#protection

1 messages ยท Page 217 of 1

ionic fern
#

You can run past them all.

jagged pier
#

well its easier to see shockwave damage than the other damage TR gives u

#

but ๐Ÿคท

limpid anchor
#

You kinda have to if you want to skip sentinels

#

Unless you do bulls as well

jade panther
#

anyway was just popping SW getting some aggro up then kitting them after getting midhealth

ionic fern
#

I always do bulls.

#

Also..is it me or does the beer not work in HoV anymore?

sick sentinel
#

i had figured this would be an okay way to pull speaking of hov wolves

jade panther
#

bulls feel pretty good, only my rogue complains^^

ionic fern
#

Throw it on the middle pack..walk past..they still aggro to you later.

limpid anchor
ionic fern
pulsar sedge
#

Kite them?

limpid anchor
#

Bears are fine, bulls are too much for me

sick sentinel
#

my key is a 7 but, im very confused how your supposed to get bears bottom right and i saw other peoples routes that were similiar, not inlcuding top orange wolves (2 of them)

pulsar sedge
#

Just smack the bulls and walk away from the stomp

limpid anchor
#

But I also run with a meele comp, they canโ€™t do dps during bulls

pulsar sedge
#

Use Shockwave

#

Use stops.

sick sentinel
#

i dont know if all the mobs in the section are yellow dont attack

uneven mason
#

That shockwave build is pretty chonky

sick sentinel
#

but its confusing me how youd get the bears and not everything else

ionic fern
#

.....

pulsar sedge
#

It promotes bad game play tho... using a stop for dmg on cd is bad

sick sentinel
#

i skipped literally all of legion as well

#

many, many gaps in my knowledge

jade panther
#

so 8 worlves

uneven mason
jade panther
#

then kiting them

#

coz i got hunt and rogue

#

but melee pugs get killed^^

uneven mason
jade panther
#

xd

pulsar sedge
#

Using Shockwave for interrupts or stops is good ๐Ÿ˜‰ but using it on that Shockwave dmg build is meh

limpid anchor
#

Shockwave is cool tho

mossy gulch
#

can someone teach me how to use raidbots to sim my prot warrior? ๐Ÿ™‚ i have only ever simmed dps chars and that was 2 expansions ago ๐Ÿ˜ฆ

#

i could use some pointers

limpid anchor
#

Same@as dps

sick sentinel
#

what is it that the wolves do that is going to make them unpullable

edgy spear
#

Raidbots is only useable for dps

uneven mason
limpid anchor
#

Also, they can oneshot you as well

jade panther
#

aight to my questions, is there like a "perfect timing for Spell reflect" ? i tried it on mini hyrja and got one tapped (popped it like 2 sec before frontal hit)

pulsar sedge
#

And make mobs immune to cc? Sure... you do that

mossy gulch
#

how do you sim your defensive performance in order to get reasonable upgrades?

edgy spear
ionic fern
ionic fern
mossy gulch
#

i am looking to get an overview of my best options to upgrade my gear. basically i want to know what m+ to spam for upgrades.

edgy spear
#

Just target ilvl

ionic fern
#

You can only sim for DPS, not for defensive.

jade panther
edgy spear
#

All secondaries give some form of defensive value but ilvl is more secondaries, and importantly, more armor/str/stam

uneven mason
mossy gulch
#

okay ๐Ÿ™‚

limpid anchor
jade panther
#

yes

#

melee range

#

if u stand over 7 yards 0 risks

#

if melee are behind the pack

lilac jay
#

Hi Guys. I sometimes struggle to get aggro vs. 1 Monk in my Grp. But i cant only dps in high keys after Charge -> TC no? i need to use defensives? or how is it done? is it the monks fault for not waiting 2 seconds?

strong forum
#

no reason to tank that hit

jade panther
#

iknow

#

wanted to try for hyrja

slim dove
#

It's also not reflectable

jade panther
#

yes just saw that

strong forum
#

hyrja you just need to layer defensives

primal hound
slim dove
#

On low keys I chase my dh friend around with it keks

jade panther
#

yep got one tapped in 16 coz i didnt SW after SB and SR and my healer was like 'VRANK ?'

primal hound
pulsar sedge
#

She leaps. You charge to her a d spin her away from group. Then sidestep the stabby stab

#

And*

primal hound
#

Is BrV still buggy?

edgy spear
jade panther
#

other quick question, i struggle with my Shield block uptime. Should i SC on pulls when it's up for safety as i'm going into higher keys ?

strong forum
#

play HR

jade panther
slim dove
#

I literally SC on CD.

strong forum
#

and youll never have to struggle with SB uptime

sick sentinel
#

see, like, i don't mind to do this pulling, but im not sure the pathing i use to do so like from what direction pulled to where type of thing

strong forum
#

and yeah SC on CD

slim dove
#

Just tryna PUMP

edgy spear
slim dove
#

Can't let dps get that #1 overall

fluid shard
#

man i really want to get battering ram in, is Thunderlord the only viable swap? (M+)

ionic fern
primal hound
jade panther
edgy spear
#

Is the dragon good count? Been trying to skip it the last few runs

strong forum
#

dragon is shit

pulsar sedge
#

Hard to skip tho

sick sentinel
#

dragon is listed at 2.96%

edgy spear
#

nah its easy

#

stand still, one guy runs forward 5 yards to activate it then back

urban bane
#

For AA tree boss, when do the small adds actually respond to threat? I keep having issues where one or two stray adds melee a player and just absolutely dome them. Is it at the end of the uproot spell or w/e it is called?

edgy spear
#

and then you just run right around it

pulsar sedge
#

Your pugs will ass pull it 99% of the time going in or out

edgy spear
#

Only been doing it with friends/guild

pulsar sedge
#

Pugged all but CoS on 11s so far... and I do almost 0 skips or fancy shit. Pugs are dumb ๐Ÿ˜‰

jade panther
#

allright, other question, i can overcap on IP right ? so should i dump rage into it during pulls or try to manage it and only it it when IP going down ?

pulsar sedge
#

Makes life easy when all I need them to do is press w and kill shit I pull

ionic fern
sick sentinel
pulsar sedge
#

Use aoe taunt on first add wave. Roar on second. You should be fine on threat then

sick sentinel
#

aoe "phase 1" the plant adds, single target/interupt "phase 2" with the healing tree

urban bane
#

Yeah it literally is just one or two which may have spawned out of range or whatever. bleh.

sick sentinel
#

if the group spreads the adds everywhere, its total GG

#

thats like literal his win condition

idle summit
#

Morning, new in this prot tank thing. I wanted to know which stats should I look

pulsar sedge
#

Just pump ilvl.

#

A +10 Ilvl increase is better than losing a specific stat

sick sentinel
#

bull says it does 273k dmg

#

you sure i want to pull them lol

idle summit
pulsar sedge
#

Just kite the bull...and cc it

slim dove
oblique garnet
sick sentinel
strong forum
oblique garnet
#

Do tell

#

It just insta aggroes as soon as you go without shroud

strong forum
#

just dont walk forward when you enter

#

no it doesnt

#

stand still

oblique garnet
#

Yes

#

it does

strong forum
#

go to the right

#

bro i can show you on video

#

u sure?

oblique garnet
#

Show

limpid anchor
#

It doesnโ€™t pull

#

Only if you move

#

Unless you identify as a stag

strong forum
oblique garnet
strong forum
#

just dont walk forward

#

๐Ÿ˜„

oblique garnet
#

I knew that it doesnt aggro if you go right but thought you couldnt get past without killing it

sick sentinel
#

that looks like that will be a standard skip once us normal players learn how it works

strong forum
#

ye

#

once more people know about it

severe hatch
#

So the AA Tree boss... felt an absolutely monumental difference between 12 and 13. On the 13 we are stacking to cluster add spawns, chaining AoE stops as much as possible, popping all CDs + BL, and wiping with a solid 290k group dps

#

On 12, easy walk through the park, +2 the key np

strong forum
#

kill the ancient branch (healing add) insta

severe hatch
#

We did to clear stacks

strong forum
#

and then coordinate CDs

severe hatch
#

Still ripperoni

strong forum
#

using it to clear stacks is bad

#

cuz youre likely to kill the healing add when small adds are up

#

and youll end up topping those adds

severe hatch
#

So do I not go for the circle and just kite?

strong forum
#

if the adds are low HP, yes get them out of the circle

#

if you check here

#

thats how we did it with 5 tanks

sick sentinel
#

thats why im heavily advocating for the stack on tree boss AA, everything is all together you can kill them before the branch comes out possibly and then its much easier to kill before it can do some BS

severe hatch
#

I'll give it a watch when I'm back home, appreciate it

strong forum
#

and you do the exact same in normal comps

#

we just have less dmg to burn adds and boss so its takes a bit more coordination

lucid pasture
#

Still fried

#

I mean

inland raft
#

A bit off topoc but how are hpals this season? I have a pally one trick friend thinking of coming back to game

balmy gate
strong forum
#

its the m+ timer weakaura from reloe

#

i just modified the looks of it a bit

regal pier
#

So I know right now stats are hard to come by, but with haste being so important for Prot is taking Into the Fray better or heavy repercussions?

strong forum
#

ITF gets better the more haste you have

#

i myself permanently play HR cuz ive died more than once due to gaps of SB because of ITF

#

CBA that struggle just to do 7% more aoe dmg

limpid anchor
#

Mobs hit too hard for gaps :(

#

But why does itf scale better the more haste you have? My brain is too small

strong forum
#

cuz the more haste you have, the lower your SB CD

regal pier
#

I think I have like 3400 haste but without ITF I feel like I canโ€™t keep up ignore pain along with shield block due to rage issues

strong forum
#

if you have low haste, ITF will not be enough to cover your gaps

#

and its a % modifier

strong forum
#

are you by chance playing barbaric training?

regal pier
#

Yes I am

strong forum
#

cuz that shit will rage starve you real quick

#

yeah stop playing that

regal pier
#

God damn youโ€™re a wizard

hazy bronze
#

RIP bloodsurge

strong forum
#

all your rage starvation will be lifted

#

if you stop playing that

regal pier
#

No that perhaps changed my entire gameplay right there

strong forum
#

yeah it will

edgy grail
#

16 TOJS was spicyyyy

inland raft
#

Youll have so much rage without it

regal pier
#

There are points in a fight where I canโ€™t keep up ignore or sb because thereโ€™s no rage

edgy grail
#

I guess my only option is to kite the last pack ๐Ÿ˜”

inland raft
#

Once we have a lot of haste will itf become standard?

strong forum
#

if you have around 35% haste before ITF

#

youll be fine to play it in keys

regal pier
#

Nomer what do you put points into instead?

strong forum
#

without much SB downtime

#

i play this

#

instead of pain and gain you can get titanic throw

#

for super easy time on leashing packs

inland raft
#

Thats what i do, i love titanic for gathering

strong forum
#

and playing battering ram will also help you alot with rage gen

#

and gives you alot more dmg in ST/low target count

stone condor
#

the trinket from kurog is it any good for def tanks ?

strong forum
#

all totem?

stone condor
#

yes

strong forum
#

suuper good in m+

regal pier
#

Thatโ€™s fantastic

strong forum
#

bad in raid unless you tank alot of adds

stone condor
#

perfekt

#

thanks guys

edgy grail
#

I got the crit trinket from SBG and it sims pretty shit

#

Is it that bad?

regal pier
#

Do you hold shield charge for important interupts? Or because it does so much damage you use it on cd?

strong forum
#

CDs on CD

sick sentinel
#

im considering attempting to go to some raid tonight

edgy grail
#

398 Sims only like 500 dps higher than 373

strong forum
#

500dps is a considerable amount

#

for a trinket

edgy grail
#

2% for 25 ilvl?

strong forum
#

toe is a good send and forget trinket

#

yeah?

#

thats normal lol

#

its 1 item

edgy grail
#

Yea I guess I was just comparing it to the gain on fury

#

And itโ€™s ridic there

#

Like 7-8%?

high drum
#

you need to spec non-prot loot for toe right

#

i was wondering why i didnt get it in 10 runs ๐Ÿ˜”

edgy grail
#

Think so yea

#

I have a shield already that I crafted

balmy gate
edgy grail
#

So Iโ€™m always either in fury spec or arms spec depending on if the dungeon has 1H or not

strong forum
#

bloodborne is garbage for dmg

balmy gate
#

what does your overall damage distribution look like?

high drum
#

single or multi

#

tclap and revenge high in dun duns otherwise shield slam is king

strong forum
#

CoS+18

high drum
#

higher key less mobs per pull i guess, and cos aint exactly aoe central

strong forum
#

AA+16

balmy gate
#

is slicing maelstrom the cos trinket?

strong forum
#

ye

high drum
#

yes

balmy gate
#

seems juicy

high drum
#

trash for raid

#

great for m+

strong forum
#

5min 5 targets

#

Bloodborne is less dmg than battering ram

edgy grail
#

Is dslice any good for prot?

strong forum
#

wouldnt trust it

balmy gate
#

fair enough, just asked since I saw a few people running it when looking at the top m+ runs atm

strong forum
#

yeah cuz theyre baited into it

#

like many others

spark cedar
strong forum
#

phial

sick sentinel
#

am i just stupid or did you remove the video where you were showing how to skip the dragon

strong forum
#

no i didnt remove it

#

its on twitch

#

not on youtube

sick sentinel
#

was going to watch to try to see how you pulled rest of that room

strong forum
#

bloodborne at first glance looks good, but if you crunch some numbers and weigh your options, its a huge bait talent

#

it gets better the worse you are at dealing damage

balmy gate
#

do you not miss thunderlord with that build btw or do you just use it once every pull?

strong forum
#

TL desyncs CDs from demo shout

edgy grail
#

What is a decent passive trinket for prot? They all seem omega garbage

strong forum
#

rumbling ruby, all-totem, trample from nokhud

ornate thunder
#

Is scale any good?

strong forum
#

turtle shell obv strong

#

i dont like scale tbh

#

1ppm on a 60k absorb?

#

pretty whack

balmy gate
#

how is the nokhud trinket for damage?

high drum
#

not terrible imo, but its main upside is the hps

#

oh nvm u mean the centaur

#

its ok single

edgy grail
#

What is the full name for the turtle shell sorry?

#

Cant find it on wowhead

balmy gate
ivory cairn
#

lariat + 1h is solid right? I want to start crafting <.<

high drum
#

primal ritual shell

edgy grail
#

Is that like the workd quest one?

#

Ahh from rares

#

Oooff

balmy gate
inland raft
#

Isnt shell from doing key farm?

high drum
#

i made a food ring and its great

#

๐Ÿคค

ornate thunder
#

I can't decide if I wannt be cheap or get more dmg

edgy grail
#

You can do both

ornate thunder
#

seems like people are all just cheap

edgy grail
#

There is a guy in Tichondrius crafting lariat for free ๐Ÿ˜‚

deft pagoda
#

What's the best thing to craft outside of Lariat ?

edgy grail
#

Shield Weap

#

He was charging 5k until he made back the 9m from the pattern

hasty echo
#

I probably miss something at a certain point... arent' we going for haste versa? why we are crafting/enchanting crit?

ornate thunder
#

wouldn't you want potion extension and barbs

#

rather than food for pure dmg

edgy grail
#

Now he is crafting for free to screw over the people charging 50k each

inland raft
#

We already tanky enough

edgy grail
#

I mean def not ๐Ÿ˜‚

#

Most people are prob like 390 ilvl

#

And it still gets spicy in keys at that ilvl

sweet summit
#

not rly

high drum
#

just parry lol

ornate thunder
#

outside temple does anyone take dmg in a dungeon, lol

slim dove
#

Nah most are 375-385 judging by the dps that sign up for my groups

tacit widget
#

Hay guys, wich gems should i socket into my Lariat?

sweet summit
#

i haven't done all keys, but the ones i've done at like 18 have not been bad
if i die it's because i fucked up

inland raft
#

Im 379 and have yet to feel like im in pain outside temple and last boss rbl when healer misses a dispel and take a suped up tank buster

high drum
#

usually ur grp is dead long before you are

hasty echo
#

i'm actually 386 in m+ what my group is missing are interrupts/stuns XD

#

and yes, if I die i probably fucked up something

tropic sundial
#

Is this trinket any good?

high drum
#

no

hasty echo
#

most of the time ppl die and i'll stay still tanking waiting them to come back

ivory cairn
#

what about the whelp? got a 385

lilac delta
inland raft
#

Ya 99% if die its cuz I royally fucked up like standing in a stun or something brain dead

hasty echo
high drum
#

thundering makes me want intervene

plush tendon
#

you can still take it without losing too much

strong forum
idle inlet
#

intervene is made for thundering affix

high drum
#

i feel like most of the time its okay because either a melee clears with you or everyone but you clears

edgy grail
#

Intervene is insane on last boss temple

high drum
#

but the times when its a ranged who just chills forever it would be so nice

edgy grail
#

Shit trucks your teammates while you just afk

past parrot
#

Any advice or tips on surviving 4-5 stacks of the Zephyr Slam on heroic? Finding I am getting yetted off the platform or getting a big one shot at 5 stacks

high drum
#

tank swap no?

plush tendon
#

or leap

past parrot
sick sentinel
#

am i supposed to walk like this do white line after the boss for towards pull 22 and out the door?

#

if im doing dragon route, with bears, i guess? this is pka pug route anyway

solar blade
#

yes

limpid anchor
#

Depends if you want to skip sentinels tho

solar blade
#

i use the plka route

shadow sun
#

What are you guys using to keep track of the other tanks debuffs during raids?

sick sentinel
#

okay i'll attempt this 7 halls key soon after reset

#

just want to run 2 keys today for second reward so long as they aren't hell to run

limpid anchor
lyric elm
#

try to get good dps players for halls, they make or break it

#

timer tight

plush tendon
#

wait, you guys aren't just rerolling and doing only Shadowmoon?

edgy grail
#

We pull everything up to the dragon and lust

inland raft
#

Havnt even done shadowmoon yet, is it the easiest one?

edgy grail
#

Saves us about a minute

sick sentinel
#

what are we dropping for intervene

sick sentinel
#

m+ dungeon build

limpid anchor
#

Smb is such a joke

edgy grail
#

Depends on group if Im playing with my normal group

#

I drop storm bolt

#

But we play dh rogue ww

#

So infinite stuns already

sick sentinel
#

id want to drop intimidating shout or bolt probably

plush tendon
#

SMB is soo good

edgy grail
#

Is it good?

plush tendon
#

we keep getting 15s of that, then doing whatever 17 or 16 we get

edgy grail
#

Or just easy lol

sonic wadi
#

its a cozy dungeon too

sick sentinel
#

super mario brothers? hell yeah, thats a great game

plush tendon
#

^

#

super cozy

#

better then RLP

sonic wadi
#

only the mind control mob pulls are annoying everything else is nice

edgy grail
#

Itโ€™s Zzzzzz

plush tendon
#

where's everyone asshole is just getting hammered

tepid coral
plush tendon
#

^

#

tech

sick sentinel
#

SMBg a bit reminds me of lvl 2 super mario

lyric elm
#

the dominators?

tepid coral
#

y

lyric elm
#

pro

edgy grail
#

Yea no cc on those

sonic wadi
sick sentinel
#

under the ground in a cave dark and whatever

edgy grail
#

They get 100% more health but still easy

tepid coral
#

say before you pull em

plush tendon
#

My other favorite is Academy

craggy pilot
#

@strong forum u said you dont run Thunderlord, do you also skip out on BV? ๐Ÿค”

lucid pasture
#

My favorite is turned off pc

#

Or delete the game as I would usually say

edgy grail
#

I like temple besides the last pack lol

plush tendon
edgy grail
#

That needs work

plush tendon
#

Temple is meh to me

#

not scary for tank

lucid pasture
#

I tanked Temple 2nd Last boss as fury once

#

Kinda pog

plush tendon
#

but everyones got to be on point

#

or they die

craggy pilot
sick sentinel
#

i cant remember what nomer was railing on about, but something about " FBV, BV or BSV doesn't work"

lyric elm
#

temple is good because you'll be able to determine if the group is good or not on the first boss

edgy grail
#

Its easy to carry temple as tank

#

Just call all kicks

lucid pasture
#

Because Wash away is glitchy asf

plush tendon
lyric elm
#

ok buddy

lucid pasture
#

That shit does not work correctky

lyric elm
sick sentinel
#

i want to say its that the IP one wasn't working correctly or the bleed one, but not real sure

lucid pasture
lyric elm
craggy pilot
#

if i have a 14 key, and i time someone else 14 key, can i rotate my key? or do i have to time a 15 to rotate it?

plush tendon
#

you can rotate on equal or higher key level

#

thats what we do; keep changing 15s to avoid the shit dungeons like RLP

safe tundra
#

Anything I seem to be missing regarding stat weights? Looks pretty mixed between haste/vers haste/mast on the Lariate neck, also seems to be a fair number of m+ wars not even crafting neck

edgy grail
#

Ive never had a problem with the water even before they โ€œfixedโ€ it

#

Maybe Im just lucky

#

I have over 10 runs there this week

plush tendon
#

Or you can haste crit

plush tendon
#

or haste vers

#

just have haste

edgy grail
#

The reality is

#

It doesnโ€™t matter

#

Thatโ€™s why everyone has different shit

uneven mason
#

Haste Crit is pumpers

#

Haste vers is ok

sick sentinel
#

imagine a veto system for keystones, you just select the key you don't want to get, for that week and it turns into a 1% chance to turn into that key instead of higher normal value, pay 5000 gold to activate the feature each week

plush tendon
#

Haste Crit is for chads, Haste Vers is for people who follow the guide, and Haste Mastery for fury guys

uneven mason
#

Haste mastery if you want to use the same gear for fury

severe steeple
#

i can log in with my friends on CSGO and we can play whatever map we want as much as we like

#

but on wow....

edgy grail
#

You canโ€™t do that in COD ๐Ÿ‘€

uneven mason
#

Part of the challenge is the random keys

edgy grail
#

Yep

#

What I want to see is keystones not depleting

sick sentinel
#

going even further back to 1993 doom, not only are you able to code in and make custom levels and monsters and share them online and play others mods, but you are even like, encouraged to do so by the people that orginally made it

plush tendon
#

If keystones didnt deplete on us putting them in, we would see a lot higher key pushing

edgy grail
#

I think that isnโ€™t really needed

#

Yes and what is wrong with that?

plush tendon
#

nothing

sick sentinel
#

there are still tons and tons of doom wads being made and played

plush tendon
#

just a observation

inland raft
#

Diablo rift system on a per dungeon basis, can always enter highest unlocked in a dungeon

plush tendon
#

Maybe takes a bit of the pressure away when you got that big key

#

and you got one shot

edgy grail
#

๐Ÿซ 

plush tendon
#

but I wouldnt mind it

sick sentinel
#

my view on depleting is that should be when you are 5 to 10 minutes over the key, but it only ever depletes 1 time,

#

you cant just make it go from 20 to a 3

plush tendon
#

would allow for some very good progression stuff in keys

#

and practice

edgy grail
#

The practice part is what I like

plush tendon
#

but it might get degenerate

#

Could always just have practice mode?

edgy grail
#

Right now we sign up for TR just so we can practice over and over

severe steeple
sick sentinel
#

i think if you are within 5 minutes of completing a keystone, it should stay at that level and change to another dungeon

ionic roost
plush tendon
heavy hawk
#

Question: Do we take the strenght+haste epic gem or just ignore that and go for pure haste?

uneven mason
#

STR is nice

craggy pilot
#

str > secondary stat

uneven mason
#

STR is armor

plush tendon
#

everyone should pretty much use the epic gem

uneven mason
#

STR is damage

plush tendon
#

its really strong, but it is expensive right now

severe steeple
#

if you could chose what key you play you could get all the practice you want
when you go over the same thing again it clicks, like raid fights
when you make a mistake on dungeon A you can't go again straight cause you need a keystone
you might need to go through 4-5 dungs until you can do that part again and try to make it right

plush tendon
#

It would be interesting

#

Depends if you want that extra pressure of only one chance or the ability to reset and redo until you get it

edgy grail
#

I think it would shorten the play time of the season maybe

uneven mason
#

It would

plush tendon
#

I think people would have done much higher keys this first week

sick sentinel
#

i think if there is a major malfunction in the group in the first 3 minutes you should get a vote option to muilligan and restart or disband with no penalty

plush tendon
#

if you could just recycle over and over again

severe steeple
#

also choosing what key you play would lower toxicity, at least a tiny bit

sick sentinel
#

is another alternitave to vetoing keys

plush tendon
#

I dont like the option to choose keys; I think being forced in some way to do every dungeon is fine

tawdry lynx
#

Both myself and another dude in my guild are both brand new to tanking this expansion. We're doing pretty fine mechanically speaking but I'm having an issue of pulling aggro from him after taunt swaps, occasionally resulting in fucked tank swaps that lead to wipes.

On kills I'm putting in 90% or above damage parses to his ~60%. Is there something we're missing here or is it just a damage discrepancy?

limpid anchor
plush tendon
#

and the reroll option is pretty good compromise

plush tendon
#

help him do more damage

tawdry lynx
#

ya just backing of DPS seems stupid but i guess ill have tto

sick sentinel
#

keystone can be inserted to dungeon A or B could be cool as well.

plush tendon
#

What is he playing?

tawdry lynx
#

Blood DK

plush tendon
#

and are you about evenly geared?

limpid anchor
#

Check logs with him

tawdry lynx
#

I'm about 4 ilvl higher

#

Will do thanks for the feedback

limpid anchor
#

But gimping yourself and the raid dmg seems like a bandaid solution

#

To adjust to a shitty player

plush tendon
#

You do what you need to do to kill a boss though

limpid anchor
#

Instead of permanently fixing the issue

plush tendon
#

at least, in the moment

tawdry lynx
#

Can't really adjust my DPS because we're already carrying other poor souls lol

limpid anchor
#

Ye temporary you can do that

plush tendon
#

Also, hes a DK, so if he loses threat a quick death grip retaunts

tawdry lynx
#

good to know

sick sentinel
#

is there a reset for NA soon?

#

i want to wait on that first if its not gon e out

limpid anchor
#

Does grip count as taunt - for taunt immunity?

sick sentinel
#

yes

#

deathgrip is 100% a taunt as well

limpid anchor
#

So even if he does that

#

You might have issues taunting back

noble lynx
#

taunt dr falls off fast

#

end its 3 taunts

limpid anchor
#

Idk we had the issue that I couldnโ€™t taunt once or twice yesterday

#

As I pulled aggro and co tank had to retaunt

plush tendon
#

We are playing double prot war

#

no aggro issues over here

dusky canopy
#

When Iโ€™m doing 20k plus and the DK is doing 8k

plush tendon
#

DK is doing something wrong

#

like 100%

dusky canopy
#

We know itโ€™s new to him

plush tendon
#

Though, DK is kind of sick this raid

#

with all the knocks and movement impairing shit

edgy grail
#

They need to go hit a target dummy with a guide opeb

#

8k is almost like AA only

uneven mason
#

What do you mean I can't just spam howling blast?

dusky canopy
#

LIL

plush tendon
#

FOOL

#

this aint classic

limpid anchor
#

8k is really really low

uneven mason
#

I'd ask if they have their fishing pole equipped

#

But that's not even a thing

plush tendon
#

Somethings he might not be doing; keeping icy talons up by spending runic power, not standing in DND or making sure one is down all the time

#

not popping Tombstone and DRW on CD

#

overcapping boneshields (need more heartstrike)

uneven mason
#

We're talking raid Right?

limpid anchor
#

Does he work on his issues or are you trying to fix the problem?

plush tendon
#

I mean, thats in general

#

M+ and raid

#

You could prob hold DRW till you actively tanking

uneven mason
#

Because in m+ my bdk is slapping

plush tendon
#

BDK does decent damage

#

not as high as my warrior

#

but its better then it has been in the past XD

uneven mason
#

Yeah

plush tendon
#

without a busted tier set

#

I gotta run some DK and Paladin keys tonight

#

but I also need one more 16 for two 415 choices on my war.... why do I have work today ๐Ÿ˜ฆ

uneven mason
#

I could be running keys

#

But my work has been starting to monitor how long between inputs

#

Which is some scummy crap

safe tundra
# uneven mason We don't do stat weights

Yeah I donโ€™t mean stat weights directly but I thought prot war was mainly haste>vers so some of the haste>mastery necks were a bit confusing unless thereโ€™s something I was missing

plush tendon
#

Do they not see you inputting all those Shield Slams?

high drum
plush tendon
#

kind of sus

safe tundra
#

Iโ€™m getting into DF a bit late, wasnโ€™t going to play but Iโ€™ve heard prot is like S4 of BFA busted so Iโ€™ll try it

#

Can say I donโ€™t think Iโ€™ve dropped below 98% hp just doing heroics in scrub gear, pretty pumped to try some m+

plush tendon
#

Prot isnt BFA levels of busted

#

but its probably the best all around tank and really fun to play

#

and heroics and M0s are kind of a joke

safe tundra
#

Yeah thatโ€™s still good to hear, taking a tier off of raiding for the first time since OG TBC, kind of just want to meme around m+

plush tendon
#

M+ aint bad, but I feel like it ramps up in difficulty much quicker

#

Especially with 20 being the new 15

tame jasper
tame jasper
edgy grail
#

He means reward levels

plush tendon
#

Yea

tame jasper
marble cipher
#

Does anyone know if the panda double food racial stacks with the double food embellishment?

edgy grail
#

The modifiers donโ€™t really mean anything

#

In terms of comparing difficulty

safe tundra
#

Yeah Iโ€™ll need to see, lot of guildlies complaining about m+ but the normal group I run with has been getting their 16s in fine it sounds like

edgy grail
#

Since you have to account for the m0 damage which is what is scaled

plush tendon
#

Thats pretty much the deal now

#

I run with a lot of 'get your weekly 15 key gamers' who now have to go 5 key levels up

#

and then a handful of guys who want to actually push

safe tundra
#

Yeah thatโ€™s the vast majority of my old guild

plush tendon
#

Now we gotta drag everyone up to a 20 key

#

for the raid

safe tundra
#

Only did it for greatvault slot and then there was 4 of us that pushed as high as we could the first couple weeks

plush tendon
#

The good thing at least this raid has a couple of free bosses

safe tundra
#

Biggest meme was timing a lower kara 20 week 1 while watching them complain that 11 was overturned lol (thatโ€™s obviously different than a s1 where no one has busted items)

plush tendon
#

and I like only have 8 to do

safe tundra
#

Is it more, โ€œthis unavoidable damage is overtunedโ€

#

Or if I step in this I just die

tame jasper
#

Glad you have a grp ๐Ÿ™‚ I only have 2 to 3 man, but the third is not one you can keep until higher keys and one of the others only has few hours per week due family ๐Ÿ˜ฆ

uneven mason
safe tundra
#

Regardless I think they got it tuned right if the vast majority are complaining itโ€™s too hard week 1 because itโ€™s supposed to be tuned relative to mythic raid for comparable ilvl?

plush tendon
#

100%

#

not everyone should be getting to 15s or 16s week one

tame jasper
plush tendon
#

hell, even 20s you gotta be a real gamer

tame jasper
#

had an AA grp yesterday

uneven mason
tame jasper
#

mage didnt play thudnerigng

#

enhancer didnt even played quaking

#

so easy 14 key deplete

limpid anchor
safe tundra
#

Yeah I mean regardless a s1 is always going to be your hardest szn (assuming same dungeon pool) youโ€™re going in with mainly quest gear and maybe 1 raid clear

plush tendon
#

RLP can rot in hell

uneven mason
#

The gameplay in df has been so smooth that people feel like it's end of xpac and don't understand the power curve

limpid anchor
#

Especially bcs itโ€™s fort and not even tyr

safe tundra
#

S2 youโ€™ll enter with a 4 set and maybe some busted trinkets/weps and most routes down

plush tendon
#

Our characters feel good to play

#

so we like 'oh, we geared'

uneven mason
#

S2 is a completely different selection of dungeons

plush tendon
#

then we get minced when we go to high

safe tundra
#

I miss kyrian spear, doesnโ€™t look like any prot warriors are running it ๐Ÿ˜ฆ

#

About my only thing lol

plush tendon
#

you can run it; just not as a good as roar

safe tundra
#

Yeah for sure

plush tendon
#

but not totally troll to run it

safe tundra
#

Major hurdle is figuring out this crafting systemโ€ฆ

brittle garnet
plush tendon
#

after that, I would just save a spark and see what you end up needing to make your toon as strong as possible

safe tundra
#

Yeah I think Iโ€™m going MH with second

plush tendon
#

thats what I did

safe tundra
#

Also need to figure out how to get a spark lol

plush tendon
#

Every two weeks

safe tundra
#

I dinged last night and did most things I think

plush tendon
#

the main storyline shouldve shown ya

edgy grail
#

Its in valdraken

odd iron
#

Hello, Hunger of the pack VS Granyths Enduring Scale VS Hunger of the pack, all same ilvl, whats preferrable for m+?

edgy grail
#

The engine or whatever

plush tendon
#

its 1 spark every two weeks (we at 2 right now) and then after like 5 sparks it becomes a rare drop

safe tundra
#

Yeah I did the main quest line up until unlocking WQs

plush tendon
#

and you can catch up whenever

safe tundra
#

Next step is like rep locked or something

craggy pilot
safe tundra
#

Iโ€™ll take a bigger look

plush tendon
#

I think so?

#

Nothing wrong with a well itemized neck with socket

safe tundra
#

Yeah I just noticed that there is a haste/vers neck from m+ I think

#

So was debating just going MH/Shield

plush tendon
#

You can do whatever you want

#

in two weeks you can make a third piece

craggy pilot
#

so i feel its way more like "make whatever makes the most sense in your own case"

plush tendon
#

True

safe tundra
#

Yee Iโ€™m just a bit behind so trying to optimize. Might see what I get from first vault and go from there

plush tendon
#

In reality, you just gotta make something at some point

#

spent way too much time earlier this week being like 'omg, whats BiS crafted.... omg need to min max'

craggy pilot
uneven mason
#

I just want a crafted neck because I still have a 359

craggy pilot
#

so thing is, if youre waiting for Price to drop on Neck, then probably better to craft something else

craggy pilot
plush tendon
#

What I learned (and I havnt crafted it yet) if the person is advertising to make the neck for 75k, just send him a work order for like 20k

#

he'll do it

deft vessel
#

random question - what phials do you people use in raid (razsageth) and m+?

plush tendon
#

this is what my guildies did

craggy pilot
#

sometimes i did accept an order cus i thought the price was the same, and then after i thought "wait how much gold did i just get?" and theres no way to double check ๐Ÿคฃ

deft vessel
#

but then you get one proc at the start of combat and that's it until a new target, of which there aren't that many, not where it matters (razsageth herself)

plush tendon
#

Razsageth (at least on normal) aint gonna be won or lost by tank damage

#

most of our wipes came from the ---- ++++ mech

#

gotta send the raid back to Nax

craggy pilot
#

Lariat compared to Wrist or Belt is probably 0.1% more dps or some shit anyway ๐Ÿคฃ

#

we cant even properly sim it yet

plush tendon
#

yet people are buying the recipe for literal gold cap

deft vessel
#

oh hm, I misread glacial fury, nvm

craggy pilot
#

well because of RWF

#

and Mythic raid guilds etc

plush tendon
#

I think you are better off as a guild just having everyone spend 75K for the craft itself

#

then spending 9mil on a recipe

craggy pilot
#

dont rly think a lot of guilds benefit from paying for the recipe at all

#

should just craft some other items tbh

plush tendon
#

I need to craft my engineering bracers

#

so I can use the flamethrower

craggy pilot
#

i heard flamethrower is bait

#

it is channeled

plush tendon
#

Yea, but its a flamethrower

craggy pilot
#

i would rather get a CR ๐Ÿ˜„

plush tendon
#

we used it on the tree boss

#

it did like a million damage

#

its pretty nutty

#

if you can just channel it

#

of course it could malfunction

craggy pilot
#

sounds crazy

#

if theres no dmg cap

plush tendon
#

it does a lot

#

hell, our rogue used it on the add plateform on Dethea

#

500k

#

Easy gains

craggy pilot
#

i would assume it was like 50k dmg or so ๐Ÿ˜„

plush tendon
#

nope 500k

#

well 492k

#

it did malfunction on him one pull though, which basically just means you dead

craggy pilot
#

lol

#

maybe bad as tank then ๐Ÿคฃ

plush tendon
#

but with mechanical mind and tinker stuff, you can get the chance pretty low

craggy pilot
#

what if im n ot Eng?

plush tendon
#

IDK

#

its still the wildwest out here

ornate thunder
#

Doesn't even hurt as a tank, I use it all the time

#

when it explodes you take like 20k dmg

#

the knock up is annoying though

craggy pilot
#

guess ill try it out

ornate thunder
#

But, if you're engi, you can get the thing to make it always work

#

I'm just lazy getting points for professions

plush tendon
#

and higher ranks of Breath make it channel faster

#

not hit harder

sick sentinel
#

my engi is 50+ 6

craggy pilot
plush tendon
#

yea

#

I went full on into Mechanical Mind and Inventions

#

so reduce chance on getting.... malfunctioned

#

I basically just talked myself into making engineering bracers

craggy pilot
#

ohh i can put safety component on even if im not engi?

sick sentinel
#

putting all my points into bombs

plush tendon
#

I think only Engi

deft vessel
#

wait which tinker is this?

plush tendon
#

Breath of Nelth

red mulch
#

hey guys, can you change the secondary stats on crafted gear afterwards?

#

also, if I put in a optional embellishment, can I remove it afterwards?

craggy pilot
deft vessel
plush tendon
#

but its a LONG CD (10min)

red mulch
#

cool, so only think I commit to is the piece itself

plush tendon
#

I think its something worth to looking into

#

cause there are spots where big damage like that is probably nutty

ornate thunder
#

if it malfunctions it's only 5

plush tendon
#

like Tree Boss

ornate thunder
#

on the cd

plush tendon
#

and if you dont like it, you can slot a Bres

sick sentinel
#

i used nitro speed belt all of BFA

#

you go, so fast

ornate thunder
#

Bring back synapse springs

#

imo

brisk gust
#

What are spending sparks on?

plush tendon
brisk gust
#

I saw on wowhead we want neck -> sword, but should i prioritize my lowest item ilvl or should i get those even if i have 392+ in both slots

plush tendon
#

I would wait for tomorrows reset, see what you get from vault

#

and then craft for what would make your toon best

brisk gust
#

So the neck isn't super important?

plush tendon
#

its good

#

not like, omg need this right now or Ill die, good

#

but super solid, and the neck slot is usually a safe pick since youll have ideal stats with sockets

#

so not too easily replaced

eager fractal
#

got decoration of flame with leech and all totem of master both from hc this week lol

#

kinda smurfing

plush tendon
#

The wind walkers took my decoration of flame

#

๐Ÿ˜ฆ

placid vale
#

I took it from them BWAHAHAHA

jolly wasp
#

I wonder why world first tanks are crafting the unstable frostfire belt if crafting prio should be neck sword tho

plush tendon
#

Frostfire belt is really good

#

and it also lets us use the rare raid rings

#

to deal fire damage

jolly wasp
#

idk, for my warrior at 418 it barely sims like 100 dps higher while falling back in any kind of cleave or aoe

#

compared to lariat

placid vale
#

How tf are u 418 already? XD

plush tendon
#

you can craft a 418 if you do 10 16s

loud patrol
#

my man is a mythic raider

#

yeah but thats 1 418

jolly wasp
#

i meant 418 on both pieces, not that im 418 XD

placid vale
#

Im progging 11s

plush tendon
loud patrol
placid vale
#

Going slow, need to carry with me 2 of my friends. And one is...bad at playing this game

#

Dies the second anything farts at him and complains he needs to move too much while playing a BM Hunter

#

So....yeah xD

jolly wasp
#

highest ilvl in the world is 409 or something kekw but anyway... i dont see the reason to craft the belt over lariat in any situation unless you have a 340 belt or something

neon elk
#

Is recrafting actualy harder than crafting new item ? Heard something but idk if its true

plush tendon
#

no

#

its cheaper

#

Recrafting a item is harder if you start adding more stuff to the item to make it more difficult

neon elk
#

Yea but if i just wanna bump ilvl its not harder , apart from using higher lvl infusion, right?

tender cove
#

wow, insane... This dude on draenor was one, if not the first with a lariat design... About 24 hours ago, he had the achievement for 500 personal crafts... Today he has the 1k crafts achivement. He's selling lariat for 99k. Lets assume those are all lariats... Thats 50 million gold made in 24 hours, wtf ๐Ÿ˜ฎ

brisk gust
tender cove
brave tapir
#

This achievement is stupid

earnest nymph
#

this is probably asked daily so my apologies - has the BV bug even been acknowledged by blizzo yet?

tender cove
brave tapir
deft vessel
#

I don't think there are work orders that are that cheap

#

plenty cheap stuff, but not that cheap

plush tendon
#

hes probably not selling all of them at 75k

jolly wasp
brave tapir
#

Even for 1g, for 1000g you get the max achievement and you link it in chat like youโ€™re reputable

plush tendon
#

but even just 1000 20k work orders is a metric shit ton

#

all in all, a good days work

brisk gust
#

@jolly wasp Ye i don't have any concecrated primal focus, but i've 1 primal infusion

#

@tender cove only have primal infusion so 405 lariat is fine? Its easy to upgrade later stage?

neon elk
brisk gust
#

What's the diff between ** Quality Illimited Diamond and ***? The diff i price is 34k lmao

plush tendon
#

more stats

#

probably minimal

brisk gust
#

2 stars cost 1k and 3 stars cost 35k

plush tendon
#

or at least, has a very high marginal cost

brisk gust
#

lmao

jolly wasp
neon elk
plush tendon
#

flamethower bracers!

#

๐Ÿ˜„

craggy pilot
#

man im legit looking into getting them

#

my guildie can make them but only 386

plush tendon
#

Engineering bracers still probably gonna be siq for pushing if you want a BRES

#

but flamethrower is awesome

#

cause, flamethrower

craggy pilot
#

was so much thinking i would make BS Wrist and BS Belt, but now i got 392 belt from M+

craggy pilot
#

but i hate it when i have druid heal, and the druid dies, and no one can CR ๐Ÿ˜„

#

if i recraft Wrist, i can put safety equipment on later right?

#

fuck man i just wanna make it for the meme ๐Ÿคฃ

#

anyone know how the material shit works, like if i craft it with rank 2 will i be fucked later?

plush tendon
#

Im just waiting for someone to tell me its a terrible idea

tender cove
#

Is there a point to running shockwave on raz? I cant figure out why naowh would run it and use it on cooldown when he would get more dps from maxing TR capstones instead?

plush tendon
#

it looks pretty fun

#

I just dont know how good it actually is

#

and what the other costs are

craggy pilot
#

embellishments are made for fun

limpid anchor
#

You would lose a lot of dps

plush tendon
#

yea, why am I psyching myself outta of it

craggy pilot
#

not for "which embellish is my bis plz discord channel h e l p m e i cant decide anything about my character myself"

tender cove
plush tendon
#

Maybe hes just lazy and hasnt gotten around to changing talents

craggy pilot
radiant magnet
tender cove
craggy pilot
tender cove
#

I would assume so or it will be a dps loss pressing it over anything else?

#

Specially since he's running it on cooldown every single time

craggy pilot
#

he is pressing it to stun the sparks no?

sage sun
#

You guys spent your valor yet ?

jolly wasp
#

no, better wait for vault

sage sun
#

True

tender cove
craggy pilot
onyx matrix
median tulip
#

At this stage it's not worth spending Valor; better to save it for later

tender cove
craggy pilot
#

everyone gets their own spark that they need to CC

jolly wasp
#

I mean if everyone despawned 2 sparks, there would be none left

#

so i dont see whats wrong

craggy pilot
#

maybe he shockwave 1 and Storm Bolt the other

tender quartz
#

Any input appreciated ( but more from a pug perspective )

tender cove
weary python
#

Any advice on spending valor? If I have a BiS m+ piece should I upgrade that if it's like 392? Should I hold on to valor for now?

tender quartz
#

Wait for vault I'd say?

#

It's just a day away.

#

Or two.

jolly wasp
#

Ye wait for vault 100%.

craggy pilot
#

so any CC helps

plush tendon
#

I think you need to interrupt the spark 4 times

tender cove
craggy pilot
#

inspired to 389

craggy pilot
tender cove
#

yeh

queen cave
#

Hey Guys. i am curious, do prot warriors have any way of getting the buff from the ring?

plush tendon
#

time to flamethrower some stuff

craggy pilot
#

bought the rank 2 flame

#

oh no first time i tried it malfunctioned ๐Ÿคฃ

plush tendon
craggy pilot
#

5min CD

#

reduced my str peepostudy

plush tendon
#

by how much?

azure grove
#

Is dragon roar really worth the points over Sonic boom and Rumbling Earth for shockwave?

queen cave
craggy pilot
jolly wasp
#

@azure grove dragon roar is cracked

craggy pilot
#

and it was like 2-3 sec debuff

plush tendon
#

ah, not terrible

craggy pilot
#

i guess i just pop wall and im ok ๐Ÿ˜„

#

but man i need a safety module

#

it even rolled haste โค๏ธ

#

i hope it stays haste forever even if i reforge

modern brook
jolly wasp
#

exactly, when you can talent into roar and have both

craggy pilot
plush tendon
craggy pilot
#

a little unfortunate, but i never use combat potions anyway so im gucci ๐Ÿ˜„

fair stump
#

Any other tanks competitive with prot atm?

plush tendon
#

I wonder if you can easily take tinkers in and out

craggy pilot
jolly wasp
#

not really you need to recraft or re-purchase

plush tendon
#

unless you buy a new one?

craggy pilot
craggy pilot
plush tendon
#

but is uncapped

#

๐Ÿ˜ฎ

craggy pilot
#

uncapped AOE lets gooo

plush tendon
#

and scales with crit

craggy pilot
#

fuck that combat pot and those 6 globals ๐Ÿ˜„

plush tendon
#

more reason to get crit

craggy pilot
#

im tank anyway 6 globals is peanuts

craggy pilot
#

works well with my crit/vers playstyle ๐Ÿ˜„

plush tendon
#

I ignored the vers part

jolly wasp
#

Keep in mind it's also a channel, soooo... im not sure you can use it while tanking without getting smashed

craggy pilot
craggy pilot
plush tendon
#

its 100% meme

#

but I think there are on use scenarios

jolly wasp
plush tendon
#

like Tree Boss

foggy kernel
#

Cant find Prot Warrior m+ EMBELLISHMENTS recommendations in any list.

Not any good sims/suggestions out yet? Neck is a given choice for many classes but seeing as we have GIGA BIS HASTE HEAVY neck from Court I am not so sure.

craggy pilot
#

it did 90k dmg on ST

#

and 10min CD when it doesnt backfire

craggy pilot
#

it doesnt rly matter

edgy grail
#

That is not giga bis nothing

#

Bis neck is lariat

severe steeple
craggy pilot
onyx kayak
#

I got the trinket Ruby Whelp Shell in 392, but i feel like it never does anything - Overall it looks worse aswell, but most people call it a good trinket, Do i need to press the trinket at a specific time lol

foggy kernel
craggy pilot
#

just craft whatever

plush tendon
foggy kernel
plush tendon
#

make something that sounds cool

craggy pilot
#

you can make a flamethrower

plush tendon
#

like a flamethrower

lucid cloak
#

shield is probably worth?

plush tendon
#

I didnt make shield

#

cause im raiding

#

and first boss drops one

foggy kernel
#

Fair fair, does that mean you can have unlimited amount of embellishments?

plush tendon
#

but its probably good

plush tendon
#

I think

lucid cloak
#

the BIS shield is from Azure vault 20weekly vault right?

plush tendon
#

I just try to get a high I level shield first

craggy pilot
lucid cloak
#

untill you kill last boss mythic

plush tendon
#

then we figure out whats BiS

#

later

lucid cloak
severe steeple
#

think about it this way, the crafted item slot is getting to 418 as soon as you start pumping 16s

craggy pilot
#

thing is, Lariat is BIS (by like 0.2% or so) but if you are waiting for the price to drop for Lariat, you might as well craft something else now, and get Lariat later

#

Shield is omega value, armor is also value

#

a ton if different stuff can work great

paper coral
#

So, I noticed some builds that dont have shockwave, like even M+ builds. Isn't a cone stun that does good damage good?

craggy pilot
#

just everyone says "Lariat" cus its much easier to explain to peabrain people

plush tendon
#

Builds are fluid

plush tendon
#

there are some talents that are like way too good to not take

craggy pilot
#

but its good ye

plush tendon
#

and others where you can make choices on

#

might not need shockwave if you have a WW and DH or something

craggy pilot
lucid cloak
#

shockwave is more a stopper for casts on stunnable mobs

#

than a dmg ability

modern brook
paper coral
ionic fern
sick sentinel
#

halls of valor doesn't seem too rough

lucid cloak
#

mate. Thats a 7

paper coral
modern brook
sick sentinel
#

i died to uhh something of light on before boss 2 trash

ionic fern
sick sentinel
#

307k

onyx matrix
#

Are you guys going for the tier set bonus? ๐Ÿ˜„

lucid cloak
#

its after miniboss leaps

#

she does a beam. Avoidable