#Magic the Gathering
1 messages · Page 155 of 1
Maybe 40 mana sources, but not lands
You don’t need the dead 9% chance for your first 5-7 lands in your opening hand
Actually 40 mana sources is too low, with ramp you’re going to want 42 or so mana sources
But genuine lands you’re going to want 37 or so
So in terms of toolbox
I got the guy that sticks on board and pings everyone while I do gameplan
I got the combo wincon
I got the swing the board with living death wincon
I think all I'm really missing rn
Is the reanimate target that threatens game wincon
There's toxrill but I wanna be swaggier
Mono black valgavoth
I added that like 10 minutes before you sent that lol
Funnily enough he is in my binder
Alongside watery grave and polluted delta
Losing binder value for a better deck
Options options
Question for anyone who played kaldheim standard were pathways good?
Yes
Word
iirc all those lands were played
Really depends on what bracket you are in imo. If you are in bracket 2 and your deck is less efficient, you face less pressure and you have less card advantage, hitting land drops is really strong
not only were they good, they were beautiful to look at
I have 2 full art foils, I need to complete the set
I have the orzhov pathways in foil they're gorgeous
is 35 lands enough for rhys the redeemed despite running 14 4+ drops? serious question
also have a load from that time in foil
i love the bordereless
Oh there it is
The super chase card that's gonna make the set worth anything
And of course you need it for every black commander deck ever
Huh that’s pretty cool
But also correct, most cases
There are still some considerations to make in deckbuilding with this just because it’s a mana rock that costs a color
Surely thats a cycle
Indestructible and the ability for it to not be dead lategame is crazy on a generic mana rock
They'll probably split it over the 3 marvel sets
So that way when one looks bad (Spiderman) there's still reason to open it because generically strong commander card
Honestly wish this was a 3 mana rock since that'd make it a lot weaker
Ok but there’s 6 stones…
Did you ever consider that
Yes and there’s 6 colors
White blue black red green brown

I have a feeling once you activate and infinity for one of the stones you get it for all of them
Hey on the bright side, I can proxy the UW version for my cedh decks
So true
so i watched a few videos about some budget commander decks, and i wanted to get the cards for 2 of the decks. Which 2 do i get the cards for? [[Lord Xander, the Collector]] [[Rydia, Summoner of Mist]] [[Shantotto, Tactician Magician]] or [[Squall, Seed Mercenary]]
Legendary Creature — Vampire Demon Noble
When Lord Xander enters, target opponent discards half the cards in their hand, rounded down.
Whenever Lord Xander attacks, defending player mills half their library, rounded down.
When Lord Xander dies, target opponent sacrifices half the nonland permanents they control of their choice, rounded down.
6/6
Legendary Creature — Human Shaman
Landfall — Whenever a land you control enters, you may discard a card. If you do, draw a card.
Summon —
,
: Return target Saga card with mana value X from your graveyard to the battlefield with a finality counter on it. It gains haste until end of turn. Activate only as a sorcery.
1/2
Legendary Creature — Dwarf Wizard
Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, Shantotto gets +X/+0 until end of turn, where X is the amount of mana spent to cast that spell. If X is 4 or more, draw a card.
"Ohohoho! I might be the harshest mistress in all of Vana'diel. But I may yet forgive you, if at my feet you kneel."
0/4
Back to important stuff: how the fuck do I make the Jeskai manabase not suck rn? Why don't any of the verges I'd play tap for blue first ?
Retcon 
Get a time machine and play farewell
Honestly this feels kinda cracked
Just "nah you don't get to play the game" but I'm also beating you to death in the process
I can’t believe we’re about to have mind stone and THE mind stone 
undefined
what
OH omg didnt even notice XD
Beeeeg winnnnna
actually beautiful
Yes I am
wao rich and degenerate
I keep missing land drops here. is 37 lands literally not enough and/or is Dogmeat not the best choice here?
How many lands do you have on field before you start missing land drops?
Because if you have like 6 on board before missing then you didn’t miss land drops 
if you wanna hit more land drops I feel like you could add more card advantage or ramp
Who knew the best deck for Fire Crystal would end up being synth lol
giving karnstructs haste does sound really good
tournament didn't go well but this is sick
yeah those are some really solid pulls tbh
desculpting blast 
What are some white, blue, or black cards that make lander tokens if any?
Colorless too
Ketramose continues to be the biggest fraud in standard. Why do people try so hard to play this guy?
Ketramose is for chumps
@tardy echo defend yourself (you can't)
Are you proud of me Mr marang
here you go oomfie
Ty. Scrapbot it is
good fucking lord
https://vxtwitter.com/BeExcellent80s/status/1951444859925176782?t=AL2uyjoOMRvDVetBO5rHXw&s=19
$30,000 Legacy Jeskai Wizards deck with BETA DUALS, alters, and foil everything. Super flavorful card choices (Vivi, Terminus, Counterbalance, Vendilion Clique).
Deck builder: Iso at Shinjuku Hareruya Tournament Center in Tokyo. https://t.co/cd2Xh2UMob
Yeah, just loss of a game off them using bay for it, you don’t even need to be on any red splash for it
Yes, I'm proud of all ketramose haters
Now all you have to agree commander is for chumps
commander is magics only real format

deadly cover up
Imperial iron wall
Incredible gameplay
Thank you
Stupid fun
@ornate cedar
Yeah im surprised even the low rarity stuff is pretty good 
Holy Jesus this is cracked esp in commander
my favorite common? Is like [[cryogen relic]]
Artifact
When this artifact enters or leaves the battlefield, draw a card.

, Sacrifice this artifact: Put a stun counter on up to one target tapped creature. (If a permanent with a stun counter would become untapped, remove one from it instead.)
Older than the Eumidian seedships that populated Evendo.
I may have to draft this on Arena 
Yeah it's nerfed tolarian academy but tolarian academy is still busted
[[tolarian academy]]
All hail the Academy
green and white get to have cradle and sanctum 

(What does red and black get?)
Was less enthused by FF than I thought I would be
I don’t have the wild cards for it, but I theoried this up and I think this is pretty strong
@golden plover
Pixie engine is crazy for just letting you be very evasive
An argument could be made mono white is way better also
Also pixie light stall is crazy
Yeah true. I just think running the Dimir flash engine instead feels good
@glad peak I need your help oh wise one 
Wuh
How big is the jump from bracket 3 to bracket 4?
friends are bracketing up and I need to do so as well
Also what are some good things to reanimate that I can play in esper colors
. So far ive been looking at archon of cruelty and hullbreaker horror
but there might be smth that griefs multiple people better
Game changers and 2 card combos are huge
Bracket 3 is stax heaven because they don’t have access to ways to turbo out kills like 4 and 5
I kiinda have to be the stax guy bc everyone's on some crazy sht but its a little tough since ppl do kingmaking turbo
guess I could join the thassa club 
People will always kingmake turbo
People are bad 
Or are you kingmaking turbo by playing stax 
My incidental hatebear is usually the only one stopping the super fast instawin most of the time 
tho ofc I get ganged up on it then the combo guy that I was locking out wins because of it
doesnt happen all the time but it's a common theme
Oh yep that’s just a skill issue
Even if you point out that you’re the only reason they’re not dead
Yeah
I've also told them that it's not a hard lock and you can still play while being slowed down, we're buying time to find an out to his thing, etc etc
but no the jailer or something usually gets bonked and then yeh turbo guy wins
People have weird definitions of fun, I thought people liked playing a longer game 
I want to play more magic yeah 
Good news, you can choose to not die to turbo
The response to "you can still (somewhat) play under the stax piece was" "well I cant play much / im being crippled too so im gonna remove it 🙂"
guy that clears it usually doesnt win btw its the other guy next to him
welp 
Anyway would like some suggestions for this
You get a even more crippled boardstate if you’re killed by turbo 
I think the problem for many people with stax is that it feels in a way simmillair to floodgate decks I. Yugioh and we al know how fun those are even though yes I know stax is less bad but does Kinda give of a similar feeling
Tbh in these levels stax a lot worse
Compared to yugioh
Since stax never hits every way to interact like yugioh sometimes does
2
Also, Who’s the most yugioh protagonist looking commander to exist?
spongebob?
Same one the spongebob card has effect wise, it's basically Yugi
Heart of the cards but you are guaranteed a free legendary, and they are on friendship speeches? 10/10 Yugi
Yes
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4BUTv0kTy7M&ab_channel=MaldHound In the words of Maldhound
Jodah looks REAl familiar to anyone who grew up watching the YuGiOh cartoons that’s all I’m saying. They just put conditioner in his hair.
#mtg #magicthegathering #mtgcommunity #cardgame #mtgcommander
Honestly would argue that when it comes to mechanics Morph and Foretell are peak Yugis too honestly
Theyre peak magic too tbh
It’s just a shame there aren’t too many good ones because a morph cube is really fun
What’s the biggest skill check card in magic in your opinion? For me it’s either counterspell or Armageddon
There’s also defense grid but that only tests the skill of the turbo player that plays the card
https://archidekt.com/decks/14975133/faest_sanic_the_hedgehorge_budget Any cards I could add to help the deck and/or lower the budget?
Does Scryfall have a tag specifically for "whenever x deals combat damage"
did this card ever do anything or is it noob bait
card's seen a lot of play in jeskai oculus in standard
but its a standard power level card for a tier 2 deck
so make of that what u will
nodding
Vivi also plays it
For your purposes of commander tho, not great
seems fine in commander as card advantage idk
you should be running it in big creature decks to get the most value but a draw spell on rate with flashback seems fine
Second time it’s good but first time you use it you basically skip your turn for almost no effect
Well, draw 3 discard 1 isn’t too bad but you’d want more value for that
What if I just pitch it and then use the second effect
outclassed by [[deep analysis]] I'm assuming? or a sidegrade
Depends on deck but even then you don’t play deep analysis in most decks
I see. Is the best blue creature to reanimate usually Hullbreaker Horror?
sans atraxa
Tidespout tyrant too
[[tidespout tyrant]]
Actually probably [[Consecrated Sphinx]]
Creature — Sphinx
Flying
Whenever an opponent draws a card, you may draw two cards.
A curse is just another name for an unwanted blessing.
4/6
You just make so much value
But with the other 2 you can just win 
Yeah true. Depends on the current game state and if you've got other wincons or not
I just like Consecrated Sphinx in cedh Hashaton because that card feels really good when you play it for 3 mana
Dumb q
Can you still play stuff exiled by oppo if oppo goes away?
In what context
Say I flash in oppo agent to a tutor
I see it, so I control their search yeah then exile whatever
After that let's say it gets killed
Could I still play the exiled card or do I need oppo faceup in order to do that
Just look at Hashaton lists
They’ll have the good reanimate targets for the most part
[[plague rats]]
chat am I cooking
you need a lot more non-basics and a screenshot vs something that isn't lifegain tbh
Welp I was building bracket 2 erinis street urchin and I completely forgot traveling chocobo and a way to look for kodama of the East tree
Got enough landfall = creatures/tokens cards and bouncelands and land tutors to make kodama + any of them into infinites
I don’t think I can really add any kiki stuff into bracket 2 and there really isn’t too many good options to search kiki combo
@glad peak since you were talking about heliod recently https://youtu.be/-xC_mZTz-sg?si=SlPrStMT1_D2xG2u
This week we're joined by Greenie to play some cEDH!
DECKLISTS - https://moxfield.com/bookmarks/WV9Z5-greenie-winota-blue-farm-heliod-esika
GIRL WITH THE GREEN SUIT - https://beacons.ai/girlwiththegreensuit
PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/playtowin
DRAGONSHIELD AFFILIATE LINK - https://dragonshield.com/?ref=playtowin
Use this code for 5%...
🤢
delete them before they launch Ultimate Guard
https://archidekt.com/decks/14975133/faest_sanic_the_hedgehorge_budget Im 11 cards over on the deck, what should i cut?
I'm guessing you're keeping the sonic stuff in the 99 there for flavor, cause otherwise that's probably the first stuff I would cut
id prefer to yeah, knuckles is probably the last thing to cut since he generates mana/wincon/keyword soup
i probably dont need unexpected windfall/seize the spoils do i?
not really but I feel like a lot of this deck just seems suboptimal
yeah, part of it is trying not to break the bank
are you taking random draft chaff cause [[$swords to plowshares]] has been reprinted into the ground
$0.82 • €1.25 • 0.05 TIX
$390.44
$2.99 • €1.99
$1.05 • €1.59 • 0.16 TIX
$1.18 • €1.53 • 0.05 TIX
$1.22 • €1.77 • 0.15 TIX
$15.77 • €13.92 • 1.24 TIX
$1.58 • €2.54 • 0.71 TIX
$1.41 • €2.99 • 0.39 TIX
$5.52
and comes in every white precon ever
honestly forgot about it because i wanted to use flash dudes that removed stuff
sure but stuff like reduce to memory could be [[$generous gift]]
$1.85
$1.12 • €1.09 • 0.21 TIX
0.20 TIX
$0.85 • €0.74 • 0.30 TIX
$0.86 • €0.78 • 0.15 TIX
$1.92 • €0.57 • 0.04 TIX
$0.93 • €0.75 • 0.21 TIX
$0.78
$0.80 • €0.89 • 0.05 TIX
$0.97 • €0.67 • 0.06 TIX
oh it's the sonic art
yeah
[[stroke of midnight]]
this is already infinitely better
yeah thats still better since instant speed
reduce to memory is only the way it is cause it's a lesson
i think 3 mana exile anything is still helpful, but when im trying to optimize, its not
as in if i had the room id run it lol
I think I'd put grasp of fate in before I'd run the lesson
exile one from each board
[[grasp of fate]]
oh
fair
oh yeah, would you like to hear what the goal of the deck was, at least my shit show version
play haste dudes, or give dudes haste, play flash dudes for interaction, swing, pump them, then get benefits when those dudes connect
thats partially why Calamity is there, since he can duplicate dudes that do ETB triggers/duplicate dudes with damage triggers
yeah makes sense
should i just move the entire "rewards for punching" section into the other groups to make seeing what is needed/not needed easier?
as in putting the bladegriff/underminer/visionary etc into the removal
well I think you need more ways of preventing your creatures from being blocked if your whole gameplan is to benefit off punching
sure
have you looked at the edhrec page for sonic
a few times, mainly the main page
there should be cheap hasty/flash creatures that work better than quaketusk boar
or just cutting it entirely
realistically i was keeping it since it was one of the few creatures that gave trample to my board with odric
[[nova hellkite]] is a card
thanks for the advice Komi, im heading off to bed for now and ill take a crack at it in the morning

Not the heliod I was talking about but yep that deck is cool af
This is fun
Gwenom, Remorseless
3BB
Legendary Creature - Symbiote Spider Hero
Deathtouch, Lifelink
Whenever Gwenom attacks, until end of turn you may look at the top card of your library and you may play cards from the top of your library. If you cast a spell this way, pay life equal to its mana value rather than pay its mana cost.
4/4
Poor guy never knew what hit him
Oh damn Citadel on legs
Damn you’re bullying
Poor Stephen
Nathan from Drawfee is here to play Commander from Voxy, Amy The Amazonian, and Prof! He's used to turning your ideas into drawings, but can he turn his cards sideways to defeat his opponents and card draw his way to victory? Let's find out!
▶Are you looking to Shuffle Up & Play games of Magic: The Gathering over webcam? The "Looking For Gam...
They got the weasel playing the weasel deck!
Wait hol up wtf
Hopefully no Full Throttle Incident this time
Its alright
(Haven't seen the full episode so idk if she does)
Weasel go into maximum overdrive!! All engines ago!
spins out in nonbo
Basically just remember the last time I saw Voxy play Cruelclaw and having a nonbo with it in her deck because of chat apparently in [[Full Throttle]]
Yep I know the reference
Damn you support bullying?
No son 
I pulled off a rly stupid kill with [psychic frog] and [dual-sun technique] just now
oh wow eoe cards already
Reminded I had Cruelclaw in Magar myself lol
Wow you like bullying kids?
Cruelclaw just acting as a discard outlet and a way to cast more
My friend was at 16 and had a rly fat board I had a 2/3 frog and a full grip of cards
so I dumped my entire hand to push for game
Sadly ended up cutting the wezl but The Infamous Cruelclaw could be fun as much as its a bit too similar to Satya for my collection
(I also wholeheartedly apologise to my fellow wezl fans for having to cut Cruelclaw from Magar)
Wezl players deserve it
Mostly just had him as a discard outlet
Legendary Creature — Angel
Flash
Flying, vigilance
When Archangel Avacyn enters, creatures you control gain indestructible until end of turn.
When a non-Angel creature you control dies, transform Archangel Avacyn at the beginning of the next upkeep.
4/4
Avacyn, the Purifier
Legendary Creature — Angel
Flying
When this creature transforms into Avacyn, the Purifier, it deals 3 damage to each other creature and each opponent.
"Wings that once bore hope are now stained with blood. She is our guardian no longer." —Grete, cathar apostate
6/5
Does anyone know of Ultimate Guard boulder alternatives?
How many ranks are in this game
it goes bronze -> silver -> gold -> platinum -> diamond -> mythic
and within mythic you have percentages at lower ranks then numbers at higher ranks
Thank you ko mee
Welp was trying to build a bracket 2 erinis deck because friends usually only play precon stuff
Control + layered combo is probably not precon level but at least no 2 card combos, right? 
I'm building Coram the Undertaker rn for casual commander nights
probably leaning into bracket 3
Eh I’m just gonna play the layered combo variant because it’s funny
[[coram the undertaker]]
Legendary Creature — Human Warrior
Coram gets +X/+0, where X is the greatest power among creature cards in all graveyards.
Whenever Coram attacks, each player mills a card.
During each of your turns, you may play a land and cast a spell from among cards in graveyards that were put there from libraries this turn.
0/5
Oh this combo is all triggers, welp time to play stax pieces
Wait does land tutors count in the few tutors clause
Idts
Satin Towers are nice, it's taller then boulders but these babies got strong magnets (and a dice storage for all your counter tracking dice)
I only have the one tho
Wao I didn’t know how fun resolving stormchasers talent was
it is indeed quite fun
I used stock up 5 times in one turn 
New pixie stuff is extremely fun cosmogrand zenith is a tad bit crazy
Cryogen relic has also been a little crazy
would [[perilous forays]] combo be considered too many tutors? 
It’s a land tutor so they can’t really complain
Does bracket 2 only specify nonland tutors?
This is a combo piece to get all of my basics onto the field + deal 3*lands 
Bracket 2 is up to 3 tutors
That didnt answer my question 
Oh my bad you are asking if ramp counts as tutors
they dont
otherwise nearly every green precon would be bracket 3
I feel like you're tunneling too hard on the tutor aspect, how reliable is the combo and how much mana does it take 
This one takes like 11 minimum (enchantment, lotus cobra, scute swarm + activation) + a creature
If I get it off I make like 15 basic land drops and depending on the outlet I either do that much*3 damage or scute swarm 2^14
I have a couple cards that tutors 2 creatures
Tooth and nail or summons
2 of those pieces can be used in another combo that wins the game and maybe 1-2 of the other pieces can be used in another combo
I have a rulings question
Does [[hushbringer]] have any interactions w cards tht have like "whenever you sacrifice a creature"
[[queen of the golgari]]
Legendary Creature — Elf Shaman
Whenever you sacrifice a black creature, you may pay 2 life. If you do, each other player sacrifices a creature of their choice.
Whenever you sacrifice a green creature, you may gain 2 life.
"Nature's most raw beauty is the circle: perfect in its continuance, with no break between death and life."
2/2
And is it the same with "whenever you sacrifice a permanent" effects only IF they sac a creature specifically?
The effect that causes the sacrifice works but the trigger when something gets sacrificed doesn’t
Thank you Mr mudkip 
For the second thing, only if it's creatures right?
[[mayhem devil]]
so if guy sacks a creature mayhem devil doesn't ping
But if it's an artifact land or w/e mayhem pings
It does ping
The only thing hushbringer stops is if mayhem devil said “whenever a creature dies”
Something that still kinda I’m not great with is [[cloud midgar mercenary]]
Is the shortening of names cause too used to yugioh where this would mean every card named cloud not just itself
God i really hate the particle effect they added on terror of the peaks
I keep thinking it's uncounterable
I have to double take every time i see it
Synth players and not reading, what an iconic duo
Truly a deck made for its players
How the fuck am I supposed to beat that temur smugglers deck?
Smugglers surprise
To cheat out a bunch of stupid big assholes
Vaultborn enuri etc
And when it’s not doing that it’s basically just a control deck
Fire magic is ok no?
yeah but fire magic doesn't have the versitility of brotherhood's end
I mean it’s worse fs but it’s still a good board wipe
And at times can be a lot more annoying to deal with if they have a bunch of 1 toughness guys
Oh nothing at all, they actually sound super fun
So the player skill vs infect opinions graph is very likely a normal graph
Low and high ends of skill level say infect is fine while mid players say infect is the least fun thing in the game 
I mean I think it’s an extremely unfun deck
I just also think it’s fine because I still win vs it 90% of the time
Climbing thru gold again sigh
Ahem
M I D

Speaking of which, I wonder why league players used to announce their skill level right when they entered lobbies

I think infect is pretty toxic, and I consider myself a pretty good player
infect's main issue I have is that sometimes they just highroll you and there's no counterplay to it
i personally hate infect/toxic but that's more a pet peeve
getting highrolled with no counterplay is just magic 
Grixis reanimator makes me incredibly angry
why 
I play the game in order to actually play the game
So decks that entirely seek to not play the game are a little frustrating
regardless of whether they’re good or bad
but you are playing the game, reanimator's a core part of magic design 

Hand hate is also a core part of magic design but wotc decided im not allowed to play hopeless nightmare anymore
I guess I’ll just play Bo3 so I don’t get cheesed to death anymore…
hand hate is also a core part of magic design but is bad in commander and commander players hate it so wotc won't print good ones anymore 
what deck are you playing against where it's not uncounterable
No it is counterable, but looks like it isn't
No more dreams though which is sadge
no I mean if you're playing that card you should be using cavern and/or smuggler's
bring back mind twist cowards 
But it’s unfortunate that the best hand hate for pixie now is momentum breaker
True!!!!
give me hymn in standard cowards
truth be told if you're playing it you should smuggle it in every time you can
hol up you don't want thoughtseize in standard but want mind twist? 
Reprint all of time spiral
Yes except only let me play mind twist
Draft stinky
You say this like I play commander???
If you ain’t playing old school then you ain’t playing as Garfield intended 
Speaking of which apparently they have some weird thing where some of them saying you can’t play old school if you don’t have the original printing 
I play a swamp I play dark ritual I use that mana to play dark ritual I use that mana to play dark ritual I activate mind twist for 7
Let me just gather up all my alpha lotuses 
5 card combo and you don’t even win 
Ah yes let me just get 4 ofs of all of my power nine to play a dead format 
Turn 2 I play…
Please hold
Black knight
gg
You gave them a turn? Suboptimal
Reaching max speed = real shit
Finished the grind from s1 to p1 in approximately 3 hours only lost two games this pixie deck is pretty ok @sleek ferry
D1 tomorrow maybe 
What’s your peak rank so far
You may be stuck in diamond for a bit if you’ve never reached diamond 2+
I hit p1 last season and then stopped laddering
Unironically I feel like D4 is the hardest rank to get out of
Bronze -Gold is free, Plat is usually free
Diamond is sometimes tough
It’s just extremely annoying that the pip increase goes down from 2>1
Like I get it but 
stonks day
I thought of a funny idea, [[Sami, wildcat captain]] x spells
D2 imo
Welp built a bracket 2 deck to play with my friends who have bracket 4 decks but insist on their deck being bracket 2 and only playing vs precons 
Are they stupid or something?
i don't think so?
but one guy literally has the thoracle consult combo but doesn't count it as a fast 2 card combo because "they don't do anything on their own"

Nice troll holy
Also some combination of excuses like “but I opened these cards in packs” and “but I’m not running tutors”
But seriously 
no wonder you think so poorly of commander lol
They’re the type of people that get banned from every pod at an LGS

Who’s the most brain dead commander to ever exist
And isn’t gishath, krenko, or atarka
[[Fynn, the Fangbearer]] probably
Legendary Creature — Human Warrior
Deathtouch (Any amount of damage this deals to a creature is enough to destroy it.)
Whenever a creature you control with deathtouch deals combat damage to a player, that player gets two poison counters. (A player with ten or more poison counters loses the game.)
"Come, Koma, and reclaim what you lost! Or does the great serpent fear a rematch?"
1/3
Have deathtouchers, punch people to death with poison
Can’t get simpler than that in terms of gameplay
yeah I'd agree with that
I agree with your friend. You’d be surprised the brain power that can go into getting the most of your landfall effects
my tatyova cedh deck was only for the most educated edh player
Like Landfall honestly seems simple to learn but takes a bit to really master
You know what deck is really difficult to play gishath really hard really complicated
I traumatized our local gishath player. Was playing an atraxa blink deck, I think. Saved all my blinks to stall out gishath. Never connected once.
Nah, I had that before I met these guys, they just made it worse
For people that play commander what’s everyone’s favorite mine is [[Valgavoth harrower of souls]]
right now it's [[Chatterfang]]
Multiple cards match “Chatterfang”, can you be more specific?
[[Chatterfang, Squirrel Genral]]
Legendary Creature — Squirrel Warrior
Forestwalk (This creature can't be blocked as long as defending player controls a Forest.)
If one or more tokens would be created under your control, those tokens plus that many 1/1 green Squirrel creature tokens are created instead.
, Sacrifice X Squirrels: Target creature gets +X/-X until end of turn.
3/3
[[celes, rune knight]]
Legendary Creature — Human Wizard Knight
When Celes enters, discard any number of cards, then draw that many cards plus one.
Whenever one or more other creatures you control enter, if one or more of them entered from a graveyard or was cast from a graveyard, put a +1/+1 counter on each creature you control.
4/4
Nice commanders
No card found for “Tannuk, Secondhand General”
[[Tannuk, Steadfast Second]]
Legendary Creature — Kavu Pilot
Other creatures you control have haste.
Artifact cards and red creature cards in your hand have warp 
. (You may cast a card from your hand for its warp cost. Exile that permanent at the beginning of the next end step, then you may cast it from exile on a later turn.)
"We're a few bones short of a skeleton crew, Sami, but we've got plenty of spine."
3/5
(I should really look these card names up first lol)
Secondhand general 
[[Anikthea, Hand of Erebos]]
Legendary Enchantment Creature — Demigod
Menace
Other enchantment creatures you control have menace.
Whenever Anikthea enters or attacks, exile up to one target non-Aura enchantment card from your graveyard. Create a token that's a copy of that card, except it's a 3/3 black Zombie creature in addition to its other types.
4/4
[[coram the undertaker]] for casual rn
Legendary Creature — Human Warrior
Coram gets +X/+0, where X is the greatest power among creature cards in all graveyards.
Whenever Coram attacks, each player mills a card.
During each of your turns, you may play a land and cast a spell from among cards in graveyards that were put there from libraries this turn.
0/5
Mine is [[Hashaton, Scarab's Fist]] for Cedh or Tannuk for casual
Nice nice I sort of have/had anikthea didn’t really end up liking it
[[magda, hoardmaster]] for sonic?
Legendary Creature — Dwarf Berserker
Whenever you commit a crime, create a tapped Treasure token. This ability triggers only once each turn. (Targeting opponents, anything they control, and/or cards in their graveyards is a crime.)
Sacrifice three Treasures: Create a 4/4 red Scorpion Dragon creature token with flying and haste. Activate only as a sorcery.
2/2
Me when I call every deck in the format aggro
Yeah it really shouldn't be 88% aggro
But that 30% being Vivi Cauldron is pretty concerning
Weird. They usually do split the archetypes
Well I don’t see any distinguishing feature for a second izzet aggro deck
Tbh the other deck is pretty much the same as cauldron, but minus cauldron
it's still good as a list resource
It plays cauldron sometimes still it just
Yeah the 88% aggro is wrong
But I guess I can see an argument for both decks being considered the same archetype
Actual cauldron lists look and play very diff
Prowess doesn’t play any of the shit like proft winternight etc
Yeah I can see the argument where you want to intentionally inflate numbers to make the deck you like look comparatively less strong 
Fair, they probably should be split. Weird they're categorized as the same list
Automated algorithms not good at categorizing decks
I would play the cauldron deck if it wasn’t 6 quadrillion rares/mythics for a deck that will almost certainly eat a ban in the near ish future
The most underrated deck in the format is mono white/azorius mid range
I do kinda hope Cauldron eats a ban in the near future yeah
$1000+ deck where the cleanest interaction sometimes just doesn't stop them
Vivi is fine if Cauldron isn't there to make it go super stupid
I mean there are def ways to interact
Cauldron isn’t even as repped as dimir rn im pretty sure lol
There are, but they can abrade or flood maw pinnacle
strategic betrayal casually fucks half of the common decks you see in the ladder
Dimir is more repped rn, but cauldron is taking more wins
It'll depend how the format shapes up, but I think Cauldron is definitely a potential threat
Aggro is always over represented before lists settle too
But it does look like cauldron is pretty cemented in its list
I love it when modern decks are cheaper than standard, don’t you? 
Anyways yeah that was expected when we learned there would be premium sets in standard which sucks
Thats disingenuous tbh, only vivi cauldron is an $800 deck
Esper aggro is $350
The average price of the top 5 modern decks is around $800
The average price of the top 5 standard decks is $540
yes only 1 deck is that expensive but the point is that no standard deck should be reaching that high and it was artificially created through premium sets being pushed to standard
Rn mine is [[raffine, scheming]]
gonna play b3 commander w friends tmr
Hopefully in October when FF gets its 2nd print run, starting town prices go down
I got to pull off a raffine connive archon of cruelty then reanimate the other day

How good is aristrocrats in standard rn
Or w/e the archetype that is "sac your own stuff for value" is called
Brain fart
It’s ok
Sephiroth raise the past etc are good cards but it’s simultaneously easy to interact with and struggles to interact with other decks
Ghost vacuum soul guide rest in peace ntm playing pretty poorly into cards like starcage or other generic wipes
Lol
Integrity In Journalism 
bracket 1 vs bracket 3 thinking 
The funny thing about this is that, Vivi isn’t even the most expensive card in the deck 
Cauldron randomly costs 1k for a playset 
$276
So you could technically play izzet prowess with no cauldron, for under the average cost of other standard decks rn 
I think that’s the big appeal of regular prowess atm 
It’s a very strange deck from what I’ve seen of it
No creatures besides Vivi and just spamming bodies off talent + ral
It’s a cool deck though
Cauldron’s main appeal rn is that half the decks in the meta are gy reliant, so it’s utility + combo tool in your deck naturally
It’s wincon is also just very strong
But as soon as that changes, izzet prowess should just become more popular
I’ve seen that deck win the game on t4 a not inconsiderable number of times
Welp time to stock up on shocklands in the next couple weeks
How much are shocks post eoe
Most of them are under $10
Last time they were in standard they were like $8
I think only the dimir one exactly is $10-11
Btw, this might be the best streak of standard sets I can remember
Where a good portion of mythics are all pretty valuable
https://archidekt.com/decks/14975133/sonic_the_hedgehog
what do you guys think of the Soltari Visionary, Akki Underminer, and Dawning Purist? Should I swap them out for regular removal pieces?
Like 8 bucks right?
Why 
Oh no specifically the Promo Pack one cause it’s the only foil copy lol
It’s like $70
Glen Elendra also surprised me at $65 but it is old
Holy if you have some yeah!
They deserve to be in my shame box ngl
I like the card 
A lot of cards are in my shame box 
Who knew giving a death touch creature a 9mm lead to killing people quickly
The formats themselves have also been pretty fire can’t lie
Even csc meta I enjoyed
Fair enough
Mutate was such a cool mechanic I wish it would come back 
Can we visit ikoria again dad @sleek ferry
We are aren’t we?
I thought it was confirmed we were going back
(I was not a big fan of the first Ikoria set)
I did enjoy it a lot thematically though
And it gave us the best commander precons of recent times
Oh was it confirmed
I have no idea
I think mutate is a really cool mechanic
And I think stuff like ultimatums/apexes are extremely huge flavor w’s
We might not get Mutate back
Sigh
Also you might enjoy Digimon then
Its not guaranteed either way, just that mutate didnt play too well
Skill issue on wotcs part 
Also companions were cool (possibly controversial opinion) and it would be cool to see more of them
i agree entirely with seeing more
Oh thats definitely out of the question
but idk what they could do
they'd have to be really limited and only in non-rotating/eternal formats
Companion is probably the mechanic most certain to not return from the last 10 years
Okay you yugioh player
Holy
A boy wants to see cards that reward specific deckbuilding what do u want from me
I’m not saying I want another lurrus but plenty of the companions are at acceptable power levels 
Mutate I can see coming back, companion? I doubt
Man says this like [[yorion]] didn’t exist
Legendary Creature — Bird Serpent
Companion — Your starting deck contains at least twenty cards more than the minimum deck size. (If this card is your chosen companion, you may put it into your hand from outside the game for
as a sorcery.)
Flying
When Yorion enters, exile any number of other nonland permanents you own and control. Return those cards to the battlefield at the beginning of the next end step.
4/5
Or the elk
Well I don’t expect to see them but it would be cool if I did
Which one was the one where your deck can’t have a cmc above 3 or something
No I’m sorry I meant below 3
Let’s you play spells from gy
Not lurrus
Legendary Creature — Cat Nightmare
Companion — Each permanent card in your starting deck has mana value 2 or less. (If this card is your chosen companion, you may put it into your hand from outside the game for
as a sorcery.)
Lifelink
Once during each of your turns, you may cast a permanent spell with mana value 2 or less from your graveyard.
3/2
CMC <3
No, as in there’s one where the deck building requirement is all your spells have to be cmc 3 or greater
Or 4 or greater
Legendary Creature — Dinosaur Hippo
Companion — Your starting deck contains only cards with mana value 3 or greater and land cards. (If this card is your chosen companion, you may put it into your hand from outside the game for
as a sorcery.)
When Keruga enters, draw a card for each other permanent you control with mana value 3 or greater.
5/4
Oh yeah this was ass nvm

The ones that got banned were like
Jegantha lurrus lutri (fake) yorion and the fox right
Lutri doesn’t count because it got banned in the singleton formats 
Yeah we're almost certainly never seeing companion again
Ridiculously busted mechanic
Every companion has been at least playable in modern except the fox and lutri
Jegantha was broken in pioneer too, don’t worry 
There’s definitely ways to make it balanced they just didn’t realize how good it would be in non rotating/other deckbuilding constricted formats
rewarding a specific kind of deckbuilding is one thing but giving you an extra card in your starting hand is way too strong
The fox got literally banned didn’t it
Is that in a diff format
fox got banned in legacy
I disagree. I'm not sure there's a way to make a companion balanced that isn't making the deck entirely unplayable
Legacy
Or was it legacy
Oops
Lurrus got banned in vintage, right
I mean half the companions do a pretty good job idk
even the companions that aren't broken make formats less diverse just by existing
Ikoria draft sucked so much 
Even Jegantha and Kaheera, who might as well be vanillas, are problematic to the point of Jegantha being banned
ikoria draft would have been fine if it weren't for [[zenith bolt]]
No card found for “zenith bolt”
[[zenith flare]]
Legitimately most decks that played Jegantha didn't play it for its text at all
And it's still banned
like i said, the companions made formats less diverse by discouraging playing certain cards without really adding anything to the formats by themselves
I could see companions being printed into commander only sets like 6 years from now
But I don't think they'll EVER put a companion in a 60 card format again
they warp the deckbuilding without making the format better
Companion is one of the few mechanics where the ENTIRE mechanic is nerfed
i don't think they're ever going to print more companions ever again
Ikoria draft had a couple more problems than just the cycling deck
And for a while, Lurrus was banned in Vintage. The only card banned in Vintage for power level reasons
Companion is legitimately probably the biggest miss of a mechanic ever
Mutate only being available on non-humans meant you were railroaded into one of the options
not really? there were plenty of human and non-human options in every color
I think potentially companions could work in a supplemental commander product with a huge ass restriction like "your deck is mono-colored"
No I mean if you were playing a deck revolving around humans (there was a combination or 2) or a deck with a decent amount of humans then you couldn’t pick most of the mutate cards
But I don't think we'll ever see a new companion in a standard set
it's crazy that they made the companions hybrid
It's so wacky
as though they weren't already easy to run
Just everything about companions is ridiculous
lurrus was originally going to be 6 mana btw
I have legitimately no clue how they could have ever been okay with companions
Iirc this was to make them easier to build around in draft but that didn’t work out
Although yorion in cube has got to be one of my favorite things
apparently they were so focused on mutate that they just didn't notice the issues with companions, somehow
Also fuck companions for getting an exception to the commander rules in a way that's dumb
shout out to lutri being the fastest ban ever
I wish there was a partner card that allows you to partner with mono colored commanders and was like 2-3 mana and had an eminence ability that says you can’t cast your other commander unless you have that partner out
(You don't have a sideboard in commander, but you can have a sideboard if you have a companion. It's just a one card sideboard for your companion)
they're never going to make something like this
I feel like companions shouldn't get an exception to the rules lol
But luckily most of them are ass in commander
I know but I can dream lmao, would be fair
The only ones that were playable in cedh were Lurrus, jegantha, and the fox, right?
Yeah and two of those fell off after the rule change
The 3 mana extra cost for your companion
And the constant try to make Lurrus good
Ridiculous ass mechanic
And the combo deck where 2 of the pieces were in the command zone and companion zone lmao
This could be legitimately cool if they did this
They should bring back eminence but only as negative effects
But make the commander absurd
I feel like mutate was a well received mechanic, just the execution was kinda eh
it has a lot of really weird edge cases but overall i thought it was fine
I still wanna see more mutate cards with static keywords or something
my main issue with it is how so many of the mutate cards are only good with other mutate cards
yeah
since almost all of them have an effect that triggers when you mutate them
that isn't inherent to the mechanic though, it's just how they designed those specific cards
this also meant anti synergy with stuff like nethroi
I'd like more power matters and stuff like it to justify mutating too
but either way I'll welcome any amount of new mutate support cause the mechanic is fun as hell, I love building a voltron boss by stapling other creatures on top of it
Mutate is a neat mechanic but needs some changes to be more fun and less confusing imo
Mainly less confusing
anyways this is my bracket 2 erinis deck, yes i know i could add a ton of fetchlands but i wanted to make this budget for now until i buy enough fetchlands for my other decks https://archidekt.com/decks/15115308/bad_deck
I was about to say, you could run evolving wilds/terramorphic expanse
nah those are too slow
same reason why i don't run dryad arbor yet, too slow if i don't have fetches
slag gets a pass because it's an artifact i can snipe something with
But yep I can add 6 or so more fetchlands, probably going to get rid of basics asap
22 ramp spells 
reading destroy all humanity and i noticed this niv mizzet cameo
Actual question what’s the appeal of dryad arbor
You get it off fetchlands, ping with erinis, block with it, and use land ramp to grab a creature pretty much
I don’t have it in here because I don’t have green sun’s (I’m never looking for 1 specific creature), because I need more fetchlands to make it worth, and because it’s effectively a tapped land in this case
Is this not also llanowar
I didn’t realize you could fetch it
llanowar elves isn't a land
dryad arbor counts as a land for cards that care about lands
and also costs 0 mana
True…
iirc the head designer has said if he could retroactively erase a card from existance dryad arbor would be the one he would pick because it causes so many weird rulings problems
[[!dryad arbor]]
and also so people would stop asking him about when they're gonna print the other land creatures
As long as I get the rest of my cheap ass dual lands I wouldn’t mind deleting dryad arbor
gsz fetching dryad as a 2nd land is something llanowar can never do
also ive been collecting as many of these as i find so i can play them as basics
[[!dryad arbor|v12]]
someone will notice eventually my 20 basic forests are all dryad arbors
why did they give the tree on the far right a thicc gyatt
They made all the trees hot
Very loaded imagery
Holy I just realized there are people making out
"the trees need to be caked up or this set won't sell" - john wotc
Tabletop crashed after this\
Am I crazy or are the pathway lands undervalued?
They’re not undervalued but they’re good
8 ranked games today, 8 wins
I ask because the most expensive one is like $7
Theyre only good in pioneer, some modern decks, and 2c commander decks and those aren’t as popular as 3+ colors
We are?
Yep
Pathways let you choose 1 of 2 colors while this one land lets you choose 1 of any of the 5
Yep that one
Definitely amazing for 5c decks
This one friend loves to spite play turbo @glad peak
@fallow citrus
oppo has a huge ass green board with a frostfang and elven chorus but he still beasts within my spellskite which is just to protect my commander
"I don't care"
For some good news, managed to clutch out a close game with [[Prismatic Strands]] twice
A hard cast then a flashback
I’ve vsed this version of landfall, I personally feel like this is better than the mono green version https://x.com/hexamyn/status/1953605006965547046?s=46&t=DdUsqNPs-c3IFDRYOhiq8A
💪 Simic Landfall/ Counters supersizes your creatures. You're opponents won't know whats hit them 😏
This deck hits hard and is very resilient in Bo1 meta
Ouroboroid is a beast
List in Alt
Video - https://t.co/VU3XRkofXA
@fireshoes #mtgeoe #mtgeternities
It feels less fragile
Errr, maybe less feast and famine is a better way to phrase it
Sounds like commander alright
I changed my mind on the cauldron vs Vivi ban. I want Vivi DEAD
Fair and interactive gameplay when they can win under a pinnacle starcage + RIP because proft gives Vivi 4 power out the gate and they get to play 14 cards
Couldn't even floodpits pin Vivi because he doesn't have to tap????
Vivi should've had prowess and have to tap
I wanna play a deck with ral very badly
So yep I have way too many mana sources in my list, time to add back in my bully pieces 
just played against a guy on arena whose username was "fartshidda47"
He’s just a very big fan of a local rapper
more like a local crapper
Was he a smart fella
no he conceded to me dropping a ragavan on him turn 2
So he was a fart smella….
He who smelt it....
made some adjustments, i have can easily get trades for the lands so why not https://moxfield.com/decks/QCfEa5aIFkGAd5Tqceq-3Q
what else am i missing
55 early mana sources, what am i thinking 
37 deck sample size in a bad tournament format has been the biggest click bait on Twitter today
@atomic harness your boy!
Oh wow!
Also I heard somewhere that they mixed the rep for cauldron/prowess
Which matters since cauldron gets clapped by UW control
Typically the two decks have been lumped together
They're slightly different archetypes yes, but they overlap on most cards and are being lumped together in a lot of data collection
Cauldron having a significantly lower monster count matters a lot in this discussion
Apparently there’s a new pioneer simic deck that uses wandering minstrel
@golden plover @glad peak @sleek ferry what am I supposed to do if I have to be the responsible one at the table?
The other blue player I play w it is extremely selfish and is pretty much fine w letting the game end because he's saving his interaction for himself, or well he does it on a whim. Sometimes he'll pitch in, most of the time he won't
Of course I do try to be responsible and have stopped plenty of crazy win attempts before
But yday he could've saved us and kept the game going and potentially stop the combo kill but just let it. I even already used my interacts to stop the guy so I just needed one more form of assistance (either removal or counterspell)
Hell he even had path and a cspell on hand
but "it's funnier" if we all die
https://youtu.be/0-L1EvRjmIo?si=It39WeH3Q-AC22DG
also is this weird bait or prio bullying or whatever?
tl:dr guy says you want to interact as late as possible, and ideally your counterspells should be drawing out at least 3 (though realistically 2) cards from your opponents
Hey everyone,
let's talk about sandbagging interaction like a boss!
Eisenherz ✌️
●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●● SUPPORT ●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●
● Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Eisenherz
● Discord: https://discord.gg/NxsDyqrum8
● Twitter: https://twitter.com/Eisenhe...
It seems to involve a lot of politicking and saying stuff like "I can't answer it right now specifically due to the way my card works, but I can back up your answer if he has something else"
And some spiel about prio
Which he does do. say opp casts ad naus, guy in vid passes prio, other player on the table counters ad naus, opp also counters the counter
Then he finally pitches in and uses his specific counterspell that couldn't beat ad naus but beats the card protecting it
Anyway sorry if it's a lot, would love some insights 
kill them
the other blue player i mean

not even joking gang up on them until they get the message
in a way
the reasoning is entirely just that u shouldnt feel obligated to be the anchor to a commander game
3 players is doable if your deck is good enough
I have let stuff gone thru b4 because I was sick of them being greedy little piggies but theyre just fine w it, so I guess that's the wrong approach
Yeah I have 1v3d a bunch before which is why I'm often archenemy. But I'm also the one making sure the table doesn't autodie to crazy 2ccs so 
Tough lol
in such a situation, i encourage just winning the game
dude also sounds like they have different standards of playing than what you want out of a game
sounds like he wants to play loki
Loki? 
a trickster
They also love grief outing hatebears that are also keeping us in the game which then immediately kingmakes
Instead of just playing it slow and taking advantage of one guy being majorly dicked because they're inconvenienced too
e.g player A is mildly bothered by smth like Dennick but not a backbreaker
Dennick is the only thing keeping player C from immediately winning the next turn
I'm vibing w dennick also and doing some other value whatevers. I protected him from Player C's kill spell. Player A then outs it, which leads to player C winning

theres no saving them
cooked

Yeah sounds like they want to do other stuff in commander games
It’s why not all pods/players are enjoyable.
Sounds like a pain in the ass person to play with tbh. It’s perfectly okay to not want to play your interaction vs non winning plays, but they should at the very least be politicking on potentially game winning spells
Yeah 
Just play slicer 
Slicer is a good way to speed up the table tbh
I dont understand him mudkip San, what if slicer dies bc he's only 3/4?
You’re gonna buff him and also it’s surprisingly hard to kill him

Especially if you get him down turn 2 or 3 like you should aim for
That and some stax pieces and you got an aggro deck that you can politick attacks with
Like “kill the turbo player and I can get rid of my stax pieces since I’m trying to stop us from dying”
Thank you Mr mudkip
Oh some other good news, I got to pull off a super early archon of cruelty again w a dumb pet card 
well, early by b3 standards bc I'm not actually playing high tier stuff
Tbh a lot of problems can be fixed with “just play slicer” 
What if I wanted to play birgi instead 
Then you die to stax pieces 
not current on cedh but
isn’t slicer kinda ass
Slicer isn’t cedh playable, correct
Slicer is ass if people see it coming
[[invasion of Amonkhet]] 
Battle — Siege
(As a Siege enters, choose an opponent to protect it. You and others can attack it. When it's defeated, exile it, then cast it transformed.)
When this Siege enters, each player mills three cards, then each opponent discards a card and you draw a card. (To mill three cards, a player puts the top three cards of their library into their graveyard.)
Defense: 4
Lazotep Convert
Creature — Zombie
You may have this creature enter as a copy of any creature card in a graveyard, except it's a 4/4 black Zombie in addition to its other colors and types.
As the lazotep covered his body, he heard Norn's voice fade from a deafening clarion to a distant whisper.
4/4
Slicer’s only good into ad naus metas
borderline playable
And we’re not in an ad naus meta (though ad naus is still very strong and one premier way to win)
Slicer also got hit hard with the crypt ban
anyway cedh is a fake format
Sigh... the kids told me ad naus was still good Mr mudkip
Commander in general is a fake format
Ad naus is still good, right now we’re just in a rhystic mystic meta
the only real formats are pauper, premodern and casual edh
everything else is schizophrenia
It’s okay, the meta will shift again soon. Thrasios went over a year without being a real consideration, now he’s part of the best deck in the format 
Thank you roggy poggy
vintage is the best MTGO-exclusive format however
I’m genuinely curious as to the current actual paper playerbase of vintage
non-proxy
Sigh Mr mudkip, how come psychic frog got banned in legacy? 
I don't actually remmber

there’s the yearly Vegas event and what else
I think some Hareruya stores run vintage ?
How do you feel about delver, one of the best creatures in legacy, but it does more things
wait what they crept delver?
Well delver itself isn’t great in legacy right now 
Delver is washed little one
did they print a direct upgrade to DoS

muh 7 turn clock




