#Buff hmelee crafteds/ings

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

dreamy grove
#

buff hmelee ings for crafteds or at least reduce the requirements for them as a quick bandaid patch
ironwood chips are the best melee % ing by far, but at a 24 req per use it stacks up quickly. reducing by 4 to make it a solid 20 would make it more usable in hmelee crafted builds, allowing for more variety in builds rather than just non crafteds being literally better 9/10 times!

another thing that should be buffed/changed regarding melee crafteds is the raw melee ings. Literally there is no raw melee ing that is worth putting in in place of ironwood chips which feels kind bad being forced to just use melee % damage on crafteds where there should be a variety of damage types to be able to use in crafteds, since right now youre forced to meet this 170% melee % threshold to be better than a noncrafted.

I feel like crafteds when used and built properly should lead to a dps increase in most cases, but again, this is very hard to do with hmelee because of how bad the ings are to use.
items with a high enough base dps will make use of the 170% melee crafteds (something like https://wynnbuilder.github.io/crafter/#4aZCSCSCSCSCSec81), which requires a whopping 140 str req, not achievable in most situations. While argued I can flip blackholes (something like https://wynnbuilder.github.io/crafter/#4KZucOaSOWnCSec81), yes only 82 str req, you get 145% melee, which will in turn do less than a noncrafted even with high base.
basically for the insane req youre not getting your worth of the crafted in almost every case.
like

vague steppe
#

please buff H melee im begging for twains arc to be a real play style

dreamy grove
#

"curse of tier flipping"
@crystal knoll be so fr this is an ing problem. flipping neg tiers to get something like +3 tiers shouldnt be a thing, them getting punished from higher melee % numbers is just a wom womp for them (get it)
this is the common 1 tier helmet https://wynnbuilder.github.io/crafter/#4KQKZKQWcWcWpec81 which isnt even flipped and is fair. There is literally no issue with this request.

vague steppe
#

This isnt a non issue, getting raw melee is not worth from any crafts leaving builds to be more static and lame

#

oh shit i misread what you said im an idoit

dreamy grove
#

responding to a deleted message :D

vague steppe
#

THE VOICEE IB MY HEAD THEE VOICESSS

#

axiom crafted rings are literally just x6 silver bullets because H melee has so little ing nothing is worth effecting so you just stack thunder dmg and a tiny amout of raw melee. THAT IS A BORING BRAIN DEAD CRAFT BECAUSE THERE ARE LIKE ZERO OTHER OPTIONS

dreamy grove
#

my crafted version vs non crafted i think does just shy of like 5% more per twains which is so little beacuse i cant even replace every piece, as noncrafted is literally the better option most of the time

#

5% considering how twains does so little rn is bad

stuck hawk
sick crown
#

wild

teal nimbus
#

your recipes are shit are you even trying

#

not a single soul looks at this and thinks "yea thats the best i can get!"

#

this is what i can do

#

if youre gonna make a post complaining about hmelee ings being too weak at least take the time to put together a thought out recipe instead of slapping a meta-ing and 5 of the things you wanna buff and yap

#

i posted 169% at 90 str

dreamy grove
#

send the recipe lmao screenshots do nothing

teal nimbus
dreamy grove
#

whats the dura on it, what are the other reqs, u sending 2 screenshots of numbers does not a lot

dreamy grove
#

other reqs?

#

even then you cant argue this is BARELY better than a noncrafted lmao

teal nimbus
teal nimbus
dreamy grove
#

yea its really not but that was my attempt

#

but if theres other reqs urs and is 'feasible' it might not be worth using that much either

teal nimbus
#

for reference whats the noncrafted your comparing it to?

dreamy grove
#

depends?
chestplate taurus beats literally any crafted
boots dbreak is the best, but theres the def requirement
if ur going thunder build impossiblity threshold or withering are insane
it depends on ur build?

teal nimbus
#

and the build is strong (for pfinder in bursts)

dreamy grove
#

yea your build does, what about other builds that arent just et(some other element)

#

again not a lot of variety with recipes regardless if ur crafted works on your niche build

teal nimbus
vague steppe
#

is this point not literally saying iron chips are basically the only option. Making and iron chips recipe isnt helping your point to proving “theres enough options” for this to not be an issue

dreamy grove
#

yes but im assuming theres another req on ur crafted which isnt viable on pure et

teal nimbus
dreamy grove
#

no bc u wont say LMAOOOO thats my point

#

u gatekeeping doesnt help if ur trying to prove a point

#

bc it makes me assume theres an insane other req that not every other et build can take

vague steppe
#

If youre talking abour iron chips, not really its just stregth. You are locked into str builds but thats about it

#

(this knowledge comes from trying to make Bignis) (Hmelee ignis) (its fun but having over 200% melee abd still inly getting 200k twains arc is depressing)

dreamy grove
#

depends bc some effectiveness ings have reqs too, if you flip something like a dizzying void just bc of how the recipe is youre forced to have sp in defense

teal nimbus
dreamy grove
#

et is base for most hmelee as you said, so most will have almost all sp in earth and thunder

vague steppe
teal nimbus
#

however i am gatekeeping it for a reason...

neon cobalt
#

Keep hmelee bad

dreamy grove
#

mb for using a hyperbole, but regardless theres another req that not every other et build can use

vague steppe
#

gatekeeping recipe is stupid anyways, its basically saying i found skmething broken that CT are going to nerf if they find out. Its bad for the comminity in every single way

vague steppe
teal nimbus
neon cobalt
vague steppe
#

battery im gonna party bomb ur next annie

dreamy grove
teal nimbus
dreamy grove
#

so why do you do it 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭

vague steppe
#

i think wynn should have a basic guide on effectiveness and neg flip stuff. Its one of the biggest gate keep in wynn crafting jmo

teal nimbus
vague steppe
#

again this is just negtive fir the health of the game

teal nimbus
#

granted not ALL of them are gatekept recipe but at least 1/3rd should be

teal nimbus
dreamy grove
#

dernics so cheap rn be so fr 😭 i have like a page just sitting waiting to be put on the tm

teal nimbus
#

its not like im sharing gatekept recipes/builds with other people also gatekeeping, this is all individual work

vague steppe
#

me when deric use to be 7le each 😭

teal nimbus
#

it does happen but ultimately i take pride in my own work

dreamy grove
#

regardless i feel like gatekeeping is just such an unhealthy thing for the game but i get that others do it so wtv 🤷‍♂️ thats not what this post is about

teal nimbus
#

and it feels really shit when your recipe is halved

teal nimbus
vague steppe
#

i mean this is more a problem with the design team not being able to balamce ing

#

baddest

#

what rings would you make for axiom that isnt just x6 silver bullets?

dreamy grove
teal nimbus
#

im spamming bonfire rn bcs its peak game

vague steppe
#

thunder Hmelee bow with twains arc MID. Currebtly best twains arc bow for dmg

dreamy grove
#

bro here just to argue not actually have convo

vague steppe
#

fr i kinda agree with op

teal nimbus
#

just like you give constructive feedback on hmelee ings i give constructive feedback on how to build

dreamy grove
#

debate u constantly go off topic didnt even read the discussion post

#

you clicked on a link and said "ew bad crafted" and argued

vague steppe
#

dude jusy admit h melee could use more ing

teal nimbus
#

this one right

vague steppe
#

yes

dreamy grove
#

axiom epoch are the main reason i made this post yes but across all hmelee it can be improved

vague steppe
#

^ i became an axiom gamer after my post about adding in “360”

dreamy grove
#

its such a fun playstyle shame it cant be in a better spot
not saying its not viable bc it defintely is but defintely room for improvement compared to other playstyles

vague steppe
#

baddest ill link u my axiom build when im home but ive tried pretty hard to make it as best as possible and crafts can add about 10k extra to my twains. It might be build issue but again i agree with Op i couldnt find almost anything that made it worth it to use crafts over the massive base attack dmg added from normal items like writhing growth or taurus

teal nimbus
vague steppe
#

is alka melee dead aswell? I havent seen any builds recently that actually utilize melee in any sort of way that classes can abuse spells. Twains seems to be the only thing close to a melee focus build and it is very lacking compared to almlst snytbing else in the game

forest cloud
#

alka tstack

dreamy grove
#

ts dead 😭

teal nimbus
vague steppe
dreamy grove
#

jewling fr just spamming + lunar charm

teal nimbus
dreamy grove
#

occasional doom stone 😭

teal nimbus
#

(not that its any better since numbers are too low)

vague steppe
#

baddest ive seen recipe for like 60% nelee %60 spell but those always look like clickbait to me i need mkre experimve cause i never seem to be able to fit them into “real” builds

#

for Tailor and armoring *

dreamy grove
#

u can get these 'low req builds' but are so niche bc they have other reqs or lower dura that people just dont wanna say

teal nimbus
#

(or a number higher than 60 in jeweling really)

teal nimbus
vague steppe
#

nooooo (i think 25-35 is decent enough)

#

either neg flip +int -spell. Or just juicing up lunar charms

teal nimbus
vague steppe
#

I might ask ur help/opnions when im home about my axiom build

teal nimbus
vague steppe
#

its friday night fir me still 😭

teal nimbus
#

do note ive only ever played tstack for archer but i assume the premise is the same

#

i remember the hmelee rings were like vortexian horizon whatever the item name is

#

and it had disturbing amounts of melee% and i think 0 reqs or negative reqs, i dont remember

forest cloud
#

no longera thing

teal nimbus
#

yea curse you linny

forest cloud
#

best is probably flipped naval

#

or silver bullet

#

or flipped elytra if ur a psychopath

teal nimbus
#

have you tried the epoch rings or is that too low number

vague steppe
#

U have ti admit “optimal” T H melee rings being just x6 silver bullets is absolutely the most lame thing ever

forest cloud
#

28% melee is fine

#

what else can u use anyway

teal nimbus
#

i believe youre already using this in your axiom bulid but this item is goated

forest cloud
#

like lost seconds 😭

#

or scrap amalgam

teal nimbus
forest cloud
#

aestival is bugged

teal nimbus
forest cloud
#

not 40 %

teal nimbus
forest cloud
#

abominator is pretty cool

teal nimbus
#

but i wasnt one to complain

vague steppe
# teal nimbus

this isnt helping your argument that base items are almost 100x better than trying to figure iut crafts (also im a major idiot how did i not see these when looking 😭 disgregaurd maybe like half of ehat ive been talking abkut)

teal nimbus
forest cloud
#

i was thinking rings

teal nimbus
#

most items after the 2nd row are irrelevant

forest cloud
#

the ring situation is not that good

vague steppe
#

perfect chance to add “360” on a Mid on a ring is what im hearing

forest cloud
#

also a perfect chance to use crafteds

#

idk i feel like crafteds dont need to be super great

#

crafteds can just fill that niche spot

#

in a few builds

teal nimbus
dreamy grove
#

whats the point of crafteds then 😭 you put in a lot of work to make them and also have to repair for no benefit then

forest cloud
#

its better is certain situations

#

but not just a slap for everything

dreamy grove
#

so we should stick to noncrafteds in most cases, doesnt this mean less variety

vague steppe
dreamy grove
#

i feel like you should be able to go either way, at least have crafteds have even power as non crafteds

forest cloud
#

it really just depends on the situation

#

u can go far with a good crafted

tranquil chasm
#

curse of ingredient flipping 🥀
it wouldd be nice for more hmlee ings to become available that arent absolutely busted for tstack im sure linny could cook usomething up eventually tm

dreamy grove
#

yes i get that crafteds shouldnt be better in every situation, but right now crafteds for hmelee specifically is especially weak and doesnt have a niche

forest cloud
#

erm but they do

dreamy grove
#

where

forest cloud
#

just ask any oblivion hmelee fan

#

or animo

jade silo
vague steppe
forest cloud
#

they have some weird crafted stuff that is better

dreamy grove
#

hmelee shade is kinda killed with the rage changes no? quake doesnt do as much

forest cloud
#

no?

dreamy grove
#

even then the crafteds for that hmelee are different than a twains hmelee

forest cloud
#

if by killed u mean it can do longer do 8 digits

#

i guess

jade silo
#

some people still use it

vague steppe
dreamy grove
#

it certinaly does a lot less even if its not killed 🤷‍♂️
u do what 7m quakes every like 6 seconds which is fair ig

forest cloud
#

there is a use for all ts weird hmelee stuff

#

maybe would be better to specify

dreamy grove
#

blending earth into ur armor is not the same as spamming ironwood chips

#

ironwood chips are the only useful melee damage ing no?

forest cloud
#

there is cursed wings

#

searing heartwood maybe

vague steppe
#

i dont think ive ever seen a cursed wing craft

forest cloud
#

mostly just the elemental stuff

dreamy grove
#

20% vs the 30% on ironwood chips

forest cloud
#

lower reqs to get tighter sp

dreamy grove
#

less dmg i just go uncrafted

forest cloud
#

to fill the gaps between each ironwood chip

dreamy grove
#

why not just use more ironwood chips whar 😭 or an uncrafted which does more dmg

vague steppe
#

^skill point req if u wanted to use different armor

forest cloud
#

so u supplement with something weaker with lower reqs

dreamy grove
#

so i just use uncrafted instead of cursed wings though bc cursed wings does less in hmelee

forest cloud
#

no

#

u can mix ings

dreamy grove
#

its the same loop,
too high req -> diffrent ing less dmg -> uncrafted

forest cloud
#

no

vague steppe
#

im agreeing eith op kn this acrually

forest cloud
#

u can do like 3 ironwood 3 cursed for example

dreamy grove
#

as u said in the im thread you need 170% melee to be about par with uncrafteds
how do i get this with cursed wings

forest cloud
#

its not the same as 6 ironwood or nothing

dreamy grove
#

im not getting the threshold to do more than an uncrafted here

forest cloud
#

unless u use impossibility threshold

#

but then ur losing out on ehp

#

so its a sidegrade

#

its not about uncrafted vs crafteds here necessarily its moreso %dmg vs raw

dreamy grove
#

if i want to maximize dmg with crafteds i should be able to
not just impossibility threshold either, theres items like dbreak, taurus, obsidian helm the lsit goes on, its hard to beat these items

#

i cant build raw on crafteds theres no good options

forest cloud
#

hard pressed to find a crafted that can beat a mythic

dreamy grove
#

ok ignor dbreak, chestplate and helm options theres betetr options than crafteds

vague steppe
forest cloud
#

and even in spell builds there are powerhouse pieces like cannonade memento and sagittarius

#

that u cannot beat with a craft

dreamy grove
#

we're talking hmelee

forest cloud
#

yes

#

but clearly crafted is not always the solution

dreamy grove
#

it doesnt even have a niche in hmelee like you suggested it should, its jsut staright up worse

vague steppe
#

ok but we are sayung Hmelee options are boring and limited

dreamy grove
#

therse no variety in hmelee, its the same armor pieces

forest cloud
#

yea

dreamy grove
#

so shouldnt crafteds fill the gap of variety?

forest cloud
#

u can for accessories and leggings

#

and maybe helmets

vague steppe
#

Hiw woukd a “craftman” class deal with this saltroll

forest cloud
#

u cant melee on craftsman

vague steppe
#

u can still twains 😭😭😭😭😭

dreamy grove
forest cloud
#

what leggngs do u use

vague steppe
#

writhing growth

dreamy grove
#

impossibility, yes im sacraficing hp, but its impossible to make a higher dps crafted

vague steppe
#

huge base m helee boost

forest cloud
#

erm well do u see the issue

dreamy grove
#

if i want more hp i could just writhing growth no?

forest cloud
#

u are sacking hp

dreamy grove
#

writhing growth still does more and i have hp

#

im min maxing dps here lol

forest cloud
#

if ur min maxing

#

crafted is not always the solution

dreamy grove
#

i believe crafted should have a place, but it literally doesnt..? do i just go writhing or impossibility? like what

forest cloud
#

it does have a place on assassin tho

dreamy grove
#

so not on archer lets just ignore an entire class 😭

#

lets all play quake hmelee guys who likes twains or alka (is that a thing) hmelee anyawys

forest cloud
#

alka has no slots

#

also warrior hmelee is just not a thing

dreamy grove
#

idk example, therse other hmelee but ive been messing with axiom epoch so thats where my examples are from

#

regardless crafteds have no niche within the archer hmelee playstyle, not for hp or dps

#

this just means that hmelee crafteds need to be readjusted or changed in general no?

vague steppe
#

i mean if h melee is workint on other classes its pretty clear archwr has such linited options even when a core part if its game play if fully centered aroundit. Just weird to me. Twains could 100% use more support

forest cloud
#

that would affect assassin and idk if they want to change that or smth

dreamy grove
#

imma be so fr idt assassin should have that high quakes 😭 the fact you can mega boost it with a good team too to just nearly 1 shot bosses seems unhealthy no?

#

if this is the case twains with wind prison should do 5m minimum!

forest cloud
#

its like 4 mil max

vague steppe
#

i think its fine for shade to basicslly one shot this if they have built up the stacks for it (imo)

forest cloud
#

with every relevant raid buff

#

and team buff

dreamy grove
#

ok 4 mil isnt bad then so a buff to hmelee isnt that much of a buff to assassin? countering your own argument here...

vague steppe
forest cloud
dreamy grove
#

do you agree hmelee crafteds/ings should get a change in some shape or form at least (the point of this thread) because theres some niches it cant fill?

vague steppe
#

sadly im not so sure abymore. Them bringing up t stack is a real thing to concider

dreamy grove
#

how would this bring up tstack?
also i didnt even ask for them to add onto the melee %, i just asked for a req adjustment at least 😭

vague steppe
#

how d u buff h melee without juicing T melee by way mkreb

forest cloud
#

crafted hmelee for thunder is just not gonna exist

vague steppe
#

why?

forest cloud
#

i dont like it but whatever

#

raw goes thunder

#

% is strength

vague steppe
dreamy grove
#

its terrible philosophy wtf😭

vague steppe
#

og whoops

forest cloud
#

% elemental is free reign

dreamy grove
#

so do we just not want twains to exist or whar

forest cloud
#

twains does exist

#

also stinger

vague steppe
#

i mean im not sure thats exactly a good idea. Seems like t H melee just uses bandaid patches to get what other H melee get ti do for free

dreamy grove
#

its a fun playstyle but again like ive said, it just doesnt put up to other playstyles (not saying its not viable bc it is)

forest cloud
#

i think everything is said in the context of axiom here

vague steppe
dreamy grove
#

axiom is objectively the best twains bow as of rn

forest cloud
#

but stinger has great synergy with assassin hmelee stuff

#

since both are quake centric

dreamy grove
#

it still does less ive tried building it (unless i did bad)

vague steppe
#

i mean if yall had an earth bow this convo would be way different

dreamy grove
#

also hitting quake is 10x harder 😭

forest cloud
#

always

dreamy grove
#

thats just powder, actual twains does less

forest cloud
#

and u have to rely on chains

dreamy grove
#

when i built it did maybe 200k more, for every 3 melees isnt worth the most

vague steppe
#

chain is free homing dmg and holding/gen focus. Thunder qol is WAY WAY MORE

forest cloud
#

does axiom do so much more dmg that 3 melees from axiom is worth 1 quake

dreamy grove
#

with spells yes

forest cloud
#

stinger has spells too

jade silo
forest cloud
#

if u want

dreamy grove
#

stinger spells again are a lot less

#

added up the 3 melees 3 phasing beams coursing restraint etc. it does less im pretty sure

vague steppe
#

B u use twains, insta thunder. Insta ghost trigger. Thus is much fastwr than builinf Quake and trying ti hit wuakes at max focus

forest cloud
#

also in practise ur not hitting much with those spells

dreamy grove
#

you cycle phasing beam between twains wdym, unless youre soloing or have aggro you should ideally hit everythiung

forest cloud
#

gonna be a few missing ticks of phray

dreamy grove
#

why what

forest cloud
#

cuz u need to move 😭

#

unless u just stare at the boss all the time

dreamy grove
#

again if you dont have aggro and are sitting where you dont have aggro you should ideally hit every beam every twains

#

you escape when you have aggro from any mob and do lose dps yes but in ideal situations

#

same is true for both stinger and axiom, but i believe axiom dmg from spells and twains is more than the pure quake dmg from stinger

forest cloud
#

ideal situations is cool but in practise trying to spell with hmelee is not practical

dreamy grove
#

more than not you can cycle phasing beam between twains which is ideal

#

unless you straight up dont have a team

vague steppe
#

No team means escape and GT every 3 seconds

dreamy grove
#

not even called phasing beam its called phantom ray 🙏 😭 cooked

vague steppe
#

easy to hold focus liek that

dreamy grove
#

THIS ISTN WHAT THIS THREAD IS ABOUT THO JUST PLS DO SOMETHIGN ABT HMELEE CRAFTEDS!!

forest cloud
#

it is tho because we are analysing where hmelee support is least

#

and its thunder hmelee

#

but like

#

there is a lot of support for earth hmelee

vague steppe
#

So buff T h melee

dreamy grove
#

even if stinger is better theres still a problem with crafteds since it doesnt fill the niche its supposed to with thunder hmelee no?

forest cloud
#

thunder hmelee will always be funky

vague steppe
#

esp after adding in the only good way to use twains is using thunder

dreamy grove
vague steppe
forest cloud
vague steppe
#

ITS THE BEST OPTIONS

forest cloud
#

epoch wasnt even hmelee in the first place

dreamy grove
#

epoch hmelee killed after that one patch sadge

#

literally halved its raw melee

vague steppe
#

u cant fault players for using uour items then going “why do they make making build with this so awkward”

forest cloud
#

raw melee

#

makes zero

#

difference

dreamy grove
#

what 😭

forest cloud
#

ur losing one whole ring of dps

#

which is not a lot to being with

vague steppe
#

raw melee is extremelt important for h melee what the F are u on about

dreamy grove
#

🤷‍♂️ it was more viable at one point for one reason or another

forest cloud
#

dawnbreak would not be dawnbreak without 2k raw

vague steppe
#

like in baltro. Yiu beed a certaib amlunt of chips or else your xmult is uskess

forest cloud
#

% is multiplicative on weapon base dmg

#

raw is addative

#

but like

#

u need to math it

#

so like is 500 raw better than 30% melee per se

#

its all just based on the pieces

#

and the weapon base

vague steppe
#

ubless im wrong sbkut how the dmg calc works again raw is so much worth. I make by build in builder abd compaired. T raw gets 117k twains basic % gets 105k

forest cloud
#

raw pieces usually just give so much % is not worth it

#

but with stuff like doomsday omen

#

the % is high enough it can beat raw

#

hmelee is just weird like that

vague steppe
#

ok so now we are sayinr crafted could use more raw ing. Silver bullets being the only option for axiom is stupid and is build limiting

#

or make a earth bow saltroll

forest cloud
#

stinger 🌈

#

stinger is all the elements

#

anyway

vague steppe
#

isnt stinger a legendary? Also thats like dayinf freedom skull

forest cloud
#

more raw is cool i dont really see an issue with current percent melee ings

vague steppe
#

That aint it cheif

forest cloud
#

and axiom is a fabled

#

both non mythic

vague steppe
#

yaaaa fable much closer to mythic than a lvl 90 legendary

forest cloud
#

not really how it works

#

stats is stats

#

rarity is whatever

vague steppe
#

b if u can make a stringer buikd have mkre than 100k twains ill eat my words. But that thing is 💩 imo

forest cloud
#

ok give me a moment

vague steppe
#

(fuck im thinking about cluster) (im still curious tho)

forest cloud
#

102k

#

not optimal

vague steppe
#

dawg taurus writhing growth bling trust…..

#

you not see the massive ankut of raw you are needing

forest cloud
#

doomsday omen is definitely better

vague steppe
#

this made me face palm so much

forest cloud
vague steppe
#

fine do it wouth raw cheating then

forest cloud
#

100+100 is gonna be better than 1x2

#

its all relative

#

hmelee pieces just favour raw over %

vague steppe
#

so i go back h melee uses raw so much more. Give crafts a reasonble way to get them

#

currently its get raw from items and gwt % from crafts. Thats limiting for builds and kinda boring

forest cloud
#

-tier raw thunder ing would be so weird tho

#

idk if they would do that

#

but epipelagic eye is a thing so...

vague steppe
#

then stop making twains bows be thunder

forest cloud
#

im fine with more thunder melee crafts

#

current hmelee ings fill that niche where % is overpowering to the point where the crazy raw melee numbers dont suffice

#

which is most meta hmelee daggers and a limited selection of bows

vague steppe
#

so h nelee is being abused by assassin and aecher suffers because if it?

#

thats kinda lame

forest cloud
#

basically

night hull
#

There will be infinitely more downsides to adding more heavy melee options than upsides

forest cloud
#

not earth has no support from crafteds

#

if u are earth

#

u have fun

vague steppe
#

I hate when people say blanlet statwments liek this and dint back it up by anything

night hull
#

Any feasible option will either make Sslow free on every build or will be flipped to make sfast easy as hell, i think ironwood is the perfect singular choice and should just be outclassed later on with new additions

forest cloud
#

searing heartwood 😔

dry cove
#

one big issue with hmelee ings in general is the fact that you can just flip them, so you run into some silly situation in balancing where you would sometimes either make something too strong or too weak on the flipped or non-flipped recipe

an ironwood chip buff is not entirely out of the question, however, reducing str req would mess up the req-cancel recipes that use ironwood chips, and increasing melee% would make flipped ironwood tier items a bit too weak (considering they arent even meta rn)

a better option in general is to release an alternative that doesnt cost strength rather than changing existing tier ingredients, which are kinda fucked up in terms of balancing anyway

forest cloud
#

elephelk req cancel 🤤

#

or urdars stone cancel 🤤

dry cove
night hull
#

oblivinyan wins once again

forest cloud
dry cove
vague steppe
#

tbh again why i go with buffing twains in the skill tree instead kf with items kr crafg

dreamy grove
#

can we make tiers unflippable 😭 ts so hard to balance

forest cloud
dry cove
#

unintuitive + its interesting how they are flippable

the melee ings just... need a lot of tuning

forest cloud
#

flipped ritual catalyst moment

dry cove
forest cloud
#

NOOOO

#

can ritual catalyst be buffed

#

55 int with nothing to show

night hull
#

8 mana steal

dry cove
forest cloud
dry cove
forest cloud
#

my ass dont war

#

actually lie

#

i warred yesterday

dry cove
#

whats current war meta again
divzer/cata/reso?

forest cloud
#

idk

#

i used

#

crabs reso

forest cloud
full gate
#

Woah I missed a huge hmelee discussion

full gate
forest cloud
#

not really about the weapon

#

its just that raw is not particularly special

#

happens for hmelee to have crazy raw

candid raptor
full gate
# forest cloud difference

I disagree, like the other person said raw makes a huge difference, that's why lower level bows like attrition actually stand a chance, that's why removing the int req from attrition makes it better than axiom

forest cloud
#

i just need twains to be able to one shot mobs

full gate
forest cloud
#

raw is not actually important on normal hmelee weapons

#

attrition is an outlier

vague steppe
full gate
vague steppe
#

if u want “pacing” play monster light bender💩

candid raptor
#

100k makes all fights last a duration where they feel meaningful and force you to play around the enemies

night hull
#

Tickling the boss long enough for it to show me all its attacks >.<

night hull
#

Can also just play a build bad enough to make the ability stay at the same level

candid raptor
vague steppe
#

please look at my thread about 360 twains

#

hoky shit i disagree with yoy so much on like a fudimental level

candid raptor
#

Please give a single agument in your favor then, as so far all you've done is insult me.

night hull
#

Your build, rolls, aspects, and tomes can always get worse, anything can have good pacing if you take note of the limitless choice you have

vague steppe
#

thw twaisn yiur describe ja boring corner twains whwre u escape and sit still waiting to pull agro again. Its boring af abd makes twains auch a lamw llay style

candid raptor
night hull
#

So if the ability itself was good you wouldn't have to play with an optimized well rolled build

#

Win-Win for everyone ?

vague steppe
#

on my phone no auto correbt please just try to interpret what in saying

night hull
#

use finger typing it's good

dreamy grove
#

me when i speak gibberish

candid raptor
#

I've decided I'm not emotionally invested in this enough to argue it, and wouldn't mind much if Twain's did more damage, even if I think it would make it slightly less fun.

#

they could triple the conversion and I still would barely care.

vague steppe
# candid raptor you are drunk.

tldr low dmg twains is just fps aim simulator with escape mixed in when ever yoy get agro. So braibless sit in a corner twains, escape to abother corner, brainless twains. Repeat. The low dmg twains gameplay “pacing” might be some of the lowest skill lowest brain game llay. I go back to my “360” idea as it adds a much more dynamic and unique way to buikd dmg that ties both ibto movement os escape and adding in the “fun” “fps part of twains” the pacing you describe is generally boring and leads to very simple gameplay loops that mostly rely on you not holding agro

#

i mean ok leave? Ur the one with the 💩 opinion

full gate
mighty hazel
full gate
vague steppe
candid raptor
mighty hazel
vague steppe
#

it me it is. Irs gameplay loop is so simple ot cab be broken fown into 2 state, agro and no agro

candid raptor
#

I already said I decided I don't care much.

mighty hazel
#

First of all thats like 90% of the game

ripe orchid
night hull
#

RB alt account.

ripe orchid
#

This was the downfall of some ancient civilization

mighty hazel
#

Punscake alt account

candid raptor
#

360 is a shit idea that couldn't be implemented in Minecraft, wouldn't work on Lagcraft even if it could be, and isn't something that should be mechanically incentivized.

night hull
#

You'd be surprised how well they make things work when they really put their minds 2 it

mighty hazel
vague steppe
#

aster its super easy to implimwnt. Ive talked with Ct about the implications ot would takw to add, its nit hard

candid raptor
vague steppe
candid raptor
#

Please stop insulting my opinions baselessly.

ripe orchid
vague steppe
#

imo

#

Indint mean to gwt tolted yoy are just so stupid in my eyes

dreamy grove
#

pls fix autocorrect 😭 🙏

candid raptor
vague steppe
#

irs not…

#

literally litho has mobs that have face tracking mexhanics. Its literally in the game already

#

the dude that make u chake your mouse, it’s literally trackinf extactly ehat in talking about

candid raptor
vague steppe
#

you arent lisyening whatvwr ☠️

#

Just know ived talked with staff/ct about how hard it eould be to add this is, irs really not

candid raptor
#

the data your client sends to the server tells it what direction you are facing as a vector, not as a rotation.

full gate
#

Ok guys, this thread isnt about 360 twains, you can take that discussion to the original thread

ripe orchid
vague steppe
#

👍 buff twains more to be w play style that can stand on its own (no im aruck on my phone without auto correbt atm still)

night hull
night hull
#

A moderator that isn't bee town might happen 2 read It

vague steppe
#

if i gwt muted for an hour for being mad at an idoit, ngl i wont care

night hull
#

gg

forest cloud
#

@vague steppe dont filter evade

vague steppe
#

on my phone i cant eveb promkse what i type rn

#

trjst me im not trying ti avkud the filter kn purpose

forest cloud
#

dont purposely filter evade

vague steppe
#

lpl im not

forest cloud
#

dawg

#

e

#

is very far from space bar

#

nice try

teal nimbus
#

ive only been playing for a year so i dont have an infinite supply of le

vague steppe
#

incoming mute from galatuis saltroll

quasi bobcat
#

plz make hmelee good

lone saddle
#

Haven't read this post yet but I'll reverse engineer all the gatekept crafteds and post them

lone saddle
#

Nah I probably already have it saved in my recipes document I'm just on mobile and haven't read the thread

#

Figured that there would be at least a couple gatekept recipes here given this is a crafted feedback thread

#

Fwiw people tend to gatekeep suboptimal builds and crafteds anyways so if you have a brain you can probably do better

dry cove
# lone saddle Nah I probably already have it saved in my recipes document I'm just on mobile a...

the recipe is claimed to be 169 melee with 90 str requirement, and since each ironwood chip provides 30% melee at the cost of 24 str req, about 112 melee% is sourced from the ironwood chips

hence we are left with ~57 melee% that is sourced from a black hole, and coincidentally plasteel + unsettling void + negative rafflesia flips black hole to -275% effectiveness which makes it give 55 melee%, but due to rounding it may have been caused by some other effectiveness ings

alternatively the melee may also be sourced from enchanted chain links

#

ok now, just noticed the lower bound being 146%

full gate
#

Thanks for your wisdom, wise

dry cove
#

and 84-87 dura

craggy bronze
#

#1 crafted gatekeep rule do not send any information abt your crafted whatsoever

night hull
#

yeah that recipe is like practically solved there's only so many options for effectiveness ings lol

dry cove
#

assuming the recipe is only constructed by black hole and ironwood, we can roughly estimate (absolute) total effectiveness of each ing by solving the following:

let x and y be absolute value of the effectiveness of ironwood and black hole respectively
30x+20y=169
26x+15y=146

which yields 550% for ironwood and -20% for black hole, inconsistent with the estimation from the effectiveness side of things, meaning some other melee% ings are utilised, most likely enchanted chain links

#

alternatively it might have been req-cancelled

#

so lets say the recipe is only enchanted chain link and ironwood chips

doing the same thing as above

30x+9y=169
26x+9y=146

y is negative, hence enchanted chain link is most likely unused

#

since the absolutely value for black hole and ironwood chips are both really low, theres a high likelihood that the recipe is a str cancel one

dry cove
ripe orchid
dry cove
#

fucking obli exclusive recipe 😭

ripe orchid
#

Eye of the beast accs survived like 8 months for crying out loud

teal nimbus
full gate
full gate
dry cove
flat kiln
#

i wanna make a larger post about the state of every build type, hmeles, heavy spell, spell spam, tstack, hybrid, etc and their interaction with every archetype soon, this post gonna help a lil cuz i have no experience with crafted for most of these playstyles

so I'm just putting this here so it's saved

full gate
teal nimbus
dry cove
#

so like wdym by putting thought into the recipe this thing doesnt even involve some insane effectiveness ing synergy smh

full gate
teal nimbus
ripe orchid
dry cove
#

also like why the fuck would i nerf hmelee recipes 😭

ripe orchid
#

If they got nerfed before that point it wasn't your crafteds that made it happen

teal nimbus
#

complaining about ings while using the same recipe template is a decision of all time

teal nimbus
full gate
teal nimbus
ripe orchid
#

New META Oblivion Hmelee shadestepper 3m DPS! - Wynncraft

teal nimbus
full gate
ripe orchid
#

CT we need to talk.

teal nimbus
full gate
teal nimbus
#

keep in mind we saw laby got nerfed significantly and it was nowhere near the best!

dry cove
#

at least you can now talk about your crafted because your only worry is no longer a concern

night hull
#

nerf every non obli ingredient it's time for a change 🤑

craggy bronze
#

yea its not a crafted issue u can never expect anything to not randomly get nuked or changed in a patch take the entropy and entire rift situation for example

full gate
teal nimbus
teal nimbus
craggy bronze
#

yea 160 is like a rlly big number!! too op

teal nimbus
craggy bronze
#

mb i just forgot like

night hull
#

subjoined craziest thing to happen to oblivion

verbal pawn
#

Oh nvm someone else already did it 💔

teal nimbus
night hull
#

the best gatekeep is where no one knows you're even gatekeeping anything

teal nimbus
teal nimbus
#

ofc public recipes are extremely suboptimal...

night hull
#

idk with decaying and rafflesia existing you can't really make a recipe that's too terrible if you tried, pretty much everything is good enough

teal nimbus
verbal pawn
night hull
#

for most spell stuff optimal recipe really is just decaying rafflesia and vomit all over the other 4 slots

#

melee's more creative but also limited in a way

teal nimbus
night hull
#

the choice is pre determined based on ur dura i guess yea

night hull
#

5 int req hol on this oblivion

uneven river
#

btw my axiom build id say id link when i got home

#

interesting, quickly looking im not sure what id change to push for more dmg. from my limited knowlwge on crafts i dont think u can do any better?

dreamy grove
#

ive tried it is WHY i made this post 💀

#

idt its even worth to play with 9.5k ehp im ngl but its funny to have a big twains number, but its literally like 7k more than the other

dim carbon
#

can we also buff epoch?

#

bottom tier ehp for above average dps is unacceptable from one of the only good bows on archer

tranquil chasm
#

it was like 190% melee or smth stupid and made me have 140 str, which was horrid for raid buff scaling

lone saddle
#

or they're experienced enough to be able to reverse engineer crafteds on their own

#

or both

#

in the arms race of gatekeepers vs class builders I think the class builders win after 2 hours at most

native grotto
lone saddle
#

I mean for crafting in general there are like 4 different types of crafting concepts/templates and you can just mix and match until you find what you need

#

you can effectiveness stack, flip, both, or req cancel

verbal pawn
lone saddle
#

it's almost impossible to gatekeep the very idea of a crafted either lol

verbal pawn
#

That’s why the whole build concept is gatekept instead!

#

No one really gatekeeps a single crafted

lone saddle
#

🤷 I think gatekeeping has its place in keeping out the bottom 99% of wynn players from accessing top builds

#

but if you stare at wynnbuilder for thousands of hours and you really really hate gatekeeping you could probably just offload like 3 builds per day and still completely ruin gatekeeping

#

like if you spend an ungodly amount of time class building it's not very hard to imagine the list of stats a war build would require and then you'd just mix and match using existing templates or concepts until you come up with something that's definitively BIS

#

actually for war builds you would also need to know how to bug abuse so probably not the most relevant example

native grotto
#

:3

night hull
#

That's why you shouldn't let anyone know there's even something being gatekept

verbal pawn
verbal pawn
#

If people actually care

full gate
lone saddle
#

I have a whole document of builds saved that I'm fairly sure are BIS for silly bug abuse tech

full gate
lone saddle
#

like I don't think it's that hard if you're just a no life class builder

#

I just don't go around leaking builds constantly for the sake of public interest and to not receive death threats from warrers

verbal pawn
#

No one’s going to send you death threats for leaking builds 💔

full gate
#

As a naive person, how bad are death threats even?

native grotto
verbal pawn
native grotto
lone saddle
#

there is no way you have only 70h on wynnbuilder 😭

full gate
lone saddle
#

I swear you're a way more prolific class builder than that

native grotto
#

Could be 150 lowk

lone saddle
#

idk maybe I'm just the exception, I definitely have more hours on wynnbuilder than the actual game

lone saddle
#

at least in the low 2000s

native grotto
#

Or more than 150 :3

#

I nowadays spent about 2h a day on wynnbuilder

#

Used to be 3

lone saddle
#

I used to spend like 8h a day on wynnbuilder during covid

#

crazy work

native grotto
#

Lmao yeah

#

Spending 5h on getting 1% melee dmg more is fun

lone saddle
native grotto
#

Never made non int recipes for hmelee lol

lone saddle
#

they exist but they're slightly worse