#protection

1 messages · Page 290 of 1

astral crystal
#

raz is considerably easier with a smaller raid group for all it's worth

solar sandal
#

might be a silly question but how reliable are stat sims for prot war?

high drum
#

we were doing it with 30 lol

jagged pier
#

in terms of mechanics is actually harder than spider and kurog as well

stable valve
#

think it's worth knocking out mythic council before heroic raz?

astral crystal
#

yeah 30 ppl is a nightmare

high drum
#

mystic council is way easier than raz

solar sandal
jagged pier
#

but the tuning of those make them harders than raz hc

astral crystal
#

our first h raz kill was with 16 i think

high drum
#

mystic council is as easy as hc council

#

no changes

stable valve
#

In a new want to be 5/8M this tier team, so unsure

#

still new to the raiding scene

solar sandal
#

i have not a lot of haste gear so decided to just full pivot into crit since stat weights said crit was "better". fine or kinda should just stack haste regardless?

high drum
#

haste #1

#

crit and vers are both fine but why would u want less haste

solar sandal
#

it's like putting a bandaid on the problem when i gem and enchant for haste

#

lol

#

just feels bad idk

edgy grail
#

You just sim your enchants in top gear

jagged pier
#

yer it will give u crit

wind vigil
#

primary stats on prot ?

modern brook
cinder storm
#

Monk dies 15 times on cos 19, dies on last boss 40% to go, missed timer by 30s, monk still gets whetstone

modern brook
#

owned

cinder storm
sick sentinel
#

this is the way

#

the worse you do, the better loot you get

cinder storm
#

Spin 2 win

sick sentinel
#

yup, and the simpler your attacks are, the more dps it does

blazing condor
#

in the same sense that no good deed goes unpunished

#

so does bad deeds never go unrewarded

sick sentinel
#

its like going to a game of friday night magic and some shit head kid thats been screaming all night wins a default pack and opens foil mythic and mythic

fresh belfry
#

looking for some input: what specific reasons are there that to always have a BDK tank diurna (in phase one specifically) and not the adds. or maybe to not have the BDK play adds but warrior instead

#

other than "everyone does it"

high drum
#

on mystic or hc?

fresh belfry
#

mythic ofc

#

heroic allows for any tank combinations but mythic specifically has 27 out of 27 public logs with a bdk, but the reason for that isnt p1 but p2

high drum
#

is it something to do with the mortal strike?

uneven ice
#

Hi! Why is it mythic+ guides builds on wowhead takes intimidating shout? Fear always looked really troublesome in closed spaces

high drum
#

to interrupt with

#

it breaks immediately

drifting needle
#

Just another aoe stop, always handy

uneven ice
#

But there is danger to over pull isn’t it?

high drum
#

no they dont move

#

because it breaks immediately

uneven ice
#

Aaaaaaa

#

So they don’t run around?

drifting needle
#

I mean by spell effect yes, but the damage “needed” to break it is so small, it would be rare they full send into another pack

uneven ice
#

Ok, now makes more sense to me

#

Thanks!

drifting needle
#

But when in doubt, just pull em back slightly from another pack if danger of pulling but likely if you’re that close, your back flipping DH would have pulled by now

oak echo
#

just tclap right after sending it and it will almost guarantee to break right away. only time you have strays running off is if they were already too far away to get hit by aoe damage but close enough for the fear

uneven ice
#

One more question: I see mist builds go without intervene. Is it bad?

drifting needle
modern brook
oak echo
#

it just doesn't serve a ton of utility. not a huge amount of targeted mechanics anymore. and intervening like your melee is more often than not going to get them frontaled instead

drifting needle
#

Wolf boi in HoV as an example

high drum
#

good to use on healer in tjs last guy

#

during adds

uneven ice
#

Oh, ok. Thanks for the quick answers! 👍

median vortex
#

Wowhead tells me Ruby Whelp Shell is the bis trinket for prot warriors

#

Is this true? seems like such a waste trinket.

oak echo
#

It is not very good

median vortex
#

Wth is it doing on the bis list? 😛

gritty glen
#

Don't use "bis" lists

median vortex
#

Mkay =p

high drum
#

GRIEFTORCH

gritty glen
#

Regarding Ruby Whelp Shell, it's bad because you can't control the proc

high drum
#

grieftorch is so great

#

not only is it strong but its thematically fantastic

#

with the name and cdr effect

limpid anchor
#

Especially because you can’t block during it

sturdy sable
high drum
#

grief ur friends for a reset

#

grief ur team trying to use it

sturdy sable
#

Grief of all those babies being lightning beamed

limpid anchor
#

I had the grieftorch weakaura that whispers people if they die

#

It got a bit spamy on mythic progress

high drum
#

i need that

limpid anchor
#

And I got so many angry whispers

#

It was fun :)

grave flower
#

405 crafted weapon or strike twice?

jagged pier
coarse crystal
#

Strike twice because then you can have embellishments on other items

earnest nymph
#

does the eye in the storm buff last until combat drop?

#

I just noticed there's no duration on it

uncut zephyr
#

Can you easily see on wowhead if a spell/ability is blockable?

lofty widget
#

theres a pinned sheet that will tell you

#

for all dungeons+raid

uncut zephyr
#

sweet

#

Algethar bird boss fucks man

toxic gyro
#

Yea the bleed is definitely not pleasant

lime urchin
#

just tell your dps to do more dps!

wide dragon
#

Hello Warrior hivemind, question for ya. If you already have decoration of flame, is it worth also using an unstable frostfire belt for the Eranog/Diurna rings?

lofty widget
#

yeah

autumn tundra
#

For keys, do i care about wearing 4 set? Is it big? or should i prio 2stat and stats?

wide dragon
#

4 set feels really good in keys imo

lofty widget
#

you can drop 4p for ilvl, but not for stats

autumn tundra
#

Is recommended?

fallen pulsar
#

Its basically 5% leech, makes damage intake much smoother

steep condor
#

Is it possible for warriors to do the death run in court of stars where the party goes to the beginning and you go round and open the gate? I’ve never done it - anything to know?

fallen pulsar
#

I dont see why not, you probably want to just charge the bridge adds then leap to the gate to make it fast, I think thats all you need to do to open it right? Just reach the area

obtuse pebble
#

Did it yesterday, it's fine. You only need to get to the bridge and the gate will open

steep condor
#

i think that is all - was just wondering what survivability chances are to get that far 🙂

fallen pulsar
#

Theres nothing super dangerous imo

#

Maybe if you butt pull imps

#

But nothing else should turbo kill you

#

Can also probably shield wall for safety

tropic linden
#

Hey @jagged pier why not run ITF when my block is 85%? Or is it only for Tyr when bosses hit harder?

steep condor
#

i'll be attempting it with a pug - fraught with peril 🙂 I've never actually tanked that dungeon and only dps'd it a couple of times. Wondering what the more straightforward traditional route looks like. Maybe i should start iwth that

fallen pulsar
#

CoS is pretty easy tankwise

#

I see people around me drop way before I ever do

obtuse pebble
#

There is only really one mob (the big one at the start) and once you get out the last door you can pretty much just leap to bridge

steep condor
#

thanks guys 🙂

jagged pier
#

someone replied to u earlier

fallen pulsar
#

Idk, I never bother doing death run, feel like its just as fast to dps the add up the stairs and have everyone there

steep condor
fallen pulsar
#

Yeah

#

Pugs never expect death skips

#

Afaik

fallow osprey
#

Sounds like a recipe for disaster

tropic linden
lyric geode
#

There is a rumor that @sick sentinel reached 110% uptime Shield block.

fallen pulsar
#

I desperately want bitter immunity to cleanse bleeds

#

Would be so pog

toxic gyro
#

I mean you can, just drop a point somewhere

fallen pulsar
#

It doesnt cleanse bleeds

limpid anchor
#

But it doesn’t cure bleed

#

Useless talent imo

#

Except aa

fallen pulsar
#

Yeah I only take it if no poison cleanse in group for tree

toxic gyro
#

No poison cleanse sounds like a troll in aa

fallen pulsar
#

Eh, bitter immunity is good enough imo

sweet summit
#

wat

#

no

jagged pier
#

eh?

#

what?

#

eh?

limpid anchor
#

1 dispell isn’t enough

#

At least not for me :(

toxic gyro
#

How you deal with 4th germination ?

fallen pulsar
#

I mean I havent done high enough keys for there to be more than 2 add phases lmao

slender blade
#

3 min cooldown, im not chad enough to tank a high tyran with only one dispel the whole fight

fallen pulsar
#

Shield wall and d stance

limpid anchor
#

Doesn’t help

#

When it ticks 150k

fallen pulsar
#

Yeah this answer changes dramatically on higher keys lmao

toxic gyro
#

Youre a thick warrior lol

limpid anchor
#

Yea

fallen pulsar
#

But I havent done AA on anything past a 15 yet

limpid anchor
#

On 20 it didn’t die quickly :(

slender blade
toxic gyro
#

On higher keys you will need dispell period

fallen pulsar
#

Yes agreed

#

I’m not a madman

tropic linden
fallen pulsar
#

I just also am not pushing that high

naive hatch
#

what trinkets are we lookin' at being good for us

limpid anchor
#

Can any dps dispell poison? Except sham with the totem

toxic gyro
#

It’s best when you ask your ret friend for dispell and he replies with “oh fuck I forgot to talent it” keks

fallen pulsar
#

I think poison is just sham, druid, and uhh ret?

#

I dont remember

sweet summit
#

pala monk evoker

#

and uhhh

#

druid

limpid anchor
#

Dps evoker? Good to know

sweet summit
#

no idea

fallen pulsar
#

No idea

high drum
#

yes dps envoker

#

on like 8 sec cd

merry scroll
#

Anyone still using the assembly ring? I got a heroic emmisary's flamewrought seal the other night and deciding if i should sell or not

warm plinth
#

Do they actually talent it is the question

tropic linden
fallen pulsar
#

I still have cobalt ring, havent gotten better ring drops yet sadge

merry scroll
#

Also curious if people just sim gear as tank or if theres a better way to decide since i know theres more to tanking than dps

fallen pulsar
#

Still rock damage cobalt + melandrus

coral frost
#

hello guys! im new to prot warrior and have a question. Do we ever use Rend?

fallen pulsar
#

No

high drum
#

no just tclap

merry scroll
#

blood and thunder

fallen pulsar
#

No whirlwind, no slam

coral frost
#

shield slam and thunderclap

earnest nymph
#

what phial are y'all using in M+ these days? I've been exclusively using eye in the storm but I see some using the vers one and I can't wrap my head around it

fallen pulsar
#

Revenge shield slam and thunderclap is all you need

#
  • execute
jagged pier
#

u use eye

coral frost
#

ok, ty!

fallen pulsar
merry scroll
#

thoughts on all-totem? currently use that and spiteful storm until i get something that does more damage

tropic linden
#

I'm going with this for M+, beside swapping ITF for HR, any other tip?

jagged pier
#

u dont run BSV

merry scroll
#

I tend to avoid bsv

fallen pulsar
#

I prefer the second shield charge talent over bsv

tropic linden
jagged pier
#

u shouldnt use that ither

fallen pulsar
#

? What do those have to do with eachother

limpid anchor
#

Nando doesn’t know keks

fallen pulsar
#

Rip

#

Educate me

earnest nymph
tropic linden
#

It makes ravage cost 0 rage when u parry

high drum
#

thunderlord sucks

tropic linden
#

So the 10 more rage is nullified

jagged pier
#

because its doesnt work properly and is actually bad

jagged pier
#

u use revenge alot

urban portal
#

3 ppm

#

sheesh

merry scroll
#

wish it was easier to get points into bloodborne, i feel like that would add a lot

urban portal
#

bloodborne needs to be a 1 point

#

its too weak at 2

jagged pier
#

its like 1.5% damage per point in it

#

its usless

urban portal
#

tho prot warrior is too strong

earnest nymph
#

my b

tropic linden
#

Should i get what instead?

urban portal
#

so idk

jagged pier
#

as tough of nails if 5% for 1 point

pallid quiver
urban portal
#

nothing wrong with vers tho

#

even dps uses vers

jagged pier
urban portal
#

but vers is more dps for dps than tanks

high drum
#

so is the mainstat flask

tropic linden
#

Maybe show of force?

jagged pier
#

battering ram

fallen pulsar
#

also I dont think you're running show of force

jagged pier
#

show of force

fallen pulsar
#

yeah show of force is great

jagged pier
#

wha

high drum
#

remove thunderlord take show of force

tropic linden
high drum
#

remove battle scarred veteran add battering ram

merry scroll
#

Hows this for m+https://i.imgur.com/RVRXIn4.jpeg

high drum
#

remove thunderlord add battering ram

#

and take spellblock instaed of nails in most dungeons

pallid quiver
#

"most dungeons"

lofty widget
#

nah nails is good

pallid quiver
#

doubt

high drum
#

oh and stormbolt

cinder storm
#

Most dungeons?

gritty swallow
#

Spell block is a hot take

high drum
#

SPELL BLOCK #1

gritty swallow
#

Good in temple

cinder storm
#

It's not a hot take, buts it's goat in three

tropic linden
#

But if I don't take BSC i can't take the AOE taunt

high drum
#

temple, sbg, ruby, azure vaults

tropic linden
#

And improved heroic throw looks garbo

high drum
#

fantastic in all of those

drifting needle
#

3/8 for Spell Block, otherwise I go nails

high drum
#

im sure im forgetting another too

fallen pulsar
#

Spell Block also good in RLP tyrannical imo, makes 1st boss much smoother

lofty widget
#

havent felt the need for spell block in 20s yet, overrated imo

high drum
#

really?

gritty swallow
#

Only 20 I grabbed spell block for was temple specifically for 3rd boss

cinder storm
#

Why would you take spell block for SBG? Two packs that you can kite

grave flower
high drum
#

first boss too

drifting needle
high drum
#

his auto attack damage buff is a spell

gritty swallow
#

I feel like otherwise it’s underutilized because I’ve adapted defensives otherwise so I forget I have it

buoyant narwhal
#

Do you all use Pain and Gain? feels like it doesnt do much at all for 1 point

gritty swallow
#

Spell reflect lasts long enough

high drum
#

wrong

trim hill
#

first boss rlp without Spell Block yikes

high drum
#

and in AV you will die last boss without spellblock for the random dragonstrike with reflect down

merry scroll
#

is it really worth dropping thunderlord for battering ram?

lofty widget
lofty widget
#

the +15 is a really nice buffer

merry scroll
#

aight

fallen pulsar
#

pain and gain is decent, but usually once of the first ones that gets swapped out for other tech choices

buoyant narwhal
#

sweet

young rivet
#

is there a list of where to use spell block for M+?

trim hill
#

why would you take overwhelming rage just hit IP its off the gcd

gritty swallow
#

Pins

fallen pulsar
#

yeah overwhelming in m+ feels kinda meh

lofty widget
#

not like it matters

#

i'd swap it for a dps talent but theres nothing else to take

fallen pulsar
#

main things I swap in m+ are taking double shield wall for tank buster heavy dungeons, like RLP boss 2, TJS boss 3, and AA Bird

#

spell block in TJS

tropic linden
#

If I remove BSC, I need to get improved heroic throw to go down that tree, shouldn't i stick with BSC?

cinder storm
#

Faster leap is good to for AV last boss

jagged pier
#

no

#

BSV

#

not BSC

fallen pulsar
#

I usually tech intervene for AV over like pain and gain

#

and use an ally to dodge balls

tropic linden
#

Oh, got all wrong

#

think i'll stick with BSV until I get more confidence. Already saved me from death more than 1 time

trim hill
high drum
#

no

#

it sucks

slender blade
high drum
#

thunderlord means ur devo no longer lines up with battering ram/avatar

fallen pulsar
#

plenty of people do take BSV, it however can be buggy.

jagged pier
#

no they fixed the bug

#

its still bad tho

fallen pulsar
#

for real this time?

strong forum
#

It's still buggy

fallen pulsar
#

lmfao

strong forum
#

Just not as buggy

jagged pier
#

lots of time u dip below 30% and u dont need it and it will proc

#

then when u do need it

#

its gone

strong forum
#

It doesn't proc at 100% hp anymore

#

But it does proc at 50-80% still

astral crystal
#

it has randomly procced during prog for me as well

#

at about half health yeah

#

it's weird

jagged pier
#

well there u go

#

pretty garbage then

strong forum
#

Yeah it's pretty terrible

jagged pier
#

also it being untrackble without a WA

#

is horrendous

trim hill
#

how can it not line up if the demo cd is lower than avatar

high drum
#

avatar cd usually winds up being around 45 sec

atomic inlet
#

hey guys whats ur strategy for mitigating damage from ruby second boss

grave flower
#

dont out range it

modern brook
high drum
#

so if ur using TL to decrease demo cd, its not gonna line up

jagged pier
#

u cant

modern brook
atomic inlet
fallen pulsar
#

what if I jump down the hole 🤔

strong forum
#

Killing yourself ingame is the best way to avoid mechanics

fallen pulsar
#

ezpz

lucid cloak
high drum
#

cant fall any further

strong forum
#

Exactly

#

Hp can't be reduced either

#

Insane lifehack

atomic inlet
#

guys whats ur strategy for mitigating damage from ruby second boss ? i always get crushed even thouge im using shield block and full ignore pain

high drum
#

2 walls

jagged pier
#

but as its been said

#

its procs at 80-30% range

#

so how is that a cheat death?

atomic inlet
#

at least i got a reply

#

😄

earnest nymph
#

and pray

jagged pier
#

spell reflect does nothing on that boss

#

🤔

earnest nymph
#

^^

jagged pier
#

its physical damage

earnest nymph
#

spell block doesn't work either

gritty swallow
#

Press it to feel good

toxic gyro
#

What you mean, you just reflect that bleed keks

jagged pier
#

imma tell

#

u

earnest nymph
#

the talent

jagged pier
#

guys the secret strat

toxic gyro
jagged pier
#

run crit

#

u can parry stacks

earnest nymph
#

oh god

raw meadow
#

the add still does fire damage no? with spell reflect you consume less IP

alpine night
#

since evo can, probably dwarf too yes

gritty swallow
#

Crit gang

jagged pier
#

unless they changed it like the bird i guess

toxic gyro
earnest nymph
#

here we go with the crit/haste thing again D:

safe moon
jagged pier
#

i mean crit is our best defensive stat in m+ technically speaking

#

🤷

grave flower
#

just be darkiron dwarf

atomic inlet
#

where is it i cant find

grave flower
#

I guess any dward

atomic inlet
grave flower
#

but why be a reg dwarf you know?

toxic gyro
atomic inlet
#

got it

#

ty

jagged pier
#

so your taking BRV which is amazing

#

you dont like block for some reason

torpid cloak
#

got loot questions boys

#

which one to take

olive steeple
#

I’d take trinket

torpid cloak
#

both best in slot

tropic linden
#

Sooo... Show of Force or Battering Ram?

earnest nymph
#

hands, rather

torpid cloak
#

thats the debate

#

hands do have a rarer drop chance

buoyant narwhal
#

Anything you guys would change using this as a base, and changing a few things based on the dungeon like Tough as nails to spell block, double wall at times etc?

olive steeple
#

I think your current trinkets aren’t great. But yes you’ll eventually get the trinket from first boss anyway

jagged pier
buoyant narwhal
#

oh yeah, i always have stormbolt instead

olive steeple
buoyant narwhal
#

not sure why i have it lol, thx

earnest nymph
#

I'm wrong

#

😄

torpid cloak
#

its +22 str vs +40

earnest nymph
#

yep

#

ignore me

torpid cloak
#

but could the trinket damage make up

buoyant narwhal
olive steeple
#

Yes trinket is fantastic

jade radish
#

Has anyone had any issues with sims showing a much higher average damage per hit of abilities than they see in the actual game? sims showing me with 30k+ average shield slams and my dungeon averages are closer to 22k

olive steeple
#

The on use is great offensively and defensively

torpid cloak
#

thanks for the help

earnest nymph
jagged pier
#

why would u take a trinket that drops for the first boss of the raid

#

before uve run the raid?

#

like u can ever pug eggnogg hc

#

and its better than that one

torpid cloak
#

cause im swapping out ruby trinket

rare kraken
#

I love prot warrior

#

spell reflect is my passion

proud dock
#

403ilvl, at wat lvl key wud u "sit in dstance" cuz everything hurts?

#

i know u not posed to sit in dstance

astral crystal
#

what is going on with that dmg breakdown

jade radish
#

none

earnest nymph
rare kraken
#

Prot warrior should be able to take everything

candid reef
#

Hey guys, any tips for talents for 3rd boss in temple of jade? Always struggling there

proud dock
#

god dammit, i gotta be less scared then

rare kraken
#

I can't think of a trash pull where I have to actively kite it

#

Prot has a button for every problem

high drum
#

last pull tjs

earnest nymph
#

there are times where you'll want to stance dance but there's no reason to perma sit in dstance

rare kraken
high drum
#

runs out

rare kraken
#

Not quickly enough

astral crystal
#

ya i just have MD and run

high drum
#

same with pull b4 first boss sbg

strong forum
rare kraken
#

Shield wall + spell reflect + spell block makes it a breeze

high drum
#

dont forget shockwave

rare kraken
#

Usually both dark claws go off at the same time so your spell reflect has double value

strong forum
#

And crit rng also plays a role geum

limpid anchor
high drum
#

but it still runs out

rare kraken
#

yeah shockwave to stop dark claws you can't mitigate

earnest nymph
tropic linden
rare kraken
#

You can reflect conducive strike, gives him the debuff

#

Insane dot damage, especially on tyrannical

astral crystal
#

did your dps die or something?

#

how'd they manage sub 30k

rare kraken
#

Nah they were just very mid

#

It was only a 10

rare kraken
high drum
#

what does mid mean

rare kraken
#

just have to cycle cooldowns and watch the dark claws

#

Basically stare at the minions of doubt

#

you don't have to use your defensive cds until they start casting it

high drum
#

and are you telling him its easy after posting a 27k single target dps details with 25% of it being reflect

astral crystal
#

fear shas also have piercing gaze

rare kraken
#

They're the only tankbusters

astral crystal
#

which also trucks

#

that's also a tankbuster

earnest nymph
#

does bumping bug reports on the forum help anything?

rare kraken
#

Not as hard as dark claw does

rare kraken
rare kraken
#

I tanked a 15 this week and had no issues with the pack

high drum
#

damn ur strong

rare kraken
#

Spell reflect solves that pack very well

#

If you can do it while they're enraged

proud dock
#

does sidearm target something CC'd? liek for last boss NO, wud it proc on a nearby CC'd add?

tropic linden
#

R u guys picking Battering Ram or SoF?

rare kraken
#

chefs kiss

astral crystal
#

timed a 20 TJS yesterday and i kited, granted i didn't even think to take spell block

#

would've made it much easier

proud dock
rare kraken
#

I think my spell reflect record on that pack is uh

#

280k from one hit?

trim hill
#

15 tyrannical trash dies in like 5 secs which is why you don’t care. Once the pack survives your CDs it’s difficult and you will need to coordinate stops or kite

rare kraken
#

That was an enraged dark claw I think

rare kraken
#

Should really be taken but I see so many prot warriors take tough as nails which is :\

#

And then they complain about prot being squishy to magic damage xDD

astral crystal
#

thing is i dont really feel squishy

high drum
#

ur also saying u dont need to kite in tjs last pack

astral crystal
#

so i dont feel forced to take it

high drum
#

but ur experience is a 15

#

u need to kite it trust me

rare kraken
gritty swallow
#

Idk ran a 20 and just took it to the face like a champ

rare kraken
#

I usually do above what people would consider acceptable for my ilvl

gritty swallow
#

Just rotate defensives

rare kraken
gritty swallow
#

Stun when spell reflect down

high drum
#

i did a 20 fort last week

cinder storm
#

You can SR then SW then spell block last mob % when they enrage

high drum
#

and u absolutely do not have enough defensives

rare kraken
#

If you don't have defensives, you have cc

high drum
#

u gotta leap away at some point

gritty swallow
#

🤷

cinder storm
#

I mostly move only to grab adds that spawn when people run like headless chickens

rare kraken
#

They don't recast when you stun them

#

Which means the timer will reset and you'll have spell reflect by the next dark claw

gritty swallow
#

Exactly

earnest nymph
#

it just depends on what is up, what you're comfortable with, and how much dam your group is doing. like there are several ways to tackle that pack

#

this doesn't need to be a fight

gritty swallow
limpid anchor
#

And we are prob around the same gear, they do chunk and they do outlive your spell block when dps isn’t that good

astral crystal
#

ya ultimately group dmg is what makes the difference in those deadly packs

rare kraken
#

I don't pug

limpid anchor
#

Saying no need to kite is just wrong

rare kraken
#

So my group does great damage and is constantly dropping cc

limpid anchor
#

What’s your ilvl

high drum
rare kraken
#

396 now

limpid anchor
#

27k dps

#

Aya

rare kraken
#

what should it be then

tropic tangle
#

you're also doing 15? like, trying to compare a 15 to a 20 is silly in terms of damage from the mobs and how long they live even with good DPS

rare kraken
#

fine I'll do a 20 next week and compare

#

if I don't have to kite because I rotate my defensives and cc the mobs then yall are trolling me

high drum
#

why would people troll

#

you can just go watch anyone do that key on high level

#

on fort or whatever

#

you'll see them kite

#

when cds run out

rare kraken
#

link for a high Jade?

high drum
#

i don't have a dossier im afraid

rare kraken
#

lol ok

rare kraken
#

ty

gritty swallow
#

Nerftank streamed a 23 the other day

tropic tangle
earnest nymph
#

btw no kiting on that 21

tropic tangle
#

this you? because you didn't time that 15

mild river
#

Hey there! I have a doubt: The trinket "Ruby Whelp Shell" is good for tanks?

rare kraken
high drum
earnest nymph
#

that's what I just said, and is also consistent with what I've been saying

high drum
#

mobs will die before spellblock expires

earnest nymph
#

there are several options for dealing with that pack

jade radish
# strong forum You're not using outburst often enough on shield slam then

seems like thats still quite a gap. VO procs after 280 rage, i generated 1.5k rage in a 2.5 min fight in that details segment (ST boss) that'd only be 5 VOs or so out of 44 SS casts, VO is 200% extra dam, basically add dam for 10 more SS, even assuming i used 0 VOs on SS that fight, that would bring my average to 27k compared to raidbots 32k average

earnest nymph
#

and they're all situational

rare kraken
#

I mean I heard "you'll see them kite" and I didn't see them kite

#

Show me a pull where they have to kite the pack

earnest nymph
#

it's always going to be situational

#

like holy moly

rare kraken
jade radish
rare kraken
#

The "situation" I'm hearing is that if the group doesn't dps/cc enough then you have to kite?

earnest nymph
#

if group dam sucks and you're not running spell block, you might have to kite depending on key level. if group dam is pumping, and you're running spell block, maybe you don't have to kite

high drum
#

if the mobs arent dead and ur cds arent' up, you have to kite on some packs

earnest nymph
#

if you're running a 10 and you're comfortable with your class, you probably don't have to kite

high drum
#

if you dont believe this, then whatever

rare kraken
#

I think yall are talking about situations I haven't encountered yet

earnest nymph
#

sure

rare kraken
#

so I guess I'll just keep rocking it

earnest nymph
#

that's possible

rare kraken
#

until I encounter otherwise

earnest nymph
#

everyone who is saying there is only one option to deal with that pack though is out of touch imo

rare kraken
#

There isn't only one option to deal with that pack, as with most things there are a variety of approaches

#

but I'm suspicious of people who say the pack trucks and they're forced to kite because prot has the toolkit to handle it no stress

earnest nymph
#

the pack does objectively truck. but if you're equipped to handle it then maybe you can facetank it

#

there are like, idk, 10 different factors that determine it, including key level

rare kraken
high drum
#

understand that there might be things you don't know

rare kraken
#

lol ok

cinder storm
#

On a 15 with your gear you have time to drool on the keyboard before you experience any spikes, on a higher key you have to be on point with your cds

rare kraken
#

Again I'll check back next week

high drum
#

why? noone cares

#

just take the advice or don't

rare kraken
#

What "advice"

#

Your "advice" is that I don't know any better

high drum
#

if the mobs arent dead and ur cds arent' up, you have to kite on some packs

earnest nymph
atomic inlet
#

daymn guys

#

thanks for the tip

#

fianly did ruby 18

high drum
#

pog

atomic inlet
#

double shield wall worked like a charm

cinder storm
#

EZ clap

atomic inlet
serene fox
#

Hey prot warriors! I play resto and my friends a prot warrior. Wondered if anyone could give me some tips on ruby life pools, the 2nd boss searing wounds debuff just absolutely melts my friend... If I don't have iron bark on him or he's not got any shield walls he gets deleted. Running it on 16 and 17s this week anyone got some tips? Thank you x

earnest nymph
#

run double wall

#

rotate bark in with wall charges

#

be prepared to bomb him with heals when those three run out

serene fox
#

I think that is what we have been doing unless we just out of sync he still seems to get slapped

earnest nymph
#

you can do something like bark --> wall 1 --> wall 2 --> demo shout + last stand --> bark again

cinder storm
#

1- SW first
2- Healer external + demo
3- SW second
4- Last stand + heal pot

serene fox
#

Is there a trick to face tanking or best to leap away?

high drum
#

make sure he's not turning his back when hes running away

#

when the add spawns

#

or dies*

cinder storm
#

sometimes the boss casts tank frontal during inferno and its....quite pain inducing

serene fox
#

Oki thank guy. Not gonna lie we do have a meme going with his back turning sometimes ROFL might be that

earnest nymph
cinder storm
#

druid ext

earnest nymph
#

^^

#

we used a similar approach in a 19 TJS on third boss yesterday

cinder storm
#

I thought bark was 1m

earnest nymph
#

jade serpent strike fucks

serene fox
#

Man I was gonna ask that secondly hahaha

#

But I'll just take what you said with timing cds

earnest nymph
atomic inlet
rare kraken
#

same deal with the double wall but you can also run spell block to mitigate a portion of one of the jade serpent strikes

atomic inlet
#

didnt even sweat

true vortex
#

Tell him he can strafe away as well just don't straight up run

cinder storm
serene fox
#

Might make him go dwarf.

cinder storm
#

Nah no need

rare kraken
#

Overkill

cinder storm
#

Unless you are doing the highest keys 22s+ you dont need race change

rare kraken
#

Dwarf bleed helps but you don't need to race change to deal with that boss

cinder storm
#

You need to press your buttons better thats all

serene fox
#

Feels like a 20 sometimes

atomic inlet
#

btw thids is really cool idk why people dont use this

serene fox
#

Oki 😂. Cheers guys thanks for the tips

atomic inlet
cinder storm
#

for temple, that's plka

drifting needle
atomic inlet
#

i didnt let any cast goin to my party

high drum
atomic inlet
cinder storm
atomic inlet
drifting needle
earnest nymph
#

reflect doesn't work on JSS

atomic inlet
#

he can dwarf out 1 without a sweat

cinder storm
#

it mitigates dmg

#

20%

earnest nymph
#

oh true

toxic pewter
#

anyone else lagging badly and cant load into instances etc (NA)

earnest nymph
#

forgive me, is fire dam magic dam?

toxic pewter
#

yes

earnest nymph
#

or are those two separate things

#

kk

cinder storm
# serene fox Thanks

for temple 2nd boss make sure as a healer you keep superiority stacks, wild growth goes brrr

toxic pewter
#

all fire damage is magic but not all magic damage is fire

cinder storm
#

words to live by

serene fox
#

Man I love that 2nd boss, verdancy is insane btw

modern brook
drifting needle
toxic pewter
#

is that common knowledge among pug healers yet or what? I have yet to see any of my healers grab that buff

earnest nymph
toxic pewter
#

I guess should i be running it onto my healer?

#

like grabbing it off a dps and then bring to healer

modern brook
earnest nymph
#

(was a joke)

cinder storm
#

First time we did it I told my healer I wasnt losing the debuff thing and melees wouldnt stand with me, she stood with me, took it like a champ and was popping 90k casually

toxic pewter
#

Ok thats good I will do that myself next time

modern brook
#

no jokes in prot chat 😠

cinder storm
#

can't talk about brewmasters then

earnest nymph
#

or taking certain stat gems

drifting needle
strong forum
#

First of all it's 240 rage, 2nd of all 1.5k rage in 2.5min is pretty low

#

@jade radish

jade radish
#

sure. im still learning prot but like why would melee be twice as much dam on a sim?

#

no wf or external buffs in that sim either

strong forum
#

Idk chief it lines up with my dmg pretty much on point

modern brook
#

sounds like you were out of attack range for 50% of the fight

jade radish
#

uptime wouldnt change dam per hit though

#

its not dps. its damage

tulip harness
#

What phial do we use for m+?

strong forum
#

Did you sim 2.5min, only battle shout, no Lust, no WF totem, no food buffs, no monk buff

modern brook
#

i mean

strong forum
#

And without phial

modern brook
#

Gota sim and a log?

jade radish
#

sim was 5min only battle shout but i can run another

strong forum
strong forum
#

Obv your results will be different

round cliff
#

how do i handle the orbs on crystal dragon? even when i don't move until they're right on top of me, as soon as i start moving i slow down so much they catch up

jade radish
#

because fight length doesnt affect how hard a melee hits

strong forum
#

Again, are you fully emulating your environment

#

Properly

#

Without any buffs you don't have when you test the dummy

alpine night
strong forum
#

If you go in full raid buffed, and dont press shield charge on CD, yeah your melee dmg will be wildly different

round cliff
strong forum
#

Leap is your biggest friend on that boss

#

And potentially charging to fractures away from boss

alpine night
inland raft
#

vault worth opening in prot for chance at 421 shield over 418 crafted shield or as arms for chance at trinkets like whetstone?

round cliff
#

they just catch up to me after leaping i feel like

strong forum
#

I wouldn't try to bank on luck to get a whetstone from vault

modern brook
#

which is better will vary based on your equipment

#

but as a rule I would open in prot until you have a shield

#

then fury until you have a weapon

cinder storm
#

Anyone got a "change your key" reminder wa?

round cliff
modern brook
#

i mean

#

i can say that if you'd like

round cliff
#

ive been sitting on 2 sparks forever now

#

idk what to do with em

strong forum
#

Weapon+shield

round cliff
#

i have a lariat already

strong forum
#

Are the most important slots to get high ilvl on asap

modern brook
#

yeah weapon and shield

#

dont even need to be embelished

uncut notch
#

Yo is there a new SR sheet? I remember something about the one in pins being out of date?

strong forum
#

Pins

round cliff
#

should i use the 395 haste neck instead? then use crafted wep and shield

modern brook
#

crafted items arent limited

strong forum
#

You can craft non-embellished items

modern brook
#

embelishments are

round cliff
#

bro what

#

blowing my mind rn

cinder storm
#

food buffs doesnt counts tho

strong forum
#

You can wear 10 crafted items for what it's worth

round cliff
#

well a 1hander and a shield are still 2 sparks each no?

strong forum
#

It's just embellished items that are limited

#

No they've never been fruity

modern brook
#

Its literally cheaper to just eat another feast than pay for the food buff lasts embelsihment

cinder storm
#

it is

strong forum
#

They're 1 spark

round cliff
#

bruh.

#

ok

strong forum
#

Only 2handers are 2 sparks

round cliff
#

fury brain ig

#

is anyone here a blacksmith i can commission xd

full monolith
#

I can craft shields on EU-Blackhand if you happen to be there 😄

round cliff
#

US 😔

gritty glen
#

I can craft guaranteed Q4 shields on US-The Underbog

round cliff
#

i thought crafting was cross server

#

huh

gritty glen
#

I think has to be a connected realm

round cliff
#

ah

#

im on a52

mighty valley
#

if they're in your trade chat, you can make an order for them

strong forum
#

Works Cross-faction too

#

But has to be connected Realm

round cliff
#

is a52 even connected to any realms

gritty glen
#

Try to send a personal order to Lilnachox-The Underbog. If it let's you then I'll craft it for you.

round cliff
#

no dice

jade radish
# strong forum If you go in full raid buffed, and dont press shield charge on CD, yeah your mel...

As far as im aware, nothing buffs auto attack damage in our talent tree, just attack speed. Heres a 2min sim showing an average melee of 8833 damage. https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/5exiRPj7nhZPvorgniaWcU I just sat on a dummy, with no buffs other than battle shout, and hit the dummy for 2 minutes, average 4077 dam, dummy test was using avatar/demo/blood fury/etc. full dam cds same as sim would

#

battering ram does actually affect dam but im not playing that in either

high drum
#

u should take battering ram its powerful

jade radish
#

kinda not the point here

#

but sure

strong forum
#

If you're not using any buttons

modern brook
high drum
#

is sim merging devestator into melee?

modern brook
#

yes

jade radish
#

Devestator averaging 2.8k in my dummy test.

modern brook
jade radish
#

so much closer but still not quite there

jade radish
#

8.8k vs 6.8k

strong forum
#

4807 average hit

#

9610 average crit

#

5.8k overall average of melee hit

weary python
#

Switching faction later today to horde for the first time in a very long time. For us, the meta pick is tauren for this raid tier, right?

strong forum
#

Tauren is always meta for horde raid

#

Cuz stamina and 2% crit dmg

#

But racials are insanely irrelevant

#

Especially for raid

#

That's like a 0.01% optimisation

jade radish
# strong forum

Where is this from? my details is showing 4077 average (3300 hit, 6800 crit)

strong forum
#

This is literally from your sim

wanton shale
#

the Fury guys were just talking about crafted revive bracers - engi socket but don't need to be engi to use. Since prot is often the last to die in a M+, these bracers would be pretty good for us too?

strong forum
#

The detailed HTML breakdown

strong forum
wanton shale
#

ahh that's pretty rough 50/50 play

strong forum
#

People have failed it as often ad 4/4

rare kraken
strong forum
#

Back to back

#

as engi

rare kraken
#

I wonder what the fail rate goes down to after the advancements

strong forum
#

With maxed out chance on res

jade radish
#

so thats without devastator then, still higher than what im seeing. Im lost

rare kraken
strong forum
#

m8

#

This is with perfect play

modern brook
strong forum
#

Melee average goes up with demo and avatar uptime

modern brook
#

sophic

strong forum
#

If you only afk auto attack

jade radish
#

20% more?

strong forum
#

Yes.

#

You have 60% uptime on avatar

weary python
#

I thought war stomp was a very nice pickup for raszageth

strong forum
#

Then 15% uptime on Demo shout

#

Then get some crits, some procs

#

And boom

modern brook
strong forum
#

^

modern brook
#

+-8k dps over 22k iterations

somber shell
#

In TJS, can you dodge the serpent kick by running out of the circle?

strong forum
#

1 dummy test can't compete with 22000

modern brook
#

one 2 minute dummy hit will not mirror it perfectly

sick sentinel
#

If I have enough rage is there any downside to using 2 charges of shield block at the same time?

somber shell
strong forum
#

Yes

somber shell
#

ok

modern brook
#

the huge disaprity you're seeing @jade radish is because devestator is baked into melee hits in the damage breakdown on the sumamry page

somber shell
#

Does the fist have a magic omponent? eg does reflect help mitigate?

modern brook
#

the rest is just bad rng

strong forum
jade radish
#

thanks for the help here yall. makes more sense

rare kraken
#

reflect will reduce by 20%, spell block will outright block the damage

strong forum
#

You'll still end up with the dot

rare kraken
#

yeah but the initial hit is reduced

strong forum
#

Which your healer has to outheal

rare kraken
#

You can't stop the dot

#

Does ignore pain contribute to reducing the heal cap or does it not count because it's a shield

strong forum
#

It helps with the dot, not with the absorb

rare kraken
#

gotcha

modern brook
strong forum
#

Indom will, but IP wont

rare kraken
#

I spam IP during it anyway to reduce the dot but was always curious if it actually contributed to reducing the healing absorb or not

modern brook
#

through indom yeah, probably not notably compared to the work your healers doing

rare kraken
#

definitely not compared to my healer haha

#

he clocked a new dungeon healing record on temple the other day

#

it was like 82k on second boss

strong forum
#

The higher you go the more absurd the hps requirement becomes

rare kraken
#

yeah the damage taken on that fight seems obscene

strong forum
#

Highest I've seen was 240k hps on that boss

rare kraken
#

holy shit

#

Was that from a resto druid?

modern brook
#

BDK 😎 <-- bad joke <-- nevermind bdk is that dumb

strong forum
#

And 2mil hps if you include overhealing

#

Yeah the largest deathstrike I've seen on that boss was 2.5mil with 1 single cast

rare kraken
#

holy shit wtf

#

I didn't realise the damage taken for bdk was that high on that boss

strong forum
#

It's because of the debuff

mighty valley
#

i missed this but can confirm that the bres wrists are pretty awful, i assumed they'd be like last seasons'

strong forum
#

Its a 25% healing increase that stacks every 5 seconds

drifting needle
#

Yeh even in my 21 a resto druid finished at 190k hps. Spicy

rare kraken
#

Garbage compared to SL and BFA

mighty valley
#

i mean, it's like... ok to have an absolute last resort now that i have it, but if i'd known i'd never have crafted them

rare kraken
#

yeah I didn't pay attention to what the buff/debuff actually did

strong forum
#

Very few people do

#

Just slap that debuff on your healer

modern brook
#

IDK how i get it tbh

rare kraken
#

I mean you don't really play around it though

strong forum
#

And the boss is free

strong forum
lavish oracle
#

At a certain key level, if your healer doesn't have the buff you just evaporate

strong forum
#

You pass it by touching

rare kraken
#

Imma go read what the boss actually does

drifting needle
#

Even worse when someone snipes the buff off him and he has - healing 😂

strong forum
#

The dmg part of it doesn't stack

#

Only the healing does

#

So you just dump it on healer if you want the boss killed

rare kraken
#

ahh

#

I knew it did increased damage but not increased healing

#

wowhead doesn't say the buff stacks either

weary python
#

@strong forum I thought war stomp was sought after for raszageth. Not needed but it is a good pickup

urban portal
#

idk man

#

HOF guils are forcing their guys to reroll

rancid wolf
#

hey, 385 Granyth's Enduring Scale or 389 Rumbling Ruby to pair with 402 Horn of Valor?

urban portal
#

well race change to raz

#

that or belf

rancid wolf
modern brook
#

love my rumbler tbh

#

thing omega owns

heady jetty
mighty crest
drifting needle
heady jetty
#

Right so stack with him xD

modern brook
heady jetty
#

sounds simple

drifting needle
#

But no jokes just run over him/her

rare kraken
quiet monolith
#

can i add or replace an embellishment with a recraft?

mighty crest
#

awesome thanks.

quiet monolith
#

going to craft a shield but lariat counts as embell right?

blazing condor
#

touch the boss?

quiet monolith
#

and i want the slot open for a frostfire belt

blazing condor
#

or someone gets it and keeps

#

until touched

drifting needle
#

Lariat of course slightly different but a shield/wep for example can add/drop

quiet monolith
#

ok so

#

if i only have 1 embell right now

#

it doesn't hurt to just throw an embell on the shield

#

i can always remove later without crashing ilvl

drifting needle
#

Indeed

#

Unless it’s the specifically embellished shield? What’s it called the versa one

mighty valley
#

yeah don't make shield of the hearth

round cliff
#

is it better to have an embellishment on shield or embellishment on wep to go with my lariat?

mighty valley
#

the embellishments are all so close it doesn't really matter

#

in that case just sim it i guess

high drum
#

larry is the only one that is significantly better than the others

round cliff
#

if it's so close ill just do shield cuz im crafting it rn

neat gyro
#

what are people crafting with the 3rd and 4th spark. I have 418 lariat and 418 frostfire, We clear mythic Earnog/Council every week so I dont feel like shield/weapon get much value, as I can valor upgrade my strike twice. Do I just make a 418 ring to replace my 389 shield ring from that week 1 rep?

mighty valley
#

yeah, just plug low ilvl slots

high drum
#

ring is nice because it always has socket

mighty valley
#

although the damage ring from cobalt is still pretty great

neat gyro
#

how good is the ring anyway? I am currently using it over a 402 mastery crit ring with a socket, and have earnogs ring in my other slot

#

the shield ring*

sick sentinel
#

How do y’all deal with tanking the last boss of Azure vaults? In a +9 last night I wiped on it twice last night and killed the key before we finally got it, my strat was just to stay still and tank the boss unless I absolutely had to move, but it felt shaky at best, and there were times that I felt I couldn’t get away from the orbs at all. It felt like we had no shot without lust. Also a couple times I basically heroic leaped across the boss to save myself from balls of fury

mighty valley
#

uncontrollable shields are kinda whatever imo

weak snow
#

i finally swapped off my colbolt assembly ring (scholar's loop i think?) for a 408 Seal of Diurna

fast knot
#

Not having thundering in AV is going to hurt a lot on that boss

livid aurora
fast knot
#

Since you heal so often balls are going to gravitate your way

livid aurora
cinder storm
#

AV won't be next season

mighty valley
#

they said +9

#

so no thundering

sick sentinel
livid aurora
#

We'll have bracken and infusion to worry about next season

mighty valley
#

think they meant spell reflect

fast knot
#

You just have to be more proactive on movement and having healer dispel in that case when you need to move

sick sentinel
#

Holy shit you can reflect the dragon strike?

livid aurora
#

That one

mighty valley
#

yep - check the spell reflect list in pins, commit to heart

livid aurora
sick sentinel
livid aurora
#

Do note that you can't reflect each one as the timer doesn't allow it

sick sentinel
#

+9 is also the highest key I’ve done so far so that might have something to do with it

round cliff
mighty valley
#

it's just a fixed embellishment

fast knot
#

Comes down to managing leap/intervene and having healer dispel you if you're in a bad spot and need to move then

mighty valley
#

so you can't remove it later like you can with armor spikes on molten defender

round cliff
#

gotcha

#

ill do armor spikes defender then

#

and i do haste/vers right

mighty valley
#

i'm a haste/crit enjoyer but do what you feel

round cliff
#

i feel what others tell me to do

#

i dont think i need the vers, ur right

sick sentinel
weak snow
#

You can always ask for a dispel from your healer if possible

sick sentinel
#

Healer was pretty on point with dispels which is why I felt like such a failure wiping

rain topaz
#

Is there a trick to vicious peck(bird on Algethar academy)? Currently at 394-395 ilvl and i feel like its hurting unreasonably much, can you backstep it maybe?

#

14-15m+

granite nest
#

Communicate with your healer when you have a DR for it, or when you'll need an external

wide charm
#

but you can kite him endlessly and he won't do his TB

#

but will still scream

#

but your dps will hate you and someone will likely die in the process

rain topaz
#

Ohh ok, ill have to weigh if its possible to outlive based on the key im playing, maybe be alittle mean and kite it then worst case scenario 😄

#

Thanks!

sleek current
#

Raid is asking me to pick up disrupting shout for Dathea, any got any ideas what I can drop for it?

slim dove
#

Thunderlord

wide charm
#

^

sleek current
#

Cheers

slim dove
#

Drop it anyways for battering ram

#

And swap show of force for sudden death (imo)

wanton shale
#

crit is our biggest +dmg stat and has a little defensive value cuz it gives parry right?

sterile bough
#

parry is good stat

strong forum
#

I play this on dathea

sterile bough
#

its just it doesnt work against most mechanics

strong forum
wanton shale
#

i'm trying to go haste/crit too just cuz it seems more fun, will see when it gets me in too much trouble

sleek current
strong forum
#

With this you get all the cc you need and close to Max St dmg output

strong forum
#

Which means more SS, which means more rage gen and thus more everything

urban portal
#

the conversion from crit to parry is quite good

#

vs melees parry is about as twice as good as vers

wanton shale
#

nice another perk through wild strikes

urban portal
#

wild strike doesnt work

#

i dont think

strong forum
#

?

urban portal
#

crit to parry is crit rating

#

according to tanknotes

strong forum
#

What does that have to do with parry

#

Huh

urban portal
#

oh i thought it was something else

#

i keep getting all the "strikes" mixed up

strong forum
#

No, it's just higher uptime on it

urban portal
#

yeah makes sense