#My feedback after playing for 7 hours straight and getting through the first age.

9 messages ยท Page 1 of 1 (latest)

radiant kindle
#

The Negatives

  1. Minimal match creation settings compared to previous games. I really enjoyed how much customization there used to be and this is a very disappointing reversal.
  2. No automatic exploration. This really sucks.
  3. Traders, or at least whatever the unique unit for Confucius/Mississippian, will not allow me to trade or at the very least making a trade path is not obvious.
  4. Various graphical weirdness, such as tile outline highlights in Wonder cut scenes.
  5. Escape key doesn't always close windows, such as the trade routes window.
  6. I don't know if it was a bug, but at the very start of the game hovering over tiles wouldn't produce any tooltips about the content of the tiles and what they were. I felt like I couldn't at all make an educated decision about what was in my surroundings.
  7. Yields map view keeps turning off. I don't know if there is some window change causing that or if its a feature, but its obnoxious.
  8. The fact there is a build queue at all was not obvious. I had included a lack of build queue as an issue until I accidentally pressed another building and found out there was one after multiple hours of playing.
  9. The order of operations of some in your face notification splash screens was kinda out of order. I consistently get the notification of having completed a milestone BEFORE I get the notification of getting the object that completed that milestone.
  10. There's a lot of weird redundant notifications, such as not selecting a focus on a town every couple turns. It then forces you to go through the process of going into the town just to say that I wanted what I selected already. If I was playing on auto-end turn I can see this being even worse.
  11. I don't know if I missed a tooltop, but assigning Great Works/Resources wasn't intuitive. It took me a little bit to figure out it was a click on the work and then click on the slot. This feels like it could have been a draggable thing, but this is a minor thing.
  12. Technology queue would be nice.

Some Positives:

  1. The game so far has been so much less overwhelming to get into than Civ 6 was. I don't think its as simple as Civ 5, but I definitely appreciate it a lot. It felt way less information overload than when I first got into Civ 6.
  2. The soundtrack is really good. I've caught myself just leaning back and listening to the classical music several times.
  3. The premium Fog of War skin looks so nice, its a lot less claustrophobic feeling than Civ 6 was. I feel like I'm actually playing a board game now instead of just not being able to see anything.
  4. The progression system (Foundation?) that has been added has my interest. I appreciate there being some amount of reward for trying different things and putting effort into the diversity. My only feedback is that I kinda wish there was achievements to further incentivize it.
  5. Load times are so much faster than Civ 6 was. I think this also has to do with minimizing a lot of settings though which I would take back in a heart beat for more customization.

New Issues:

  1. Another redundant notification notifying me that I have resource slots open despite having filled all of the slots. I assume this is asking me to trade, but its still obnoxious.
  2. Trading on normal merchants is also broken for me.
  3. Not being able to do more than one of each diplomatic action because another Civ is being targeted really sucks. I would rather deal with a spy limit or something than this. It feels very unnecessarily constrained.
keen pawn
#

i reported 6 and 7 too...def not just you

upbeat harbor
#

At the start of the game it's a bit buggy, even turning on yields etc will have them turned off or associated with only a particular stance/lens i.e. settler/continents/none vs just being on universally.

#

Also, if you haven't experienced it, the resources can get stuck where you aren't able to unassign them from citites/towns and so can't reassign them ๐Ÿ‘

radiant kindle
elfin spade
#

this is really awesome feedback! thanks for taking the time to put this all together. ๐Ÿ™‚

radiant kindle
radiant kindle
#

forgot to say something, but updated a couple things

obtuse grove