so again, he learned the lesson finally and maintained it lol. he is an infalliable design that was meant to stay as such.
i know you like the idea of humanizing an infalliable symbol, but that's just not good story telling. you dont shit on established characters to try and force a unique character story that doesn't fit.
make this story with a different character, and its good. make it with luke skywalker, and it's just bad.
it has the same energy as superman killing civilians or goku talking about heroism. it just clashes entirely with the pre established character designs, and that's what makes it bad.
there's a reason why mark hamil was so vocally against the LJ story, and i think he knows luke better than you and rian lmfao