#protection

1 messages · Page 233 of 1

glad perch
#

is prot warrior more fun than havoc dh?

sick sentinel
#

DH is alot of fun

glad perch
#

yes

#

i know, that’s what i play

#

im interested in how fun prot warrior is

strong forum
#

fun is subjective

glad perch
#

and what is your opinion?

strong forum
#

i play pwar exclusively

#

so uh yeah its very fun

sick sentinel
#

thats what im implying, is that i had more fun as a DH than i do as warrior but overall i enjoy warrior more

glad perch
#

so you have more fun as warrior even though you have more fun as dh?

#

cool

sick sentinel
#

i think fun is more temporary, enoyability is more like, long term

ebon geyser
#

i played dh for a bit is fun and all but i want a shield wearing tank

glad perch
#

yep

#

i get ur point yogi

ebon geyser
#

also i havent played war since vanilla

glad perch
#

think it could be related to being a tank?

#

or did you play vengeance

ebon geyser
#

im super bad but with nom help i will just be bad

glad perch
#

does prot warrior do more damage than havoc?

craggy pilot
#

Comparing havoc to prot is kinda weird tho 😂

ebon geyser
#

havoc is dps spec

#

i bet u mean veng

craggy pilot
#

Exactly

strong forum
#

havoc is one of the best dps specs

#

so, it does worlds more dmg than a tank

#

kek

glad perch
#

no i mean havoc

#

the dps spec

#

kek

craggy pilot
glad perch
#

but i was trolling

ebon geyser
#

thats comparing wow with ff14

sick sentinel
#

well, one is clearly better than the other, to be frank

glad perch
#

yep

#

ff14

sick sentinel
#

i'll leave it at that

glad perch
#

jkjk

surreal birch
glad perch
#

yeah, either you want fun or you want to be bored

#

if you like fun: wow

#

if you want to be bored: ff

ebon geyser
#

i mean

glad perch
sick sentinel
#

its not my final fantasy to play that game - brother

glad perch
#

lmao

surreal birch
glad perch
#

hmmm

#

sussy

deft hazel
#

sadge i havent tanked this week because i got really nervous about bosses

craggy pilot
#

Damn the twitch chats are pure 🍿 now

surreal birch
#

on prot is it worth upgrading weapons first with valor, or better to get trinkets etc. ?

ebon geyser
craggy pilot
craggy pilot
fading tide
#

Pugs can be funny. Did a 10 ruby with only 2 deaths and a 10 Jade that took over an hour to complete.

sick sentinel
#

athene is back and going for gladiator

surreal birch
sick sentinel
#

he quit the game for a long time

surreal birch
#

iirc he was 2.7k SL S1

waxen cedar
#

How much ilvl would you rate our 4 set ? Is it worth dropping 20 ilvl in total for it ?

sick sentinel
#

that seems insane to me, but i mean, he's a healer

ebon geyser
craggy pilot
#

They just had a 10% wipe before i think

#

Where boss healed up to 16

short temple
#

is this any good?

craggy pilot
#

Sounds cringe

strong forum
#

nothing relevating

#

it takes ~2minutes to reach max stacks

short temple
#

is this better

craggy pilot
#

I just saw it doesn't give dmg, so i run arms loot spec for that dungeon 😂

strong forum
#

no granthys is not better

#

not by a long shot

short temple
#

hehe just my though xD

craggy pilot
#

Also that ilvl is troll

short temple
#

been super unlucky with trinkets on my war

uneven robin
#

i mean, Scale proc is good, but its rng so that meh

jolly wasp
#

Guys is it possible to actually sim embellishments through raidbots? Can't seem to figure it out

strong forum
#

its 1ppm

#

scale proc is like 70k per minute, not exactly good

craggy pilot
#

And i think you can sim them in droptimizer

#

But not sure all of them sim correctly 🤔

wet gate
#

what did you guys pick for 2nd spark craft? the belt looks nice since it might proc raid rings?

nova sentinel
#

took wrist gladge

craggy pilot
#

I did wrist cus I had 379 wrist, but now i kinda wanted to craft weap instead (i made shield first)

#

I did engi wrist btw

uneven robin
#

i think he mostly talking about Embelished stuff

jolly wasp
fading tide
#

I crafted a 386 shield but then got a 392 shield from a plus 10. Is my crafted shield trash now?

wet gate
#

yea made elemental lariat with my first spark thinking of 2nd

craggy pilot
uneven robin
#

you can recraft it with a primal infusion to 405. or even 418

fading tide
craggy pilot
#

If you trash your crafted shield, the spark is gone

jolly wasp
fading tide
#

Can I get the spark back at all?

craggy pilot
#

Huge no-no

wet gate
#

theres always item recovery when people realize 😛

craggy pilot
#

Not sure if u can sim armor spikes/fang then 🤔

craggy pilot
uneven robin
#

not sure which gem to put on my Lariat, Is it better to just focus on 1 type of buff. or mix it

wet gate
#

i was wondering the same thing seems we prio haste a lot

jolly wasp
#

it shouldnt as it has no extra effect right?

cobalt grove
#

I made a shield, recrafted with an armor spike and it became a 392

#

I've never had the best luck with shields actually dropping

craggy pilot
tawdry lynx
#

I know this has been discussed a lot and I did search but I'm still trying to understand why and how phial glacial fury is ideal in raid and not just m+.

It reads "Whenever you first attack a target" So just one proc at the beginning of the fight...?

mortal brook
#

You always have the damage proc.

#

The attacking new targets is for amping that damage proc

tawdry lynx
#

Gotttttt it. Thank you.

craggy pilot
#

Is it better than eye of the storm though in M+? 🤔

mortal brook
#

Offensively maybe, simmable. Defensively no

onyx matrix
#

hey, is anyone using armor spike on the crafted shield? ty

craggy pilot
#

A lot of people are running armor spikes + fang on shield + wep

onyx matrix
#

alright cool

craggy pilot
#

Might as well, since you only have 2 sparks, and wep+shield are huge items for us

onyx matrix
#

true, ty mate ^^

mortal brook
#

Optional reagent is nice since you can get recrafted out

craggy pilot
#

But honestly can craft just about anything

tawdry lynx
#

im sure it comes out in the wash with internal cds and what not but im a little turned off by spikes in long taunt swap scenarios

sick sentinel
#

ty

pallid quiver
fading tide
#

I got the sword that wowhead says is our m+ bis. Should I just pump all my valor into it?

tawdry lynx
#

sim

craggy pilot
sick sentinel
#

how many times out of 10 do you run spell block

#

or, like, is it only dungeon/ raid boss specific

craggy pilot
#

I run it only in temple

sick sentinel
#

never in any else content?

slim dove
#

temple and vault i like it.

final gust
#

it's not a solid yes or no

#

it's "wherever you find it essential"

#

there are several places where a lot of people agree, like temple

sick sentinel
#

i mean like, i opened the spell reflect google doc right, and it says, everything is spell blockable in one of first pages i looked at

#

so, i know it has a long CD, and then im thinking to my self hmmm am i missing something?

final gust
#

so if you find that there are certain spells that are killing/chunking you, you should consider bringing spell block

uneven mason
final gust
#

hmmmm

mighty valley
#

"we don't take damage"

final gust
#

slam the dam

sick sentinel
#

"why aren't you using defensive stance?"

#

every pug ever

final gust
#

the stance dance I'm having to get used to

#

but it feels good when it works

#

better than I thought it would

uneven mason
#

I had a pug ask that, so I replied "I'll run defensive stance when I don't have to carry you in DPS"

#

They left

final gust
#

kek

uneven mason
#

Sads

sick sentinel
#

fury stance for prot blizzard plz

#

i know its stupid but i want it anway

final gust
#

zerk stance

uneven mason
#

I want it to at least apply a stance when you switch soecs

sick sentinel
#

zug zug

prisma echo
#

i just test it and i dont know how i was capable of plaing without it :d it was like plaing prot on hard mode

#

i have so much rage now

compact jackal
#

🤔

#

Lariat+Bracers, Bracers+Armor spikes, bracers+belt, or bracers+fang

slim dove
#

im doing bracers next reset.

prisma echo
#

and i feel synchro

compact jackal
marsh radish
#

What gems would you guys toss into your Lariat's?

prisma echo
#

btw we dont get spark this week?

onyx matrix
compact jackal
latent onyx
slim dove
compact jackal
craggy pilot
#

Morgan go wrist + fang + shield(food buff)

slim dove
#

lmao imagine actually getting drops in raid

#

LOL

#

look at this dude

compact jackal
#

I have 1 tier piece sadge

slim dove
#

(ive done 2 8/8 normal clears and 2 4/8 heroic clears, won nothing)

uneven mason
fading tide
slim dove
craggy pilot
#

Or wrist + belt + food shield

compact jackal
#

I'm not an asmongold alt

#

I can use shield block

fading tide
#

No bully the bald man plz

compact jackal
slim dove
#

and change that godawful tabard the fuck

craggy pilot
compact jackal
slim dove
craggy pilot
#

No one likes a gem nerd 😂

compact jackal
#

DRIP

slim dove
#

let it go

#

i dont wear my mop tabards cuz im washed up

compact jackal
sick sentinel
compact jackal
slim dove
#

OG argent dawn tabard?

compact jackal
devout parcel
#

is there a weakaura that helps with spell reflects? or a list of some sort which lists what can be spell reflected?

full venture
#

Yes

#

Look it up

fading tide
#

7th legion rate warfront gear with theremore tabard

slim dove
compact jackal
#

do I go from drip to gigadrip?

slim dove
#

nah

#

tabard of frost would be giga drip

fading tide
#

Twitch drop soon

compact jackal
#

it could work.

slim dove
#

sword does though

#

purple is the best though get on it peepo

compact jackal
fading tide
deft hazel
compact jackal
#

Oh, the unchained glad shield could work

slim dove
vocal cradle
#

Guys I'm a long time fury warrior that has converted to tank, I'm still reading the Wowhead articles on it. Anything else I should be reading on to know more of the spec? Also is there a prot with public logs I can look up to on builds for certain fights and what not?

edgy grail
#

There are thousands on WCL

craggy pilot
#

And pins

vocal cradle
craggy pilot
#

It's not always the play to copy those at the top though, their playstyle could be very much catered to a specific situation & setup, which will not work for you the same

vocal cradle
craggy pilot
#

Well that's what you're looking for no?

vocal cradle
#

I'm not looking to parse atm

#

I know good dps is part of the equation but I also want to survive

craggy pilot
#

Then just look wowhead and pins

edgy grail
#

Parsing well

#

Means you didn’t die

#

At a minimum

vocal cradle
#

That's a fact

#

But there's a whole lot of reasons one could parse and not die

#

But I get what you all mean

edgy grail
#

Yea but if you are concerned with learning how to live

vocal cradle
#

I'll look at pins and wowhead

edgy grail
#

All the top logs show you

#

How to live

#

There is no substitute for playing

#

Read the guides and go have some fun

vocal cradle
#

Well this is my first week tanking for real so I hope I can do well

edgy grail
#

When yiu die

#

Look at all your defensives

#

And see what you could have used

fading tide
#

What should my deadlift be at if I want to tank +15s?

violet spruce
#

3 plates no sumo

fading tide
#

KEK sumo

edgy grail
#

Dont need much

drifting dove
#

One of the gents on my guild keeps telling me I should run battle scarred veteran but none of the builds / guides I see are running that. Just thought I’d come ask people’s thoughts whether I’m relying too much on the guides or not? Not had any mega issues

edgy grail
#

Dont use it

#

You’ll know when you need it

craggy pilot
edgy grail
#

(Most people will never need it)

craggy pilot
#

You can potentially run it,but there are other stuff which has equal if not more effect

drifting dove
#

That was sort my thought. Other than on prog I haven’t had any issues and well prog is prog and it’s not really the tanks dropping first

#

Thanks for the quick response

craggy pilot
#

In the end we have 1 talent left, which you can put in thunderlord, battering ram or battle scared vet

limpid anchor
craggy pilot
#

It was, but i recall a few people showing logs where it seemed like it had been fixed

limpid anchor
#

But even if it works, I would prob only run it in a few m+ on very high keys

#

And definitely not in raid

#

(Unless a fight requires it for top 100)

sterile bough
#

what is best 1 hand for warrior?

craggy pilot
#

The ones with str and high ilvl

cerulean urchin
#

strike twice?

#

i just crafted this cause i cba to chse weapon, but now the shield wont drop lol

craggy pilot
#

You got 2 sparks though 🤔

sterile bough
#

but if I want to craft one

wary heath
#

3 sparks as of Tuesday

cerulean urchin
#

kind wasted my 1 spark on week 1 ring

sterile bough
cerulean urchin
#

not worth

#

also fk ruby pools man still aids dungeon

craggy pilot
# sterile bough

I think most weaponsmiths are sword spec, not sure why, but looks that way

slim dove
#

can make wep for every class.

craggy pilot
# cerulean urchin

I'm like 100 points away from ksm and only missing rlp on tyran, but said fuck it and went for Christmas break 😂

cerulean urchin
#

week 1 was lack luster, but i also was like 15 ilvls lower

slim dove
#

its free next week anyways

#

compared to this

craggy pilot
cerulean urchin
#

next weeks sanguine and volcanic, ez

craggy pilot
slim dove
#

really gave us the hardest 2 weeks to start the expac

cerulean urchin
#

especially week 1 fortified raging, with shit gear

craggy pilot
cerulean urchin
#

thunderclap and inshallah

#

if we live we live

#

i also play with guildies but they had to stop to go rtaid and he was 1 score away lol

slim dove
slow gazelle
#

Is Strike Twice better than a haste/vers sword? I got one in my vault and want to know if I should dump valor into improving it if the extra proc actually puts it above all the other 1 handers

craggy pilot
#

Same ilvl i think strike twice wins

cerulean urchin
#

i still havend dropped a shield

#

i think im at like 15+ runs in halls of valor and 5-8 in azure and nothing

#

i evne had my fury friend loot spec prot and still nothing

craggy pilot
#

I had no shield either 😂 but i have 405 crafted 🥳

slow gazelle
cerulean urchin
#

i think im gonna have to craft one too, but i was thinking of crafting lariat next week, its like free to craft basically

quasi otter
#

Newbie warrior tank here, are people using BSV? I saw some folks talking about it earlier in the week

craggy pilot
cerulean urchin
cerulean urchin
#

in lower keys you dont need it

quasi otter
#

Word, I think my issue must be SB an IP uptime

craggy pilot
#

Ip is not usually anything to worry about

cerulean urchin
#

Try running Heavy rep and bolster maybe that will help your shield block uptime

#

Last stand + bolster and 2 shield blocks is like 30 sec of shield block ,then u just shield slam and spam shield block of cd

craggy pilot
#

Hr+enduring is usually enough without bolster

#

+shield charge

quasi otter
#

Aye, on the phone so kinda hard to show but it's not great uptime. Last I checked I was keeping up at like ~70% of the time, according to details. I feel like I should be quite a bit higher than that

craggy pilot
cerulean urchin
#

its also not fortified so stuff dies fast, my uptime hjas gone down this week too

subtle nymph
#

Hey guys, quick question what phial you using in mm+?

craggy pilot
#

And SB uptime doesn't mean anything, amount of blocked hits matter

cerulean urchin
craggy pilot
cerulean urchin
#

its usually around 2-3m dmg for me

subtle nymph
#

Cz im new to war prot so dk what to take

#

but thanks for advice

quasi otter
#

Alright, fair enough. You guys use shield wall liberally?

craggy pilot
silent anchor
#

how do yu survive jade sewrpent strike?

#

past reflect and block

quasi otter
#

Sounds good, I also have had some trouble when doing an AOE pull and trying to gather mobs around if the AOE taunt isn't up. But I blame the dh in my group for not chilling a sec before ripping it XD

cerulean urchin
#

i play with a fury warrior and DH

#

literaly apes that wont wait 2 sec

#

i just let them die

#

if they rip aggro

quasi otter
#

Lmao, you use shield charge to pull?

stoic elm
#

hey guys new to tanking and prot warrior

#

this is my buff uptime

cerulean urchin
stoic elm
#

can some one share theirs so i can compare

quasi otter
#

Sometimes I feel a bit rage starved right at the beginning of a pull. Shield charge feels nice with that extra bit of rage and SB up

craggy pilot
cerulean urchin
craggy pilot
#

Details doesn't rly help much

craggy pilot
stoic elm
#

ok

craggy pilot
bleak quartz
#

is it possible to skip temple 3rd boss absorb attack by leaping away ? has anyone tried

violet coral
#

How good is armor spikes as an embellishment? Worth using? I havent been able to find much info about it and was thinking of getting crafted boots as its my lowest, but im not sure if i should

cerulean urchin
#

i mean u dont have many options so armors spikes is kinda the way to go if u really want it

#

i dont think its that big

craggy pilot
solemn current
# stoic elm can some one share theirs so i can compare

Not able to post mine but I’m assuming you’re running HR and enduring? Should be making sure to never be at 2 charges of shield block, using avatar on CD, using shield slam when it’s up, and never wasting any rage. My shield block is typically around 95+% in details with roughly 50% avatar uptime. You might also be using outburst on TC too much.

violet coral
#

Reckon it would be better to use embellishment for weapon then? I have a lariat so only got 1 more slot for emb

cerulean urchin
#

thunderclap

craggy pilot
quasi otter
cerulean urchin
quasi otter
#

That's probably the case then

weary remnant
#

Lads for how much did u make 418 one handed swords for your warriors?

quasi otter
#

To be entirely honest I don't feel like I've had trouble staying alive. But I've definitely seen SB go off and my health drop instantly, mostly last week XD

cerulean urchin
#

last week was kinda rough, fortified + raging and you were probably not that high ilvl so you were getting clapped

#

i remember pulling the sha mobs in 13 Temple and getting one shot by dark claw

craggy pilot
topaz fable
#

What is better for pure DPS - Shockwave and its two subtalents or Thunderous Roar and its two?

quasi otter
#

And not just press SB randomly hahahah

quasi otter
lone eagle
#

Does the frostfire belt trigger the fire rings?

cerulean urchin
#

idk i didnt even have time to move one step back, i inst adfied

cerulean urchin
craggy pilot
#

You can spam SB no problem, and pretty much use Shield Charge on CD and u'll be fine

craggy pilot
quasi otter
#

Word, what's your SB cd right now? Not sure if my haste is just lowish, sitting at 13 secs

edgy grail
#

Mostly irrelevant

naive panther
#

anyone burning valor early on for shield upgrade?

edgy grail
#

You can have 100% SB with the correct talents

edgy grail
craggy pilot
quasi otter
#

Alright, thanks for the tips

naive panther
#

I did neck and weapon, could maybe do shield next week, but I can upgrade shield to 408 right now if i wanted

edgy grail
#

Maybe wait fir vault

#

And decide

naive panther
#

probably smart

#

been using 372 shield till today

edgy grail
#

But yea not a bad investment

naive panther
#

well no, 376 whatever junk rank shield i crafted

silent anchor
#

jade serpent strike

#

how can you survive

naive panther
#

good luck

#

i can'

#

t

silent anchor
#

after SR and SB

edgy grail
#

Wall

#

Last stand

#

Healer external

cerulean urchin
#

Shield wall and inshallah

#

Or just die and brez

silent anchor
#

it absorbs 85k healing

craggy pilot
#

You can SR every 2nd

silent anchor
#

aswell as healing 70k every 1 second

craggy pilot
#

And sit dstance for it

silent anchor
#

still*

#

SR 2 and SB 1

edgy grail
#

SR every 2 and impending victory

craggy pilot
#

What key?

silent anchor
#

then didnt have SR

edgy grail
#

Wall 2 of them

silent anchor
#

17

#

wall doesnt stop the healing

#

or the dot

craggy pilot
#

Hmm didn't try it on 17

edgy grail
#

It reduces the damage lol

#

So the healer can heal you

craggy pilot
#

Do you have log?

silent anchor
#

lol its alot of damage

edgy grail
#

It’s a healer check if you used wall

#

They need to prep

cerulean urchin
#

That shit killed me on a 14 lol

silent anchor
#

i used everything XD

cerulean urchin
#

The third one

edgy grail
#

I lived easily on our 16

#

At like 375 ilvl

silent anchor
edgy grail
#

Just need to communicate at a certain point

cerulean urchin
#

I call bs

edgy grail
#

Yes

cerulean urchin
#

No shot u survive that at 375

silent anchor
cerulean urchin
#

It halves your hp

#
  • the dot
silent anchor
#

its 70k every 1 second

cerulean urchin
#

I have 405k hp

silent anchor
#

and negates 80k healing

cerulean urchin
#

You at 375 have like 350k mqx

silent anchor
#

im 391 with 386k

torn gulch
#

417k at 388

edgy grail
#

Healer diff idk what to tell you

torn gulch
#

what?

edgy grail
#

Talk to your healer and have them prep for the abosrb

silent anchor
#

mate, no chance u lived "easily" at 375

edgy grail
#

I play with rdruid so the abosrb is basically gone instantly

slim dove
#

man i do not get the toxicity with pugs this expac

silent anchor
#

tell me how u have 400k health

#

at 375

#

20 ilvl lover than me

#

with 20k more hp lol

cerulean urchin
#

He doesn't

slim dove
#

1 mistake on a cos12 , more than enough time to still 1 chest, buddy kicks me from the group and spam emotes me from respawn

#

like??? i did the same dam as you???

edgy grail
#

Anyway

#

Do you want actual help or just here to complain lol

#

Play defenders aegis

silent anchor
cerulean urchin
#

Lol first few weeks of m+ pugs is horrible

edgy grail
#

So you have 2 shield walls for the dot

silent anchor
#

you literally just said u have more hp than u do and its easy

deft socket
#

Should I be crafting lariat or 1h weapon first?

craggy pilot
#

2 wall + spell block is nice for temple

slim dove
edgy grail
#

I didnt say a single thing about my HP

craggy pilot
silent anchor
edgy grail
#

But ok keep dying to the dragon and keep complaining yep

#

Later

deft socket
late surge
#

is dslice any good for pwar? how should we sim for dungs?

silent anchor
craggy pilot
#

If you have log from boss in temple, it's 100 times easier for us to help tbh

silent anchor
craggy pilot
#

I know a lot of people don't log tho

edgy grail
#

If you have no other option

#

You can lust P2

limpid anchor
#

Just coordinate cds with the heal, the boss isn’t that difficult

silent anchor
craggy pilot
#

But you should be able to live it with dstance + Sr + wall + imp victory

limpid anchor
#

I can negate 2 serpents completely

silent anchor
#

i lived 3/4 casts

#

was a pug healer

#

prob the issue

limpid anchor
#

Yes

edgy grail
#

Yess

#

Lol

silent anchor
#

its fucking hell tho

edgy grail
#

My healer preps each kick

silent anchor
#

the tank busters on tyr r insane

limpid anchor
#

Like I used cds on first 2, the the heal, than my cd + pot

#

Works pretty fine

edgy grail
#

And swiftmends me

ornate thunder
#

Good thing blizzard gave them that whole agency thing….

silent anchor
#

i specced into spell block for the 2nd boss in halls

limpid anchor
edgy grail
#

The abosrb is the issue really

limpid anchor
#

You can’t expect to solo something

edgy grail
#

You can easily live the dot alone

#

You just cant fuckign healer yourself

#

Well you can a bit

silent anchor
sick sentinel
#

Just bl and burst

#

Ez tactic

limpid anchor
silent anchor
#

yeah that pushes u bk

limpid anchor
#

I mean, def stance and sr is enough

slim dove
#

last stand + wall one, reflect + commanding the next

limpid anchor
#

And you have other cds as well, don’t even need healer

slim dove
#

def stance for both

#

its not hard.

#

what is hard is finding pugs that arent remedial but thats another discussion

craggy pilot
#

Razs dead x2

silent anchor
#

yup just seen it

cerulean musk
#

Who won?

limpid anchor
#

Eu ofc

craggy pilot
#

Blizz wins

#

They killed the boss with nerfs

#

So blizz got world first

slim dove
#

aint much of a race if the boss gets nerfed while the competition is sleeping

craggy pilot
#

Indeed 😂

deft socket
#

Has limit killed it yet?

craggy pilot
#

And i think they nerfed the boss like 3 times?

slim dove
#

yup

craggy pilot
strong forum
slim dove
#

aint no way that sim is taking into account the proc.

limpid anchor
#

Undeserved echo win btw

strong forum
#

Yes, the helmet is not implemented in simc

strong forum
slim dove
#

its 3.5ppm iirc.

tropic tangle
slim dove
#

35k dmg / min, or 583 dps

craggy pilot
#

Heard liquid spent 80 pulls on a pre nerf boss p1 that was basically impossible 😂 so entire first day on razs is a joke

limpid anchor
#

Even if they would have started at the same time

strong forum
#

Yes so how is it undeserved that echo won

craggy pilot
#

Does helmet have less stat budget?

cerulean urchin
#

echo pre nerf best pull 8% , liquid 14%

limpid anchor
cerulean urchin
#

echo took 1 pull after nerf

limpid anchor
#

People cried that it was unfair for liquid

#

But in the end, it didn’t matter

blazing aspen
#

echo won baybeeee YUS

strong forum
#

Yes

blazing aspen
#

won me some cash haha

cerulean urchin
#

i mean if liquid won, unfair for echo
echo wins unfair for liquid people always gonna cry

wind talon
#

on a fresh prot warrior. what should i use my sparks on? neck and weapon? or is helmet good?

craggy pilot
#

Wasn't liquid on razs 1,5 days before echo? But it basically makes no sense since you need to wait for nerfs anyway

blazing aspen
#

liquid has like 3 times the pulls than echo lmfao

tropic tangle
#

or very close to it

strong forum
#

^

tropic tangle
#

you could make the argument that the timing of that was worse for liquid, since they finished Diurna with like half or better of a raid day left

blazing aspen
#

we all knew echo would win, they always do. they played amazing and did almost every boss in less pulls. get rekt

tropic tangle
#

so Echo went to sleep, Liquid went against overtuned P1, but that's just how it goes sometimes

jagged pier
#

and echo also went to bed with the adds being nerfs by 50%

craggy pilot
#

Liquid have more pulls pr hour than echo, and always have

blazing aspen
#

obviously a better strat then

#

maybe liquid could learn a thing or two now that its over for next time who knows

craggy pilot
jagged pier
#

differences in how they play actually echo talk alot more liquid just pull pull pull

craggy pilot
#

Not everyone is wired the same

#

Liquid minmax downtime, echo talk about who/what fucked up between pulls

#

Why I feel echo is sometimes a bit toxic

#

Instant after wipe it's like "what did you fuck up x person"

jagged pier
#

thats not what they talk about at all

craggy pilot
#

But dunno if that's just normal mythic

#

Sometimes it does sound like that

jagged pier
#

they literally look at logs to see data like the first time they got into second intermission there was only noawh alive

#

they then spend an hour looking at logs at mob health looking at vods to see where the stun orbs were going

#

etc etc

#

literally spent that time making a strat for that phase they saw for 10 seconds maybe

craggy pilot
#

Belt works for arms/fury also

#

So i know what I'm making 😊

strong forum
#

Belt works yes

edgy grail
#

Crazy part is Echo did more splits and had 1 ilvl more

#

Started later and finished first 🫠

#

Masterloot has helped then a lot

#

They never had enough helpers before with high ilvl to tradr

#

Bc liquid paid more gold

craggy pilot
#

Do u have same ilvl belt/helmet?

#

Ye but i mean ur current

#

Or just give ring to fire mage 😂

#

And get auto attack ring + cobalt

#

Think Nome said it is bis currently, over 418 ilvl ring

hidden ether
#

So I have been a big fan of the high shockwave damage talents but most guides I see suggest thunderous roar and the increased bleed damage talent. Is this for single target damage? Or is it just higher output in general?

craggy pilot
#

For prot at least, dunno if it's the same when we are 420 overall

brisk sandal
#

guys i have a question on dathea heroic, during cyclone i yeet away from her ofc and when it ends I charge back in, but when i do i get melee'd by her insta. Is the tonk in this case losing aggro? I dont use any abilities, I charge in and boss melees me, Same happens when the add dies and to stay on platform I charge dathea albiet i delay a wee bit, and yeah in that spot i get melee'd also

craggy pilot
fast knot
#

Her ability seems to whack proximity

full venture
#

@hidden ether I don’t spec any extra talents into shockwave, I only use it for aoe interrupts

fast knot
#

Hence why I get an extra stack instead of my paladin offtank keksquad

#

or a dps gets absolutely blasted

hidden ether
craggy pilot
#

Roar is probably same if not more dmg

#

And u put mobs on stun cr

full venture
#

You get heals off roar bc of bleed too

lofty widget
#

if you shockwave every 25 sec every other stun is gonna be super DR'ed

hidden ether
#

Yeah pretty much shockwave each pack.

craggy pilot
#

More bleed more rage more rend dmg more deep wounds dmg

hidden ether
craggy pilot
#

But using shockwave for interrupt is miles better than using it for dmg

#

And then just roar for dmg

fast knot
#

Most of your meta comps are going to already have stun capability so DRing them is kind of a yikes

limpid anchor
#

Fire proc ring is a special case

hidden ether
craggy pilot
hidden ether
#

Also will probably notice more in higher keys only running 10’s right now so the bleed doesn’t have time vs the shockwave deleting half the low mobs

hidden ether
craggy pilot
hidden ether
#

Yeah gotta work my way up. Went from 360-380 IL this week so time to do real keys after Christmas

royal coral
#

Keep in mind 11 give you the mats for primal infusion, so even 1 lvl higher would be worth to upgrade crafted gear

slim dove
#

you mean after this shit week lol

hidden ether
hidden ether
#

Gib haste

#

Honestly what groups have you guys been using for pugs? My ideal is DH and lock right now. But not sure what 3rd. Normally a hunter for lust if I don’t get a lust healer

slim dove
#

ive given up on pugging this week entirely.

limpid anchor
#

A cr

slim dove
#

1500+ IO is all i look for

hidden ether
#

I’ve had 2 hunters tell me they “can’t lust”

sick sentinel
#

Mage , dh , warlock

slim dove
#

i pick 1-2 extra stops depending on the key and thats about it.

limpid anchor
hidden ether
#

DH’s be broken. I like evoker as healer

limpid anchor
#

Dh is a save pick bcs broken and easy to play

sick sentinel
slim dove
#

then say ????healer????

hidden ether
#

Broken, easy and has a lot of utility

slim dove
#

100% i will pick the 1600 IO ret/fury over the 800 IO havoc lol

hidden ether
#

Does IO still match keys, for example does a 1K mean finished all 10 keys and a 2K all 20 or no?

strong forum
#

All 20s is closer to 2.7k

sick sentinel
#

Im 2100 and my highest dung is 18

strong forum
#

All 15s is 2k

hidden ether
#

Ahh fair I’m use to 10 or 15 being the highest reward 20 is weird to me

loud patrol
#

gotta say, watching asmongold streams and seeing people being mad cuz hes tanking a dungeon without def stance makes me happy

sick sentinel
#

But still tree boss needs a nerf

strong forum
#

98% of twitch chatters are just bandwagoning

#

Complaining about things they have no idea about

loud patrol
#

true

#

is fun to see that

#

"war tank top dps in a cd cleave pull wtf"

jagged pier
#

took him 30% of the boss to press SB

#

that enough of that stream

slim dove
jade otter
#

you saw nothing

loud patrol
#

lol true but i dont watch him cuz hes a good player

#

but the fact that you "can" do that

#

makes me take m+ more relaxed

slim dove
#

21k st with lust

#

pressing block every minute or so

#

alright, stream closed.

strong forum
#

I mean that's just as much dmg as some people doing 18s are doing ye?

hidden ether
#

Which stance do you guys use? I go defense stance just because I don’t wanna wipe the group for my DPS

strong forum
#

When I watched jbs stream his pug tank did 20k st

lofty widget
#

what's good ST these days?

strong forum
#

And I'm like bruh, I do 35k

strong forum
hidden ether
loud patrol
#

30k meanwhile i do 20k ;_;

hidden ether
#

?

strong forum
#

For tank

slim dove
#

better have whetstone keks

loud patrol
#

and i spam SS

slim dove
#

and / or grieftorch

sick sentinel
#

About the SB how much uptime should it be in M+ ?

strong forum
#

100

quiet crane
#

100%

jagged pier
#

i do 35k without greiftorch or whetstone

hidden ether
#

99.99%

sick sentinel
#

Im 100% doin it wrong then

hidden ether
#

Can you link me a log? I wanna compare to mine

sick sentinel
#

I have 17%

#

Xd

loud patrol
strong forum
#

M+ or raid log

pulsar sedge
#

17% SB? Yeah.. you gotta fix something there

jagged pier
pulsar sedge
#

You are playing on hardmode fs

hidden ether
#

Mythic plus

strong forum
#

Have fun

sick sentinel
#

Bro im relaxin in 18s

#

This class is op

#

But i should focus SB more

slim dove
#

lmao 40k overall

#

christ nom chill out

loud patrol
#

jesus making his sham feel depressed

strong forum
#

With an actual weapon I'd do 50k 😦

slim dove
#

craft a 416 on tuesday

#

?

strong forum
#

Hell yeah

slim dove
#

giga pumper

#

382 to 416 Pepexecute

#

whats your fav healer to pug with btw @strong forum

sick sentinel
#

Is lariat a must to craft ?

loud patrol
#

huh now i notice nom

#

you spam tc way more than me

#

but WAY more

mortal brook
#

Nice to craft. Not gonna fail content not having it

loud patrol
#

using it on cd?

strong forum
sick sentinel
strong forum
#

Well yeah

lusty tiger
strong forum
#

You're taking like 60% extra dmg

#

Compared to an actual tank

sick sentinel
#

Fk it let them do their job and i go full revenge spam

lusty tiger
#

I wish

jagged pier
#

full revenge spam

#

monka

strong forum
#

Wait until you find out that SB increases your strongest button by 30%

jagged pier
sick sentinel
#

Shield slam ?

strong forum
#

Yea

sick sentinel
#

I only do big pulls okayge

strong forum
#

Uhuh sure

sick sentinel
#

Revenge TC

#

Ftw

#

Just kiddin thanks fro the info

#

Will try to make my SB 100%

lusty tiger
warm hill
#

how good is the ring from court for us? is the more autoattack dmgt good or is it just eh?

slim dove
#

with same secondary stats.

strong forum
#

Court ring is bis

strong forum
#

If your goal is max tank, that's a good one ye

lusty tiger
weary python
#

If we put illimited diamonds in our lariat, can it proc main stat?

slim dove
#

n o

hidden ether
#

I need to get my logs uploaded can’t Check to compare to yours. I’m normally doing like 12-20K ST but doing it in D stance. But there is more things I am doing wrong as well.

weary python
#

So is it worth putting illimited diamonds in there or just go with quick ysemeralds?

slim dove
#

haste/crit x2

weary python
#

Is the reasoning for that outlined anywhere?

hazy thicket
#

More total stats on the multi stat gems

#

Better stat economy

strong forum
#

^

#

More stats > "better" stats

#

It's that simple

weary python
#

And go haste/ crit instead of haste/ verse?

hazy thicket
#

That's down to what is your favourite

#

They're both swell

wet gate
#

what settings in raidbots do you use for simming prot? 5 target patchwerk 2 mins? or dungeon slice?

craggy pilot
#

17% sb uptime in 18+ must be troll 100%

dense coral
#

Do you ever WirlWind as tank or should I not put it as hot key.

craggy pilot
#

Would love to see that log though

craggy pilot
hidden ether
dense coral
#

Rend = auto from TC right

sick sentinel
#

revenge and shield slam literal replace those 2 abilities

#

due to how much shit is connected to revenge and ss

hidden ether
#

You should use rage on ignore pain or revenge. Assuming shield block is on CD

dense coral
#

Ok thanks!

hidden ether
#

Yea rend is auto up with a talent for TC

sick sentinel
#

if you come in here with a log and we find WW casts in it, we will probably post it here, and laugh

tulip kelp
#

Have you guys been spending your valor yet?

#

Or still waiting?

sick sentinel
#

used 800 on set shoulders, dunno how much i have now

fading tide
#

You guys like battering ram more then ravager?

craggy pilot
sick sentinel
tulip kelp
#

WOuld it be dumb to upgrade shield with vers/mastery on it? lol

sick sentinel
craggy pilot
sick sentinel
#

this is what im running for dungeon

craggy pilot
grave heart
#

i think storm bolt is worth the trade off for sidearm, especially when pugging

craggy pilot
sick sentinel
#

i don't like side arm OR titanic throw

#

i had 1 bad experience with TT and that was it

#

it pulled boss leveling dwarf warrior in WCM fat man boss, we wiped, immediately took the talent off

#

i can see the use, but im not crazy about it

craggy pilot
#

Sidearm did that?

fading tide
sick sentinel
#

it was TT

#

i used TT to pull that room, and it pulled the boss

craggy pilot
#

Don't think sidearm can ever pull anything

sick sentinel
#

so i said fuck this , never looked back, never fucked with spell block.... at all....

craggy pilot
sick sentinel
#

cuz its a 2 minutes CD, so, i'd have to plan it out

#

i asked blizzard for spell block, said i don't care what kind, regerts now 90s cd, thats a bit better than i though

fading tide
#

Fear is good for m+? It doesn’t cause chaos with the mobs running everywhere?

craggy pilot
#

It is broken insta

sick sentinel
#

i like it personally, but i know its bad, so i don't use it

fading tide
#

I’ve been using thunder lord and into the Frey but I guess that was wrong

weary python
#

So earlier it was noted that the CoS ring is BIS. That across raid as well? i.e. if I have it, it's worth dumping valor into or hold off on doing that for now?

craggy pilot
#

Thunderlord is ok, but not too impactful, battering ram or battle scared vet is better in most situations, whether you need dmg or tankiness

sick sentinel
#

i say ITF is better, because, if you play well, you can get equal SB uptime to that talent, probably

#

im using HR for some reason tho

fading tide
#

Thank you both for you help gonna see how these different talents play in a m+

tulip kelp
craggy pilot
#

But rly depends on if you're gonna craft a shield or not

tulip kelp
#

I have an average shield and average wep from m+ both 392

#

Strike Twice and Drake Rider's Steckarge

#

Thinking I could upgrade shield to 411 now and then craft wep next week with spark

craggy pilot
#

Strike twice is not avg 😂

tulip kelp
#

Is it not? lol

#

Tons of mastery as well haha

craggy pilot
#

It's the best dungeon wep currently

weary python
#

So is the damaging cobalt ring better to get than the shield one?

craggy pilot
#

The dmg ring is huge

weary python
#

Is it?

tulip kelp
craggy pilot
#

Might be equals idk, you can sim them

#

Strike twice has same stat budget + the extra effect

weary python
#

And if I have the CoS ring(apparently BiS?) at 389, is it worth dumping valor into it? Or should valor be best saved/ spent elsewhere?

craggy pilot
#

I think only ring to maybe compete with cobalt ring and cos ring is the flame ring from raid, if you have flame belt, but not sure how close it is

tulip kelp
#

Cobalt ring is 389 tho right? Any 411+ ring would surely be better?

craggy pilot
#

No

tulip kelp
#

For real?

craggy pilot
#

The dmg is insane

tulip kelp
#

Damn, I was trying not to farm rep

craggy pilot
#

You'll be fine without it tho

#

Like its not the end of the world

pallid quiver
#

Strike Twice extra effect procs like once a minute iirc

#

It's something abysmally low

tulip kelp
#

Yeah proc is pretty garbo

urban portal
#

the proc is just free

craggy pilot
#

Ye ok, saw someone had overall dmg where it did like 0,5% dmg

pallid quiver
#

actually it might be once every two mins

It is free, though, on top of the budget iirc

craggy pilot
#

But still free dmg + full stat budget

urban portal
#

it says 3ppm on wowhead

craggy pilot
#

All in all comes down to how much % it adds

urban portal
craggy pilot
#
  • haste
tulip kelp
#

Difference is shield is like less then half the price of upgrade when it comes to valor

craggy pilot
#

And if u run battering ram, u have 20% attack speed on like 40% uptime

tulip kelp
#

So I think I'll upgrade my shield and then craft wep next week

urban portal
#

but yea

craggy pilot
urban portal
#

almost no procs in this game do

craggy pilot
#

Was hoping I could do huge AA build with battering + ring + strike twice 😂

urban portal
#

anything that is a borrowed power dont work with attack speed

#

hypothetically

sick sentinel
#

is this the closet taxi to HOV?

north dew
#

Hey Guys

#

one question

#

does anyone have a problem jadeserpent 2. Boss?

sick sentinel
#

nvm this ones pretty close

north dew
#

+16

#

the tank damage is insane. we switch the bosses at 6 Stacks but i get 150k+ tick dmg all the time

#

every 2 seconds. Any ideas?

cinder storm
#

Are you dropping strife?

strong forum
#

Stand on the far side

#

Not between the bosses

mellow quartz
#

How quickly did the stacks drop from the one you swapped away from?

strong forum
#

Make sure TC only hits 1 at a time

north dew
#

yes we stack on left side and then switch all complete to right side

mellow quartz
#

Sounds like people kept hitting it

#

If the whole group swaps it should drop stacks inside 1-2 seconds

north dew
#

its normal that the debuff stack up to 10 or more stacks on me`?

#

the stack should get removed if we switch sides right? but it doesnt work

warm plinth
#

Everyone has to switch and not have random shit hitting the other

#

Some shit that shouldn't count will trigger it too like frozen orb

deft socket
#

Sophic Writ or Frozen enchant?

oblique quarry
#

is shield of the hearth worth using? I got the pattern and can craft it

warm plinth
#

Stats

cinder storm
chilly brook
#

So fucking annoying

north dew
#

Thanks. Than i think someone cleave all the time

digital frigate
#

It sucks sometimes to pug keys because people with 400 or 300 points more queue together and eat up all the 16-17 keys ):

digital frigate
#

Ah I have pushed my key and still do. I am just making a comment about it.

craggy pilot
#

Pugging always has this weird feeling where low keys are much harder than high keys, because different people join

#

Did a 16 and it felt many times easier than a 14 i did in same dungeon, just because of more dmg, more healing, more interrupts

digital frigate
#

I do a few 16's now

#

I think highest is 18

#

but if a group of players with my rio join or if one person in that group has 200-300 more than me

#

I will get kicked

#

I am just expressing it's a bit of a pain to deal with.

craggy pilot
#

You can't get kicked from your own key

digital frigate
#

Yes but I mean when I am joining others.

#

Sometimes I have bad key, want to reroll.

#

Like I will not do over +17 on Algathar

#

I have this now

#

I want to reroll and still farm

#

A bit of pain

loud patrol
#

im scared of going up from a 13 :D

#

i just had 2 tunnel vision hunters

craggy pilot
loud patrol
#

im scared

craggy pilot
#

It becomes easier when you invite giga pumpers

#

The push from 14 to 16 is hard, but when you get to the 16 it will be easy

loud patrol
#

but how! i see some guys having cleared a +16 something then they are the cause i cant time a 10

craggy pilot
#

Some people get boosted

#

Have to check how many keys they timed, and if they timed a similar dungeon

#

Like doing a +16 shadow moon doesn't mean shit in +10 rlp

loud patrol
#

gonna start having warcraft logs open when i get people

craggy pilot
dusky sentinel
#

Hey folks! Is Static-charged scale trinket any good or just fake news?

silver patrol
#

Hey all, super new to prot warrior, it seems like there isn’t a lot of buttons to press in single target, so I still just spam revenge to offensively spend rage in single target outside of execute phase?

silver patrol
#

@craggy pilot Ty sir

dusky sentinel
#

One of the biggest burners in ST is pressing thunderclap instead of SS on outburst

craggy pilot
#

Ss is huge damage in st

sweet summit
#

Ss is huge damage in st 😎

grizzled current
#

How to Tank Ruby Last Boss?

craggy pilot
tender cove
#

Merry Christmas to everyone ❤️

ocean bloom
grizzled current
#

Ty

sweet summit
#

plka owns

ocean bloom
#

oh shit i need that

grizzled current
#

Can healer dispell debuff?

craggy pilot
#

Damn that's huge

#

So start on left, and go counter clockwise

#

And gg

sweet summit
#

focus dragon p1
lust p2
p3 is free

craggy pilot
#

What is p2? When he sits on dragon?

sweet summit
#

ya

nova rover
#

because Im just noticing now... did prot lose berzerker rage?

sweet summit
#

it's a talent

#

class tree top left

dreamy sail
#

where can i find info on what embellishments to put on my gear?

slim dove
#

pins.

dreamy sail
#

i looked thru and didnt see them

nova rover
#

Thank you

dreamy sail
#

oh

#

i see

nova rover
compact jackal
#

Is there a way to toss crafted items in gear compare with embellishments? All I can think of as a workaround is using strike twice to compensate for fang adornment.

sweet summit
#

a lot of them are in droptimizer

#

but uhhh

royal coral
#

i couldnt find emblishments

sweet summit
#

not all

#

think this is your best bet

glass spear
#

how to do guys deal with the poison dot from the lashers from the tree boss in academy?

glass spear
#

I've been trying to use decoration of flame for one and SW for the other but it's still rough

edgy grail
#

Doesnt the healing add clear it?

plush briar
#

It does the bleed I believe haven’t noticed if it does the poison too

glass spear
fading tide
#

Anything to watch out for in HoB this week?

#

HoV

compact jackal
fast knot
#

Dps that don't stack on you with Fenryr

compact jackal
#

that was perfect for getting fang though, ty

#

being lazy and comparing 405 lariat, 405 belt, 405 weapon while having a 402 weapon, 392 neck, and 398 belt.

#

if I'm right, lariat should be the worst option

sweet summit
#

the lightning phase thingy kinda fucks

#

fenryr can be rough if you can't skip the jumps

#

rest should be fine

sweet summit
copper talon
#

Guys I’m 392ilvl and tried RLP 13 and I got smashed. 3.5k haste, 2k vers. Any opinions?

fast knot
#

second boss pipes

sweet summit
copper talon
#

Prayer?

compact jackal
#

Yes.

fast knot
#

to the point of going like full turtle with spell block and double wall talent

oak echo
#

Stats won't make the difference and geared enough for it so need logs

compact jackal
#

RLP 13 is like

#

140k/s in dots?

fast knot
#

I'm about that item level and unless you have blaster dps you run out of coolies fast

sweet summit
compact jackal
#

the dot from the add + boss

#

14 was something like 60K+90k

copper talon
#

I was getting nuked

sweet summit
#

last boss or what

copper talon
#

Lemme see if i can send a log

compact jackal
#

2nd

fast knot
#

no bleed dispel sadge

sweet summit
#

you have wall for every other smacky

#

and demo/sr for every one