#Magic the Gathering

1 messages · Page 176 of 1

golden plover
#

I mean the exile is a big upside on NML

#

But you also have to have white

tardy echo
#

It also gets infinitely worse after you get to like

lusty trench
#

Honestly this is prolly bad

tardy echo
#

Turn 6

lusty trench
#

But its funny

fallow citrus
#

well it scales better

lusty trench
#

My guy gets a deadly disease but he stopped ur spell

fallow citrus
#

I think it's fine in a world in where you play 3 steps

#

it's just more copies of it

lusty trench
#

Isn't three steps good because its multi purpose and not because its cancel

tardy echo
#

80% of the time you just use it for the Counterspell

#

And this one is probably going to be cancel less often than actual counterspell

lusty trench
#

Fair enough

#

Didn't know the standard counterspell game was so weak rn

tardy echo
#

Well spell snare just got printed in this set icant

#

But aside from that

golden plover
#

I mean, there also a lot of times where you play it late game to counter and draw

tardy echo
#

It’s all quenches

fallow citrus
golden plover
#

They've outright said they feel bad

tardy echo
#

I mean I understand from a game feel perspective

#

I think the real solution to this to allow maximal interaction on both sides is to reprint force spike ITSCOMING

golden plover
#

Nah I get it, but I think that they're a necessary "evil"

#

Not everything can feel good for both players

tardy echo
#

I think quenches are fine enough but I think they should probably just be better cards

lusty trench
#

War

#

Not brothers war

#

War

fallow citrus
#

The issue is they're feelbads for the opp when they get countered

golden plover
#

But letting stuff resolve also feels bad

fallow citrus
#

and then they're feelbads for the counter player bc you're overpaying for them or playing a quench they can pay for

lusty trench
#

Nothings quenchier

golden plover
#

Not everyone can have an equal amount of fun

#

I think we should get more hard counters but we don't need counterspell in standard

fallow citrus
#

I think we should get mental misstep

golden plover
#

I want fatal push

zinc shard
golden plover
#

Nice reprint

tardy echo
#

Why did I think this card was colorless the whole time

lusty trench
#

____less
turns black with yellow eyes

#

Close enough welcome to magic kingdom hearts

tardy echo
#

Also I feel as if I misunderstood the whole point of the lorwyn power shift

#

Shadowmoor is still just horrible? And lorwyn is still just Disneyland? But now the elves aren’t even super evil anymore?

#

Am I missing something

copper pecan
tardy echo
#

The elves aren’t but everybody else in shadowmoor is

#

And now the elves are marginally less evil in lorwyn

#

That’s what I meant

glad peak
#

Actually yeah what even is the conflict here

tardy echo
#

I thought they like got rid of oona and ended the eclipse but it feels like the status quo shifted maybe like a whole 2 inches

copper pecan
#

the status quo has shifted a lot

tardy echo
#

In what sense

copper pecan
#

in the past the whole plane was either lorwyn or shadowmoor, but now it's both at once

#

different parts are lorwyn and different parts are shadowmoor and they can interact now

tardy echo
#

Seeing…

#

But is the actual status of the 2 any different?

copper pecan
#

yes

#

there are huge portions of the plane that the lorwyners need to avoid because shadowmoor is there

zinc shard
#

The counterspell with set mechanic

tardy echo
#

Cool card

gritty nest
#

Who?

subtle sierra
zinc shard
subtle sierra
#

i just posted it icant

golden plover
#

Hell yeah

#

Kinda wish that was an instant tho

sleek ferry
golden plover
sleek ferry
#

Big difference between paying 2 or 3

#

Sometimes I just play no more lies just so they tap out

tardy echo
sleek ferry
#

Pack 1 Pick 1

Orcish Bowmasters

Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer

Tinker

Minsc and Boo, Timeless Heroes

#

What would you guys pick

glad peak
#

depends, is there power in the draft?

tardy echo
#

Actually no either ragavan or obm

glad peak
#

with power: m&b, without power: raggy

twilit canyon
#

obm and tinker are more or less never picks

tardy echo
#

Is obm really not good in draft

twilit canyon
#

ehhh

#

not p1p1 good

#

there will be many spots where at best? its a 2 mana removal spell

#

from x/1s -> x/3s

tardy echo
#

I guess yeah

#

M&B pick feels like it needs a lot to be really good though

#

Maybe it’s just always ragavan CoolSmile

lusty trench
# zinc shard

Nice board wipe assface, everyone to the smugglers copter

lusty trench
glad peak
#

m&b is very good in 1v1, just need any ramp and he takes over the game

#

raggyman does keep you open and is pretty good on his own too though

lusty trench
#

Minsc and boo is just a board check, can they get past boo? Card is bad, if they cant? Card is batshit insane.

#

Not sure if id pack 1 pick 1 it

glad peak
#

get him out turns 1-3 and it's game over nyaruhodo

lusty trench
#

Ragavan is just so much value

#

Dream world would be i take both nyaruhodo

#

Tinker and obm are just not pack 1 pick 1

#

Very very good cards just dont have the value rag does

glad peak
#

but yeah if i'm being a responsible drafter i'd take rag

zinc shard
lusty trench
#

Bit old no?

#

And also I thought Gorgon's and humans couldn't produce offspring

copper pecan
#

we know jace is rewriting reality based on the ending of the story having white liliana show up

#

so this could be him retroactively making this happen

sudden lava
lusty trench
#

Jace retroactively implanting memories of childbirth in vraska

#

Evil

stark skiff
#

Delney salivating

fallow citrus
#

are goblins real in standard now with lorwyn

zinc shard
sleek ferry
zinc shard
zinc shard
trail anvil
#

hot damn that's a lot of value in a 1 drop

atomic harness
#

Thank you kommers

subtle sierra
#

Wait i just realized we're only getting 5 elemental incarnations this set 😭

#

Rip azorius incarnation

tardy echo
#

The rest are prob in strixhaven

atomic harness
#

@glad peak @fallow citrus @twilit canyon is the talon gates oboro cradle line only used by thrasios decks? Idr if kinnan is on it

twilit canyon
atomic harness
#

Thank you fauwisty

tardy echo
glad peak
#

I swear, the more I look into even the most fringe/outdated lists/combos of amulet titan the deck is just ddd

#

Hardest deck in the game my ass icant

stark skiff
subtle sierra
#

Aaand we now know all the cards

sudden lava
#

thirst for knowledge but creature

fallow citrus
tardy echo
#

Thirst…

stark skiff
#

some neat tokens

zinc shard
stark skiff
#

which one of you rich folk did this

subtle sierra
#

you

sudden lava
#

New Lorwyn commander party rules looks fun

glad peak
#

wait what happens if you blight without creatures

copper pecan
#

you can't

glad peak
#

for most of the cards that's not a problem because blight is a cost but i mean for stuff like this:

#

feels weird

#

i know the answer is that nothing happens but it's funny to think the game rolls back and makes the trigger moot

copper pecan
#

oh then nothing happens

stark skiff
#

Some choco foils and a good boi @atomic harness nyaruhodo

atomic harness
#

Good job son

#

I miss you

sudden lava
copper pecan
#

do people still run the behold removal spells from dragonstorm in standard? i wonder if [[nameless inversion]] will see play since it counts as a dragon for those

lost widgetBOT
zinc shard
glad peak
#

3 ally color pairs, 2 enemy color pairs

#

damn

#

historically not a great thing to have but who knows, maybe this experiment will work this time

tardy echo
#

The black one much more infrequently

#

I think decks already playing those cards might slot inversion in but not sure if decks that weren’t would include both

sleek ferry
#

The draft archetypes are pretty much what I expected tbh

tardy echo
#

I think the elves in this set are actually really cool

#

Now put priest in standard okbuddy

#

But unironically the elf champion is sick as fuck

sleek ferry
#

I haven’t seen a cool elf yet

#

All the cool cards are goblins or kithkins

#

Also don’t ask me why autocorrect tried changing kithkins to Lithuanians

tardy echo
#

You’re a hater

#

I’ll let you become my waiter

sleek ferry
#

You are my bartender already

#

So joke’s on you

tardy echo
#

I just wish they put like a good untapper in there somewhere

#

The wc card is pretty lit but it costs 1 so it’s hard to be mana positive worrysad

tardy echo
#

@twilit canyon have u seen the stompy deck that’s been doing numbers

#

Maybe badgermole is good after all…

twilit canyon
#

i havet much no

trail anvil
#

it's not the simic pile?

subtle sierra
#

So i can see then slotting in

#

Not that dimir dragons top

tardy echo
subtle sierra
#

It does clash slightly with the black exhale

tardy echo
#

But with like the green white verge and then it sideboards some random removal stuff

subtle sierra
#

They're both 2 mana removals

subtle sierra
#

So if you wanna slot them in selesnya is the way

tardy echo
#

Idt it really does that regardless

#

Pretty sure that deck is trying to kill on 3/4 not drop a doorkeeper icant

subtle sierra
#

I see one list on 2 conqueror, one on 2 rip

#

It's not frequent but it's there

#

It's mostly removal

#

Lantern most popular side icant

#

We truly are in gy format

glad peak
#

If we were then we’d be main decking nyaruhodo

subtle sierra
#

Anyway I'm trying 2 metalbending tomorrow at store champ

#

Artifact removal that protects a combo piece sounds good

trail anvil
#

I didn't think that this card would be standard playable

subtle sierra
#

mightform and worldwagon are crazy

#

but it seems now lists are on ascension

trail anvil
#

ascension seems like a big ol pile of value

#

ramp, body that floats and its effect with enough counters just finishes games with your enormous creatures

subtle sierra
#

yeah but worldwagon into mightform ends the game on turn 4

zinc shard
#

unfinity planet lands are on sale today

sleek ferry
subtle sierra
#

I was sent this list

#

I wanna ask what moron made this

glad peak
#

Me

#

I’m the moron

subtle sierra
#

This is craterhoof combo where ouroboroid is better

#

Then we have the aurlock shit

#

Which isn't consistent without rhythym

#

But you use rhythym to get to craterhoof so like what

#

This deck has 0 cohesion

golden plover
#

There's another half that's not tribal

sleek ferry
subtle sierra
#

ok that explains the bant list

#

holy shit

#

84 players; single elimination

glad peak
#

[[necrogoyf]]

lost widgetBOT
glad peak
#

I keep mistaking this guy with the other guy

#

I ordered 4 of these guys on accident and thought I had a good deal icant

trail anvil
#

oof

glad peak
#

So I have… 9 necrogoyfs now?

sudden lava
#

Got 11 of these at locals today thanks to a friend 💖

#

(got the one from strix, ignore the set id )

past socket
#

Good shit pestie

tardy echo
#

Is there really no w/b command in this set

copper pecan
#

iirc wotc said they're trying to cut down on the number of legends in in-universe sets because people were complaining about there being too many

fallow citrus
#

dont see what that has to do with commands

copper pecan
#

sorry i thought you said commanders

fallow citrus
golden plover
#

Lorwyn doesn't have a White/Black tribe. Treefolk are the closest but they're in Abzan

glad peak
#

They should reduce the amount of legends in the UB sets nyaruhodo

golden plover
#

True

#

But what if my favorite obscure character in the show doesn't get a card

gritty nest
#

sold more magic stuff today, got about $100 for it

tardy echo
#

I guess thematically it doesn’t work anyways because eirdus flip is just a different guy icant

#

But still feelsbad idk

sleek ferry
#

Simic vs mono green landfall in top 8

sleek ferry
#

Meta looking pretty healthy

tardy echo
#

60% wr monkaS

sleek ferry
copper pecan
#

it sucks that [[conch horn]] is on the reserve list

lost widgetBOT
copper pecan
#

it would be fun in limited

past socket
#

My favourite obscure reserve list card is honestly [[Ritual of the Machine]]

lost widgetBOT
glad peak
#

oh hey conch horn

#

i remember someone made a cube with that being the main focus, like the ornithopters cube

#

a friend of a cube content creator, can't remember who

tardy echo
#

I like artifacts that draw >1 card

#

Cantrip artifacts just feel so boring worrysad

copper pecan
glad peak
#

wait huh? monkaGIGA

copper pecan
#

if you're talking about this cube i know the guy who made it

glad peak
#

maybe not, i remember it was specifically 100 conchs

#

so there's like 10 cards i want to test in tayam cedh but i don't think i'll be able to get it ready for a local tournament in time, time to just do minstrel turbo

zinc shard
#

fuck it we ball

sleek ferry
subtle sierra
sleek ferry
#

Sigh I hate twitter

subtle sierra
#

ew

#

dork build

#

i should try web watch tho

urban crane
#

should i pick up a force of negation

sleek ferry
#

I like web watch a lot

atomic harness
#

[[web watch]]

lost widgetBOT
#

Multiple cards match “web watch”, can you be more specific?

sleek ferry
#

[[interdimensional web watch]]

lost widgetBOT
vivid hatch
#

mailday

zinc shard
#

Devoted Druid and Painter Servant prebanned in Historic

fallow citrus
#

wotc just hate fun

glad peak
#

Huh why Druid

#

It’s a good card but not busted lol

golden plover
#

God they just hate historic, huh?

golden plover
#

Literally not even a power level thing

glad peak
#

Bruh that’s it? icant

golden plover
#

Honestly, is painters combo too good for historic?

#

I can't see it

twilit canyon
#

painter is way too pre-emptive for historic yeah

#

druid i kind of get

#

there are plenty of good decks it'd slot into and/or your devoted combo could slot into that exist already so no need to feed them

golden plover
#

I mean, surely the solution for druid is to work on a way for infinite combos to have a set cut-off yeah?

zinc shard
copper pecan
fallow citrus
#

I don't want to sound like one of those people but

#

why does that matter

#

also painter is like a very established legacy combo deck

#

it's far from the least fun thing you can be doing, it's not like urza winter orb or smth

twilit canyon
twilit canyon
sleek ferry
#

Historic and alchemy also seems like formats wizards wants to shape differently imo

#

Which is probably a good thing for their audience

twilit canyon
#

which is fine but they are extremely inconsistent about it

#

ie: spreading seas banned but cleansing wildfire and other land hate of that nature banned

#

painter banned but we have more toxic reanim combos available

tardy echo
#

Druid ban is actually just bizarre though

twilit canyon
#

timeless painter will be fun however, even if its bad

atomic harness
#

https://youtu.be/wSUyEYH10qc?si=r27WLRTG6glEry4I subtlety not washed?! @twilit canyon jigglypog

Time stamps:
0:00 Intro
1:43 Round1 vs Grixis Reanimator
18:02 Round2 vs Eldrazi
30:14 Round3 vs Tron
46:23 Round4 vs Boros Energy
53:34 Round5 vs Jeskai Control

Decklist: https://partner.tcgplayer.com/MAPOBJ

Buying from TCGPlayer? Use Mengu affiliate link!
https://tcgplayer.pxf.io/QyEvVP

Check out Mengu's newest Youtube Channel, fully dedica...

▶ Play video
#

this winning modern challenge list was maining 4

twilit canyon
#

it hasnt been for a bit

#

better than solitude in some spots

atomic harness
#

He said it's good for example like youre on the draw and opponent goes t2 ajani you subtlety it

twilit canyon
#

yeah theres a lot that subtlety beats decently rn thanks to being able to make that a bad draw or a permanent counter by having them bottom the creature

glad peak
#

Subtlety’s great, one of the only real clean answers to a cavern’d Titan

atomic harness
#

Thank you gamers

tardy echo
#

Kydele is so cool @atomic harness

atomic harness
#

Link me son

tardy echo
#

[[kydele chosen of kruphix]]

lost widgetBOT
glad peak
#

Someone convince me not to play turbo minstrel in this cedh tournament a few weeks out icant

#

Deck’s sick but damn I’m going to time every round

zinc shard
merry owl
#

Game changer alert

glad peak
#

Oh they released 6?

#

Time to read

sleek ferry
#

[[flitterwing nuisance]]

lost widgetBOT
glad peak
#

How is it that literally no one in my area has slickshots

#

I’m gonna loan prowess to someone else so I 4 more for my deck and nothing icant

copper pecan
#

you ever get someone with a combat trick and they immediately scoop

lusty trench
#

Especially in limited

#

Mf you made the deck, you know what cards you have, if you didnt plan on being stopped thats on you

copper pecan
#

it's crazy seeing them scoop to that in limited when there's actually something to lose

glad peak
#

ok i have a cedh theory

#

time to play oops in cedh

#

the theory is that people will go more all in on turbo and creature removal and remove some counterspells

atomic harness
atomic harness
glad peak
#

Rogrey here I come

#

Or do I play ikra to sandbag a worse commander blob3c

sudden lava
#

Strixhaven Precon leaks happened

#

we dont know if real, but they looks pretty legit

sleek ferry
#

4 different ones I would assume yeah?

sudden lava
#

specifically the printing sheets for prismari, including 2 new cards (neither are a commander) were leaked

sudden lava
#

golgari, izzet, boros, simic, and orzhov
In order of the color pairings above, witherbloom, prismari, lorehold, quandrix, and silverquill

sleek ferry
#

gotcha, definitely getting witherbloom again

glad peak
#

Post leak nyaruhodo

golden plover
#

Just got hit with a waterbent secret of bloodbending??? They still lost lol

#

People should scoop from losing positions more often

glad peak
#

Tbh yes

#

If you have no outs then there’s no reason to continue

#

Yes, even in competitive play

golden plover
#

Yeah, if I know I'm not gonna win it I just take the L and scoop

glad peak
#

Unless you have no time limit, since time limit might be a factor

golden plover
#

Sure it's whatever if there's a 1/60 chance you draw your super perfect out

#

But like, if you don't draw it go GG and move on

glad peak
golden plover
#

They literally spent the whole timer tapping down my board (except the guys who would've killed them if they swung) and then just did nothing else

#

Like bro, press the concede button

glad peak
#

I found it in another way, working now nyaruhodo

subtle sierra
#

work pc i assume

glad peak
#

Nope my phone icant

subtle sierra
#

oh wow

glad peak
#

Yeah the Reddit guy popped up saying it was a network block

#

So them bastards blocked my phone nukgar

golden plover
#

Would it work on data lol?

glad peak
#

I tried lol

golden plover
#

Holy shit this week's bottom 5 is amazing

#

This is ridiculous. I kinda love it?

#

Apparently the creator's intent is just "name a 2 card combo"

#

What if thoracle consult was in the command zone and won every game t1

hidden ermine
#

Wait

#

I figured it would require you to name a card you exiled

#

This just lets you go through every ritual??

golden plover
#

Yup

#

That was the creator's intent too

#

Although it's never doing that lol

#

You just play a bunch of 0 drops, declare LED, declare thoracle, declare consult

fallow citrus
#

well it can't do that because it's not got black in the colour identity

#

so you'd have to thoracle in mono blue

hidden ermine
#

It doesnt need to, youre not restricted to your colours since its just creating them out of thin air

fallow citrus
#

oh yeah

golden plover
#

Yeah you don't need to actually be able to play the card

#

You just have to know the name of the card

hidden ermine
#

It even lets you cheat mana lmao

#

Well

#

Ignore mana colour rather

zinc shard
#

I don't get why this card's on the list, like it doesnt seem offensively bad?

glad peak
#

Holy abilities

#

I wouldn’t put it past them to print this though

sudden lava
#

You doing a bit too much

glad peak
#

Yeah but this is commander design nyaruhodo

#

Very much in the ballpark of what they want

copper pecan
#

like, why does this need charge counters if the only thing it uses them for is to put +1/+1 counters on him?

#

just have it get +1/+1 counters when it damages an opponent instead of giving it charge counters and then immeidately removing the counters in order to place another kind of counter on him

glad peak
#

Because charge counter synergy duh

#

And you can proliferate both +1/+1 counters and charge counters on him nyaruhodo

#

It’s just 3 keywords and 1 activated ability and 1 trigger, fully in line froghead

sleek ferry
#

Watch our Lorwyn Eclipsed Shuffle Up & PLay with Lorwyn Eclipsed w/ Arin Hanson, Rhystic Studies, and ZachTheBold here: https://youtu.be/FTyuGSNpZcU
Shop Lorwyn Eclipse Product: https://micro.center/e61b05
Check out TCG Accessories: https://micro.center/cf126c
Shop Micro Center’s Winter Savings: https://micro.center/a28b5f
Check out Micro Cent...

▶ Play video
#

I’ve seen some sealed gameplay of this and it doesn’t seem as exciting as avatar

#

But we’ll see on Friday

glad peak
#

Hopefully it’s more fun than atla, that format was bombs.dek

tardy echo
tardy echo
#

I wish there were more funky color fairies

#

I’m tired of u/b grandpa

trail anvil
#

[[ivy, gleeful spellthief]] like her?

lost widgetBOT
glad peak
#

limitation: we shouldn't have a 5c faerie with keyword soup that gives faeries keywords

sleek ferry
#

I hate you for reminding me this existed

#

I think I also vsed it the one time I queued up for brawl

trail anvil
#

oof

stark skiff
#

Big raised foil Dino and some secret lair pickups

glad peak
#

welp i spent 30 minutes on my rog thras turn 3 win

#

i'm gonna be the reason why this event goes overtime

tardy echo
#

I feel green also just makes sense for faeries flavor wise

#

Not design wise but vro

tropic cape
tropic cape
#

also kinda want that commodore 64 ultimate, and there would go another 400, vaultborn never stood a chance

golden plover
#

Lessons feels so feast or famine to play against. It either does nothing or has all the tools all the time and there's nothing I can do against it

#

Honestly this whole standard feels like that rn

#

Everything either wins on 4 or loses on it and you're largely ignoring each others gameplan

#

I think I just miss midrange

atomic harness
#

Sigh back in my day we would cast sheoldred the apocalypse and be happy with it

#

Word me @tardy echo @trail anvil

tardy echo
sleek ferry
#

Sheoldred was a disgusting card before we got the proper removal for it

tardy echo
#

I don’t care, I was the one playing it jajaja

glad peak
#

Sheoldred was the time when people realized they don’t actually like midrange, just the idea of it

#

Tale as old as time icant

sleek ferry
#

Doing 5 damage was just unrealistic during the first year of sheoldred

#

Nowadays sheoldred has like a million answers

subtle sierra
#

is anything relevant meta wise come out in lorwyn for standard? besides requiting hex and shocks

golden plover
#

I just want midrange back

#

And sheoldred would do that

glad peak
subtle sierra
#

Abigale?

#

Ig a 7/7 turn 2 is cute

glad peak
#

Which card is the 7/7 clearly

subtle sierra
#

[[moonshadow]]

lost widgetBOT
tardy echo
#

But probably not anything to create new decks in the same way avatar did

subtle sierra
#

Oh wait this doesn't remove counters

#

I'm stupid

subtle sierra
#

Idk if i complete bant with shocks or make something else altogether

tardy echo
#

Some copers believe faeries will be playable

#

I do not. bleh

#

The eldraine faeries are just not very good cards

glad peak
#

Faeries have some decent tools but only the famous reason why they were good, not the real reasons nyaruhodo

tardy echo
#

The real reasons being thoughtseize and spellstutter sprite CoolSmile

glad peak
#

People think bitterblossom is the only reason why faeries were good the first time around, it’s not icant

tardy echo
#

There’s a weird ratchet faerie exclusive thoughtseize but it’s also just not a very good card

golden plover
lost widgetBOT
golden plover
#

T3 8/8 flying first strike lifelink

glad peak
#

I wish we got a spellstutter that’s a mana leak instead of a snare

tardy echo
#

Wdym

#

Oh nvm

#

They printed that on an instant

glad peak
#

Yeah but no body

tardy echo
#

Well they did that for a reason

glad peak
#

It wouldn’t be overpowered nyaruhodo

tardy echo
#

All the budget for good cards in woe had to go to beans

glad peak
#

Damn green taking all our budget yet again

tardy echo
#

Well to compensate they didn’t give green good cards for like a year afterwards

glad peak
#

Fully deserved

tardy echo
#

Green is the best color in mtg you’re just jealous

glad peak
#

I’m jealous of all the handholding wotc does for it, yes

#

I want my hand to be held and for me to be cradled like green players do nukgar

golden plover
#

They should just make the green deck build itself for you now too

#

Landfall already plays itself

#

Oh wow your guys get bigger when you play lands

tardy echo
#

Reprint natural order

#

Reprint sotf

#

Reprint fauna shaman

#

gg

glad peak
#

Nah those cards require too much thinking

#

Just print more of decent/overstatted cards that also get bigger and gain advantage on landfall

golden plover
#

That way you can construct your deck by putting #1-60 together

glad peak
#

Yeah, those cards are much too hard for the best green players

#

Theyre abused by people who decide to just splash green tho

golden plover
#

Tbh it really does feel like wotc has dumbed down green's identity a lot

#

But honestly, it's probably the whole mobile client thing?

#

They want games to be played on arena, and want you to be able to do that during your lunch break, so we get way more super easy to pilot simple aggro decks

tardy echo
#

Did historic actually just ban all the free mh cards @twilit canyon

golden plover
#

Landfall definitely feels like that's the design process there

golden plover
tardy echo
#

I knew they banned endurance but I just realized fov was banned too

golden plover
#

Iirc historic prebans 0 cost cards

tardy echo
#

No like I just didn’t realize that literally all of them

twilit canyon
#

yeah

#

all free spells

tardy echo
#

I don’t play that shit ass format dog icant

#

That’s kind of an unwise decision imo

golden plover
#

I mean they banned devoted druid and painter's servant too lol

tardy echo
#

Esp when cards like endurance almost exclusively help to stop people from actually doing incredibly unfair things

golden plover
#

The mind of a historic format curator is an enigma

tardy echo
#

There was a very dry spell for a while

golden plover
#

Yeah they kinda swing to one extreme or the other in standard tbh

#

So now we're all in on ramp

#

And red is all in on hosers?

glad peak
#

Yeah, red being all in on hosers is kinda weird

tardy echo
#

But also whenever they make green good people just unabashedly hate it

#

And then when it’s bad they go wow wotc hates green so much it’s unfair etc

glad peak
#

I don’t mind it since red’s thing is hard to do without oversaturating but eh

golden plover
#

Actually, when was the last time green was good in standard?

tardy echo
#

And forgot the sheer vitriol people had for beans

golden plover
#

It's kinda been forever lol

glad peak
#

Wotc should hate green at all icant

tardy echo
#

Overlords

golden plover
#

Not counting stuff like the overlord

tardy echo
#

Why would you not count domain

golden plover
#

I guess the current Simic deck is primary green?

tardy echo
#

That deck died after they banned beans

golden plover
#

Domain Overlords was hardly green

tardy echo
#

That was 80% of the reason people played it

golden plover
#

They just played it for beans and the fixing tbh

tardy echo
#

And beans was why you played the deck

sleek ferry
#

Beans and green overlord were legitly what made the deck lol

golden plover
#

Yeah for sure but they ran like 3 green cards

tardy echo
#

That’s still only being good because of green

golden plover
#

True, guess it counts

tardy echo
#

People tried playing that deck without beans (and with little/no green splash) and it was dogshit

golden plover
#

Before that I can't think of a time green was as good tho

tardy echo
#

Before that is out of my scope of knowledge Yeppers

golden plover
tardy echo
#

The last time I remember green being actually like best color contender was throne of eldraine

#

But again there’s like a 3/4 year gap in my knowledge

golden plover
#

We're in one of the least interactive standards in a while rn so I don't think they're crossing a line yet, but they're so overtuned

tardy echo
#

What if we put questing beast back in standard

#

Surely this time it’ll be okay

sleek ferry
golden plover
#

Simic would play 1

#

Landfall MIGHT play 2

tardy echo
#

Stompy was an actual deck before avatar

golden plover
#

Stompy is real rn

#

But it's Simic stompy

tardy echo
#

I mean mono green

golden plover
#

Oh it's still around

tardy echo
#

Like playing the 2/3/2 from eoe and shit

golden plover
#

It's just worse than simic

tardy echo
#

It’s like sort of fake now

golden plover
#

And loses to lessons t0

#

People play it on ladder

#

But they lose

tardy echo
#

But it was actual real deck when mono red was killing everybody

#

People play anything on ladder icant

#

Also has anyone else ever thought it’s weird that green and red just have special fun names for aggro decks that none of the other colors do

#

Actually I guess white is weenie

#

But u/b just get… aggro

golden plover
#

We need ones for black and blue

#

I guess that's kinda aristocrats?

tardy echo
#

Aristocrats is kinda different idk

golden plover
#

Not exactly the same thing yeah

#

But it's typically the closest they get

tardy echo
#

I would say that’s a midrange deck anyways and also it’s orzhov half the time

#

People call mono green without any tramplers or anything stompy icant

#

And I guess mono blue doesn’t really get aggro decks anyways gp_borpa

golden plover
#

Fliers or merfolk sometimes

sleek ferry
#

Hex is such a good addition to the meta tbh

#

Goblins got some legs because they still got the old good goblins + the good ones coming in letting them splash black

subtle sierra
#

as much as i love hex my aurlocks and bramble will fucking die

sleek ferry
#

We needed a good 1 mana removal since cut down left

#

Interesting that Simic beats both landfall decks but the landfall decks are better into Simic’s bad matchups

golden plover
#

Damn, Dimir is struggling hard rn

#

Only one list it's got over 50% against

sleek ferry
#

Overall pretty healthy meta, I’m curious to see what brews people come up with post Lorwyn

#

There’s almost no reason for us not to dwell into 3 colors

golden plover
#

I do think the sheer deck variety is healthy yeah, but I have some issues with gameplay rn

#

Every deck just feels like it's looking for a win on 4 and not interacting

#

Healthy, but doesn't really feel like there's a lot of back and forth going on

sleek ferry
#

Wdym, Lessons interact, it’s just the different variants of green decks that don’t

#

Which makes sense. Green’s never cared about anything but advancing its own strat

golden plover
#

Yeah I guess it's moreso how much of the meta is green

#

Lessons is pretty interactive but even there it feels like you have to stop them before they get the board online

#

Once they've got a few monuments or whatever there's nothing to stop them

zinc shard
golden plover
#

Oh that Lucy art is...

#

Not very flattering

glad peak
#

Mr. Robot, is that you? icant

sudden lava
#

Doggos

golden plover
zinc shard
#

$10 reprint, not bad

golden plover
#

Oh full superdrop

#

Also... Show spoiler???

zinc shard
#

"Hey, Nice Marit Lage. Ima make one too"

#

so

Mesmeric Orb - $20
Mindcrank - $10
Yoshimaru -$9
Patchwork Banner -$5
Caged Sun - $4
Isshin - $3

Plus 3 new cards

golden plover
#

It might be two lairs minimum

#

Almost certainly is actually

#

Considering it's a superdrop

#

Weird that The Ghoul, Lucy, and presumably Maximus don't have partner

#

They don't

past socket
#

KUNA-MAN!

#

I imagine a lot of folks would kill for Joshua Graham Isshin given how much of a fan favourite he is

zinc shard
#

Also it says in the article this can be bought on Amazon

tropic cape
#

this will be decent support for my upgraded mothman dck

zinc shard
golden plover
#

Fucked up they made Matthew Perry a skeleton

past socket
#

So that’s what happens when you choose to crucify Benny!

lusty trench
#

Joshua Graham
Worst people you know making their second deck (other than 40k)

tardy echo
#

Well checks out that isshin is the one who gets reskinned as the evil guy icant

zinc shard
#

I might have to pick up the New Vegas lair

sudden lava
#

Ah nice new mothman art

past socket
#

Oh right forgot Joshua is the idolise him and you miss the point crowd

copper pecan
#

watching some gameplay of lorwyn on arena and i really like how the board dynamically changes based on how much life you have

#

the visual effect is really cool

#

also [[aurora awakener]] is crazy if you open leyline

lost widgetBOT
glad peak
#

Would you consider [[gilt-leaf archdruid]] to be mass land denial? I’m not destroying your lands, theyre just going under new management NyanGun

lost widgetBOT
copper pecan
#

yeah i would consider that to be mass land denial

glad peak
#

Flavor win for the four horsemen nyaruhodo

#

Either conquest or pestilence, not sure yet

zinc shard
#

MTG Promo leak

glad peak
#

Are you anticipating it

past socket
#

Almost time for prerelease for me. Signed and just waiting woo

stark skiff
#

my store has to cancel prerelease for the weirdest reason lol

#

they got their box and apparently wizards emailed telling them they have to return it cause they accidentally put in TMNT prerelease in there

glad peak
#

Ayo?

#

Leaks incoming?

stark skiff
#

yea like i said its random lol

#

nah they havent popped it open and have to send it back

#

otherwise pinkertons kill us off

glad peak
#

damn, I can’t believe rdr2 ub happened irl faster than magic

stark skiff
zinc shard
#

TMNT card was put in Lorwyn pre-release kit by mistake

copper pecan
#

cool card

glad peak
#

Hopefully I get the tmnt cards tomorrow

#

Just because it’ll be funny

#

Do we know what sneak does? clearly

#

Oh it’s ninjitsu but it’s a cast instead of ability

sudden lava
#

And doesnt have to be in hand

sleek ferry
#

Oh nvm

sudden lava
#

so commanders can sneak in, unlike ninjitsu (Tiger's Shadow doesn't count, that's commander Ninjitsu)

sleek ferry
#

It has first strike

#

I was going to say

#

How does it enter tapped and attacking

copper pecan
#

what happens if you somehow give this double strike?

zinc shard
#

I'm guessing for the second damage it puts a creature in, but they dont attack

sudden lava
glad peak
#

Technically attacking but damage already passed

copper pecan
glad peak
#

Also funny if you revive a creature with first strike, they don’t take damage from the other first striker

tardy echo
#

What does sneak do I forgor

glad peak
#

They are still technically attacking, just their damage window has passed

sudden lava
#

If you revive a double striker, the revived double striker doesnt hit for "1st damage"

#

But it will hit for regular damage

#

Unless you revive the double striker during regular damage, then it doesnt hit

copper pecan
sudden lava
past socket
#

1-1 atm

past socket
#

Finished up! 1-2 but came very close

sleek ferry
#

Nice! Is that for your prerelease?

#

If so, how was the prerelease for this set? I have mine tomorrow

past socket
#

Was quite a fun time, played Elves and the games were a blast

stark skiff
#

guess my shop isnt the only that got tmnt cards lol

zinc shard
#

I just looked at her gatherer page on a whim

tropic cape
#

Bruh, are they seriously still using this like .. 4 year old secret lair for ads?

golden plover
#

Yeah sure man whatever I guess

sleek ferry
#

Walking to prerelease now, will post pics of what I pull for draft review later

golden plover
#

Lmao someone in Japan pulled the same serialized number twice

hidden ermine
#

... wait how does that even work

#

Factory error?

golden plover
#

I assume so? First time this has happened lol

hidden ermine
#

It being specifically 444 is oddly ominous too

golden plover
#

Oh right, isn't 444 unlucky in japan

#

Crazy that not only did they pull it, they pulled 2 of it then

hidden ermine
#

4 in general but yeah

#

It's associated with death I believe

#

... I only know because of Soul Eater lmao

sleek ferry
#

Anime teaching us life lessons for the win

#

@past socket Any draft bombs I should look out for?

zinc shard
#

Another TMNT Leak

hidden ermine
past socket
golden plover
#

LMAO "Does Machines" is an AWFUL name for a class

glad peak
#

Would anyone oppose to allowing monocolored commanders innate “partners with class” nyaruhodo

tardy echo
#

I assume the whole cycle is gonna be does x does y does z

#

Otherwise that’s a strange name

#

Seems like a good card though

glad peak
#

I would love to play “selvala does machines” icant

golden plover
#

So it's gonna be "Leads", "Does Machines", "Cool But Crude", and.... "Party Dude"...

tardy echo
#

I mean

#

Weird naming conventions but it’s not that bad

golden plover
#

Really clunky names for a set of classes imo

tardy echo
#

Shrug

#

You can’t call them x/y/z class for this one

#

Name is probably just meant to have like some semblance of styling from the franchise

trail anvil
#

I feel like I'm not gonna be able to enjoy the theming from this set regardless but it feels okay as a fit

golden plover
#

I'm sure there's better titles for each that isn't lines from the themesong imo

sleek ferry
#

I mean naming aside, that glass is pretty insane for Sultai/reanimator strategies

#

It puts 4 cards in your gy

#

By itself

golden plover
#

"Dedicated Leader" and "Machine Operator" would be generic enough class names

golden plover
#

No clue how to translate "Cool But Crude" and "Party Dude" but there's other titles for them, no?

tardy echo
#

They don’t want them to be generic enough

subtle sierra
#

this is just first cast of something like esper origins on drugs

tardy echo
#

Is the point

sleek ferry
#

You could also just use it in lessons and have gran gran turned on t2 lmao

tardy echo
#

There aren’t any lootings that are standard legal right now right

sudden lava
copper pecan
subtle sierra
#

when is lorwyn legal on arena again?

golden plover
#

Next Tuesday

sleek ferry
#

Won round 1 with a clean 2-0

#

I’m on GW

sleek ferry
#

Kithkins lowkey have insane cards

trail anvil
#

I think that 2 mana aether vial one might be the best card in the set?

copper pecan
#

me? goongala

sudden lava
#

this makes 5 cards revealed via prerelease

stark skiff
#

Just reveal the cards already

sudden lava
copper pecan
#

for each what among permanents you control?

lusty trench
#

Color

sudden lava
copper pecan
#

oh okay

sudden lava
#

you can see a faint r outline

copper pecan
#

so this is support for vivid then

subtle sierra
#

god this never gets old

copper pecan
#

me when i know how to read

trail anvil
#

bruh there's even a little highlight too on the corner

#

then again sometimes it's just easy to do dumb stuff when you're tired

tardy echo
#

No more vivid ability word I guess icant

#

That was short lived

sudden lava
#

Teenage Mutant Ninja Lorwyn #7

trail anvil
#

well that's just a commander card

#

and it's speed demon but better

sudden lava
#

WOTC when they find out what printer is doing this

trail anvil
#

I think this is on purpose for teasers

lost widgetBOT
sudden lava
trail anvil
#

I mean it wouldn't be the first time they're stepping on the toes of an in-universe set

tardy echo
#

They asked stores to send back pre release teasers no?

trail anvil
#

did they?

copper pecan
tardy echo
#

I doubt they’re trying to play 17-d chess

#

Adam said his store was asked to I believ

copper pecan
# trail anvil did they?

yeah they asked at least one store to send their box back because they accidentally sent tmnt cards instead of lorwyn ones

trail anvil
#

ic

glad peak
#

Tbh wizards has done this on purpose ™ before

tardy echo
#

Normally they don’t ask for the boxes back when they do though no?

copper pecan
#

not that i know of

past socket
#

Yeah I’m on thw side of it being a mistake

#

The quality control issue being something that should be addressed still

#

Still really bad that people aren’t getting what they’re paying for too

copper pecan
#

ninja teen seems really strong

tardy echo
#

2 mana mill half your opponents library is just really fun awesome card design thanks wotc

trail anvil
#

how about 4 mana cheat something onto the battlefield without broadcasting it

lusty trench
sudden lava
#

green technique

trail anvil
copper pecan
#

that seems pretty strong

trail anvil
#

I understand why this effect is black as far as the color pie, but why is it black lore-wise? isn't he the martial arts master of the turtles or something?

copper pecan
#

you could say he tutored them in martial arts

hidden ermine
copper pecan
#

in the original comic his main motivation was to get revenge for shredder killing his master

#

i think revenge is a pretty black thing

trail anvil
#

ic. I feel like the flavor text didn't seem very black lol

sudden lava
#

its also for wubrg reasons

#

They made him the monoblack for character select in the precon

sleek ferry
sudden lava
#

WOTC gave permission to use the turtles in prerelease 🥷 🐢

tardy echo
#

Regardless these cards seem good in general

#

Tutor being 4 mana sorcery is a little idk

#

But the company seems strong

golden plover
#

Miserable round 2 lol. Opponent smelled like cigarettes and tried to argue that because my card says "difference" and not "absolute value" for [[Doran, Besieged By Time]]

lost widgetBOT
#

Legendary Creature — Treefolk Druid
Each creature spell you cast with toughness greater than its power costs mana1 less to cast.
Whenever a creature you control attacks or blocks, it gets +X/+X until end of turn, where X is the difference between its power and toughness.
"Each year that passes rots you with scars. Shelter your heart, for the world is cruel."
0/5

zinc shard
sudden lava
#

Gonna need a copy of south wind Avatar for my Dina deck I'm likely making

trail anvil
#

bruh landfall did not need a mana rock that lightning bolts 😭

golden plover
#

I don't think it's good lol

#

Starts on 3?

#

They want you dying by then

sleek ferry
#

T1 elves
T2 weather maker
T3 play fabled passage, fetch a forest, play icetill explorer, play fabled passage, fetch a forest

sudden lava
#

More prerelease leaks

#

Including a new Splinter commander

trail anvil
#

omg it's another doubler

sudden lava
#

Espur doubler PogYu ninjas go brrrr

glad peak
trail anvil
#

this seems like a really nice sideboard card yeah? 3/2 with menace is already a great value for 2 mana and you can punish cheated out spells

tardy echo
#

hhhh I love wish in standard

#

My favorite mechanic

trail anvil
#

it's a pretty expensive wish but tied to a good body

#

but does a 5/5 flyer stabilize you still? ig jeskai could use this to grab a revelation for a finisher?

tardy echo
#

I mean I’m not super concerned about it being crazy or anything

#

But when there’s a will there’s a way with wishes

#

Just leads to a lot of unfun play patterns in my experience

#

They did try to balance all the annoying stuff you could’ve done with it at least

trail anvil
#

oh no I didn't think it'd be game breaking at all, but just thinking how usable it is in a fast standard

#

preventing blinking it is smart

tardy echo
#

But I will be very unhappy if I ever see it

trail anvil
#

I feel like most of the time if I see it then a Johnny is using it for a fun combo

tardy echo
#

Yes and I hate fun combos CoolSmile

trail anvil
#

oh this does work with airbending though

zinc shard
#

Goddamn, the whole set is gonna get leaked at this rate

#

I thought this was just a couple isolated incidents but the cards are everywhere lmao

golden plover
#

Can they print a playable card in the set tho lol

#

The blue class is good but everything else has looked... Bad

tardy echo
#

The black class looked good too

zinc shard
subtle sierra
#

I miseed it

tardy echo
#

2B when a creature leaves the battlefield deal 1 to opp for 1B all creatures get +1 menace and for B you can sneak anything from gy for 2BB

sleek ferry
#

I think most of the sneaks look playable

#

Raphael’s technique

tardy echo
#

The only technique that I’m not super sure about is the splinter one

lusty trench
#

My favourite

lusty trench
#

Portal is probably still better but this is neat

last glen
#

yo it's a three mana combat trick with permanence

lusty trench
#

Turtles only, I get it, limited exists but man

#

Imagine spending £6 a pack and getting that as your rare

#

I would actually feel like wotc personally saw to it i was torn apart by a spongebobian contraption

sleek ferry
twilit canyon
subtle sierra
#

Hey don't diss my swift aang

glad peak
#

she knows what she said

#

and i agree

lusty trench
#

Like yeah sure its a rare because of limited but like... come on some level of game design work to make this interesting

glad peak
#

that's the main reason why i say no tribe has an identity nyaruhodo

#

no matter what it is, there will always be some cards where the effect is just "give +x/+x"

lusty trench
#

Theres 3 types of creature typal decks that get Venn diagramed: stats, keywords and tokens

#

Occasionally the types do something somewhat interesting with their themes like graveyard interactions (i.e the vermin types), but a lot of the time its just random effects that fit the colour and then those 3 types as glue

glad peak
#

i'm sad it got to that point tbh

#

because now it's just you choose from 2 mechanics with a hat

lusty trench
#

So does giada

#

So does overgrown battlements

sudden lava
lusty trench
#

So do druids

sudden lava
#

"cost 1 less", oh boy I wonder what thats for

lusty trench
#

Wouldve liked it more in red so you can use it for blood but its nice

sudden lava
#

Green card doing green things

glad peak
glad peak
tardy echo
lusty trench
#

Squirrels do it now too

glad peak
#

Not to mention artifacts do it too nyaruhodo

sleek ferry
#

Goblins can also tap for mana

subtle sierra
#

Anything can tap for mana if you try hard enough

sleek ferry
#

And spiders

zinc shard
glad peak
#

Gonna see if I can force bw in this prerelease

#

Was busted in the prerelease yesterday

sleek ferry
#

Specifically GW

glad peak
#

White in general is really really good here

sudden lava
#

Some new commanders I picked up for future decks, and 2 enchantments (Outlander for JennyVastra, twists and turns for Hakbal)

sudden lava
#

As for what the non-enchantments are for (All leading their own decks)
Jinnie: I wanna build selesnya cats.
Satoru Umezawa: No clue, but that guy has aura.
Vren: RATS! 💖 (I am aware Vren cares more about destruction then typical rat kindred. )
Chishiro: I have a copy of [[Barret, Avalanche Leader]] that is going unplayed, I already have big beefy storm aura (Pearl-Ear) and big beefy equipment (Naya Tifa). Now to make token army gruul equipment
Iroh Pizza Master: As an enjoyer of junk food, I am making boros pizza deck. White has multiple ways to get food including Iroh's own enter ability. Iroh also gives me an employee for every pizza sold, with them getting bigger paychecks with each slice given out

lost widgetBOT
sudden lava
#

@past socket what did you mean by the X 😅 ?

past socket
#

For some reason I double tap sometimes and it does X’s because Discord is weird

sudden lava
#

Ah ok

past socket
#

I usually catch it

zinc shard
#

New blink target just dropped

lusty trench
#

I feel like kitsune couldve been permanents without it causing issues

knotty ferry
#

yo i just beat mtg arena tutorial

#

this game is fucking easy

twilit canyon
#

true

zinc shard
glad peak
#

So I opened a cracked bw deck

#

And still lost a round because I was stuck on 3 lands and all my ways of getting out of the jam were 4 mana

sleek ferry
glad peak
#

I opened so much removal but it was all 2 mana and I had no creatures on field anymore nukgar

#

I lost with all of my answers in hand

sleek ferry
trail anvil
#

fwiw credit to wizards. they're doing a lot better job on this than I thought they would, especially after the spiderman debacle

#

I'm thinking/hoping that was an outlier

subtle sierra
#

hmm i like this land

sleek ferry
#

Look at Lorwyn too, it’s a pretty low power set all things considered

#

But it has a lot of soul

trail anvil
#

aetherdrift and mkm were just misguided really

#

and thunder junction

glad peak
#

Tried eclipse’s draft, surprisingly fun for a kindred set

#

Focusing more on mechanics rather than kindred synergy really helped them out here

#

You can actually get emergent gameplay this way

golden plover
#

What are we doing here

#

My opponent shouldn't be able to get anything from my 7 mana sorcery

stark skiff
#

Some of these just feel like other MtG cards being skinned for TMNT meh

glad peak
#

Made some headway into my modular jund cube

#

Made the executive decision to have 3 piles: 1 for fixing, 1 for core cards (removal, ramp, draw, etc), 1 for themes (bulk of the cube, semi-parasitic cute archetypes)

#

I think I’ll actually make the mana weak

golden plover
#

New Maralen as a commander is fun, but rough when you start running out of steam. I imagine she gets better the stronger the other cards are tho

glad peak
#

New food chain commander alert new food chain commander alert

molten scaffold
#

does anyone know how to get snapcaster mage miku the gambling way

lusty trench
subtle sierra
#

Is there an amount of shock lands that is too much in a deck?

#

I'm debating on getting 3 of temple garden and hallowed fountain, or 4 of each

#

Context the deck is bant airbending

#

And for simic mana i use botanical sanctum

fallow citrus
#

depends how much mana fixing you have already

#

you could use modern as a guideline, granted they have fetches but you could substitute them for your other lands

subtle sierra