden ravine
#

sorta

lusty grotto
#

doubtful

#

there's no way its gonna be additive

#

we dont really need any more defensiveness

granite anvil
#

I read it as a higher amount in total

median tulip
#

I don't think more IP is a particularly enticing talent TBQH

lusty grotto
#

☝️

kind glen
#

the other one sounded worse

maiden ravine
#

65% IP would be awesome

lusty grotto
#

why

#

you already have dstance, spell block, demo

maiden ravine
#

57.5% would be fine too though

kind glen
#

I think it's kinda meh overall

#

both of them

lusty grotto
#

kinda weird that you would focus on that instead of the rest tbh

median tulip
#

2s of Second Wind is pretty big

#

12% of your HP

kind glen
#

need to know proc rate

median tulip
#

Yeah, and the ICD

kind glen
#

because if it procs while full hp then its useless

lusty grotto
#

you know thats gonna happen

#

100%

kind glen
#

Which is why i dont care about it lol

lusty grotto
#

blizzard logic

kind glen
#

Maybe something like the auto Frenzied regen but at a high HP amount would make it better to me

plush tendon
#

what I gotta figure out is how big Ill be when I press avatar and stoneform together with 5% extra size

compact palm
#

Is the Shockwave knock low key the best part of this tree

kind glen
#

no

#

the 5% size is

lusty grotto
median tulip
#

Increased Critical Block is... ok, I guess, but mostly for Spell Block. It's not going to make me stack Mastery.

lusty grotto
#

jesus fuck

median tulip
#

20% extra Bleed damage is nice

lusty grotto
#

yeah plenty to go around

#

SS increase etc

knotty pewter
grand veldt
#

yeah that movement immune and 2s bonus to schokwave

#

really like that

compact palm
#

True just thinking having a cc that doesn't Dr would be nice

median tulip
#

Wonder how long the channel on Demolish is

knotty pewter
#

just depends on encounter/dungeon design

compact palm
#

Would be better if it acts like Aug knock ancld groups them

kind glen
#

Thats the benefit of knock up, yeah? the no DR interaction?

knotty pewter
#

oh the knock is really good too. stun dr is bitch

lusty grotto
#

it'll still contribute to stun dr

#

theres nothing in that tooltip that says otherwise

knotty pewter
#

right

#

but it ignores it

median tulip
knotty pewter
#

you get a knock

kind glen
#

I was more talking about Knock up as an affect

compact palm
#

Yea the stun portion but u will still knock them

lusty grotto
#

i mentioned we will see if its like warbringer but even warbringer's tooltip didnt say anything concerning DRs

#

the knock happens in tandem

#

so while

knotty pewter
#

thats fine

lusty grotto
#

stun dr isnt affecting that part

#

you're still contributing to stun dr

knotty pewter
#

yeah. so

#

Sfury, legsweep, cap totem

#

then you shockwave

kind glen
#

I mean it's not like you lead with SW anyway

lusty grotto
#

so ideally you want to use it dead last in a dr chain

knotty pewter
#

and the knock works

toxic pewter
#

What’s the point of knocking up and stunning

compact palm
#

More of a if I use this late in pull its still gunna stop thigs kinda deal

knotty pewter
#

thats what im talking about

lusty grotto
#

not a lot of people think about DRs when sending it

#

so that's a problem

#

maybe not for you and me

#

because we're tracking them

#

and we know when we would use them

knotty pewter
#

yeah, im just thinking about my gameplay

#

its made even worse with all the other stuff that randomly stuns

lusty grotto
#

keep in mind this is also available to arms

knotty pewter
#

like shield charge and demo kick

compact palm
#

Most groups don't have a bunch of aoe stuns anyway anymore

lusty grotto
#

uhhh

#

HDH alone has 2

median tulip
knotty pewter
#

it is less common in the more meta comps

lusty grotto
#

and one of them they will absolutely fucking send cause its meta

#

literally their dps cd

kind glen
#

but I think the damage will outweigh the bleed damage, especially since it looks like it stacks quickly

compact palm
#

Yea but havoc is a outlier there not the general

lusty grotto
#

how many stuns do you think a DR takes

#

its not 5

knotty pewter
#

its 3

#

and he isnt wrong

lusty grotto
#

so no, HDH is not an outlier

compact palm
#

I'm aware

knotty pewter
#

aoe stuns arennt that common in the meta comps

lusty grotto
#

neither are we

#

so why consider meta comps at all

kind glen
knotty pewter
#

i feel like youre just eager to argue lol

median tulip
#

TBH I'm mostly used to watching piss-poor Havoc players kill themselves

wild hemlock
#

so whats the verdict, boys

kind glen
#

For me, it's the knock up

median tulip
wild hemlock
#

sorry i only want yogis opinion

#

forgot to mention that

lusty grotto
median tulip
#

@tribal wharf

maiden fern
#

5% increased size

#

gg boys

lusty grotto
#

youre not yogi sorry

urban bane
#

5% larger LETSGOOO

maiden fern
#

YES!

plush tendon
#

its a good tree

#

I like it

wild hemlock
#

@azure forum i miss u

#

i miss it here 😦

lusty grotto
#

thats not him

#

@tribal wharf is

tribal wharf
plush tendon
#

though I do wonder how long the Demolish channel is

tribal wharf
#

out of 22 minutes

wild hemlock
#

yogi is that u

lusty grotto
#

wasnt that account slated for deletion yogi?

median tulip
tribal wharf
#

for time up, i didnt check how much it healed or dmg it did

wild hemlock
plush tendon
#

like another 10% size would be reasonable

tribal wharf
#

theres spider dmg

#

healing

#

vague memory

lusty grotto
#

ty yogi

#

still trash

#

should have taken the socket

kind glen
#

^

tribal wharf
#

but then i didnt

lusty grotto
#

why isnt yogi deleted

#

the account

#

didnt you said it was slated for deletion?

#

this is the important question

#

anyway, a friend was tagging you and you didnt say hi back

tribal wharf
#

im migrating away from that user name

#

it stuck too hard

sick sentinel
#

Deathray is yogi?

lusty grotto
#

well

#

WERE STILL CALLING YOU YOGI

#

so thats not going away

#

ever

sick sentinel
#

Yogi is yogi

lusty grotto
#

its a good name

tribal wharf
#

deathray has always been my callsign

lusty grotto
#

deathray isnt

#

ok yogi

sick sentinel
#

Deathray is a DH name

tribal wharf
#

dk you'd think really

#

maybe monk

sick sentinel
#

They do not spawn rays or beams

#

Neither does monk

lusty grotto
#

nah it stinks of edgelord

sick sentinel
#

Deathray deffo a DH name

tribal wharf
#

this is a ray, like a bullet / laser

#

star trek phaser

tribal wharf
#

this, something a bit like this

#

i had to come up with a name couldnt think of anything better

#

i was like, 15-18 at the time dont shame me

sick sentinel
tribal wharf
#

also this deathray, very very very very storng deathray

#

excellent base defens

lusty grotto
#

good shit yogi

sick sentinel
#

Deathray is a beam = eyebeam

tribal wharf
#

everyone gangster until they see the obelisk of light poewrin up

waxen frigate
#

If death is part of it

#

How can you be more death

kind glen
#

depends on what amount of death it deals

tribal wharf
#

that friggin structer is like, INSTANT death

tribal wharf
#

instantantly vaporized human body

lusty grotto
#

what about double instant death?

waxen frigate
#

!

tribal wharf
#

like, 1 frame in a video game

waxen frigate
kind glen
#

frame perfect death

tribal wharf
#

so i can speak everyones language 100- 0

waxen frigate
#

Yogi what do you think of this heavy whipping cream bottle

tribal wharf
#

hmm

#

i need to send out more wood choppers in wc2 later....

#

never enough lumber

lusty grotto
#

ghosted nish

wild sentinel
#

do prot warriors stay in defense stance or do they juggle between

lusty grotto
#

mostly battle stance

#

but yes we juggle

waxen frigate
tribal wharf
#

i dunno how i feel about that sorry

lusty grotto
#

would you say

kind glen
#

I wonder if theyll ever force dstance upon us

#

I hope not

lusty grotto
#

its a very cozy but stylish whipping cream bottle?

waxen frigate
lusty grotto
#

would that be accurate to you yogi?

tribal wharf
#

i dont use heavy cream sorry

lusty grotto
#

ah

tribal wharf
#

not a coffee perseon

lusty grotto
#

understandable

maiden ravine
#

I'm kinda shocked stances haven't been pruned again yet

#

they've been rather minor all things considered

waxen frigate
tribal wharf
#

i dont understand why they didnt add fury stance for dps specs

toxic pewter
#

did somebody say stances

waxen frigate
#

It’s just a nice defensive

kind glen
#

They keep trying to make dstance more enticing

maiden ravine
#

fury has fury stance haha

lusty grotto
#

berserking stance is part of the fury kit

tribal wharf
#

hmm i have to see this

#

oh, i figured it would be battle and fury

maiden ravine
#

I really hope the colossus ability looks amazing

lusty grotto
#

well, they did too on the DF ptr, but there was no real reason to have a talent point into both

kind glen
lusty grotto
#

an obligatory talent point mind you

zinc iris
#

Ok but

#

Size bis stat

tribal wharf
#

defensive stance could be additional 10-30% protection agianst damage over time ticks

lusty karma
#

Thoughts on Colossus? Seems like a reskinned/renamed Legion artifact power (was also a channel) with more usefulness baked in. I kinda like the tree but some things have me whelmed, wonder if the play will be not to use Demolish (unless it hits insanely hard) to keep up buff instead for 20% bleed damage

wild hemlock
#

holy fuck do i miss necro banner

tribal wharf
#

yes but no i miss sl pwar kit

#

dark times

lusty karma
#

The healing of Second Wind doesn't seem bad, 12% health over 2s, could be OP

wild hemlock
#

s4 prot warrior was so fun lol

sick sentinel
#

I miss night fae Fury Warrior

lusty grotto
#

nome and mwahi will pin shit shortly im sure

sick sentinel
#

Shadowlands was goated expansion

wild hemlock
#

i ran NF prot for awhile s3 lol

sick sentinel
#

SL > DF

wild hemlock
#

warriors were down bad lol

waxen frigate
warm plinth
#

Colossus looks fun

waxen frigate
#

Pwarr was second best tank in s3/4

#

Just so hard to play well that it wasn’t worth

tribal wharf
#

i might get ahead on war resources this expansion for once

waxen frigate
#

And if not played well then yeah it sucked

tribal wharf
#

only 43.3k to get everything i c an with them, thats a ton of wq though

sick sentinel
#

Pwar is and always will be the best tank in the game it just needs some love from Blizztard

warm plinth
#

What love

wild hemlock
lusty grotto
#

dunno ghash

wild hemlock
#

how werent we down bad

lusty grotto
#

guy said SL was a goated expansion, what do you expect

sick sentinel
wild hemlock
#

did u play sl?

waxen frigate
#

?

lusty grotto
#

banner play was pretty great though ngl, we all agree here

waxen frigate
#

How does that change what I said

#

Define “down bad”

#

Pwarr was definitely not weak

sick sentinel
#

I won't lie, I preffered SL to DF expansion wise but gameplay wise ofc DF is better, Dragons are just too cuddly and nicey nice

wild hemlock
#

we were by far worst tank lol

warm plinth
#

I don't even remember the last time pwar was bad

waxen frigate
tribal wharf
#

9.0 was scary times for pwar

#

i didnt even get ksm

lusty grotto
#

it doesnt matter if dragons are cuddly, nothing is worse than dumpster-fire-lands

wild hemlock
waxen frigate
#

No

#

That’s me

tribal wharf
#

the problem with shadowlands was it just wasnt done correctly

warm plinth
#

I enjoyed shadowlands myself. I think the dungeon pool was better than dragonflight's

tribal wharf
#

everything weas speerated and weird and different

waxen frigate
lusty grotto
#

☝️

sick sentinel
#

Shadowlands covenants and such made it bad, But genereally, the dungeons were better and I would even say the raids were better imo

waxen frigate
#

Go back to doing the same dungeons with changing affixes

warm plinth
#

Well I meant the actual expansion dungeons

waxen frigate
#

Maybe sprinkle in some change

sick sentinel
#

Atleast Nathria was goated

waxen frigate
#

Nathria ruled

lusty grotto
#

raids were decent, and there's nothing that beats CN

waxen frigate
#

But I also liked VotI

tribal wharf
#

you look at bastian or night fae land and its good in a vaccum

warm plinth
#

DF dungeons are mostly bad

tribal wharf
#

but it doesnt fit the rest of the ghame

lusty grotto
waxen frigate
#

Brackenhide and AA are good. RLP is pretty good.

sick sentinel
#

Nathria > SoD > DF raids > Sepulcher

lusty grotto
#

the rest of DF dungeons are great

waxen frigate
sick sentinel
#

Fuck nokhud

warm plinth
#

HoI is the 2nd worst M+ dungeon they've ever made

lusty grotto
#

nish youve been around

#

you know i fucking love nokhud

sick sentinel
#

Any dungeon that requires dragonriding i hate

#

Dragonriding sucks

lusty grotto
#

whats that?

#

...

warm plinth
#

Lol

waxen frigate
#

And yogi

lusty grotto
#

okay his opinions are now invalid for the rest of this discussion

warm plinth
#

Now that is 100% an unpopular opinion

tribal wharf
#

will be be going under the water as well as under the earth in expansion?

tribal wharf
#

like, we dig so far in we find water and aliens basically

wild hemlock
#

that was a weird statement

#

holy shit

sick sentinel
lusty grotto
#

what

warm plinth
#

Dragonriding bug?

tribal wharf
#

the disconnect

wild hemlock
#

nish is worked up lol

sick sentinel
#

When you just fly straight into nowhere and DC

tribal wharf
#

im sure of it

sick sentinel
#

That shit has bricked so many of my nokhuds

warm plinth
#

I never had that happen. That's unfortunate.

lusty grotto
#

tf?

tribal wharf
#

cuz i randomly get the dc flying bug too and its like whatever but its annoying

waxen frigate
lusty grotto
#

ive never had that happen either

sick sentinel
#

I've had it happen at least 10 times

tribal wharf
#

you are just flying and then you arent cuz you get logged out

warm plinth
#

My main issue with it was that you had no real choices when it came to trash

tribal wharf
#

and then u log back in and its fine, thats all is too it

lusty grotto
#

thats not what hes talking about yogi

sick sentinel
#

But I had more people who just can't fly properly so we are 3-4 men on trash before bosses

lusty grotto
#

that shouldn't be the case any more

#

people know how to fly

warm plinth
#

Linear dungeons are a thing and are fine from time to time but don't make this huge sprawling dungeon and then make us kill specific shit

tribal wharf
#

oh? hes talking about dragon fling mount dungeon aint he

sick sentinel
#

That's why I hate dragonriding, Pre season 1 it sucked ass, But now it's okay

lusty grotto
#

otherwise tindral wouldn't be beaten in any difficulty

sick sentinel
lusty grotto
#

i never had any problems with people flying in nokhud

waxen frigate
lusty grotto
#

ever

waxen frigate
#

Did you watch RWF

#

There are people who absolutely can’t do Dragonriding to save their lives

sick sentinel
lusty grotto
#

thats a sidepoint nish

#

oh

#

you got banned

#

now it all makes sense

tribal wharf
#

hot take

lusty grotto
#

anyway nish this guy is saying HE BRICKED keys because people couldnt fly

sick sentinel
#

In LFR cause I called a mage a dumbass for triggering the frog about 20 times and people asked dathea tactics to which i wrote " Kill boss, Kill adds" then guess what 2 week suspension

lusty grotto
#

that is just not something that happens

#

you cant compare that to RWF

tribal wharf
#

i think whoever made the dragon flying hard mode stuff designed it for a controller probably

sick sentinel
#

I had keys bricked cause of the flying bug and people just flying stupidly

#

That's just why I hate nokhud

tribal wharf
#

like those races

lusty grotto
#

sure you got banned for calling a mage names

#

sure sure

warm plinth
#

I'm the luckiest player alive

lusty grotto
#

its not like they do warnings first

#

or anything

sick sentinel
lusty grotto
#

just plain ole ban

waxen frigate
lusty grotto
#

now that's a good one

warm plinth
#

9 times out of 10 you catch a silence for language, not a ban.

lusty grotto
#

yeah thats what i meant

sick sentinel
#

I have never been silenced only banned

lusty grotto
#

so repeated offender

#

basically