#Ragins Train Sets

1 messages · Page 12 of 1

strange pivot
mental musk
#

manufacturer calls ED161 Dart

Polish railroaders and railfans Karp (Carp)

strange pivot
#

haha thats a great name

mental musk
#

peaking about the couplar cover

#

it's just as with the streamlining of the lower fron undercarridge

#

EVERYTHING looks better with it

#

BR103 is an great example

#

the lower plough/stramlined schield just completes the look

strange pivot
#

an egg on wheels

mental musk
#

more like an glorious loaf of bread

strange pivot
mental musk
#

worlds fastest loaf?

mental musk
strange pivot
#

the bread is upside down, the jam is on the bottom

mental musk
#

thay got other colours too

strange pivot
#

I don't think we have anything like it in aus

#

livery is kinda bland

mental musk
#

God, that windschield....

Like in an jet airliner

strange pivot
#

it's squinting

strange quiver
#

Comeng trains re-done :3

dim pulsar
#

I hope Ragin doesn’t push themselves too much…

strange quiver
#

I'm fine, I'm spending more time playing games and stuff :3

strange quiver
#

also did the proposed Vline Gippsland line EMUs

#

idk how I feel about the liveries, but they kinda work

strange quiver
#

going through and removing the base CC1 sprites, so now the variant group parent is the first livery

#

I think it looks so much better now

frosty sand
#

So much more distinctive!

strange quiver
#

You shoulda convinced me to do it earlier!

#

aa

strange quiver
#

Guess who found Comeng's Tangara concept sketches 😎

#

I am covered in so much mould, but holy hell I found so much today

#

lots of stuff on the 4GT train designs, and of COMERT

severe elbow
mental musk
#

wait an moment

#

Comert is an non-gangwayed compartmentised subway train?

strange quiver
#

yee, that was the idea

mental musk
#

design of some of these trains, including comert looks like streight out of Japan

#

I like tham

strange quiver
#

yee, I'm guessing they did a Japan trip and thought they were cool

#

tbf, there were a lot of photo album of study trips to Japan in there too

#

and to Europe too

mental musk
#

and I must say that these sketches look far better than the production Tangara

strange quiver
#

you're allowed to be wrong :3

#

but also, blame the british

#

the same company that did the Tangara design did the 1992 Tube Stock and Eurotunnel class 9 locomotives

severe elbow
#

whats wrong with the 92 stock and 9000s

strange quiver
mental musk
#

series 9000 looks great!

strange quiver
#

actually, I just realised...

#

those reports go into full detail on COMERT

#

I could do a pretty accurate representation of it in Openttd now

#

might do that third rail add on I talked about a while ago too

#

okay surprisingly, my guesses were pretty spot on

#

I guessed a weight of 20t and 300hp per car

#

but in actuality, its 22.5t and 250hp per car

#

passenger capacity and maximum speed I got bang on the money

#

length too surprisingly

strange quiver
#

3rd rail melbourne trains is kinda cursed, but cool

strange quiver
#

Hitachi trains re-done

#

gonna code up the third rail versions now

mental musk
strange quiver
#

But both cities decided on 1.5kv DC OHLE

mental musk
#

whan was the electricification construced?

#

1500V DC is considered obositle from very long time

strange quiver
mental musk
#

theorethically it can be easly modernised to 3000V DC

strange quiver
#

And a lot of clearances would need to be adjusted

#

Also all the rolling stock would need to be modified

#

(around 1500 rail vehicles)

mental musk
#

||In the CIS 3kV DC railroads de facto operate on 3300V DC, but this is MAXIMUM of the DC railway... Everything higher voltage de facto has to be AC. And Higher voltage == higher power == ability to use more powerfull motors||

#

while converting loco/MU from 1500 to 3000V is simple it is still an big operation that takes the rolling stock out of service for quite an long time...

#

Druing the conversion likely some services would have to be supplemented with diesel trains...

strange quiver
#

Yh, ans we don't have diesel vehicles that would be able to take over

#

And its really just not worth it

#

Might as well just convert to 25kv at that point

mental musk
#

I wonder if in the future 50kV AC will became popular?

#

to my knowladge this is the highest voltage AC railroad existing today

strange quiver
mental musk
#

yeah....

strange quiver
#

The higher the voltage, the larger the distance between live wires and structures need to be

mental musk
#

indeed

strange quiver
#

Its why some new metro systems still use 1.5kv DC

mental musk
#

thus, 3rd rail systems cant operate on voltages larger than +/- 1000V

strange quiver
#

Since you can have those wires fairly close to walls and stuff

strange quiver
mental musk
#

and converting legacy systems can be pain in the...

strange quiver
#

And the required bulk of the rail induces too much resistance iirc

mental musk
#

speaking about obosytle systems

I may be wrong, but some private railway in Japan still uses 650V which is lower voltage than streetcars in my city (800V)

strange quiver
#

Yee, its not unheard of

dim pulsar
#

There is even 600V 50Hz in Japan

strange quiver
mental musk
dim pulsar
#

I don't know; Part of Tokyo Metro

haughty pollen
#

Isn't that the lime that uses linear motors?

severe elbow
strange quiver
severe elbow
#

if they were 3rd rail, it wouldnt be too cursed

#

as they have 3 doors per side

strange quiver
severe elbow
#

metro

mental musk
#

hmmmm

#

subways tend to have 4 doors per coach side

#

overground commuter railroads tend to have 3 doors per side

severe elbow
#

tbf a lot have 3 as well

strange quiver
mental musk
#

regional 2 doors/side

mental musk
strange quiver
#

the NE US and Southern part of the UK has a lot of commuter lines using third rail

severe elbow
#

metro/isolated suburban networks should be the only 3rd rail trains

#

imo

#

i dislike the southern region

mental musk
strange quiver
severe elbow
#

its a nuisance

strange quiver
#

although Sydney dropped it because "it was impossible to keep children off the railway line in outter suburban areas, and the third rail posed a risk of electrocution"

severe elbow
mental musk
severe elbow
#

may as well be ohle at those speeds

mental musk
severe elbow
#

money also exists

#

fences cost money

strange quiver
#

the concern was children getting past the fence

severe elbow
#

well yea cause who would ever build smart fences

#

waste of money

mental musk
#

children schould be thought at school that electric trains travel quickly and cannot stop on an dime?

steep echo
strange pivot
tall merlin
#

WW2 killed the coolest Pennsy projects

frosty sand
#

It really did

strange quiver
#

Random thought, but the base liveries for my locomotives, instead of being all CC1 should be the demonstrator/manufacturer livery...

#

Bit more effort, but it could be cool

finite mountain
#

I like that idea!

strange quiver
#

Now I'll just need to find demonstrator liveries :33333

finite mountain
#

Here's the demonstrator liveries for some of EMD's locomotives

#

SDP40F

strange quiver
#

Ooh neat :3

#

Tbh the EMD ones are easy to find

finite mountain
strange quiver
#

For companies like ALCO or Comeng, it might be more difficult since I've never really seen a demonstrator livery foe them

finite mountain
#

Couldn't find one for the F7 or FL9

#

Oh wait- the F7 isn't in the pack I forgot

#

And the F3

strange quiver
#

F7 is iirc?

#

There were a few f units I cut because they were identical

#

Iirc I cut the F5

#

Might have cut the F7 and merged it with the F9 actually

#

Idk, I can't remember

finite mountain
#

Tried looking for the demonstrator liveries for the other stuff but I can't find any

strange quiver
#

Can always make one up :3

finite mountain
#

Well, you could always make demonstrator liveries based on the original concept art

strange quiver
#

Yee, that's another back up plan

finite mountain
#

Found some concept art for R211 and an old mock up for the R143

#

Then there's this for the R44

strange quiver
#

Ooooh, I love them

finite mountain
#

Here's an original render of the CTA 7000 series

#

And apparently, this is what the CTA 5000 series was originally supposed to looked like

strange quiver
#

Oh yh, I've seen that

#

Its more interesting than what we got

strange quiver
#

Omg true...

strange quiver
#

Tangential thought

#

But should the demonstrator liveries be company colour? Or real colour?

#

I think the latter might be better since it makes it clear which locomotive was made by who easier

#

And its a livery the player isn't expected to necessarily use

mental musk
#

hmmmm demonstrators, how delicious!

#

is there any way to tell apart diffrent F series (and E series too, but within the series, becouse E is of course longer) locos visually/

strange quiver
#

Pretty much just by the greebles and windows

#

Otherwise they're all very similar

strange quiver
#

Ragins Train Sets

finite mountain
#

Tried looking for demonstrators for the Budd Metropolitan, Cosmopolitan, Neapolitan, and Metroliner. This was the best I could find

#

It's the demonstrator livery worn by the SPV-2000

#

A diesel version of the Metroliner

frosty sand
#

Upside-down Southwest Airlines!

finite mountain
#

Yeah I kinda see it. It does look like the Southwest Airlines livery, minus the blue

#

Couldn't find one for the Budd Silverliner so maybe it can work for it as well

finite mountain
#

Couldn't find any other demonstrators or concept for any other locomotives or railcars

#

They either don't have one or look exactly like the final result

mental musk
#

||Shut up, take my money and give me this bullet train||

#

so, there were 3 (?) types of fronts in these coaches

severe elbow
#

Units, not coaches

mental musk
#

I wonder why Yanks use scuch smol side windows usually...

#

and almost exclusivly non-opening

steep echo
#

reg small windows, maybe vandalism or cheaper maintenance

#

reg them not opening, probably the whole carriage has aircon

severe elbow
mental musk
#

what's wrong with drop down windows?

severe elbow
#

They like air conditioning

#

A bit too much

strange quiver
strange quiver
#

Tbf, I'm only doing demonstrator liveries for locomotives anyway

#

Passenger carriages are fine rn

frosty sand
#

Modern US trains are back to big windows

strange quiver
#

Yee

strange quiver
#

well that third rail add-on I mentioned is basically done

#

at some point I'm gonna need to touch up some of the older sprites, but otherwise I'm gonna put it on Bananas now

red stump
#

We've been workshopping an IH/Ragin setup and that was one of the only things that was missing haha

strange quiver
strange quiver
#

also if you do want anything in particular, you're always free to just ask

#

I'm more than happy to help draw/code anything you need :3

red stump
#

IH is completely void of 3rd mainline stuff so anything in that vein is good, i know you typically avoid UK vibes but LIRR or MN EMUs would fit in there

strange quiver
#

I just need to rework all my north american stuff tbh

#

but those will be in the whole NARP passenger set, and not a separate addon

#

but if you do have something specific you want to do, I can prioritise them

red stump
#

you ever thought of doing anything narrow gauge?

#

IH has no electric narrow gauge trains

strange quiver
#

I'm not opposed to it

#

you got anything in mind?

red stump
#

hmmm I'm trying to think of anything that might fit your themes

#

I feel like electrified narrow gauge is only either Japan stuff or Swiss

strange quiver
#

NZ, West Australia, and Queensland all operate narrow gauge electric trains

#

could always just take my existing stuff and re-code them as narrow gauge

red stump
#

oh, really?

strange quiver
#

it's just the scale might be quite different

strange quiver
haughty pollen
#

South Africa has a lot of electric narrow gauge too

red stump
#

hm, dunno how I didn't know that

#

Austrailia really is a blind spot for me

haughty pollen
#

QR also does the only electric hauled freight in Australia

strange quiver
#

and I have a lot of info on South African electric locomotives too

strange quiver
red stump
#

there's just so much to know!

frosty sand
#

Why’d you have to put it so far away? 😭

strange quiver
#

I need to stop going into archives to find more 😦

strange quiver
frosty sand
#

Narrator: You will never stop. This is your life now.

strange quiver
frosty sand
#

We will never stop learning about our special interests, although the medium sometimes change. I don’t look at many archives anymore but I still talk to insiders and fellow nerds and learn from them

strange quiver
frosty sand
#

But damned if I’m not going to try!

strange quiver
frosty sand
#

I have reached the point where I now forget things I used to know 😦

strange quiver
#

could be a fun exercise, just lmk what you'd particularly want in terms of style/states

red stump
strange quiver
red stump
#

the biggest gap in IH is narrow gauge electrics

#

maybe some variety in historic narrow gauge too

#

and there's no mainline 3rd rail stuff despite all of the south of england

#

I believe Gwyd was working on something that added extra EMUs

haughty pollen
#

Yeah Gwyd's addon looked promising but I don't think there's a playable release yet

red stump
#

nope

#

you should beat him to it haha

strange quiver
#

but yh, I'll do maybe a handful of electric locomotives and multiple units

#

I think I'll try and make them somewhat generic

#

because I don't think there are many UK prototypes tbh

red stump
#

you know what I'm gonna hit him with a ping so he sees this in the morning @silent hollow

#

maybe you guys can collab

red stump
strange quiver
strange quiver
#

but I'm just thinking atm

#

WAGR had these quite cute narrow gauge steeplecab locomotives which might be a good starting option

#

also the SECV 900mm mine locomotives might be good too

red stump
#

damn thats a weird looking dude

strange quiver
#

they're goofy enough tho :3

haughty pollen
#

First time I've seen those WAGR electrics haha

red stump
#

mining locos are cool I'm down

haughty pollen
#

Yellow pantos almost make it look Czech

strange quiver
#

it was legit only for connecting the mainline to a power station in Perth

#

so here's how horses narrow gauge locomotive roster is set up atm

strange quiver
strange quiver
#

those two can be the low powered ones

#

and the higher powered ones can be box cabs?

red stump
#

yeah seems about right to me

strange quiver
#

actually, dumb idea...

#

but Ufiby's track set has third rail narrow gauge tracks

#

could also add Glasgow subway trains too, since they're narrow gauge and third rail

red stump
#

so does SETS: narrow gauge haha

strange quiver
#

oh perfect then :3

#

onto the idea list it goes

steep echo
#

i need to get over my cripping procrastination and make stuff again

#

i'd love to make some ng stuff

strange quiver
#

do it, narrow gauge is great :3

red stump
#

interesting so, GNARTS shows up on the third rail list

strange quiver
red stump
#

ORP shows up on the fourth rail haha

strange quiver
#

wait wtf?

steep echo
#

its much cooler just to disable 4th rail in SETS

red stump
#

well then I couldn't use the IH metros

#

thats why its active

steep echo
#

dont they appear on 3rd if you disable 4th?

red stump
#

they didn't the last time I tested this but that was a long time ago

#

let me check

strange quiver
#

GNARTS:
railtypetable {
RAIL, SAA3: [ MTRO, SBA3, SCA3, SDA3, "3RDR", "3RDC", MTRO, ELRL], ELRL

red stump
#

well I disbled fourth rail and now it shows up on 3rd

strange quiver
#

ORP3r
railtypetable {
RAIL, SAA3: [ MTRO, SBA3, SCA3, SDA3, "3RDR", "3RDC", MTRO, ELRL], ELRL, IHBA: [SGAA, SGAE, ELRL], TR_UNIVERSAL: [_AAE, RAIL]

#

I think it's probably because I added the IHBA to it?

steep echo
red stump
#

but the IH metros are gone 😆

#

yeah

steep echo
#

thats gay

red stump
#

I blame this on andy

red stump
strange quiver
steep echo
#

ill need to check if rukts does the same thing with the LU stock

#

since im making a multiplayer game with rukts, ukrs2, dutch3xl and sbb soon, among other things

red stump
#

I'll just RP that its two different systems or something

steep echo
#

would you be able to check kale, since you're kinda going that thing rn?

red stump
#

wait check what?

#

I'm just messing with an IH/Ragin Setup

steep echo
#

if togling 4th rail in SETS impacts the availability of RUKTS LU stock

#

fair

strange quiver
#

I'll have to fix it

#

it'd just require testing and I'm lazy

#

I normally play with Ufiby's track set anyway so that's why I didn't spot the issue

red stump
#

well this seems like an issue

#

I dont think it liked me removing 4th rail

strange quiver
#

oh?

red stump
steep echo
#

eepy

red stump
#

this is not a ragin problem this is a my save problem

#

but its kinda funny

strange quiver
#

they're paving over the railways 😦

red stump
#

it was the lack of their capability to build narrow gauge electric railways that did us in

red stump
#

also the multiple unit cars

#

can these be used for all of your sets? or just their corresponding newgrf

strange quiver
#

I'd be designing this add on to directly match Iron Horse

#

it'd be compatible with my other stuff, but I'd try and match Andy's scale/style more closely

red stump
#

or I just mean all the multiple unit trailer units

strange quiver
#

oh yh, it'll match the way horse does it

#

I'm also gonna need to give each set its own MU trailer sprite at some point

red stump
#

I was just gonna suggest maybe identifying these in the depot menu

red stump
#

edit because my brain is fried

#

just so you know which trailer to use

#

kind of like how JP+ does it

strange quiver
#

oh yh, I plan on doing something like that at some point

red stump
#

it can be confusing to sift through with a lot of vehicles

#

otherwise these are looking great

strange quiver
strange quiver
steep echo
#

Are there any other sets that match horse like this?

strange quiver
red stump
#

pretty cool addition to the current list

#

also totally missed ORP modern locos haha

strange quiver
#

yeeee, Openttd has been badly needing more 3rd rail MUs

strange quiver
red stump
#

you could probably simplify it but I like the variety

strange quiver
red stump
#

same

strange quiver
#

also

#

here's my basic idea for that add on

#

Problem is trying to find electric stuff that would match UK train design aesthetics

#

or at least could be bodged to match

red stump
#

damn this rules

strange quiver
#

thanks, to both:3

red stump
#

I think you're on to something with the IH add on

#

if I can think of anything else I'll bring it up

strange quiver
#

all good

#

I'm down for suggestions, but worst case I can just make something up

#

also I just realised I'm gonna have to come up with names 😦

red stump
#

aha gotta go the IH route and name them things like "Badger" and "Centaur"

strange quiver
#

I'm sure I could come up with some

strange quiver
turbid bronze
#

Otherwise I like big stinky diesels

#

bigger and stinkier the better

#

technically it doesn't need to be diesel, electric can also be stinky just it stinks of oil and ozone instead of oil and diesel

red stump
#

heck all the QLD narrow gauge emus are cool

#

Didn't even know these existed

strange quiver
#

but the problem is they're all stainless steel, which isn't really something that's common in the UK

#

like they'd have to be entirely painted to match the rest of Iron horse tbh

strange quiver
#

idk how big I want the IH addon locomotives to be

#

I was thinking quite small

steep echo
#

Did you ever do double deck carriages, DVT and EMU?

strange quiver
#

but I'd be willing to go to full size tri-bo electrics like in Queensland

strange quiver
#

but nah, not gonna do narrow gauge double deck stuff

red stump
#

It's like someone mashed a budd design together with Japanese and UK influences

#

Could always just use it as inspiration for something fictional

strange quiver
steep echo
red stump
#

Like an SBU type deal but without the stainless steel and more UK vibes

strange quiver
# strange quiver that's literally what it is

the first gen of QR EMUs were based on Queensland rails experience with British derived rolling stock, Japanese traction technology, and the previous AUPT design. The latter was mostly led by former Comeng engineers who worked very closely with Budd

#

QR EMUs are literally a hybrid between all 3

red stump
#

Oh true IH doesn't have any double decker coaches

red stump
strange quiver
red stump
#

Really cool very unique etc

strange quiver
#

tbh idk if Iron horse would work with double deckers

red stump
#

Right that UK loading gauge

strange quiver
#

Horse is mostly UK inspired, so anything I add reasonably should be able to appear in the UK

steep echo
red stump
#

sorry SMU

strange quiver
#

ooooh

#

yh...

red stump
strange quiver
#

I could imagine that cab style working in the UK tbh...

red stump
#

Yeah it totally would

strange quiver
#

maybe an SMU networker hybrid thing?

red stump
#

Yeah I could see that working

strange quiver
#

Although I do think it'd be better to scale it down

#

to match the small-ish railcars already in horse

red stump
#

And something NGR inspired for express trains

#

Yeah I agree

strange quiver
#

idk about you, but I generally envisage Iron Horses narrow gauge being like 2ft or something

#

so really small trains

#

and that's the vibe I wanna stick with tbh

#

tbh a 2ft gauge streamlined express train is kinda dumb, and I'd be all for it tho

turbid bronze
#

commonwealth themed set

red stump
#

It would just need to match the IH size

turbid bronze
#

and fucky sprite offsets

red stump
#

Which is pretty small indeed lol

turbid bronze
#

I don't mind the exagerated size differences in horse too much

red stump
#

Yeah it gets the point across

#

"These are small trains"

#

"These are the big trains"

strange quiver
turbid bronze
#

precedent set, go hog wild

#

😛

strange quiver
#

fine!

#

I'm adding gallery cars

turbid bronze
#

Bullying successful

strange quiver
#

:/

#

but yh, I'm gonna bash some stuff together

#

probably gonna focus on locomotives and those narrow gauge metro trains first

#

Horse has a weird way of doing its MUs that I'll need help if I'm to replicate

turbid bronze
#

Just fork his codebase and do it up as a new roster

strange quiver
#

if I could get what the final NML looks like, that would be easy

#

but it's all written in python stuff that I don't understand

turbid bronze
#

It's mostly data driven, the idea is you shouldn't need to touch that python

#

Actually tbh I'd probably wait til Iron Badge Horse comes out, a lot of his MU weirdness will be handled by just looking for a badge rather than look for an ID

#

should violently reduce the complexity

strange quiver
#

well fair

#

but yh, I just don't get how it all works, and whenever I look it goes right over my head

silent hollow
#

Hello

#

I have been summoned

#

What did we want, some generic UK multiple units?

strange quiver
#

that's what sorta the discussion

#

basically it was talk of an iron horse addon that include electric narrow gauge

#

that and a desire for more EMUs, and third rail EMUs for Iron Horse

#

but I don't wanna do them since you're still working on a bunch iirc

silent hollow
#

Yeah I'm about halfway through a set that adds 20ish UK EMUs, including 3rd rail and some more fictional units

#

Although I haven't been making much progress

strange quiver
#

fair enough

#

do you want it to just be a EMU addon? because it might be good to chuck my narrow gauge stuff in

#

I wanna do some OHLE narrow gauge locomotives and EMUs, plus some stuff based on the glasgow subway

signal gate
#

IH compile is not recommended for use by others 😛

#

but as soon as you want anything fancy like "2 part locomotive, one part is AC, the other is diesel, and it's high speed capable, and I want to suppress the pantograph sparks"

#

then it's faff

#

and there's quite a bit of "this is magic and works great, but you just can't use articulated vehicles"

#

or "it's 100% done, but you can't use some lengths"

severe elbow
strange quiver
strange quiver
signal gate
#

Horse compile also requires keeping a python environment up to date with multiple modules

#

dunno, depends what you want to do with it

silent hollow
#

I think they would be cool

strange quiver
strange quiver
#

idk the specifics

strange quiver
silent hollow
#

Fair enough, I can pump code out fairly quickly

strange quiver
#

well if you wanna work together, I'm down

#

I struggle with code, but I'm good at drawing

mental musk
signal gate
#

one option for a Horse-ish set might be using nml #include, but that's not merged yet

#

could take a Horse engine nml file, then use it as a template

#

gets more complicated for units etc

#

dunno, unless OpenTTD grfspec changes wildly, I don't forsee rewriting Horse compile again

silent hollow
#

I'm not sure what your objective is with your set, but I would still like to release my own horse add on set

#

I'm more than happy for your set to reuse my graphics/concepts since they're largely borrowed from IH anyway

signal gate
#

whatever we do, could we not name it "Horse" please

#

or Iron

#

I feel stabby every time I'm asked why Iron Horse requires the Quicksilver addon

#

I realise from watching my kids play minecraft, terraria etc that some people are used to games that stack mods to just get them to work

#

but I hate all that shit

strange quiver
silent hollow
signal gate
#

Iron Iron Horse Horse

silent hollow
#

Or just equine multiple units

signal gate
#

include several version numbers

#

"Iron 2 Horse 7 v3 final final"

strange quiver
silent hollow
#

V0.2.342 02-04-2025 r295

signal gate
#

^

strange quiver
silent hollow
#

(Nightly)

signal gate
#

just call it Brass Monkey

#

Copper Cow

silent hollow
#

Iron Horse v5

signal gate
#

the ones I have, if I don't die first: Horse (Pony), Ibex, Moose, Wallaby, Zebra, maybe Llama or Alpaca

#

I'd love to do a Japan one, but I will die first, and JP+ exists

silent hollow
#

I think iron donkey would be fun

silent hollow
mental musk
mental musk
turbid bronze
#

Ferrous Equine Expansion Set

#

It'll keep the redittors away from Andy at least

mental musk
#

Electric toughbread horse replaces kettle with more horse power and can operate in submarged lines?

dim pulsar
#

Have I included all of Ragin's sets

strange quiver
#

Yee, that's all of them

finite mountain
#

I remember you saying that you were waiting for the Stadler METRO CQ400s to be unveiled before putting it in the MARTA set

strange quiver
#

yee, but now I'm waiting until I've finished redoing GNARTS before I do :3

#

they're on the list tho

finite mountain
#

Cool

strange quiver
#

next version of GNARTS will basically be entirely re-done, and maybe include some of the great society metros

finite mountain
#

I really like the look of those Stadler METRO trains and I wish more North American cities would select them for their subway networks

#

Was hoping for Toronto's new trains to be made by Stadler but it seems like we're already going with Alstom

strange quiver
#

yeah...

#

can always do them as sci-fi stuff

#

but priority is real trains anyway

vestal minnow
#

Hey Ragin I have a question:

strange quiver
#

ye?

vestal minnow
#

Tried drawing my own trains but one of the angles look wrong

strange quiver
#

oh? I'd be happy to take a look

vestal minnow
#

Mark I skytrains in Vancouver

strange quiver
#

aight, I'll have a look

vestal minnow
#

Thanks!

civic ether
#

Seconding QR EMUs for IH addon

vestal minnow
#

Also drew Canada Line trains

strange quiver
civic ether
#

Thx

#

Very cool that your pack has NGRs already

strange quiver
strange quiver
#

or, what are you trying to get them to match?

#

because the sprites seem quite small

vestal minnow
#

The sprites are 52 pixels long, 10 high and 8 deep

#

Tried eyeballing dimensions from screenshotting vehicles and counting pixels to get an estimate

#

The vertical views (1st and 5th images) look very off and compressed

strange quiver
#

the proportions do seem a little off when I put them on my template

vestal minnow
#

Dimensions are very rough

strange quiver
#

can easily be sorted tho :3

#

Here's the template I normally use btw

#

might be a good reference for what you're doing

#

but as for the sprite work

#

it's one of those cases where you learn over time

#

but the biggest bits of advice I can give you is to create contrast

#

where it transitions from the body to the roof should be somewhat clear, and that should be the lightest part of the vehicle

#

also it's good to create contrast between the doors and the rest of the body

#

also with the side views, you do sorta have to compress things

#

and it's fine to not get it perfect

strange quiver
strange quiver
#

but you can experiment around

strange quiver
#

@red stump 🤔

#

kinda works

#

gonna code it now and see how it looks in game

#

tried doing something like this

strange quiver
#

I think this works quite well

strange quiver
#

also goes hard

#

we finally get to use those narrow gauge third rail tracks in U&RERMM

#

I'll probably add more when I get time

#

I just wanted to do some prototyping

#

I also need to add automatic lowering/raising of the pantographs for the Gazelle

glossy compass
#

Nice

strange quiver
#

random thought, but I was curious and looked up the original GWR loading gauge

#

and it's was about 3.3m and 4.5m tall, which is plenty large enough for double deckers

#

so if the GWR stuck with broad gauge, or their larger loading gauge, then it's likely the UK could have had double deck trains in the west

#

so that does create an alternate history route for double deck stuff to exist...

red stump
#

Hell yeah looks awesome

#

And yeah I agree push that creative license

haughty pollen
#

Reminder that double decker trains would fit in the British loading gauge, it's the regulation forbidding passenger compartments below the platform level that prevents it

mental musk
#

why thay got banned?

red stump
#

Isn't there a height limit too? All their tunnels are small

signal gate
#

double deck was built and used

haughty pollen
#

Gwyd has a potential design #openttd message

mental musk
severe elbow
#

and we didnt even need them

steep echo
#

Double deckers would be good where i live

#

Like the German diesel ones

#

But 2 cars instead of as a railbus

#

We have 2tph but they can get quite packed at some hours

#

Something like a diesel version of the Swedish X40

#

To replace the class 156 and 158 we have

dim pulsar
#

british loading gauge...

severe elbow
#

eh

#

uk rail network deserves to be bad

mental musk
#

early adaptor weirdness

severe elbow
#

its, different

dim pulsar
#

Britain has to do this to fit a double decker

#

and being not accessible

mental musk
#

run mixed trains

Double decker coaches for most of passengers

AND

Single decker coaches for disabled, people with baby prams, bicycles and large luggage

#

Although double deckers have an drawback...

Slow loading speed...

#

this means that these are more suited for 1st class or express lines

spice kernel
#

The loading speed isnt that much diffrent on trains

#

We have a standard loading speed in the netherlands and the minimal station time is a timetabled 20 seconds for any train

#

54 for ic stations

#

And 2,5 min for big stations

#

Which shorter than pretty much every system about

dim pulsar
#

How do the Dutch timetable it to 54 seconds? This number is strange

spice kernel
#

Dutch timetable is based of every 6 seconds

steep echo
#

There’s no reason for uk double decker to not be accessible

strange quiver
#

max height in Britain seems to be around 4m, which would make a double deck train really tight

#

we're talking 180-190cm per level

#

NSW is about the minimum height you need, which is 4.4m, and that allows 200-210cm per deck

#

so I guess it it theoretically possible, just not pracitcally possible

#

only reason I say the GWR gauge could do it is because it goes up to 4.6m tall at centre height, which is plenty of room

strange quiver
#

IRL those trains were introduced around 1897, and moving them forward meaning if you're playing with iron horse, they're the first underground trains you get

#

so it encourages actually using them

#

idk my thought process

vestal minnow
#

Got caught up in tax filing and now got back to your reply

strange quiver
#

so template 8 is for trains that are 0.5tiles long in game

vestal minnow
#

Ok

#

Going to take a look

strange quiver
#

easy, lmk if you need any help

#

but those templates are a good first step

#

also there's lots of sprites in there for different trains which you can easily look at for inspiration

#

might remove the yellow nose

#

but idk how I feel about this guy

#

tried bodging it from the previous Gazelle sprite

signal gate
#

the white stripes cause the bonnets to not read

strange quiver
#

I think it's more the shading on it tho

signal gate
#

to stripe bonnet locos, darken it

#

also the shading by the cabs, so the cab pops

strange quiver
#

I'll have a play around

#

I think this works?

#

maybe i should reduce the contrast between the body and cab?

strange quiver
#

I can see it

#

I think it's better?

mental musk
#

now it looks like an russian mining loco

#

||Mainly due to the colours||

strange quiver
#

tbf that's not inherently bad

#

electric mining locos is what I imagine narrow gauge horse locos would be

vestal minnow
#

Ok what am I looking at here? Thanks for fixing it tho

#

Spaces to draw additional liveries below and other vehicles to the right?

strange quiver
#

pretty much

#

I use them for whatever

#

often it's for related vehicles or different parts of the same vehicle

vestal minnow
#

Ok

strange quiver
#

So for EMUs, it's to include all the variations of motor cars and driving trailers and the like

vestal minnow
#

Got this warning when trying to download?

strange quiver
vestal minnow
#

Ok

strange quiver
#

it's your anti virus being over zealous

vestal minnow
#

Yeah sometimes my anti spam filter also blocks out important stuff

#

As well as anti virus

strange quiver
#

yee, they do that

vestal minnow
#

?

strange quiver
#

idk why it's doing that?

#

maybe its the .bat file in there?

vestal minnow
#

Just found the download link from the discord above

strange quiver
#

like that's all thats in there

#

a bunch of gimp files, pngs, bat files to compile, and a copy of nml

vestal minnow
#

And it won't let me unzip

strange quiver
#

strange?

#

have you got winrar?

vestal minnow
#

No

haughty pollen
#

7zip is better 🙂

vestal minnow
#

Now it auto deleted and won't let me download lol

strange quiver
strange quiver
vestal minnow
#

I am blocked from downloading again it due to viruses

strange quiver
#

well I'm not sure what to do about that

#

you should be able to bypass it?

#

are you on a chromebook or something?

vestal minnow
#

No I'm not

haughty pollen
#

copy the download link and paste it in a browser

signal gate
#

it has things like .bat files

#

if you don't know what you're doing, don't try and bypass the antivirus

wind valley
mental musk
wind valley
mental musk
red stump
#

They've been using those as regular coaches for a long time mostly on peak services on the NEC with an alp

#

They use them on the raritan line as well, if my experiences are to be believed they're pretty slow to load

#

But I wouldn't describe NJT as very efficient either haha

severe elbow
#

Does New Jersey really deserve to be efficient though?

wind valley
red stump
#

Gotcha they've probably relegated the arrows and comets to peak services by now because they're ancient at this point

#

Back in my day arrows did all the regular services, I only used to see the huge multilevel consists at rush hour

frosty sand
#

cries in Silverliner IV

red stump
#

Septa uses the multilevels too don't they

#

Or maybe that's MARC

frosty sand
#

Nope, just two types of Silverliners and push-pull ACS64 + Comet (actually same spec as Metro-North Shorelinere) sets.

#

Yeah you’re thinking of MARC

finite mountain
red stump
#

ah gotcha

#

At least you get ACS-64s 😛

finite mountain
#

You know I've always wondered, what's the difference between the Arrows and the Silverliners?

#

Is it just the name or what?

red stump
#

No some slight details are different they were made for different companies

#

Like the arrows have center doors

#

But it's basically the same thing

frosty sand
#

The Silverliners could get the center doors, they’re just plugged.

wind valley
frosty sand
#

It would be the ultimate SEPTA moment to blow out the plugs at speed a la Boeing 737 😛

red stump
#

It's one of the things I've always liked about the arrows

#

Really just ahead of its time on all fronts

mental musk
#

I wonder what may ORP mean...

strange quiver
#

Oceanian rail pack?

mental musk
#

sudden Ragin jumpscare LOL

mint cargo
#

@strange quiver just take a look on site ArtStation, and found this interesting design for a Amtrak HST, call Amtrak Columbia. I just a Concept Design, but imagine would be good on North America Set on later times (2030s/2040s?) https://www.artstation.com/artwork/kNKXxd

ArtStation

In thinking of how a renaissance in American rail building could continue to take shape, I saw one missing element: truly homegrown American high-speed passenger rail equipment. Early industrial America saw the rise of locomotive and passenger car innovation and manufacturing that influenced the evolution of rail technology worldwide- now, in th...

finite mountain
mint cargo
#

True, much better look than the Avelia Liberty, and let´s say less problematic...

strange quiver
#

just got back from a camping trip and I'm gonna try and do another electric pony sprite

#

but I've been thinking about the new place houses feature and I love it

#

I quite like the randomisation feature that full english houses has

#

so if I ever did my own town set I'd probably do something similar

#

since it means you can spam houses over an area, and you get some variety

#

I think if I were to ever do it I'd use zoning types, but it's random future thoughts for something I won't get to for a long while anyway

strange quiver
#

Metro Cammell Glasgow subway stock done

#

still not happy about the liveries

#

so I might rework them at a later date

#

probably was mostly trying to sus out what liveries to do, and how to do them in an Iron Horse style

mental musk
#

clockwork orange

#

you use fictional names?

strange quiver
#

well it's an iron horse addon

#

so it's to match it

crystal crag
#

Fictional Names is the Horse Tradition

mental musk
#

only MUs or locos too?

strange quiver
#

narrow gauge mus and locos

#

but it's only going to be a handful of things

crystal crag
#

Hopefully this will incentivize JP+ Rails to get NG3RD

mental musk
#

Some time ago I though about re-using the OG Generic Train Set sprites for an horse addon

With electric locos, MUs and double deck coaches

haughty pollen
#

Last I checked Glasgow isn't in Japan 🙂

crystal crag
#

No, but JP+ is imo the best track set and it lacks NG 3rd Rail

mental musk
#

but glasgow uses some weird gauge

#

in the subway

#

is it unique?

#

||And if You ask what it has to do with Japan. Tokyo's 2 streetcar lines run on some weird gauge||

haughty pollen
#

It's 4ft gauge which is pretty unique

strange quiver
crystal crag
#

Yeah, I don't think there are

strange quiver
#

all lines that use third rail in Japan are standard gauge

mental musk
#

what?

#

no 3rd rail 1067mm?

haughty pollen
#

nope

mental musk
#

most of railroads in Japan are 1067mm

mental musk
crystal crag
#

I mainly want it because I have an alternative version of my UKRS set that is Narrow Gauge because finescale looks better on it :D

haughty pollen
#

No, all 3rd rail systems in Japan are dedicated metros that never connect with the national rail system

crystal crag
#

I'm admittedly curious why all the 3rd Rail is standard gauge, but that's not for here to discuss

strange quiver
strange quiver
#

I know third rail narrow gauge is incredibly rare

#

only system I know of is the glasgow metro

#

iirc there might be one in South America or spain? but regardless, it's rare

dim pulsar
#

There is something in the Alps

mental musk
#

that railway with yellow trains in france?

severe elbow
#

france has yellow trains other than la poste?

dim pulsar
#

The Ligne de Cerdagne (French pronunciation: [liɲ də sɛʁdaɲ]), usually referred to as Le Petit Train Jaune (English: Little Yellow Train, Catalan: Tren Groc), is a 1,000 mm (3 ft 3+3⁄8 in) gauge railway that runs from Villefranche-de-Conflent to Latour-de-Carol-Enveitg in the French Pyrenees.

strange quiver
mental musk
#

we have berlin S-bahn at home

strange quiver
#

Ooooooh

#

Those are neat

strange quiver
#

random thought for the horse addon, but carriages that mach the height/size of the deep level tube trains

#

so you can do goofy loco hauled tube trains

#

like you can kinda do them now

#

but you can't do stuff liek this without it looking funky

signal gate
#

I considered adding mail and pax tube stock

#

but nah

strange quiver
#

like if I'm doing stuff, it's gonna be things i think are cool, that I otherwise wouldn't include in one of my sets

#

and that I don't think you'd add to iron horse yourself

#

that's why I'm doing electric narrow gauge

signal gate
#

ok so let's assume I'm not wanting to expand the Horse metro roster at all

#

I get a bit completionist sometimes

#

and do things I'm not at all interested in, just because I can see the gap

#

tube-gauge reefers? 😛

#

would look cool AF

strange quiver
#

tbh... it would

#

but did they ever operate any irl?

signal gate
#

pff no

#

most things have a prototype somewhere

strange quiver
#

because I feel like at that point, you might be getting pressed to do a full metro freight roster

signal gate
#

there's probably an ice reefer been trialled in NYC subway

#

but that's a guess

strange quiver
#

not that I've heard of?

#

some subway somewhere migt have considered one tbh

#

in like the early 1900s or something tho

signal gate
#

pff I need to get on to Moose 😄

strange quiver
#

horse is done, leave all the goofy additions for me and gwyd

#

get on moose

#

you're barred from horse now

severe elbow
#

not moose

#

ibex

strange quiver
#

tbh we do need more European stuff

#

but I also wanna see Andy's take on North America

severe elbow
#

i think ibex is wanted more but it is up to him ofc

dim pulsar
#

I want some game system with completely no electric engines

#

I used to have a "GRF Plan" on that

dim pulsar
#

It's like, an interesting "alternate history"

severe elbow
#

there isnt many countries with a wide variety of only diesel locos/units

strange quiver
#

tbh I'd be interested

#

sounds like a fun little set

crystal crag
#

One day I'll pick up my idea of a train/track set that tries to use 'weights' to seperate trains again. the French NG set tries it but in a realistic way that makes it less significant, I'd try and make a set that really forces you to think "Do I want high speed rail here, or a rail that supports heavier trains"

vestal minnow
#

You mean tracks not allowing trains over a certain weight?

crystal crag
# vestal minnow You mean tracks not allowing trains over a certain weight?

Yeah, so you'd have different 'weight classes', cargo locomotives would be "heavy" and only be able to run on heavy tracks with a low speed limit, while passenger locomotives would be "light" and be able to run on any tracks, so you need to decide where to build heavy tracks and where to build light tracks, with some intermediate options ofc

strange quiver
#

Also

#

Dumb idea for a European set 🤔

steep echo
strange quiver
steep echo
#

Sadly it never happened

strange quiver
#

Yeah, but it can always be a fun addition

#

So onto the list it goes :3

steep echo
#

I can help you with liveries for it

#

There’s like 3 different liveries it could have had

strange quiver
#

I'd be keen then

#

I could modify my existing tangara sprite pretty easily and just include that in a one off set or something

#

I don't wanna dedicate myself to European stuff just yet...

steep echo
#

I’ll find some livery images for you

strange quiver
#

Easy

steep echo
#

Actually i can think of a 4th possible livery

#

Danish S trains since the mid 60s went red and in the 90s some got bike symbols on the sides

Left is s train 2 and right is 4, there’s a 3rd Gen but only a few were produced and they’re not really historically relevant

strange quiver
#

Still, they can have some fun liveries too :3

#

My code allows for up to 20 liveries per MU

#

So I've got the space

steep echo
#

A single s train was given the same livery as mainline MUs as a trial

strange quiver
#

Ooooh

#

Neat

steep echo
#

In the early 00s DSB rented and later bought these carriages to replace their Bn stock on local non S train routes so they might give some idea of how the Auz stuff would be painted

#

They’re going to be repainted soon i think to match DSBs new livery

strange quiver
#

Oh yh, that goes hard tbh

#

Also I looked it up, and platform height in denmark is 550mm, while the tangaras are 1,080mm

#

So they'd need to be modified to have low level doors

#

But that'd be easy tbh

steep echo
#

Which leads me to the 4th livery

severe elbow
#

talgo 👎

strange quiver
strange quiver
#

I'm so thankful Talgo has fucked up every time they've tried to get into the Australian market

steep echo
#

At some point a single 2nd Gen s train was given white doors

#

Which is much like the modern livery

#

Idk when this happened but the trains were withdrawn around 2006

#

Also other ideas

#

2nd gen s trains got ads on them sometimes

strange quiver
#

Yee

#

Ad liveries are something i plan on doing tbh

#

It'd just be too much of a hassle

steep echo
#

Fair

#

Just some ideas

strange quiver
#

Yee, I can consider it :3

steep echo
#

))

mental musk
#

We have an JNR limited express MU at home

strange quiver
#

The goober

strange quiver
#

Train ride to work had me thinking about signals again

#

Might put those signal sprites I made ages ago to use...

strange quiver
#

okay signals are a dead end for tonight

#

but I don't have any work to do, and I can stay up late, so it's train time

#

now I just need to sus out what to draw...

strange quiver
#

American version of the BR sprinter

#

might just keep it as a single railcar

frosty sand
#

RDC!

strange quiver
# frosty sand RDC!

it's the ungodly child of a BR Sprinter, Budd RDC, SPV2000, and Comet coach

#

also technichally a CTA 2400 series and SEPTA M4

strange quiver
#

okay so I've gone through and updated the NARP-Passenger set to remove the base sprites in like with what I did with ORP

#

but for some reason... now when I boot a new game with openttd and it activited, the game crashes?

#

or at least it freezes

#

so I've somehow really bodged this grf

#

okay so removing all the passenger cars fixes it?

#

so it's the Amfleet thats are causing issues?

signal gate
#

Pacer USA

#

Was a thing

strange quiver
#

but I think if a Pacer made it onto the main line in the US it'd crumple like paper

#

fixed it :3

#

seems that setting all the amfleets variant group parent to the PHIII livery broke it?

#

since the lowest id amfleet is the PHII?

#

idk

severe elbow
#

Original highliner?

strange quiver
#

the highliner 2000 isn't real

#

idk why I made it

#

I think I was bored and wanted to design something goofy

severe elbow
#

I mean the one with the pantograph above the cab

#

They look awesome

strange quiver
#

oooooh

#

the highliner 1

#

I haven't done it yet 😦

severe elbow
#

That’s your night sorted then 🙂

strange quiver
#

maybe tomorrow

#

I already did some code things

strange quiver
severe elbow
#

Ah cool

strange quiver
#

goober sprinters done :3

#

might do an intercity version as an american version of the Express Sprinter

#

but we'll see

#

I quite like these little goober DMUs

haughty pollen
#

I can't wait to use this stuff on Cindini 🙂

strange quiver
#

Cindini?

haughty pollen
strange quiver
#

Oooooooh, thats interesting

#

Tbh I wish more people made detailed scenarios like that

#

Legit the ideas of fictional geography are what get me interested in more fictional train designs

strange quiver
#

okay, updates on the signals, I seem to be able to grasp how the code works

#

now I just need to make something with it

strange quiver
#

good news, signals look good

#

gonna touch up the poles

#

they still feel kinda crap?

#

idk

#

much better looking

strange quiver
#

alright

#

done my planning for the signals

#

now I know what I'm doing

#

so now I just gotta draw and code it

crystal crag
#

Signal sets are always weird to me, they all look too big. Only ever been able to use the finescale signals

strange quiver
crystal crag
#

Exactly

#

Visuals are very important to me, if visuals are a little off or not nice it ruins my enjoyment, annoyingly enough

strange quiver
#

valid

#

tbh I'm not opposed to doing a finescale version at some point, it's just harder to do what I want I guess

strange quiver
#

I think I've done well so far

#

fuck, didn't rename one of the signals

#

there we go

#

oddly enough, QR and Tasmania both use british railway signals

#

but yh, gonna try and broadly group signals together because different systems can be somewhat similar

#

but the broad architypes are Route Signalling in NSW, Queensland, WA, Tasmania, and parts of SA and NZ

#

and american style speed signalling which is common in Victoria, New Zealand and parts of SA

strange quiver
#

realised I fucked up the order, but I fixed it

#

also I changed the signs to match how combined north american signals does it

real sun
#

Shouldnt these be shifted up one light? Anyway these look very nice

strange quiver
#

that's broadly how british signals work

real sun
strange quiver
#

oooooooooh

#

I see

#

I'll fix that now