Why is chief the only rank that can give out rewards... people should be able to disperse rewards without having guild nuke capabilities. In discord terms this is like giving out full administrator to someone when they only need the ability to timeout users.
#Pls remove guild reward perms from guild nuke perms
dull wraith
hallow violet
that is stupid, chiefs are supossed to be the person that helps the owner of the guild with almost everything
if you dont have good chiefs just turn them into strat
upper light
custom perms for all ranks and players just like housing
(suggested for the 20th time by now 🔥)
dull wraith
yeah its along those lines, but if they dont want to do that then this is the least id ask for
halcyon depot
Rejected: Guild suggestion
dawn sparrow
This is actually a really good suggestion. Giving out guild rewards isn't as big a deal as literally destroying the guild. You shouldn't need Chief in order to do give aspects and money.
I think you should have Chief for the tomes tho, since those are much harder to get
exotic abyss
Rejected: Guild suggestion
Real
jovial basin
This is actually a really good suggestion. Giving out guild rewards isn't as big...
hot take: if chief can be capable of using their perms to nuke guild they shouldn't be getting one in the first place, as they weren't trusted enough
warm totem
Strats can nuke guild just fine
jovial basin
and for 2 years of being a part of active guild community I've witnessed 2 guild nukes, and these and both were caused by one person
they weren't even proper guild nukes, just guild drama relating to people leaving a guild
dawn sparrow
hot take: if chief can be capable of using their perms to nuke guild they should...
Hot take: Guilds should be able to hand out rewards without worrying about giving a singular person too much power. The discord comparison was really good. There's a very clear difference between "kick perms" and "administrator perms", and you should be able to give very specific roles to people.
You don't just promote someone from janitor to CEO, there's steps in between
jovial basin
that didn't happen to us either, for example, idk how that's in other guilds
we have this well organized as well
dawn sparrow
that didn't happen to us either, for example, idk how that's in other guilds
we ...
"My anecdotal experience trumps the logical progression of this discussion"
dawn sparrow
that didn't happen to us either, for example, idk how that's in other guilds
we ...
If we take your reasoning to it's logical conclusion, there should only be 2 roles. Recruit, and Admin. Either not trusting someone, or trusting them completely
jovial basin
still, that's very much related to owner trust
nah, not THAT much
but note that strategist has as much nuking capabilities as chief does
the only difference between strat and chief is that chief is able to distribute rewards and change guild banner
dawn sparrow
nah, not THAT much
But that's essentially what you're saying. That the roles being compressed as they are now isn't a big deal because "if you don't trust them then they shouldn't be given that role to begin with"
Your argument here is very weak.
dawn sparrow
but note that strategist has as much nuking capabilities as chief does
More of a reason to make handing out rewards lower down
jovial basin
I would love custom perms though
and ideally so that you can split which rewards each rank could distribute
because the issue we currently have is rather high inconvenience leading from that, cause I'd love that captains (or even below) would be able to hand out aspects
exotic abyss
I would love custom perms though
I want to give people access to eco but not second gbank...
dawn sparrow
I would love custom perms though
I think this is the best solution. Make owners able to customize role permissions for each category of role.
Much like the housing island rules, where you click the block to toggle each one, I wish we had custome roles in guild where we could toggle certain perms for each one. @rugged wraith what are your thoughts on this