#protection

1 messages · Page 532 of 1

rose orchid
#

prot war brez? yell in their dead face "WAKE UP YOU'RE NOT DONE YET"

jagged pier
#

no skill expression in the class anymore

crude notch
#

you'd be in trouble if there was

jagged pier
rose orchid
#

I thought the charge intervene meta of s3 of shadowlands was fun but overall current prot war is so much smoother feeling

jagged pier
#

brah that was in the first patch on SLs

#

came in the .5 patch

rose orchid
#

well with the double legendaries i mean

crude notch
#

huh

jagged pier
#

literally didnt change anything expect u got more rage because of banner

#

didnt change the charge intervene thing

rose orchid
#

oh yeah ok

echo egret
#

That's me trying to Storm Bolt the cast on normal difficulty

rose orchid
#

i misremember

limpid anchor
jagged pier
#

backpeddling is fine

#

S key very strong this season

echo egret
#

One less stun to worry about.

quasi lintel
#

you're lying that I should be building crit instead of vers...

#

you have to be..

#

i'm gonna kms

jagged pier
#

u dont have

#

to

#

its prefernce

#

but your vers isnt gunna save u

#

but parrying that boss mechanic can

#

like searing blows in RLP last season parrable

rose orchid
crimson hornet
#

you heard him boys, vers is useless. crit is better then haste. go ham. (it's a joke im sorry lol)

quasi lintel
#

I'm fake experienced at this game boys and need some advice. Can I get a TLDR of the mechanic behind dodge/parry/block?

jagged pier
#

i didnt say crit was better than haste

crimson hornet
#

100% quote ./s

chrome falcon
#

with 447 shield we just open as fury right

#

the vault that is

quasi lintel
#

Cause I thoguth parry was only for auto attacks but people kept saying to use the Dancing Rune Weapon for certain mechanics so now I'm thinking I don't know anything

jagged pier
#

dodge and parry u take no damage block is reduced by your block chance

warm plinth
#

Crit probably IS better than haste for straight damage tbf, unless you have very little haste

#

But haste is great for both damage and survival

jagged pier
chrome falcon
crimson hornet
chrome falcon
#

it's not consistent at all

chrome falcon
#

but that would drop for fury

jagged pier
#

yes

chrome falcon
#

i have 447 shield and the tank trinkets suck

crimson hornet
#

i see

chrome falcon
#

so imma just open as fury

jagged pier
#

yes

quasi lintel
#

I got a 441 haste/vers weapon from vault and I crafted my 447 shield with shadowflame patch

chrome falcon
quasi lintel
#

now I'm not gonna be so stingy about using crit/haste gear (i've been getting crit haste all season)

#

literally picked up arms because of it

chrome falcon
#

oh shit

#

444 class trinket is this thing gaming for us

#

it seemed kinda doggy on bloodmallet

quasi lintel
#

how true is this:
Haste>Vers=Crit>Mastery

rose orchid
#

So the Mark Of Dargul trinket is solid? I have 424 4/8 champion right now. Worth upgrading to 8/8 champion?

jagged pier
vivid abyss
#

is that trinket good for us or nah?

jagged pier
#

nope

chrome falcon
#

yeah i mean i can see that it's listed there but i don't know how much it's actually good 🤔

#

no

#

that shit sucks

jagged pier
#

its good in aoe

chrome falcon
#

that's a bad vault

#

yeesh

jagged pier
#

as it says in the pins

#

what yah mean thats bis tmog right there

torn gust
#

Praise the pins

opal flame
#

Neltharion's Call to Chaos - does the benefit outweighs the negatives? I feel like I'm gonna die almost half of a dungeon on big pulls

chrome falcon
#

if you're dying from taking 5% more damage

#

then that's a problem

#

you need to fix

jagged pier
#

^

marble cipher
#

when it procs, you're killing the mobs also 5% faster, so, 😝

opal flame
#

cool, I'll get it from the vault, thanks boys 🙂

crimson hornet
#

good shit i didnt have to think about, got my heroic leg piece from the vault

#

i go Bolster with 2s i assume?

jagged pier
#

in raid

limpid anchor
jagged pier
#

in m+ wait for 4pc

crimson hornet
#

thanks

jagged pier
#

well up to u with 2pc tbh

#

if u want practice for 4 set just change now

crimson hornet
#

yea exactly my thought

quasi lintel
jagged pier
#

up to u#

#

2pc 2pc is fine

tight hedge
#

So, new weapon enchants, what are we taking?

jagged pier
quasi lintel
#

Irideus Fragment or Whetstone (already have icon) (don't know how to sim myself)

jagged pier
#

u get the addon simcraft

#

u log in game

#

u type /simc

#

u copy the output

#

u go to raidbots

#

u choose top gear

#

u paste the output in the box

quasi lintel
jagged pier
#

and the u scroll down till u see the trinkets choose which ones u one to see the difference u scroll to the bottom u press run sim

tight hedge
#

@jagged pier I appreciate what you're trying to achieve - but sometimes people just want to be given an answer

jagged pier
tight hedge
#

not a way to get the answer themselves

jagged pier
#

cant give the answer its based on there char

#

like every piece of gear it answer will always be

#

sim yourself

#

we cant give u the answer your characters are not ours

tight hedge
#

in the case of enchants, it shouldnt matter what gear you are in, some clearly outpreform others

quasi lintel
#

No what he said was better I feel annoying asking questions every 2 seconds

jagged pier
#

nope

quasi lintel
#

needed to learn how to sim anyway

marble cipher
#

not specific to this discussion at all, but, learning how to sim your character is way too important to miss out on

jagged pier
#

3 enchants for wep are so close for us

marble cipher
#

it helps soooo much

jagged pier
#

it actually does depend on your gear

marble cipher
#

(and isn't hard at all since raidbots exists)

jagged pier
#

sophic was simming highest for me until i got more gear

chrome falcon
#

ayy what the fuck this trinket's proc rate is terrible

#

i just fought a rare for 1 minute and 20 seconds before it procced

#

(neltharions)

tight hedge
jagged pier
#

no because i have different gear than u

tight hedge
#

not sounding like a twat and just typing "sim yo self"

jagged pier
#

nome and me have different enchants and around the same gear

#

because diifferent ones simmed higher

jagged pier
marble cipher
#

the answer "sim you self" isn't sounding like a twat, cause it is the correct answer in 99% of the cases

jagged pier
#

99% of the questions about vault or enchants literally solved yourself it u sim yourself takes 2 mins to do as well

chrome falcon
#

ok i can't tell what's going on but

#

this class trinket's proc rate is absolute dogass

jagged pier
#

🤷

sonic moon
#

What does shield block even do even

jagged pier
#

makes u block all physical attacks that can be block in a 180 cone in front of u

#

block reduces the damage of these attacks by block value on your shield

sonic moon
#

God damnit Jakey

#

Why do you do this to yourself

rose orchid
#

What phial you use in m+? I didn't see anything in the pinned posts

jagged pier
#

vers

rose orchid
#

you trolling me brah?

jagged pier
#

no all the phials suck

#

vers is by proxy the best cause its 3% damage

#

which is the most of them all

#

the 1.5% damage reduction is not why we take it

#

u can go eye of the storm if u want

#

but on bosses its garbo

rose orchid
#

so NOW verse is good?? i feel like im taking crazy pills

#

jk

#

Ok thanks man

#

i been using eye of storm forever but i'll try out the verse one

iron cosmos
#

Did you guys open vault as prot or fury?

jagged pier
#

fury but i have shield

iron cosmos
#

Yeah I have shield as well

#

Gonna do fury too

opal flame
rose orchid
#

yo verse phial is way cheaper than eye of the storm, that's the real reason to use it

jagged pier
rose orchid
#

i been spending like 40k gold per week on phials

#

rip me

jagged pier
iron cosmos
chrome falcon
#

only tier i got offered was an upgrade on my LFR hands

#

would have definitely taken any other tier over this dumb class trinket

#

i guess i'll see how it does in a key

chrome falcon
rose orchid
#

Jakey what weapon enhancement you use? 135 attack power or the other one?

jagged pier
#

haste or crit rune

rose orchid
#

i've just been wrong about everything my whole life it seems

#

thanks again man

jagged pier
#

hey your using the discord to improve

#

thats better than most ppl

rose orchid
#

❤️

cunning knot
#

Do we use LS as def or off now

warm plinth
#

Offensive, on CD

jagged pier
#

u use it on CD

cunning knot
#

fair

quasi lintel
#

last stand?

jagged pier
#

its part of your block now

cunning knot
#

my block?

quasi lintel
#

core rot

jagged pier
#

well u take bolster with the new tier set

#

so u need to use LS on CD to keep block up

crude notch
#

@warm plinth hello qt, wut vault?

rose orchid
#

Thoughts on dropping enduring defenses in order to get unnerving focus, bolster, and spell block? (assuming you have 4 set)?

#

for m+

jagged pier
#

u drop BS

#

not enduring

#

the talents and the explanation are in the pins

tidal forge
#

Where can I see trinket list in vault for fury spec?

crude notch
#

by going through every dungeon and raid with fury loot spec selected

chrome falcon
#

i'm not sure where you can find a list but it doesn't really matter because the tank trinkets are kinda doo doo

#

just open in fury if you already have a crafted shield

rose orchid
#

why fueled by violence over brutal vitality?

dark lark
#

With the 4p, do I want the post LS buff to line up with avatar? How would this work out on a practical level in m+?

jagged pier
#

no

#

during LS ss damage is increased

#

so u want avatar for that

night heron
#

Hello guys, I wanted to know what you think : I already have a 441 weapon and a 447 shield ; so should I open the vauld with dps specialization for offensive trinkets or should i stay with protection ?

chrome falcon
#

open in fury

#

or maybe arms if your 441 is forgestorm

jagged pier
rose orchid
#

ok thank you

#

ive gone back and forth between the two several times, it's hard to decide. I ~feel like~ brutal vitality is slightly better

boreal wave
#

Heart of Thunder fucks in keys. This is my PSA

night heron
tidal forge
dusty monolith
#

@rose orchid 17 nelt 66k at 426 for reference to your key earlier, pulled quite conservative still timed comfortably

#

and no forgestorm drop qq

rose orchid
#

nice im miron

#

i'll try it again later. i had a mage do 45k overall in the run i did i think the entire run was just going very bad

dusty monolith
#

only died to a bolstered warden 620k tankbuster kekw

rose orchid
#

yeah

#

i think pulling more than 5 or 6 mobs at a time in there (other than the birds they dont bolster) is bad news

sharp ruin
#

after the shield 447 , in your opinion guys what is the best piece to craft?

#

i'm looking that the shoulders of the set give us haste mastery (with more mastery) maybe craft the shoulders haste versa can be a good choice?

dusty monolith
#

its really situational, depending on what gear you got from m+ raid vault so far

frosty mist
#

Hi guys, question for mm+ build, I see in the pin post thats we may take spellblock (droping punish or another talent), but dont think discruptive shout is good to have too ?

dusty monolith
sharp ruin
sharp ruin
#

cause the head of the set Crit Haste (even if more crit) are not bad stats for us

dusty monolith
dusty monolith
sharp ruin
#

yeah that's true , was thinking about the back

#

but the last boss back is so op

#

so i really don't know xD

dusty monolith
#

Back from endboss is BiS, you could go for frostfire belt if you want or if you'd like two shadowflame patch embellishments go for boots or wrist

jagged pier
#

u can just craft a belt to take over the frostfire spot as well

dusty monolith
#

^ also valid option

sharp ruin
#

u think is better frostfire or 2xshadowflame?

dusty monolith
#

that we havent quite figured out yet. personally i'm going with ffb + one shadowflame patch

warm plinth
frosty mist
warm plinth
#

They sim within margin of error from each other

dusty monolith
#

but I dont play in 3.3k rio range so that one percent difference (if even that much) doesnt matter

dusty monolith
sharp ruin
#

i prefer 2x shadowflame , but maybe better on wrist , cause there are not good wrists ? 😄

jagged pier
#

last boss drops great wrists

sharp ruin
#

oh true

jagged pier
sharp ruin
#

giga good

dusty monolith
#

if you dont have a raid to kill him in hc i'd say 447 crafted > 437 upgraded wrists from sarkareth normal

sharp ruin
#

same for the belt , cause a very big belt drop from 4th boss and a bis one drop from freehold

dusty monolith
#

now you see why there is no bis list and its a individual choice

jagged pier
#

pretty sure belt is more stats than wrists

#

wasting a craft on low budget items early is kinda cringe

warm plinth
#

Yeah belt is more stats by quite a bit

#

Wrists and cloak are the two lowest budget slots you have

dusty monolith
#

True if you min max Jakey then again depends on what they currently have in their waist/belt slot

sick sentinel
#

Is there a good way for us to sim? Obv we can do damage sim, but lets say i wanna change s1 crit haste wrist with crit versa ones at a higher ilvl ( 7 higher). Its worse stats but i lose out on mainstat

warm plinth
#

My 415 belt has more stats than my 428 bracers by a significant amount

dusty monolith
#

raidbots gear compare and edit the gearsets Hinge

dusty monolith
#

could also go for boots, they have the same amount of stats as belt

quasi lintel
#

what tier piece do we not want?

dusty monolith
#

the one we get last copium

jagged pier
#

^

#

your thinking to long term for now

dusty monolith
#

a 444 or 447 tier from vault with "worse" stats can outperform a 441 from raid with good stats, so it really isnt set in stone as far as i understood

jagged pier
#

correct

young rampart
#

guys if i dont take the vault now and play m+ does it count to my vault for next week?

jagged pier
#

ye

dusty monolith
#

yes

young rampart
#

thx

warm plinth
#

Pretty sure the corollaries are this in order of highest to lowest stat budgets (main armor pieces):

  1. Helm/Chest/Legs
  2. Belt/Boots/Shoulders/Gloves
  3. Cloak/Wrists
#

Might have the middle two swapped, lemme check

dusty monolith
#

gloves boots shoulders belt have same amount of stats

jagged pier
#

yer but 2 of them are tier slots

warm plinth
#

Ah so they do

hardy snow
#

spell reflect on last boss of Halls is pretty cool okayge

jagged pier
#

yep

night heron
#

Should I get the 447 boots (even though it's crit/mastery) or the 441 (with upgrades) hands tier set?

potent gulch
#

i'm thinking of crafting chest ;>

night heron
#

Raidbot tells me boots are 1,4% dps increase in AoE vs 1% for hands

potent gulch
jagged pier
#

its big on the 3rd boss of halls if u time it right and get all frost shocks

hardy snow
#

last one in neltharions lair as well

#

is there a way to SR all molten crashes?

#

yesterday I had cd on every 2nd only, not every cast

jagged pier
#

spell queu

dusty monolith
jagged pier
#

but not reliable

tame jasper
hardy snow
sleek current
#

Before it I believe.

tame jasper
jagged pier
#

landside is a seperate thing he just does

night heron
#

Thanks for the answer!

hardy snow
#

sorry, i messed up with lair's boss

tame jasper
#

all finde 😄

hardy snow
#

in halls its cast after the knockback

dusty monolith
hardy snow
#

both knockback and dot are reflectable, but dot (deluge skill) does more dmg

night heron
dry spear
granite pond
#

Sim question: still learning this, is there a way to sim gear as if it was upgraded to max? Like see if a ring would be better than my current stuff if I upgraded it

night heron
dry spear
#

i'm sitting on hc shoulders and 2 omni tokens. i could take hc hands and run 2/2 piece or wait to loot one item in the raid and get full 4 p. but i was reading here earlier, that 2/2 isnt a bad way to keep.

dusty monolith
#

2/2 if your 2 new pieces are >15 ilvl upgrades (e.g. going from 421 to fully upgraded normal 437)

zealous spade
#

how much dps increase the tier 2 bonus in general?

dusty monolith
#

yes

tidal forge
#

Is fury spec now gets 2h and 1h weapons in vault?

#

Change loot for fury and get 2x 2h weapons..

potent gulch
hardy snow
winged sage
#

Is there any mob in freehold or boss for that matter that takes increased dmg?

warm plinth
#

The last boss takes increased damage during the last 30%

#

And there is a spell used by mobs on the last island that does damage to mobs around it, though that's not technically increased damage

winged sage
#

oh yea! the last boss, did a 434k crit with shield slam, so got super confused 😄

warm plinth
#

Yeah it's this fella

winged sage
#

aaw, just got super stoked when I saw the crit in details, but that makes sense 😄

obsidian rampart
#

Hi guys, what is the best slot for the part ?

granite pond
#

The best slot for the part! Answer the man! The part!

plush moat
#

guys a friend of mine told me prot warrior is the worst tank, what do i tell him ....

mental scarab
#

He is a idjet

#

We can cheese alot of stuff

#

Block and SR

#

And We take zero dmg compared to other tanks

#

”Oh no a tank Buster”

#

Block

hardy snow
#

good luck with blocking zskarn's claws on mythic deadge

serene steppe
#

Has anyone found an m+ boss or trash pack where spell block was particularly good? I think the trash after frog boss in HoI but apart from that I cant think where else it can be used

crude notch
#

Good luck with blocking dn

cinder nova
#

bruh 4p is carpal tunnel

#

I barely take my finger off SS

sonic moon
#

Can't wait to get pocket anvil. Shield slam gonna smack.

cinder nova
#

I wonder if LFR anvil is worth it

serene steppe
limpid anchor
#

From chain guy to armor

jagged pier
#

wardens its good on

#

halls a tone of trash

#

u can just look at the sheet

#

and choose for yourself

limpid anchor
#

Also first part of neltharud if you don’t want to dodge the blazing slash

serene steppe
#

Ye I did, just seems like there is a lot less use for it this season compared to last

limpid anchor
#

Which is good

jagged pier
#

good

#

we dont have the point for it anyway

tight gull
cinder nova
#

Wow that's a dogshit vault

#

My condolences.

tight gull
#

Kinda 😅

cinder nova
#

What are the stats on the neck

#

That seems like the best take since you gotta unseat lariat anyway

#

And catalyst is over a month out, so trying to hold pieces is kinda clowning

tight gull
#

I can drop that vault into a socket and bait on a longer proc for that lariat some days....

#

Neck is crit vers. Seems ok thow

cinder nova
#

idk even a 441 crit/vers is good

strong forum
cinder nova
#

it's just no haste kinda blows

strong forum
cinder nova
#

Really? The orb?

strong forum
#

Yes

#

It's the new icon

#

It's really good on aoe

tight gull
#

It's kinda strength and will be for me haste

#

It helps a lot in aoe by tic I zgree

vocal nimbus
#

Thought you can only dodge the frontal cone

limpid anchor
#

Yes you can

cinder nova
vocal nimbus
#

Sidestep?

cinder nova
#

Why is just heaping stats so much better that something like say, Ulurogg

tight gull
#

Overall DMG I guess

fallow beacon
#

heroic logs kinda free when everyone has switched to pally 👀

strong forum
uneven mason
tight gull
#

As it is not timegatted you will keep doing more DMG with is it at the end of our runs

uneven mason
#

And prot has strong ae cd

strong forum
limpid anchor
fallow beacon
#

but now they are free-er!

tight gull
#

So it's actually a really good drop 😅

strong forum
jagged pier
#

i mean depends when u do them as well

strong forum
#

Ye

fallow beacon
#

we are oceanic nz guild

#

so pretty arly

#

early*

limpid anchor
#

Very gear dependent tho

jagged pier
#

i mean its not

#

i was r1 in a lot of fights last week

#

being 10ish ilvls behind

#

the other top prots

strong forum
#

Rn logs come down to: 4pc trinket and forgestorm

#

If you have beacon + 4pc already

jagged pier
#

like on zskarn i was 6k ahead of someone with new 4 piece

cinder nova
#

I got forge and 4p

limpid anchor
#

Idk not having beacon, 4p and forge is huge

#

Doesn’t mean others aren’t shit

strong forum
#

If you have beacon + 4pc + a guild that can actually kill bosses at a decent pace

#

You're pretty much guaranteed to have a 99

#

Or 100

jagged pier
#

wish i had beacon

crude notch
#

Sense's beacon beating all your asses

jagged pier
#

i was beating him on sarc until he recleared yesterday

strong forum
#

Sense R1 on kazzara is 7k ahead cuz his killtime is 30sec faster than anyone else + beacon + it's sense

fallow beacon
#

mans doing 5k more than me on sark wtf

#

filthy padder

strong forum
#

Get skill issued

fallow beacon
#

bet his beacon crit

strong forum
fallow beacon
#

copium.jpg

hasty wigeon
#

Having a hard deciding what to pick here. I'm thinking the ring which has got a gem slot but wondering if I should take the tier piece but it will cost me a lot to upgrade it plus I will lose the S1 set bonus and I don't have any other S2 tier pieces

jagged pier
crude notch
jagged pier
#

i have 10 less ilvls and no beacon

fallow beacon
fallow beacon
crude notch
#

<Fluffy Lemon Noodles>

wtf

#

Jakey?

strong forum
#

Socket is a bit spicy on ring that's true

jagged pier
#

it was a good clean kill tbh

strong forum
#

So it's up to you really

#

Can't help you with that

crude notch
#

You got the typical super serious guild names like <Nurfed> and <Miracle> then you get <Fluffy Lemon Noodles>

jagged pier
#

im casual now

fallow beacon
#

beat him on experiments tho lesgooo

fallow beacon
#

heroic logs are important right guys

crude notch
#

They're important to someone

fallow beacon
#

😄

strong forum
#

Kill time will always play a role

#

It's just how it is

#

It's more of a factor in heroic than in mythic

jagged pier
crude notch
#

Jakey's guild too slow

strong forum
#

Cuz mythic takes longer to have way faster kill times

#

Heroic is meme anyway

crude notch
#

7m sark among all those 6m

jagged pier
#

they both on us schedules

#

we eu

light bison
#

what gear are you guys crafting?

fallow beacon
#

yeah we finished raid 2 hours ago

#

so we way ahead of eu

jagged pier
#

still not like ill get close im not high on the beacon list

strong forum
limpid anchor
strong forum
jagged pier
#

i know

strong forum
#

Tanks, just like with grieftorch, are the best for it

fallow beacon
#

just roll a 98

#

its that easy

light bison
limpid anchor
junior brook
#

do we keep eranog ring (with frostfire belt) for entire raiding or replace at some point?

limpid anchor
#

You replace the belt

#

But Eranog is gonna be at your side for the season (or until nerfs)

cinder nova
#

Could probably safely drop it in M+

#

Maybe crack it out on Tyr

serene steppe
#

How do you proc the ring without belt?

dusty monolith
#

new weapon enchant

serene steppe
#

oh okay

limpid anchor
dusty monolith
#

I mainly play m+ and will get a 447 frostfire belt with one Shadowflame Armor Patch as it is a very very minor dps loss. i just like the belt and the animation and proc

rough thorn
#

how is shadowflame wreathe for us?

limpid anchor
dusty monolith
#

447 FFB sims 200dps over 447 crafted haste/vers with shadowflame armor patch for me

#

pretty neglectable tbh

jagged pier
#

what about it?

jagged pier
strong forum
#

as i said in the pin

#

the difference is negligible

sick sentinel
#

your name reminds me of the teacher from beavis and butthead, mr van Driessen

dusty monolith
#

Dreizehn is the german word for thirteen (13), and I had a huge crush on olivia wilde in dr house back when I made that char

serene steppe
#

damn thats some lore

hollow hill
#

is enduring dreadplate pretty meh like the wowhead guide says or is there some disagreement with that?

#

nvm i used the search function

#

I see it has been talked about

frosty mist
#

Question about weapon and Shield, in the pin it speak about forgestorm and crafted Shield, wowhead speak about another weapon and Shield. I don't know which one follow. 😅 I dont use my shadowflame spark so I can still choose my first craft.

strong forum
#

forgestorm is more dmg than crafted weapon

#

wowhead listed a normal weapon cuz its probably a tiny bit more defensive

hollow hill
#

yea it simmed -1500 dps over my ol blazebinder's hoof

frosty mist
#

Ok, but forgestorm has to drop also. Dont' know when I could loot it. Atm I have 421 crafted Sword.

limpid anchor
#

Anyone got a log with the deadplate?

strong forum
#

it doesnt show up on healing

#

its just a flat -7k on dmg events

#

for 15sec

heavy sinew
#

the new set pieces are not upgradable right?

#

with like crests

mystic breach
#

Tried to check on pins and older messages but I got lost, Enduring Dreadplate or Shard of Rokmora from the vault? Both Champion (the only hero is a crit/mastery ring...), I have shitty trinket rn

heavy sinew
#

i mean there are alot of trinkets that are very simillar to shard

#

which are not too hard to get

#

personally id prob go plate but idk

#

dont take my word for it

potent gulch
#

is becon 2 secon cast?

icy atlas
heavy sinew
steel fossil
#

so when we craft shield do we craft Shadowed Impact Buckler or A Molten Defender?

heavy sinew
#

just couse i got 441 shoulders from vault and i dont see an option to upgrade them

heavy sinew
#

i see thx

steel fossil
#

i mean primal molten defender with a patch

heavy sinew
#

molten

mystic breach
heavy sinew
#

it's also more fun that shard : D

#

more numbers

serene steppe
#

Shard is just absorb, other one does some dmg

limpid anchor
strong forum
#

its bad

#

pao mega reverse engineered how the trinket works

#

and its just -7k dmg taken on dmg events for 15seconds

#

no matter how many plates you have

ember tangle
#

Is there a set order for mitigation being applied? Is it armor then Block then trinket then ignore pain for example?

strong forum
#

block is just armor but 2x

#

every % mitigation is multiplicative so it doesnt really matter in which order those happen

#

but its %DR > absorbs > ignore pain

jagged pier
#

then codex

strong forum
#

yeah and codex after all of that

jagged pier
#

brah it was so strong tho

#

couldnt go past 2% DR for prot

#

but it was apprently must have

strong forum
#

love losing 7% dmg and being 7% weaker defensively

strong forum
#

but atleast i gain a details bar

jagged pier
#

KEKW

soft plume
#

yo im getting chunked in 18s, any advice?

dusty monolith
#

got any logs for us to go through Antivist?

soft plume
#

nope every key i have joined since last night has failed and i havn't kept logs of it sorry

sick sentinel
#

specific bosses and what you theorize may have happened helps too if you don't have log

soft plume
#

uh the trash murders me

#

in neltharions lair the enemies get like 10 bolsters right off the bat

harsh trellis
#

Well it's trash week don't overpull and dps down evenly

soft plume
#

in halls of infusion just pulling one pack at a time i feel like im a constant state of clinging on to a thread of life

harsh trellis
#

Hoi is aids atm

#

At 16 not so bad but 17 and 18 are meh

soft plume
#

i have only been in 17s and 18s and yeah i've been questioning everything, i just got my 4pc and i was even wondering if losing my old 10.0 2pc made me weaker

dusty monolith
#

any chance you could link your raider.io profile maybe your chars equip is lacking a bit for 18s

soft plume
dusty monolith
#

get 447 shield

#

makes a huge difference in defense

soft plume
#

how do you do that

dusty monolith
#

craft one with the new spark

soft plume
#

dont i need a special power infusion or something

dusty monolith
#

I noticed great improvement in terms of defense when I got my 447 shield compared to my 421, got mine just yesterday as well because I didnt think it would be that much of a difference

jagged pier
#

palcebo

dusty monolith
#

you need 4 aspects crests, get a enchanter to craft an enchanted aspects crests

jagged pier
#

it will make a difference

dusty monolith
#

and primal molten alloy thats it i think

harsh trellis
#

What shield specifically?

dusty monolith
#

primal molten defender

jagged pier
#

but playing correct will be far greater than just getting a higher ilvl shield

soft plume
#

so its worth using my aspect crests to just make a shield?

harsh trellis
soft plume
#

i have 5 aspect crests atm and i have hoarded most of the crests since i wasnt sure how hard they would be to get with the limited amounts

dusty monolith
#

you also got a spark laying around? with this ID you should have gotten your second since 10.1

sick sentinel
#

whats the 3 gems its recommended to use in the lariat ?

soft plume
#

i have a spark of shadowflame yes

dusty monolith
#

It helped me, might not be the only thing to improve upon but wont hurt for sure

#

getting the 447 shield that is

harsh trellis
sick sentinel
dusty monolith
#

best way for me to learn was to log keys or even better record the gameplay, I noticed I dropped Ignore Pain or Shield Block when first starting to tank and overcapped rage, didnt kick/stun/reflect when available etc.

harsh trellis
#

I like to use subcreation to see what everyone is using for whatever key. And then I like to use keystone guru for pulls

jagged pier
soft plume
#

which neck should i get to replace lariat

#

so i can amke shadowflame patch on shield

strong forum
#

subcreation only shows whats popular

#

not whats good

harsh trellis
#

Right

#

Use it as a guide

jagged pier
mental scarab
#

btw how did we get the spark again

#

and 444 Tongue Hacker in first vault 😄

sick sentinel
#

with 2 set and last stand up. Do we change from revenge to shield slam

#

or first with 4 set

opal flame
#

check your reagents bank if you use that, I've forgot I put one there in "move all reagents"

odd tree
#

1st spark was from a quest, but i think you can loot them from dungeon chests, raid bosses, and epic loot bags from world quests

mental scarab
#

wtf is loom quest

harsh trellis
#

Loam

#

New area

mental scarab
#

oh

odd tree
#

i got half a spark from a dungeon yesterday. you get 1 every 2 weeks, this week was the 2nd spark

mental scarab
#

oh

#

thats the shadowflame thigny golden icon

mystic breach
urban bane
strong forum
#

i wouldnt use either nezha

#

both are whack

harsh trellis
daring marlin
#

How's the trash in VP this week, lads?

toxic pewter
#

Last pack is strong

round pendant
#

I still have my lariat from season 1, do I drop it?

jagged pier
#

ye

vocal nimbus
#

how can we dodge blazing slash from qalashi wardens in neltharus?

jagged pier
#

spell block

vocal nimbus
#

read here that it can be dodged, sadge

harsh trellis
#

You can just wait for cast and side step

vocal nimbus
#

nah you cant

#

thats the other skill

knotty stump
#

Is there a spell block weakaura that is updated for Season 2? I'm talking about a weakaura similar to the season 1 one that would tell you if the incoming spell was reflectable.

hardy snow
knotty stump
#

tells if the spell is reflectable

#

The one I used for season one doesn't seem to be updated

#

The one in resources appears to be out of date as well

hushed harbor
# jagged pier spell block

Reading the pins it looks like there are a couple (unfortunate) talents we can drop to get shield block. In Neltharus, what would be best to swap out?

jagged pier
#

u mean spell block and as it says in the pins

#

u drop bloodsurge

hushed harbor
#

Yeah sorry. Ok that one instead of punish got it

#

Thank you

jagged pier
#

u really dont want to drop punish

hushed harbor
#

Ok cool.

#

Spell block is the balls.

jagged pier
#

i mean it has cases in like 2 dungeons but okay

daring marlin
#

It's not very good in most dungeons this time around

#

then again it was only great in like two dungeons last season too 👀

soft plume
#

with 4pc should i spam last stand for optimal dps gains

dusky canopy
#

no id hold it

strong forum
#

just send it

#

its 1min CD with bolster

dusky canopy
wary spire
#

Aren't we supposed to get a splintered spark this week?

jagged pier
#

yes if u do your rep quest

wary spire
#

Ty

daring marlin
toxic pewter
#

That event in the middle of the cavern gives 1k rep by the way

daring marlin
#

Just be a loser like me and hold your rep tokens(don't actually do that)

toxic pewter
#

That works

daring marlin
#

researcher event is pretty quick

dusky canopy
#

oh im holding mind too LOL

#

can not be bothered to do world content if i can avoid it

wary spire
daring marlin
#

I actually didn't do campaign last week so I had two 2500 tokens chillin

#

Now I have one for next week too

#

Quick valdrakken and loam rep quest completes!

twin bramble
#

Which piece of gear are we supposed to put shadow flame armor patch on? Frost fire belt already has embellishment and the other two items to craft are weapons.

jagged pier
#

u can put it on shield wrists belt and just recraft belt

#

u wont be crafting wep

twin bramble
#

Oh heck yeah. Thanks!

#

I ready crafted weapon 👀 I’ll put it on shield.

twin bramble
#

Wowhead said to get primal molten main hand first! 😂

twin bramble
#

So frostfire belt and primal molten defender with shadow flame tempered armor patch is a good approach to the two embellishments?

jagged pier
#

yes

twin bramble
#

Awesome. Thanks.

proud patrol
#

I keep hearing that spell block is only good in two dungeons (Neltharus and Neltharions Lair I think?) - is it just because there’s a lot to block or something specific?

jagged pier
#

both

twin bramble
#

The link above is my go to (in pin) and it helps answer your question

proud patrol
#

Thanks!

twin bramble
runic hatch
#

How do you guys deal with the dragon breath in halls? It's wrecking my ass.

jagged pier
#

spell block or your S key

twin bramble
trim pumice
#

Was looking through faq/pins and didn’t see, what wep enchant do you guys recommend? Just started playing warr for alt (m+ only) and was looking at top rio and was a mix of sophic/frozen/shadowflame

jagged pier
twin bramble
runic hatch
jagged pier
mystic breach
runic hatch
#

Will do

dusky canopy
#

holy shit guys blazing slash in neltharus TRUCKS

jagged pier
#

yes

dusky canopy
#

just ran a 19 and man

#

getting blasted for like 50% hp it felt like

strong forum
#

That's why it's a Spellblock dungeon

#

Sucks to use it for just 2 packs

jagged pier
#

^

strong forum
#

But it do be like that

dusky canopy
#

drop blood surge?

jagged pier
#

if u have tier yer

dusky canopy
#

oh wait i dont have new tier set so old talent build duh

#

lol

twin bramble
graceful kite
#

I forgot something - if I don't pick anything from the vault and do an m+, will I get a key I shuold've gotten from the vault or will it depend on that m+ level?

trim pumice
#

same level as vault would be

#

can also open the chest and not loot the key and keep doing keys until you get the key you want

graceful kite
#

thanks

daring marlin
wary spire
#

Are fortified weeks generally more difficult as tank? New to tanking so prolly a dumb q

plush tendon
#

Pretty much

#

Fort weeks is when as a tank you really have to cycle through CDs properly and control packs much more effectivly

#

Tyran weeks are our lazy weeks

daring marlin
#

especially now

#

Not many tankbusters to worry about this season

plush tendon
#

much like last week, I expect we will see a plethora of nerfs

#

hopfully

glad flax
#

hello! are we supposed to get a 2nd Spark of Shadowflame this week?

daring marlin
#

lots of noodle damage bosses

#

for tanks at least lmao

daring marlin
#

Get that 👜

glad flax
#

[A Worthy Ally: Loamm Niffen] you mean this one?

plush tendon
trim pumice
#

Yeah those give half a spark per week, so you get the full spark every 2 weeks from it. If you miss a week they can randomly drop from dungeon/raid etc

strong forum
#

feelsgood

pastel sleet
#

question:

I just recieved a 1/5 hero shield as a drop.
i havent crafted either of my sparks.

i was planning on crafting the primal shield at 447.

do i follow through with that or level up the hero shield and craft a different piece for more power now

strong forum
strong forum
#

and shield is the most important item

pastel sleet
#

so craft shield and just vendor the hero shield?

dusky canopy
#

thats what i would do

strong forum
#

if you want to be optimal, yeah pmuch

#

unless you wanna gamble on getting a 447 from vault

#

for weeks on end

pastel sleet
#

hm

strong forum
#

dargrul you can reflect most of em

#

same goes for 2nd boss

#

but occasionally you have to eat or 1 or 2

#

the only scary boss for tanks in the current dungeon pool is last boss brackenhide tbh

#

and thats just a healing absorb but not infinite dmg intake coupled with it

daring marlin
#

It's honestly hilarious to me cuz

#

Dargrul terrifies me on my Pally but BH last boss I laugh in WoG

dusky canopy
#

yeah last boss BH is nothing compared to TJS

#

we were thoroughly prepared

#

LOL

daring marlin
#

idk what they were thinking frankly

pastel atlas
#

which piece of the tier do we play without, assuming we have all 5? Chest?

dusky canopy
#

any piece without haste

#

is bad

plush tendon
#

chest if you get a 450 chest

daring marlin
#

Liu was such a shit boss

pastel atlas
#

pants it is

plush tendon
#

pantaloons 😦

#

gonna make some crafted pants XD

#

once I get more tier

deep cairn
#

is thera macro for tracking 4set dmg bonus component?

#

i mean weaka ura

dusky canopy
#

i dont think its worth the mental

#

just push last stand and send

deep cairn
#

but the dmg is only after alst stand ends right?

fresh igloo
#

you're not really going to change anything though

#

our core game play is use shield slam as much as possible, then thunder clap, then revenge. Keep SB up, use IP to not over cap rage.

#

doing more damage when LS ends doesn't change that.

sick sentinel
#

new launcher thingies

toxic pewter
#

mine doesnt have that hmmm

strong forum
#

Beta Client has had that for weeks

toxic pewter
#

interesting beta client

#

switching to beta now

sick sentinel
#

log out

#

it logged me out., so

#

or, wanted me to relogin more specfici

crude notch
sick sentinel
#

How's the rotation once you get 2set? do we pump shieldslam into aoe packs to reduce the cd of last stand?

crystal mauve
#

Has anyone had some great experience in Nelthrus this week? I got my ass handed hover by synchronized tank buster in our 20 yesterday. 0.5s cast time and hit for 750k fire damage each, fun times…

crystal mauve
sick sentinel
#

but revenge is more damage no?

#

on aoe

#

before 4 set

#

but thanks ill slam some more

twin bramble
urban bane
crystal mauve
urban bane
#

oh gotcha

#

yeah molten blazing slash is a spell block angle from what i've seen ppls say thus far. havent done it myself this week though so 🤷‍♂️

dusky canopy
#

oh yeah night and day difference

#

spell block for blazing slashes

frank saddle
#

i've heard people speculate that the 59k value here only actives if 1 hit exceeds it

blissful sable
#

Create 2 shadowflame is better or 1 shadowflame + frostfire? which one have more sim?

dusty monolith
#

I'm currently 427 and ffb+patch sim better than 2 patch

dusky canopy
#

double shadowflame is roughly 200dps better at same ilvl becuase you can do prefered stats

dusty monolith
dusky canopy
#

idk what you're simming but orange man confirmed

dusty monolith
#

orange man also said if you dont have bis end of season gear ffb might be better

dusky canopy
#

ok so go double shadowflame so youre ready to go

dusty monolith
#

sure, its personal preference both are fine

strong forum
#

All depends on your gear

#

For myself shadowflame simmed less than ffb

#

With bis gear, it simmed slightly better

prisma crane
#

either way it falls, i at least appreciate that it's closer to 2-3% of dmg than the 1% it was

#

last season they were emborishments

chrome falcon
#

so nom assuming you have all cooldowns and pack/boss is living for a long time

#

are we holding LS for like 20 seconds to line up 4pc with second avatar?

#

we just full send everything like in 9.2 right?

#

and when stuff lines up that's cool?

sick sentinel
#

diz any good? 😉

chrome falcon
#

nop

sick sentinel
#

guess my warlock friend is gonna be happy in a bit then

hushed cobalt
#

i'm still rocking my whetstone

prisma crane
#

yea that would be ok for someone who doesnt spam casts like we do

sick sentinel
#

yea fair

dusty monolith
#

I'm still rocking a 415 gift of radiance deadge really want the landslide trinket from NL

hushed cobalt
#

not sure if it was the pug i was in, but the trash that cast landslide usually killed someone(s) per pull

sick sentinel
#

thx but no

hushed cobalt
#

so the trinket that landslides should be good

sick sentinel
#

i don't want to see shadowlands forever

bitter herald
#

elementium pocket anvil is proc on shield slam hits
can this apply on the aoe from 4set?

urban bane
#

no the aoe from 4set is not shield slam

#

it is a separate effect altogether

bitter herald
#

so decent but not insane, cheers

orchid mural
#

So, i macro'ed DemoShout and LastStand together - seems to synergize really well. anyone else find the same?

chrome falcon
#

you should be pressing last stand on cooldown anyway

#

as soon as you get 2set

strong forum
#

They're 2 entirely different CDs so uh

#

Doesn't really do much

#

LS is 1min demo is 45sec

dusty monolith
chrome falcon
#

you press both of those abilities essentially on cooldown

#

i mean you're not gonna get stoned to death but

hushed cobalt
#

Unless you run thunderlord 😉

chrome falcon
#

that's just objectively wrong

strong forum
chrome falcon
#

yeah running thunderlord WILL get you stoned to death

dusty monolith
#

not running thunderlord and it works out - somehow

#

at least good enough for the bracket i play in

hushed cobalt
#

Aside from thunderlord, how are haste pants for m+ compared to a second shadowflame

sick sentinel
#

raid group in zaralek angry at tanks for "not stacking them so he can cleave" and im telling them they get a 90% dmg reduce for being close apparently.

dusty monolith
#

classic

sick sentinel
#

has a buff is some kind of melee brain rot

exotic hare
#

What would yall pick?

#

helmet is 441 with Haste Versa,

ashen harness
#

Hey, so Frostfire belt sims highest for me to craft. But i guess thats just cause i have the erenog ring still?

Should i go for the frostfire belt? Or is that item terrible once i get rid of the ring?

undone verge
#

It’s bis

ashen harness
#

i have a good weapon and shield already

sick sentinel
#

i swear melee players are way dumber on average than ranged or healer or tank

#

and its not even close

ashen harness
ashen harness
#

or is it still good on its own?

undone verge
#

*it’s bis with or without the ring

sick sentinel
#

do you guys find the entangling to be rough or no

dusty monolith
#

i think its fine

ashen harness
sick sentinel
#

game wants me to run 8 nelth lair, see what happens i guess

exotic hare
#

Hey can anyone help me with what to pick? 😄

#

i cant decide

undone verge
#

Storming is like having a sore throat. It’s annoying, and painful, entangling is like having a stuffy nose, I wish I didn’t have it, but it doesn’t effect me at all

dusty monolith
sick sentinel
#

im imagining its rough in parts of VP

#

any of the movement or aoe parts really

undone verge
#

On bosses yeah

#

Trash not really

exotic hare
sick sentinel
#

even on aoe trash and movment like over the birdge, i'd be scared about entangling popping up

orchid mural
undone verge
daring marlin
quartz mist
#

Anyone else getting dummied from ice shard in halls of infusion

sick sentinel
#

i mean, what are the options realistically as warrior when it happens

exotic hare
sick sentinel
#

i've not yet experience it

daring marlin
#

walk slightly out

sick sentinel
#

so, i duno for instance how leap, or charge, or intervene works with it, or avatar as that has some interaction

#

my assumption is you cant leap or blink out

dusty monolith
# exotic hare there ;D

depends on how assessable tier set pieces are for you, I'd go for the chest if you dont raid as much or helm if you do raid quite a lot. you could pick the 421 chest, upgrade to 437 and push 2k rating this week to get a second tier token and run 2p/2p 🙂 or if you are confident you'll get tier soon through your raid you could pick the helm

quartz mist
#

Good to know ty

undone verge
exotic hare
#

Thanks allot yall

undone verge
dusty monolith
#

the s key counters the whole affix tbh

sick sentinel
#

yeah, okay i know about nelth lair now that i look at the mpa

daring marlin
#

not that they're needed

sick sentinel
#

i kind of figured being a big vine thing it would grab hold

dusty monolith
daring marlin
#

yogi sometimes I question how you overthink stuff

hybrid cobalt
#

heart of thunder is good (20 underrot)

dusty monolith
daring marlin
strong forum
jagged pier
#

yer i dunno felt like a very non affix

ashen harness
hybrid cobalt
strong forum
#

How much on bosses

hybrid cobalt
strong forum
#

Yeah that's 4k

#

That's pretty good

hybrid cobalt
#

not maxed either only 434

dusty monolith
#

thats the VP trinket right?

hybrid cobalt
#

yea

strong forum
#

Slightly better than whetstone

#

Neat

dusty monolith
#

I'm just gonna grab that and landslide and call it a day this season then hopium

strong forum
#

But bacon

dusty monolith
#

bacon is pretty fun as well true

#

hard to grab one without raid though

daring marlin
shut summit
dusty monolith
#

i really havent thought about that trinket, it ranked so low on sites like bloodmalled i never gave it a second thought, thanks for sharing! might be an option if I get it or find one in vault 🙂

strong forum
#

Time to lock myself into vp prison

#

To replace the awful rocks trinket for good

dusty monolith
#

Sense you're quite decked out i might say. forgestorm, an'shuul, everything you went super hard! grats great gear

strong forum
#

Skill based loot drops

#

The new system

dusty monolith
#

explains a lot really

ashen harness
#

but thats my opinion

#

if people find it usefull then great

shut summit
#

2nd neltharus forgestorm 🤭

strong forum
#

Entangling on last boss vp during triangle is very fun 🙂

daring marlin
#

wtf sense

strong forum
#

They never learned from quaking

dusty monolith
#

entangle on third boss HoI can also be juicy during hiding I imagine. got hit by hailstorm once becaue i was to far behind the ice shard

daring marlin
#

Just move out and back in clueless

strong forum
daring marlin
#

I look forward to pain

dusty monolith
daring marlin
#

And prot loot spec too? 🤢

red wave
#

Finding the 2nd point is hard but I notice taking Bloodborne (1 rank) over Battering Ram isn't simming much higher at all, despite being a 10% benefit to several strong abilities. I must be really downplaying Battering Ram in my head?

strong forum
#

Yes

#

Bloodborne is kaka

#

Battering ram is goated

#

Battering ram = more shield slams and just alot of auto attack dmg

sick sentinel
#

any prio on what pieces to get with omnitoken? Legs or head will give me 4 set. Same ilvl diff

lofty widget
#

taking 441 forgestorm?

strong forum
#

Your bleeds only make up like 15% of your dmg if not less

#

Buffing that by 10%

#

Is only a 1.5% gain

#

That's not alot

red wave
#

Yea, that's fair. Okay you walked me off the ledge.

urban portal
#

Blood borne should be a 1 pointer

dusty monolith
strong forum
lofty widget
#

forgestorm sims 1k higher for me

red wave
#

I've been debating going for forgestorm even though no primaries, but since I 447'd my sword I think I'd only do it if 441-vault.

dusty monolith
#

is forgestorm really that strong

#

damn

dusty monolith
red wave
#

I barely knew yee wasted spark.

daring marlin
#

It's a well designed dungeon at least

thorny stone
red wave
#

Forge* isn't simming better for me, but I have been curious in it since M0. might have to farm it and try for myself.

#

Tested again at 5 tar/3 minutes. Added a non-embellished 1H since I have a Fang on mine ATM.

#

Need to look up it's proc rate to see what a fair time comparison is though.

strong forum
#

It's rppm

#

So sometimes it can go crazy

#

On beta with 421 forgestorm I had it do up to 6k dps on dummies on ST

#

And sometimes only 1k

red wave
#

Gooood, I love items like this so I'm glad y'all are getting good experiences. I loved the week of pre season 1 I got to run it on war/enhance

strong forum
#

But yes, forgestorm won't perform as good in aoe as it does on ST

#

That's just fact

#

The extra Str from regular weapon goes a long way in big pulls

#

Stats in general will perform better in aoe

soft plume
#

for mark of dargrul do i need to be set to arms or fury loot or can prot get it too

strong forum
#

Only dps

sick sentinel
#

yea any dps

strong forum
#

Aaaah mobile

weak spade
#

what would you guys recommend as trinkets

plush tendon
#

Pins 😄

#

Nom wrote a pretty good thing

lusty tiger
sick sentinel
#

How big of a damage increase is the shadowflame embellishment?

jagged pier
signal plover
#

I love being gone for 6mo and then reading some Nom wisdoms

tulip egret
#

Is @strong forum the god of prot ? guy knows everything

signal plover
#

No we worship our Lord and Savior Sense

#

Nom is like the sweaty majordomo that lets you into the temple

hushed cobalt
#

i raid as arms, and m+ as prot
is there any downside to having crafted legs and boots for both specs, as opposed to having 2 of these (Boots/Belt/Wrists/Shield)?

turbid hemlock
#

There's any weak aura to track our 4set?

restive crown
#

is there any cape with haste on it?

#

other then crafted one

#

specifically frm m+ lol

glacial grove
toxic pewter
azure temple
#

Whats the better trinket? Raid horn or anvil

restive crown
#

ow ok will nt upgrade other capes then

#

thanks

crimson mountain
#

just used a 424 heart in a 16 VP it feels like slightly lower dmg overall compared to my 415 Whetstone

strong forum
#

vp is a low pull dungeon

lusty tiger
lusty tiger
#

not rly related most pulls r in fact 2-3 mobs

strong forum
#

i have not

#

cuz healer struggled a bit with dragon alone

lusty tiger
#

(:

strong forum
#

so i didnt decide for that pull