#protection
1 messages · Page 853 of 1
running to the seed
and got obliterated by roar

Okay it was worth
I got Gholak
Nice
Do you send rageheart in big pulls?
Just for the dps?
Or do you wanna use it defensively exclusively
Is a 476 ghholack better than using a 489 weap for m+ or nah?
im guessing no, but idk how valuable gholack is
is there ever a point where you dont keep stacking haste?
I dont have Gholak on my Warr but my Frost DK and it does around 1 mil on a heroic boss
Its pretty good
do we now anything about leggo yet, do we turn loot spec to arms only on last or the whole raid?
oh, nice to hear, thank you!
The objective is to luck into it before your MDPS and watch them peel their faces off, savouring the agony
is there a reason to craft embelish on wrists in particular?
got myth wrists from raid with crit haste, so feel like it may be better to do diff piece
Crafted gear caps 3 ilvls below max.
So you want the embels for the damij
But on your lowest stat budget items
So the actual raw stats you lose is as low as possible.
ah makes sense, if i got myth track wrists with crit haste though and have lower other pieces think its worth putting on something else?
and just swapping it to wrists later once im myth gear out
Only if you can afford juggling the crafted slot
I'm just setting it, maxing it, and mentally checking out
gold isnt a big issue
Then yes, it's probably better, but you might be dropping tens of thousands for less than +1000 DPS
alright, thanks 🙂
Is it normal I'm thinking of taking token vault #2 ?
(I'm probably gonna take free ilvl on belt, but still)
Well sounds like you shouldn't take tokens if there's an upgrade... so no
Two of my toons took tokens but I also only have 1 slot for most of my toons
with my Mark of Mastery, is there any reason to NOT get the pvp version of the tier?
shows the same 483 max ilvl
Uh... is it not the upgrade path like last season's?
Last season they were the same olevel but the pvp ones were maxed on their upgrade track and the pve ones weren't
Ilevel
Yeah doesn't seem to matter this time around
ALL of the pvp ones start at 1/6 but i would be getting the gloves anyways
Is there a haste breakpoint or cap I should care about?
no
7100 haste rating is when you'd want to seek out other stats when possible
5400 is not really a breakpoint but it's about where you can run into the fray instead of heavy repercussions
But it requires closer management of shield block
If I have 7100 should I drop into the fray?
No. Into the fray is MORE valuable with more haste, not less
Well before you start changing your items for different stats, you can also change enchants, gems, rune etc
Ofc. I'm far from good gear atm
Ilvl > all for me atm, just wondering. Thanks for your help.
But yeah into the fray is % haste so it's multiplicative. Makes it better the more you have
Guys, do i take Rezans, i already have it on champion
yuh
well u wont be replacing it most likely
i got this from vault 🙂 upgraded it immediately
This might be a stupid question but does the rank of the shadowflame patch effect the damage on the item it's crafted on in anyway?
Only the craft % chance?
Just the difficulty of the craft
Ty
Is it worth taking Gholak, the final conflagration? I heard it's bis but the stats seem funky. It also says shadowfllame suffused
u take it
The other choice worth considering is a helm with a socket
thats not worth it as u can put a socket in any helm later on
Without a doubt
Take the weapon, and pray for a shield soon so you can stop looting vault as prot
Yeah, that's pretty sweet
The 4p might not bring that much dps (or so i've read) but damn it is good qol
4pc definitely makes me feel quite a bit tankier
Vault check
Is Frozen Devotion still the go-to enchant for M+ ?
why is ursine simming so high for ST but mine does about 3.5% of my overall damage where like rezans sims lower but does more
It's bugged apparently
like the sim is bugged or the trinket? becasue i know for my friend its hits were doing like 24k and mine do 13k
IG*
Blizz claims they fixed it but IIRC the trinket just turns itself off
weird lol
So you stack it up for 90s and then it just turns off the damage early
i mean my hits are just half of my friends for some reason
no
it sims correctly
but its bugged so it doesnt work like that
is it just bugged for warrior?
its bugged for everyone
Hi - I currently have 2 piece tier. Do I take legs here despite lower ilvl and then convert an existing piece to tier to get 4pce? Sorry I'm a bit noob
Then what is ? Pins mention single-target or defense

If you raid, wait for the reclear before picking legs
do we need to be in Arms / Fury loot spec to get a chance at weapon or prot will also show it? meaning is the chance Class based or Spec based?
I asked this in arms channel but wanted to be sure some prot lads got chance at ait
According to Blizzard, any spec.
leggo any spec
"Fyr’alath can be obtained with any loot specialization for Death Knights, Paladins, and Warriors by defeating Fyrakk within the heart of Amirdrassil on all difficulties"
@jagged pier don't you love fresh new season
6900 vault questions
420 legendary questions
0 people simming
omg you guys should I take choice #1:[hero path upgrade I will replace in 2 weeks] or choice #2:[champ path upgrade I will replace in 2 days]
God gave us sockets
So we can at least unfuck like 4-5 vault weeks
yer no i took tmog
no
Just did 24 DHT and BRH
Felt p good with 4 set
Take this with a grain of salt because there was some tomfoolery with DPS missing kicks
If only there was a simple setting to sim and give you an overall M+ score
yer because setting patchwerk to 5 targets and change the time then unticking all the buffs is really hard to do
like super hard
How representative is it of a M+ run where you alternate big/small packs, runtime, then bosses ?
well on average im pulling about 4-5 mobs
at around 1-1:30 combat time
so kinda of accurate
u can also just sim for ST
because its most likely gunna be an upgrade for aoe
and if its not it wont be that much different
and u want to focus on ST more in m+ anyway for bosses etc
you guys trying and over think everything
its really kinda simple
Mind you, sims and guides, across the whole game, make us overthink everything
Like “this small minor parameter matters” everywhere
“it doesn’t matter that much” is far from your common line in any guide about any spec or any encounter
Same, i feel you
what? my line in any guide?? i dont write guides?
btw. can we cause any nature damage as prot regarding the rare neck?
It’s a figure of speech
already have myhtic hands, the trinket seems meh, pips and the 1hand is ony hc and the ring has no haste either,...
u sim
yeah already running, but the sim would only be a short term upgrade, and I guess it's gonna be pips for DPS specc,... long term this looks like a socket vault to me
I already have myhtic gloves
F
yep
Or take necklace
To save crests
May be a dumb question: raid Loot cant drop in m+ vault, right?
But Not Trinkets/weapons
Correct
So i am Stuck with m+ crap… jay
Raid loot is a lot more deterministic.
Thanks for confirmation
Yes, maybe. Cant stand raiding anymore
Heroic Loot via timewalk it is 😄
i could cry ... second vault and I'm already thinking about taking the 6 tokens....
trasmog > 6 tokens
already got that 😉
i dunno pip or token then i guess
we dont do wordle anymore
what loot spec do we need to have for Rageheart in our box?
prot
thanks mate, didnt want to fuck that up haha
i mean yeah thats what ill take
true true
Fuxakes Blizz
cool ring
I guess.
that's a sad vault
coiled serpent isnt terrible
2x shadowflame is best embelish combo ?
ye
so uhm, vault question i've got this . But already 4pc tier set. Should i go for the shoulders to catalise? or Pip's trinket?
i've been wanting to swap old trinket but seeing how much dps i get from M+, dunno if its worth it :S
what dungeon was that?
it usually ranges from 5% to 7% dmg done. think it was thrones of tides?
right so that inflated by the damage buff at the end then
oh
With insta-reset on thunderclap, what deals more dmg and should take prio now, still use revenge or spam thunder?
its the same as its ever been SS > TC
cool thanks
Builder > Spender
Spender I hardly know her
do you guys use a swing timer weakaura on prot?
theres literally no reason to
does the 4 set mechanic work on rezan trinket?
you cant upgrade crests above seasonal limit right
luckily you can still buy the item and keep in bag
so you can still get crests
also are the "bis" items chosen based on sims or just "seems good"
which embelishment do you run for m+? I'm currently running with battle rez bracers but unsure about the second one
oh nice, always thought this counts as emb 😄 dumb me. ty!

so is the mythic red tint for the gloves not working for anyone? i have them and they just appear on character like the (normal, I think?) ones
im not gunna do any catalysts on veteran or champion gear personally
Council is such a cursed fight. I love the rock/paper/scissors aspect of the mobs but I have seen way too many melee deaths eating the bear frontal, that thing thing's a slight nerf in the cast time
only on the hero and myth ones
council is a cool boss but in practice its just chaos lol
even if its "easy"
shit going down and around everywhere
Silly question. If I open the vault with fury loot spec and remain in prot does that mean I’ll get fury tier or will it still be prot? Also good morning!
the tier changes with your spec
But it changes as you swap specs
yeah it makes no difference what spec you are when you obtain tier because it'll just change when you change your spec.
Ya, tier is whatever spec u change to
it doesnt cost anyting
u dont have to get extra parts
Ooooo cool ok thank you
u dont have to re-convert it
i think there should have been parity of point distrbution maybe for number of knowledge
almost done with smith, 80 some points to go, but 60 some extra on engi
Thank you again! I have only the one toon that I pretty much play and they stay prot 100% of the time haha
Good knowledge
Excuse the photo of a screen, my mates checking my vault whilst I’m overseas, but is it always shield here? Regardless of tier?
if udont mythic raid then yes
sorry if it's been asked before, but do we prefer versa wrist or double shadowflame for crafts?
i see people using both
Shadow
But
If you want the vers wrists go for it
Since embellishment for prot is pretty low impact
is there something they are good at separately?
Vers is also defense Shadow is Just damage
Is it really worth stacking more than the 5400 haste for the itf build?
the amount of vers the bracers give
will give u no amount of vers to make a difference
defesnivly at all
aight
Hmmm OK my bad
You got this
Yes. Into the Fray is stronger the more haste you have because it's multiplicative.
5400 haste makes 0 difference in what stats you go for. It just impacts a talent option.
And it should be noted that running ItF means you need to manage your shield block more carefully
7100 is the cap
yeh I go over with sandglass buff
this trinket fucks lol
yes
i dps keys mostly did my first prot key with it. unreal lol
revenge shouldnt be that high tho
it was only a 18 so i was spamming it a lot
Holy augury bro
I mean
right but thats still less damage than playing correctly
Can’t wait to watch the outlaw rouges get that
You should be pressing tclap far more often than revenge
think you missed the part where i said i was a dps. was just sharing the trinket dmg. but thanks for the critique
revenge is usually like 3% of my overall, if that
also dont know what dungeon could have had a lucky proc rate on damage increases
theres lots of them in the new dungeons
and the reason why its so high in your breakdown is due to playing incorrectly, were we all agreeing it does a lot of damage
but it shouldnt be second on your breakdown
Pror war, the second dps...
also just because your dps doesnt mean u should play your off spec incorrectly, hell if i swap i go looking into fury and arms so i know what im doing regardless of lvl of content
I found rageheart to be amazing also, dps is crazy
Am joking - but I am V jealous of the Augury
My guild still trying to get him down in heroic, he's a bitch
didn't expect BRH hast ttrinket to perform so well.
It seems to be about the same as AD's one
Hmm, i passed on that trinket seeing it so low on our list
That's one of the best results I got on it in my current raid run I think
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/gthRWHVYrxj7vBPc#fight=39&type=damage-done&source=1
it's between 6 & 10 % of my damage, or something
doubt it does as well in mm+ overall though, I'll see after I'm done with raid
flat damage trinkets tend to be good for tanks
they represent a higher partial percentage of our total dps than they would for dps specs
Yes, but still expected this one to be weaker
It doesn't have str or
Ye it doesnt
So it's quite a bit weaker than it looks
And it's rppm, so it's rng if you get good procs or not in just 1 fight
Better than what I had though
Had the crit one from manor
just got the branch of tormented ancient from the first boss though, I'll try it out too
taking full bloom with the nature damage debuff kinda hurting
Are you running barbaric training? or is your weapon just that good?
People don't seem to quite grasp
How much losing a trinkets worth of mainstat actually does
They just see big detail bar
Instead of losing a ton of shit everywhere else.
The trinkets effectively stealing damage from other bars. It's not quite as strong as it looks
why people revenge damage so high lol mine is ss and fervid
because they are playing incorrectly
That is very true, still an upgrade for me though
why u guys spamming revenge that is weird and more boring tbh lmao
augary actually doing the damage its supposed to
the player doing far less damage than they are supposed to
i actively try to avoid pressing revenge these days lmao
well according to them because they are dps and it was an 18 🤷

I spam clap a lot. I waste rage sometimes 😦
Just spamming my builders
clap is ok with tier nowadays
And the overcapping
but revenge.. gross..
Damage is damage tho right? If they lose damage on trinket they gain it elsewhere or no?
Lol
Easy parse farm because people are shit and basically no one plays prot warrior
Prot has been soo much fun
I'm a huge parse sl*t
Not judging you
Step up that Game, go log normal full 99s
Or lfr and get some 100s LOL
I got half 99s in normal im working on it
Or be like me I. Shadowlands, and refuse to use the right covenant and legendary
And parse 98 on first mythic kill after a month of prog
Lol
LOL
dr helps I guess but honestly pwar takes basically no damage in the raid in general
all the busters are physical and the dangerous magic stuff can all be spell blocked
Mine was a joke lol, mine sits between 3-5%
i used at least 1 of the new rank 3 healing potions toi try it
didnt really notice too much, i have 10 rank 2 of the new toxic ones but the 3's also cost a ton of gold
2s are fine if you dont want to spend 150g a pop
3s hit me for 800k tho which is baller
i would pay extrra for the main healing potion because its like it only does healing
so its not a gamble if i eat it am i going to die
the dot is 30s long you aren't going to die lol
im not sure, does the healing potions share same cd as this toxic one
yes
could just be bad news if you like use it and then take a bunch of dmg
im not sure, i'll have to try using them
withering are insanely more useful than regular
it seems like more like those potions are better for BDK or something that takes dmg and heals it back, so healers might like it too
depends how much the tick hits for and how often
massive heal now + manageable dot is way way more valuable than a 150k pot that barely moves your healthbar
quick q - if i haven't looted the vault yet, and i do a m+ does it count to next week? Or do i have to loot vault first
Surprisingly ive never had to deal with that before rofl
Yes it counts toward next week.
Awesome ty
Pls help. Will a Adulation Enforcer 489 from a vault be better then a theoretical Gholak, the Final Conflagration from heroic?
the only thing better than a h gholak is an m gholak
Heroic Gholak for the shadowflame bonus
but then it's a theoretical gholak and the weapon in your vault is real
^ thats also VERy true
one in the hand > two in the bush
maybe i'll use it
You could always play Single-Minded Fury 😁
Wow only issues out 1 and then the next to the second highest roller?
i hope that's how it's gonna go
what is the strat to dodge breath on last boss in rise? literally just leap away before its over? does it not follow you?
Shield block
You cant "dodge"
iv heard you can literally leap away and not take anything
Thats a first, and also likely to hit the group
You can le
You can?!
Yes
Hmm, ill have to give that a try
Yeah but you gotta leap the moment you see that cast bar, otherwise you land and still take damage
You have to leap backwards to outrange it, not leap to the side
Macro it with a razer 😀
The breath does track so if you go to the side you'll just spin him
oh ok .. so i have to rethink my tank positioning cause im using too close to the wall
Ill just create a WA that shouts "Leap" lmfao
But the sounds our DPS make are adorable when we do that
kek
They yelp for half a second
Female gnomish warrior has the best audio in game
can we upgrade crests this week or whatever
anyone know
like turn 60 whelp into drake or whatever it is
I can, because I had the achievement last week
What achievement do you need?
Ksm?
Oh have 463 in every slot
Guess I'll be waiting until it decides to give me heroic tier drops
Silly me. Saw he answered his own question.
Isn't that like.....absurd? "You can buy this now that you no longer need it"
It's like Blizzard holding the mentality of those pugs "lfm normal - min ilvl 480"
Not quite; you can trade away whelplings once whelplings no longer have use to you
last week i was struggling on 20s
put 10 ilvls
now i feel invincible
easy affixes too
Good, I feel it's takes a lot for me to forgive Blizzard every time sanguine is a thing.
This week doesn't have affixes
I’ll never forgive them for necrotic
After the nerfs, sanguine doesn't really feel that bad
Outside of volcanic randomly aggroing extra packs
How would volcanic aggro extra packs?
Doesn't matter what they do to it. I have no displacement abilities and I'm sick of having to think 40 steps ahead. 😂
Missed 22EB last night havoc was Inting the whole dungeon and left group on last boss 
On wcm, it can pull the floor above you
Idk how
But it happened twice to my run
i just did a wcm
Oh yeah the buggy things so can boomkin abilities
Can anyone please explain the difference between spell block and spell reflect?
serious question! 🙂
Likewise Wake of Ashes from Retribution Paladin
Spell block mitigates spell dmg by your block value
Spell Reflect reduces magic damage by 25% and can reflect certain spells.
Spell Block just allows you to block the damage of spells in the same way that you Shield Block melee hits.
Thank you both! I ahve been using the spells interchangeably.
not sure if i was doing it wrong
why are lust timings so hard in pugs
Basically splock is for big magic tank Buster
They're like planning to specifically use lust at exactly 3 minutes and 45 seconds into the fight
Sr is, press it because it's CD is miniscule
also does anyone know if spiteful hurts us at all?
like i had pulls where my team died
but spiteful felt like it dealt 0 dmg
when it was on me
Can't target tanks
Spiteful shouldn't ever look at you in the first place
^ explained above
Not actually true, but they never go for us on initial spawn
the onlyl time i have been targeted by spitful is if my dps dies they were targeting
One swing and your rogue was a red puddle
This is a really good week to bring an Arms Warrior along to mythic+
What embellishments this season still double shadowflame patch or?
Yes.
Thanks 🙂
Yes, but that's in the long run. In the short term crafting a good Shield if you don't have one is a solid plan
I was able to upgrade a shield to 476 right away with bis stats on it so I'll probably use my 2 sparks on my two shadowflame items I have from last season
Ohhhh I forgot you can put shadowflame on a shield
That's what I ran all last season. Shame blizz nerfed crafting.
I always put my well fed food bonus on it
It's mostly the extra tiers they added into heroic
They didn't adjust the ilvl of crafted items to accomodate that change and just said "f it"
I have a ring with Alchemical Flavour Pocket on it.
Rings are also good early crafts because the crafted rings always have a socket.
Upgraded my neck lastnight
Because flavor pocket
And primary stat gem
Too cheap to replace it even though I looted a neck from heroic
Crafted Bracers with Vers is a sneaky option 2
Wait we don’t get a 3rd craft this week do we?
Negative, Ghost Rider
No next
Thought so
Prob going neck myself too for flavor pocket
Depends on vault
Might go ring too
Kinda undesirable rings all around as far as arms goes so I’m unsure
High vers rings so far, I feel dirty using them
Yeah we die in 3 hits, not like those puny rogues who get 2 shot
sparks on tyran weeks, catalyst on fort weeks
how do you guys have the gcds to press revenge this much
do most hunters not take misdirect in keys or wat lmao
dps loss for them
dang really
Not really, but they have to trade a bit of utility to get it
They do have binding shot, I have yet to see a hunter use it
How much % better is new tier?
fervid should be higher than revenge thats for sure
revenge is only ever used to get a shield slam reset these days
i pressed a lot during last boss inbetween shield slams and tc
yeah but IP procs the tier at a 90% rate
oh ye ofc
Revenge is the ‘thunderclap didn’t proc now I gotta either press this or I can’t press anything for a sec’
but when i would be overcapping
i just press both revenge and ip
i only use ip for resetting tier when i get a ss reset
also unrelated question
if anyone did the higher key route for atal dazar
after rezan do u just walk the same way?
like i painted it
Man speaking of, the % change fucked me up real good the first time I tried AD last week
By the third extra pack we had to pull for % it started to feel a bit silly
this route has like 99% but u just pull one more raptor or whatever
or can do the pack before totems
and not take any extra flying raptors
meh they don't aoe anymore, they're pretty whatever now
I had to double check, but worst case scenario a hunter is gonna lose 3% move speed to take MD
which was the consensus to sim m+ guys?
v0v my hunter said it's a dps for him and I took him at his word
does anyone know if farming for servent splitter is worth it?
No.
your best wep comes form fyrak
and as 2nd best, it or just crafted ?
Not crafted
i mean normal ghloaks which is easy to pug is better than literally everything pretty much
^^^
Any haste 1h at myth track if you don't raid
It's better than stat weapons at max mythic track
He seems to drop it like skittles
Gholak is nutty
DPS hardly even interrupts I usually sit at 20+ and the next close one is 3 lol
gholak dropped in every hc kill in my guild
i dunno we've had it on 3 or our 4 kills
my luck is horrendous
its week 2
no jokes
Yeah we've had one every kill
ok its a joke
We do alt normal, heroic and a fun normal we're like 7/7
ye
so 2 weeks and a day
Your buddy may actually be right, I'm looking at the builds on both wowhead and IV and frankly they make bad decisions. It is indeed a DPS loss for a BM hunter to take MD, it's just not a DPS loss if you're wasting talents like the guide builders are
Imagine not having a Mwahi to write your guide
I hope it doesn't take a Mwahi to realize that a talent that increases your exe crit damage by 25% is worth more DPS than a 3% run speed buff
Bruh, were the mobility ranged

the guide is written with the general intent of making sure your average hunter can die even just once less per year
alternatively, for optimal ninja pulling prowess
Actually funny enough if you're on the wrong side of the swirlies Fyrakk drops we don't have enough run speed to get out before getting one shot unless you leap it, maybe that 3% makes all the difference in the world (as arms at least)
What’s the “proper” way to tank gnarlroot? I got my first mythic kill yesterday and I got got when adds were up and I had to taunt the boss
these fotm dh's getting on my nerves
idk what was worse, s2 tanks where they would run 3 rooms ahead of the pack and wonder why the party is dying or their s3 dps counterparts doing 3 times more dps than they know how to handle and blowing up every 30 seconds
class is so easy its hard to find a bad dh anyway
Watching DH's die, duh
just had one that refused to kick.. had 2 kicks entire run lol
and it was in muruzonds rise with those annoying volleys and spell casting mobs
To you losing aggro? Or is the dh a tank? I’m confused
The Fyrakk weapon is basically only replaceable by the fyrakk weapon of a higher ilvl, right?
Yes
👍
Isn't kicking a DPS increase for them?
They get like 10 fury or something if they take the talent
It really is, one of the few dungeons that disrupting is locked in, because those packs in the sand can have 4 "fuck your couch" casts lined up at once
Y’all pull the big tree in EB?
Depends if I have a hdh or hunter in the group
He’s so easy though and worth like 8*
%
Just pull him into another pack and you get a 12% pull easy
I get on high fort keys but like I have no trouble with him on a 20
count isnt hard in that dungeon anyway you can just pull one extra pack
Or pull him into a pack you’re already killing and skip a pack entirely
Another pack that doesn't shit silencing zones
count's mega hard because i always forget literally two mobs
It's the same two mobs
every time

they buffed the hell out of mistweaver monk didnt they
just dont 
The patrolls?
im calling the hornets
There's a caster and berserker dude I like to grab while moving towards 2nd boss
i say like to grab
My actions say I don't like to grab them
MW was strong, just no one noticed
Probably my favorite healer this season
monk giga bubble is sure nice
Cocoon is just
for these tankbusters
Resto druids the best cause the boss is dead before the tank busters happen
Yeah if you're lucky enough to have a cat weaving resto
Hotw makes them insane
Getting casters rooted in a silence is pretty cringe, I don't touch that dude
Sounds like a dps issue cause everyone just stacks and aoes and it’s ez
Stacks in silence?
Honestly when I don’t have my cd I really don’t understand how you can not loose aggro, revenge and thunderclap deal so low damages even when I spam them
Stacks for route
Against dh i mean
this is nice and all
I often have to change my target for shield slam and taunt one or two mob
but i want to see it in video form
Like it becomes inefficient on high keys when the roots become hard to dps down before the silence but that should happen till at least a 23 fort
Shouldn’t *
Pug hdh are indeed cringe for hitting all their CD while I'm gathering the mobs
To be fair I think it is more because other tank never loose aggro so they don’t need to wait
It’s not an aggro issue if I haven’t even hit the mobs yet since I’m pulling more
Or at least hit them in a meaningful way
It's this, and I have way less aggro issues on my warrior compared to bdk or vdh
But sometimes I hit mobs with tc and revenge like once of each, but they still take aggro again if I don’t ss the one they focus

And it’s not a gear issue because i have 4p and 472
I don’t know if i am meant to change target so i use ss on the most of mobs
The set bonus does lend itself to this
It depends on the dungeon, like in BRH I was at 115k
Usually i am more around 100k or a little bit less
Should probably be like 20-30k more but that shouldn’t lend itself to big threat issues
But seriously you shouldn't have a ton of aggro issues unless the DPS are just lighting up mobs before your engaged
Which is an issue in pugs for sure
Does it ? Usually auto attack is enough to keep bleed no ?
Wow really ? But I do follow the priority order shown in icy vein I don’t know what can I do better
I will try to log my games
For ss to consume the bleeds
bleeds should be back up when you SS again no?
unless you get 2 back to back SS without using thunderclap
It is not with everyone but there is often at least one mob that takes aggro or sometimes I donkt have cd and dh or paladin do
That’s what I thought
There is only thundering roar which is not consumed again
yeah but thunderoar roar theres no advantage between consume and no consume in dps unless your mob is dying before it ends
I was meaning from an aggro point of view, the burst of damage would help solidify from ss consuming the bleeds
ah
i find most aggro issues being some rare megaburster dps or aoe not hitting everything
does feel liks revenge has a really small aoe
or maybe i just ply classes where melee range aoe does way bigger than typical 8yards
Revenge is frontal arc only so if they're 1 pixel behind that line it doesn't hit, also they're punching you in the back
yeah
It is possible that I miss them maybe ?
feel like other tanks i play their aoe is more generous
anywyas its not a massive issue i always take it into account
Yeah the other tanks ae are 360 more or less
happens to me often, really gotta make sure you get in and smash shit
do you have like threatplates that show threat status?
it makes it easy to pick up loose mobs
Do you really not have aggro issue with burst class even without thundering roar or ravager up ? Then I should watch out for revenge and care to switch target for 2p
A lot of your upfront threat gen should be from thunderclap, like I usually charge in TC SS then TC again, then usually I have something like ravager TR or outburst thunderclap to ensure I don’t get ripped on by big bursts
I have threat lates but it doesn’t show prrcentzge, only color
Shield charge is big dam and should be up nearly every pull
yep, should use SC on either a high priority target, or the whole group balled up when you have CD
Yeah shield charge does help indeed and it has helped me a lot
color is what i meant so youre good
Also make sure avatar is up
But as I always need things like that or taunt I have he feeling that TC and revenge are just not enough (not overall of course but just for threat)
giga taunt is something you want to use only in specific scenarios
but its you use it all the time too
its very powerful and you dont want it to miss something whati mean
I use it on cd
Same for demo, btw it may be another reason : when I use a gcd on demo sometimes it is when it happens
I just realized I'm also running some burst ae trinkets
if youre doing 100k dps that should be good tbh
So that's probably why 😅
aggro loss will happen sometimes but its mostly when you arent hitting something or someone is doing insane burst
paladins and druids and warriors are extremely good at ripping aggro
I use it a lot and although in the end "it is ok", the amount of ressource and focus i have to put just for something which is meant to be basic makes me wonder what i do bad
Q: What Embellishments should i run in 10.2?
A: 2x Shadowflame on Cloak and Bracers will be your go-to choice of embellishments again.
Reading FAQ and wondering if this is accurate for prot as well? First time playing my warrior all expansion really lol. Are there any defensive embellishments that I might use for now and recraft to later?
defensive ones dont make much of a differnece
shadowflame does a chunky dps increase though
its 5% damage boos from shadowflame or 0.5% damage reduction from vers bracers
We don't aim for defense
is the accelerated hourglass trinket good?
believe it's the best trinket from M+
i like it
pales compared to raid trinkets though
Do you use demo on pull ? I tend to use for both defensive and offensive reason in engage but maybe I should wait
But when i have my cd I want to use demo at the same time but wasting a gcd may be a reason of threat issues
ya, raid trinkets generally always better
but you have to then actually do the raid to get it
so
I really need to change my tank perspective lol. Last time I tanked mainspec was when tank stats existed on gear >.>.
Yeah it's possible
i make sure i have hit everything then i demo shout before using all my gigachad cds
We never engage with demo ? Or only when there is offensive cd to use with it ?
Modern tanking in a nutshell - we're DPS that don't die, optimal offensive play leads to optimal defensive play
Okay i see
I’ve personally never had aggro issues but I cycle through CDs. Make sure you have everything for a big pull for damage and then AOE taunt on pulls where you have less threat
Oh yes so when I don’t have cd I should do smaller packs
Yup
oh is this reds once a season im not holding aggro issue
where we tell him the same stuff everytime?
The classic DH walk of shame
within 10 seconds of a keystone in BFA
DH dont stand in the maggot plz
Dh respond : 'ya ya this is ez dungeon'
I am trying to apply the advices but I still have issues
10 seconds later
hes dead to standing in maggto breath
key dead
cuz dh left
it seems like alot of the players that started to learn how to do keys have gotten better at it
even the casual like, almost role player types, can do the things and time keys
Somehow most of my guild has actually become worse
Makes sense
is brand any good for us in m+ ? It;s doing maybe 5% of my damage in a 21. not sure how that compared to hourglass or other stuff i dont have.
That's about on par for a trinket
Hello! Question, I have seen on many sites BiS items have haste on everything, but the Deminishing returns are over 20%, does that not matter for prot?
7100 rating i think is cap well over 20
but is it not better to just take more crit and verse then?
So like hit the 5200 cap for haste and then realocate the secondaries (Crit/verse) ?
Should you only use the fyrakk axe in ST situations??
.
mines alot higher i like ITF. so i have 35% haste before buffs then i go crit verse. but u do want at least around 1k mastery thats about 20%
<-------------------
no
never
is it because the value on deminising haste is still more valuable than moving it to crit/verse?
well, capped I mean that you are losing value on the haste
doesnt matter
as long as haste gives you something its still valuable
I come from a dps background and wondered cause I use True Stat Values
until you hit the 2nd round of DR
taht that diminishing returns nonsense and throw that out the window
spoilers: you wont
I appreciate that information and detail
its bis in all situations
Well in terms of pure dps there is a point well before the second tier of DR where things like vers/mastery start to pull ahead of even haste, but haste still feels better for the things it does to rage gen/gcd
Where does mastery dps comes from? I thought it just increase blocked damages
It's not set in the character sheet, sorry~
It is in the character sheet, I just missed it 234 times
Mastery gives % attack power
is nightmare egg shell good
What andy said, it basically scales incredibly well the more targets you have
No.
Rezan's Eye vs. Signet Brand for M+? Assuming I only use one because I really like my cheat death trinket.

u drop the cheat death because i can guarentee its not doing anything
If you're hitting the cheat death something went wrong
It's very handy for not dying 😄
Is it though
what key lvls u doing?
18
Oof
u drop cheat death
If they're dead they can't hurt you
if you like to run it, run it, but it aint something you need by a long shot in that key range
its an 18 they arent hurting u anyway
Wildhammer headdress too
ah goes with my p2w tmog
also ursine vengeance still bugged
What they are trying to say, is that if you need it in 18, there's probably something wrong in your gameplay, and you might be better of finding out what it is =)
It can also be confortable to learn your role if you never tanked before, your spec, and the dungeons
Well "need" and "enjoy having" aren't necessarily the same. It doens't pop often, but it feels good when it does. And it is a reliable way not to be murdered by the spiders in BRH.
@strong forum is rageheart exclusively a big defensive button
or can we safely press it for dam
So when it pops captain panda, checkout your logs to see why it popped and try and locate where things went to poo
you try to use it on CD as often as possible
its more a dps than a tank trinket
Like did you have defensive options
Really? Why?
And it popped because you didn't use it?
cuz its a short fucking CD thats does quite some damage
Interesting.
The absorb is pretty stronk
would it be bad to hold it for a big pull if I see one coming up
I have the Fyrakk Weapon at 476 and crafted shield at 486 should I be opening my 20s vaults as Arms at this point do you think?
Like that's a use grey matter moment
Yes
^
Well some argument to be had about looting fury incase you can get heroic fyrak weapon
But arms prob the way
Said 20s, idk if they raid?
True depends if they raid heroic or not
I raid but only half cleared Hc won't clear Fyrakk for a week or 2 yet.
Then arms yes
Lotta vaults I'm seeing are like lfr in the raid spots, and 20s

I swear I ran all 3 wings of lfr hoping for tier
Im apparently missing out on my 2nd mythic slot this week 3 warriors in group and they picked me to sit for 5th healer on council
And ended up with the same brm as my cotank

And he won all 3 pieces
Well like I said, doesn't pop often. I don't see it as a crutch for poor gameplay, just an emergency button for when things go south that can save a fight that might otherwise wipe. And that has happened a couple times.
(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻
Makes sense, pugging heroic, hell even quite a bit of normal with pugs is a depressing shitshow of no talent and bad communication. Unless you're in a raiding guild that top tier is staying dark for a healthy population
Yeah pugging normal is a crapshoot
Yeah I must admit now that Ive experienced a new season with an organized guild I won’t ever go back to pugging
idk if anyw warriors need some tips for EB, but this is how I pull all the trash on first boss without DH silence
Pugging is such a horrendous experience
It increases the damage you deal up to 5 targets, so depending on specifically what you mean, it's more damage as long as you don't miss out on uses
Especially when you get kicked for ripping aggro
And telling the other tank to press buttons
you just don't understand aggro control 🙂
I tried to lead a heroic fyrakk pug, got consistently to P3 but healers these days make me want to scream into a pillow. First group broke up, rallied a second later in the night and we couldn't even make it to P2 after 45 minutes (Dispelling is hard 😦 )
LUL
i can't get over that bear, he lives rent free in my head
I mean that happens in my organized guild runs too, but they don't boot me

Tanks these days should not ever have to think about threat
Unless taunt swapping
If you do one of the tanks is just bad
pugging wouldn't be that bad if the default mindset people have wasn't "Never my fault, these idiots are dragging me down"
1st 5 Heroic PUG isn't too painful if appropriately selective and well run but starts getting annoying beyond that. I did 6 last week and 10% ish wipes on Smolderon but that was a bit painful without fail detection WAs.
also wouldn't be as bad if people were literate, but a lot of guild people are also illiterate, so that's not just a pug issue
We pugged Fyrakk week 1 on Saturday night for like 6 hours straight to kill it
For how much people love their parses and number pumping, it really is difficult to find someone who understands how numbers work and which numbers are actually bigger than others
Only replaced two people that were not figuring it out
Seeds are by far the struggle in pugs
I enjoy doing that in previous seasons but not had the time for the last few.
I was chilling in discord, doing heroic council, invited the tank in to chat and help coordinate, guy goes on a 2 minute spiel about how this is the third set of tanks he's been with and everyone doesn't know what they're doing, etc. etc.
Did he then wipe you because he didn't know what to do? XD
Guy then proceeds to aim the bear frontal at half the raid, then fuck up the charge into the vines ability and wipe the raid, twice.
I must be Nostradamus.
Raid tanks are the fucking worst human beings I have the displeasure to ever even witness on my free time.
this is before we even get to how they play the game
99% of pug tanks just cannot do dam
It wouldn't have been nearly so bad if he didn't also have the kind of voice that could grate cheese
I'm partially tempted to get my second computer set up just so I can do both tank roles just so I never have to interact with them ever again
In the grand scheme of things, I don't actually really care if you're doing like 20k DPS
is there a way to position to time last mages pack in ToTT spell reflect for all of them?
You couldn't pay me to be in a PUG discord
I care a lot more if you're an absolute reprobate and trogladyte who should have been banished to a cave filled with lions as an infant
I’m so washed man I haven’t touched Prot in about 6 months I tried tanking a key and was like nope..
A lot of times I'm just there to refine my CD usage for M
Definitely gotta stick with it to perform well
So when they tell me to be in disc I just bounce
At least I do
Every now and then the rando disc pug pays off
Never.
In my experience the pugs who require voice and exp are typically the successful ones
It's literally the same chance in my boat
sometimes people just like to hear themselves talk
I don't want to listen to a bunch of aimless chatter from people I do not know or care about.
Almost everytime I pug I already know the fight
I don't need some low-ball andy trying to tell me how to do it
I was in a pug just earlier where the guy wanted everyone in Disc and to take his 6 weak auras for the fight, and had about a 20 minute explanation of the very specific strat needed to handle the boss
it was for smolderon
I met another warrior from a pug we started, had a voice that sounded like if barry white was a radio host, and we both had the same mustache, #bros4lyfe
lol what
i think he had more weak auras than smold has mechanics
Smold is literally walk around the ring, stand behind boss with overheat, stand in front/side with tank soak
Grab orbs
burn
Don't be in fire
how is that 20 minutes and 6 auras
He had weak auras for how to properly position all the overheats and which direction they're going and how to assign people to soak and
This is why I don't raid.
so i did this weird thing known as not taking any of those and leaving when they wiped pull 1
You forgot the part where pugs drop all 10 rings underneath the boss then complain when half the raid dies
we didn't even get to that part
The tanks just kinda ran the boss around everywhere
(I got in as DPS)
And so the raid got blasted by the tank swap debuff
lmfao
is there an updated afenar 10.2.0 weakaura anywhere?
Honestly it's easier to get into pugs as a DPS than tank, then you just snipe the position once you bully the worse of the 2 tanks out of the raid
on average I'd prefer to DPS because I can do more to ensure the raid succeeds as DPS than tank
Of course, then we run into the issue of the tanks just simply not understanding how to just taunt at all
and so i have a better chance of making the raid succeed by not having holes in my brain
I actually had someone tell me not to move fyrakk meteors out of the path of the spirits
I'd say normally you're right, but a lot of the make or break moments are tank mechanics this tier
Because they wanted to let their RDPS hang out in narnia rather than move up so leap doesn't blast them
That makes more sense than some of the other shit I've heard
Or have to move at all, frankly
does fall drop shit loot for priest?
like it has nothing good for them or no good trinket?
source - not a priest
Doesn't fall have that insane int staff with the proc?
Hopefully that was before the key started
Got to go - good luck
I've had 3 brick last week, even after posting multiple times before starting which portion of doti it is, some rogue or dh goes "mfer I thought this was the other one" the moment the dungeon starts
zzzz I think people think I buy boosts since my io's at like 1100 but I've timed a 20
easiest part of the fight
stay close, move counterclockwise behind most recently spawned set
Ez, it's a rotary phone
some german prot mentor here?
Guys i got 4set today and I feel like my dps is lot lower than before, should I change some rotation or is just in my head?
in your head
priority hasnt changed
check your prio
SS > TC > rev/exe
you probably arent thunderclapping enough
Sounds right
it seems it is in my head
you should have SS as #1
I hate to say it
i keep getting tc first
but my DPS went up by like 10K just not funneling all my rage into Exec outside of SS



