#protection

1 messages · Page 358 of 1

drifting glade
#

hes pulling the stupid wind adds onto one another

#

since his side had 2 healers they could heal through it but it was stupid amounts of inc damage

blazing condor
#

typical jerry

wet crow
#

Hey guys sorry moob question, but do we prefer frozen or sophic weapon ench for high keys?

hardy snow
#

go with earthen devotion

#

i always wonder why Blizz is even making such pointless enchants

#

but answering your question - both frozen and sophic are good

lofty widget
#

you can sim the dmg difference

#

keep in mind sophic has a defensive component since it gives mainstat

ocean prairie
#

what should we train our whelpling in for m+?

sick sentinel
#

im strictly doing m+, with this new spark i was curious if the haste alch trinket could be any value for us? none of the guides or bloodmallet even mention it so my guess is no.. 😛

amber siren
#

the alch trinket is pretty average

jagged pier
cold pollen
#

anyone as a nice route for pug in 20+ ?

#

azur vault

jagged pier
#

press w

cold pollen
#

more of a ''kind of guy

#

'z'

timber forge
#

hey guys im new at prot.. what is the best way to generate aggro/threat in AoE playing with people who deal a lot of damage. ty

ocean prairie
#

If you want to be fancy you can jump to first boss after flowers

cold pollen
jagged pier
#

no

#

u dont use shield charge as a charge

#

u rav

#

then u charge

#

normal charge

#

as your are chraging

#

u avatar

#

when u get to the group

#

u demo

cold pollen
#

there is no prio to my list just listing what's avaialable to him

jagged pier
#

Thundours rosr

#

then shield charge

#

then SS

#

then TC > revenge etc etc

cold pollen
#

Well i guess we don't discuss optimal route here 😦

limpid anchor
#

You asked for a pug route

jagged pier
#

there isnt an optimal route for AV

limpid anchor
#

I wouldn’t do some skips or huge pulls with pugs

jagged pier
#

theres no variance anymore

timber forge
#

thanks guys

jagged pier
#

u cant skip to second boss

#

its literally

#

press w

#

ggs

limpid anchor
#

Why can’t you skip anyomore?

eager phoenix
#

you cant jump down from 1st ring to 2nd boss ring?

cold pollen
#

since when you cant skip to second boss?

jagged pier
#

i heard u die if u do that

#

🤷

high drum
#

u can skip to 3rd

#

not 2nd

cold pollen
#

you can skip seonc dand third

limpid anchor
#

3rd the ice guy?

high drum
#

ye

eager phoenix
#

Well then its just W

high drum
#

u go back and jump down after 2nd

#

no its not just w

#

u break all the piercing dorks out

eager phoenix
#

dont bolster the big dragonkin when you pass 2nd boss keks

limpid anchor
#

Mhm

high drum
#

with the whelps

#

then go back after 2nd boss

#

and jump to 3rd

#

skip all the frog bullchips

jagged pier
#

ah yes

#

skip the easier trash

#

in a pug

cold pollen
lofty widget
#

just cause you can doesnt mean you should

ionic fern
lofty widget
#

from 2nd to 3rd boss you pull like 40 % trash in 3 pulls

#

sounds worth to me

ionic fern
#

We doing that every time.

jagged pier
ionic fern
#

Platform skip to 2nd and to 3rd

jagged pier
#

and u just die now

ionic fern
eager phoenix
#

fuck it, ill go in and try

ionic fern
#

But we just did it yesterday

#

And it was fine.

high drum
#

havent encountered any death planes

#

in AV yet

#

and ive been doing it since vanilla HAHA get it lmao

bitter ravine
#

i did the skip today it still works

cold pollen
#

my only issue on frog room is the bosltering but i guess it reauires just smart dds

jagged pier
#

just pull the big guys

#

get them low

#

then pull the rest

#

like skipping frogs in a pug and having to deal with shard adds in fort and in a pug

#

just seems dumb

#

but meh

#

🤷

cold pollen
#

i had good pugs, though i am an optimistic kind of guy

high drum
#

the shrieked mobs have less hp than the regular ones

cold pollen
#

i just trigger the first shriek then

twin temple
#

how haste ist must have?

jagged pier
#

there is no set amount

#

u want as much as u can get without dropping ilvl

#

when u hit 40% unbuffed by anything

#

u can look at other stats

twin temple
#

haste-versa-mastery-crit?

jagged pier
#

no

#

haste>crit=vers>=mastery

twin temple
jagged pier
#

for everything

rough egret
#

This is the way

ionic fern
#

Luckily the ones above you can LoS

twin temple
dense ledge
#

wish I was higher io to actually do cool routes in av and not just press w

wet crow
#

hey guys, what ilvl of a ring do you think we should start replacing cobalt rings with?

#

it does a lot of damage/healing but the stats and ilvl are really low

flat jackal
hardy snow
dense ledge
#

in that dungeon it does

autumn marsh
#

Just take the chad route, and practicer

wet crow
#

did a 20 temple just now and it did about 2.8% of my dam which seems like a lot to give up but idk if im losing too much on stats

hardy snow
dense ledge
#

I yoinked the last route from shuh but not trying that in 16s

hazy sluice
#

Yo are there any hot tips/ cheap tricks for mage tower ? cobalt ring or something like that ? Any specific phases to hold a def CD for ?

dense ledge
#

bro

#

go nuts then, I am not typing a wall of text in 16s to just leave the key after they mess up

blazing condor
#

and orbs

hazy sluice
#

What are these orbs for ?

blazing condor
#

they help you

#

stuns every enemy

#

and gives you health

hazy sluice
#

So just kick drain life, don't stack decay too much and don't fall off platform.

blazing condor
#

yeah p much

hazy sluice
#

Kk

blazing condor
#

deal damage and live

jagged pier
hazy sluice
#

No enrage timer ?

blazing condor
#

annihilate will stack on you

#

so eventually you'll get one shot

jagged pier
#

i mean me and nome both did mage tower yesterday

blazing condor
#

you can also spell reflect Kruuls cast

jagged pier
#

its very easy

blazing condor
#

the healing one

hazy sluice
#

Ah so hold def CDs for later annihilations

#

Yeah I mean I tank 20s. Should be doable for me

blazing condor
#

its easier now for sure

#

not that i plan on doing it again

jagged pier
#

i mean i got 2 annhilates

#

we did it again because ppl were stuggling wanted to see what it was like

ionic fern
#

You and Nom are decent players tho.

jagged pier
#

also have done it the last 2 times

#

so we know whats going on

ionic fern
#

Jeah..maybe they are lacking...vers.

blazing condor
#

cringe "i one shot it cus its so easy" vs chad "i let the NPC finish kruul off because i died"

hazy sluice
#

What a shame. Did it week 1 with my enhancer in legion, was kinda challenging then but nothing more than 8 tries

#

So it's not a mog for showoff kek

blazing condor
#

to most people it probably still is

#

i dont see the average player doing MT

jagged pier
#

for most ppl its too hard

#

in legion even top players sturggled

lone eagle
#

I did it on Brew first day in Legion

jagged pier
#

because they didnt have WAs and raid leaders telling them what to do

lone eagle
#

And then we all remembered Angry Dave existed

jagged pier
#

u actually need to learn it yourself

hardy snow
#

In legion you just rolled through it with better gear on next patch

lone eagle
#

And I was kicking myself for making the fight harder than it was

#

Angry Dave would just tank the boss for 2 annihilates in p2

#

so you'd eat first annihilate, dave would eat 2nd/3rd

#

then you'd do w/e for 4th and 5th

#

if you even got them

jagged pier
#

I didnt SR twisted reflection in legion

#

and was still in top 100 prots to do it

#

or somthing like that

#

best was druid challenge in SLs tho

#

so many ppl malding over it

lone eagle
#

lmao

#

only tank challenge I never bothered with was BDK

#

Hated the weapon mog, hated the gear mog in SL

solemn island
#

anybody got any data please on eranog ring % damage in a ~20 key please?

#

lmao double please what is english

strong forum
#

For the dmg ring you just sim for raid

#

In m+ a higher ilvl one will win

strong forum
wet crow
#

415+ ring for m+ is better than shield cobalt?

strong forum
#

A 400 one even

solemn island
wet crow
#

O even 405

#

3mil damage it did for me though

strong forum
#

The shield from the ring is nice but you lose almost 700 stats

#

To get it

wet crow
#

My other option is a 405 crit haste ring

strong forum
#

Yeah use that

#

I replaced my cobalt ring with a 402 haste crit for m+

#

But yesterday I got 421 eranog ring so that just wins everywhere

wet crow
#

Didn't think those stats would beat out straight up like 3-4mil healing/damage per dungeon

cedar trench
#

cobalt ring overrated IMO

silent comet
#

@jagged pier How do I do mage tower? Do I spam rend???

solemn island
#

guild didnt want to give it to tank

strong forum
#

I pugged

solemn island
#

so you just won

#

a roll

#

vs 16 people

strong forum
#

Yeah my roll luck is pretty high

hardy snow
#

and im sitting with cobalt ring, as I dont have anything higher ilvl, already crafted one, need to craft next sadge

strong forum
#

I win like 90%of rolls in raid

solemn island
#

couldnt be me

#

only thing i got from a raid was council mythic trinket and wasnt even won on roll was loot council

jagged pier
#

yer nome has better trinkets than me

#

and I raid every week

strong forum
#

I got all hc trinkets but grieftorch and storm

#

Within like 3 weeks

solemn island
#

smh they wont ever give boon

#

LET TANK HAVE BOON

ionic fern
#

And Nom doesn't even play..still has better trinkets.

solemn island
#

i want to pad AA so hard with boon

jagged pier
#

man quits

#

then

#

goes into a mythic pug

#

get ring from eggnogg

#

cool

strong forum
#

Eragon ring gud

ionic fern
#

We've had a lot of rings drop tbh.

#

Apparently our feral had a 3k dps increase from it

#

Which sounds.....

cedar trench
#

sussy

solemn island
#

i mean in theory for raid

jagged pier
#

or loot luck

solemn island
#

i guess ring on tank is grief

#

vs dps

jagged pier
#

is garbage

strong forum
#

If he goes from assembly ring to eragon

#

Maybe

#

Vdh gets like 2.5k dps from myffic

solemn island
#

cause strictly for raid

#

tanks dont need shit

#

press spells stay alive

cedar trench
#

eragon kekw

strong forum
#

For raid it's whack ye, outside of maybe rasz

limpid anchor
#

Tank dps important winde

unborn sable
#

is frostfire belt only bis if i have one of the 2 raid rings?

ionic fern
strong forum
#

Ye

#

:squint:

#

That's sus

#

Maybe the stats are also omega bis

ionic fern
#

Pretty sure he simmed with head embellishment.

#

😂

cedar trench
#

its 5k upgrade for me if i change my entire gear set yep

solemn island
edgy spear
#

like +-1%

unborn sable
pliant geyser
#

do we have fire dmg from something or can we not really use the raid fire dmg rings?

cedar trench
#

belt

pliant geyser
#

the frostfire belt or something?

edgy spear
#

Yes

#

Has enough uptime on the dot to cause regular procs

lilac jay
unborn sable
edgy spear
#

Belt is a decent option in any case, ring or not.

tender quartz
#

I'm slowly getting into the 22 range, is it okay if I change all the Haste / Crit stuff like Boots / Hands from COS / SBG to 418 Haste / Vers once or do we actually want some crit?

#

I would sit on around 11-12% Crit then as usualy 16%

thin cedar
#

people still triple pulling HOV first pull?

#

this week i should say

jagged pier
#

no

thin cedar
#

didnt think so

hardy snow
#

if your team is coordinated enough to not bolster drake you can try

#

if they bolster drake, frontal become quite strong

strong forum
#

The only stat you want on pretty much all pieces is haste

humble ferry
#

And kite once shit starts to bolster ofc

keen steppe
#

do you have some raid talents for Prot?

jagged pier
keen steppe
#

thx

vestal rover
#

which 2 should I run?:)

fresh belfry
#

Am I reading the APL correctly that I want to use Violent Outburst with Shieldslam instead of TC to up to 4 targets?

jagged pier
#

yes

fresh belfry
#

kinda thought it was 3, glad i checked. ty

solemn island
#

is it worth going intervene in NO for first packs 3rd boss ?

jagged pier
#

no

trim bay
#

what percentage of 2 set do you guys have in a key? should i be revenging on say a boss when it isnt free to get the buff?

jagged pier
#

u should be using revenge when its not free regardless of tier set or not

trim bay
#

no i know, i explained that terribly

#

when you wouldnt cast it, like SS is off CD your not rage capped but vanguard has dropped off

#

do you revenge or SS

strong forum
#

85-95%

trim bay
#

kk

sick sentinel
#

mage in my key last night said he "died to aggro"

#

time to see if thats true or not, HE DID

#

died to aggro on the ninja pull bull we aggroed but didnt kill before ramping

fresh belfry
#

i never checked: can the Seismic Reverberation revenge hit proc Strategist?

#

I'd assume yes since its the same spell ID as a normal revenge just with less damage

#

but you never know

strong forum
#

pretty sure its not the hit but the cast that can proc strategist

fresh belfry
#

so that would be a no

strong forum
#

ye

fresh belfry
#

?

#

ok

rough solar
#

Cloak upgrade/sidegrade or socket? Socket sims slightly higher

sick sentinel
#

yeah, the only other deaths was to blast of light (i told them what it was and not to get hit, get hit like 2-3 times anyways), and bowman aggroing 3rd warrior

fresh belfry
rough solar
fresh belfry
#

can always craft a 418 cloak, cant craft a socket. sim it

sick sentinel
#

what should i craft at 405

#

bracer, weapon embellished, food on belt, i could remove the embellishment on weapon to go for neck maybe, or cloak is my thoughts

#

anything i have crafted/plan to craft, i would want to eventually recraft at maximum level way later on

fresh belfry
sick sentinel
#

weapon is already crafted

#

and i have a valor haste versa at like 392 i think? only a small amount of valor once uncapped

last mason
#

does anyone know if the 50% health debuff on the first few sbg packs can go on tank

acoustic oasis
#

Opinions on mage tower? Got it done last night within 2 hours, somewhere between 10-20 tries. Had a blast but man, that fight was BUGGY I fell through the floor 3 times.

last mason
#

i was randomly just getting absolutely 1 shot in like a 19 and that has never happened before

limpid anchor
#

Yea

last mason
#

at like 411 ilvl

limpid anchor
#

Check logs tho

last mason
#

i was so confused i did an 18 right after and it still hurt but not as mucj

#

so was thinking i didnt get it there

high drum
#

yeah it can go on tanks

#

very dangerous if it lines up with a void slash

last mason
#

i was so embarrased bc i had no idea why i was just falling over like it was a 30

ancient cosmos
#

Any thoughts on Dragon Games Equipment trinket? 415 vs a 395 icon. Raw stats and damage go to games, but harder to use and at this point a lot of people in M+ are using icon

#

Sim has dragon games +1284 vs icon +870

topaz pulsar
#

how do you even use that trinket. I got once from low dungeons and never could figure it out

ancient cosmos
#

i think the balls land on the floor and you have to walk into them

topaz pulsar
#

i tried that didnt do nothing

#

then i threw it away

woeful trellis
sick sentinel
#

oh right, im gunna recraft it to 405 later

#

just, im probably also going to craft it to 418 later too

cobalt mesa
#

Hey; quick question about spell prio in M+, lets say on AoE dmg on 5-6 target:
I'm at 90rage, with Thunderclap, Shield Slam both available, should I :
- IP + SS to not overcap rage
- IP + TC

  • Revenge
icy bane
#

Anyone seen a picture 2nd spark drop? Got one to drop on Tuesday just wondering if anyone had any luck on two drops

finite vortex
#

where i can find best routes for mdt ?

lofty widget
#

unless the TC procs SS

agile elbow
eager phoenix
# finite vortex where i can find best routes for mdt ?

does dratnos still do his weekly route on raider.io? dorki has routes uploaded to wago. head to his stream to find the link. should be a good baseline. after that its a bit of experience and opinion what pulls you prefer, depending on comp, key lvl and weekly affixes. for example, dodging ravagers in AA this week is kind of nice

pale sorrel
#

hello all . question does 4 set synergise with bstance and make u effectively just as tankier then if you were just in dstance

finite vortex
#

ok thx will check

jagged pier
#

your always tankier in d stance

#

and 4 set isnt 15% DR or whatever it is now

versed delta
#

Should I start double pulling in higher keys?

jagged pier
#

if your comfotable with it

#

u can pull as much as u want

#

its more expected because u need to save time some where

pale sorrel
versed delta
#

Single pulls are already breaking the party...

#

So many deaths...

jagged pier
#

i was going to say even tho they are expected doesnt mean it works

reef holly
hard quartz
#

i mean do what pulls your party can handle; but, you will need to pull multiple groups to time higher keys

jagged pier
#

like pugs ask me to pull bigger

#

so i do

reef holly
#

I'm dealing with dps zerging one mob as opposed to dpsing all mobs equally

jagged pier
#

then they die because they cant deal with it

#

and guess what

#

i get blamed

#

👍

slim dove
#

Pugs critcake

hard quartz
reef holly
bitter ravine
#

dps are stupid

eager phoenix
#

you can time almost every dungeon up to 20s without going too crazy on the pace if the group otherwise is doing the dmg it should for the key level. pulling more doesnt make it faster if the team cant control the pull

silent comet
jagged pier
versed delta
#

Alright

#

Will take note of that

#

I think it's just they are not that good

#

They ate so much avoidable damage

bitter ravine
#

some affixes favor some dungeons over others too

hard quartz
#

I mean, do your best not to wildly swing mobs with frontals at your DPS. when a mob gets bolstered what used to be an annoying frontal is now deadly even at low keys.

oak echo
#

in fairness you also need to do some work to understand what mobs do what which makes them more or less safe to combine with other pulls. while yes there are lots of times where pugs won't execute how they need to, you shouldn't also take the approach that "other people are doing double pulls so i can too" if you don't know what you're double pulling

jagged pier
#

like I guarentee there will be pug dps that pull the dragon group with the first 5 mobs in HoV this week

#

and not care about bolstering and blame the tank when it doesnt work

oak echo
#

tank gets 1 shot by a 6 stack lightning breath "lol you're made of paper"

versed delta
#

Honestly thought Bolstering would be easier but man, it's been wrecking the keys

eager phoenix
#

i love the guys who ask me to link route and then go "????" when i dont pull first 5 into drake in HoV

jagged pier
#

because its fort bolstering

#

things scale up real quick

sick sentinel
#

if you didn play through 8.0 bolstering i dont want to even hear about it

versed delta
#

I was just so surprised when people were focusing single target

lyric elm
#

I sit out this week while people learn what bolstering is lol

sick sentinel
#

yellow non elite non hostiles would PERMANENT bolster whatever was pulled

#

after one or 2 thunderclaps

grave flower
#

Fort bolstering has all dps saying “push week!”

sick sentinel
#

and then its GG we have to wipe now, cant kill it

grave flower
#

And us tanks being extra careful. Makes for some toxic pugs

ember tangle
#

and shit would bolster bosses aswell

reef holly
#

dont make my mistake on my first 2 CoS and butt pull the 2 constructs in the very first pull...critcake

grave flower
#

Oooooof

eager phoenix
#

some pulls are just stupid, like the ravagers or birds in AA. sure, skip the ravagers but can't really avoid not bolstering the big bird. requires dps with brain to not make a problem that cant practically be outplayed by most comps even bigger

reef holly
#

quickest 15 deplete in history

oak echo
#

that's definitely not a deplete

#

that timer is so lenient

ripe dock
#

Every time a mobs bolster I arch my back

sick sentinel
reef holly
#

well- everyone left after that keks

eager phoenix
#

asspulling the constructs is whatever, just die and go. you spawn just there in cos ^^

oak echo
#

oh lol

ember tangle
#

i did a cos earlier where one guy just dc'ed when we put in key and then couldn't get back in the instance

pulsar parrot
grave flower
#

I’m a thin boy. Belf

sick sentinel
pulsar parrot
#

anyone done a Ruby Life pools bolstering yet? Just how terrible are those fire elementals?

#

Cause even if you cleave off they have like 30-40% more health than the other mobs, no?

grave flower
#

Everything sucks with bolstering

reef holly
ripe dock
crystal mauve
#

DPS dont understand that bolstering is a DPS affix that has conséquence only on the tank if they screw up

reef holly
sick sentinel
#

this is the transmog list if you are interested

pulsar parrot
#

Got my hands on a 21 Temple. Last trash pull of the dungeon and the first 2 monks after the first boss are giving me anxiety

dusky canopy
#

What In the hell is blizzard achieving by removing friendly nameplate cvar!?!? Just being more annoying???

grave flower
#

Last pull on temple is fucked

pulsar parrot
#

Even with spell reflect

#

it's a mess

crystal mauve
pulsar parrot
#

But better than sanguine week. That vomit boss standing in sanguine was a mess

dusky canopy
bold olive
# ripe dock Done on a 18 and it's fucking grim

Just did a 19 and we had 18 DPS trash deaths leading up to the last boss that were basically "I used my personal at the wrong time or I didn't use a personal at all" during a bolstering inferno/etc.

#

Healer was also scuffed, but mostly mongoing.

pulsar parrot
#

Server shutdown in 10 minutes....CatjamR

ripe dock
pulsar parrot
#

and lust it

bitter ravine
#

bolstering is just something you cant outgear at any meaningful level

ripe dock
#

Whys is Sever going down lol

#

Something is defo broken haha

#

Oh blizz

robust jackal
#

hello guys, quick question -> I am just learning rotation and other stuff for prot warr -> do you shield block whenever possible or only when its about to fall off?

bold olive
urban bane
alpine night
dusky canopy
reef holly
dusky canopy
#

Pressing block adds to the current duration of block too so all is good

jagged pier
#

u should really get into the habit of not spamming it away

#

one nerf here or there and u need to manage shield block again

dusky canopy
#

Yeah tbf we are spoiled with this 100% block up time

thin cedar
#

Whoever asked about ruby.. I just timed a 20 ruby this week and it actually wasn’t as terrifying as you’d think

dusky canopy
#

I can’t imagine it will last forever

versed delta
#

I played Guardian Druid once and I was so miffed that Ironfur didn't work like Shield Block

robust jackal
#

ok so its better to keep one charge of shield block ready

#

thanks

dusky canopy
#

Unless you don’t have block active

robust jackal
#

ofc

dusky canopy
#

Then you use it obviously

toxic mesa
plush tendon
reef holly
dusky canopy
#

No it really hasn’t

plush tendon
#

naw, you shield charge on CD

plush tendon
#

big dam

robust jackal
jagged pier
#

not 100%

#

and not many ppl could keep that uptime ither

dusky canopy
#

They’re talking about getting 90% uptime as a standard and you had to run hr witch was worse than the other options

#

I remember SL still keks

jagged pier
#

also that

plush tendon
jagged pier
#

^

plush tendon
#

regardless of SB time

#

cause dam

dusky canopy
#

Ye always send shield charge

#

Try to stun something useful if it works out

plush tendon
#

If it stuns something thats cool

#

if not, whatever

#

SC slaps

dusky canopy
#

Right right

plush tendon
#

especially when you line it up with Demo shout and Avatar (sometimes)

reef holly
#

I need to get out of the habit of spamming SB on accident

plush tendon
#

theres no real reason not to

jagged pier
dusky canopy
#

It’s better to spam IP than waste SB charges

versed delta
dusky canopy
#

If you have to have a bad habit

plush tendon
reef holly
#

as a note- don't shield charge a mob in sanguine keks

jagged pier
#

thats a TLs player right there

plush tendon
#

naw, im battering ram

dusky canopy
plush tendon
#

cause dam

pulsar parrot
plush tendon
#

sometimes we are bad though.... and forget to press demo shout

jagged pier
plush tendon
#

the worst is on Sennarth

dusky canopy
#

Demo shout on cd

plush tendon
#

I dont know why, by SC sometimes doesnt go off

pulsar parrot
plush tendon
#

and then my Demo window is closed

dusky canopy
#

Gcd

pulsar parrot
#

i.e. Hyrjal HoV

#

Or whatever her name is

jagged pier
plush tendon
#

I dont want to think about that spider

#

5 1% wipes on reclear Tuesday

jagged pier
#

garbage fight followed by 2 more garbage fights

plush tendon
#

naw, Kurog is a good time

jagged pier
#

its garbage

#

mis time the movement

#

pull over

#

cool

#

nice

plush tendon
#

the movement part is the easy thing

dusky canopy
#

I would absolutely re do this tier again vs freaking SoFo

plush tendon
#

I've only screwed it up once

#

in like 30 pulls

jagged pier
#

yer but that in itself is garbage like the fight isnt supposed to be done that way it has to be cheesed

#

its actually over tuned as fuck

plush tendon
#

true

#

but its also the first boss where im like "oh, I take damage?"

naive trellis
#

In M+ do we only take rend for the thunder clap application? We don't actually want to waste rage on it right?

oak echo
#

yes

ionic roost
# jagged pier mis time the movement

Whats there to miss time, fire phase has the energy always move at 97, earth phase, Bigwigs has accurate timers, even easier if you do the 1.5 auto wait

plush tendon
#

minus Terros; and thats mostly due to healers dying like half way through and us having to deal with it

pulsar parrot
plush tendon
#

cause yea, its kind of silly

jagged pier
#

well also saying oh well this and that have a timer

#

makes it also a shit mechanic

#

as it requires somthing to tell u what to do

#

and its not always 97%

#

because i move him at 96%

plush tendon
#

Its between 96 and 97

jagged pier
#

if i move him at 97%

naive trellis
#

Are there anymore spells that we take or have that we don't use? I'm new to prot warrior but tank 20s on other classes so I'm used to using all other utility

jagged pier
#

its a wipe

#

it all depends on how u move him at the start

#

its different for every guild

#

pretty much

ionic roost
#

If it's between 96 and 97 you're too far from the line

jagged pier
#

this is my point

#

its not the same

#

for everyone

#

so its a pointless arguement

#

i spoke to ppl and they hold the boss in the middle for a few seconds

plush tendon
#

we're all different and special ❤️

ionic roost
#

Also you can use energy for the earth phase too, just requires more numbers than seeing if you aligned the two timers or desync

jagged pier
#

and they move at 96

ionic roost
jagged pier
#

for you

reef holly
#

kurog in LFR is interesting

jagged pier
#

i position him the same everytime

#

and i have to move before 97

plush tendon
ionic roost
#

That's like saying jailer LoS MCs are random if you just have the boss in random spots all the time

robust lark
#

You guys talking about moving kurog at 96 97 is this mythic you're talking about?

plush tendon
#

yea

robust lark
#

K I shall forget what I'm seeing then lol.

plush tendon
ionic roost
#

Kurog and his adds also move really well compared to most other fights

#

I feel like the adds are just glued to you

#

Compared to like Tyrant, Anduin, Jaina, xymox,

sturdy sable
sturdy sable
ionic roost
#

Yea idk what's worse, Jaina, Tyrant or the Big Adds on Dathea

plush tendon
#

Jaina was bad

#

almost as bad as those NO adds at the start that cast a spell then stand still for 5 seconds soaking up the Sanguine after a interrupt

sick sentinel
#

not gud

jade wolf
#

Someone knows if u want to play 4p now? with the nerfs?

cedar trench
#

wut

inland raft
#

It was 5% to brv changes nothing

ocean finch
#

Sophic devotion or Frozen Devotion for pwarr M+ only?

inland raft
#

You would have to look at logs side by side and really look to find the differences it was a token nerf to appease community

jade wolf
#

so u dont play it anyways like before changes. Just had a discussion and someone said that warrior plays 4p now after the changes.

inland raft
#

In raid 4 set is whatever, in m+ 4 set is nice, thats always been the case

deep spruce
#

I don't think the advice has ever been to not play it, and this is the prot warr discord, so God knows who you're talking to

plush tendon
#

yea, 4 piece is ok; you dont avoid it if you can get it with minimal i level loss

#

and especially now that catalyst is out

inland raft
#

Think he thinking fury

sick sentinel
#

do they still do that thing where you give friend 30 days if you gift them wow, i dunno if hes even interested in playing or not or if he has a good enough pc

jade wolf
#

nono i mean prot. most of the hightier raiders are skipping 4p for better stats like on the Hands

sick sentinel
#

but i thought about it

plush tendon
deep spruce
jade wolf
deep spruce
#

It's whatever in raid. 2 set and highest ilvl

#

But if 4set is your best ilvl, play it

plush tendon
#

^

jade wolf
sick sentinel
#

all totem over powered

#

kill the frogs im supposed to bring to 50% and put hat on for WQ

agile elbow
#

It's weird being the only one in Valdrakken. Lol. I'm either in my own instance or people just haven't logged in yet.

sick sentinel
#

lots of random DC when dragon flying, i can still log in and all just lololol

agile elbow
#

Yeah. I got stuck in a loop yesterday where I couldn't login for like 20 minutes because it's automatically boot me once I logged back in because I was dragonflying.

#

Then when I did get in, my character was zooming like 9000% speed across the map to his doom while not on his dragon anymore. 🙃

sick sentinel
#

i was stuck in TW cos for 3 hours

#

further cementing my hatred of cos

woven trellis
#

ran a bunch of sims, there is no trinket that equal the fckin boon even if my boon is only 395 and i compare it to 415 trinkets

#

insane

pallid quiver
#

no softcap baybeeeeee

sick sentinel
#

my poor man is running diablo 3 i think it is probably bored out of his mind

river granite
#

Hey all, question about gemming my Lariat as a prot war.

I crafted mine recently and read that the proc depends on the elements of your elemental gems. So in order to ensure that I always get the haste proc, I socketed a Fierce Illimited Diamond (doesn’t effect which proc b/c it’s not an elemental gem), and two Quick Ysemeralds (haste only gem) because they are the only haste-forward air gems.

Last night in raid a warrior in my guild told me that all the top tanks have Energized Ysemerald (haste over vers split gem) socketed in their Lariats. I don’t think he was lying but that doesn’t make any sense to me. I get that the split gems have a higher stat budget so in general are better, but doesn’t getting the haste proc far outweigh the ~30 extra static secondary stat? Am I misunderstanding how the proc works?

The only thing I could think of is that while haste is bis mitigation stat maybe there is another stat that is bis damage and they are socketing for that? Or maybe that he meant Energized Malygite (vers over haste split gem) because it is still air element and will proc haste on the lariat.

Thanks in advance.

round pendant
#

I put energized ysemerald in everything 🤷‍♂️

deep spruce
#

TLDR; What gems should i socket as prot warrior?

river granite
jagged pier
#

haste/ x stats

river granite
#

Lariat*

jagged pier
#

well what ever stat u want it to proc u need to put that type of gem in it

river granite
#

...

jagged pier
#

u still want haste whatever stat of that type of gem

#

mine procs crit cause i got fire gems

river granite
#

It doesn't proc based on the stat of the gem it procs based on the element of the gem

jagged pier
#

as far as im aware yes

river granite
#

So there is not haste / x gem that procs haste

#

No*

strong forum
#

the tradeoff is whatever

inland mesa
#

Whetstone is better than boon at same ilvl ye?

Trying to figure out trinkets now. Have whetstone, all master, boon, decoration.

Raid dps is boon whetstone? Then m+ would be whetstone all totem?

strong forum
#

either you get 120 haste from having big haste gems, or you get 120 haste on average from the proc

#

lariat proc only has 30% uptime

plush tendon
#

Boon in M+ if you feeling spicey

strong forum
#

if you go big haste /X gems, you get ~40 extra haste per gem over having say Vers>haste gems

#

but instead you get the haste proc from the element

#

the outcome is the same over the course of a boss/dungeon

#

in regards of haste

tawny briar
#

Which dungeons are ppl speccing in to spell block? I don't run it default and am not sure which dungeons I should be bringing it on

river granite
strong forum
#

its not

#

cuz its 30% uptime

river granite
#

I see

toxic gyro
#

You pick, both are about the same

inland mesa
#

Nome you said frosted Leg enchant yesterday over fierce, was curious to the rational as I see fierce most often

strong forum
#

armor = str

fluid shard
#

Progging on Raszageth H tonight, i'm guessing if i want to cut my healer a bit of slack i could go Immovable Object?

#

Or....

#

hehehe

ocean bloom
#

if you really need an extra button go spell block, but really you should be fine with just Wall and Last stand

strong forum
#

up to you

#

the dmg loss is minimal

robust jackal
#

hey guys I am trying to learn the rotation -> should my dmg look smthing like this ? (I assume revenge would somewhat lower since I barely used ignore pain since it was dummies)

inland mesa
jagged pier
#

SR is fine for that

#

spell block is for final phase

fluid shard
#

kk

#

makes sense

fluid shard
#

haven't gotten there yet

robust jackal
fluid shard
#

how many last phase breath do you go into before no room left? 4?

plush tendon
#

maybe 3 each?

inland mesa
#

First tank 3, 2nd tank 2 is when you barely have room left

plush tendon
#

yea, the tank frontal for war is pretty easy

#

Spell Reflect+SW

#

take like no damage

inland mesa
#

Mythic diurna add team is gonna give me ptsd

plush tendon
#

Havnt looked at that fight yet

inland mesa
#

That stupid add frontal that defies time and space

plush tendon
#

I thought boss tank was the hard role XD

inland mesa
#

And I've had to sit in d stance 😦

plush tendon
#

sadge

inland mesa
#

Yeah, claim we can't 2 heal boss team, so we are trying to 2 heal add team. It's spooky

round pendant
#

I thought fort bolstering would be easy

#

but it's been a nightmare

icy bane
chrome lance
#

guys can anyone please help with mage tower. i did 40 pulls and my best try is 50% on inquisitor.

indigo gulch
#

for weapon enchant, what is prefer, sophic devotion or frozen devotion

plush tendon
#

EZ

sick sentinel
#

dunno if it is just me, but the prot mage tower is really hard

#

like i talked to my bear friend and my boss has 4x the hp as his, my encounter seems really stretched out

icy bane
#

Frozen is slightly more damage, Sophic provides damage and some slight defensive application

jagged pier
#

its the easiest its ever been

plush tendon
#

can you still cheese it with MoP PVP crafted gear?

sick sentinel
#

hmm, im not a tank player tbh

modern brook
#

IV trivilaizes it and fury both tbh

jagged pier
sick sentinel
#

I get to last phase but the annihilate stacks fast

icy bane
sick sentinel
#

fury i literally one shot

jagged pier
#

nome video is on YT if u want to watch nomes its in the promotion channel

sick sentinel
#

YEa ima have a look, i think my mitigation is maybe ass, but its a long encounter + im not really tank player

#

i dide like 15 pulls

chrome lance
#

i am on my 40th.... and my best try is 50% inq

#

and i get 3 infernals before 60

#

rend kills me a lot of times

indigo gulch
lusty tiger
#

how can i acquire more globals to cast revenge

limpid anchor
#

More haste :>

lusty tiger
robust jackal
#

I am probably doing something wrong if I die on tank dummy after 8:20 mins right?

limpid anchor
#

Yes

fluid shard
#

that look like a good heroic Rasz prog build?

limpid anchor
#

Probably

primal totem
#

Does Bloodborne's 10/20% bleed effect work the same as Thunderous Words 15% increase?

limpid anchor
#

And bolster

#

Also you want stun on raz

lofty widget
fluid shard
#

oh true

limpid anchor
#

The higher rage cap is useless

fluid shard
#

yeah i'll move 1 from overwhelming rage

limpid anchor
#

2 :<

#

There’s no way to overcap anyway, and no reason to save so much rage

lusty tiger
#

looking at a prot warrior in a 25, his most cast spell is revenge and i am not near that

icy bane
violet spruce
lofty widget
#

they have 2 charges on heroic

kindred prairie
#

hey, channeling stuff like grieftorch prevents you from blocking, right?

gloomy trail
#

Hey guys, any addons that help becoming a tank in mythic? I have problem only with routes and just leading group

lusty tiger
lusty tiger
lusty tiger
lusty tiger
icy bane
quiet monolith
#

anyone toss me a good current ST dps prot spec?

#

mine got all messed up

robust lark
#

The best way to learn the dungeons is experience.

That being said I'm still trying to figure out when to optimally spell block and SR in keys and bosses. I feel like there are attacks I should be popping it for that aren't necessarily obviously magic attacks

gritty bane
#

hey, the guild is running heroic raid and i am a bit unsure about my performance. mostly when it comes holding up defensives like SB and IP. i feel like i have a problem with rage, but also keeping track of it. this is the logs from yesterdays raid, we did all bosses except for razz.

lusty tiger
deft mortar
#

how viable is barbaric trainnig

#

33% more rage cost for 25% more dmg

strong forum
#

its whack

deft mortar
#

not very rage efficient innit

strong forum
#

its 50% more rage cost

deft mortar
#

roight mate

deft mortar
#

nvm

#

im rollin shockwave

strong forum
#

BT just plays awful

#

for almost 0 gain

deft mortar
#

ye

#

I thought it was 33% rage cost additional

#

Im so dumb

#

how tf am I banker man

lusty tiger
#

@strong forum how can i cast more revenge

strong forum
#

by pressing more shield slams

lusty tiger
#

i do

#

like a fuckton

strong forum
#

and by pressing more revenges, you get more shield slams

strong forum
#

wasted rage is a bit high

#

should be below 1%

deft mortar
#

ahh 20 rage revenge feels good

strong forum
#

but yours is almost 5%

spice axle
#

is there any info on how shield block cap works? sometimes i get 30+ seconds sometimes i dont

strong forum
#

3x duration

#
  • 15sec from bolster
#

so 24sec is cap with Enduring Defenses, when bolster is active, cap is 39sec

lusty tiger
strong forum
#

youre not starved

#

youre overcapping rage

#

aka, not spending enough

modern brook
#

the opposite even

#

you're too mad

lusty tiger
#

I have the hate of a young man's heart

strong forum
#

besides that it looks fine tbh

#

except that somehow DR is your highest dmg

#

you got alot of pad it seems

lusty tiger
#

i like pressing that button (:

strong forum
#

aaah you wiped like 2 times

kindred prairie
strong forum
#

on flowers

#

its true

lofty widget
#

it is

kindred prairie
#

ty. so thats -1 trinket I want lol

strong forum
#

its only a 2second channel

icy bane
#

It’s still a good trinket

strong forum
#

can be easily played

kindred prairie
#

I guess. but kinda risky

heavy glen
#

what are we doing for our builds now?

jagged pier
#

nothing has changed

lusty tiger
plush tendon
#

I hope theres a competition where everyone has to do a randomized build

swift orbit
#

Yo, how do I train the ruby whelp shell trinket for m+? AoE or ST?

modern brook
#

St proc bis imo

gloomy trail
#

Any addons for easy routes then :D?

swift orbit
#

So every day I just train it on a single mob, ye?

agile elbow
#

Is Phial of Eye in the Storm not good compared to other phials?

lusty tiger
gritty bane
lusty tiger
#

the only issue i have with guru is there are a lot of invis skips

lusty tiger
spice axle
lusty tiger
spice axle
#

ok

lusty tiger
#

about 1/5 of your shield slams gave no rage- basically

gritty bane
# lusty tiger BRO U GOTTA BLOCK

yeah my uptime is kinda bad, thats whats been bothering me :L but dont know a good way to train it. but ill try to think more about the rage overcapping

#

didnt think that would be a problem 🤔

lusty tiger
#

u should block at least 90%

#

u blocked 63%

inner rock
#

Is spell reflecting bomb on last boss of AA just trolling my melee?

lusty tiger
#

log the raid tank dummy and practice there

urban bane
#

ya think about it like this re: rage overcap. all of those rage points are CDR, and damage/IP just down the drain

#

rage overcap is a leak in a fuel pipe

scenic marten
#

did they nerf the setbonus or am i tripping? didnt it actually renew the buff so the timer reseted every time as well?

modern snow
#

what dps y'all reckon you need for mage tower

lofty widget
#

it just applied IP if you didnt have it up

#

well it still does that

scenic marten
#

ahh yea makes sense

gritty bane
# lusty tiger u blocked 63%

where do i see that? and what makes me block less other than having shieldblock not up? (also sorry for nooby questions, im kinda new to watching logs. but thanks so much for help)

lusty tiger
gritty bane
#

ahhh, yeah that is a small problem

lusty tiger
#

a small giant problem

#

its like playing deathknight w a 20 sec CD on deathstrike

gritty bane
#

i dont understand the comparison, but i bet it makes sense for others. crucial ability is crucial i guess

#

again, is it just that i dont have shieldblock up enough? or amd i playing wrong. like standing with back against mobs etc (sometimes happens but rarely)

timber terrace
#

With your talents shield wall is around a 1 minute cd you should use it very often and you almost don't

lusty tiger
lusty tiger
tropic tangle
#

yeah, that's your main form of mitigation

timber terrace
#

Just maintain shield block as close to 100% as you can and use your cds way more

gritty bane
#

6 ish seconds. i do have WA for it.

lusty tiger
#

also shield block makes shield slam stronger which will up your dps a ton

lusty tiger
gritty bane
#

36 seconds

lusty tiger
#

mhm

gritty bane
#

1/5 ish of the fight

lusty tiger
#

yep

timber terrace
#

Play with bolster if you struggle to maintain shield block and use last stand on the pull

tropic tangle
#

press buttons

lusty tiger
#

press buttons more methodically

tropic tangle
#

use your abilities

gritty bane
#

is there a good way to "train" to use shieldblock more? since as mentioned i felt that keeping up my defensives were my biggest problem

gritty bane
#

or is it just, git gud.

#

ait

lusty tiger
#

u are overcapped rage

#

u need to just press it

tropic tangle
#

shield block is off the gcd

#

ignore pain is off the gcd

timber terrace
#

Make a weakaura that calls you an idiot when you get meleed and shield block isn't up

lofty widget
#

place a shield block weakaura where it's easy to see, can add an audio cue when it drops if that helps

gritty bane
#

so many sounds already going on in raid 😦

lusty tiger
lofty widget
#

as long as youre aware when it's up and when it isnt

slate kraken
#

I'm fond of a WW2 Submarine Dive Klaxon

lusty tiger
gritty bane
#

i also tend to sometimes double tap it, which makes me use too many charges.

timber terrace
#

Adjust your boss mod you don't need wub wub and horn sounds for every mechanic

slate kraken
#

yes, you'll know it when you hear it

lusty tiger
kindred prairie
#

do sims take into consideration getting hit? for trinkets with on-hit effects like Granyth's Enduring Scale

lusty tiger
#

youll be fine if u do that more than if u dont press it at all

gritty bane
#

ait thanks. maybe ill make the wa bigger so i easier sees when it goes away 🤔

#

even tho i feel my screen is too cluttered already

lusty tiger
#

there is nothing to spend rage on until you have sb up

gritty bane
#

that is fair

lusty tiger
frosty mango
#

did they remove double wall?

gritty bane
#

this is how it usually looks when im in combat. just add lots of spell effects and shit too. is it ok or should i try find a better setup?

#

and ofcourse raid profiles etc

lusty tiger
gritty bane
#

hard to see if cds are off or not with smaller action bars tho

#

and to find -> click potion

lusty tiger
lusty tiger
gritty bane
#

i dont have more accesible binds, recently started to use shift binds, before that i just clicked all defensives and personals that wasnt SB or IP

#

so still getting used to it

lusty tiger
gritty bane
#

ait, ill try that!

#

omw to become nr.1 prot warrior. credits to jerreeeeee

lusty tiger
#

sense would like a word w us all

#

GL tho

short elk
#

How many ilvls until I should give up the cobalt ring?

slate kraken
deft mortar
#

I got the xtra stams for Jade Serpent

#

idk if dumb but

#

Intervane isnt very useful here

lusty tiger
#

but i think u run a lil higher keys so might need it

#

battering ram gives some big time leech ya kno

deft mortar
#

ye but

#

afraid of getting one hit

lofty widget
#

double wall or spell block is a lot better than 5 % stam

amber siren
#

No shockwave and no spell block?

lofty widget
#

99/100 times that does nothing for your survival

deft mortar
#

I got shockwave

#

sry I meant

#

I got spell block

#

My melee hits are like 7.5% of my overall so probably loose 1.5%ish dps from not having ram

lofty widget
#

more

#

from fewer SS resets

deft mortar
#

90 Shield Charges in a run proba loose like 30% dps on them and thats another 1.5%ish dps loss

#

eh tbf my SS resets seem fine

#

Wish details told me the source of SS resets

icy bane
cunning parcel
#

Anyone else's shield bugged and not showing after the patch?

uneven ice
#

Hi! On logs, where do you see blocked hits?

lofty widget
#

hover the number

rough egret
slow spire
#

Still mulling over vault options. Thoughts on whether its worth to nab a 3 ilvl (415->418) weapon upgrade when the 415 has 161 leech? I'd be taking a socket if not...

cunning parcel
#

ahh yeh its colloding with cooking equipment

rough egret
#

So i sometimes end up with weap only visual

cunning parcel
#

thanks thought I was loosing my mind

lofty widget
slow spire
#

but... muh leech

lofty widget
#

leech isnt that big of a deal

slow spire
#

I'm sure it sims higher as I would be moving from haste/vers to haste/crit as well as just raw ilvl

rough egret
#

Fear, shockweave, stormbolt

wary ivy
deft mortar
#

speaking of it why are ppl who leave M+ at slightest inconvenience are not scrutunized

#

But I get insta banned if I whisper them after

#

unkindly

amber siren
#

Can't force people to play with you

deft mortar
#

If we were in the same room I could kekw

#

Gotta make mfs sing contracts before doing M+ with them it seems

plush tendon
#

because one is against the terms of service

#

and the other is allowed

deft mortar
#

lol the company with 700 reported incidents of employee harassment judging me 2 hard

jagged pier
chrome jacinth
#

spell block does not help with the bleeds in AA right only the caster mobs ?

jagged pier
#

its the problem with score being acttached to things

#

and thats literally a player made issue

deft mortar
#

Dude legit left cuz I didnt skip Lorewalker trash

#

Jiang and Xiang specifically

jagged pier
#

happens

#

it is easier to skip them

#

but not key ending

plush tendon
#

I mean, you want to skip those two panda

#

double the health of every other panda

#

and like half the count

#

.#notworth

#

and they always kill at least one person with their dot

tacit widget
#

brutal vitality still better than fuled by violence?

plush tendon
tacit widget
strong forum
#

Spellblock doesn't work vs dots

#

Only vs direct casts

frosty mango
#

Bolster is no fun :/

jagged pier
#

nope

#

love slowing down keys

#

for no reason

#

good fun

frosty mango
#

Rlp is terrible for bolster

#

Can't pull large anywhere, it hurts my soul

#

Healer told me to double the last packs before boss, I said "prob a bad choice" but he was confident

heady gyro
#

That sounds like a bad idea

pallid hare
#

ill take bolster over sanguine any day =/ dumb that it slows things down but meh

plush tendon
#

never trust healer confidence

#

only tank confidence

#

healer confidence is just ignorance

frosty mango
deft mortar
#

tbf

#

I will send vibe check whispers before inviting ppl

sick sentinel
#

i've gone and put my self in another sketchy group comp

#

no lust

deft mortar
#

drums np

toxic gyro
#

Lust isn’t mandatory

deft mortar
#

all 3 have Attack power buff

#

monk gives 5% physical

plush tendon
#

that looks like a good group

deft mortar
#

DH gives 5% magic dmg

plush tendon
#

arms, havoc, ww

deft mortar
#

resto there

frosty mango
#

Is that an arms warrior?

deft mortar
#

13% more dmg in there just cuz buffs

sick sentinel
plush tendon
#

fuck yea it is

#

arms slaps