#Magic the Gathering

1 messages · Page 158 of 1

sudden lava
#

Also as people said, Bello is a fun commander. Trash panda chucking artifacts and enchantments at people 💖 mass respect to the commander

#

(though I don't have a Bello list, I see it around the LGS)

fast tide
#

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

#

How reliant on upgrades is trash panda or bunny? Or are they plenty playable oob?

sudden lava
#

Bunny is pretty good out the box, though her upgrades aren't too expensive

fast tide
#

@atomic harness how's the trash panda by comparison?

sudden lava
#

The funny thing to do with trash panda, vehicles

fast tide
#

Oh god you can throw vehicles at people too?!

sudden lava
#

Yup

#

as long as they are mana value 4+

fast tide
#

SOLD AMERICAN

sudden lava
#

Bello even gives the enchantments/artifacts haste so the stuff can be thrown the turn they are placed down

fast tide
#

Cool I'll eye it up

#

Still keeping Bumbleflower bookmarked though she looks super fun and a playstyle I've never even thought of before

atomic harness
#

Otherwise its cracked you get so much value

#

my friend keeps playing this hideaway buggy card

sudden lava
#

also bumbleflower precon comes with the cutest of the planeswalker animals (each precon came with 1)

fast tide
#

fffffffffffffffffffffffff

atomic harness
#

Enjoy little duckster

#

I need to build a different deck because my entire table keeps dying to our friend's vandalblast Sadge

gritty nest
#

I tore apart my bumbleflower because nobody ever interacted with me and those that did got beat to death. When I’d (obviously) win, the other players would get salty about it

trail anvil
#

@golden plover good news for you

#

coming september 2, so really soon

#

oh no sorry preorders start september 2 lmao, 23rd is the release date

tardy echo
#

That’s still very soon no

trail anvil
#

depends on how you see time nyarusnatchy

tardy echo
#

<30 days

sudden lava
fast tide
#

Oh my lord they're all cool

past socket
#

[[!Liliana of the Dark Realms|BLC]]

past socket
#

[[!Nissa, Who Shakes The World|BLC]]

fast tide
#

There we go

#

Bello deck ordered and a smattering of upgrades ordered

past socket
#

Ooo Bello is incredibly funny

fast tide
#

Lowkey thought about getting

#

The idea of a screaming raccoon yeeting a necron monolith while necron warriors spill out of the eternity gate is hysterical to me

#

But the mill doesn't quite work with the deck

past socket
#

It is very possible to do Vehicle funnies with Bello too

#

Considering how he works allows you to not bother with Crew costs

fast tide
#

Yeah I didn't go too crazy but I got some fun ones

#

Thanks renren for the buggy rec

#

And these seem like they'd have fun interactions too HyperLUL Thunderhulk would enter as a 7/7 right? And shits out seven 1/1 gnomes, then I can immediately attack and shit out seven more gnomes?

#

Kind of wanted roaming throne but holy fuck that's an expensive bitch

atomic harness
#

The deck is really resilient to usual wipes when it gets going because most of your threats are vehicles or enchantments/artifacts that are not creatures

#

then the value you get off hitting should be enough to just recast bello if he dies

#

Ofc theres dedicated artifact hate but thats usually on the rarer side (rip to a farewell ig)

#

I think the stuff you have to worry about is mass artifact hate
Ppl killing 🅱️ello too much

And alpha strikes

stark skiff
#

People kiling Bello will be your biggest problem

#

usually just gets removed right away.

atomic harness
#

So these green kids just get to have fun ICANT

stark skiff
atomic harness
#

Yeah I havent been playing much

#

Combo guy just lets the other value kids do whatever because Im literally the only one that can stop him

#

and so im also the only one hes focusing

stark skiff
#

we've been converting a decent amount of players to commander at our shop so its been helpful in instilling good habits lol

ornate cedar
#

Ngl I haven’t felt the need to play magic in a good minute because I’m having more fun with YGO at the moment

#

That, and ironically YGO is cheaper than Magic atm

waxen timber
#

I mostly play Commander and draft but, my LGS has had a hard time running drafts for current releases

#

For Final Fantasy draft, they only had enough product to do 1 draft and the draft they did was more expensive with less prizing

#

This might be just because they didn't order enough but, they also ran out of EoE within 2 weeks so they couldn't do that much EoE draft

glad peak
ornate cedar
#

I still haven’t played with my Doctor Who deck, need to get around to that

trail anvil
#

man even oswald fiddlebender is playing fucking strip mine lock now lmao

golden plover
#

Yeah, strip mine is a problem in 1v1 formats

#

Turns out always being ahead on lands is good

glad peak
#

They should bring port into the game

ornate cedar
#

I just realized something

#

How long until labubu secret lair?

glad peak
#

Depends

#

But it’s also possible there’s going to be a labubu inspired set in about 2 years

ornate cedar
#

Does Labubu even have the lore for that?

#

I don’t know a thing about the show lol

glad peak
#

No idea but would that stop wotc? icant

ornate cedar
#

Sigh they’re gonna make a skibidi toilet set one day aren’t they?

glad peak
#

I think skibidi toilet is too niche for them

#

Oh I know where labubus can come in

#

Due to the popularity of kpop demon hunters, there will be a kpop themed set with an enemies to lovers storyline and in there there’s a collectible set of artifacts that look like a bastardization of chibi monsters

copper pecan
#

it's just figurines

glad peak
#

There’s a children’s book on it

#

Well, a book that has them

ornate cedar
#

Oh it’s in development

#

Then what did I watch? Maybe it was just content farms idk

#

Ok you’re right oomphie

golden plover
#

Okay yeah brawl is fucked

#

W6 is insane lol

golden plover
#

Bundles and Commander Precons cost $10 more as of Lorwyn Eclipsed 🙁

#

Oh and collector boosters are $27 MSRP

lusty trench
#

Didn't they like

#

Put up prices a year ago?

sleek ferry
#

Its been a couple of years since they put precon prices up iirc

#

Like post Covid if I remember

golden plover
#

They went from $40 to $45 like 2022ish?

#

Now they're $55 for a commander precon and almost $60 for a bundle

#

Which is crazy btw, considering you can get the same amount of packs for like $3 less

#

What are you paying for then? $3 for the dice?

sudden lava
#

new precons

#

for Lorwyn

#

Commander bundle includes 4 decks (keep in mind this doesnt indicate 4 different precons)

gritty nest
#

Have any of you heard of an LGS doing essentially a pro membership thing?

lusty trench
#

Honestly, if it comes with free usage of the play spaces, im all for them

gritty nest
#

As far as I understood it, $10 month gets you 10 store credit, 10% off, and apparently cash back as store credit

sudden lava
trail anvil
#

christ I've suddenly run into a massive spike in wrenn and six in brawl for some reason

glad peak
#

Now that I think about it when was the first time wotc decided to balance sets around archetypes

copper pecan
#

if you mean the color pair draft archetypes then idk which one was the first to be designed around those

atomic harness
#

Mirage

copper pecan
#

apparently theros was the first set that used the current design structure of "every color pair gets a limited archetype"

atomic harness
#

I kinda wish kunoros was a little bit better

glad peak
#

Interesting

#

Yeah I remember mirage and tempest having a lot of fans but I never played them

atomic harness
#

Thank you mr mudkip

#

Also the pod dynamic seems to be improving when I was away
The green kids are finally looking their way at mr combo man who always destroys them with the free spells

stark skiff
#

Well when the crutch is gone they either need to adapt or just die

atomic harness
broken fjord
#

I know that feeling. Though I have a very "gun to your head" form of deterrence. Not for every play, or even most.

gritty nest
#

can someone tell me why [[frenzied baloth]] is $2?

lost widgetBOT
twilit canyon
#

card's ass

gritty nest
#

whys that

broken fjord
#

I guess people like that it makes sure your creatures resolve and prevents fogs.

twilit canyon
#

neither effect is useful at the cost.

golden plover
#

Hmm having a decent bit of luck with Tidebinder in Dimir against Cauldron. Turns off Cauldron or Vivi

#

Deck is still unfair and needs a ban, but Tidebinder is helping lol

subtle sierra
#

Yeah i need to get two more tidebinders

#

I kinda wanna side 4

#

Tishana even hitting random shit like drowner or bat is kinda clutch sometimes

golden plover
#

Card is very solid, I just always feel bad when it's a 3/2 that dies on spot

subtle sierra
#

That is true but since cut down rotated it's slightly better

#

If they waste a stab on her it's fine since she still negates

golden plover
#

Yeah true

subtle sierra
#

Or even better, waste mana on tragic trajectory

glad peak
#

I actually can’t remember, what happens if you pull from tomorrow a card “under” Agatha’s? Or more commonly, if you Agatha’s your commander in grave and then put it into the command zone right after?

subtle sierra
#

Then they have to lose tempo cause you're suddenly in no more lies range

glad peak
#

Iirc creatures with counters no longer have the card that was under Agatha’s because it’s no longer a “card exiled by Agatha’s soul cauldron”, right?

golden plover
#

Yeah if the card isn't in the cauldron, they don't get the ability

glad peak
#

Welp back to building lantern control in commander

#

Nah tho I’m glad I got the lands portion of my 15 card modular cube all set KEKW

#

The rest is easy: just go through my favorite draft archetypes/sets and port over their 15

#

Oh and figure out a way to remove the parasites of course (energy is the worst one here unfortunately because I like the mh drafts)

ornate cedar
#

Are the EOE precons good or should I get singles?

atomic harness
#

World shaper is really strong and only needs a few changes (take out the wastes)

sudden lava
steady onyx
#

if I want to build a new commander deck is a parnter commander deck or enchantment tribal a better direction

#

i want something thats not too expensive

#

and it just kinda fun

#

ive always wanted to try some like enchantment tribal but ikd

#

idk what enchantment are good but like eriette seems cool I like sythis because she is cheap, I like go shintai, i just dont wanna play a complete like wait a while and play the game deck

glad peak
#

Ahem

steady onyx
#

i want to ahve some early board presence

#

idk

glad peak
#

Erinis + street urchin KEKW

#

Sythis is very very good if you’re willing to do multiple storm turns with no wins until you can win

steady onyx
#

hmm

#

is eriette good

#

she honestly seems like the most fun to me

#

but idk

#

or aniketha

glad peak
#

Which eriette?

steady onyx
#

the charmed apple

glad peak
#

[[aniketha]] iirc was pretty fun

lost widgetBOT
#

No card found for “aniketha”

steady onyx
#

yeah

glad peak
#

I remember some stupid combo with it but it’s also very heavy stax KEKW

#

I don’t really like the charmed apple one, honestly plays out very boring

steady onyx
#

or wait

#

edgar is finally cheap

#

...

#

cause I like decks where commanders are cheap

#

or the deck functions without them on field

#

also [[calix guided by fate]]

lost widgetBOT
#

Legendary Enchantment Creature — Human Druid
Constellation — Whenever Calix or another enchantment you control enters, put a +1/+1 counter on target creature.
Whenever Calix or an enchanted creature you control deals combat damage to a player, you may create a token that's a copy of a nonlegendary enchantment you control. Do this only once each turn.
2/2

glad peak
steady onyx
glad peak
#

Doesn’t have to be

steady onyx
#

i kinda always thought he was more agro

#

but idk

glad peak
#

But he’s the old school mentality of “build big enough board then destroy all lands to freeze the board”

steady onyx
#

ok ngl

#

calix seems v interesting to me

#

but idk about selesnya

trail anvil
#

seconding anikthea

#

the black splash into abzan gives you some really fun stuff to dip into and using your graveyard as a second hand is always fun

glad peak
#

Tbh most decks should just be made with stax pieces ngl

#

I can’t remember [[yosei]]’s full text

lost widgetBOT
trail anvil
#

the precon is super solid too

steady onyx
#

im between calix and anikthea rn

#

they both seem fun

trail anvil
#

I'd personally go for anikthea, especially if you're on a budget

glad peak
#

Anikthea because you’re going to be able to get better staples that way

steady onyx
#

can i at least put calix in the deck

#

;-;

#

he seems cool

trail anvil
#

yeah he's probably fine

#

if you really want you can build calix but I imagine it's way different, like some kind of aura voltron strategy

steady onyx
#

just like

#

my only worry

#

can anikthea playwithout commander on field?

#

and do I buy precon and upgrade

#

or what

glad peak
#

I’d suggest singles

steady onyx
#

ok

glad peak
#

Anikthea doesn’t need the commander and probably shouldn’t come out until you have stuff in grave

trail anvil
#

in the case of anikthea I'd actually buy the precon first, it genuinely has a lot of stuff you'd want for it

#

and you'll save on shipping costs

glad peak
#

Calix really needs the commander out on the field

steady onyx
#

hes 3 mana

#

anikthea is 5

#

idk

#

but ok

trail anvil
#

if you really want a cheap commander you can just play sythis lol

steady onyx
#

no

#

no

#

no

#

i dont wanna play her

glad peak
#

3 is still very expensive since you need to double spell to get any impact on his first turn out

#

Why not sythis ?

steady onyx
#

boring

#

k ill buy precon

#

and upgrade later

#

omg its my bestie cake

tardy echo
#

I wish newgin had a real home in standard this card is so hype

#

But all the decks that play him are like

steady onyx
tardy echo
#

Ketramose or weirdo ramp

#

Both of which I enjoy playing but bleh

glad peak
#

Tbh enchantress in general is pretty boring

#

But at least this way you can draw cards nyaruhodo

trail anvil
#

I actually like anikthea in terms of enchantress

#

normally it's a pretty bland strategy but graveyard synergy my beloved

glad peak
#

I actually like calix even though it’s a mix of the 2 least interesting things

tardy echo
#

[[anikthea]]

lost widgetBOT
#

Legendary Enchantment Creature — Demigod
Menace
Other enchantment creatures you control have menace.
Whenever Anikthea enters or attacks, exile up to one target non-Aura enchantment card from your graveyard. Create a token that's a copy of that card, except it's a 3/3 black Zombie creature in addition to its other types.
4/4

tardy echo
#

Theros had some super hype stuff

golden plover
#

I'm honestly kinda glad Newgin sucks in standard

#

I don't want you to exile my shit on a cast trigger, go away

tardy echo
#
  • hates when aggro is good
  • hates when combo is good
  • hates when control is good
trail anvil
#

7 mana ugin makes me miss 8 mana ugin in standard lol

#

I remember using that in monowhite

tardy echo
#

6 mana ugin was also cool

#

Ugin is just a cool pw

#

Colorless cards are a cool design space Prayge

trail anvil
#

when are we getting all is dust on arena

#

wizards pls

tardy echo
#

[[all is dust]]

lost widgetBOT
tardy echo
#

This isn’t in arena yet??

twilit canyon
#

nope

trail anvil
#

I'd slam it straight into ugin otherwise

hidden ermine
#

Not the only thing you would slam into Ugin I wager

tardy echo
#

I have something I’d

#

Fuck

hidden ermine
#

Ninja'd

sleek ferry
#

I hear you, but [[farewell]] any response?

lost widgetBOT
trail anvil
tardy echo
hidden ermine
#

Un afraud we already said Farewell nyaruhodo

copper pecan
#

was farewell seb's last card?

#

if it was that's a crazy coincidence

glad peak
#

Wait seb isn’t doing art for wotc anymore?

hidden ermine
#

Nay

#

He got axed because of ...

sleek ferry
#

He had the whole anti vaxxer thing with the white supremacist group

glad peak
#

Oh huh

hidden ermine
#

Was it antivax bullshit or Qanon bullshit

#

Oh both

sleek ferry
#

Yeah, he double dipped

#

He could have gotten past just being an anti vaxxer probably

glad peak
#

Welp I can’t be bothered to remember who has and hasn’t been canceled anymore lmao

golden plover
#

I think he had a card in baldurs gate?

#

But he's definitely been axed since

#

Although they aren't consistent on changing his art yet and still reprint it sometimes

sleek ferry
#

Farewell got reprinted almost immediately tbf

#

It’s not as if all his arts are of relevant cards anyways

golden plover
#

Yeah but stuff like Archfiend of Ifnir got a reprint in Aetherdrift

#

And it kept his art

sleek ferry
#

Oh huh, I mean ig it was a commander reprint

#

Speculation, but I would think WotC doesn’t want his art to be held into for monetary gain

#

So reprinting his cards every now and then is probably not the worst idea?

golden plover
#

Typically they fully swap the art

#

And sometimes they have with him

#

Like Animatou's Augury has new art in Duskmorn commander

sudden lava
#

oh yeah ruling clarification since @fast tide was discussing Bello.
The way it works with vehicles/spacecraft is it will be a 4/4

glad peak
#

[[bello,]]

lost widgetBOT
#

Multiple cards match “bello,”, can you be more specific?

sudden lava
#

[[bello, bard]]

lost widgetBOT
glad peak
#

I think bello specifies non-creature artifacts so yep

#

Oh wait he doesn’t

#

But still yep

#

But if you crew it stays a 4/4 I think

sudden lava
#

well, always on own turn

#

cuz Bello turns off on opponents turns

glad peak
#

I think it overwrites since on your turn it’s a static ability no matter if the artifact is a creature or not but it’s been a while since I looked at the rulings so nyaruhodo

trail anvil
#

just realized w6 is an even more cancerous commander than I initially thought, you actually just can't play creatures with 1 toughness

#

is this how legacy players felt

tardy echo
#

It does indeed take a fair bit for a card to be banned in legacy

twilit canyon
fallow citrus
#

w6 and bowmasters made 1 toughness creatures unplayable

#

you could cope with w6 but with bowmasters too it was just joever

gritty nest
#

Do any of you play mono black in commander?

glad peak
#

Turns out wasteland looping and also making thalia unplayable is pretty good in legacy KEKW

zinc shard
broken fjord
#

I have Zenos. Used to have Gix as well as Kaervek the Punisher.

trail anvil
#

I liked Junji with cheat effects

glad peak
#

i like yawgdaddy but losing green hurts

sudden lava
atomic harness
gritty nest
#

My friend is now having trouble with the same LGS I had the ancient tomb problems with. Same trade in issue, but they traded in a week before I did, where they were advertising the 80% credit. And then on top of that, said the master piece they traded in was fake

atomic harness
golden plover
#

Whoops WAR Nissa + Springheart Nantuko goes infinite

steady onyx
#

is sultai midrange good in standard?

#

i was like i know dimir midrange is good

#

and I know simic midrange is good

#

so if u mix the 2 toegether

#

they share green

#

so its has to be good no?

tardy echo
#

Simic midrange is “good”

#

And the 2 decks play very differently

#

There are sultai decks in standard but they play more like a control deck

golden plover
#

Just remembered how people freaked the fuck out about [[Lord Xander, the Collector]]

lost widgetBOT
#

Legendary Creature — Vampire Demon Noble
When Lord Xander enters, target opponent discards half the cards in their hand, rounded down.
Whenever Lord Xander attacks, defending player mills half their library, rounded down.
When Lord Xander dies, target opponent sacrifices half the nonland permanents they control of their choice, rounded down.
6/6

golden plover
#

People said he was gonna be the most busted commander ever or whatever lol

#

You could make him 4 mana and make everything round up and he'd still be kinda bad

#

Could also strip the nonland clause off his death trigger lol

glad peak
#

People still think that whenever they see it at the table

#

Theyre wrong obviously but still

golden plover
#

Lmao good luck getting him out and able to swing

#

He's gonna die on the spot and I'll just lose my 2 worst guys for it

#

He reads 7 mana "discard 2, sacc 3 bad cards"

glad peak
#

Tbf these are also the guys who say mill is too strong

lusty trench
#

I think i still have my gilded xander

golden plover
#

This is still a bad card lol

fallow citrus
#

not even in white for the good flicker effects smh

golden plover
#

Honestly, there's like 3 flickers total in blue

#

And conjurers closet ig?

#

Cool 13 mana combo to make 2 players discard 2 each

glad peak
#

I’ve had one guy tell me that they saw a cedh video and they won with mill so mill is overpowered

golden plover
#

The fact that they pick is really what seals the deal on him being awful

glad peak
#

The mill they were talking about was brain freeze

golden plover
#

He will literally always grab the worst half of what the mode is

#

And because he rounds down, he can never take their last card or their last permanent

#

Ob actually killed this guy because he was so dogshit at doing anything

gritty nest
#

My friend got the cards back

#

Urza is fake but the Meekstone were unsure about

sleek ferry
#

Lord Xanders biggest strength is that his art is sexy

glad peak
#

So I talked to the guy who thought mill was cedh because he saw brain freeze winning a game

#

Now he thinks hope is cedh viable because you can gain a bunch of life with aetherflux and mill everyone out with it icant

golden plover
#

Lmao what

glad peak
#

“Hope + aetherflux + storming off = win, mill is broken” was the argument KEKW

zinc shard
#

Boy, its a shame Aetherflux Resevoir cant win the game on its own

glad peak
#

Ikr icant

#

Yes, someone else brought that up

#

Yes, he doubled down and said “well what if they played the one ring last turn” froghead

#

Mans doesn’t know what instant speed is

golden plover
#

What if they played the one ring and have a tefs protection and an angels grace and a nexus of fate and you're under drannith magistrate and winter orb and silence

#

What would you do then

glad peak
#

True icant

copper pecan
#

what if the world was made of pudding

glad peak
#

For all we know, it is

#

We just don’t know it because we don’t know what not-pudding is

golden plover
#

Actually wait show them nexus

#

Tell them that half the time you can't mill out a blue deck in cedh

#

And the green one but who plays the green one

fallow citrus
#

wait until they learn about inkmoth nexus + colossus hammer

glad peak
#

Hmm brb showing them nexus but I think I know what their answer’s gonna be

golden plover
#

Wait until they learn about [[Blighted Agent]]

lost widgetBOT
golden plover
#

Don't even have to jump through as many hoops

glad peak
#

Nah they already think infect is broken

golden plover
#

What did they say about nexus

glad peak
#

First it started with “that’s too expensive, no one in cedh plays this card”

golden plover
#

Did you tell them that most blue decks do lol

#

And half the time it's not even getting cast

#

It just stops the brain freeze win

glad peak
#

Then it became “hope can just mill their entire deck except for this and win on the turn after” KEKW

golden plover
#

"Hope can give the opponent infinite extra turns"

glad peak
#

Yeah I don’t think they registered that nexus will give them another card to draw after it gets cast

#

Tbf had an argument with them about infect a long long time ago and he was convinced no one in cedh played infect as a sort of gentleman’s agreement clearly

golden plover
#

Lmao I wish there was a viable way to do infect in cedh

#

It's funky and it'd be funny

fallow citrus
#

gentlemens agreement not to play bad cards in cedh yeah

trail anvil
golden plover
#

Guys let's all agree now to not play [[Gray Ogre]] in cedh

lost widgetBOT
golden plover
fallow citrus
#

I love the bracket system because I can make a bracket 3 deck with some fucked combos in because it doesn't use any game changers

copper pecan
fallow citrus
#

I am also so shocked that some cards aren't game changers but maybe it's my 60 card goggles on

golden plover
copper pecan
#

you take every advantage you can get without cheating or you lose

fallow citrus
#

like daze and gush aren't game changers?

copper pecan
golden plover
lost widgetBOT
fallow citrus
#

HUH

copper pecan
#

weevil underwood moment

golden plover
#

Aura Shards is the funniest fucking game changer

#

Like bro this is just worse than a farewell

fallow citrus
#

I only just learned about which cards are game changers when making some lower bracket edh decks for friends

golden plover
#

Grand Arbiter is also a game changer

#

It's like they found a 5 year old article about what cards piss people off in commander and just went "that's the game changer list"

fallow citrus
#

coalition victory is a game changer...

trail anvil
copper pecan
#

i feel like coalition victory being a game changer makes sense

trail anvil
#

I think the best way to play it is atraxa but that's still gonna get you focused down super early

golden plover
#

Sway of the Stars is a game changer...

copper pecan
#

just controling a 5 color creature is not nearly a difficult enough hoop to jump through for a card that just wins the game on the spot

golden plover
#

Although tbh if someone plays Sway of the Stars against me and I don't have a counter I'm just gonna scoop

#

Not because they're winning but because that card is insufferable and just restarts the game

trail anvil
#

coalition victory and sway of the stars are probably coming off the game changer list soon, it's like konami with the semi-limited list

fallow citrus
#

glacial chasm is a funny one

golden plover
#

You are no closer to winning after a sway than you were before

#

In fact, you're almost guaranteed to be worse off

trail anvil
#

chasm is mostly cause people don't run land destruction

fallow citrus
#

is it just a game changer because people refuse to run land destruction

golden plover
#

Sway of the Stars is fine being unbanned, but the play pattern of that card is so annoying

fallow citrus
#

lmao

trail anvil
#

which like

#

idk it fits the list lol

golden plover
#

Reminder that if you have too much land destruction you're bracket 4 by default

fallow citrus
#

but also like game changers feel like they encompass too much of a range

golden plover
#

I also still don't get why Yuriko is a game changer when they can just eratta commande ninjitsu to work the way it's supposed to

fallow citrus
#

smothering tithe is not on the same page as gaea's cradle

golden plover
#

I guess it's too late now but they could easily just go "Oh yeah you still pay tax on commander ninjitsu"

trail anvil
#

I mean yeah but I get why they're both game changers

fallow citrus
#

I understand it I just don't like it

copper pecan
#

i don't think they want to do a power level errata

trail anvil
#

what I don't get is why crop rotation is on there

fallow citrus
#

I almost feel like you could have looked at some cards like mishra's workshop, cradle, ancient tomb etc and be like

golden plover
#

Tutor

fallow citrus
#

you can't play these unless it's bracket 4 or 5

trail anvil
#

open the armory is a tutor

golden plover
#

For some reason random tutors are game changers

fallow citrus
#

instead of being able to play cradle in my pre-con

trail anvil
#

I need a better argument than that

fallow citrus
#

bad example but you get the idea

golden plover
#

The game changer tutors are completely randomly decided based on vibes

#

Like I wish I could give you a better argument

#

But it's literally all vibes based

#

Gamble is a game changer

trail anvil
#

gamble is an unconditional tutor even with the random discard

golden plover
#

Tergrid being a game changer is hilarious

fallow citrus
#

I like the idea of "game changers are kinda powerful cards that if you have too many your deck is probably broken" and then you have a list like "these cards are definitely broken unless you're playing a high powered pod so you're bracket 4 minimum by playng them" for example

#

but I don't think there's a right way to do it at the end of the day

trail anvil
#

tergrid is like the poster child of a game changer

golden plover
#

I don't think it deters that one guy at your LGS who pub stomps new players with tergrid because they just won't run the others

#

But like, Tergrid is such an easy card to deal with

#

I dunno, I feel like game changers are a good idea

#

But it literally just feels like they asked 100 random people what cards make them salty and picked all of those

trail anvil
#

I feel like half the point of game changers is to get rid of salty cards

#

for pods that want it

copper pecan
#

yeah the point isn't that they're too strong, it's that they're not fun for casual players

trail anvil
#

if it was a power thing they'd just be banned

gritty nest
#

Just ban everything ngl

tardy echo
#

Commander players hate everything. Solution? Ban commander

gritty nest
#

This

#

(I only play commander)

golden plover
#

New bracket system

#

If a card beats you it's banned

gritty nest
#

Shit basics are banned

golden plover
#

Did you get beat to death with a basic land?

gritty nest
#

Mayhaps

golden plover
#

Then Nissa or whatever gets banned ig

gritty nest
#

Ah just ban both to be safe

#

Get rid of the enabler and the end piece to make sure no more degenerate combos

sleek ferry
tardy echo
#

Also random question what is oathbreaker icant

rigid scarab
#

Your commander is a planeswalker and is a partner with any instant/sorcery

tardy echo
#

Still 4 player or no

rigid scarab
#

Still 4 player

rigid scarab
tardy echo
#

Nvm

#

I was gonna say this sounds hype but nvm

#

Is there oathbreaker but brawl

rigid scarab
#

Idk

glad peak
#

It’s pretty fun

#

But needs a lot more fixing

gritty nest
#

Do you guys want to see that meekstones T and green dot?

glad peak
#

sure, but it's hard to tell for sure online

gritty nest
glad peak
#

i can't tell for green dot but T looks right

sudden lava
#

Got a free copy of Serah from the person who gave me a free copy of Lightning Army of One

#

Same person also gave me a Gilgamesh a while back, definitely is naya legends they got extras of

sudden lava
#

Spoiler season debut for spiderman tomorrow

gritty nest
steady onyx
#

If i wanna build mono black
massacre girl
massacre girl known killer
braids arisen nightmare

gritty nest
#

I dont plan to use them myself tbh

fallow citrus
sleek ferry
#

I’ve been playing out of my god damn mind today

#

Probably some of the best play I’ve seen out of myself

golden plover
#

I played like 3 really good Dimir games earlier myself

#

Then I hit that temur deck and I just felt like I played awful

#

That deck is even bigger gambling than mono-G landfall tho lol

sleek ferry
#

I’ve been testing a mardu legendary matters deck

#

And the amount of synergy this deck has is crazy, I didn’t even notice it until I tested it

#

Cards like [[Kellan, the far blooded]] have aged really nicely

lost widgetBOT
#

No card found for “Kellan, the far blooded”

sleek ferry
#

Just grabbing sheltered by ghosts on demand

#

[[the seriema]] has also just been great

lost widgetBOT
#

Legendary Artifact — Spacecraft
When The Seriema enters, search your library for a legendary creature card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle.
Station (Tap another creature you control: Put charge counters equal to its power on this Spacecraft. Station only as a sorcery. It's an artifact creature at 7+.)
STATION 7+
Flying
Other tapped legendary creatures you control have indestructible.
5/5

sleek ferry
golden plover
#

Okay maybe Brawl can be fun

sleek ferry
#

Cope

#

1v1 commander can never be fun

glad peak
#

you can remove the 1v1 from your message and it'll still be right

sleek ferry
#

Also cope

glad peak
#

yes you are if i'm wrong nyaruhodo

golden plover
#

Brawl isn't like great, but I get to strip lock people from the command zone

#

And that's funny

glad peak
#

what're some of the most fun draft archetypes in the past 10 years?

#

mh2 rw artifacts, kld rb vehicles, tsm ur storm are some of my favorites

zinc shard
sudden lava
#

2 glitters in one for my pearl ear deck is neat

twilit canyon
#

literally had it all and they freaked it

copper pecan
#

shouldn't have taken the harry potter licensing deal then

twilit canyon
#

or used ai on products

copper pecan
#

i feel like directly funding hate groups is worse than using ai

#

like

#

not even close

stark skiff
#

Sick art

twilit canyon
#

def doesnt help to kick the hornet's nest over ai and then immediately going into harry potter lol

copper pecan
#

tbh if someone was more upset about the ai thing than about the harry potter thing then they really need to get their priorities straight

subtle sierra
copper pecan
#

ultimate guard used ai to extend the art on one of their sleves because they accidentally commissioned it at the wrong aspect ratio

#

they apologized and said they wouldn't do it again

#

but then a few days later they took a brand deal with harry potter

subtle sierra
copper pecan
#

and people were not willing to put up with them fucking up twice in a row like that

trail anvil
#

LSV could learn a thing or two

zinc shard
#

Spiderman reveals are starting

twilit canyon
zinc shard
past socket
#

We”re Junding em out!

zinc shard
#

There's more hybrid cards in this set

#

Sand creature

lusty trench
#

Ayo electro decent

zinc shard
trail anvil
#

oh hey, ozolith at home

#

but it does start off with counters so a higher baseline

zinc shard
trail anvil
# zinc shard

peak commander card, can't wait to use this in green land mill decks

zinc shard
copper pecan
#

obligatory "grixis goblin" joke

zinc shard
#

set was made with "Pick 2 Draft" in mind

#

Archetypes:

GW: Spider Heroes
WU: Modified
UB: Villains/Connive
RG: Big Creatures
BR: Mayhem

stark skiff
zinc shard
copper pecan
# zinc shard

they're marketing this as a spiderman set but it's clearly a new york set

zinc shard
trail anvil
#

rhino looks like a limited bomb and a half

#

vigilance, trample and draw all in one

#

also I'm glad mayhem is named so generically for future use considering it's just madness with normal timing restrictions

zinc shard
#

bonus sheet time

trail anvil
#

gotta love another heroic intervention reprint

zinc shard
hidden ermine
#

OK yeah it's definitely spiderman pointing at spiderman for the meme as a card

zinc shard
past socket
#

Electro’s last effect is really funny

#

Just going out hating

zinc shard
#

The Soul Stone is the only Infinity Stone in this set

hidden ermine
stark skiff
#

New secret lair!

gritty nest
#

Got stomped at the lgs, left

#

Only played 2 games

fallow citrus
# zinc shard

do.. they not have a name? surely they're not just "spider man india"

zinc shard
#

Pavitr Prabhakar

hidden ermine
trail anvil
#

libel is a crime

rigid scarab
#

Not bad formatting either

rigid scarab
#

In the command zone it can be annoying ig but not as annoying as krrik

stark skiff
tardy echo
#

I want a refund

ornate cedar
#

So, I just saw how much the avatar products are

#

There goes any desire to buy those cards lol

#

Arena is all I need

#

I wonder how long this continues before the shoe drops

glad peak
#

Until it stops making money

stark skiff
#

cant wait to open some collector boxes

ornate cedar
#

Sigh I guess wizards have figured that people that just want to play will deal with Arena, and people that want to collect will have to fork over the money

#

And then people like Rudy just buy everything and scalp it

glad peak
#

Can’t wait to forego my car payment to buy a booster box nyaruhodo

ornate cedar
#

I can’t wait to buy none of it PoyoyoThumbsUp

#

That’s the result Wizards clearly wants

stark skiff
#

threw this together. did a few feel out games and its pretty fun. just feel like i need more protection. any suggestions to edit?

glad peak
#

Esper Terra
Looks inside
5 colors

stark skiff
sudden lava
#

Front side is red green

#

But when she becomes Esper Terra she gets black, blue, and white

fallow citrus
#

I like that you essentially trade in your pictures of spiderman for money

past socket
#

Reminded of some other JK Simmons roles

#

Like in Whiplash and one of the Command and Conquer titles as the President of the United States

golden plover
#

30% of SGC was on Vivi Cauldron. That number shoots up to 60% top cut

ornate cedar
#

Sigh stop making broken cards WOTC

sudden lava
#

People found a combo for "with great power"

#

slap it on an indestructible creature

trail anvil
#

that combo is older than the dinosaurs [[pariah]]

lost widgetBOT
sudden lava
#

always good to have an extra, consistency and all

golden plover
#

Great Power is unplayable in standard

#

Ketramose is a fraud

#

You'll be dead to Vivi 5 turns before they get that going

#

And if you do get it online? Flood Maw GG

twilit canyon
#

theres infinite outs

#

type of noob trap combo someone plays that explodes vs good cards

sudden lava
#

yeah sadly

steady onyx
#

omg omg its misty

#

hello misty!!

#

u play legacy / anyone here play legacy

#

?

#

the club at my school is running legacy tourney tonight and I wanna proxy a deck to use

#

and I wanted some reccomendations

twilit canyon
#

oh its this dipshit again /s

#

i do not play legacy atm i dont have an lgs near me that has a legacy scene

steady onyx
#

ok

twilit canyon
#

if u are ever in doubt

steady onyx
#

i kinda wanna play sneak attack

#

it looks fun

#

just drop emrakul onto field

twilit canyon
#

u can probably jam something simple like painter

steady onyx
#

i can

#

but like

#

SNEAK ATTACK boo

#

m

twilit canyon
#

playing anything with blue is a recipe for wracking your head and failing bc these decks are just not intuitive

steady onyx
#

is painter not blue?

twilit canyon
#

red stompy also works

#

painter is mono brown/red

steady onyx
#

..

twilit canyon
#

ik some builds play blue

#

i dont love them

steady onyx
#

ok time to find the list

twilit canyon
#

yeah no i dont like the blue versions

#

emissary has done a number on artifact lists

#

but the traditional painter combo is mono red

steady onyx
#

so like this?

twilit canyon
#

yep

steady onyx
#

ok

twilit canyon
#

its a "simple" combo list

steady onyx
#

i also need to buy a painters servant

#

...

#

for commander play

#

so i can build a legacy deck!!

twilit canyon
#

wait they are making u pay for the decks?

#

not proxy lists?

steady onyx
#

no no no no no

#

im proxying

#

im saying I want to play teysa and painters servat is good with her in commander

twilit canyon
#

ah fair

#

yeah dont pay for a legacy list

steady onyx
#

no that seems stupid

#

and a waste of money

twilit canyon
#

red trinisphere

#

is also solid

#

simple

#

good deck

steady onyx
#

ok

#

ill look into a mono red ish deck

#

i do like painter as a card tho so i kinda wanna play something around him

twilit canyon
#

u basically can never go wrong with a t1 saga -> t2 trinisphere

#

and then finding a chrome mox to replace saga

#

its a good way to play

steady onyx
#

hmm ok

#

my only thing is

#

i wanna play a deck thats like not super how do i put this into words

#

like had bad and good mu

#

is more just generally solid deck I can learn format throuhg

twilit canyon
#

those decks have massive skill gaps in legacy

steady onyx
#

oh

#

fk

twilit canyon
#

because they are blue

steady onyx
#

is there mystic mine in legacy...

twilit canyon
#

in 90% of scenarios

#

trinisphere

steady onyx
#

aok

twilit canyon
#

lol

steady onyx
#

lmao

#

time to play red trinisphere

twilit canyon
#

these decks win off [[pyrogoyf]] nowdays

lost widgetBOT
steady onyx
#

wait

#

thats hilarious

#

i assume grave is something a lot of decks play with

twilit canyon
#

massively

#

ik ygo says a lot that the grave is often the second hand

#

in legacy this is very much the case

steady onyx
#

ok ok

#

so out of red stompy, red trinis, and red painter

twilit canyon
#

stompy can slot trinisphere

#

eldrazi stompy too

#

same deal

#

its a t2 trinisphere deck

#

but eldrazi flavored

steady onyx
#

i personally dont like eldrazi would fvour red something

twilit canyon
#

fair enough

steady onyx
#

ooh

#

did i show u the new stadnard deck i made

twilit canyon
#

yeah stick to the more basic decks outside of blue

steady onyx
#

its simic ouroboid

#

im really liking it

twilit canyon
#

bc legacy is brutal

#

for learning it

steady onyx
#

okie

twilit canyon
#

and blue is a large part of it

steady onyx
#

i got inda stomped when I played a standard tournament cause I was missing all the good cards

#

like into the flood maw, enruding curiosity

#

but next tournament I will have those and im excited

#

the deck feels sick to play

#

i still ngl need to learn keeping hands and sideboarding a bit better

#

but I think that willl come with jsut more play experience

twilit canyon
#

for standard its weird but sure

glad peak
#

Just play moon or oops

fallow citrus
glad peak
#

Oops is hard to start with but if your competition doesn’t know what they’re doing (and from the sounds of it they don’t) then you’ll stomp

fallow citrus
#

cephalid breakfast too is also a good shout

#

I have a type of legacy deck I enjoy

glad peak
#

I don’t really like breakfast very much tbh

twilit canyon
#

i am also not a big breakfast fan

#

even tho ik its solid/good

steady onyx
#

like here

glad peak
#

Stompy is probably the easiest and most consistent

fallow citrus
#

tbf I haven't played breakfast in a hot minute

steady onyx
#

im torn rn between aggro (stompy) and combo (painter)

#

im like

fallow citrus
#

aggro will be easier

#

by an order of magnitudes

steady onyx
#

i want to play combo

#

but i dont like want to die to one interaction on combo

glad peak
#

I know someone I know played a sideboard plan which was painter with blood moons and trinisphere tho

steady onyx
#

and then deck is uselss

#

useless

#

u get me?

fallow citrus
#

is initiative still a thing in legacy

glad peak
#

Not really

fallow citrus
#

ah shame

#

now that was a deck

steady onyx
#

like i dislike decks where i am going to either resolve combo and win and have fun

glad peak
#

White is pretty funny because you can do the turn 1/2 miracle 5/5

steady onyx
#

or not resolve combo and lsoe because my deck is only centered around that combo

#

because of that should I just play stompy?

fallow citrus
#

well if you don't like the idea of losing if you jam combo and get answered then play stompy

glad peak
#

Play delver and just outskill your opponents nyaruhodo

steady onyx
#

i dont mind getting answered

#

im more just like

#

does painter do anything then just resolve the combo

#

like can I win through other routes?

glad peak
#

Yes, painter has blood moon nyaruhodo

steady onyx
#

stompy also has blood moon

#

:)

glad peak
#

Correct nyaruhodo

#

Play both KEKW

fallow citrus
#

caves of chaos adventurer is still legacy legal where is it in my stompy decks

steady onyx
#

or smt

#

like do people more expect the combo g1 or the aggro g1

#

and then side in the other when they side for the first

glad peak
#

Smokescreening is based

steady onyx
#

sounds fun

#

lets make a list

#

which first

#

aggro or painter

glad peak
#

Painter first always

steady onyx
#

ok

fallow citrus
#

could just play reanimator

steady onyx
#

hm does this work

steady onyx
glad peak
#

And then when they side in anti-painter stuff just all in beeg guys

steady onyx
#

misty said no blue

#

cause it will hurt my brain

#

what am i not playing if i take ut combo

#

obv the grindstone and the painters

#

hm this may not work

#

its not like ygo where u have ur small engine u can take out

fallow citrus
#

I don't think smokescreening is real

steady onyx
#

but i cant decide

fallow citrus
#

if you had to do it for stompy you'd take out welder engineer painter grindstone

glad peak
#

It’s not real (unless you do oops then belcher)

#

But in this case it’s funny

steady onyx
#

ok then

#

for me who has never played legacy

fallow citrus
#

also I don't think the blue in reanimator is like

steady onyx
#

stompy or painter

fallow citrus
#

difficult

glad peak
#

Brainstorm is always difficult nyaruhodo

steady onyx
#

^

#

and ponder

fallow citrus
#

agree to disagree

glad peak
#

The common truth of “you will always brainstorm wrong” nyaruhodo

#

I love old pro quotes

fallow citrus
#

I think unless we're talking super high level play it doesn't really matter if you play brainstorm wrong

glad peak
#

Idk I play a funny deck whenever I do play legacy nowadays

#

Tin fins

steady onyx
#

like yeah

#

i wanna play something funny

#

but i also want to play something thats simple and like good

#

so i can learn the format

glad peak
#

Tin fins is simple and funny but not great

steady onyx
#

with a deck on the level of everything else

fallow citrus
#

just goldfish some hands with decks you want to try and see if you might enjoy the play patterns

steady onyx
#

im just watching some gameplay ngl

#

I play a Magic: the Gathering Online Legacy league with a Moon Stompy / Red Prison decklist to help people prepare for Eternal Weekend this year. Moon Stompy is an objectively powerful deck, but should you play a version with or without Urza's Saga. This video will also reference a sideboard guide, linked below!

Sb guide article: https://mt...

▶ Play video
glad peak
#

Tin fins is just turbo gris then pay a ton of life then somehow get children of koilos to come back over and over and over again

fallow citrus
#

the mystic forge deck interests me

steady onyx
#

ok i thinkive decided painter

#

but i see 2 lists

#

which one

#

the second seems more midrangey and the first seems more comb cause it has like led and shit

fallow citrus
#

I don't believe in cauldron in that deck tbh

steady onyx
#

ok\

fallow citrus
#

but i havent seen it in action so idk

steady onyx
#

ill try non agatha

zinc shard
atomic harness
#

Whoa

copper pecan
#

colorless removal spell PogYu

subtle sierra
#

this is a weird abrade...

glad peak
#

Pretty cool abrade

#

Hopefully it’s a cycle

glad peak
#

i love cradle control but damn is it hard

#

you just give up game 1 if you had a fairly slow hand vs combo

atomic harness
fast tide
#

Some of the cards for Bello have started trickling in

#

And Bello got shipped yesterday

atomic harness
#

Good job, Mr ducky

atomic harness
#

The pregame actions are crazy

fast tide
#

Oh god Bello can throw them all too

#

Oh these are wild

broken fjord
#

What's the dirtiest you've ever done anyone in a game of mtg?

sudden lava
broken fjord
#

I opened Devastating Mastery vs a Reaper King player. Let them use their entire hand to ramp him out. Turn 3, which was pretty fast. Too bad Devastating Mastery has an alternate cost that lets me cast it for 4. Punted him out of the game.

#

Runner up is commandeering a turn 1 sol ring from an Arcanus player.

trail anvil
#

that's funny

glad peak
stark skiff
#

Web of Life and Destiny
Enchantment
Convoke
At the beginning of combat on your turn look at the top 5 cards of your library. You can put a creature among them onto the battlefield. Put the rest on the bottom in a random order.

subtle sierra
#

Aren't both of these decent?

glad peak
#

We already got a powercrept (not by much) dragon sniper?

subtle sierra
#

Well it's a sidegrade

#

Sniper has vigilance

glad peak
#

Oh right forgot it had that too

#

Wow dragon sniper is stupid icant

fallow citrus
#

shame convoke isn't a deck rn

atomic harness
#

Red de La Vida y El Destino

glad peak
#

Is it red or not clearly

stark skiff
stark skiff
#

Beast Within

ornate cedar
gritty nest
#

i got an ad for arena with the tagline saying "standard is the best its ever been!"

last glen
#

doesn't look very heroic....

steady onyx
#

@twilit canyon u able to help lil ol me with my standard deck or r u busy

#

ur just like rly good at standard

#

and idk what to do

#

this is it

#

im just confused mainly about like my sideboard

i would love vivien
but idk about the rest
and like should I keep schooners in main?

#

oh also azure beastbinder and scrapshooter I want to know if I should run those or not

twilit canyon
#

not much to do rn bc the meta is centralized around vivi cauldron

#

sb to beat that deck

steady onyx
#

just like artifact removal

#

for the cauldron?

twilit canyon
#

theres no real secret bc even if u do so ug has no real tools to deal with their deck

steady onyx
#

ig

glad peak
#

In fact main board to beat the deck nyaruhodo

sleek ferry
#

You just don’t want to be in simic right now, you don’t have ways to beat multiple threats

trail anvil
#

does simic even have an exile pongify effect in standard rn

lusty trench
#

They did the thing

glad peak
#

Of course

sudden lava
#

the fact you both posted it makes it funnier

past socket
#

But which is the real imposter syndrome?

hidden ermine
#

The art feels too zoomed in

trail anvil
#

neither, if you're on arena

zinc shard
#

To complete the trifecta

past socket
#

Certainly some pictures of Spider-Man

steady onyx
#

what is best way to build rdw in current standard

#

is it like burn

#

or is there still a way to play pump

#

or is that no more

#

this is my current list

sleek ferry
gritty nest
glad peak
#

Let it be known I was light

steady onyx
sleek ferry
#

You got to do what you got to do

#

Nova hellkite is a hell of a card

#

It’s a guaranteed 8-10 damage in the air

zinc shard
#

Goblin's Shadow

1R

Enchantment

At the beginning of your first main phase, discard a card. If you do, draw a card.

Whenever you play a land or cast a spell from anywhere other than your hand, this enchantment deals 1 damage to each opponent.

trail anvil
#

ah yes another card that goes insane with ob nix

#

and pairs well with prosper of course

sudden lava
#

Paradox without the paradox

atomic harness
#

Hallo, need an mtg ruling question answered

fallow citrus
#

what ruling

atomic harness
#

[[Hashaton]] triggered ability
Does it care if the creature it's trying to make a copy token of goes away somewhere?

lost widgetBOT
atomic harness
#

say I pitch an archon and pay 3
Opp rakdos charms me or something

#

or will I still get my 4/4 tapped archon of cruelty regardless

zinc shard
past socket
#

Love mail day

gilded glade
# atomic harness say I pitch an archon and pay 3 Opp rakdos charms me or something

There's two parts to this:

  • Does a spell/ability target, as in, can it fizzle if the card goes away
  • What information is used

The first part is only relevant if you use something like Reanimate that targets a creature for the spell. So as opposed to yugioh, a spell/ability only really "fizzles" (doesn't resolve) if all the targets of a spell/ability are gone. But the word target is required to be used in the oracle (database) text.

For the second part, MTG uses "last known information", meaning as opposed to yugioh, MTG checks the last place it was visible/known, and uses that information to resolve an ability.

atomic harness
atomic harness
#

Danke

gilded glade