#Magic the Gathering

1 messages · Page 56 of 1

fallow citrus
#

seems standard playable

#

at worst it's black shock at best it's thoughtseize in standard

golden plover
#

That's 1 mana?

#

Wack

lusty trench
#

Pauper playable

#

Me when I angler off of this in my grave

atomic harness
#

that's really good for one B

waxen timber
#

Hopeless seems really good with bargain

atomic harness
#

Yee since it fixes your draws too

lusty trench
#

Turn one hopeless nightmare, turn 4 for the new tutor sac it to search sheoldred?

#

Seems pretty good

trail anvil
#

that card is nuts

#

casually return sheoldred to your field

twilit canyon
#

its not

#

its barely cheating on mana

#

requires a spare body

#

its mid

zinc shard
#

Bloodtithe Harvester

#

I'm sure there's plenty of cards that incidentally make a token in black

sudden lava
#

mono red burn commander

clever sun
#

The card itself provides little value

#

It's marginally better than using a two mana dork to accelerate towards Sheoldred early anyways

#

and it requires more set up

#

Since you need two creatures in the graveyard

trail anvil
#

I've never seen this card before, that's kinda funny

#

but also probably terrible lmao

fallow citrus
#

just show and tell it in :^)

trail anvil
#

also this feels like an almost direct upgrade to [[snakeskin veil]]

lost widgetBOT
trail anvil
#

there are some upsides to counters but that ward is real nice

clever sun
#

Ward One in the future but can't proliferate the counter and is susceptible to losing the aura itself

#

Still sounds strong

golden plover
#

Man the WOT sheet has like 2 misses

#

Crazy how it's a better CMM than CMM

lusty trench
#

Is that all of it?

#

If not don't jinx it

golden plover
#

We've got a few uncommons left iirc

lusty trench
#

Damn wow

golden plover
#

But we've hit all the rares and mythics iirc

#

But it's by far the most stacked bonus sheet

lusty trench
#

Doubling season to the pits

golden plover
#

Doubling Season, and [[Parallel Lives]]

lost widgetBOT
golden plover
#

They finally had the technology to reprint it

#

Card was literally $80 for no reason before the reprint was revealed

lusty trench
#

Too bad the anime art is ass

golden plover
#

Yeah true. But at least the other art is good

#

And it tanked the original print to $50

lusty trench
#

Tbh most of the anime arts are ass

#

It's mostly just "guy standing"

#

With the posing being awkward

golden plover
#

Yeah I also just don't really see why the set got anime arts???

fallow citrus
#

oh is it this conversation again

#

idk there are anime arts in this set because it clearly sells

golden plover
#

I mean yeah, that's the obvious reason

#

But why eldraine

fallow citrus
#

because they sell

#

people want them, people buy them, there's a clear demand that's enough for people to want them

#

plus it's a whole new paint of coat for older cards that are going to be exposed to new players

#

like a brand new player coming from x game might not care that yawg will has an old art

#

but the new anime art? man they dig that one

#

obvs just an example

lusty trench
#

I don't mind them

#

It's just I wish they were better

golden plover
#

I just kinda don't see why they're in the European fantasy set of all places

twilit canyon
#

anime sells

#

regardless of setting

granite badge
#

I'm not super fond of the anime arts but most of them are fine

#

I'd rather have more options for art choice then less

granite badge
#

probably one of my favs out of spoiler season so far

trail anvil
#

ye it's an old card but it's fun flavor

zinc shard
zinc shard
#

Guys I found them!

#

They Mulliganed to 5 and conceded. At least they live up to their name.

twilit canyon
rigid scarab
#

Wow

#

A LOT of EDH stories I find to be just self-validation

#

"I did a thing and my opponents reacted like this. Am I in the wrong?"

#

Story clearly constructed to put the opposition in the worst light possible

#

"What's y'alls thoughts?"

zinc shard
#

it's a meme

modern minnow
#

Everyone i play against in commander who beats me is ontologically evil

rigid scarab
glad peak
#

anyone playing edh is mean always :^)

#

^sub edh to literally any game and you have the truth to how it feels to play any game

rich bronze
#

One of the coolest alters I’ve seen

golden plover
#

This is really good for standard aggro right?

#

[[Doomed Traveler]] saw play every standard it was in

lost widgetBOT
golden plover
#

And this is a way better doomed Traveler

#

Well the token is worse, but the upfront body is better

#

Also that flavor text sucks

trail anvil
#

I like it

#

also I think it's a sidegrade

#

it has haste but the token doesn't have evasion which is very notable

golden plover
#

It's not [[Ancient Grudge |ISD]] bad but it's not good either

lost widgetBOT
golden plover
#

And yeah, the token is much worse than Doomed Traveler's flier

#

But the upfront body having haste is a lot better

#

It's a side grade for sure, but it's probably a standard playable side grade

#

Unless we're at the point where doomed traveler wouldn't see constructed play next time he's in standard

trail anvil
#

I mean she elaborates on bricks being something rats don't eat, but she's probably doing so out of exasperation

#

which actually makes sense

golden plover
#

She's also wrong there tho lmao

#

Rats can totally eat through bricks to get to food

trail anvil
#

I'll take your word for it fam but I think she means they're not good food

golden plover
#

Yeah but there's food in the storehouse

#

It's honestly crazy how motivated rats can be to get to food irl

trail anvil
#

my dude she's saying that's a warehouse full of bricks, as in a construction material warehouse

#

the warehouse itself is full of bricks

golden plover
#

Ohh yeah I guess they don't need to eat that then

copper pecan
#

avacyn's bricks, the construction material of her church

sudden lava
#

rat tribal is eating good this expansion

pulsar talon
#

is it supposed to look like this?

copper pecan
#

i don't think so

pulsar talon
#

any reason to not open up my packs?

sudden lava
#

||I wonder if we will get an otter for all color combinations with blue as an adventure considering the spoilered Elusive Otter||

last glen
glad peak
#

Bricks are the building blocks ||to a good breakfast||

rich bronze
sudden lava
#

are we expecting reveals at magiccon las vegas?

#

oh yeah seems we are

storm elbow
twilit canyon
#

slam t1 oko its just stronger

golden plover
#

Speaking of Oko, which of his colors do you think his son is gonna get?

fallow citrus
#

isn't his son the boros equipment guy

hidden ermine
#

Yep

fallow citrus
#

so unless he gets a third colour later, the answer is none

twilit canyon
#

yea im pretty sure thats just confirmed to be boros

golden plover
#

Yeah, I meant down the line since he's a new main character

clever sun
#

Wait I'm lost

#

When did he become the main character?

golden plover
#

Not the main, but he's very much going to be a main one going forward

hidden ermine
#

He is already confirmed to be important for Thunder Junction iirc

golden plover
#

Yup

copper pecan
#

yeah it'd be super weird for him to not be important given his role in the story so far

trail anvil
#

do we know his mom

copper pecan
#

just some random lady who isn't important

trail anvil
#

she managed to snag the hottest guy on the plane tho pensivecowboybread

waxen timber
#

The mom I think used to be a witch or something

golden plover
#

I still refuse to believe Oki isn't gay

sudden lava
#

oh I get it now

#

deal 2 is red (too hot), tap is blue (too cold), and 3 is just regular food ability (Just right)

#

cute

pulsar talon
#

Hmmmm

#

Porridge

rigid scarab
#

With strawberries?

sudden lava
#

Ogre at cinderella's ball PogYu

glad peak
#

Eh scam is annoying and very very good but broken? Not really

trail anvil
#

this looks potentially spooky with roles

golden plover
#

Very strange blogatog response

#

"not every card type needs to be evergreen"

#

Then why make them a new card type???

sudden lava
#

I wonder if we will get Jenny (The Doctor's daughter) in the precons

copper pecan
#

i don't understand why you think this is weird

#

just because it's a new card type doesn't mean it needs to be in every set

golden plover
#

I dunno, it's just weird to have a card type that's not used every set

copper pecan
#

tribal wasn't in every set back when that was a thing

golden plover
#

Yeah but tribal wasn't really a card type in the same sense

#

It was more of a supertype

copper pecan
#

if they had to use this in every set they probably just wouldn't make the mechanic at all since that's a lot to commit to

golden plover
#

Yeah true. I just think it's sorta weird since I feel like card types for magic come with the expectation they're used every set

#

You wouldn't have a set without artifacts

twilit canyon
#

didnt see this one till now

#

really decent rate

copper pecan
#

ye that seems great

rich bronze
#

This honestly seems really promising

#

Tho

#

I’m 100% playing mardu burn

twilit canyon
#

2 mana -1/-1 can catch a surprising amount of stuff and then it becomes a 2 mana 2/2 that boosts by 2 its a lot of abilities in 1 card. probably solid in standard

rich bronze
#

Standard sure

#

But who plays that

twilit canyon
rich bronze
twilit canyon
rich bronze
#

Better than PwF

twilit canyon
#

what was that one card

#

[[vicious rumors]]

lost widgetBOT
twilit canyon
#

almost a strict upgrade

rich bronze
#

I mean not that relevant since you know that sucks

#

but

#

Burn is okay with running a few shocks

twilit canyon
#

outside of modern yeah

rich bronze
#

Because, simply put, 3x6+2=20

rich bronze
twilit canyon
#

ehhh

rich bronze
#

Burn discord is all over it

#

Half of us are running PwF anyway

twilit canyon
#

im not sold on running black for a deal 2 discard 1 entirely

rich bronze
#

this is just better than PwF

rich bronze
lost widgetBOT
twilit canyon
#

in burn yeah. hm i mean.

#

oh no yeah bump is for sure if ur in mardu or rakdos

rich bronze
#

Spike with a small upside

#

That comes up sometimes

twilit canyon
#

im just thinking about deck space for this one

lusty trench
twilit canyon
#

it is not

lusty trench
twilit canyon
#

burn wont run that tutor

rich bronze
#

We’re talking about modern burn

#

Which is about as streamlined

lusty trench
#

Oh burn ignore me

rich bronze
#

As a deck can get

rich bronze
#

My current burn list costs 700 bucks

sudden lava
#

Simple hasty body

rich bronze
#

because I’m on 2 monkeys and 4 chalices

twilit canyon
#

the only 4 mana spell i have ran in burn and actually cast (orvar doesnt count) is a single wandering emperor when i forgot an exquisite firecraft in the side and i had no time to find anything else

rich bronze
#

since 10 1 mana creatures is where I wanna be if we’re off eidolon

#

Also doing well with 5C creativity rn

#

People ditched orvar

#

Feels good

twilit canyon
rich bronze
twilit canyon
#

1 of

rich bronze
#

mhm

twilit canyon
#

i toyed with 3 guides 2 monkey

rich bronze
#

Lol

#

Imagine cutting guides

twilit canyon
#

yea i went back bc i have had ppl do silly things to eat or kill guides

rich bronze
#

Remember when guides were like

#

50 bucks

#

That was a moment in time for sure

twilit canyon
#

nope. i started magic in 2019

#

i got my guides for 5$

rich bronze
#

Same

twilit canyon
#

and swiftspears for 2

rich bronze
#

but I started earlier

twilit canyon
#

best investment ive made in magic besides my bolts

rich bronze
#

I’m avoiding buying obm

#

For 50

#

Since it’ll inevitably be a $20 rare

twilit canyon
#

yea idt that card will be long for this modern format too

#

it depends

#

tbh itd be really solid in a mardu/rakdos burn list hm

rich bronze
#

Eh no

#

Not where we wanna be

#

My MH3 wishlist

#

Is busted colour soup options

#

And also PoP

twilit canyon
#

price of progress isnt happening in modern

#

it should

#

but it wont

rich bronze
#

No

#

Right now it shouldn’t

#

4c 5c too weak to handle it

#

Make colour soup a lot stronger

twilit canyon
rich bronze
#

And also print pop

twilit canyon
#

especially in rakdos

#

what else are u filling up the side slots with?

rich bronze
twilit canyon
#

fuck. i mean

#

sure

#

but i think we can probably do better or more optimized.

#

bowmasters can wreck face against draw heavy decks. its a lot of burn

rich bronze
#

Ah man

#

When chalice is $70

twilit canyon
#

out of stock SadChamp

rich bronze
#

And out of stock on CK

twilit canyon
#

i dont have a chalice playset too

rich bronze
#

You know something is wrong

twilit canyon
#

i have been waiting

#

chalice good

rich bronze
#

Got this a month ago!

twilit canyon
#

i only have 2 chalice since often times i only ever play em in decks where 2 of chalice is good enough

rich bronze
#

Aye

#

Chalice and Sheol and probably the two most weirdly expensive cards

twilit canyon
#

its one of those cards that im like "its good to have the playset" but i havent justified the purchase of it yet

rich bronze
#

Also cavern

twilit canyon
#

cavern is so fucking weird

#

decks where its good havent been relevant in a while

#

and yet

#

infinite money

rich bronze
#

Why the fuck is it 50

#

Honestly

#

Edh

twilit canyon
#

nah cant be

rich bronze
#

It’s a powerhouse

twilit canyon
#

itd be a 1 of there

rich bronze
#

Explain sheoldred

twilit canyon
#

standard

#

and pioneer

rich bronze
#

It’s a mythic from an in print standard set

#

it shouldn’t be 80

twilit canyon
#

also in modern it sees play bc ppl still copying jake's decklist that won and he played 2 in the side of scam

#

not that i didnt see 1 or 2 of in the side sometimes main in scam before that but it really ramped up in popularity after that

rich bronze
#

It sucks in scam

twilit canyon
#

im not a fan of it in scam yes

#

every time i play against it in scam im like

#

thank god

#

they tapped out for shelly

#

both when playing burn and murktide

rich bronze
#

What decks do you hate playing against

#

The most

twilit canyon
#

honestly i dont particularly hate playing vs anything in modern rn

rich bronze
#

Scam for me

twilit canyon
#

i am annoyed by decks doing ring shenanigans since they are usually kinda shit but they can sometimes sack you

#

like dimir control or 4/5c control lists on ring + minamo

rich bronze
#

Also I love playing against omnath

#

Tbh

twilit canyon
#

they are usually not great decks

#

and if they dont run into enough ring copies and minamo they kinda fall over into themselves

rich bronze
#

Meh

#

They fold to 2 archons

twilit canyon
#

but sometimes they do draw enough ring copies

#

no yeah

#

thats what im saying

#

they usually suck

#

but sometimes they draw multiple rings + minamo and they bury u in cards

#

which feels bad to me cus its losing to an otherwise bad deck

rich bronze
#

I love spell piercing rings

#

Or binding them

twilit canyon
#

ye

#

ive been force of negation on murktide with subtlety and its also satisfying to hit the ring with it

rich bronze
#

Murk plays 1 FoN Mb

twilit canyon
#

yea

rich bronze
#

Sometimes 1 sb

twilit canyon
#

that 1 of fon

rich bronze
#

You on more?

twilit canyon
#

1 of side

#

nope

#

just 2

#

1 main 1 side

#

and 2 subtlety main

#

1 side

#

feels like i can get away with shit thanks to preordain

rich bronze
#

Yeah preordain

#

Is honestly a big upgrade

#

I wonder if 5CC wants to be on it

#

Some people are on it

#

But idk yet

#

In a non bowmaster meta

#

For sure

golden plover
#

@lusty trench lmao I just saw Astarion's alt art for the first time

lusty trench
#

What the fuck

golden plover
#

This man is NOT Astarion

lusty trench
#

That's the crimson chin

#

Tf

golden plover
#

Halsin is super off too

lusty trench
#

Twink halsin

golden plover
#

Honestly Karlach's main art is really off

#

Her alt art is at least sorta closer

#

But neither are that good at capturing her

#

Gale's is weird too

#

Lae'zel is the most consistently correct

#

Then Shadowheart and Wyll

granite badge
lusty trench
#

Ive been playing since 2015 and I'm still dumb af

twilit canyon
hidden ermine
#

Theres not that much historical context thats important for the timeframe, you can learn stuff relatively quickly

fallow citrus
#

yeah if you just learn from people who are very experienced it rubs off on you

lusty trench
#

I learnt from casual edh players

fallow citrus
#

unfortunate

sudden lava
#

wait, there is cards that straight up kill the opponent if you pick feed

#

was scrolled up

#

if they were at say 40, then they lost 20 life

#

and then feed takes the other half

granite badge
#

that's the only thing the folks at the hs lunch table would play

hidden ermine
#

Thats how most people get into paper magic nowadays

#

Other formats are either too expensive or unpopular

#

And draft/limited is a specific niche tbh

pulsar talon
#

just to know

#

is eldrazi legal in standard?

sudden lava
pulsar talon
#

any

golden plover
#

Nope

sudden lava
#

yeah pretty sure none are in rotation

#

outside of like changelings

waxen timber
#

I don't think any changelings are even in standard cause I think the last standard set that had that was Kaldheim

pulsar talon
#

Is kethek, crucible goliath any good?

twilit canyon
#

[[kethek crucible goliath]]

lost widgetBOT
#

Legendary Creature — Phyrexian Beast
At the beginning of your end step, you may sacrifice another creature. If you do, reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a nonlegendary creature card with lesser mana value, put it onto the battlefield, then put the rest on the bottom of your library in a random order.
4/4

twilit canyon
#

not particularly. not bad but not good

pulsar talon
#

I see

rich bronze
#

I know people who started playing in 2020

#

And are better than 99.9% of players I know

rich bronze
granite badge
#

just edh and draft and infrequently at that

rich bronze
#

edh is a board game

#

And draft varies a lot

#

Play a 60 card format and learn the meta

trail anvil
#

this card is actually so nice for monogreen in hbrawl

#

ETB draw at 2 mana slaps

sudden lava
#

a new sorcery for Elsa.dek

lusty trench
trail anvil
#

5
bruh this is one of the most popular commanders

sudden lava
glad peak
#

Up the beanstalk is interesting due to working with some of the best evoke elementals and leyline binding

trail anvil
#

bruh they give you all access no banlist and you decide to do fuckin trickery?

twilit canyon
#

im gonna be playing an izzet tempo list with brainstorm ragavan counterspell bolts and drc

trail anvil
#

see now that sounds fun

glad peak
#

You’re in blue so might as well add oko and uro too

twilit canyon
#

nah not strong enough for what im doing

zinc shard
#

Already got leaked but officially revealed now, this card seems nuts

lusty trench
#

If I see this card played against me in limited I'm just gonna scoop

sudden lava
#

so its 1 mana and 1 green per triplet

twilit canyon
#

time to farm

#

poor guy

trail anvil
#

oof channel elves?

twilit canyon
#

they aint channeling shit

#

this game has ended

#

my opponent just doesnt know it yet

clever sun
#

WHAT

#

I GOT SACKED BY CHANNEL BANEFIRE

#

Fucking hell I hate Channel

twilit canyon
trail anvil
#

I thought I'd see a lot more of those decks than I have so far lmao

#

wtf is this pile supposed to be, ik no-lands is a deck but I'm really confused what they're going for here

fallow citrus
#

isn't that just charbelcher

trail anvil
#

[[goblin charbelcher]]

lost widgetBOT
fallow citrus
#

you ironcrag feat into win

trail anvil
#

ic

twilit canyon
#

lmfao

#

im almost 2x farther into my deck than my opponent is

clever sun
#

I give up

#

I'm going the Izzet way

trail anvil
#

yeah this deck is busted

twilit canyon
#

gonna try this as well

clever sun
#

Oh this is gross

#

I love the NBL event

trail anvil
#

I feel like there are a pretty cool amount of decks

#

I saw someone just run monored with lightning bolt which honestly with all these greedy decks running around sounds like a good idea

twilit canyon
#

thats worse than izzet

#

actually

#

we dont have goblin guide

#

so ur just losing out on the good blue tempo aggro cards

clever sun
#

Yeah it feels like

#

You get the whole world at your disposal and you spend it on... Mono-Red with Bolt

twilit canyon
#

this is really pushed lol

lusty trench
#

Savannah lions in shambles

sudden lava
#

who would win, Savannah Lions or one cheeky smol mouse

twilit canyon
#

neither. they both die

lusty trench
#

It is an unfair fight, the mouse has rabies

twilit canyon
#

and i oop

trail anvil
sudden lava
#

they really trying to make faerie tribal a thing

lusty trench
#

Card made for the commander deck

twilit canyon
#

they couldnt have just reprinted [[spellstutter sprite]]?

lost widgetBOT
golden plover
#

Nah that's a $4 common

#

Gotta save it for a secret lair/masters set

glad peak
#

Oh cool spell stutter’s interesting

#

(Not really)

copper pecan
#

they should reprint the smug anime girl alt art of spellstutter sprite into standard

#

only the smug anime girl one though

trail anvil
#

ah fuck I shouldn't have said this was fun in the post match survey lmao

dense berry
zinc shard
#

Might be overcosted, but this seems decent?

atomic harness
#

I'm back nyaruhodo

lusty trench
#

I think this is the first time this effect has appeared colourless isn't it?

copper pecan
#

i think so

lusty trench
#

Doubt it's good though, 4 is a mana too high for this type of effect

fallow citrus
#

4 mana claim the firstborn poggers

atomic harness
#

foundry makes it 3 copium

hidden ermine
#

Because if so

#

Nope

#

We got one 18 days ago

#

[[Flayer of Loyalties]]

lost widgetBOT
hidden ermine
lusty trench
#

Completely forgot about flayer despite it being one of the better eldrazi

sudden lava
#

deploy unruly catapult

fallow citrus
#

[[thermo alchemist]]

lost widgetBOT
fallow citrus
#

1 toughness is worth 1 mana ig

sudden lava
#

second copy of thermo-alchemist

atomic harness
#

foundry also makes it cost as much as thermo alchemist PauseChamp

#

(I dont know where I'm going with this)

granite badge
zinc shard
#

Welp, they brought the right deck for this matchup

rich bronze
#

I mean to be fair piomeme is a joke too and explorer is piomeme lite

#

the only real formats are modern and legacy

zinc shard
#

I'm doin it to get missions done

pulsar talon
#

so i'm playing the 2-color starter deck matches in arena

#

how do i stop getting steamrolled by red/white and blue/white?

zinc shard
#

Commander Spoilers

lusty trench
zinc shard
#

Golem Tribal Commander lets go!

glad peak
sudden lava
#

also weird implication that this turns your creatures into cookies

trail anvil
# lusty trench

I feel like this is worse than the other korvold cause the other one plussed off of treasures super hard

trail anvil
zinc shard
#

Roll Credits

glad peak
trail anvil
#

ig you run this in the other korvold?

#

in the 99

lusty trench
#

I feel like you could probably put this korvold in the 99 of the other korvold yeah

#

Cause like 3 mana 4/4 flying trample haste that gets you value if it isn't stopped is pretty decent

#

Wait, each card type sacrificed? Cringe

#

This is... Certainly a card

trail anvil
#

so a mana rock that turns into an equipment when you really need it

twilit canyon
#

this is kinda shit

granite badge
#

so a mana dork that turns into a bad equipment when a legendary etbs

#

flavorful but mid

golden plover
#

I think I'll try it in Roghark/Yoshimaru

#

And other legendary tribals but it's not great

trail anvil
#

at least in hbrawl you run this just cause it's a mana rock that has another use

#

maybe in equipment decks

glad peak
#

Welp it’s a 2 mana mana rock that enters untapped so it goes into all 0-1 color edh deck

trail anvil
#

this one looks like it's super under costed

#

I'm putting this right into slogurk for sure

trail anvil
#

there it is

#

[[god-eternal bontu]]

lost widgetBOT
trail anvil
lusty trench
trail anvil
#

I feel like this one would be pretty good in certain decks nyaruhodo

#

vomit your hand and use the first 2 modes, if all your advantage is in your hand you can use the last 2 modes

lusty trench
#

The louder they scrankle the harder he lankles

trail anvil
#

rankle's prankle

#

[[vampiric rites]]

lost widgetBOT
lusty trench
#

Art goes harder than that card has any rights to

trail anvil
#

sometimes the weirder cards get the better arts

#

Redtooth Vanguard - 1G

Creature - Elf Warrior (Uncommon)

Trample

Whenever an enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, you may pay (2). If you do, return ~ from your graveyard to your hand.

3/1

#

also apparently this is a cycle

twilit canyon
# trail anvil

this card is really confusing to me bc its honestly kinda shit

#

like

#

why is this a rare

trail anvil
#

probably cause it's mechanically unique with the next turn deal damage part

twilit canyon
#

its the next combat phase this turn

#

so it has to be used mp1

#

or else u dont get the fight at all

#

but then that telegraphs ur entire play sequence

lusty trench
#

They destroy the creature you were gonna pick lmao

twilit canyon
#

it also doesnt even cheat on mana for the creature you exile to cast that turn

trail anvil
#

o misread that

#

idk it seems terrible into instant speed removal which is most of this format but a dig for 5 + damage doesn't sound like a bad rate for 2 mana

#

the more I think about it the less I think it'll be a good rare but I get why they put it as a rare

sudden lava
lusty trench
#

That ain't a mana rock

#

That's a mana boulder

sudden lava
#

it's not just a boulder, its a rock!

lusty trench
#

They're really waiting a while for these last two virtues to drop huh

zinc shard
atomic harness
#

That's pretty nice actually

trail anvil
#

that's solid value, ig you side this in vs monored?

zinc shard
#

This combos with that 6 mana demon

zinc shard
sudden lava
#

RAT COLONY pogofgreed

zinc shard
sudden lava
#

1.75 speed go brrr

lusty trench
trail anvil
#

yeah that's a card that exists

rigid scarab
#

NOOOOOOOOOO

#

HOW COULD YOU POWERCREEP DIVINATION LIKE THAT

#

THE GAME IS BROKEN

trail anvil
#

literally unplayable

sudden lava
#

started as a tree, was turned into cardboard, and now its a tree again that is an insult to the tree that made it PuddingSip

golden plover
sudden lava
#

at the very least, it works with Gylwain Casting Director

waxen timber
#

Timber seems really good. Like Roles are very cheap so, he's basically a 3/3 for 2 which is playable

lusty trench
#

They're commander/legacy/vintage only

waxen timber
#

Oh, yeah then trash

sudden lava
#

Not much longer until doctor who reveals

#

and then Ixalan

zinc shard
#

my opponent brought all their 4 leafed clovers to this game

#

Update: AHHHHHH

trail anvil
#

we missed out on brawl mwm for this VERYSADCAT

zinc shard
zinc shard
lusty trench
#

My thoughts on this deck is it's fun, and has some nice new cards for the faerie strats

#

It also has nice reprints

zinc shard
lusty trench
#

Buts it's never going to win a game unless your opponents ignore completely

zinc shard
golden plover
lusty trench
#

I feel sorry for people that pick up the faerie deck tbh

#

Why did they not give them a decent finisher

golden plover
#

Puppeteers is your "finisher"

lusty trench
#

That's what I mean though

#

This deck can't close games

#

And its in blue and can't protect itself

#

how are you in blue and have 3 spells with the words counter target spell while offering 0 other protection

zinc shard
rigid scarab
#

-Umbra Mystic
-Retether
-Utopia Sprawl
-Daybreak Coronet
-Bear Umbra
-Mantle of the Ancients
-Hall of Heliod's Generosity

#

Most expensive card is Hall of Heliod's Generosity at $10 for the Aura deck

#

Not looking too good for it

#

Actually

#

Do we know the general price of these precons?

#

Because these cards are ABYSMALLY low value for even a $40 precon

lusty trench
#

Higher price per card on average than most decks, lower top end

#

Idk that's kinda cringe

sudden lava
#

Support the show and become a Patron! Be a part of our community, receive awesome rewards, and more! https://www.patreon.com/commandzone


Show Notes:

Wilds of Eldraine is just around the corner, and we’re FAERIE excited to reveal one of the brand new precons! That’s right, this episode we’re revealing the full decklist for the blue an...

▶ Play video
golden plover
#

Tbf doesn't seem like they care about any precons now

granite badge
#

ngl I miss the days when commander precons were yearly things

#

there are way too many of them nowadays

dense berry
#

shadow puppeteers looks flavorfully bankrupt

golden plover
#

Although the $20 Kaldheim and Zendikar ones were pretty good

dense berry
#

why is shadow puppeteers not a shade or a dragon

#

why doesnt it have shadow

copper pecan
#

because shadow is an awful mechanic

#

and also doing an impression of a dragon or casting a shadow doesn't mean you are a dragon or a shade

lusty trench
#

The card is also the shadow and not the two faeries casting it, as those are made when it etbs

#

It's very wonky flavour wise

dense berry
#

yeah it seems high concept and executed poorly

copper pecan
#

the card is called shadow puppeteers, not "shadow puppet"

#

it's the guys doing the shadow puppets and not the shadow itself

#

they're only doing the shadow puppets while they're attacking and that's why they're not dragons all the time

dense berry
#

the art shows two fairys and a shadow dragon the card is a 4/4 flying fairy that makes two fairy tokens???

lusty trench
copper pecan
#

if it was the puppet then it wouldn't be called a puppeteer

lusty trench
#

Worse nyxbloom ancient

dense berry
copper pecan
#

why does it being 4/4 mean it can't be a fairy

#

shadow puppetry translates to doing damage because it's magic shadow puppetry

#

the dragon is red because most dragons are red

#

idk why it makes 2 tokens

#

the fairy tokens are black because the ones in the set are black

lusty trench
dense berry
#

why would a random fairy rogue be as strong in terms of power and toughness as the fairy archmage thats flavorfully noted to be exceptionally powerful

lusty trench
#

This is how I see the card

#

And the card allowing others to become dragons is these creatures telling your other faeries how to do it

dense berry
#

oh also why is the base card a fairy wizard

#

but the tokens are rogues

stark skiff
#

You’re really overthinking this

dense berry
#

its high concept its meant to be thought about

copper pecan
#

you're really overthinking this

#

this is getting into the realm of "why can i equip lightning greaves onto a snake"

#

the card is a 4/4 because it's seven mana

dense berry
#

thats a straw man and you know it but sure

#

lightning greaves and any other card for that matter cannot flavorfully account for everything ever printed in the creature supertype

#

its design is solid for what the idea is trying to convey

#

this wizard puppet thing does not convey its flavor effectively like lightning greaves

copper pecan
burnt relic
sudden lava
atomic harness
#

Hey I love horsemanship

zinc shard
#

I wanna make a deck with this commander sometime. Basically reads "your creatures are unblockable"

atomic harness
#

sun quan infect jigglepog

glad peak
#

Let’s make blighted agent unblockable fancy

atomic harness
#

now he can have unblockable and horsemanship EZ

rigid scarab
atomic harness
#

That's baral kid...

rigid scarab
#

As in

#

I've seen everyone who played Sun Quan

#

Play it as counterspell tribal

atomic harness
#

why play it like bad baral ahri

#

might as well make use of horsemanship

rigid scarab
#

But why make use of creature-based blue when you can play mono blue combo instead

fallow citrus
#

sure if you want to play sun quan for mono blue combo go ahead

#

just sounds like a waste of a commander slot

trail anvil
twilit canyon
#

if the main body had flash id like it a lot

#

as-is? its kinda meh

dense berry
#

pack 1 pick 1 quality

twilit canyon
#

oh in limited this thing fucks

trail anvil
#

I feel like you need to run it in a flicker deck to justify it

#

so you're just doing a 2 mana flicker with a body after, unfortunate it doesn't have an etb itself pensiveCowboy

atomic harness
#

hi chat, my new lgs has this $100 bommander thing and I still want to play my usual unga bunga list but it seems to be clocking at $214 according to moxfield worrythink is there a way for me to keep stuff like urza's saga and esper sentinel in the list still

lusty trench
#

Show the list

atomic harness
#

kk give me a few mins since the moxfield one isnt updated

rigid scarab
#

I know Zada can be scary

atomic harness
rigid scarab
#

Well

atomic harness
#

as long as we get to keep the main idea of slap early artifact creatures on the board, t3/t4 urza take over with constructs and hold some mana for interaction I'm okay with that ahri4
havent played in a while, when I played the main mvps were esper sentinel, ethersworn, the mana myrs, karn (construct first, then free cards)
and like the stupidly cheap interaction spells since I dont have a lot of mana most of the time

rigid scarab
#

No way in hell a $100 list is keeping Urza's Saga

atomic harness
#

yeah rip saga ahri

rigid scarab
#

We gotta focus on

#

Which cards are crazy expensive because they're technically optimal

#

I'm looking at like

#

Relic of Progenitus

atomic harness
#

oh you can cut that tbh im not sure why its so expensive it came in the precon worrythink

rigid scarab
#

And idk what Skullclamp does for the deck

#

I think Teferi Time Reveler is best if you're going for a combo win

#

But your deck is very clearly focused on combat to win

atomic harness
#

the deck does have a combo win but I rarely get to pull it off yeah

rigid scarab
#

What does the combo win involve?

atomic harness
#

tef is honestly just removal draw and a funny "kill me" guy

#

Uh it's lord high, thopsword. infinite blue mana, infinite thopters, infinite life, and infinite uses of urza's gacha

#

but yeah I usually just punch people to death

rigid scarab
#

Glimmervoid is an expensive optimization that you can honestly just replace with a basic

#

And idt Inventor's Fair is gonna see the final list either if it's not a strict wincon

atomic harness
#

yeah thats a good cut. I just have one lying around so I play with it. funny lifegain wee

rigid scarab
#

Same with Veto being an expensive optimization

#

I don't see you getting in many counterspell wars

atomic harness
#

could we keep that, that card is kinda clutch worrythink

rigid scarab
#

Is it clutch in a $100 setting though

atomic harness
#

maybe not, but the use case has often been it stops something that ends the game without being stoppable by a kingmaker or the person trying to win

#

or those silly red elemental blast / pyroblast ppl

rigid scarab
#

I would honestly only keep $3+ cards in the deck if it's absolutely indisputably vital in the list

atomic harness
#

gotcha

rigid scarab
#

And Veto isn't a necessary card

#

Just a good card

atomic harness
#

we can just stick with the cheapo counterspells then

#

I do agree with running more basics to reduce the cost since the deck doesnt actually care about colored mana that much
I usually just need the esper mana for my commander then thats about it

more blue since counterspells and yeah

rigid scarab
#

I think anything $15+ is a no-go

#

So

#

I don't think Esper Sentinel's stayin

#

You can replace him with a Remora though

#

Accomplishes around the same job

atomic harness
#

I do own remora but I dont feel good about it because of bumulative bupkeep and it's harder to stick

shame but I guess 30 is a bit too much

#

esper has been the goat NukGar I buff him with cranial plating and he goes up to like 10+
and everyone says "you can just draw"

rigid scarab
#

Do you pay the 13 nyaruhodo

atomic harness
#

"I will not pay the 15" ICANT

#

some people pay the 5 though, madmen

#

oh what do you think of mishra's bauble, it's only like a dollip. Was a good time with emry

#

also I know scion of urza is $8 but I really do want to keep him worrythink

rigid scarab
#

Ren

#

I'm sorry

#

We have to put him down

atomic harness
#

narset is just a funny girl you know. I haven't had mine be punched in all the games I've played her because of the fat constructs being great blockers

#

then she digs for a counterspell smth smth it's a good time

meager isle
#

about narset?

atomic harness
#

oh I need some help getting my list down to a 100 dollars

#

while still keeping the general gameplan

meager isle
#

3 colors oof

#

you have a lot of pricey lands

#

urzas saga

atomic harness
#

Yeah we're cutting that

meager isle
#

are you even trying ren?

#

okay lol

atomic harness
#

No that's just my original list

#

urza's saga hard carries me every game CopiumOverdose

#

I get two constructs and sol ring PeepoFight

meager isle
#

yea good card

atomic harness
#

for my actual lands we can cut some of the expensive ones for basics since I dont actually need that much colored mana

meager isle
#

yeah I'd cut anything above $3

atomic harness
#

why is adarkar wastes 5 dollars minimum monkaGIGA

meager isle
#

best land in standard iirc

#

well the pains in general

atomic harness
#

guess im taking out my sea of clouds too

#

islands plains and swamps time CopiumOverdose

meager isle
#

goodness offer you cant refuse is $3?

#

relic you probably don't need

#

clamp is strong enough to keep probably

atomic harness
#

sickle said I couldnt make use of clamp enough but I love the card

#

it's pretty broken so why not play it yfm

meager isle
#

ethersworn canist and esper sent are obvious cuts

#

urza is good enough to keep I guess

atomic harness
#

why didnt they reprint esper sentinel in cmm NukGar

meager isle
#

theyy don't want to throw modern a bone yet pensivecowboybread

atomic harness
#

it dies to bowmasters copium

#

I think we can keep most of my friends

meager isle
#

ban bowmaster

atomic harness
lusty trench
#

If you want to cut more

atomic harness
#

Aye

meager isle
#

ehh lion sash is cuttable

#

if not then cut the bojuka bog

atomic harness
#

oh sure we can cut lion sash

#

honestly the 1 and 2 drops can just be anyhing that has some bonus effect

#

you just want to have 2-3 artifact creatures when you play urza for affinity

#

vault skirge is my favorite PeepoLove

meager isle
#

I can't think of any cheap artifact creatures rn

lusty trench
#

Possible inclusion for a cheap searcher

#

It's like

#

$2 rn

meager isle
#

[[$fabricate]]

atomic harness
#

Oh this is cute if I commit to the thopsword play more

lost widgetBOT
#
Secret Lair Drop

$10.95

Warhammer 40,000 Commander

$3.17 • €2.07

Secret Lair Drop

$10.47

The List

$4.22 • €3.49

Planechase

$6.92 • €2.70 • 1.77 TIX

Magic 2010

$4.12 • €1.97 • 0.03 TIX

World Championship Decks 2004

$5.67 • €1.75

Mirrodin

$4.46 • €2.82 • 0.03 TIX

atomic harness
#

I think I have one

#

im kind of dying for card draw now that esper died, best I have rn is spy network

is there anything else that's cheap to use? worrythink

lusty trench
#

Technically it's free if you played at the right time :3

#

Mask of memory if you can reliably get hits in

meager isle
#

[[mirrodin besieged]] is pretty decent I'd say

lost widgetBOT
#

Enchantment
As Mirrodin Besieged enters the battlefield, choose Mirran or Phyrexian.
• Mirran — Whenever you cast an artifact spell, create a 1/1 colorless Myr artifact creature token.
• Phyrexian — At the beginning of your end step, draw a card, then discard a card. Then if there are fifteen or more artifact cards in your graveyard, target opponent loses the game.

meager isle
#

can also kill someone if you choose to

lusty trench
#

This is also good

atomic harness
#

Yeah I have him PeepoLove

#

have cast and monitor

meager isle
#

Ayy $90 you have room

atomic harness
#

bumped lands back to 31

#

apparently this one is good [[liberator, urza's battlethopter]]

lost widgetBOT
meager isle
#

Oh yeah it should be cheap too

#

[[$liberator urza]]

lost widgetBOT
meager isle
#

Ehhhh

#

We’ll see what we can add instead lol

atomic harness
#

I'm looking for cheap artifact creatures that bring some sort of utility worrythink

#

like soulless jailer is nice because of the floodgate

#

time to bring back lion sash copium

meager isle
#

Yeah lion sash is fine probably

#

[[myr smith]]?

lost widgetBOT
meager isle
#

Idk how much extra mana you have

atomic harness
#

not a lot tbh

meager isle
#

There’s also [[myr battle sphere]] as a top end card

lost widgetBOT
atomic harness
#

[[$pithing needle]]

lost widgetBOT
#
Magic Online Promos

1.57 TIX

Double Masters 2022

$0.97 • €1.04 • 0.58 TIX

Double Masters 2022

$3.23 • €3.00

Double Masters 2022

$3.08

Magic Online Promos

0.74 TIX

Innistrad: Double Feature

$1.09 • €0.90 • 0.86 TIX

Innistrad: Midnight Hunt Promos

$0.99 • €0.95

Innistrad: Midnight Hunt Promos

$1.79 • €1.80

Innistrad: Midnight Hunt

$0.75 • €1.05 • 0.26 TIX

Innistrad: Midnight Hunt

$1.68 • €2.48

lusty trench
#

Be aware of the possibility of going against zada

atomic harness
#

hm how do we deal with that NukGar

meager isle
#

[[zada]]

lost widgetBOT
#

Multiple cards match “zada”, can you be more specific?

atomic harness
#

this one right

meager isle
#

White has protection cards I guess

atomic harness
#

im pretty sure you have to like always counter this or else they pop off any time or smth

lusty trench
#

If someone brings zada to the table get the rest of the table on your side to wipe them out

#

Playing zada is a declaration of war

meager isle
#

hm you only have like 3 creature counter spells

atomic harness
#

[[$blue elemental blast]]
[[$hydroblast]]

lost widgetBOT
#
30th Anniversary Edition

$74.99

Mystery Booster

$0.40 • €2.50

Magic Online Promos

8.35 TIX

Signature Spellbook: Jace

$0.59 • €1.37

Masters 25

$0.80 • €2.00 • 7.80 TIX

Magic Online Promos

6.09 TIX

Magic Online Promos

7.44 TIX

Masters Edition IV

7.82 TIX

Media Inserts

$2.04 • €5.50

Fourth Edition Foreign Black Border

$9.44 • €6.75

#
Magic Online Promos

9.34 TIX

Eternal Masters

$2.36 • €4.99 • 9.68 TIX

Masters Edition

8.74 TIX

World Championship Decks 1998

$0.41 • €0.24

World Championship Decks 1997

$0.59 • €0.30

World Championship Decks 1997

$0.29 • €1.49

Fifth Edition

$2.16 • €2.81

Pro Tour Collector Set

$1.99 • €2.39

rigid scarab
#

Zada is one of those commanders that "Never goes this crazy!"

#

(It was meant to go that crazy)

atomic harness
#

[[wash away]]

lost widgetBOT
atomic harness
#

what about this one jigglepog

meager isle
#

Good anti commander card yea

#

If it’s cheap id play it

atomic harness
#

Yeah it's less than 50 cents

meager isle
#

Perfect

atomic harness
#

I know timmies are always bashed for not having any interactions against decks they cry about

#

so I like to run a lot of counterspells removal etc

meager isle
#

Does your table run interaction?

atomic harness
#

at any given time

atomic harness
#

hmm theres a billion 2 mana blue counterspells, what do we run aside from the ones I already have

#

also gonna put in both Beb and hydroblast I feel

meager isle
#

I would play only one

atomic harness
#

Yeah I prefer the ones that only cost U for the most part ahri4

meager isle
#

I guess there’s spell pierce but I hate those in non cedh

rich bronze
#

And flinched for a second

#

“It’s already at $100?!”

rigid scarab
#

When you say "Run interaction"

#

How many

#

In specific

#

And don't answer "As much as possible"

meager isle
#

I want to say 5 at the least

atomic harness
#

then some utility artifacts that interact with the opp like relic and co

lusty trench
#

15-20% is usually my answer for people asking how much interaction you should run

glad peak
#

40 nyaruhodo

rigid scarab
#

I now know what colours everyone plays

#

Bioo plays Green
Jot plays Black
Mudkip plays Blue

atomic harness
#

what about me ahri

rigid scarab
#

Well I already know you

glad peak
#

No I play red nyaruhodo

lusty trench
atomic harness
#

devoid EZ

lusty trench
#

(I got the eldrazi precon at a good discount)

rigid scarab
glad peak
#

I do set things on fire, yes

lusty trench
#

Bro wtf my pants

#

How could you

meager isle
#

You’re not a very good detective

rigid scarab
#

I literally am not

meager isle
#

Don’t let dreams be dreams

atomic harness
#

I used to hate blue now it's my favorite color umubongo

lusty trench
atomic harness
rigid scarab
#

I'm still a green lover

lusty trench
#

Few things better than ramp and big thing go sideways

meager isle
#

Yea, defending it with counters

rigid scarab
#

Simic goodstuff cheems

meager isle
#

You know me so well

dense berry
#

@atomic harness the cheapest deck possible is probably tatyova

atomic harness
#

oh i dont really wanna buy a new deck

dense berry
#

it would probably set you back like 15 dollars

#

you probably already have mana dorks and basics right

#

and various cheap counterspells

atomic harness
#

That's probably true loot but I'll stick w this deck for now, managed to get it down to 100

sudden lava
#

looking over the final reveals

#

new doggo

rich bronze
copper pecan
#

love the flavor in this set

rich bronze
#

Basically : if your deck can’t consistently cast Leyline Binding for 1 mana turn 2, your deck isn’t interactive enough

copper pecan
#

this is like

#

one of the best combat tricks in a long time, right?

sudden lava
#

for sure

rigid scarab
#

Also idk how much that speaks to your deck being interactive

#

Being able to consistently cast Leyline Binding for 1

rich bronze
rigid scarab
#

Is just a matter of getting 2 triomes out

#

Aww

#

How do I play magic right

rich bronze
#

Proper magic is when youre on 4-5 colours play a playset of wrenn and six and at least 20% of your deck is fetchlands

rigid scarab
#

Dammit!

rich bronze
#

Jund gets a pass though

#

Despite being only 3 colours

glad peak
#

Proper magic is running nonbasic land destruction and cards like blood moon and back to basics and price of progress

#

Magic like the good old days

dense berry
#

proper magic is cube drafting a power cube that only includes mtg cards printed before 2000

rigid scarab
#

I'm surprised there isn't much demand for "Cedh with a twist"

meager isle
#

Pauper cedh is a “thing”

rigid scarab
#

Also

#

EDH question

#

Snore

#

I'm looking for cards/interactions that make opponents go "Holy shit" rather than "Ah ok"

#

Basically

#

Rare/Uncommon haymakers

#

Not talking about card rarity

glad peak
#

Selvala + fetch with panglacial wurm in the deck

meager isle
#

Interaction as in combo or as in removal?

rich bronze