#battlefield-legacy-titles

1 messages · Page 3546 of 1

prime pine
#

The first 6 months for bf5 were annoying

queen canopy
#

A lot of people really don't like the fact that theres no Eastern Front too

shy sable
#

The worst part is they priritized fake tom cruise over the eastern front or Normandy

solid hinge
#

Tbh bf5 did lacked bit of content

proven charm
#

we did get Russian weapons

solid hinge
#

But

proven charm
#

rmn50 mortar

solid hinge
#

The gave 1940s op metro

hallow peak
#

Panzerstorm is too open. I mean i know its a vehicle tank map but still yeah it needs a small town somewhere in the middle

prime pine
#

How would an elite get in the way of a map

#

When that is made by an entirely different team

queen canopy
#

yep

solid hinge
#

I was waiting for d day map

proven charm
#

play iwo jima

shy sable
queen canopy
#

D-Day map would've been probably mediocre at best

proven charm
#

^

queen canopy
#

Like Iwo Jima, pretty solid on BT, and awful on CQ

prime pine
#

Would just have been a plane farming mess like iwo jima

queen canopy
#

Its not a huge loss to me considering that fact

#

And to be fair, we did get Iwo Jima which is almost as big of a landing

prime pine
#

Iwo jima was a great map

cobalt swallow
shy sable
solid hinge
#

There was alot of maps they could of done

queen canopy
#

Not to mention that Provence was the location of Operation Dragoon, which was D-Day's southern cousin

shy sable
#

S

solid hinge
#

Major battles

queen canopy
shy sable
prime pine
#

Eh. With games people are always going to say "they could have"

solid hinge
#

I mean DICE can still make content

#

When they feel like it

#

They have all the files ready

shy sable
queen canopy
#

DICE is choosing to make content for BF6 though, which is good

#

BFV's a bit of a sinking ship

#

Or at least slightly listing to port LUL

lime sleet
#

bf4 is gun asf

#

fun

queen canopy
#

so you've mentioned

prime pine
#

Id rather dice focus on the next game

novel light
shy sable
#

Tru

lime sleet
#

ive never had such a good time lol

shy sable
#

But modern day again

#

Like why

prime pine
#

Its simple

queen canopy
#

Its what a lot of people want

prime pine
#

Lots of creative freedom

solid hinge
shy sable
queen canopy
#

People still play BF1, but I'd hardly call it alive

prime pine
#

They really need to refresh

jade lintel
#

yeah

solid hinge
#

People dont play BF4 on PC cause DICE dont support the 7 year old game

jade lintel
#

BF5 is gonna die when BF6 is revealed

#

i bet

#

They do actually

#

Tons

queen canopy
jade lintel
#

Becuase its a fucking banger

shy sable
#

But i think an early cold war era proxy war would be pretty cool. Korea or nam

solid hinge
queen canopy
jade lintel
#

Yeah

queen canopy
#

Were you asleep for the entire prelaunch marketing for BFV?

#

It was a trainwreck, for which people STILL have issues

solid hinge
jade lintel
#

BF5s PR was bad until abt pacific update

queen canopy
jade lintel
#

The trailer for that was pog AF

shy sable
queen canopy
#

And that really has affected this game's longetivity

jade lintel
#

yeah

prime pine
#

The pr went to shit when 5.2 came out

jade lintel
#

why

queen canopy
#

I bought it too

#

And a lot of people didn't

prime pine
#

Weapon balance, engineer

solid hinge
shy sable
queen canopy
#

Neither of us do, good job.

jade lintel
#

Yeah weapon balance in BF5 seems...a bit crap

shy sable
solid hinge
golden walrus
queen canopy
#

And so are you, why'd you bring up the point?

prime pine
#

It was even worse in 5.2 engineer

jade lintel
#

Im only saaying that cuz i only play BF4 and the weapon balance there was amazing

solid hinge
#

How many copies bf5 sold....

shy sable
queen canopy
#

We don't represent the greater audience as a whole.

jade lintel
#

There are basically no dumb overpowered guns

queen canopy
#

And a lot of people chose not to buy because of PR

shy sable
#

Remeber the bf1 trailer

jade lintel
#

yeah

shy sable
#

Ppl got so damn hyped

novel light
#

I remember thinking a lot of things about BF4 gun balance

#

Tbh "amazing" was not one of them

shy sable
#

And it destrowed cod infinite warfare

jade lintel
#

Tons of people bought BF1 because of the great PR

queen canopy
#

Exactly

shy sable
jade lintel
#

yeah

prime pine
#

Guns were turned into peashooters and made meta Guns even more prevalent

solid hinge
jade lintel
#

The trailers are unforgettable

shy sable
queen canopy
#

"PR isn't playerbase" except when the state of your PR often directly affects the size of your playerbase

jade lintel
solid hinge
#

PR dont mean much its about money

prime pine
#

I dont give a damn about the over use of the Guns but the stg 44 was the only gun worth a damn in 5.2

shy sable
jade lintel
queen canopy
#

What are you even trying to say at this point LULW

lime sleet
#

bf4 aek hits dif

woven furnace
#

But seriously BF1 feels so...'honest' besides the occasional sweats in TDM

jade lintel
#

Can you please use uh, i dunno, LOGIC?

solid hinge
#

People still buy it 🤣🤣

novel light
#

Actually, most of slow-shooters were powerful back then, if anything

woven furnace
#

I guess it feels honest because WW1 and no fancy gadgets

shy sable
lime sleet
#

bf1 looks good sucks i didnt play it in prime

jade lintel
queen canopy
#

You wonder why people hate BFV? Go look at the comment section for the BFV reveal trailer and tell me how PR doesn't matter

#

@solid hinge

shy sable
prime pine
#

They gutted the fuck out of the fg42 in 5.2, it was an assault rifle not an smg. An actual submachine gun like the type 100 had better killing power at a range.

woven furnace
queen canopy
jade lintel
#

Is ur english just bad elias?

dusty dagger
#

i keep getting kicked by punbuster

#

wth

jade lintel
#

Because if so then thats fine

#

i can understand that

shy sable
jade lintel
#

yesh

novel light
#

Bren, semis not called M1 Carbine or G1-5 and a good couple of other guns actually raked in 5.2... FG has been done dirty tho

lime sleet
#

bf4 ultra still holds up

jade lintel
#

uh huh

shy sable
queen canopy
#

People still today write BFV off solely because of what they saw in the prelaunch marketing.

solid hinge
#

you can have johnny cash PR like bf1 did even if game good or bad but money matters

prime pine
#

The one thing 5.2 did right was balancing some of the semis out better and making things like the mp40 decent but as a whole it was a really shit update

jade lintel
#

The only "overpowered" guns in BF4 are arguably the M416 and ACE 23 and still they do have their weaknesses

shy sable
woven furnace
#

soo no one cares that there's black people and women in BF1?

jade lintel
#

Yeah

novel light
#

ACE wasn't anywhere near overpowered outside first few months

woven furnace
shy sable
solid hinge
#

You have google check how much units and money made from bf5

novel light
#

If anything, it was upper average for most of game's cycle

prime pine
#

People are selective over their outrage mani lmao

jade lintel
#

not as much as BF1

woven furnace
jade lintel
#

I think BF5 only sold abt 8 mil copies

queen canopy
#

Thats still a success...but IIRC its mid-tier for the franchise

jade lintel
#

yeah

shy sable
#

Instead of putting women just like that they added women with the russians saying that the women were a part of the womens battalion of death

jade lintel
#

BF5 wasnt a sucess but it was still good

queen canopy
#

Most people that haven't played BFV have a negative opinion of the game

jade lintel
#

Yeah

shy sable
#

And no one has a problem with black people

jade lintel
#

And they use critisms from launch

woven furnace
queen canopy
#

And thats entirely due to BFV's marketing

novel light
#

From what I recall, if anything, 1 sales were an aberration (in a positive way), historically

shy sable
#

K i got to go yall

#

Bye

golden walrus
jade lintel
jade lintel
woven furnace
#

I actually...genuinely enjoy BF1's campaigns

jade lintel
#

yeah

woven furnace
#

Usually I wouldn't care about FPS campaigns but this is good

jade lintel
#

BF1s war stories are good

solid hinge
#

Only thing that i disliked about bf1 was clunky weapon selection

queen canopy
#

If you want a fun challenge, abandon the tank after Finch dies in "Through Mud and Blood" and advance on foot

#

The game lets you do it

solid hinge
#

To many repeated weapons

jade lintel
#

cool

#

Its called variants

#

And they add a nice lil bit of variety to the game

jade lintel
#

Like maybe something with more range or damage or ammo

queen canopy
#

oh boy they brought back a solid C-tier map the game is saved

jade lintel
#

lol

solid hinge
queen canopy
#

pre builds? LUL

novel light
#

Variants kind of felt like an answer to people being clueless about how attachments should be picked in 4

solid hinge
#

Sweeper then sweeper with optic then sweeper with foregrip

jade lintel
#

Yeah

granite wyvern
#

What’s everyone’s fave Conquest maps on BFV?

prime pine
#

Variants eh

novel light
#

1 has the best sight/scope customization from all recent BFs easily though

queen canopy
#

Thats literally the point

#

How are you not getting this

jade lintel
#

i like the different ironsight zooms in BF1 tho

#

I hope they bring it back for BF6

novel light
#

Oh yeah, I always ran irons on 2x

queen canopy
#

I don't think its a great system, but its still as intended

novel light
#

Also, aiming reticle variety

solid hinge
jade lintel
#

No

prime pine
#

The only interesting variants were when they actually changed how the gun worked. E.g model 8 extended, full auto m1907, m1903 experimental

queen canopy
jade lintel
#

I think itll have attachments

queen canopy
#

We don't know what BF6 is gonna look like

novel light
#

Which saved me from horror of having to use chevrons and post sights

proven charm
jade lintel
#

because WW2 guns rarely had any attachments or anything so specs made more sense

solid hinge
queen canopy
proven charm
#

dice rushed.. bf1?

jade lintel
#

no they didnt

solid hinge
#

Like bf5

proven charm
#

are you drugged wheeze

jade lintel
#

He is

queen canopy
proven charm
prime pine
jade lintel
#

Next hes gonna say they rushed it after hardline

#

Im calling it

prime pine
#

Hardline was a fun game

queen canopy
#

BF1 was probably one of the most polished titles on release this series has had

jade lintel
#

yeah

#

And hardline was pog too

prime pine
#

Bf1 was one of the most stable games in the franchise I have ever played

jade lintel
#

Even if it was unbalanced as shit

queen canopy
#

He calls BF1 rushed and can't understand why people don't like BFV...

proven charm
#

only problem is how long TSNP took to release

jade lintel
#

yeah

queen canopy
#

BFV is the definition of rushed

jade lintel
#

mhm

proven charm
#

but the dlcs were polished af

solid hinge
#

bf1 isnt rushed

jade lintel
#

Yeah russian DLC was amazing

queen canopy
#

Nearly every problem BFV has can be attributed to DICE not having the time they needed

solid hinge
jade lintel
#

No

proven charm
#

bf1 remains my favourite bf game to this day

queen canopy
#

Thats a nitpick

#

Thats such a nitpick

jade lintel
#

Weapons in WW1 had like no attachments

#

And they were going for historical accuracy

granite wyvern
queen canopy
#

Speaking of which BFV barely has attachments

prime pine
#

They tried a completely different system, calling that rushed just has no weight.

jade lintel
#

So having an attachment system would be kinda weird

jade lintel
proven charm
#

BUT MUH REFLEX SIGHTS

jade lintel
#

MUH

#

MUH HOLO

solid hinge
queen canopy
#

m...m...muh....muh ACOG....

solid hinge
#

bf1 is good but i prefer bfv

jade lintel
#

WUH ABUH MOH HOLO SIGHT

proven charm
#

Grug want ACOG in ww1

prime pine
#

It would be nice if specs at least had a physical effect on the gun

proven charm
#

Grug want

jade lintel
#

OOG

proven charm
#

Grug smash rock

prime pine
#

A skeleton stock fg42

proven charm
#

Roaaat

solid hinge
#

Theres old ww1 silencer before ww2

jade lintel
#

ELIAS WANT ACOG IN WW1 GAME

#

OOG

proven charm
#

caps

jade lintel
#

yeah that they literally never used

solid hinge
proven charm
jade lintel
#

not well i bet

solid hinge
proven charm
#

what

solid hinge
#

Omg

proven charm
jade lintel
#

you literally just said what RandD was

#

Do you have memory loss or something

solid hinge
queen canopy
#

See the difference is that they also could have made BF1 an accurate title, where everyone was given just a bolt action rifle, with none of the things that make BF1 what it is. Saying they "could" have done something is near pointless

proven charm
#

everyone gangsta till dot dot dot dot dot dot dot dot

solid hinge
#

Anyways

jade lintel
#

yeah

novel light
#

I actually enjoyed gun balancing in 1 the most

queen canopy
#

At that point we're not talking about BF1

#

We're talking about hypothetical games

novel light
#

In big part because it fit my own style the most

jade lintel
#

WW1 was basically fought with only bolt actions

solid hinge
#

Yeah they did R&D in ww1

proven charm
queen canopy
prime pine
#

Artillery was a big part of it too

novel light
#

And there was no gun that would dab on people almost regardless of range, like it was the case in 3, 4 and V

jade lintel
#

well i mean for infantry weapons

proven charm
#

historical accuracy 100

jade lintel
novel light
#

I think arty actually caused the most deaths

queen canopy
jade lintel
#

yes

prime pine
#

I think the germans took mp18s with them for their raiding parties

golden walrus
#

i still play iron sight bolties in BFV

jade lintel
#

I was gonna say verdun

prime pine
#

But im not sure

jade lintel
#

yeah but prolly only a few

queen canopy
#

So wait, Elias, do you think WW1 was fought with a lot of SMGs and Semis?

prime pine
#

Americans even took shotguns

solid hinge
novel light
scenic zenith
#

Yay I found the server

jade lintel
#

...no

jade lintel
prime pine
#

Welcome!

scenic zenith
#

Hello

solid hinge
novel light
#

Storm troops were basically an evolution of trench raiders

jade lintel
#

yeah

novel light
#

SMG, sidearm, short melee weapon and a fuckton of grenades

solid hinge
#

Then advance towards years

#

Auto smg

proven charm
queen canopy
#

Or melee, most of the time

jade lintel
#

Semis were invented in like the 1890s i think

queen canopy
jade lintel
#

Yeah

scenic zenith
#

Shovel WeSmart

novel light
#

And even in WW2 semi-auto was at most a specialist weapon in most of armies other than US

queen canopy
#

Not in any notable use until WW2

jade lintel
#

Until like late WW2

#

Gewher 43 tokarev and garand

prime pine
#

Pumps and bolt actions are cheaper and have greater reliability i think?

queen canopy
#

Though there were far more SMGs in WW2

jade lintel
#

Aight i gotta go

prime pine
#

See ya

jade lintel
#

Elias is making my head hurt

#

Bye

novel light
#

Also, matter of ammo management

queen canopy
novel light
#

The higher rate of fire, the more likely soldiers are to waste ammunition

#

So that was a factor in some cases too

queen canopy
#

oh boy wikipedia article

novel light
#

That link means nothing in itself

#

semis in Great War were VERY sparsely used

#

And actually more often in the air than on the ground

solid hinge
novel light
#

Before they figured out how to make MGs work properly with planes

scenic zenith
#

How maany model changes have tanks had in battlefield games

queen canopy
prime pine
#

?

scenic zenith
#

Wait

proven charm
scenic zenith
#

So

solid hinge
proven charm
#

you just proved our point

queen canopy
#

Anything besides MGs, bolt actions, and sidearms were VERY sparsely used

scenic zenith
#

You guys know the model big bess was in a war story?

queen canopy
#

Most of the guns in BF1 hardly saw use

#

If they even existed at all

#

(See: Hellriegel)

prime pine
#

Could just be an end of war british land crawler

solid hinge
novel light
#

Mondragon is a good example

solid hinge
#

Ww1 was chaod

novel light
#

Germans had couple thousand, army tried them, turned out they were trash in combat conditions and binned them

solid hinge
#

Chaos

queen canopy
#

Bolt actions were the standard.

novel light
#

And flying corps took them in instead

prime pine
#

Thing about battlefield is that its always had the most experimental to discontoninued to unknown weapons

queen canopy
#

Go watch 1917 and tell me how many SMGs and semis you see @solid hinge

solid hinge
queen canopy
#

Semis weren't used LUL

prime pine
#

F2000 i think for example has been discontinued yet bf4 a game based in the mid 2020's features it

queen canopy
#

They were experimental at best

novel light
#

Semis were a fraction of a percent of personal arms in WW1

solid hinge
#

When

novel light
#

1914-1918

queen canopy
solid hinge
#

Good

proven charm
prime pine
#

Selbstlader 1916 was a very expensive gun and so you basically never saw it

queen canopy
#

There were not Semis in widespread use during WW1

solid hinge
#

Who manufactured guns

novel light
#

Pretty sure 1916 was basically almost air-only too?

#

Just like Mondragon

proven charm
#

it was something like that

solid hinge
#

Bf1 has them

proven charm
#

the day where like 10k french and British pilots died

#

in 1 day

solid hinge
#

I play bf1 all the time

novel light
#

I think that was month, not day

queen canopy
#

And BF1 is an awful depiction of WW1 as it was

#

If you're learning WW1 history from BF1...I'm sorry but you're just fooling yourself

solid hinge
#

Main gun selb gun

spiral pawn
#

I heard Verdun is better

novel light
#

actually, no, I'm talking trash, that was ~400 aircrew lost in a month

proven charm
novel light
#

Bloody April, 1917

solid hinge
#

Bf1 has good description

proven charm
#

yeah whenever i learn about ww1 in history i learn about a royal marine with a hellriegel and howdah pistol

novel light
#

Here's the thing

solid hinge
novel light
#

BF1 is Great War-based, not Great War-recreating

queen canopy
#

wheeze WHAT

#

PLEASE BE A TROLL kek

novel light
#

...idk

solid hinge
#

Wish i was a troll

novel light
#

I'm off to do shopping

proven charm
#

cya

prime pine
#

Im getting ready for sleep

#

Not sleeping yet

proven charm
#

slweep

#

swleep

prime pine
#

You alright there

queen canopy
# solid hinge Wish i was a troll

I do too...holy fuck. Semi automatics were experimental most of the time in WW1, and when they were used they were mostly used for anti-air purposes. They saw basically no use with standard infantry.

prime pine
#

Semis by the time I would assume were still fairly new and expensive

queen canopy
#

Not to mention that almost every SMG in BF1 basically didn't exist or wasn't adopted

#

The MP-18 is about the only exception to that

crimson tinsel
#

The game would be a lot easier to make if it was just 1 rifle for each faction 😄

proven charm
prime pine
#

There is

queen canopy
prime pine
#

Theres an infantry variant for the m1903... but thats only in back to basics

solid hinge
golden walrus
queen canopy
prime pine
#

Closest you got is the experimental which may be switched to bolt

proven charm
#

ok in ww3 ill use a proton rifle to win

#

even if its not invented

prime pine
#

Laser beam

queen canopy
#

I'm honestly just gonna have to move on, I don't get how someone is this stupid

#

I hate to say it but holy fuck you just do not understand anything about WW1 do you

solid hinge
queen canopy
#

Or about how weapon R&D actually works

queen canopy
#

Basic research would tell you this.

#

Go watch 1917 and tell me how many Semi-autos you see

pine cave
#

Smgs are expensive to produce back then

proven charm
#

i still have to fully watch 1917

queen canopy
proven charm
#

c4 truckers had a movie night where we watched it and my wifi cut out through it

pine cave
gray saffron
#

I hope bf6 is as fictional and historical unaccurate as flip just so these discussions seize to happen. People using bf1 for their school essays, people mislearning things as facts. Xd

queen canopy
#

Agreed

solid hinge
queen canopy
proven charm
#

ah yes

#

the invite spam

queen canopy
#

You already posted that.

pine cave
solid hinge
#

I have a problem

queen canopy
#

@solid hinge Go watch Forgotten Weapons' videos on WW1 weapons

proven charm
#

arrr

queen canopy
#

bruh

#

pirate mode activate

pine cave
#

argh

solid hinge
#

I can’t buy guns with war bonds in battlefield 1 and I can’t buy battlepacks with scraps

proven charm
#

🏴‍☠️

solid hinge
#

Also it’s Australian guys...it’s the British Royal Navy

#

Not pirates

vapid tinsel
#

It has?

solid hinge
#

Wait rly?

proven charm
#

we need a !!battlepacks tag for zeppelin

pine cave
#

There’s a bug lately

solid hinge
#

Oh shit

#

That sucks

vapid tinsel
#

!!bf1

prime pine
#

The video also counts as research

pine cave
#

That people sometimes randomly get like 1000+ battlepacks

vapid tinsel
#

Is there like a !!help

queen canopy
solid hinge
#

Hold up what?

gray saffron
#

Wiki isn't research

vapid tinsel
#

To see all of the things we can do

solid hinge
#

Plus theres some guns in bf1 thats made up

pine cave
#

It’s true

solid hinge
#

Fuck EA

flat flicker
#

Oh I was wondering if my wifi was bad or something cause I couldn’t buy guns

solid hinge
#

They removed buying things cuz ppl got free stuff

gray saffron
#

Also the forgotten weapons dude helped with the research of guns in bf1 if i recall correctly.

pine cave
#

No, they just disabled it to fix the problem

flat flicker
#

Are they working on fixing it?

#

Ohh

vapid tinsel
queen canopy
#

I can't open all these battlepacks I wasn't supposed to get and were given to me through a bug! Fuck EA for not letting me exploit the game!

pine cave
#

Like their skins worth anything lol

solid hinge
#

“NO MAKE THEM SPEND MONEY!”
“B-But sir...we can’t?”
“THEN DELETE IT!”

solid hinge
pine cave
#

Just give us all the skins for free ffs

solid hinge
#

Christ mate, it ain’t about skins

pine cave
queen canopy
#

Its about sending a message facejoker

vapid tinsel
#

Skins don't do anything except look cool

vapid tinsel
solid hinge
pine cave
#

Then give them away

#

Like they did with Star Wars battlefront 2

solid hinge
#

Thats how DICE do research for historical games

queen canopy
#

DICE doesn't use google for their research

vapid tinsel
#

I would hope they don't use wikipedia lol

proven charm
#

wdym dice clearly use wikipedia for their research

#

now add acogs and reflex sights

#

since wiki.p.9ne.dia said its true that ww1 had these

vapid tinsel
#

Put a rail on a musket

#

And add acog

pine cave
#

Tactical musket

vapid tinsel
#

Don't forget to velcro a rear sight and lazer

queen canopy
#

Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying these guns didnt exist. I'm saying that they basically didn't see use in any notable numbers for most of the guns in BF1. They are only in BF1 because no one who plays BF would want to play a game based on how the war was ACTUALLY fought.

vapid tinsel
#

When a gun barely used in the war is the default option

pine cave
#

Sometimes you have to sacrifice some historical accuracy to make a fun and enjoyable game

queen canopy
#

Exactly ^

queen canopy
#

I mean what?

vapid tinsel
#

What is this conversation?

queen canopy
#

I don't even know man

pine cave
#

Yes

proven charm
#

its elias whos smoking from a bong and speaking to us at the same time

vapid tinsel
solid hinge
#

Bf6 could have rail gun that shoots nuclear warheads

queen canopy
gray saffron
golden walrus
#

are we still going on about this?

pine cave
queen canopy
#

yup @golden walrus

pine cave
#

They contribute nothing to the game

swift vortex
queen canopy
golden walrus
pine cave
#

Kinda major tbh

queen canopy
#

Not really, no

solid hinge
#

I just cant lol

golden walrus
#

ho-

#

how

queen canopy
golden walrus
#

why would he lie about that?

queen canopy
#

"I can't possibly be wrong...its everyone else who's wrong!"

uneven hollow
solid hinge
swift vortex
#

Do historyclasses go in depth about details such as which weapons specifically were used and how much?

pine cave
#

Like I don’t hate bfv, I’m just disappointed

proven charm
#

yeah gecko stop lying

pine cave
#

It could have been something awesome

proven charm
#

ww1 had m4s

#

with acogs

#

but you're LYING.

golden walrus
#

gecko you betta keep it shut before we hear anymore tattle tails

queen canopy
gray saffron
#

Not in debt, but depending the history class, they do go in depth.

queen canopy
#

Thats just not a fact.

swift vortex
#

I love bfv, can't play the old ones anymore after it. But it's the gunplay and movement that does it i think

pine cave
#

Gunplay and movement is good indeed

golden walrus
crimson tinsel
pine cave
#

But the game lack atmosphere or not as much as bf1

queen canopy
pine cave
#

The introduction of guns crate is good, I like that

swift vortex
#

People talk about the graphics in bfv, that it's not warlike enough. It's like people think it's not sunny or bright in wars. Spoiler: ||it is||

gray saffron
#

What's atmosphere when you're a german soldier in a French tank in the middle of amiens where they never fought in?

proven charm
queen canopy
pine cave
#

It looks too bright

proven charm
#

i haven't seen anyone say bfv is more atmospheric than bf1 so far

#

would be funny to see

swift vortex
#

I just said it

queen canopy
#

Its almost like the world doesn't automatically grey out when theres a war on thonk

crimson tinsel
#

I think parts of BFV was more atmospheric than parts of BF1 and vice versa

pine cave
proven charm
prime pine
#

Here's the question. Why would you produce semis which were more expensive at the time when you could just produce a bolt action in big mass.

pine cave
#

But where’s the smoke?

queen canopy
# solid hinge Omg

Not to mention that the Hellriegel is one of the most widely used weapons in BF1, a gun that, by our knowledge, only exists in three photographs from testing, meaning it likely didn't even work. You think thats an accurate depiction of WW1?

prime pine
#

You'd develop semis for later when you find a way to develop one for cheaper and thats about it. They were a larger part of ww2 as they were more well understood.

#

Alongside automatics

crimson tinsel
#

Some people feel gain a larger sense of atmosphere from realism while for others it might be music, explosions, amount of players, carnage, dialogue etc. etc.

pine cave
gray saffron
golden walrus
queen canopy
swift vortex
#

Imagine if they made bfv without semis tho. Would it sell enough? There has to be a balance. Battlefield is not a war LARP thing. Its not even a milsim. It's arcade

proven charm
#

bf1 is by far more atmospheric on operations with no hud

prime pine
#

Ehhh, just as a game it'd be annoying to not feature semis

#

As your previous game had them

queen canopy
#

BF1's main selling point is immersion

gray saffron
proven charm
#

fort de vaux for one is very damned atmospheric since there's no vehicles

prime pine
#

Which was the annoyance with medic because they lost semis and gained submachine guns

#

But eh

queen canopy
#

Which I can't give it enough credit for considering all the historical stuff. Its so easy to overlook because it feels real

gray saffron
#

Ww1 was all about bolties. Automatic gujs were mostly just used stationary

grave osprey
#

Hello everyone

queen canopy
#

Which unfortunately leads to cases of people like Mr. Money over here.

golden walrus
pine cave
solid hinge
#

I given you wikipedia that has sources on it

queen canopy
queen canopy
swift vortex
#

I don't play strategic a lot, but out of all the tactical maps in bfv, the ones that remind me the most about my war experience are arras, marita and mercury. Especially the dense building areas

solid hinge
pine cave
#

*were

solid hinge
#

DICE made up some

prime pine
#

Made up?

golden walrus
prime pine
#

Which ones

proud elm
pine cave
#

Gas grenade is somewhat fictional so...

queen canopy
#

All of the guns in BF1 have some historical record. The thing is, those historical records, most of the time, are restricted to experimental technology

golden walrus
pine cave
vapid tinsel
proven charm
#

livens projector

prime pine
#

I can literally look up the guns to confirm their existence

golden walrus
proven charm
#

stationary weapon

golden walrus
#

you said it

proven charm
vapid tinsel
#

Every single gun in bf1 was at least made from a prototype in ww1

#

Non of them are technically made up

queen canopy
#

Exactly

vapid tinsel
#

Just a recreation of what they might have been

queen canopy
#

But the thing is, most of them never made it past the prototype stage

#

Or were developed too late in the war to see widespread use

vapid tinsel
#

Imagine of the americans had the tommy gun

queen canopy
#

See: RSC M1917, Farquhar-Hill

swift vortex
proven charm
#

so in some ways just bringing life back to the person who designed the firearms and said persons creation

golden walrus
vapid tinsel
#

I know

proven charm
prime pine
#

Literally the m1919 is just the first ever Thompson

queen canopy
vapid tinsel
#

But in the actual ww1 it was still a prototype

proven charm
#

there's also a mosin m38

#

which by its name.. was made in 1938

pine cave
#

Broke: hating bfv for historical inaccuracies
Woke: hating bfv because it divided the fanbase

spare summit
#

is anyone else having the issue where the progress for the operation campaign is not being recorded or saved?

vapid tinsel
#

All the guns you get for preordering bfv don't count

vapid tinsel
#

Because their supposed to be from ww2

pine cave
#

Bfv was a rushed game anyway

vapid tinsel
#

Or before

proven charm
#

per order weapon lives matter

pine cave
#

Hope they make a better ww2 game in the future

proven charm
#

fedorov degtyarev op

vapid tinsel
#

I wish I ordered bfv

golden walrus
vapid tinsel
#

Because I really want to try the m1922

proven charm
vapid tinsel
#

Really?

novel light
proven charm
#

i wont link you it but you can find it

#

barely a dollar

queen canopy
vapid tinsel
#

Time to go bargain hunting lol

#

Maybe later

queen canopy
#

I haven't just done research just now, I've been trying to tell you this the whole time LUL

vapid tinsel
#

I'm so tired

pine cave
#

We either win, all we all die

vapid tinsel
#

Imagine having having less or the same amount of bullets as a revolver, this post was made my SMLE mkIII gang

golden walrus
vapid tinsel
#

That's kinda how war works ngl

queen canopy
#

I don't think its that simple

prime pine
#

Sometimes the victory can be just as bad a defeat

queen canopy
#

BFV is widely looked at as a failure, when in reality it did decently well financially and is the most populated game in the franchise right now

golden walrus
#

they should completely reinvent Battlefield if it is to be successful

queen canopy
#

And frankly takes a lot of steps in the right direction IMO

prime pine
#

Oh I thought it was being said in the real sense nvm lmao

vapid tinsel
#

A 98% casualty rate VICTORY

swift vortex
#

If bfv launched in its current state it would be OK imo. And then follow up with more content and support

pine cave
queen canopy
#

It wasn't for BF1

#

Not by my experience

#

BF1 was struggling long before BFV came out

golden walrus
#

it has to be so jam packed full of content within the first 2 years or it will flop

proven charm
#

bf1 had it the same

queen canopy
#

Yeah...sounds like you just have high standards my guy

proven charm
#

bfh had it the same

#

bf4 had it the same

pine cave
#

See?

golden walrus
vapid tinsel
#

All bf games launch kinda doo doo

proven charm
#

bad launch =/= bad game

pine cave
#

Twee is the most based man in this discord server

prime pine
#

Being honest

#

September to the end of November was the best period to play bf5

vapid tinsel
#

Based Twee

golden walrus
prime pine
#

I mesn

golden walrus
#

based twee

queen canopy
#

based

prime pine
#

At launch thats where you're gonna get your customers

#

Weather or not peoplell stick

prime pine
#

Its like fucking up a handshake but your performance slowly increases, no matter how high up you got. Your boss will remember you for the handshake.

pine cave
#

*whether

queen canopy
proven charm
#

the =/= basically meaning not equal to

prime pine
#

Weather whether

queen canopy
#

≠ gang

golden walrus
queen canopy
#

Imagine not being able to type ≠

pine cave
#

How

prime pine
#

Don't do dis to us

golden walrus
proven charm
#

Imagine not being able to type ≠

#

expz

queen canopy
#

proven charm
#

ezpz

solid hinge
golden walrus
#

queen canopy
#

...yes I was.

proven charm
#

prime pine
#

Just give it a break

pine cave
golden walrus
#

troll

solid hinge
#

I dont wanna scroll all the way up

queen canopy
#

Well thats not my problem

pine cave
#

Just stop it ok

prime pine
#

The convo was going nowhere and youre bringing it back up for reasons I cannot understand. Just, stop.

queen canopy
#

proven charm
#

elias please stop

solid hinge
#

All im saying in ww1 they where smg used in mid to late war and semi autos

proven charm
#

you're invalidating yourself more and more

wicked prairie
proven charm
#

every word you say makes you less credible

wicked prairie
#

not a substantial amount, just more than other semi auto rifles*

solid hinge
#

Not trying to be "right" but state facts

prime pine
#

Last warning. STOP

queen canopy
#

RSC 1917 and the MP-18 are the few exceptions when it comes to semiautos and SMGs respectively, and even they didn't see huge use

prime pine
#

Id reccomend you to as well gecko. Just put it behind us.

queen canopy
#

Everything else pretty much didn't make it past the experimental phase besides bolt actions and heavy MGs

pine cave
#

I wish bfv has codex entries

prime pine
#

Yeah actually. Codex entries.

#

They would have added a lot

queen canopy
#

Just drop it dude

pine cave
#

Reading them is a blast

solid hinge
#

I just gave you wikipedia

queen canopy
#

Mods are saying to stop

#

Just drop it

pine cave
#

Ignore him

golden walrus
prime pine
#

Bayonet charge in a modern battlefield anyone?

#

Would be funny for the memes

golden walrus
queen canopy
#

oh god please no LUL

prime pine
#

Tea. Stop.

solid hinge
golden walrus
#

sure

prime pine
#

Say that to the people I've impaled Elias.

queen canopy
prime pine
#

It works sometimes it doesn't

golden walrus
#

i didn't see it, i'm sorry pepeHands

prime pine
#

All fine

pine cave
#

I love bayoneting people with the Scar

proven charm
prime pine
#

Honkidy honk

solid hinge
prime pine
#

For fuck

solid hinge
#

Like in ww2 they had experimental nvg

golden walrus
#

i just said that but it's finished, we're moving on

pine cave
#

Uh oh

queen canopy
#

holy fuck ELIAS

proven charm
#

!!ban @solid hinge stfu

queen canopy
#

Drop

solid hinge
#

Night vision goggles

pine cave
#

Rip my man

proven charm
golden walrus
#

i want attachments for my repair tool

pine cave
proven charm
#

40x scope on the repair tool

golden walrus
#

please

pine cave
#

Bayonet too

prime pine
#

Flaming repair tool

queen canopy
#

Hollow point repair tool

solid hinge
#

Bf5 should of had night vision scope

golden walrus
#

@golden walrus repair tool attachments when?

queen canopy
golden walrus
#

that gun is dumb

pine cave
#

It is

proven charm
#

High Explosive Anti Tank Repair Tool

golden walrus
queen canopy
#

when we getting the 🅱️ESH Repair tool though

pine cave
#

Repair Tool Sweeper

#

Repair Tool Storm

queen canopy
#

Repair Tool Experimental

proven charm
#

sabot repair tool

golden walrus
#

what if i need a Repair Tool for my Repair Tool?

pine cave
#

Repair Tool Marksman

solemn panther
#

what is the best bf for u ?

queen canopy
#

Personally I prefer BFV

uneven hollow
#

Repair tool plane

prime pine
#

Brrrr

proven charm
prime pine
#

BOOM

crimson tinsel
#

Battlefield Vietnam from 2004 was the best Battlefield because it was the Battlefield I had the most fun in probably.

uneven hollow
solemn panther
#

I didn't play a lot of battlefield in my life

#

just 3 and v

prime pine
#

Actually talk of repair tool... nahh

crisp bay
#

whats better buying: 1.Bf3 and Bf5 or 2.Any call of duty game

prime pine
#

You do know heroes was made before fortnite right

#

Get bf5 for now

#

The multiplayer may be bs but at least the matchmaking isn't rigged just cause you're a good player lmao

crisp bay
solemn panther
#

who want play bf5 now ?

untold aspen
#

don't get 5

#

it's fucked to oblivion

uneven hollow
#

leo not as much as fallout 76

queen canopy
#

Nah, get V. Its a solid game and a good amount of content for the pricetag.

uneven hollow
#

WeSmart just buy the game when it’s cheap

untold aspen
#

only content you're going to get is constantly getting killed by people using the same meta guns

solemn panther
uneven hollow
#

leo it’s not bad if it’s cheap

pine cave
#

Wait for sale

queen canopy
solemn panther
#

buy at 60$ its a good price

untold aspen
#

most weapons are viable in bf1

queen canopy
#

Or...you're gonna tell me the StG is meta

pine cave
queen canopy
prime pine
#

At least on bf5 there's 5 good subbies

#

Type 2, grease, zk 383, suomi and Thompson

solemn panther
#

what is the best weapon for doc in bf5 pliz

untold aspen
#

type 100 is good though

prime pine
#

Type 100 is eh

queen canopy
#

Type 100 is pretty good yeah

prime pine
#

Theres no definite best weapon but I can advise some really good weapons for the class

wicked prairie
#

honestly, the “meta” weapons for bf1 aren’t really the meta. in bf1 it feels like I can use whatever I want and do good

prime pine
#

Im more versed in support soo I can give a better opinion there

prime pine
#

You can do the same in bf5

untold aspen
#

you can actually counter the metas in bf1

wicked prairie
#

it will be easier to list the guns not “meta” in bf1 than list the ones that are

prime pine
#

I can run around with an mp40 and get an easy 50 to 60 kills with it, but I usually choose the fg42 which is my child.

queen canopy
#

Ehh, after returning to BF1 recently, its really stupid to me how some weapons are just universally better than others in every way

wicked prairie
#

no

untold aspen
#

damn lost a game 0-6

#

should've been fun, but it's 5

queen canopy
#

The hellriegel for example is just stupidly more accurate than just about every other SMG

wicked prairie
#

ribeyrolles

#

is the best smg

#

hellreigel is overrated

#

it’s not that good

queen canopy
#

But the Ribey only has 25 rounds, Hellriegel has over twice that and a faster rate of fire

untold aspen
#

zh and krag are universally better than most other snipers

wicked prairie
#

Ribeyrolles can also beam people across the map

untold aspen
#

ribeyrolles has the second highest damage for smgs I think

#

and a bipod

wicked prairie
#

It’s a laserbeam

#

And still functions at close range

queen canopy
#

either way thats about 3 viable SMGs total. In BFV, you can realistically do well with just about any SMG

untold aspen
#

mp18 is viable

wicked prairie
#

Automatico is viable

queen canopy
#

I've nearly dropped 100 kills with the Type 100 in one match

wicked prairie
#

MP18 is ok

#

Anni trench is viable

untold aspen
#

rsc smg is viable if you know how to use it

prime pine
#

The only ones that will give you the most trouble is the sten and mp40 in bf5 but asides from that theyre not too had

#

Bad

wicked prairie
#

don’t mention the rsc smg

#

plz

#

nightmares

untold aspen
#

I saw a guy with 2000+ kills with it

#

on his dogtag

wicked prairie
#

Also

#

Almost all the medic rifles are meta

untold aspen
#

how

#

the autoloading 8 .35 is kinda useless compared to the other medic guns

wicked prairie
#

Um

#

My most killed weapon is the autoloading

queen canopy
prime pine
#

The only bad guns in bf5 just involve the mp40, sten, and type 97 mg really

#

Meta often refers to the top

queen canopy
wicked prairie
#

yes, and I’m saying you can be top with most of them

red garnet
#

Yo quick question, I have BF1, should I get BFV?

queen canopy
#

From what I've heard, Meta refers to "Most Effective Tactic Available"

prime pine
#

I won't deny theyre fun as hell to play with, the mp40 and sten

#

Yes get bf5

queen canopy
red garnet
#

Which one do you think is more fun and immersive when it comes to mutliplayer?

prime pine
#

While its easy to say this small group is meta, really theyre the best choices for what they do.

#

Bf5 is more fun

#

Less bs

wicked prairie
#

hm

#

Ok. I’ll reword

queen canopy
wicked prairie
#

Almost all of the medic rifles are very good

red garnet
#

Alright, is BFV's FPS better than BF1?

prime pine
#

The fg42 and bar for support are meta yet they don't completely crush everything else

red garnet
#

Or same FPS

prime pine
#

Yes

#

Bf5 has better gunplay

red garnet
#

Alr

tame flax
red garnet
#

I prefer WW2 games so I think I'd enjoy BFV a lot more

queen canopy
#

Be prepared though, you die (and kill) much faster in BFV than in BF1.

untold aspen
#

in what world

red garnet
#

Do they have a sten?

untold aspen
#

does bf5

#

have faster ttk than bf1

queen canopy
red garnet
#

The sten is my favourite gun from WW2

#

Alr bet

#

Thanks guys

prime pine
#

Guns reward control

queen canopy
#

Its the default medic SMG as well

prime pine
#

So you can beam people with them when you learn to control

queen canopy
#

Its lightning fast compared to BF1

prime pine
#

Also note the higher power creep

untold aspen
#

I'm playing it right now

prime pine
#

Cause you know. Guns go as high as 670 to 720 rpm

untold aspen
#

it really doesn't

tame flax
queen canopy
#

Having played both BF1 and BFV recently, I can definitively say BFV's is much faster

#

It was even faster at launch but they slowed it down

prime pine
#

They pretty much slightly slowed it

queen canopy
#

Most ARs/SMGs/Semiauto weapons are 3-5 BTK at close range in BFV

proven charm
#

ar's are a 4btk and smgs are a 5btk (most of them)

#

3btk for smgs would only go to the greaser

queen canopy
#

Most semis are 3BTK

#

Or a good portion of them at least

proven charm
#

yeah thats true

#

all of them are somewhere near 3 btk

#

then theres the zh and 1906

#

the 2 single most balanced, fair and fun weapons in bfv /s

prime pine
#

The chauchat is pretty fun too

proven charm
#

its amazing

prime pine
#

Thing is actually pretty well balanced but thats just me saying

proven charm
#

i only use hard hitters in bfv

gray saffron
#

shame the tripoli mag skins are broken for chauchat :<

proven charm
#

yeah jer Sadge

#

the metal bit on every site sucks

gray saffron
#

uhu 😭

proven charm
#

but its got literal physics on it for some reason

gray saffron
#

i have to resort to using the default mag skin

proven charm
#

and its not the same with default

#

since the mag is the best part of the chauchat

prime pine
#

Hey twee have you seen this

proven charm
#

yup, but ill watch it again

prime pine
#

Oh shit sorry