#protection
1 messages ยท Page 269 of 1
when we get catalysts to create tier pieces, do we keep sockets/tertiary stats?
yes we did in slands
assuming that it works how the catalyst in SL did, yes
sweet!
is 4p bonus huge?
friend is telling me ima be sad if i get the normal shoulders form vault and not the 418 legs and if i drop the shoulders in raid its a rip
It's effectively 5% leech
im like buttt 4p ill have tho
so off you go dumping all rage into revenge then ip runs out of time
ne1 got a WA to track vanguard determination buff?
so..would you grab the 418 legs and just wait for shoulders/chest?
You can make one very easily with a template, but there's no reason to track it; it doesn't change your gameplay.
or just make 4p happen now
You obvs want to take the ilvl above it. so just go for it.
i play all 3 specs, i took tier
i can't find the spell id and the name is completing
well my current shoulders are 372
but having huge ilvl legs that you can upgrade to tier in a few weeks is also huge
the legs are tier already
if shoulders are an up, take them imo
How odd. When I do a full sim of bis gear etc, strand of the stars ends up better than scorched-bone.
does spell block work on raz?
do we use howling runes or primal wht/weightstone on weapons?
yes @ maxer
on everythin?
pmed you
Why would you use it on Rasz ๐ค
Well, I am here again to ask what to do with my wall hole
drywall
what ilevel is your shield
hmm, idk. I would probably go for the trinket over the ring since that's the shield ring iirc?
it is the shield ring
i have the trinker
sorry should have said
same ilvl got in raid this week
it got nerfed?
Ruby 15 kinda nightmarish or not too bad
huge
Burst Forth now occurs 14 seconds after Germinate (was 6 seconds).
did it 15 min ago, 54 minutes, 68 deaths.
I dunno I actually find rlp pretty easy
basically you have an 8 second window after second germinate
Just gotta stop stuff
to kill/dps lashers on ground before burst forth
pretty huge ye
Bah - that's a bad change - it wasn't hard anyway
finished that tree today
In a competent group? im sure its far easier. But in a random pug without voice come and drooling idiots? its very very punishing
Be sure you use all the stops you can it helps a lot
I died twice to frigid shard but outside of that, only that dot on the 2nd boss ticking for 100k dmg is hard for me to tank. Rest is just healer not being able to heal or dps not using utility.
Very lucky on vault drops. 3 vault weeks yielded 3 tier pieces, all different slots. Got shoulders from raid this past week also.
Hardest thing in RLP is the corridor full of adds before the first boss and getting DPS to not Butt-Pull the ones on the left
Yah second boss be ready to have spell reflect/shield wall for that hard hitting melee she does
Or any defensive really
Spell block prob helps too
i tried playing with spell block ye but I dunno, in the heat of the moment? doesnt feel that valueable or strong
How ARE people dealing with that dot on 2nd boss RLP?
dwarf.
that absolutely shreds me every time
Wall, external, wall, dwarf, LS and demo shout for IP spam
yeah, let me reroll alliance quick
left 2 are equiped, right is vault option
dying to it xD
bring evoker then.
Had one death recap, it was ticking 100k every second
Only class that external cleanse bleed.
True
I had an evoker healer. Guess he wasnt that good xD
Will tell my groups resto druid to reroll ๐
devoker can do it also.
whats the cd on it though?
1 minute iirc.
my biggest issue this week was missing the previous week, so I had zero runs and zero score, having to run with 1.5k io ppl
the nerfs are great
i didn't feel any were really required.
but 95% of population can't handle holding CDs for tree so
am i suppose to be going fast enough so that i +3 mythic dungeons for the timer? im currently at +5, around 376 ilvl. i do prob 2 packs at max per pull
nah, i finally gave up and joined a guild this week. cba playing with randoms so guess i'll gotta schedlue a day for raiding so I can play m+ xD
do a lot of damage
if your low ilvl u cant really go huge
the mobs just have fuck all hp tho
+3ing doesnt really matter that much
Send help, I can either get third peace of teir OR Seal of Diurna's at 408 from my vault.
so all good as long as i beat the timer yeh?
yup
dont concern yourself with 3 chesting shit in pugs
the only dungeons i really 3 chest at this stage are shadowmoon and the occasional court.
ok thanks
Anyone know if you can equip 3 peices with embellishments and wether it grays out one of them or if it doesnt let you wear it at all?
Hey, i was wondering how do you survive the 3rd boss of ToJS on high keys on her 2nd phase, everytime i go through all my cds for Jade Serpent Kick, and when i have none left i get my ass blasted. Is there any talent that could help with that?
doesn't let you equip it
is going thorns on our shield worth it?
So, is there a reason I shouldn't just macro shield block? Seems like with the basic spec I'm using, it's 100% uptime
its like 5k damage randomly, doesnt seem that amazing tbh
This might be the one case where Iโd tell someone to not go tierโฆ.
Utilize impending victory, last stand, health pots, and healthstones to help get rid of the healing absorb.
You can IV every second
after how many are u left without defensives
Prolly around 4 - 5
A full stack ignore pain makes it hurt less but cycling IV > defensive is enough to get you through usually
Whats the best trinkets for M+ from heroic raid?
I try to save Demoralizing shout for her 2nd phase
just pray for healer harder
Well actually idk what โhigh keysโ means. I havenโt done a tyrannical TJS above 16. But the 19s fort were okay
And I sometimes clutch it, but it is really hard to survive
Whispering incarnate icon and then it depends
Is totem good?
Kkay, thanks for the tips! Gonna try it on my next runs tyvm
very good
where to look for mythic raid grp? and what ilvl to start
They find you
Any reason why you would want a DH tank for CoS? Seen it twice this week in the title "pref DH tank".
DH in general
Because people are toos tupid to do the find the spy game at the end
lol
too stupid*
Can spectral sight skip the minigame
I was gonna try pug eranog weekly mythic just for ring but I bought heroic one for 175k
ahh, okok
You can't skip it anyway. You still have to get all 5 clues, which at that point it's easy anyway.
Toos tupid
It also can slightly save time if people can mash the clues fast enouigh
yeah but you have to look is what you skip
is there any visual tell to the mob? I know how the minigame works but never really can see any diff in the mobs even after 5/5 clues
And especially if you're not used to quickly cutting the limits down (like me), it can be convenient
You have to use the clues
They are all different ๐
The clues tell you what they're wearing or not wearing, so
there's a WA that draws the front/back 3d model of ur target so you can see easier for lazy ppl who don't want to get up close to look lol
5% magic dmg
Whether they have potions on belt or not, gloves or not, etc
Gender, light/dark vest, short/long sleeves, cloak/no cloak, special item (potions, book), gloves/no gloves
they think its gonna make a diff
Also I guess orb and tome
while bringing all melee xD
well then they dont have eyes to look for the spy themselves
ive played with dh entire season so ive just signed off on ever having to do minigame
i just kinda hate it existing in a timed setting
it feels bad
It's neat to have non-combat stuff in M+ dungeons
but it just feels bad to me, which matters a lot more
I got that BIS ring from nokhud, Iโm good to pump valor into right?
i'm tank, i have to focus on doing the tank stuff, not some puny minigame, so I also just pretend its not my job ๐
Like how Nokhud feels like ass because of just sitting there clearing mobs in a stationary area like 75% of the time for count purposes
Only dungeons i really enjoy atm is, halls, court and academy.
Only one I just cant stand is ruby, not so much for the tuning but it just sucks, go in a circle, kill the exact same pack and repeat. Noty
the rest is sorta, just there i guess xD
The clues can actually be wrong, believe it or not. I had one run where the clue was "no gloves" and we eventually found the imposter wearing gloves
I fucking detest Nokhud. It's got the Halls of Atonement disease where it looks like an open-plan free-form dungeon, but it's actually incredibly linear and boring.
Not gonna lie, how much I like a given dungeon depends entirely on the pugs the fates have gifted me
Do they have trouble not standing in the brown germinate swirls on academy tree boss? Academy sucks
do they know they have wasd keys? Academy's fun
Mine is entirly based on what I find hard or annoying to tank.
SOme just feel like they're way too big and long.. like AV
Can anyone recommend a good video guide for prot warrior?
Anyone know if they patched nokhud end boss skip
did one today and it still works
for tree boss it helps telling pugs to move clockwise when stacked
how often does frostfire belt proc
is kurog trinket bis? or good?
i got the two rare rings from the raid, wondering if i should create a frostfire belt to proc the proc
Can you survive raz pushback without leap up?
kurog trinket is all-totem.
yes
i also have a 398 signet of melandrus
is a socket item better than a leech roll for tanking
should i do lfr to learn tanking in raids?
lfr is a crapshoot so i wouldnt try to learn much there imo
OMG
WHAT A HERO MOMENT
xD
solo'd the last boss in cos for 1.6 million
with 27 seconds left on timer
๐
i had a bdk solo like 5mil damage cuz everyone died lmao
on cos
and timer was 5sec off
๐ฆ
i stepped on a wrong rune on odin and we missed the timer by 1.7 seconds, mvp
I really needed that. What a high... Felt so shit all week and then, boom, savior of the run
as a dpser those bdk's stress me out cuz they go to 1% hp then regen to 100% instantly and im leaping like a maniac cuz i dont want aggro
Have anyone tested this? proc rate/values is it worth?
Just got it and currently I'm using Primal Ritual Shell (turtle buff) and Decoration of Flame (Eranog)
People with barking dogs that sleep trough their barking shouldnt be allowed to have dogs...
btw, about close calls...
our HoV run today: https://raider.io/mythic-plus-runs/season-df-1/7812426-18-halls-of-valor
๐
i might run my own keys as a prot so i wouldnt feel bad about other ppl key
its pretty meh, does like 0.6-1% of my dmg in keys, strictly dps speaking
whilst learning
what you talking about? Plenty of time left ๐
yeah ;D
im surpised it even counts in milliseconds tbh, nice rounding up ๐
i think my bossmods said it was 0.4 seconds, but rio is saying 0.525
ty for feedback
also just got this one, looks nice in theory
how much % blocked hits yall have in m+ keys?
they should make it so charge doesn't trigger traps and shit, feels so bad when you just clip smt on the side and still get caught
havent checked, but considering shield block uptime is pretty close to 100%, id say all attacks are blocked unless you turn your back against the mobs
how are you reaching anything near then 90% shield block uptime. I mean like there is time between pulls ๐
what do you mean?
I mean, I dont cast shield block when I am not pulling anything
the walks from 1 group or boss to another
ah damn, got it
Is there a massive enough difference between the crafted mace and the crafted sword that I should wait for the sword?
you also have talent that makes shield block duration longer on top of extending it.
i was somehow thinking the uptime is calculated on actual time in key
nah, the uptime is based on your melee hits taken and what % of those are blocked
as far as i know, there is no difference at all
I.. didn't think so? But everything has been saying "Craft the swooooooooooord" - and I went maces.
damn, I thought like if you reach 90% uptime on shieldblock this means that you have shieldblock up in the fights for 90%.
easy thing to confuse tbh
and not that this is based on melee hits taken and % block
yes, that's what it means
huh
no it doesn't. 100% uptime means you have 100% uptime on all the melee hits taken that you can block. Not if you have shield block active for 90% of a 30 min dungeon?
Nah i meant 90% of infight time
not actual the whole time in the dungeon
yes and unless warrior calculates it differently from say paladin, you count the blocked hits, which should be 100% or close to it
necroing but...how did your tests go?
like, if you go into warcraftlogs and look at auras and blocked hits
Question for raid single target which would be bigger damage Rumbling Ruby or Hoof or All totem?
no, buff uptimes are buff uptimes, when talking about shield block uptime, it means that how much of a percentage of the combat time your shield block buff is active, nothing else
thats what matters, not the duration in seconds
in the azure vault on the last boss should i try to help kill the crystals or just focus kiting the orbs?
blocks outside of shield block are just rng mitigation and have nothing to do with shield block uptime
it was a +4
why would you count the active time rather than the % of blocked hits?
so is the % of blocked hits
maybe im just tired but I dont get this. Can you explain like im stupid?
active time is a proxy for blocked hits
maybe because the % of blocked hits is shown in Melee dmg taken?
but you can just look at the % of blocked hits, you don't need a proxy
which one ?
It's not as important right now when you can have basically 100% up time of block anyways
more important when talents don't allow that, and you have to be more judicious about when you use block
so it would make more sense that 90% uptime on shieldblock is 90% shieldblock uptime infight rather then actual % of blocked hits.
yeah true
'blocked hits is much better
who cares if your uptime is high if you arent blocking anything
like if the boss is doing some effect that prevents them from meleeing
you can have 99% uptime and they all auto you during that 1%
yeah, right
having uptime during that time period isn't useful
got it, thanks guys for the explanation ๐
by using your rage and shield slam actively, you can achieve higher % of shield block uptime - effectively 100% at like 20+% haste
But why does it matter?
If a pwar was only able to maintain 80% uptime of the SB buff, then blocked hits becomes a much more differentiating number
for instance
it matters that if you are NOT playing properly, you are not reaching 100% uptime
when you're able to approximate 100% uptime, the two numbers are going to be similar
shield block uptime has no impact on your play
Question for raid single target which would be bigger damage Rumbling Ruby or Hoof or All totem
What an absolute joke of a shitgame... PLZ STOP GIVING ME RLP CONSTANTLY ๐ฆ
sim
yes, dog shit at least on 398 as fury
annoying to use, low damage
I wish you could downgrade a key without doing another key, even if it was like a -3 or something lol
downgrade/swap
any idea what to take ?
100% i would accept a +2 key loss for doing that. Lets write a peitition
Dang thatโs a solid vault wish I got a vault like that
head make me 4/5 btw
gz lol
if you dont take windscar, we cant be friends, just saying
My vault basically made me take 421 kickball trinket what a mistake that was
my 398 kickball was doing like 2% of my damage as fury, popping it on cd
annoying and outright bad
Itโs just awful
I'd take windscar or ring
Half the time I canโt even kick the damn balls
yeah sometimes they just dont even trigger
isnt it just 1 week left until we can make tier anyhow?
lol 421 2h, 421 bis 1h and super uber 411 trinket from raid ๐
Does anyone else have this weird bug where you charcater just starts spinning like crazy and it wont stop until you /reload and it still just keeps spinning but after /reload you can move again and it stop
its the most annoying, gamebreaking bug i've encounter in 15 years... Comes like once per hour
eu reset 5 min ago
prot war - not raiding much (pugging) already got 2p gloves / chest not sure on this week pick ๐ค any help appreciated
Oh I thought the vault didnt open for another 4 hours
likely 418 shoulders but we dont know your character.
does protection warrior deal "fire damage"? I received the ring in the loot table from vault that has a spell that deal extra fire dmg if i deal dmg.
not natively
the frostfire belt from sparks will produce it
or I think the turtle trinket
they changed it recently to be 5 and 6 am again (depends on winter/summertime)
Which is ironic because the reason they changed it from 3am back in the day was to prevent degen shit like setting alarm and waking up early for it... Had at least 3-4 ppl outside vault saying they did that
Im pretty sure my best option is gunna be to take the tokens out of my vault
the ring? isnt that very strong with the belt?
no idea, just what ive read here.
I had the easiest vault choice ever.. I had 411 tier and rest was garbage
Its the trinket that does fire dmg
and give s you a shield
Lads 408 item Set-piece or 415 Piece
what are you spending your sparks on? I have the lariat and the wristguards so far,. my weapon is 389
shield is 402
Is grieftorch good for prot?
in your opinion which tank is a good alt to compliment a prot warrior?
Frostfire belt is good if you get one of the fire rings
I spent mine on shield, lariat and was thinking weapon this week
actually cant run the belt, i have a lariat and wrists
but everyone keeps saying wrists or belt
Honestly if your not worried about an embelishment then it doesnt really matter what you spend it on
and not sure what that means
Its cause they are talking about the embellishments
wait what, you cant put them on all crafted gear or only some slots have specific embels?
you can only have 2 at a time
You can only have 2 embelishments. Some are socketable on any crafted gear some are specifically to that gear
For instance the frostfire belt has an embellishment which is only on the frostfire belt
is it common to solo tank diurna and have the other tank go adds?
was funny/spicy on heroic diurna solo w/ doing the staff
feel like I may swap some talents for it though
Decoration of Flame
in time walking
is like instant 60k damage
wtf
o_O
I hit it as per usual and bam
boss dead...
Pull entire mobs
all dead
it does like 40% on bosses and insta kill mobs, better do your 5 before the fix
[Shackles of Titanic Failure] 411 itlvl or 2 set tire set ?
Can someone for the love of god tell me Iโm doing something tragically wrong on the third boss in temple of jade serpent?
That jade serpent strike on an 18 this week is toxic
I canโt reflect it. Impending victory doesnโt heal as much and the other coolies are meh lol
I donโt know what else to do cause itโs a 100k healing absorb
On top of 290k damage
if u insist
Depends on how lucky you feel with set. I go set immediately cause over the last 15 years Iโve never gotten any worthwhile raid drops. If you have similar luck and are willing to wait until catalyst opens, get the other piece

Bruh you shoulda seen mine
oh , let me send you my main loot , sec
worse ?
i literally logged off after seeing these xD
I can imagine a BDK doing it, 2 death strikes will go through the shield and the damage
Doesn't help prot tho
it helps fury tho
Yeah
i got 421 set gloves from vault, 4pc now !
why is there a 2h loot , you looted on Arms or smth
gz ma man, i'm not even 1p
should feels good
to sign up in keys - 4p pumper
ty, the bonus is quite crap though
its effectively just 5% extra to brutal vitality :/
5 % is 5%
How good is the 4er set Boni?
I didn't want wep or shield and figured arms limited my options
xD you did a little trolling there
ive had my loot spec as arms for the whole season, ive crafted my 1h and shield
If I was on prot or fury my potential wasted spots are much higher tho
Yeah exactly
I have 418 and 415 wep and shield
Yeah exactly
can some nice guy do me a favor and take a sim for me, can't do it the website is kinda filter for my country 
is there any point todo weekly stuff if you're 392 or above in every slot?
VPN ๐
๐ I think take the legs โฆ now I have the 4 set Boni ๐
you have the gloves already?
Yes but on 405 but I can it take higher
yeah the legs are good then!
๐๐ผ
https://i.imgur.com/JeiM9jm.png how good is the eranog-ring for prot war? triggering it with frostfire belt, probably the most dmg i can get with an ring correct?
It's super good.
I think it's better than my verse haste ring
Which is 411
So I guess I just use this.
guys should i talk Hunger of the pack instead of shoulder ? i got already shoulder in 411, i got 402[Rumbling Ruby] and 398 [Burgeoning Seed]๐
Hey guys, what are ur thoughts about our second tier bonus? Does it really matter since it's only 5%? Thanks in advance
How big is our 2 set? Bare in mind this is my alt so I could either take 2 set or replace my 343 something belt with a 395 socketed belt
yeah take trink and replace seed
that trinket saved my life few times but thats what i tought too : s
seed is good tho
398 grieftorch def better then 389 rumbing ruby right?
It's like 3-4% overall damage so that's pretty significant compared to a single ilevel upgrade. You can sim though
yeah
I crafted a belt on my rogue because I was stuck with a 343
no shame in it lol
crafted shield cuz cba for azure vaults
id like to do a belt but i have the bracers and lariat
I'm pretty sure there's a non-embellished belt, no?
well im probably going to do lariat.. later tho maybe when the next one arrives
id probably be better off with a weapon, since that is 389
Any alchemy wanna know a lil goldhack I found out?
I have a friend who is an alc. I'll take any gold hacks I can find lol
Or might already be known, but i found it myself.
Hi is the all-totem trinket is good? I got that in vault in hc ilvl or should I pick a 415 setgloves?(I have setgloves from normal)
aren't set pieces both 389 in hc and normal?
All-totem is very good
yes by miles
torch is absurd.
Is there an updated Google Doc for Blockable/Reflectable Spells? The one in guides links to SL
4 piece and all-totem today, it was a good Tuesday
It's in the pins
is strike twice bis at same item level as a haste versa one?
Yeah
Rotate defensives, use last stand, impending victory, health pots/stones to help remove the healing absorb
Huh; I thought Spellbane was BiS
yeah pretty scary
FWIW the initial hit is spell blockable but usually it's the DoT that's the scary part anyway
I usually go wall first; spell block + demo on second; LS health pot stone (making sure I have impending) on third and the 4th is healer cds + pray
You can use impending on every 2nd one I believe
Ok copy. Ty. After a couple of wipes I zoned out and switched to spell block
That didnโt do much either
Yeah it's nasty
Nerf incoming Iโm sure.
Yeah spell block only affects the first part of it which is not really that scary
Itโs weird to be at 100% health in all dungeons and then running into this boss. LOL. Itโs a true test of grit
Yeah, and pretty much every tank has that same problem with it
Dude today I learned the balls on raging tempest don't give you increased damage taken
I can't imagine being like a vdh or brewmaster who can't do a big heal on demand
I dunno why I had this idea that they did give you + damage taken and it was scary
XD
They do damage to you when you collect them but no debuff XD
Just free dam/healing 
Haha true
I swear they used to give you damage taken on beta; or maybe I'm just high
Pally is probably ok
Can't paladins spellward it?
Lay, bop taunt etc
Will say though, nerf to tree boss in algethar is fantastic
Spellward yeah, lay hands, WoG ofc
Now itโs just the shit bird thatโs annoying
It is INSANE
I swear I have no idea what let fly is lol
I did a +16 with the worst group Iโve done that dungeon with and it was perf
Thank god for it
Bird boss still a nuisance
Canโt see tornados and canโt get pugs to not stack scream when they need to clear thundering ๐
Will say though itโs nice to be able to solo bosses as a prot warrior from 30% down. LOL
Shadowlands if a boss looked at us we died
I solod last boss from 15% to 0
Cause my group made about 30 orb pulls
If I got a dollar for every time I solod court of stars last boss
Lol
Back to the good ole days of thunderlord's vigor 
Bra you canโt ask that
LOL
Yeh Iโm D.I.D
Thatโs why I followed up quickly
I'm troll, because I was fury before
Ah dope
Also white af
Armour?
Agree
I got mythic council 1H tonight - was originally planning on crafting 418 phys damager embellish wep. I probably won't replace all tier unless i get smth from vault as there are no one handers from raid higher than 415. IS this still worth? Or should I craft bre bracers instead to go w/ lariat?
Lariat is king
any think this effect is pretty good?
or at least better than some of the other listed trinkets in icy veins article
I did it last week to get 4pc, but was also worried if worth
help me
Take what you need?
How is that hard? Gloves if you donโt have them.
i need both
Then gloves lol. Itโs a higher ilvl
Also is that eu?
If you're doing Timewalking please do it now as scaling is absolute bonkers easy and use Decoration of Flame one-shots bosses with 20k DPS
Before they fix
Or when is the vault reset for eu :(
Credit goes to Danat on some server who noticed the dam my trinket is doing ๐คญ
Already was 2 hours ago @limpid anchor
The next reset is next Wednesday, todays is already done
maghar orc
did i miss the conversation xd
most prob the question "what is the best race" will pop up shortly..
its maghar orc fr
20% mount speed more noticable than any 0.05% dps increase
also ur a cool orc
opened vault as arms. 415 Horn of valor or 411 grieftorch. Probably a just sim it situation right?
all situations are a sim it situation
Also got a 408 stormeaters boon with leech
The fact that SBG is in timewalking amuses me
Anyone here on Kazzak (A) that can craft Primal Molten Defender R5?
TORCH. 
we dont go for 4p set as prot right?
you don't need to rush like crazy for it but it's defensively decent
k
I'm getting fucking wrecked by the second boss of rlp dot and the jade kick dot from third boss in this, any recommendations, on the 18+ range this week
wait, i was so scrolled up
I just held my impending victories for the jade kicks
Its pretty shit. The stacks reset upon entering combat with a boss. Somewhere between 1-2 procs per minute.
Yeah all my evidence is pug based so far and can't tell if it's me doing it wrong or them
Anyone else got an answer on this ๐ I got it in vault also haha
also bring health pots
So if you hold it for max stacks? and its 2ppm? Thats 2.5 min to stack it to max. And that lasts for 12s. And stacks reset when entering combat
If its only 1 ppm? geez
RLP is a bleed.
Rotate defensives, let your healer know it wrecks.
Jade, let your DPS'ers hold CD's for the second phase.
Plan CD's, use Health potions / IV / LS to help your healer out with the healing absorb.
Yep that's where I'm using them , and lock rocks. I could probably track the iv use better so I'll try that
read above you and below you. Its shit
does mitigation reduce the absorb? I can never tell
No, but it reduces the initial smack.
Ah, okay, good to know
Ty mwahi good notes, just sucks cause I was timing a couple 20s and 19s all over the place last week. Tyrannical ok some of these bosses is just such a kick in the pants
How good is dungeon slice sims for prot? It sims significantly higher with 408 stormeaters boon over 415 hor of valor or 411 grieftorch. But 10 sec immobilize is meh
Appreciated ๐ guess i am taking ilvl upgrade on bis wrists since waist is worse stats than yesterday 405 craft ๐
I play ultra defensive talents in temple, tbh, everything in there scares me
Jeah, those bosses are horrid. Really have to rely on your healer.
well everything between the 2nd boss and the pack before the last boss
Yeah I'm running fairly defensively but guess I should double check my talents
Lol yeah some fun trash pulls I'm finding this week
So I got super lucky today
What would you guys use between 402 whetstone, 402 totem, 398 grieftorch?
not very good, you want patchwerk on several durations + several different mob count then double them and run half without lust and half with.
Honestly, Whetstone because it's upgradeable, personally
Whetstone plus totem?
@ionic fern Whats your thoughts about the procc of Blazehoof? I got 372 Blaze (which is 3% haste), 389 decoration of flame and now a 418 scale from vault, which is a lot of permanent mainstat - for now i chosed to use flame and scale, hoping to finally get an upgrade hoofe to switch to scale and blaze. or do I have an thoughts error in my plan?
what would you pick?
I am more inclined to pick the one with speed to be fair
I have around 12% more speed without it.
Is the 4pc set bonus also bugged like the talent? anyone tested that out?
blaze is also a proc of str with an explision 5 target component, its not "just 3% haste"
wrecking throw worth taking for rlp first boss?
Does prot warriors rotation and talents change much depending on having the tier set?
wait, those annoiyng shield casters that shields up tiny bit, could you just execute them with WT?
probably
not at all, not even worth tracking the buff
there's a lot of shield stuff in there
no the big shield when she summons whelps
Guys I dont know what to pick
First boss?
Maybe go for the socket one
They just nerfed the shield on the first boss, though
Aye but it still does 500% damage too them?
Mhm
N for 1 talent point
Yeh, i got that. I'd assume it works but i dont know. Which made me think of my question, wonder if it also works on those shitters?
I'm sure I read it does work.
What do you drop for it?
I'd prob say so
but i dont think im losing much by sacrificing idk, intervene
The boss is aids
hi guys, any opinions on the dodge/parry trinket from kurog? deciding between that and a heroic version of my leg tier piece
i'm very lost with trinkets this xpac
I dont even run intervene haha!
I really like intervene this season, haha
depends what you have but that sidearm, shout, bounding etc
has saved more than a few keys from absent minded DPS not clearing thundering
Am I siming wrong? the Cape is by far the best o: thought the "All-Totem of the Master" or the Scale would sim much higher o:
bounding stride is more mandatory than rallying cry xd
I'd say drop sidearm
i will NEVER be separated from my bounding stride
Small bit dps for an easier boss. Esp on tyrannical
I hear people say something similar everyday and I really dont see it or understand why.
When everyone's susceptible to just die
movement go brrrrrrrrr
Speed bro.
All the movement
We aint dks
Lol
if you're running intimidating shout, you could probably drop that
Im aware what it does lol
This also
Yes, what it does is alsp the reason for taking it
I wouldn't say that tbh lol
it doesnt matter if u can survive the pack if you cant get to it roughly 2 seconds sooner
I like shout tbh. My group has too many stuns so it's nice to get a stop not on stun DR
what?
I prefer the stun Dr tbh
Shout's nice, just if you have to drop a utility for another utility that's a point that's easily moveable
how do we live 2nd boss RLP, died through decoration of flame, last stand, and 140k ignore pain up. The bleed just did 111k a second. 19 RLP
what do u think is more useful? a group wide defensive, or a minor speed boost every 30 seconds
i rest my case
I guess what I mean is I've never considered dropping it for bounding lol
bounding stride is necessary
They're joking
Warrior has crazy movement without it
ohh, protip? They should never even think about attempting a career in stand up comedy, it would be a disaster.
guys i need some advice. I have decoration as 389 . Also i have same set gloves as 411 ilvl. I got 3 set if i get shoulder 398 i'll 4 set. For weapon i have 405 crafted one but i can make 418 today so idk what should i chose
All personal preference really. None are mandatory too survival I'd say but more quality of life.
dont have useless healer at that point lol
What i think, is that you're a troll xD
@round cliff gotta cancel your show at the comedy cellary. Sorry, buddy
if ur pushing m+ i would go for 4 set
i dont understand how jeweled signet of melandrus is good at all for us
does it get less stats or no
@buoyant helm yeah mostly im doing m+ , rarely raid
scales into abilities that scale from weap dmg (soo most of them)
@buoyant helm with 4 set we never use IP btw or something?
ohh thats op nvm
@buoyant helm would you reco the trinket from kurog? using the norm razageth one atm for my passive trinket
I'd just sim myself. Hoof is really solid. ๐
i already have the tier legs but lower difficulty so i'm pretty cut
oh, heroic razagath trinket, not the norm one
flame deco defensive component worth anything?
shield usually feels like it evaporates
cant ever please a stickler
This was in my 19 AA.
Yeah, usually about where it lands for me
Guys, is there any point doing weeklies anymore? feast, siege, trials etc? If every slot is 392 or above?
kinda what I'm doing, doesn't feel worthwhile to hold it for the shield like blood-spattered scale did
Rep
I wanted so badly for it to be a new scale, oh well
are people farming those btw? I'm like 11 renown on all
I do them once a week
huuuuge upgrade
I haven't seen anything higher than a 382 out of them in a minute
hey guys, need a little bit of help choosing my vault. I have to chose between Seal of Diurna's 421(1st boss ring) and AV Shield 421 (haste versa). The ring seems higher ofc, but would't the shield be the better pick?
sims*
How much Ilvl does a socket provide roughly? because I have these two rings and the lower Ilvl one had a socket. was wondering if its worth it to increase it with valor or not. Thanks!
hi mates any can send me reflect spreadsheet pls ? i dont find it
pins
its shadowland spreadsheet on pins
do we have any bis list? I know its frowned upon but guild wants me to provide "bis items" to avoid drama for "tanks wanting dps stuff" or vice versa. Same with all roles. I get it. Good idea.
the top pin with the weakaura. it has a link there
When your vault is so good its hard to pick
Its either Tier hands or Hoof atm, currently have 405 hands
This would be my third tier piece, meaning I will likely get another tier item in reclear today
I think the icy-veins guide usually has something like that
with everyone and their mama getting tier, even tier from m+ slosts. You want to go trinket
RING.
Just do droptimizer from raidboys and send it to them.
Not this time around. ๐
We finally got rid of it.

you have 6 slots with only 8 bosses loot tables
vs m+ trinkets with 3 slots for 8*4 (28) boss loot table
trinket has to be the mathetical correct choice?
I'd also take hoof.
Well yeah, but Icon and Decoration at mythic ilvl is only 200dps less
Icon + Hoof at this ilvl is technically BIS though
SO yeah
The only thing i got from weekly vault is depresion
Hi guys, I'd appreciate some help picking from vault. How good is the trinket? Or should I take the pants and turn them into tier later? I have 411 tier chest, 408 Incernate Icon, and a 402 Winscar Whetsone. Are there clear BIS trinkets for M+ yet?
How good is Strike Twice one handed as a prot?
guys i need some advice. I have decoration as 389 . Also i have same set gloves as 411 ilvl. I got 3 set if i get shoulder 398 i'll 4 set. For weapon i have 405 crafted one but i can make 418 today so idk what should i choose? Im mostly pushing m+.
You already got solid trinkets.
Better than other weapons of similar ilvl just for the free effect.
I'd probably take Decoration or legs, if you have access to higher ilvl tier.
From what iโve heard itโs not bad, but you generally wanna go for haste/vers or haste/crit depending on what you need.
It's a free effect....ontop of stats....
dumb question, gems, straight haste over multi stat, or multi stat is good etc?
vs other weapons with just...stats.
Multi stat is better.
recommendation?
Stats are Crit mastery, stats can be snatched elsewhere i supposed
IV/WoWHead guides. ๐
Stats don't matter that much on a weapon. ๐
Plus does it proc the devastation SS reset if the weapon procs itself ?
Look at the stat budget.
no
its a proc
its not a double attack
Alright thank you all :)
despite the name
Would have been twice as good if it did
Is this trinket good? every guide said something little different
Whats people's opinion on how good the 4pc is for Prot warrior?
Question for a Volt.. I have a chest 421 non tir vs sholders 415 tir that would give me a 2 set. do i go for 421 and wait 2 weeks to change it to tir or take a smaller ilvl sholder tir?
how good is double shockwave capstone? not at all?
Bad
most of us dont use it cause it causes DR issues
It's a proc roughly once a minute, at a random time, for 90k absorb
Does that sound good?
I do not like it because its not predictable
It's solid defensively. ๐
https://i.imgur.com/8LOipX6.png is there a good option to drop here for bounding stride
sidearm?
Well u shouldnt be running barbaric
m+
What qual mats do I need for lariat to be 405ilvl
Iirc, from beta, shockwave capstones did similar damage to TR but also DR'd everything to hell
the flee scares me
Usually it breaks immediately
unless youre doing wet noodle damage
Primal infusion
Rend ticks
The crafter is more important than the mats
but now its even harder to fit bounding stride in xd
Right
maybe i shouldnt bother
you shouldn't need stride for keys
Open pins
Take the m+ talents from there.
There you go.
So if I buy the bronze qual mats on ah it wonโt affect the ilvl?
Better mats, higher chance, most crafters have a hard time guaranteeing 5 star w/ infusion
No but it will make it harder for the crafter to get 5 star
You don't NEED stride..i personally just take it. I drop Sidearm for it, @round cliff .
right off the bat
I got mine t4 without buying the 30k diamond
I see thank you
Right
Ypu can use the r2 diamond, yeah
drop sidearm and barbaric for intim shout and bounding stride?
possibly?
t2 diamond is fine, t3 everything else though
Just find someone that can craft with t2 mats
this trinket is good ?
Drop Barbaric for Intim.
Sidearm vs Bounding is personal preference.
Yeah, its pretty good
Yea it's good
Si, bueno.
is there an option for taking shattering throw in rlp
you dont want shattering
Not quite as good as some of the raid trinkets but one of the best from the dungeon set
you want wrecking
oh did i mix it up
and i swap sidearm for it
You can take whatever.
I won't.
then yes wrecking
what a bad vault I came out with... no tier set... ๐ฆ
yeah
still does decent dmg
Some1 told me yesterday I could spell reflect all the imps' casts in CoS at the same time. Didn't know until that, o always thought spell reflect only reflects one spell :I
Decoration is good
If they are coming at the same time, you can reflect them.
Was gonna say
isn't that the rare ring from the raid lol
Enjoy.
If its cast simultaneously it'll reflect multiple
So for the imps you wanna make sure you're the only person in range for the first cast so they all target you
Ah okay. That explains why I never felt to SR multiple casts. They've never been perfectly aligned.
i have
Thx guys that makes things more clear
Oh yea kinda shit vault then
Anyone see the hotfix notes for dungeons? For Azureblade what does it mean when it says Increased the time it takes for Azureblade to drain their mana.
whats this mechanic?
U could take items to save for catalyst
So he doesn't do adds so often.
She'll spend more time actually attackable before going into the shielded phase
Does 20k for this person to craft it seem fair? They said that covers free redrafts
Recrafts*
Tree boss is ezpz now
Which I'm happy about because Algethar is my favorite dungeon
Depends on item itself and server economy .
That's about what I paid
I need some life advice fellow warriors 
Fap before asking her
Already did fap 
Okej then go ahead whats your issue
if i don't raid, just for M+ bigwigs + littlewigs is better than DBM?
ok i have 2 choices. The ring is a big upgrade but the head set piece with a sockel also seems like a solid choice
Oh and my current stats
I dont know if i wanna drop that much versa for the ring
I would
Screw versa , u get tons of haste instead
I personaly wouldnt go for 10(17 ilvl with valor ) upgrade , if it gave you another set then yes, but if its like this .. any other options ?
Ring imo
hello friends, is it wrong for me to conceptualize the 4set bonus as 5% leech
Yes
ok cool
I got 3% vers and chillin'.
Ignore pain is better than leech I think
@ionic fern SENPAI, why puzzle box is simming better then hoof on same ilvl? All i read that box is poo tier compare to god tier hoof. Should i swap or i sim wrong?
https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/hXRXveR6YttbYSRDCzSciE
heroic incarnate icon from vault, hell yeah
Nah itโs about the same
Ah gotcha
On one hand itโs an absorb which is better than a heal
puzzle box has a cast time and is cursed when tanking
On the other hand you have to take more than the damage absorbed to get value
but its crazy stats
Puzzle box is def not poo tier
Itโs a tone of stats
In m+ you pre pull it
In raid you use it while taunted off
Thereโs no issues
so treating 4set as 5% leech is about right?
so should i swap it for decoration?
Not exactly but good enough
sacrificing 4set for a ~25 ilvl boost on pants has made me have to really figure out what it's worth
Ilvl imo
I would do pants over 4set
Pants
ya, that's what i'm leaning towards
Can always convert to tier later
hmmmmmmmm Sidegrade into 1/4 tier or 20 ilvl upgrade
F in chat for LET FLY
Hi All, probably been asked before but how decent is this trink?
especially against 421 chest
i would take chest myself
I have a 418 chest already is the thing, do you know perhaps when the catalyst opens?
2 weeks
How badly do I want 4 set?
Worth swapping 411 pants for normal tier? (404 equipped ilvl)
I have the choice between:
39 ilvl upgrade on belt with crit/mastery
30 ilvl upgrade on ring with haste/crit and avoidance
9 ilvl upgrade on helmet and gain 2 set
Any suggestions?
Not belt.
2set>Ilvl
This ๐ฏ
I mostly play M+ in the 17-18 range currently and only raid casually, my guild only just cleared normal and 2 bosses on HC
Hey all. I'm new here, and hoping that you smart people can help me in the right direction ๐ . I currently have 3 pc. In vault I have the option of same ilvl shoulders, but it's tier giving me 4pc. Or tier legs, that I already have, but it's 29 ilvl upgrade
Any advice?
so just as a general question about the trinket, it's considered like a 2nd last stand with 2.5k versa on it?
i mean that trinket is kinda meh
do you maybe know how often you generate seeds?
compared to what else is out there
and for like the 900th time
we dont care about vers
had that trinket early on. Stacks didn't build super fast but they stayed long and the trink is on a rather short CD
still
didn't really do much
alrighty, thanks
Why do all the top pwar run Vers then :<
because like the shockwave build its looks good in theory
Because itโs solid
Top wars are not theory, they are actual practice
I run haste crit bcs it looks better :>
Like you are a top player
So that makes Vers better than crit
And you are pushing top keys
You realize all the vers in there is like 2.5% dr or something
Itโs minuscule
this is in m+ only
but this is some discussion behind the scenes
in raid vers is probably better just because nothing averages out
crunch the numbers
But fuck raid :>


