#protection
1 messages · Page 580 of 1
Whirlwinning
Gottem
Probably the same type of guy who argued that never surrender was a strong talent
Zero health - Maximum effect!
speaking of talents, how come people dont use Battle Scared Veteran, seems like a really good defensive passive
bugged and bad
It doesn't do what you think it does
Unfortunately it doesn’t work how we’d like it too
ah rip
yeah the tooltip on that is super misleading.
It needs to be an actual cheat death not the garbage it currently is
Also, if you're in a situation where you're relying on something along those lines, someone done fucked up already
think about how often you have close calls
and think about how often BSV wouldve done nothing in those close calls
do you guys use bolster or tough as nails too?
If you have tier you use bolster
i use a modified version of the builds in the pins
If you don't have tier, bolster isn't doing much for you
Or hell they can make it like the paladin thing proc wall whenever you dip below 40 or something idk
ah okay, cause i feel like right now my shield block uptime isnt as high as it could be
That's how it's designed but it's proccing off of raw damage
is there an addon/WA that tracks effective uptime %
It should literally be “prevents death activates wall for 4 seconds puts you at whatever HP sounds fair idk
Shouldn't have any problems with sb unless your haste is low and your trying to run itf
and i have honed reflexes spec'd but not sure if the 1s cd bonus is worth given that most casts are from procs on shield slam
No, pls read builds in pins
i do have ITF on
I think technically it’s a dps gain but extremely irrelevant
You need a certain amount of base haste and have to monitor your stacks
ive read the pins, did i miss one? i know the build linked has storm bolt, i was just using modified cause i saw quazii had hones reflexes
If you're falling below 5 stacks 80%of the time you're better off running hr
Honed that is
Nome would know better
wait we arent using ITF? i thought we were
Yes we are
technically speaking yes HR has benefits over ITF if you cant get a decent uptime on high stacks of ITF
even on some raid fights
but thats min-maxing to quite high degrees given that you dont rely on the uptime on SB from HR, its just a small rage gen difference
If you're not maintaining stacks, have low heat haste, and are not running tier with bolster
so i just dont bother mentioning it
so, you opt to not play one of the best stuns in the game, to get 1 sec shorter CD on kick
@dusky canopy who… was using whirlwind??
:nomgusted:
Quite funny
ey i just hit 70 th eother day lol and had used quazii guides for most stuff, i trustted him over wowhead/icy veins for build
Uh oh
hitting 100k details/92k logs in neltharus 20 with the buffs, feeling juiiiiiicy
im not flaming you, just phrasing it in a way so you can come to an answer yourself 



nah you good lol, wouldn't matter if you were flaming me, i only care about improvement and sometimes flaming is whats needed to improve xD
lotta people take it as a personal attack
I’ve seen it get more outta control around here
if you criticise smth about their gameplay or talents
I mean this is the era of feelings hurt tbf
i mean maybe if i wasnt a shitter lol, but im fresh 70 so not like i know more cant really get mad at someone criticizing build if they clearly have more experience
But yeah generally you will find very useful information in this channel to help you improve
Oh yeah no doubt! Haha
I got banned by a streamer for mentioning not to play in d-stance all day
Sounds about right
people forget that nuances exist
everything is SUPER black and white these days
if youre not this youre that
no nuance, no inbetween
A sad truth
lotta not listening to reason, driven more by feelings and emotions rather than fact or logic
im just here for the memes and to learn a bit every so often
WW IS A CORE WARRIOR ABILITY HOW DARE YOU SAY ITS NOT WORTH PRESSING (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻
Haters gunna hate
had to read that shit
SMH
can't erase it
If ww makes someone happy, just press it
I guess man
Like, I'm still going to stop healing their ass if I run into them on my druid or shaman
I don’t care what the guy does but he was arguing that it was better than pressing revenge
"Bruh if you got rage to press WW, hit IP you turd"
He probably use Slam in single target cause it’s better than WW
should've asked him if he uses a wweapon swap macro to 2h when he presses ww

Scroll up a tad I linked to jereee
So short story, I’m sitting in traffic right now and one of the vehicles around me is steady hot boxing
Warning, once you read that level of Reeeee you can't unsee it
the whole car is made of weed!!
FIBERWEED
i love the scene when the destract the feds in a helicopter with naked beach babes
I grew up with "Dave's not here man" (I'm Dave)
"It's mostly mawiwowi, but has a little doberman"
See, this WW shit turns us to drugs so we can forget
i love that movie
That makes two of us!
I'm watching now you see me again
the one w the magicians?
Yeah
🤔
finally 😄 It should be called SS hero for us lol
hehe


I am in turbo mode in my mind, just shooting down all the terrible shitposts that should not see the light of day now
uhhhh someone make a joke about the ssh protocol instead of the bad boys
jesus that Hackclaw Warband
is there anything i can do as a tank to make that boss easier for the healers?
failed it 3 times in a row now on 18-19 where people just die left and right
No, it's almost purely a healer fight
muyuu started it, dont @ me
spell reflect the disorient and help kill the totem that CCs the healer. otherwise it's probably the bleed that is wrecking people, so it's on the individuals to use a personal/potion etc.
oh the totem is reflectable?

i had healers who died in first 10seconds
The totem comes from the shaman, the blind comes from the bleed guy
Totem goes on healer, blind goes on tank
well that just sounds like getting charged or whirlwinded or something.
New to Prot, does Avatar/Demo shout increase the dmg my trinkets/Onyx Annulet do or is it just my own abilities like Thunderclap etc?
no
iirc theres only 1 thing leftover in the game that can buff stuff item dmg
and thats havoc
Roger roger, ty
I believe Death Chakram still can as well but don't quote me on that
lol, had the line charge go under the hill 😄
havoc? the spec? or the warlock ability?
Spec.

Know Your Enemy.
can we Spell Reflect the Consume debuff on 2nd boss Brackenhide?
seems like i did at least 🤔
kinda by accident 🤣

ive had that happen once or twice, but i always use SR when inside and it doesnt always happen
tried to do it again 2nd time, but aparently the castbar is longer than the actual eat duration
Starting mythic Roshok prog tonight, any tips?
Were you being eaten for a long time?
no clue honestly
what determines the consume length anyway?
my working speculation is that sometimes dps can blast him and cause the eat phase to end quickly resulting in no debuff
but legit idk i havent been doin keys hardcore or anything
He gets a shield burn the shield you get out.
my guild cannot seem to get steady 20 for any raid its awful
but it has happened to me a few times.
what % of blocked hits is expected in a key?
The higher the better. I aim for 90+
@dusky canopy
What is recommended spec for trinkets on the vault?
It is not intended, and I don't know if it's been fixed. I don't do a lot of that range of keys.
Fury if you still need a 1h, arms if not
That's acceptable
Arms will be. Thank you
nerfed sanguini pretty cool
You're pretty cool
gottem
I had so much sanguine healing in FH earlier than I realized that 70% of it was Captain Jolly which made me chuckle
Nice coding
I got 4pc on my Warrior. Gotta try it out now.
I see some streamers double shield slam.. How they do it? It's talent?
What does that mean, double shield slam
are you just seeing an immediate devastator shield slam reset after a shield slam?
That's what my thinking is
Shield charge... Typo from me.
Shield charge too in a row. How?
hacks
You're probably mistaking a normal charge for shield charge
There's not a single thing in the game that affects shield charge's CD; that's locked at 45 seconds
The details streaming shows the same symbol in a row
My guess is that it's showing one symbol for the initial hit and one for the AoE
My best guess is it's processing the charge portion of shield charge separately from the damage instance
Or one for the damage and one for the stun
or that
Makes sense. Thanks
what is the best sim to run?
Or yo eyes broken
is it true at the ultra high key levels do people stay in defensive stance the whole time or what
Like, I assume they are in it more than at lower keys I guess?
but prob not the whole time?
It's possible I suppose. But more likely they don't have to do it and are just to be safe.
This season there's like almost no reason to go dstance.
yeah I guess safety becomes more attractive though?
That guy just don't know what he on about in fel hammer.
Fair enough
Yeah I think it's more likely they don't want to lose the ~13-14% damage to be in defensive stance all the time.
yah I think I am overthinking it, try to keep it simple 'am i about to take a shit load of damage? change stance' thats really all need to know regardless of key level I guess
🥓
ON MY FUCKING PALADIN
FUCK MY LIFE
twinsies
😢
Why are you mad about beacon
Is looking pink

Might depend on pulls in keys
Anyone have a weakaura for Prot 4pc?
And if you have CDs like wall or not
Bstance all day erryday
yeah I guess was just curious what people doing at the top key lvls
but doesnt really matter i guess
duplicate a buff weakaura -> change trigger to earthen tenacity
voila
you now have made a new bufftracker

ayo, i made a cheap lil weakaura for tracking the new 4 set buff, if anyone wants it https://wago.io/l6Ri1qsx0
i couldnt find a good one on wago
aw man i love when a chain holder dies on 2nd boss Neltharus 🙂
lul, im signing up to keys groups as dps cuz i thought i was gunna try lfr today
not on the balll
How bad are the absorb stones for the Annulet (with the DPS one included)?
youre better oiff going with a regular ring afaik
everyone goes annulet for big damage
Lfr is fun to tank if you are learning
Have you tanked the raid at all yet?
Honestly raid tanking can be reduced to basically “the wa/addon says taunt I taunt”. There’s a little more with positioning but it’s by no means hard
Also don’t need shit for gear tbh
genuinely surprised there's no fallback for this, it's one of the few actual one death = probable wipe mechanics
yea the phase is healable, but then after the phase ends, he puts a dot on everyone that is just death
its so weird
we had the guy who had Dragon Charge on him and got chain after die
so basically a wipe then 🙂
2 players start running to the Elephant boss after that 🤣
chain should stay in their corpse tbh
which we already killed
what is the general play in that boss btw? is it 1-1-1 chain, or 2-1 or all 3 together?
and man that boss doesnt like to move
i kinda treat it like garrosh chains from sanctum
ideally they're all kinda close together so i can pop one, make sure the healer's keeping up, then keep going
decided to mess about with crit haste gone flat out in everything, practically 0 vers and feel great runnnig 20s am i just memeing myself and gimping myself not running vers instead of crit, sat at about 32% haste and 37% crit, buffed with phial and motw have about 10% vers.... would vers start pulling ahead of this hella fun crit build the higher i go in keys?
does it do an explosion when it pops? or is it just the dot 🤔
nah you're fine, vers isn't magical
because i think prolonging the dot is kinda bad
but if your vers is legit near zero it might be your best source of damage, check sims
i only have vers off the 4 set and phial most of the time lol will play about with it, see alot of peeps running vers and i feel fine in 20-22s im running with the bare minimum
there's an initial pop + dot
but the dot stacks
you're not refreshing it
i mean you are refreshing it if you wait until 1 sec, then pop the 2nd no?
potentially you could make this dot last 12 seconds with 3 stacks 🤣
but idk, i was thinking of doing 2-1, but the healer in my grp was like "no do 1-1-1"
and then he couldnt even spotheal the guy with Dragon Charge on him... :<
true
isnt the guy doing peroidical AOE dmg until he is stunned also?
so not popping them fast might also make him do more dmg
he's doing aoe around him + throwing out lava splats
So all dodgeable ye
it's safest if melee get out and just stretch their chains if the healer isn't confident
Yup makes it so much easier
you need legit defensives to hang out near him
How I was shown to do it and it works very well, is you mark 3 markers on one side of the room, and tell dps to drop them there and run directly across
so you just have a wall of 3 chains
And you just drag through, stop, drag through, stop, drag through
Or pop multiple if healer can do it
yeah that's good
the pug way is three random points around the room
and then keep moving, constantly, forever
lol, yep
What's worst is when I'm not tanking, and the tank thinks it's the dps's job to break the chains instead of him or her
they just plant themselves in the middle of the room and wait
100% chance they were just eating orbs to the face
absolute champion
dh died right before this, got brez died again looks like
Shocking
Actually worse than getting hit by the orb
He got hit by the cyclones that barely move 
when i tried to actually move the boss, he just stood there in the middle 😄
hes really awkward in the chain fase i feel
It's because if you move like 1 inch away from him he fucking jumps at you and goes right over the chain
It's super fuckin annoying
just weird boss all together
Forgemaster oneshot me because my Charge couldnt go off for some reason
so i didnt get out of the circle
For what it's worth, if you didn't know, you can just start running forward as soon as you land and you can get out of the circle without any mobility
yea but then i dont get the free rage from Charging 😄
True, just sayin lol
but yea if theres a risk of charge not going off like this i will change it ofc
also last boss still feels so weird with the items
kinda sad i didnt get to try it today because people left when its over time
Did you end up finding out why it didn't go off?
:pepehands
does the zaqali chaos grapnel only do dmg if i leap away first to get pulled in or like does it jsut suck
okay so it just sucks got it
it does not suck
what 🤣
If you do use it from range, make sure you don't charge
oh shit nvm i just saw it does two different instances of dmg on details
Because it'll cancel the damage
any whirlwinders in chat
i always whirlwind when i have more rage than i can spend on Revenge
gotta get that rage out fast boi
and i play Barbaric Training too
bis talent
had a guildie say to me Intimidating Shout was garbage, and thats why he didnt pick it for our M+ grp (he was Arms) 🤔
what are they being taught in these Arms guides
Legends say they hit up the guides in the icyveins comments. They speak words of wisdom like, don't take intishout... For it is a o.1% DPS loss.
its Intimidating Shout vs +15 max rage 🤣
It took us forever to convince yogi to to use Intim shout
Max rage will let you gain more DPS on ragecaps, trust in minmax sims. Follow the words of PuGbrain law.... Thy shall only care about thou DPS
I still remember pulling CoS imps with pack - calling for the AoE stop, only to have two warriors go "I don't take intishout". Good memories.
ez avoidance
Gentlemen. You are chatting with the one and only apb on discord
congrats
Ty
yes it works
Omg LOL
arms owns
You own
War owns
why you weird
the sky

phone lol
ohhh
Oh by the ads?
report
LOL ye
Yah that’s just normal
oh dont worry i do
im petty about those fuckers advertising in my space
do it in chat like youre supposed to
not in lfg
I rapid fire report those
Wait a minute! Does typing 19 20 21 also show 18 and 22 keys?
correct
Forgive me for being triggered but why type 19 20 21 lol
idk
i only want to do 20s
He can just type 19 and 21 and it would do the same thing
yeah
i didnt realise that
thought you had to have the middle number
huh thanks learned something new today 😄
If I want to see 21 I just type 21-21
man fuck them healers
HI JORDAN

anyone know why i lose like 9k HP and get it back when i relog?
do you have any items from the diablo thing in your inventory?
could be a delay in the extra stamina getting added
does anyone have any advice regarding mythic experiments? im typically doing fine, and then about minute 3, shit gets terrible, when Rio and Thal are up. I've been at 4 stacks, and literally drop from like 80% hp to 0. Where that sort of stacks on the beginning of fight, really not much of a problem. I'm now rolling full defense trinks, spell block. I always end up burning thru all my emergency CDz too around that time trying to stay alive
also, with rio and thal, its often one tank get up to like 6 stacks, maybe even 7, before the raid wide dot is off and we can clear. Kinda sux
So IP wasn't reducing it?
i imagine it was
evidently not enough
i mean i dont think theres an answer. just wanted to know if theres some specific mechanic i'm screwing up
really enjoying pulling using beacon to the beyond and starting fights at the top of the meter lol
I assume it was affecting the actual ability but not the explosion after the debuff runs out?
Or it was working but it was not considering the mitigation in the groupwide damage calculation
it worked against the claw but didn't count towards the blast calculation, correct.
haha warrior on sark go brrrrrrrrrr
So basically it'll be easier for healers to heal it going forward
is the crafted shield with shadowflame armor patch the best shield we can get? trying to decide to use aspect crest with that or the belt
pretty much, you can put bis stats on it too
gotcha. so cant go wrong then
That’s what I use
actually seems like theres a 450 shield from mythic echo of nelth but thats just a 3ilevel difference
up to you
yeah but im not going to be doing mythic nel. so thats out lol
this game is bad
I won the roll for boots from mag
and because I upgraded them to 441 before they were bound to me they didn't give me the heroic appearance
???
im trying to get a health set of haste/crit and haste/verse. worth just going with crit? im doing both raiding and m+
not having vers makes my skin hurt
good to know. ty

Doesn’t upgrading item make it bound to you right then or am I wrong
That is fucked up
like from the dropdown
Even if you do straight to 441 it still cycles through each level I thought
Sort of like 5 in a row
got me bro
weird
Something weird
Maybe open a ticket perhaps they can make it right
I have my doubts!
omegalul
Fuk
Just ridiculous lol
Thank you for spreading this message at least so doesn’t happen to others
jordan what key do you have
19 BH dad
let's BRICK IT
19 BH, 16 BH, 11 VP, 9 BH, 9 HOI
many keys
Was ripping 103k overall going into bh last boss with 10 mins left and proceed to deplete and disband
Saddest day of my life
nice
Do you have any tips on tanking experiments?
@pure goblet Mythic ? Cause I myself am having problems surviving the last two boss overlap . 6 stacks real problems, run outa defense cd
yea Mythic, It is very hard tank
all dmg is magic
My co tank is a Druid too lol. I’ve focused it down to the problem boss, Rio, he sends out stacks much more rapidly . Ideally a tank good at magic dot damage holds him. In my case, feels like we kinda screwed
Whoever is on rio is going to be getting stacks up to 6 or 7. You’re gona burn thru all ur defensive as quickly at that rate
Then u die
Maybe u survive if healer happens to have not used their external already lol
To make u feel better, a lot of kill videos I’m seeing tanks go down and get brezd
we have monk healer and I get bubbles all the time
Part of our issue is healed have to burn a lot of externals on the dispell foek to keep ‘em alive
@pure goblet I have no answer for you as I myself am stuck on that. Our raid is typically dying to other reasons, but maybe 30% of our wipes are due to our Druid tank dying a bit more than me, but also me.
@pure goblet are you finding spell block works? Pin spreadsheet says it does. I’m using it, but I def would not say it completely blocks the damage. If at all lol. Doesn’t feel that way…
idk, I havent used it
I thought it was useless
Spell Block does not work that way. It's literally block, for spells.
It does not completely block the damage.
Just like regular block does not prevent all the damage
Also, logs would be much more helpful than speculation.
@warm plinth confirmed spell blocks works tho on this fight?....it would then..prevent the stacks of infused strikes?
seems doubtful
according to spreadsheet it does. No way tho that's happening from what I'm seeing. That would be 30 seconds u could ignore the stacking
That is not how blocking works.
oh oh @ionic fern angry in the morning 😮 All to cover!
right. So the question of...does spell block work for infused strikes....no, it does not. correct?
It does. But you are misunderstanding how blocking works.
60 percent of the time, it blocks every time
"you are able to block spells"
Oh, no, not yet. Been a horrible morning tho.
er excuse me
😦 Hope it will get better soon!
But blocking does not prevent anything. Whether spell block or regular.
It mitigates
any effects will still occur
you are thinking of parrying
where the effects do not occur
def getting rid of it for expimrents. infused strikes says only arcane damage
might roll defender's aegis moving forward for more shield wall uptime in that horrible window with both boss
No.
You have 100% up-time on the boss (for the majority of the fight) You will get more out of Impenetrable.
Rogues/warlocks/DK's can apply their auto-attack slows on the boss which will help.
Clear asap.
Okay, its just honestly the only dangerous window is when rio and Thadrion are up. Because Rio casts infused strikes very rapidly
Don't tank the dragon (3rd boss). Tank the 2nd boss when they are both down.
Or just try understanding on tank defensives work in the game and you'll be better at mitigating damage.
problem is my co tank is a druid lol. so both of us suck at this type of damage
¯_(ツ)_/¯
druid is fine
HUH
What
OH HELL NAH
i run out of my emergency CDz quite fast at minute 3
Druid should chill there.
at 6 stacks im in a danger spot, which is where i end up becasue of the raid wide dot. again, only danger window is when thadrion and rionthus are up. at mintue 3...er 3:10
Okay so:
-Warlocks/Rogues/DK's can apply attack-speed slows on the boss which stack. If you got them, let them apply them, it reduces the stacks of Infused Strikse.
-Use Defensive stance at higher stacks.
-Use a defensive trinket if you have/feel like you need it.
-Clear stacks with your co-tank asap.
-Call for an external when you have 4+ stacks and nothing to attack.
-Don't tank Rionthus.
this druid dies faster than me on this one
@ionic fern thanks for those details. You think a druid tank is better for rion than me tho??
Side a nice way to find what other pwar are doing is to go to wcl as well and just snag a log from a war and look at cast timeline
I do it for dps a lot too
If you want more info too outside of what ppl say here
It’s kinda fun to look at imo
I want to say yes, but i'm not actively playing druid, just going by what i've read/heard from druid players.
You do have to let your healers know that you're going to get wrecked during that fight.
I was also using a defensive trinket / defensive stance / all externals on that fight when we first killed it.
Spicy.
Remember to use SR on CD.
And feed rage into IP.
FE on prot warrior was a doozy 
Indeed it was.
@ionic fern yeah i went full defense trinks. prob can squeeze out more IP as im so used to spamming revenge
Isn’t Zskarn pretty similar if not worse
Je, you can spam Revenge later on re-kills.
prob worse but there are windows of tanking at least. ur not ALWYS tanking
Worse.
Since you can’t spell block that dot either
Yeah I’m getting a different tank ready bc prot feels not gr8 on some of these bosses
I’m also just shit 
FE was an eye opener though, shit was so easy on a ratty dh compared to pwar
Granted that was farm vs prog
👀
just looking at random log, you sometimes toggle off stance and arent in battle/defensive at all, should watch that

almost 1k rage diff generated in same timeframe between you and me, prolly hit buttons more

@shut summit thx for looking up. May have fat fingered and not realized lol
fight 100% sucks for us and definitely need handholding more than other bosses but buncha small things like that add up
i have a bigass text WA that says NO STANCE cuz no way in hell i'd notice that either mid combat
youre nicer to yourself than I am
I have a couple for that stuff
"NICE STANCE, U FUCKIN IDIOT"
Just to clarify this since I have seen a few people confused lately:
How Block Works:
▫️ Blocking, despite how its name may sound, is a mitigation tool. It does not completely prevent damage like dodge and parry do. It also will not prevent any negative status effects, such as DoTs or debuffs.
▫️ Your base chance to block is dictated by a base percentage + your mastery. Using Shield Block increases that chance to 100%, which is why maximum uptime is important when tanking, and why we don't stack mastery to get higher block chance. In addition, the vast majority of your damage taken (especially in Mythic+) is from melees, which are always blockable.
▫️ The amount you block is based on a combination of the item level (block value) of your shield and certain talents that increase this value by a percentage. Because of this, it is incredibly important to always use the highest ilevel shield you can get.
▫️ Spell Block grants you the ability to block spells, but it does not guarantee blocking by itself. This means you still need to maintain Shield Block during the duration of Spell Block to guarantee that it blocks spells. See the spreadsheet here: https://tinyurl.com/TWWreflects to learn the mechanics that are blockable, spell blockable, and spell reflectable.
▫️ Protection's mastery enables critical blocking, which gives a chance to double the amount of damage that block mitigates (up to a cap of 85% reduction). For whatever reason, Spell Block bypasses this cap. Thus, when Spell Block crit blocks, it can and will sometimes mitigate all of the damage, rather than part of it.
:block:
What's the base chance to block?
I believe it's 30% but don't quote me on that

There's a base chance god damnit. I didn't specify it because I wasn't sure and it's irrelevant anyway

Meanies
How is the block value calculated from the shield?
It's on the shield
It has a formula to it.
Your block reduction has a formula, but not block value
What's the mastery coef for our block?
Unless you mean the increases from talents
Base block chance is 5%, right?
I was trying to keep it simple, not write a thesis
😂
thesis my diq
❤️
Yeah I looked it up; it does appear to be 5%
I'm probably thinking of old block that was a set 30% reduction
did you just assume i have a thesis
Funnily enough, iirc block value = 2x armor on the shield.
Oh interesting. I never even thought to compare the two
imma nitro boost this server so that i look like someone of importance
I do know that for some fucking reason, you have to own a shield to see the block on it. Even wowhead doesn't show it
1.5 for critblock, 0.5 for block.
Sharing knowledge, take it and never use it.


Obviously you need to stack mastery so you can guarantee crit blocking
Joke all you want. Avatar being a defensive CD with 3x BoM was huge.
…..unless?
RIP BoM
This was to Jordan
My favorite part of BoM was explaining to people that no, we don't want to stack mastery, but also telling them to take BoMx3
My favourite part was coming here arguing with people about 3xBoM and 3xDC.
lol
@ionic fern is getting a second dot to the raid that big of a thing? Or…let’s say I’m at 6 stack but got like 5 seconds left of the raid dot. Preferable to just give the raid a second stack? Or hell na
but we did it a few times.,

Bear almost had a BoM level strong azerite power with Vision of Perfection. But then they changed it to proc incarn instead of survival Instincts
Saj
Looking at top logs of 20s we aren't excelling in dam vs other tanks. I was a little surprised. It's not bad, but a paladin did more
I figured especially after buff did be better
Am i looking in wrong place
PWar is better... than they were.
going from Mythic experiments to Rashok felt great, I cant agree more with u
Experiments imo is one of the very worst fights ive ever experienced, not in terms of difficulty, its just annoying and not enjoyable at all
IDK this PWar did more damage https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/3pNXmwKhBYvPfQDk#fight=7&type=damage-done than every one of the PPals I've looked at on an equal footing key
Maybe stop looking at bad PWars?
¯_(ツ)_/¯
TIL Jakey is in the same guild as Kele
Who is Kele
@silent comet
A dreamgrove frequenter
Everything makes sense now both saucy
both kinda cute
That 'd be a nice pin ;)
Hello dat me
Just sleeping tbh
Ban him.
did they remove the magmatusk vial / trick?
a while ago, yes
oh, ok :/
Prot warr feelin real nice on nelth prog yknow
Damage you can do now is lovely also
@warm plinth STATS
There's a noticeable jump for raids where the end boss was killed before first reset
They nerfed the boss at the same time
Oh, I missed that patch note, thanks !
My groups keep dying (18, 17, 14...), whichever level I'm in, so I was wondergin
Is heart of Thunder simming properly ?
dont think so
it’s either not simming right or didn’t work right ingame
It doesn't sim right but also your details will deceive you because what you gain in the damage sheet you also lose some from it not being a mainstat trinket. Obviously the mainstat loss of a trinket is dependent on the proc itself (see Whetstone) for if it's worth, but just keep it in mind
Mwahi said he likes it.
Hate to be that guy
But Rashok isn’t easier

Fun fight, boss doesn’t fuck about tho
So after winning a 444 [Voice of the Silent Star] I realised it has no stam, is it best to use it still or using a normal 441+ cloak that has stam if you are pushing higher keys?
What are higher keys
20+
Then voice
I assume that at that point the extra dps is more required than the 50k hp?
The extra hp is only needed if you can’t survive without it
And in 99% it’s not the reason you die
Fair enough, ty
Rashok is super easy vs Experiments.
It has burst magic/physical damage at set intervals which we excell at.
Ah was taking it as an overall prog standpoint not just a prot warrior standpoint
Returning player here. I’ve been playing m+ for a few months and feel like I have it down for the most part doing 16s and higher. I tried to join guild for raid last night and did fine, but noticed I was having rage generation problems to a point where I had some downtime where I couldn’t cast anything, or have shield block/ignore pain up. When playing ST raid build, am I supposed to be playing anything differently from m+ build?
No, the priority is the same. SS->TC and CD's on CD.
Usually when it comes to rage issues it's a combination of two things:
-Not pressing your Rage generators on CD (SS/TC)
-Spamming too much Ignore Pain.
Can be easily clarifier if you have a log.
thanks! I suspected spamming too much ignore pain.
Do you pop it at a certain amount of extra rage, or where bar runs out? Or do you stop using sb/ip when other tank has aggro? @ionic fern
Hello friends. Is there a recommended build for starting out in m+ with bad gear (ilvl 408)?
Usually hit IP @ 70+ energy only.
IP as default is used as your off-GCD rage dump, so you use it to avoid overcapping rage
Roughly in the range of 60-100 rage, since, depending on talents, that's the range where you'll cap rage
It ends up covering all day-to-day utility you could ever want from IP while allowing you to spend the rest of the rage on revenge, which effectively is cheaper than IP due to resetting SS
Do You think it would be better to use heart of thuner or becon to the beyond in m+? Both 441 ilvl, hard to tell since heart is not simming
If you don't have tier pieces, you'll use the build in pins, but without bolster and ITF on HR instead. Otherwise, build in pins
I am using Mark of Dargul as 2nd trinket
Prot Warrior's talents are very syngergistic and are very strong when put together properly. Unfortunately, this means the build is very inflexible. So there's no beginner build or anything like that.
Even if you don’t have it up currently? Thanks! That’s my prob. Probably because I’m used to infinite rage in m+
Thank you
It just slows the amount of damage you take, effectively, and most meaningful damage in raid is telegraphed and can be covered with defensives/externals/comp decisions/etc. IP is good to use, but you shouldn't really have major rage issues, and you don't take much damage in the first place, so it lasts longer than you would expect
On top of that, even in ST, as long as you're using all of your CDs on CD, you'll have it up quite often.
Also, as a note, you'll keep using IP even when not actively taking damage, as it's a part of your damage rotation to spend your rage

@dusky canopy 
energy? ENERGY??
A fun experience!
If it's the same as the last season, it unlocks the "glow" for your tier sets (all levels).
cant find it in the transmog view 🤔
i guess i need to get the transmog first
have done barely any Raid
The tooltip specifically says:
Use: Infuse your armor with a faint echo of the Earth Warders power, unlocking additional visual effects for certain Aberrus, the Shadowed Crucible class set appearances.
This effect is account-wide.
yeah you still need to actually acquire each tierset transmog
It's just the mythic effects on each transmog, since normally LFR/normal/heroic tierset doesn't have the glowy shit that mythic tier does
Mfw I forgot to actually equip tier chest before I upgraded it to 441 so i still don't have the heroic transmog
If only getting Mythic apperances unlocked the lower difficulties...
think there's any chance immovable object is worth it on mythic experiments?
am progging it on my bdk alt, but i think the raid would benefit from another rally more than an amz
but fight is just painge for pwar the few times i pulled it before swapping to bdk
its one of the least popular tanks
i'm like 90% sure the majority of people still playing pwar in S1 had a prot pally alt ready to go for the start of s2
you got 2 vdhs and 1 bear who public logged it
which is why we just had a giga massive dropoff right then
and were just playing pwar to finish out the tier
pwar is only played if its perceived as literally #1
if its not #1 you wont see people play it
thats just how it works
I prefer when its not #1
nobody likes being #1
feels cooler
cuz it comes with alot of unpleasant people
rn is perfect for us
tied for #2 spot

Theworst
Dps loss but you’d think another wall would help
But without the fotm guys we have far less entertaining discussions here, like, "I've got more CE than god" and "but the top warrior does this, you're only #5 world" and "but revenge isn't 360 so how do you rage mobs hitting you in the back"
Cause you couldn’t send wall offensively but still. I like wall I ran it in a key for fun and was so fuckin beefy and didn’t feel like much less dps
UF isnt much of a dps gain
Can’t hit most of the tcs I wants in Ava before anyways
So to speak in this a little, especially for raid, true you won't save wall as an offensive CD but as long as you're sending wall near cd the DPS loss is minimal between io and uf
And grabbing io is way better than double wall
@shut summit or, to anyone who has an answer. Since the only window i find lethal is the overlap of the last two bosses, I'm using Ward of faceless ire and chromatic essence. I also have an enduring Dreadplate. Would that not be a better choice? Another emergency survival CD for that window of horror? I asked a similar question earlier about using defender's aegis for that reason, that was shot down a bit as a bad idea
mythic experiments we're talkin bout
Yeah that sounds pretty nice. I was surprised by how few wars play io since you end up with a wall every like 20-30s which is kinda nuts
That’s good to know. I don’t do a ton of raid tanking but I’ll keep it in mind for the couple bosses a shorter cd would be nice on
Wall with like bark skin cd 🤌
i have a Prot Pala alt, but im back to the warrior and straight up just feel more tanky
on Paladin my HP going like a yoyo
With io and spell block you could have a solid like 54 seconds of reduced or blocked magic dmg
Enough to maybe double up last pack neltharus if feeling a little risky
i hate doubling that pack because the dps never focus correct targets
and you rely on a ranged kick for the lavamancer
i mean it sucks to do them separate but never trust caster kicks 
Reread dread plate, the per hit absorb is pretty small
man i must suck ass at diablo man
this venard fight as barb is insane
i even tried to over level it LMAO
Everything scales?
Melee get absolutely shit on early game
Legit leveled as wolf/bear hybrid druid and if I got clipped outside of bear I'd explode
Are you trying it on veteran?
Nice i beat it just now
took me like 7 or 8 trys
anytime you touch anything red you become vulnerable
and then the mobs were smackin me
Yup
Lots of dodging
im assuming melee will get better with gear, in beta i did sorc becuase i didnt want to spoil barb play through
and sorc just nuked everything ez mode
lol
It does with points and gear, you can still get wrecked though if you stand in bad and some bosses are hard to get into melee with
ask for externals (especially last seconds before clearing), maybe rethink moments of clearing dot, for example clear earlier during 2nd boss only so you can start clearing earlier in the hard phase etc
also think with your co-tank who should take which boss, after spawning 3rd boss usually gives more stacks than 2nd so its better that class with more tools for mitigating this dot takes 3rd guy
from def trinkets for raid cragshaper is pretty good as its 1min cd only and helps smooths dmg intake especially from such dots (and there are 6/9 bosses with magic dot), dreadplate is bad, especially for this moment as there is lot of
lightning - 1 yogi - 0
i see lots of health still there, so you good to go 
deaths is comically tall because i was checking all the deaths from a key last night
i didn't even hit my SW or LS for that, what was i thinking
leap yogi leap!
Yogi, Do you know how to avoid the slow?
well, there is a 360 animation around him with an undefined ending radius, and, there is something about a jump, or a dispell
without opening the game or a website to look it up
thats what my answer is
Right, as soon as he's about to finish his cast you jump
avatar, but is there some potion for it?
incase i don't jump and i don't get dispelled also
You have to jump
I wait until the bar is at 0.5s normally
And jump
Works every time
wind mechanics are bullshit in every game
Is that second boss?
yogi if you have weakauras this weakaura here :https://wago.io/dfdungeons
I had problems on it week one until I learned that I can just stay in the middle and rotate the boss to always be on buff side
is extremely helpful. it also includes an aura that will show a green bar when you can jump
this yes
I am having a Hard time finding a talent from the cookie cutter build to Exchange for spell block any ideas?
The bolster tier build?
Yeah exactly
haven't gotten that far into the game yet (only at act 3, going sequentially) but seems like since none of the (at least solo) boss fights really have any enrage or even soft enrage mechanics, you can just get away with playing GIGA safe and being boring as
it's pretty cringe to play like that tho
Ah okay yeah it looks Kinda cursed tbh
how is the new shield (impact buckler) vs frostfire belt/shadowflame for M+?
It's bad
ah thats sad, thanks
I think somone mentioned, buyt the 3rd boss has no real spellqueue or long casts so when they are down they just gigga stack. So if your cotank handles dots better ideally they take this guy and you hold bos2 until he ded. Highest damage intake for me was when 2nd boss was doing violent eruption. i typically am at like 5 stacks, cant clear yet so i save wall for when he casts it. Just my experience with it. Then my bubble trinket is jut an oh shit buttton in case we get high and have a few secs until we can clear.
So I had put my loot spec on prot for some reason, I think a m+ trinket and forgot, so I opened the heroic box hoping for a bigger anvil or something and instead get the badass looking shield, great for transmog, bad compared to the upgraded crafted shield I'm already using
it's alright, transmog is the true endgame
s2 gear is ephemeral by its nature
transmog is forever
Which tank has most group utility: vengeance dh, prot warr, or brewmaster
most of the DH sigils are self serving or generic boring, so not DH imo
The silence sigil seems pretty good I guess
I would say DH for the above reason
darkness is cool, , but i feel like everthing else about DH, both specs, is memememmeme all about me
And you can make some skips safer with imprison
imprison is the best CC in the game
banish and sheep close seconds
Chaos brand vs mystic touch vs battle shout hmmm
it allows them to place an image of themselves
and they can teleport to it
same way locks thing works
Yah people do seem to like chaos brand
ofc its subjective but i find monk way more fun than vdh
i never really read a gujide on vdh but it feels so bad in M+
delayed blast on spirit bomb
I find both fun, but I cannot seem to enjoy spirit bomb I know people love it but I don’t really like playing it
Ya
lack of on demand instant aoe
It’s weird though most people seem to apparently like spirit bomb lol
spirit bomb should explode instantly
i also havent given it a shot in DF but in SL thats how it was totally
Ya when I played vdh I found if I messed up my defensives I would be in a bad spot
i dont think vdh is meant to kite more than others but it has the tools for it
Nowadays i believe they do alot of self healing
between souls/spiritbomb
and soulcleave
not bdk levels but theyd be second i think
Sounds cool
theyre i nice tank to alt with since its mainly 4 keybinds + some cd binds
The whole soul cleave vs spirit bomb dynamic still confuses me
Feels like they’re the same ability
you treat it like st vs aoe
Like I don’t get it
Being able to double jump and glide are also as addictive as crack
you spend resource in SpB whenever theres 2 or more targets
that may have changed slightly
check the guide
Will do
or to maintain the healing buff it applies
blizz should give wow the wildstar treatment
every class double jumps and has 2charge dash
imagine double jump warrior and 2 dashes on top of 2x charge and heroic leap
Lol

rip wildstar
i didnt play it much but i thought it was fun
i think they screwd themselves too much catering to hardcore players
also 0 updates
Yeah i didnt get a chance to try that one
but i heard end game was extremely difficult
from Maximum
i believe to get into endgame


