#Should Marksmen be able to 1v1 Tanks?

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

lusty spade
#

Thoughts?

main hemlock
#

Depends on the tank and the adc

#

Stuff like malphite and mundo will most of the time run down an adc unless it has insane mobility and dmg

minor reef
#

bork is just too much lol

north ingot
#

Only if they are on even level and they itemize correctly I see no problem with it

turbid atlas
#

Match up related there is no yes or no

lethal talon
#

In general? Yes. But as people state, it's dependent.

#

Early to mid game, I think Tanks should always stat check the adc (similar gold and xp). In the Late game, however, Tanks should exist in the utility role, not as a carry role.

turbid atlas
#

theres a few tanks who can outscale and adcs who are early better than late, it shouldnt be an instant win for the adc at all times. i agree it should be 8/10 times but the other two the tanks gotta have room to punish fuck ups

red patio
#

true tanks (and not juggernauts): They already do past 2 items easily.

#

Better version of this question would be asking about juggs and fighters (which the answer should be no given an equal footing).

quiet maple
#

Out side of duelist and other juggernauts

minor reef
#

the game says that mundo is a bruiser and he sure feels like that

rocky hull
#

The item is extremely overtuned and idk why riot has never addressed it. So many champs are unbeatable at their one item botrk spike because of how strong it is being able to hit for 12% current hp

lusty spade
#

The commuity just calls everything tanky and has damage as bruiser

minor reef
lusty spade
#

Or whenever they switched from the legacy system

lusty spade
amber nacelle
#

just kite man yeah

#

i know this is about arena but like yeah

lusty spade
amber nacelle
#

nuh uh no way

regal flame
#

If malphite loses 1v1 to an equal item/level adc then we have a problem

minor reef
#

he's not taking down a vayne

#

full build? yeah no, no, no. ain't happening

regal flame
#

If malphite loses 1v1 to jinx then buff that

quiet maple
lusty spade
quiet maple
#

That's what I said

regal flame
quiet maple
#

They are fighters..
Thats there class

#

Fighter has two main sub classes
Diver ( camile, J4, renekton).
Juggernaut ( mundo, darius, volibear)

lusty spade
quiet maple
#

Thank you

#

Also i love how the thread about marksman was stolen by Fighters

amber nacelle
#

I mean in theory yes they should be able to if the tank is just running at them in a straight line and tbey are able to kite using cc/slows lmao

minor reef
#

unless

#

the tank is wearing white speedy jordans with approximity veloach and spammable slow + Ghost spell

#

(also movement speed ult)

#

(definitely not talking about dr mundo)

upper seal
#

never

jade edge
#

yes

#

a tank is not supposed to be able to 1v1 and kill anyone

#

the marksmen should definitely take some time to kill them but they shouldnt lose the fight against them

#

because if I can deal the same damage as a tank and be tankier why would i play fighters right

#

check mobile legends their tanks do negative damage and it works better

#

tanks being able to solokill carries defeats their purpose

#

give them more cc and utility and way less damage so that you can't just completely ignore them in a fight

#

like a tank is just supposed to be a CC/utility bot, them dealing damage (especially this game having damage scalings off of resistances is a very bad idea imo)

long marten
jade edge
#

some do but those are supports

long marten
#

tell me what tank are like you said so

jade edge
#

ornn

#

mundo

long marten
#

he as 2/3 cc

#

mundo isn't a tank

jade edge
#

and his damage is fair?

long marten
#

his dmg reward his good play or ennemy mistake so yeah it's fair and even with that he doesn't deal that much

#

else he would be boring to play and not rewarding

#

and would also doesn't make differance between good and bad player

jade edge
#

i guess they give them more damage so people don't stop playing them

#

in most games ever tanks are meant to protect the team and apply cc but not to full combo kill a carry

#

most other mobas dont have this problem and their tanks do negative damage, both support and solo laners

long marten
#

full combo doesn't kill carry at all + he shouldn't be able to full combo a carry unless he mispositioned rly badly

long marten
jade edge
#

lol no

#

league is popular because riot is good at marketing

long marten
#

even like this tank aren't been meta in while so idk where is the problem

#

they aren't even played that much in pro-play also

jade edge
long marten
jade edge
#

yeah

long marten
#

and that should stay his biggest weakness

jade edge
#

though i feel like its hard to even get at and cc a carry with the amount of mobility and peel tools in the game unless they misposition

#

i guess thats the point so you wait for them to misposition someone and get a pick

long marten
#

yeah that's the point that made them balanced

#

as I said before

#

So I don't understand what's the problem with them xD

jade edge
#

what about fighters building full tank items and shotting carries

#

meh not most can do that

long marten
#

whitch one are you talking about ?

jade edge
#

like volibear (i know hes not a good champ)

long marten
#

i don't think he does one shot at all while building tank

jade edge
#

its not entirely oneshot

long marten
#

but fighter are low mobility champ that get rewarded by doing good dmg when getting in melee

#

like Garen, Trundle, Olaf