#protection

1 messages ยท Page 185 of 1

warm dune
#

And when exactly i use ignore pain?

warm plinth
#

To not overcap rage

cinder nova
#

Assuming you're using Anger Management (you should), spending rage reduces a lot of our CDs both offensive and defensive.

#

In essence, overcapping rage is actually wasting rage because it could be rage spent - and rage spent is rage that gives us CDR.

#

The more rage you spend, the more damage you can deal, the more mitigation CDs you can throw in each fight, making you more stable and generally safer depending on... a bit more variables, but that's how it works in a vacuum.

stable sapphire
#

Hey guys what are the best slots to use our Sparks of Ingenuity as the game progresses as prot warrior??

coarse flower
#

i just went down a rabithole of reading about mastery on google; is there somewhere recent that says that critblock caps at 85%?

#

cause im only finding stuff from back in 2011 lol

strong forum
#

all physical mitigation caps at 85%

coarse flower
#

ohh okok

strong forum
#

block is just armor

cinder nova
#

You went down a rabbit hole filled with bones and dust, mate. Mastery isn't so bad a stat that we're giving up ilvl to avoid it, but it's still pretty meh.

coarse flower
#

yeah was just curious, thanks for the info

strong forum
#

its rng mitigation, thats the cringe part about it

#

mastery that is

cinder nova
#

Mastery was better for shield tanks when we could CTC cap with it.

coarse flower
#

nothing is more cringe than parry chance on a bdk... that was not fun

strong forum
#

if you get enough of it, its reliable, but stacking it is worse than getting other stats

warm dune
#

@S ty so much now it make sense another thing is there a good Wa where i can track my mitigation cd i use Nawoh Wa its kinda small and i lose track

strong forum
#

getting crit is practically the same as mastery

#

but you get more dmg out of it

#

and the mitigation is 100% reduction, not 85%

dawn canyon
#

@strong forum only 3 more days till we never do elites again critcake

strong forum
#

kek

warm dune
#

I got the versa trinkwt out of a rare i think its kinda beast of trinket :p

dawn canyon
#

5 >379 and i cant use 4 of em smadge

strong forum
#

only thing i got was 382 chest from ancient protector

#

so thats pog

#

the one that was plate + agi

#

but it got fixed 1 day later so we gucci

dawn canyon
#

im hoping i get a ring from enkine

#

then im 383 and done

tender cove
dawn canyon
#

its just horrible luck really

#

the dedication is just flying around for an hour

tropic sundial
#

Daily super rare tour is way mire chill and enjoyable for me than key farming hell.

craggy pilot
#

do we know the PPM of the Elemental Lariat Embellishment neck? ๐Ÿค”

tropic sundial
#

I haven't even done cobalt either and I'm 379

dawn canyon
#

keys was alright

#

hated cobalt more tbh

coarse flower
#

first time i've enjoyed wow open-world content

#

probably because there's ilvl incentive behind it as well i guess

earnest canyon
#

Hi everyone
Got a quick question about violent outburst
In SL it was prioritized to spend a proc almost always on SS, is it still the case?
even while avatar is up with unstoppable force?

slim dove
#

im actually about to just buy marks and burn 200k gold to avoid this shit

sturdy sable
#

But even then the damage outweighs the tclap unless like 8+ targets iirc (I'm probably wrong on target count)

strong forum
#

they nerfed rage gen from outburst, but it now interacts with talents for shield slam

#

so a TC outburst is only +10 rage

#

when SS outburst is 30 baseline, +6 with impenetrable wall, +4 with HR

#

so the difference rage wise is larger than in SL

#

until 5 targets, SS will be more beneficial to send outburst on

coarse flower
#

whats HR?

strong forum
#

heavy repercussions

#

+2 rage on SS and it increases SB duration +1sec for each SS

coarse flower
#

is the idea that, because we're running AM that we want to generate as much rage as we can so we can spend to reduce avatar CD?

#

is there more synergy to dumping rage ontop of that? or is it mostly AM?

strong forum
#

its not just that

#

outburst, indomitable healing and AM

#

more rage = more rage

coarse flower
#

yeah ok pretty hard to argue against spending anything but SS during violent outburst

raven kettle
#

which primal ritual shell buff do we use?

strong forum
#

fire sims alot higher on ST

raven kettle
#

thats what i figured

strong forum
#

on aoe mastery will win ofc

safe shale
#

How do you know what buff you're getting?

cerulean wyvern
#

After the tank nerfs, does it make prot warrior even better than the other tanks since we can go battle stance for more trivial content?

cerulean tusk
#

More or less, for that content

cerulean wyvern
#

Iโ€™d imagine that during tank swaps you can go battle stance for increased dps, and then swap back to defensive stance when actively tanking?

coarse flower
#

youll eventually need to stance dance for some tankbusters (20% DR is kinda juiced, but most of the time youre bstance gaming)

#

honestly even then, you probably have enough defensive buttons to not stance dance; you'd use it for some cringe magic tankbusters in high keys

cerulean wyvern
#

Yeah, so prot warrior is even better now compared to the other tanks than beforeโ€ฆsince itโ€™s not a complete 10% DR nerf.

cobalt seal
#

Ppala still exists

#

Bdk still exists

#

Bear still exists

coarse flower
#

prot pala takes too much iq for me to play..

#

too many keybinds bro

jagged pier
#

its stand in conc

#

u win

strong forum
cerulean tusk
#

They should nerf def stance to a 5% dmg red only ExcitedBlushette

coarse flower
#

sadgers leave warrior alone

edgy grail
#

D stance should be 30% dmg red

#

So we never have to use it

cerulean wyvern
#

Well Iโ€™m glad they didnโ€™t nerf prot warrior damage.

coarse flower
#

they kinda did by removing some spell reflects on some bosses

#

or changing it to only stop the damage taken, it doesnt do damage back to bosses

strong forum
#

All Tanks have lost their Damage Reduction Aura
Back in 9.1 and 9.1.5 Blizzard introduced a 10% flat damage reduction aura to all tanks.
Pwar later in 9.2 received another +5% Buff to that aura of a total of 15%.

During DF Beta that Aura alongside Vanguard has had been nerfed already from 15% DR Aura and 100% Vanguard Str conversion down to 5% DR Aura and 70% Vanguard Strength conversion and other tanks' aura have been left untouched.

With the Season Launch Blizzard is removing those SL-DR Auras because they think Tanks are too tanky right now.
Pwar had only 5% left baseline they couldn't have nerfed that Aura more since we already lost 10% earlier. To compensate for the other 5% leftover they also nerfed D-Stance along with it. Rightfully so.

This is not a targeted indirect buff to Pwar.

sand saddle
#

So do we have an idea of BIS slot to craft? ๐Ÿ™‚

strong forum
#

2nd pin

cerulean tusk
#

Why dat pin

cerulean wyvern
#

Thanks for the pin. Helps to clarify.

dusky notch
#

is the pinned talents from 29/11 still the go to? ๐Ÿ˜Š

cerulean tusk
#

They nerfed def stance by 5% sadge be angwy.

strong forum
#

all the pins should be up to date

loud hull
#

how is mastery for prots?

strong forum
#

worst stat offensively and defensively

#

not bad, just least favourable

loud hull
#

i crafted a shield, but forgot about stats and how he wants to "reroll" it till i hit haste/vers etc

strong forum
#

you can force stats with an optional reagent

cerulean tusk
#

Go to workorder, have it reforged

craggy pilot
#

do we have a possibility to sim the Vers wrist vs the Proc Elemental Lariat somehow? ๐Ÿค”

loud hull
#

its 392 currently i dont want it 382 etc

cerulean tusk
#

just keep the 392, untill you farm out correct stats in m+/raid

#

you will replace it soon anyhow

strong forum
oak echo
# safe shale How do you know what buff you're getting?

didn't see if this got a response but assuming you were asking about the shell trinket, you choose it at a shrine in waking shores and it stays up i believe until you change it yourself. unsure about unequipping or logging off

#

if you choose nothing you just get the mastery proc

craggy pilot
#

i crafted shield currently, but i guess we get 1 more spark Wednesday that i can use on something else

cerulean wyvern
#

Do any of the other tanks have an indefinite 15% DR like prot warriors sitting in defensive stance?

slim dove
#

no

fathom goblet
#

no

strong forum
#

no

hoary vector
#

Its 20% is it not?

oak echo
#

it's 20% until reset

strong forum
#

itll be 15% starting next reset

fathom goblet
#

`they nerfed

hoary vector
#

Ahh, already nerfed out self healing now Defence stance ๐Ÿ˜„

#

Guess thye didn't like us not needing a healer

strong forum
#

they nerfed everything

fathom goblet
#

defensive instance also counts for magic damage ?

strong forum
#

if you count DF start

coarse flower
# strong forum not all embellishments are implemented in simc yet

I know its not an embellishment, but its gonna cost a spark - instead of opting for an embellishment craft alot of the top raiders on my server have opted for the engi helm (with cone tinker); hard to say since its not on raidbots sims but short term would the cone tinker be better for raid? (theyre like top 15 world but its weird since literally no one else is doing it)

oak echo
fathom goblet
#

15% extra dr is alot

cerulean wyvern
#

So are prot warriors sitting in an even better position for prog?

strong forum
#

if you count d-stance

#

we always had that same advantage over others

#

and its a huge point for contention why pwar is so strong

strong forum
#

but i myself used the spark on shield with armor spikes

pulsar sedge
#

A little off topic here.. But.. At what point does ItF beat out HR? At higher haste levels or just bigger pulls? Sorry if this has been answered before ;D

strong forum
#

just to see

pulsar sedge
#

Or is HR just kinda king atm ?

strong forum
pulsar sedge
#

Thought so, wanted the experts to confirm ;D

strong forum
#

because you dont need to spend 2 talent points to get full SB uptime

#

if you play ITF you need to swap a dmg talent to bolster to get close to 100% SB

#

if you play HR you get 100% SB with ease

tame jasper
#

whats the best Embellishment for us, when crafting shield?

pulsar sedge
#

Thanks nom!

strong forum
#

i used armor spikes just to test it

hoary vector
#

What should we be using First spark on?

#

Im saving mine for Amulet currently

modern brook
pulsar sedge
#

I spent mine on the helm

fathom goblet
#

Im not sure if Im doing anythhing wront but I dont have SB 100% UP

#

I can have 3 charges

#

but the forth charge takes a while

cobalt seal
#

4th charge?

fathom goblet
#

yeah

tame jasper
strong forum
fathom goblet
#

yep

strong forum
#

especially vs bosses

modern brook
cerulean tusk
#

What is the estimate for 100% uptime atm, 40-50% haste as per usual?

fathom goblet
#

@strong forum is that normal ?

modern brook
#

100% uptime with recommended talents is expected

strong forum
modern brook
#

If you're struggling to git thay you're either in the wrong talents or not shield slaming enough

cobalt seal
#

Log and come back

#

As always

#

Thats the solution

#

To find the issues

strong forum
#

and rn im too lazy to math out how much is required with champions bulwark / bolster

main anchor
#

what we dou with funk

strong forum
cerulean tusk
strong forum
#

with HR you have 100% SB at all times no matter how much haste

#

cuz of champions bulwark + ED

fathom goblet
#

@strong forum having only 3 consecutive SB

strong forum
#

thats normal ye

fathom goblet
#

@strong forum so how can i have 100% SB uptime ?

strong forum
#

you need 3 out of 4 block talents

#

in whichever combination

oak echo
#

you're talking about shield block charges like you're not using shield charge on cd

fathom goblet
#

its the talent tree on PINS ?

strong forum
#

yes

oak echo
#

and if that's the case that's your problem

strong forum
#

both m+ talent builds have 100% SB uptime

#

you have 2 options

jagged pier
#

well could also no be pressing SS enough to keep SB up

strong forum
#

ITF+Bolster

#

or HR+Nails

cobalt seal
strong forum
#

well if you dont play optimally you will lose SB uptime

cobalt seal
#

Logs

strong forum
#

but thats your issue, not the builds

jagged pier
cerulean tusk
#

Time to build 0 haste, full mastery and crit hippo

cobalt seal
#

Its better than shooting darts blind

#

Trying to find the issue

blazing condor
#

super rares are once a day ?

cobalt seal
#

Yes

strong forum
#

si

blazing condor
#

any WA/addon for where they at or we go raw

modern brook
#

There's a rare tracker you can wago, i think nom uses it

#

I'm an honest (too lazy to find a way for my own use) gamer so idk it off hand sorry but it does exiat

tame jasper
blazing condor
#

thank

sand saddle
#

Then its a matter of searching for group until one pops up?

blazing condor
#

yeah im a WA/addon minimalist

blazing condor
modern brook
#

Yeah I just group finder the name of the rare and there's usually a waiting group

#

Maybe less so deep into the week but

edgy grail
#

There is a bunch I doing then yesterday

crystal canopy
#

Random question but does anyone know how to show raid frames when in a party ?

edgy grail
#

You can go to any group and they go in order basically

tropic sundial
#

The hardest part is being accepted in a group before their rare is actually dead

cerulean tusk
tropic sundial
#

I swear sometime I apply 15sec after a party is listed and by the time I'm accepted 40sec later it's dead

cobalt seal
#

People dont wait

edgy grail
#

Well most groups wait at the location for 10 minutes at a time

#

So they waited plenty ๐Ÿ˜‚

wicked stream
#

@strong forum what Phial is best for raid?

tropic sundial
#

I just wish people didn't need to manually accept for those listing

ocean finch
#

Anyone have any good routes for S1?

blazing condor
#

is MDT even up to date with mob counters

jagged pier
#

press w

edgy grail
#

๐Ÿ˜‚ the season aint even start yet

ocean finch
#

Im aware, but they havent changed any mob count what we have seen from beta?

#

So if it was any beta routes that you could import

tropic sundial
#

Tactyks has some good videos for s1 dungeons already I think

strong forum
#

For movement heavy idk yet, haven't looked too much into it

#

Glacial fury is solid

blazing condor
#

this has been answered a million times already but i dont pay attention - do we put our sparks on anything specific or just go with whatever

indigo knot
#

Delete em

blazing condor
#

thx

indigo knot
#

Elitist mind control currency

jagged pier
blazing condor
#

i did

#

im fried in head and cant find it sadgers

modern brook
#

So don't feel too bas just sending something

jagged pier
blazing condor
#

gaslit by stormforged sadge

jagged pier
#

shield not a bad shout

strong forum
#

Didn't have a pin regard sparks specifically

#

The pin is about embellishments

jagged pier
#

yer but it helped explained the system

#

ill i personally would recommend shield but no embellishments

#

and its likely u will want neck and something

#

but the shield ones are kinda weak

blazing condor
#

ill have to read up on everything all these concepts got me messed up

fair stump
#

whats our prio? ilvl over all but then do we want haste/vers?

jagged pier
#

its in the pins but yes

tropic sundial
jagged pier
#

or haste crit for damage

sand saddle
#

so shield is good but we can only wear 2 pieces with embellishments? Shield embellishments are weak. so on week 6 we will have shield/neck(with embellish) + (something else with embellish)?

olive steeple
sand saddle
#

Jakey said he would recommend shield but no embellishment.

olive steeple
#

Ah I see

#

Ty

jagged pier
#

the vers proc is whatever and from what @strong forum said the spikes dont do much ither

sand saddle
#

Im just asking if theres a limit to the amount of crafted items we can wear or embellish

jagged pier
#

embellish i believe

olive steeple
#

You can only where two embilishments yeah?

jagged pier
#

only 2 items with embilishments yer

severe hatch
#

You can have as many crafted items in general as you want

sand saddle
#

I see. So basically shield is good because prot loves big stat shield. But we just waiting for the theory gods to tell us which embellishes are the best after they have all been tested/simmed

edgy grail
#

You can have all your gear be crafted

#

But yea embellishments are limited to 2

cinder nova
#

How's the bleed hat proc now that it's live?

#

Used to be absolutely off the chain

wide fiber
#

Is there a specific shield or weapon we want from m+ come Tuesday?

sand saddle
#

Theres a hast vers shield in m+. cant remember its name

uncut notch
lyric geode
cinder nova
#

Neltharus hammer

jagged pier
#

not in m+

uncut notch
#

heartbroken

slim dove
#

lmao happy its not in rotation

uncut notch
#

Gotta wait 6 months to enjoy it ;_;

cinder nova
#

Lowkey same.

#

I hated farming phial

slim dove
#

fuck weapons i have to farm

lyric geode
#

I dont understand. Will m+ gear will be the same on Temple of the jade serpent?

slim dove
#

let me just be happy seeing ilvl bumps and crit/haste gear

lyric geode
#

or they will change it?

uncut notch
#

I dislike the season mix for s1

#

I wanna play DF dungies ffs

#

S2+ couldnt give a fuck

lyric geode
#

Bring back titanforged.

slim dove
cinder nova
#

Ban him

sand saddle
#

Bring back covenants (dont shoot)

lyric geode
#

I like it

jagged pier
#

we have it now with the rares

severe hatch
lyric geode
#

I mean, we discuss this before. Doing reruns from previous patches on raids, its good.

cinder nova
#

Bets on the cap for the rares?

lyric geode
#

It isnt abnormal.

cinder nova
#

No way it scales indefinitely.

lyric geode
#

It is organic and it should happen

olive steeple
#

What is the proc rate of elemental lariat?

severe hatch
#

Are people getting higher than 385 from rares?

#

Thought that was a hard cap

cinder nova
#

TF is actual dogpiss.

slim dove
#

and im saying its not fun and it being "organic" isn't a good reason for it to exist.

sand saddle
#

Imagine rare farming for all your loot until next expansion.. . . .

warm violet
#

Sorry but what is the bleed helm i keep reading about

warm violet
#

Thx

slim dove
#

3.5 ppm

lyric geode
#

I dont bother with 385 gear. I know that on wenseday, it will be the first replaced. And further, I dont want to get burnt out. So... My advice. Dont bother. You wont go for the RWF. So, what is the point?

olive steeple
cinder nova
slim dove
cinder nova
#

:^)

slim dove
#

also to flex on my m+ group cuz they did 1 tour and logged off

lyric geode
#

Like asmongold said. All that will remain are, achievements and mounts. Nothing more

slim dove
#

why would i care what that bald fuck says

lyric geode
slim dove
#

ok ill go work a few OT shifts and rmt all the achievments and mounts

olive steeple
#

Does ignore pain proc the healing dart

slim dove
cinder nova
#

Dart is poopy why go for it

lyric geode
#

I am also, an achievement whore, but on different game and for different reason.

rich wigeon
#

any1 knows what to craft with primal infussion?

uncut notch
cinder nova
#

Brack is gonna be a fuckfest

merry umbra
#

in any order ๐Ÿ˜„

rich wigeon
#

oh

slim dove
#

save for lariat next week imo.

rich wigeon
#

so the first1 what should it be ?

slim dove
#

or shield idk

#

just dont use on a slot thats tier.

merry umbra
#

if you still havent used the first one

rich wigeon
slim dove
#

infusion, not spark.

merry umbra
#

i'd go for shield and then neck (elemental lariat)

slim dove
jagged pier
#

infusion u need spark for it only upgrades epic items

#

im prbs using mine on neck

merry umbra
#

neck will be craftable with the reset, cuz the recipe is from the primal storm events

lyric geode
#

So, to conclude another topic. Titanforged was great. It made you rerun raids from previous patches which was cool.

rich wigeon
#

so neck > weapon?

merry umbra
#

once you get that neck theres no changing it

#

you can upgrade it and put 3 sockets on it

lyric geode
#

What neck?

tropic sundial
merry umbra
lyric geode
#

And probably will have fated at the end of the expansion. Which by all means it is the dead patch.

#

As most of people call it.

potent gulch
#

boys

lyric geode
#

Furthermore, you have to wait 3 weeks until you reloot the boss you want.

potent gulch
#

spark shield or helmet? ;[

merry umbra
#

dont do tier slots

cobalt seal
#

@lyric geode why do you want to play the same trinket

#

All expansion

potent gulch
cobalt seal
lyric geode
merry umbra
lyric geode
#

Sometimes , the feeling of the trinket is quite nice and quite good.

cobalt seal
#

Sorry vdh couldnt use ows

lyric geode
#

I played the Elisandre trinket back in Legion for an entire expansion. From Nighthold->Argus

cobalt seal
#

Thats called blizzard being pepegas

lyric geode
cobalt seal
#

What

#

This isnt dps warrior channels

brave tapir
#

yeah cro get lost

lyric geode
#

I know.

brave tapir
#

๐Ÿ˜ก

lyric geode
#

I am comparing ptank, to dk tank

#

Bdk could use jailer's weapon. We couldnt.

#

Is that fair? No...

cobalt seal
#

Life isnt fair

severe hatch
#

How do the alchemy trinkets look for us? Seems like a decent stat stick

lyric geode
#

But, I guess there will be a time that bdk will be a shit tier and we will laugh at their misery.

craggy pilot
lyric geode
#

It doesnt give strength.

merry umbra
lyric geode
#

I prefer shield

craggy pilot
#

isnt it best to get str on main items with high ilvl Plate?

lyric geode
#

That is why ring is a trap

#

like it was in SL

craggy pilot
#

so like wep/shield/wrist/belt/boots ๐Ÿค”

merry umbra
#

i never said you should craft it first

#

๐Ÿ˜„

lyric geode
#

shield is a solid option

#

because of block

#

but afterwards, you do what you like.

tropic sundial
#

Got shield, will go neck next week and then probably engi bracers for fat haste

lyric geode
#

Futhermore, my question. How much ilvl can the crafted gear reach?

merry umbra
#

if you still havent used the first spark, i'd get the neck on wednesday and wait for first vault, then craft smth

lyric geode
#

That is quite high

merry umbra
#

yeah but you need like 10 16s and 200 primal chaos for each

rich wigeon
#

how can we use 3 sockets on neck ?

lyric geode
#

And I guess quite expensive as well

earnest nymph
lyric geode
#

No money, no tendies I guess.

merry umbra
#

the mats arent expensive

earnest nymph
#

But use the lower quality settings first

#

Cheaper

merry umbra
#

its the primal chaos and the primal infusion that needs to be farmed

#

and ofc the spark thats the time-gating

lyric geode
#

ah ok

rich wigeon
merry umbra
#

mats wont go for more than 5-10k i believe

#

if you want 3 sockets you buy 3 max quality settings

#

if u want 2 sockets u buy 2 2nd quality settings

#

you get the idea ๐Ÿ˜„

lyric geode
#

uh...

#

Brokie cant choose.

#

But mostly it is my fault.

#

I am too lavish with my gold

#

Spend right and there.

#

Dont have money for other stuff.

rich wigeon
#

found it thnx !!

jagged pier
#

If your that worried u can just craft like r1 then recraft later

cobalt seal
#

With patches

#

Or otherwise they arent really unique

#

Since everyone has something

lyric geode
#

I am confused

#

@cobalt seal people are quite bipolar to be fair. They dont want rng on the gear, but they also like the rng on the gear. Somethehell. People were furious with the legendary system in Legion. So rng. But people were crying from joy when they got dropped their bis legendary gear.

cobalt seal
#

Well

#

Thats normal

lyric geode
#

This is what I miss from wow. People would say, it is not fair etc. Game doesnt have to be fair in order to be fun.

cobalt seal
#

You getting happy you got lucky

#

Is normal

strong forum
#

I miss dopamine rushes from getting loot

lyric geode
#

The minmaxers are going to hate the statement. But that is the truth

strong forum
#

That's what I miss about TFing

lyric geode
strong forum
#

Actual excitement

#

M+ without dopamine loot is just m+

cobalt seal
#

Controlled tf would fix m+

strong forum
cobalt seal
slim zinc
#

Killing Geddon every week and starting to shake of joy when he dropped his binding

lyric geode
#

But no.... People would be furious that the loot is so rng

tropic sundial
#

Might as well play gacha games if you want that kind of dopamine hits

slim zinc
#

Loot doesn't hit the same

strong forum
#

Gacha is different

#

The whole point of gacha is just rng collecting

#

Controlled TF of up to +15 ilvl, capping at mythic raid ilvl of current season

#

That would solve so many issues

lyric geode
#

with the current system

oblique drift
#

Does anyone know how stacking damage reduction works in wow, or if not, does anyone know where I would look into that?

lyric geode
#

It would seem logical

#

Maybe hunt for the more leech buff.

cinder nova
#

Multiplicatively.

strong forum
#

Damage reductions are all multiplicative

oblique drift
#

Okay, thanks!

strong forum
#

You can reduce a hit to 0 with just % mitigation

sonic jungle
#

Is it worth crafting anything?

strong forum
#

You can get close, but without absorbs or flat reductions you can't get there

lyric geode
#

Maybe a socket? I dont know. Something so miniscule but so noteworthy to be worth doing 20 and up.

blazing condor
#

any fast way to uldaman from dragon isles

lyric geode
#

That is all I AM asking from this game.

#

But no.

oblique drift
#

What's the difference between a flat reduction and normal reduction, in that case?

lyric geode
#

RNG and shit. People cant have fun anymore.

#

Somethehell

craggy pilot
strong forum
#

Flat reduction like "reduce dmg taken by 1000"

craggy pilot
#

in Org / SW

oblique drift
#

Ahh, right!

tropic sundial
#

Portal to twilight highlands

oblique drift
#

Okay, I think I understand it! Thank you!

craggy pilot
lyric geode
#

Legion definetely better expansion

#

Better story

#

Suramar

#

An actually baddy

craggy pilot
#

what?

lyric geode
#

Not some kind of jacked old man trying to destroy the world.

craggy pilot
#

oh i responded to wrong person sry ๐Ÿ˜„

#

was responding to @blazing condor

blazing condor
#

๐Ÿ™‚

icy shale
#

whirlwind and slam

#

worth at any time?

blazing condor
#

no

sonic jungle
#

Should i use the spark of ingenuety and craft something, or just save it?

lyric geode
icy shale
#

do we just not put them on action bar

blazing condor
#

we dont

lyric geode
craggy pilot
sick sentinel
#

can i enter DF at 58

lyric geode
sick sentinel
#

in desperate need of a gathering toon, so im levling up high mountain

fading tide
#

Weak aura is just an easier way to see your CDs correct?

lyric geode
cobalt seal
#

Yes

merry umbra
craggy pilot
earnest nymph
#

You only have to buy the max quality setting to add the 3rd socket

lyric geode
#

?

craggy pilot
earnest nymph
#

You can buy one low quality, one medium, and one max quality setting to get three sockets

craggy pilot
earnest nymph
#

Yarp

spring holly
#

wrong discord I know but this is the only wow discord I'm in. Can anyone tell me why some enchants seem to be more expensive with no difference in quality? Like writ of leech is 75 leech at 1 star and 75 leech at 3 star yet the 3 star version is WAY more expensive

lyric geode
#

3 star gives 125 leech

craggy pilot
spring holly
#

ah ok that'll do it, thanks all!

craggy pilot
#

AH quality of enchants is bugged, showing lowest quality

bitter stag
#

anyone has a macro to cast Demoralizing Shout inside the rotation?

#

or GC is a limit?

lyric geode
#

GC is limit

spring holly
#

other question that actually does pertain to prot, waking stats vs sustained str, waking stats seems like it's actually marginally more dmg since it gives more str? Or is that another tooltip thing

spring holly
lyric geode
#

I would choose the strength stamina one

#

for protection

ionic fern
#

Wrooong answer.

jagged pier
#

u take waking

#

100% of the time

lyric geode
#

But for 30 strength?

ionic fern
#

Over some stamina?

#

Yes.

jagged pier
#

โ˜๏ธ

lyric geode
#

210 stamina?

#

Weird

jagged pier
#

thats like 100 hp

lyric geode
#

I guess.

jagged pier
#

strength is also armour which is also strength which is also then armour

spring holly
#

@lyric geode I think the reasoning is that stam is almost never something that holds you back, whereas more str helps. Minor in the end

jagged pier
#

no just stam is not worse it u have enough from gear

#

like theres a reason we never use stam flasks

#

since like vanilla

lyric geode
#

but anyway.

lyric geode
lyric geode
#

Finally a different gif other than bugs bunny no.

#

Quite impressed by your improvements

jagged pier
#

there was no context to use no there

neon elk
#

Is it me or are gems actualy quite expensive ?

lyric geode
zealous anchor
#

whats the stat prio for prot now?

jagged pier
jagged pier
dusk moth
#

ilvl is the prio

lyric geode
jagged pier
#

free please stop spreading the wrong information

#

its getting annoying

slim dove
lyric geode
#

ilvl > haste > crit = vers > mastery
How is that different?

neon elk
#

And i assume that wrathion neck is still not socketable right ?

jagged pier
#

thats the second time in 2 days u have got the stat prio wrong

earnest nymph
#

You wrote two different things

jagged pier
#

they are not the same

lyric geode
noble lynx
#

is this guy still leaking his iq

jagged pier
#

right okay thats fine but if as you say yourself are a noob u should not be answering questions

lyric geode
#

But even a noob doesnt have the right to express its opinion? Maybe next time, I will just copy paste the pins just for it to be certain.

earnest nymph
#

You didnโ€™t express an opinion

noble lynx
#

when people seek help they dont seek opinion, they seek the correct answer

earnest nymph
#

You stated incorrect information

jagged pier
#

i mean we literally went through a whole discussion with u on stats yesterday or the other day, so i dont know how thats your opinion

blazing condor
#

we have a " pins " for a reaosn

lyric geode
earnest nymph
#

โ€ฆno?

noble lynx
#

everything is relative, look at me, im smart

lyric geode
earnest nymph
#

Alright letโ€™s just stop

#

This is going nowhere fast

noble lynx
#

it was coming from nowhere anways

neon gulch
#

are there any recommended items to craft with spark this week?

torn gulch
#

i would hold off the spark for now

#

or if you want to craft prob shield or weapon

mellow quartz
#

neck when someone gets the recipe

#

and when you can find someone to craft it for you

torn gulch
#

that's one of them yes

#

hopefull recipe is not like 1% drop

neon gulch
#

any particular reason for waiting? is it to wait for more info?

torn gulch
#

it is to wait for a raid clear m+ farm and maybe a vault and then craft what you need

#

but it's not necesary

deft mortar
#

where them prot nerfs

molten rivet
#

Coming back to prot warrior is confusing-- am I crazy, or did they re-introduce party/raid-wide shieldwall? Which Talent (and where) is doing that?

deft mortar
#

think that was a shadowlansd legendary or smth anyway Tuft

molten rivet
#

DARN!

torn gulch
#

we had it until it was removed

cobalt seal
torn gulch
#

because it was too strong

cobalt seal
#

it would still be my opinion

molten rivet
#

My god... and for 5 minutes there I felt useful!

torn gulch
#

it wasa broken

neon gulch
#

you are still extremely useful ๐Ÿ™‚

jagged pier
#

cro leave it

cobalt seal
#

when you beat nome in dps

lyric geode
cobalt seal
#

Neither did I said you said

earnest nymph
#

Please just leave it alone

lyric geode
#

I state very clear ilvl>haste>critical/versa>mastery

#

Well maybe the >>>>>>>>>>> will be an overstatement

jagged pier
#

u didnt

#

but okay

cobalt seal
lyric geode
#

I mean yes, but look

novel temple
#

I feel like the stat priority in the guides should differentiate between an offensive and defensive stat priority though

lyric geode
#

Critical being better than versa is a fact.

#

so can we all agree and move on?

mighty valley
#

i thought everything was relative

cobalt seal
lyric geode
#

I mean everything was relative. But the earth isnt flat.

#

Anyway enough of these philosophical questions

mighty valley
#

i might be an earth shape noob, but does that mean i can't share my opinion that the earth is flat

slim dove
mighty valley
#

ok ok i'm done

slim dove
#

you stated something wrong

#

you got corrected

#

deal with it

lyric geode
#

There is no point of arguing that.

slim dove
#

cool

lyric geode
#

We can agree on that

slim dove
#

drop it

lyric geode
#

I dropped it

cobalt seal
#

I'm already gone

slim dove
#

drop it

noble lynx
#

i heard its coming with the catchup world quest gear or what

torn gulch
#

nope it's a chest drop

#

from primal storms

#

chest drop

noble lynx
#

oh

#

LOL

#

lootbox?

torn gulch
#

it's a the end of the event

near pewter
#

What Phial are you guys using in raids?

loud patrol
#

well idk since i havent been in a raid

#

unless there was an early open of vault that idk about

dusky silo
#

Can someone give me a crash course in Warrior tanking?

#

Like just some basics i should know that might not stand on wowhead

mighty valley
#

keep up shield block all the time, press your rage generating buttons whenever you can, fill the rest with Revenge

#

press IP whenever your rage is high, try to never let yourself hit the rage cap

#

use your damage CDs whenever they're up

loud patrol
#

use battle stance

dusky silo
#

why?

loud patrol
#

nah fr use it theres no reason to use defensive stance until like high ccontent or specific mechanics

mighty valley
#

we're very sturdy right now and generally don't need to be in def stance, so use battle stance by default and learn when you actually need to switch

near pewter
#

Any idea why icyveins is recommening glacial fury vial for raid if it only last for 15s on single target?

near pewter
jagged pier
#

๐Ÿคท used it on beta fine

#

havent seen any changes on it

loud patrol
#

theres no BV bug if a target dummy hits you but the bug still exist

deft mortar
#

kekw Dstance used to be something to sit in in BFA

#

except when u are bursting

#

then back to dstance

#

good ole

#

wait this is protection channel mb thought this was pvp

loud patrol
#

lol

near pewter
novel temple
#

anger management, the wall, and what else?

solar crown
#

anyone know the proc chance on the battle scarred scale-trinket?

loud patrol
#

:c

slim dove
#

thats a pretty crazy amount of procs

#

6 ppm?

#

jesus

sick sentinel
#

is the prot apl updated / public?

mellow quartz
#

was abt 5% dps

loud patrol
slim dove
#

its 6ppm before the 15% buff it gets per target

loud patrol
#

oh

mellow quartz
#

then if you wanna see glacial fury on tree boss in AA for example

#

it's a 'pretty good' flash lol

slim dove
#

what about overall in a less meme dungeon?

rugged root
#

where can i look to see the bis crafted items for prot?

mellow quartz
spice radish
#

who is that guy crystar from twistingnether asking for 150k for 1 craft???

#

selling a shield with a shit embelish as the best embelish

jagged pier
#

just find a different crafter most of the ones ive used havent charged

mellow quartz
#

it's a 'free market' if someone wants to pay that then he will sell it at that price ๐Ÿคทโ€โ™‚๏ธ

slim dove
#

fangblades-illidan

severe steeple
#

150k for just a craft ridiculus

slim dove
#

100/100 bs with shield spec

vapid mountain
#

so whats everyone playing now since prot warr is killed and buried

mellow quartz
mellow quartz
#

then its smart business

coral marsh
#

isnt 150k not even a single wowtoken?

severe steeple
mellow quartz
#

whats your point?

#

not everyone is you

#

some people dont care abt money

#

if you don't wanna pay his prices then don't, quite simple lol

severe steeple
#

my point was 150k for just a craft is ridiculus. esp with something common as that

mellow quartz
#

look at ebay, you can always ask for the moon. Doesn't mean you get it lol

spice radish
#

done my craft with another guy, he asked for just 5k gold and he told me next craft will be free . wished me a good night too

dusky silo
#

Is there like a macro i can use to switch between offensive and defensive stance by the press of a button?

wary heath
#

Yes

mellow quartz
#

see pins

dusky silo
#

thanks

strong forum
#

sims on raidbots are working

novel temple
strong forum
#

have been working since DF launch

mellow quartz
#

just don't look at that trinket that gives you a shield by doing damage to you

strong forum
#

yeah dont look too closely at trinkets

sick sentinel
#

finally got my mining high mountain to 60

#

he's pretty much destined to mining slave forever now, or at least a day or 2

tender cove
fluid beacon
#

Maybe I am blind but we don't have a Raid or Crafting BIS list yet yea? Wowhead only shows pre-raid stuff

strong forum
#

wont happen either

#

atleast on icyveins

#

dunno about wowhead tho

#

if there are plans for that

fluid beacon
#

Why's that? Because there isn't a "BIS" list and we just go for ilvl > stats?

slim zinc
#

^

fluid beacon
#

but thats so boring and not exciting :(((((

strong forum
#

theyre pointless

slim zinc
#

A "bis" list is only realistically bis if you have every single piece at max ilvl with sockets and leech procs

tender cove
#

Only thing fun about gear is getting wep, shield, trinkets and potentially OP items like legendary. Any other slot really dont matter for me at least.

fluid beacon
#

"This is not a targeted indirect buff to Pwar."

#

what do you mean by this @strong forum

strong forum
#

the intend was not to make pwar better

fluid beacon
#

the "nerf" isnt hitting us as hard as other tanks?

#

therefore it seems like a buff compared to other tanks?

mellow quartz
#

people see pwar only getting 5% in bstance vs 10% for other tanks

fluid beacon
#

that what you are saying?

strong forum
#

yes

fluid beacon
#

ok, understood. thank you!

strong forum
#

alot of people twisted it that way

#

so i included it

mellow quartz
#

disregard the 5% to def stance and that its irrelevant if you are not in def stance to begin with as you are not worried abt damage intake then

fluid beacon
#

i didnt think it was that big a deal either. when i first read the "nerfs" i mentioned it in my Guild disc as well. i dont think itll be such a big deal

strong forum
#

it isnt

#

but people made it a big deal

#

so i got pissed

mellow quartz
#

if everyone got nerfed by 10% then no one got nerfed

fluid beacon
#

yea, i find it hard to believe that ill be in D stance ever unless its to mitigate a 1 time big hit or something

#

or maybe in giant keys

strong forum
#

the worrysome part is the reasoning behind that nerf

fluid beacon
#

yea

strong forum
#

"tanks being too strong brings negative effects"

fluid beacon
#

tanks being able to outlast in m0

strong forum
#

"healers want to heal tanks"

fluid beacon
#

before anything of difficulty even got released

#

lol

strong forum
#

no they dont want to heal tanks

fluid beacon
#

exactly

#

ive never heard any of my healers complain

#

theyd rather DPS weave during healing

strong forum
#

the only people "hurt" by strong tanks are butthurt ego dps players

fluid beacon
#

its a lot more engaging

#

yes

strong forum
#

but theyre not butthurt enough to play tank

fluid beacon
#

agreed

sick sentinel
#

despite the nerfs and whatnot, a high haste build will compensate very sufficiently

strong forum
#

so...

#

youd play a high haste build regardless

#

its our best stat

strong forum
#

always has been

sturdy sable
fluid beacon
sick sentinel
#

this is the expansion which has pwarriors getting pi. im glad

fluid beacon
#

"Haste isnt your best stat"

sturdy sable
#

Its "not our job"

fluid beacon
#

lol

hollow token
#

I bet those people donโ€™t play at a high level

mellow quartz
strong forum
#

surely theyd enjoy that ๐Ÿ™‚

#

its not like history has proven multiple times, that the game is the healthiest and best when tanks have been strong

#

weird how that worked out

sturdy sable
#

^

sick sentinel
#

something tells me prot warrior will be high on the list of tanks in subcreation

strong forum
#

ofc

slim dove
#

rn youve got jealous dps that tanks can pull all of obsidian citadel and not have their hp bars move

strong forum
#

pwar is super strong

#

and super easy

mellow quartz
#

they didn't nerf tanks damage though, just survivability

strong forum
#

so itll be popular

mellow quartz
#

so why talk abt damage lol

tender cove
# strong forum "tanks being too strong brings negative effects"

I said this a week ago, community perception is very dangerous and such a big shift as we saw will have consqeuneues and here we are.
Just wait 2-3 more weeks for people to bitch about how hard 20's are and how they are entitled to those rewards because they could do 15's.
While complaining about nobody wants to tank. Just wait ๐Ÿ˜„

jagged pier
sick sentinel
#

im spamming heroic dungeons for fun this week and ive had mostly around 8 dps doing more dmg than me

#

im always at 35k dps with 360 ilvl

sturdy sable
strong forum
#

my guy

#

first week

#

will be terror

#

its fortified raging

#

every single tank discord will explode with people whining

jagged pier
#

โ˜๏ธ

mellow quartz
#

to be fair we dont know rotation

#

its just a guess now

jagged pier
#

we do know it

tender cove
strong forum
#

pretty sure theyre blizzard announced affixes

mellow quartz
#

no one said it was same as beta

strong forum
#

no

#

its not

#

but blizzard literally said the affixes

#

its fort raging bursting week 1

#

and i think tyr grievous explosive week 2

#

๐Ÿ™‚

mellow quartz
#

when did they do that?

sick sentinel
#

i rerolled from being a brewmaster since bfa and shadowlands. im so sad to watch brewmaster lose class participation for the coming months

strong forum
#

couple weeks ago

#

they released the full affix rotation

#

okay its fort raging quaking

#

then tyr bursting grievous

#

okay its not blizzard confirmed

#

but could very well be

mellow quartz
#

its just a guestimate

slim dove
#

im excited ๐Ÿคท

#

give me a hard first week

strong forum
#

yeah, i kinda hope and dont hope that we have fort raging week 1

sick sentinel
#

prot warrior feels so much better than brewmaster

strong forum
#

cuz it would be hilarious

mellow quartz
#

didn't we have fort raging quaking week 1 of SL?

strong forum
#

uuuuh

#

dont think so

#

lemme check

sturdy sable
strong forum
#

quaking + fort yes

mellow quartz
#

or was it inspiring?

long stone
#

Wednesday time for Neck ... hopefully...

strong forum
#

it was fort bursting volc

mellow quartz
#

easiest week

strong forum
#

yeah

mellow quartz
#

no weeks look easy in DF though

#

which is fine with me

sick sentinel
mellow quartz
#

if they are all hard in some way so you dont have a 'this is the week' thing

tender cove
mellow quartz
#

damn brew and their shield block

sick sentinel
#

i dont see the similarities sry

jagged pier
#

thats a take

tender cove
#

How about their roll and how it fixed charge pathing? How about their death touch which was a warrior ability? And its been so many years i've forgot a lot but its a literal list of things they stole from warrior.

mellow quartz
#

I don't even see 1 single thing that is a carry over

tender cove
jagged pier
#

im sorry but u can charge safely where u cant roll

mellow quartz
#

we are talking abt brew now though

sick sentinel
#

wrong expansion dude

tender cove
#

My point was that warrior SHOULD feel better. Not what expansion it is.

mellow quartz
#

yeah that makes no sense

strong forum
#

the similarities between brew and pwar have always been:
the have the same strength and weaknessess

#

atleast prior to DF

#

strong vs physical, weak vs sustained magical/dots

sick sentinel
#

all tanks SHOULD feel better than their weakest self

#

thats a better take

thin silo
#

Also both with strong mobility

fluid beacon
#

Biggest issue I've seen so far in general m0 is general raid wide damage from just a whole lot of pulsing uninterruptible damage

strong forum
#

yes

#

for the DPS

fluid beacon
#

It's doing a lot of damage to all non tanks

strong forum
#

theyre gonna be the ones struggling

#

not the tanks

fluid beacon
#

And is shredding them

strong forum
#

people forget that m+ is about your group, not just the tank

fluid beacon
#

And tanks laugh at it

sick sentinel
#

im sure in keys the pulls will become less big

fluid beacon
#

It wasn't really like that before

mellow quartz
#

a LOT of the aoe damage you are experiencing is related to people not doing mechanics properly and people doing stupidly large pulls

fluid beacon
#

Tanks are super tanky

#

Rather than nerf tanks nerf the non stop raid wide damage

dusky silo
fluid beacon
#

Or make non dps tankier

sick sentinel
mellow quartz
dusky silo
mellow quartz
#

read the wowhead guide

strong forum
#

most of our rage comes from CDs and shield slam

fluid beacon
#

I can't see it staying like this. Enraged mobs pulsing damage

#

On fort weeks

mellow quartz
#

it was to easy

strong forum
#

enraged dragons in RLP

#

๐Ÿ™‚

fluid beacon
#

And if they don't it'll artificially slow down keys a ton which isn't fun

strong forum
#

enraged RLP in general

#

is gonna be so fun

mellow quartz
#

just bring an evoker 4 head

strong forum
#

stormcaller? -> wipe

#

dragon? -> wipe

dusky silo
#

Do i like even use whirlwind? Like ever?

mellow quartz
#

aoe soothe

mellow quartz
sick sentinel
strong forum
#

i recommend reading the pins feruna, theres some info in there

mellow quartz
#

if you have no idea abt the basics then better read a guide before asking questions here tbh

strong forum
#

if you scroll down

sick sentinel
#

@dusky silo i can show you my overall dps from my last heroic as well as my talent tree build

fluid beacon
tropic sundial
#

I fully expect dps not bringing soothe/decurses/cc because it's a "dps loss" in the talent tree and then cry about dying to trash mechanics

fluid beacon
#

One of them pulsing on a 20

dusky silo
strong forum
#

m+ is gonna be a shit show

jagged pier
#

pugging m+ is gunna be a shit show

mellow quartz
#

you can inspect them before key starts

#

no kick or soothe on raging weeks = kick

fluid beacon
#

Nobody has kicks anymore. Nobody wants to spec into cc

loud patrol
#

low key modify dps trees in wow head and icy veins to include all utility

sick sentinel
#

@dusky silo i know that you have the wowhead one, but you can use mine for reference

mellow quartz
#

have a WA that warns if someone hasnt talented kick or something ๐Ÿ™‚

fluid beacon
#

Hell I am missing AOE fear

#

I always always used it. Prot or dps

sick sentinel
#

its a heroic one so thats not the best picture

tropic sundial
mellow quartz
jagged pier
#

its bad

sick sentinel
#

its the most ideal casual build that i feel comfortable with

#

use it because it has a lot of defensive options

#

one sec

loud patrol
#

not using roar

sweet summit
#

sussy

mellow quartz
#

builds are literally in the pins in this channel

jagged pier
#

im sorry but that is ummm

#

not good

tropic sundial
#

No roar no ravager

loud patrol
#

no ravager wtf

mellow quartz
#

BSV for m0s?

jagged pier
#

unbreakable will

#

where the wall is more defensive

deep steppe
#

Are the Cobalt Rep Ring(s) good for us?

sick sentinel
#

ravager has a 50% less usability and is lower in the dps list

mellow quartz
fluid beacon
#

I also asked why his revenge is so high

sick sentinel
#

shockwave is a big win as well as shield charge

fluid beacon
#

In raidbots revenge is always swimming highest damage done but that's not true

#

For me it's always tclap by far followed by rend

deep steppe
mellow quartz
sick sentinel
#

yeah both stun and low cd

mellow quartz
sick sentinel
#

ideal for defense

novel temple
#

I wanna dps on a healer while rotating through CDs to heal

loud patrol
fluid beacon
#

Tclap is hugely important. Especially with thunder lord

strong forum
fluid beacon
#

Shield slam being your highest damage done?

mellow quartz
fluid beacon
#

I am in a full bleed spec

strong forum
#

doesnt matter

fluid beacon
#

In another setup I think rend was 3rd or 4th

sick sentinel
#

im gonna try the bleed spec too

strong forum
#

rend should not be higher than revenge

sick sentinel
#

but not for now

jagged pier
fluid beacon
#

Well it is for me lmao.

jagged pier
#

everyone has a stun

mellow quartz
#

you guys realize this has all been tried and tested on beta right? there is no need to 'try' anything

jagged pier
#

and u shouldnt be using a stun as a dps cd

sick sentinel
mellow quartz
#

which would do more for you

strong forum
#

its good for dps, but it doesnt take much to figure out that spending 3 points to make 1 ability good is not