#subtlety
1 messages · Page 174 of 1
bc you're probably taking something like Imp Shadow Techniques or Shadow Focus which aren't that good
It'll add up and I think the estimate was you only needed it to be effectively used twice? three times? to be better than the other talents at that level.
But outside if combat for 6 seems ridiculus
if you arent gonna send cds on a dying pack, I guess you could vanish/meld to get it going sooner. No idea if this is worth doing tho
it's really not
But probably this is the real answer
you can't be in combat at all
Pick a dungeon and I bet we can find some moments where it'd be up pretty consistently
It's quite surprising
yeah its a bit weird b ut managed to do it ok on first packs in rookery
iirc vanish/meld doesn't start it sooner
Dawnbreaker was amazing for TFD
Yeah
Yes but it feels smoother wihtout chain😅
Oh yeah the fly time sets it up great
but thats also time you arent spending combo points so, probably not worth y
Stonevault has some too. Mists has a few moments, too.
you get 2 restealths with TFD and it’s numerically worth it. We don’t do shit for dmg out of cds
Sad tho😂 but i get it now
Thanks for clarification bois
🫡
Can anyone provide numbers (%) on how big of a loss it is to send CB into the first sec tech in CDs?
0.6%
Next season will have quite a few tfd applications, rookery first pull into out of combat flying. First boss into drop down out of combat. The jump between the second boss room and third boss into the water.
Thats just one dungeon
Hell yeah
I imagine ToP has some, right? Fall down into the area below, running to each wing?
Theatre has plenty
high5
would that give me permission to be a whiny bitch to my tank?
Darkflame cleft after each boss basically
this season too had a lot of instances where tfd was guaranteed
Workshop between first room and fall down to the pipe packs, then between the stealth bit and packs before boss 3
Ye
Dunno how long the trip up to the final packs before boss 4 is but maybe there too
Meadery has a fair amount too, should get solid value from pretty much all of them
Floodgate doesn't really have many, but routing on that one is kindof a mixed bag rn
Priory also has very few
for some reason workshop and de other side are blended in my mind
Running from left wing to right wing should be one, so that's two I can think of
Maybe for the pack before the final boss too
yeah pre-last boss adds and between adds and boss start iirc
Motherlode will depend on how much shit you decide to skip in it
since she does that mini-rp
Yeah, ML is the one I can think of any real good places. Maybe boss 1 -> next pack?
First area trash is pretty bad value now
It may be big first pull with lust into skip to trash before first boss unironically
Sounds like a fun time
The last area of ML sucked
What happened to eye of kezan? I see that fuu’s latest simc is almost the same as other combinations.
You're in permanent combat
Urgh, yeah
For some reason, maybe just ptr bygs
All the trash sucks too
Bleh
Really sad sin noises when i tried it the first time
Idk i did quite a few ptr keys, and all the dungeons were fine / great
Its gonna be a really good season i cant wait
Same, I'm excited for it. I'm only a AotC / +10's but it seems like it'll be a lot better this season
Yeah they took all the kicks, and shoved them into priory
Hell yeah
Finally, puggable.
Will Shadow Blades work on Secret Tech now?
are the changes for sub pog or no?
Which change?
we got nice bug fixes
the buffs were a bit contentious for those who prefer bigger burst and lower baseline damage, but probably healthier for the spec overall
since they nerfed the s2 4pc
i was doing big dam after learning some things yday
The dream of the 60M SecTec: Dead. But, it wasn't ever live, so it wasn't ever real..
will i do more dam when we go live
did they fix the tier set yet?
Im sure this has already been asked but why RS instead of GB for ST, is it because of rupture buff? and I remember something about SF being shit, but I see it in wowhead recommended build not sure whats going on
Man I think the pvp in theater will be the highlight of the season
!wa
GB is only really better for DS and in pure st
and SF is the point we flex between SF and imp storm
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
Wait a second are the RS bug fixes gonna be live?
Yes
Coup charge gone
It's a blessed day
Coup grants SnD
YES.
is this an outlaw opener?
Lmao
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1e2w0iHBCVp8K7hdSk1T8RKtUK9lr4FsRqFWd68FCQnk/pubhtml?gid=579089422&single=true - undocumented bug fixes from this ptr cycle
anyone?
Unsure after recent buffs
I'm just going to play Trickster from the get-go.
Old 4p and 2p are kinda ass, you just want new 4p asap
!bug
Rogue Bug tracker: Spreadsheet | Github Tracker
New 2p aint amazing by itself either
I think they're asking if trickster beats ds in st when 11.1 hits
with current gear
yea
i mean even if they r close i'll go with trickster just to practice more
Yes
I havent double checked but the trickster buffs were like 2.5-3%
And thats pretty much how far behind trickster was in the current tier
So if deathstalker is ahead it should be by an incredibly small margin, so why bother
just simmed with my retail rogue in mimiron and trickster is ~.7% ahead in st
gonna be Playful/Trickster from the get go 😄
ye that sounds about right
You never switched off trickster.
Are we going to play trickster in full ST fights like Sikran / Kyveza tommorow? Or DS better still



It has already started

Is there any welfare catch up gear for alts this week
full veteran from siren isle
Read the messages literally right above yours
Big "is assassination viable this expansion at whispyr" vibes
I also saved this from the other day
i hit a 60M this tier
Only outlaw is viable.
that dude was a trip
the dream was lived
hi, currently playing sub after a few expacs away, and i've a few questions.
Should secret technique be used outside of symbols/dance? if so, should i hold ST for any amount of time to line up with dance?
after our opener, should dance+symbols be used together until i'm unable to use them together? then keep on cd and hold as many stacks for flag+SB?
is coup de grace something i should track? If so, is it something that adds another stack to danse macabre and if so, is it worth playing around?
A 60M SecTec? Damn, blasting
!guide
you should always try to use either/both symbols and dance with secret technique, as long as it means you still can use 2x of sod/dance/sectech in flag+blades
can't always use both when sectech comes up so you play it by ear
and you should track coup so you know when its available to make sure Fazed is on the target before casting it
Technically yes you can sometimes use sectech outside those but only if you are 10000% sure it will be up to be used as first finisher in the following dance.
Its better to be safe than sorry and hold it than to use it and screw up
You dont really play around coup that much no, it would mostly be to make sure youre using it in huge AoE pulls instead of BP whenever its up
I'd suggest to track it but not like front and center of your screen type thing
sectech should almost always be used in symbols, very uncommon to send a natty sectech. think of using sectech with symbols, not dance.
use 2 sectechs, dances, and symbols each flag, fitting as many sectechs + symbols + dances as you can outside of flag window. it normally comes out to flag window > resend dance and symbols at 30s > resend dance and symbols at 45s > send ONLY symbols at 1:05ish with sectech > flag window
don't think about danse macabre ever. iirc coup does give another danse stack, but it doesn't matter, you don't play around it or think about it.
coup counts as evisc so I'd be surprised if it grants danse unless its your first evisc in dance
Eye of Kezan update:
Just quick information because i got dm'd about this multiple times today.
The trinket implementation was updated in simulationcraft, it did incorrectly haste itself when it shouldn't and has some small bugs in the implementation. The trinket is still bis but now a lot closer to other trinkets and might not be the best option for mythic+, because its hard to keep the stacks high consistently.
I did re-run the !sheet trinket simulations while adding some more delve trinkets this morning, you can find the trinket simulation > Here <.
^ just making this temporary pin (don't mind me)
is this the pre or post nerf transmitter value in that sim
the transmitter value should be with the latest nerfs
Oh the Goon Squad Dream is back onnnnnnnnn
unless there was a nerf/hotfix today
whos out there dming fuu and being annoying, just ask your questions here 
I'm gonna hard reserve it now instead of Eye
damn
emphasis on hard
Is the afk before flag still a thing?
thx, cant wait to pug princess each week until blizzard decides to free me 
or in m+ as a pack is dying to preserve stacks for next pull so you aren't noodle damage
I am happy to answer questions also in dm's, the message was not ment to disencourage it just to mention that the question is frequently asked.
Ty for ur input friend
-# you misspelled Kezan
its the principle!
Is there a tier set bonus spreadsheet chart like there were tiers before?
!tea
Thistle tea use:
It is recommended to macro Thistle Tea with Shadow Dance like this:
/cast Shadow Dance
/cast Thistle Tea```
Would you put rotten back in sims. 
is it just me or CtG makes no fckin sound
You have to be out of melee range. Otherwise animation goes poof
The animation and effects on live only show up if you are out of range
so the charge happens
if you spam abilities it’ll cancel animation
its still gona hit i hope 😄
Good morning Subcord
Are the bis daggers from raid from an early or late boss?
man icyveints really use weird font
3rd boss
Rik Reverb
What a good name
Lol this raid better be good. So much hype
!wa
been hearing a lot of hype about bossfights
Raid releases march or is lfr already out
and if you can't get a myth dagger from raid the rookery one is ~84 dps diff at max level
!sheet
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
the most noticable (in a good way) feature of the new patch is more visible hitboxes of abiltiies
if you looked at some ptr testing stuff, you now actually see what to run out from on the ground
huge qol change
Yes please. Week 1 AotC, let's go
The trickster fazed anti-parry only applies to the rogue that applied it, correct? I keep seeing people say it makes it so no one gets parried but the way it reads doesn't imply that
Its for the entire raid yes, probably not intended to work that way
But thats how it works
its balanced bc no 100% uptime
huh interesting, good to know
just close
Couldve been fixed for 11.1, havent double checked
Oo good call
But for nerubar palace it absolutely worked
Didn't even think to check that on ptr
we are happy to give the benefits to everyone, unless blizz fixed it in the patch (which we can't test before its live)
we're raiding tonight so I can log it
and we've got 10+ melee so plenty of people to look at
isn't downtime till after midnight cet
It'll be down until 5pm my time
6 pm est
is this still right?
which yeah I think is midnight
because
afaik
transmitter in the sim after nerf?
I'm 2 hours ahead of that
would be midnight my time
yeah
yes
will m0 be weekly or daily reset?
its with the 5% nerf
m0 won't open before raid release afaik, but be on a daily reset once raid opens
someone linked this in a diff channel
thx guys
it is because there are not many trinkets to fit our 90 secound burst phase
basically there is transmitter and house of cards
and you will combine it with a more passive option
thats what i was saying, no?
nice to have it confirmed from you then 👍
M0 will be on a weekly reset
oh, so they move away from the daily reset introduced in 11.0?
but yeah I'll check if the anti-parry is still raid-wide tonight
nice, report back what you found
i am curios too, but i don't think it is a bug blizz is super aware of
Yeah if it still works, I'll prob switch to sub for the raid
it was a big topic in s1, but ignored ever since
I hope they convert it into a feature
nobody talks about it^^
so vers is more important than mastery this season? Should i treat it like last season where the ratio was like 80/10/10/5 or similar (vers, mas, crit, has)
since our on use does not have main stat on it, isnt it better for our passive trinket to have main stat and a chance of sec stat for example
both are about on par
It does not need to be a passive trinket, it can be active too but passive ones are more comfortable
!sheet
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
do you have a guestimation on how a BiS loadout percantages would look like? not familiar with 2 stats as high prio
we can macro house just to SB right?
I'm 100% switching my reserve to Zee's lol
The goon squad is just five copies of me
Yes, but you get champion level gear now
farmable/targetable champ track gear on a daily lockout might be a bit strong
for early gearing
basically mastery is a bit higher than vers, but both rly high
haste is almost not taken
bit higher is a stretch but at least it looks like a similar flow to s1
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
is that typical in between seasons? tww is my first xpac
!wa
- only "big" rotational change is to finish with on 7+ (from 5+) on trickster
- Trinkets become transmitter 2.0 (house or card) or transmitter 1.0 (the regular trinket) + passive/damage option
- Embellishments stay 2x iris on low budget slots
- Talents stay the same
- Stats stay Mayters >= Versa > Crit > Haste
I thought keys all go to +2
no the delve keys
don't they reset next week?
I had 36000 undercoins to spend 
not today
Isn't all currency today, like crests and stones and such
wowhead said vers > mast which is why i went here. got confused
I'm not sure
but thanks for breakdown!
I'll find out after work lol
do we really only finish on 7?
perfect maintenance downtime timing
Finish with BP*
im going to eat some spaghetti and then do some things
Unless they hit us with the extendo
Vs evis
give me a moment, ill change the order, good point btw.
then maybe NA servers are up
spaghetti sounds pretty nice
oh mb
Before ye olde extendo hits you in the nuts
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
I've got contingency nuts
lmao I stopped taking off work for releases
I think the last one I did was Legion, took a week off
I remember taking off work for WoD and the horde garrison spawning item was bugged so only 1 person could interact at a time so they had to auto-complete the quest for everyone
day well spent
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
was like a goblin telescope or something like that
I got a whole twitch chat riled up when I said I was missing my daughters piano recital for the 11.0.5 release which was delayed
People were TURNT
is ptr down:
Yus
I feel bad for your daughter.
I would too if she were real and I was actually doing that but alas, twas just a joke on the internet. She wasn't even a twinkle in her father's balls.
probably its like 5-6h before NA gets the patch
I think it's so omega bad that our tier will be broken for the whole duration of progression
Like 1.5% less dps
And then fixes in the next patch
its possible it gets fixed this week
!cb
- Why is the Cold Blood and Secret Technique macro not recommended anymore?
When you macro these two together you often end up using it outside of your shadow blades window rather than inside of it, and since Subtlety gets so many damage modifiers inside its cooldowns its actually more damage use it only in Shadow Blades
(yes, even if you end up losing casts of cold blood). Ideally you use it on your second Secret Technique as it will be buffed by more stacks of Flawless Form and have higher Flagellation stacks.
we don't know yet, its still more than a week
they were fixing major bugs within our class even hours after release of raid
they did yes
e.g. if you remember the outlaw bug people lost their mind last xpac
the same bug was fixed the raid tier before during the wfr
and only re-introduced because of issues on blizz site when putting the ptr live (which did not include a lot of stuff)
In the 2nd CD window, after pressing flag, should i do an evis and after that SD + SoD + ST etc or skip evis and directly go to CDs?
I highly doubt they will fix it. I'd rather be surprised
Knife looking really strong
ye
Might do some delves first week
especially because you can cloak it off
Oh wow I didn't know that
you ideally do delves every week because of vault
Is that in simc?
no
If the debuff is haste let it live anything else cloak
sims don't cloak the debuff
but you can if it gives you mastery or vers deficits during cooldowns
So it kinda undersims or?
would not cloak it off outside of cooldowns
kind of, but i would say in a healthy way
!sheet
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
there are good arguments why you probably want to not use your defensives for dps
True
true, plus another thing to track
but i did keep the information on wowhead, similar to season 1
Sorry didn't read wowhead after you reran the trinket sims
oh all fine
you don't need to, we can have these discussions in discord as well
its simialar to transmitter
!transmitter
The orb and circle from Treacherous Transmitter always spawn in the same spot. Relative to how your character is facing it spawns northeast/1:30 o'clock/frontright, this means you can know where it will spawn and react accordingly.
https://i.imgur.com/cTPN4Tz.png
^ where eleem made a nice bot command to help with the use
its only a few trinkets that have special transactions like this
had to use this bad boy all season due to not getting a myth track crystal
on sin
if you play sub
chances are high you will use transmitter for at least some weeks
in season 2
transmitter is the least bad feeling on sub compared to other specs/classes iv used it on
for some reason idm it on sub
Trinket section looks more balanced. Also I should sim myself it but what about champion track stuff. We just replace transmitter with hoc and not play double on use I assume
On dh it's fine as long as you don't have the 3 jumps
maybe cause sub just slams their cds
i mentioned it earlier, its fine to use double on use
but if you do so, you will use transmitter or cards with your cooldowns
and the other trinkets in between
so direct damage trinkets might be better than stat on use
or passive effects
Yeah that seems apart from the bee trinket a bit cooked
e.g. this seems to sim decently well
and is a direct damage trinket
as a 2nd trinket
Yeah they look good. Also effected by lingering I assume
Is that in sims?
but most others are just passive
Lingering buffing the output of such trinkets
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
lingering is only shadow sadly
was nimble flurry ever at a % damage transfer higher than 50?
so any trinket that says:
- Shadow, Plague or Cosmic damage
it was buffed in 11.1
Ok did you find apl changes or why are we simming now closer to 2.6?
im trying to remember if it was higher before, since i thought youd use bp on mroe than 7 targets
im looking at guide cause i forgot how trickster m+ works and i kinda have to for next season
eleem found a small optimization, so i put in the updated apl with it
nothing gameplay changing tho
What was it? Oh OK so same gameplay
I still think dungeon slice will be cooked with set.
Going with full first dance 10 stacks and cds into a new pack might be worth not pressing sth when a mob is low hp
first thing we need to do is wait
and see if we got some surprises with the patch
if things are more stable, could see if we find some more small optimizations
I played like that on beta mob is under 10% hp I just rupture if cds and high stacks.
The aoe burst is imo insane
Well BP got buffed by like 70% over season one
It's a gamble themed patch so fits perfectly 🤣
So even if nimble wasnt touched, the number of targets where you stop eviscerating moved by BP being tuned differently
yeah that makes full sense then
BP has a wider range then coup or?
what kind of battlegrounds are you playing
that people are this stacked
besides on eye of the storm
So might be worth using depending on gathering even using at lower target count.
Nimbles range is melee that's it right?
spell data doesn't say but I wanna say its 7-8 also
is the reason of not using sstorm with premedation to avoid copo overcap on multi target?
would have to double check
nimble probably has the same problem BF has
that its slightly lower range than intended
I know its not just melee range bc whenever I test wm flurry bug it hits further targets in org than that
they at least in patchnotes did say they fixed that for BF, but i don't think it was ever fixed for nimble
i can test during the 11.1 week probably
not much to do anyways
I can check it after work too
hey fuu i'm a little confused
just pull up a range estimator and go
on the fuu sheet, the race says orc is better, but ont he sim itself maghar is on top ?
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
boom roasted
btw i forget if nimble of your target or of yourself
Got em
orc comes with
Does maghar orc look better though? I’ve never made one
yourself
for some reason i play it like its from target all the time
human best race
maghar has a similar one
gg
I would need to test that again
but iirc the target spread from replicating works like this
Proud Horde member. I will never be ally scum
we come ready
yeah bc I thought you could kinda dance around and have replicating hit certain targets
based on where your toon is positioned
the only horde char i ever would play is undead
and specifically on rogue
will sub be better then assa ? im a bit worried about assa st

We will, without question, be more purple.
I have a couple nelf toons just for flipping
the coin?
im still mad theyre removing shadowy duel
damn guys hopefully they nerf the circlet ring
im in shambles
bc sometimes you just gotta do a frontflip
fuck that
fatebound sub confirmed.
the day they remove trickster is the day I die inside
cook deal fate for sub
Thats for .5 or .7 They said they wanted it to be good for the start of the tier
both look fine, but neither sims above what some other classes put on the table
They wont at start. Probly only on the x.5 patch
warrior nerfs first week of raid
why are we eviscerating before rupture in the opener exactly?
that sux, i wanna equip new gear
i can already taste their tears
grants slice and dice
via updated Cut to the Chase
ah right ty
cut the cheese talent
🧀
k ty . is there a vid that teach sub completely ? im a bit lost reading the rotation ^^
Our warrior already crying after 5% nerf lol
lol same
I tried recording a basic video guide last night and it ended up 30mins long lol
the season 1 videos are still perfectly fine, the rotation did not change.
Think you can search for Hachadino or EleemX on youtube.
else
!guides
we cold blood on 2nd sectech right? or is that change out of date
yea that one is still in
correct, 2nd in flag/blades
Is the reason we secret tech as first gcd on opener to make sure secret technique gets enough cdr reduction to be up as the 2nd cast on 2nd dance?
poggers
gets on cd, procs more unseen blades
My m+ grp has always been sub rogue arms war lol. We are happy this season.
so you coup faster to get mor flawless form stacks for 2nd sectech
Ja Ur Video already uploaded?
nope
we do that
Do we do that every 1min 30? Or just opener
Every 1:30
you're holding sectech for your flag window when flag's cd is low enough so it should be ready to send as first finisher in first dance
- Why is the Cold Blood and Secret Technique macro not recommended anymore?
When you macro these two together you often end up using it outside of your shadow blades window rather than inside of it, and since Subtlety gets so many damage modifiers inside its cooldowns its actually more damage use it only in Shadow Blades
(yes, even if you end up losing casts of cold blood). Ideally you use it on your second Secret Technique as it will be buffed by more stacks of Flawless Form and have higher Flagellation stacks.
W8 for tuning )) things will change rapidly
Did sone 12-13 keys as sub … Gotta say its a very nice Playstyle
Sub best spec in the game
most fun one for sure
Just curious, what is the dps loss that comes with macroing CB with Sectech? A few percent over a fight? Smaller? Thanks
0.6% iirc
Pretty small, comfort reigns
Hence the curiosity! Thank you
unless you're going for more optimized play having them macro'd is totally fine
@vale pine I might just be overcomplicating our cleave rotation but with the nimble change i basically just bp in our dance window for dance macrabe stacks and up to 7 targets im just hitting ss and eviscerate
you bp on 7+ targets
Outlaw is also fun when u in the „Flow“ But its missing burst .. sub feels Like 0,0 damage when no Dance is up that Kinda wild
under it you just evis
and strike during dance
and storm outside
there is not much min/max outside of spreading ruptures
and if your flawless form drops
you use backstab
yeah figured as much
kk cool
is there a minimum duration rupture needs to be on a target before it becomes worth to press over evisc?
rotten on 2nd proc getting eaten
and BP does have a shadow damage part if find weakness is up
@vale pine is nimble damage still bugged? did it go from 40% (or whatever the bugged amount was) to 60% now?
Is the dps loss for evis <30s before burst comparable? B2b ruptures just feels bad
not buggy
because of a bug
!bugs
Rogue Bug tracker: Spreadsheet | Github Tracker
neat
Not a thing anymore after set nerf
I'm afraid I have no idea. I don't think we're doing that anymore though?
Mystery solved!
the bug basically says that both rotten stacks will be consumed on a shuriken storm cast
so in order to play around the bug
you strike first
and storm second (both during shadow dance)
outside of dance you always storm
or well similar to before backstab for flawless
Last i checked it wasnt really worth backstabbing for flawless either anymore
Its like +0.1% or somerthing to do it
makes things simpler, nice
wait so if nimble flurry drops in keys you wouldnt backstab to get it again? im surprised
How are you getting flawless without backstabbing though?
yeah true
But like, its up for the vast majority of the time
the backstab is already something that does not happen much
So you’d BP in that scenario
You could ye, but like, it doesnt really matter
lol burst window is all that matters
It happens so infrequently that its whatever
I see
we cooldown gamers
Is there any reason to even track flawless form then?
coup regens pretty quickly and sectech gives two stacks iirc
i'll sit on it and send a BP or rupture if my dance window is coming up shortly otherwise i'm sending it
heh sit on it 😄
basically the damage outside of cooldowns is rly low
and we use spells at a lower pacing
there is no reason to stab instead of storm so kinda staying at 3 if possible is kinda cool to have
so next dance is sec tech strike coup
big dick dmg
well that lessens the cognitive load just storm and bp until dance window
spread ruptures
lol I was doing all kind of shenanigans. I had a weak aura that indicated number count of enemy mobs so it would display an icon to bp or eviscerate
I was actually curious what subs APM is and its like top 33% of specs it looks like. according to simulationcraft we're at 60 APM. Assa is 50 and Combat is top with 86 lol
The thing about sub is that we do practically nothing outside cds
Idk what it’s like next season I didn’t do any PTR gaming. But even this season I really didn’t BP much. Every pack had a prio target
And tons of off-gcd buttons in cooldowns
And played all my keys with an UH DK
just play DS a BP for prio target
At 2 target boss (i.e council) we dont change anything?
!sheet
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
The only thing you change from pure ST at 2, 3, 4,5 or 6 targets is that we build with shuriken storm outside of shadow dance
instead of backstab
Shuriken at 2 target. I see
where exactly are you guys pressing transmitter in the opener? I have it macrod to flag right now but if I need to go chase the orb sometimes I feel like the timing gets thrown off
Bp at 7 in s.d . And outside of dance spread rupture and whatever
Rupture>bp tho. ? No?
Well if you need to refresh it ye
Yaya. For refresh purpose
DS is certainly more tolerable as sub than SIN. But my group does not need more mass aoe. It needed prio. I didn’t mind. I prefer playing that role in keys, always have.
Sry i was kinda vague
Disagree, i definitely dislike it more as sub
The mark is less problematic for sure
But its got some other sus stuff
if u have coup up outside of dance, do we send BP/ruptures just to get it in dance?
still
nah send coup
macro'd to flag, orb is the most annoying but the other two options (jump/platform) line up beautifully right before sec tech
With the recent buff to trickster. Is it safe to say trickster is ahead even in s.t? Or close enough
trickster st, like pin says
yeah figured that the was the best way
You would definitely know more than me. I was on mage most of this season. I don’t like it on either to be fair. But loathed it on SIN haha
Theres some very cursed aoe tech as deathstalker
Where you actively try to avoid proccing darkest night
Because DN eviscerate does significantly less damage than BP on aoe
And its bugged so whenever the DN buff is up you dont get the mark damage, so you cant just ignore it
Oh sweet! So no more playing around coup? If SoD/SD were back in 25sec I’d just BP/rupture to preserve coup so I could hit it in SD window
!guide
significantly more ethical 
Dont need to anymore no
so its just storm bp regardless of target count?
Just wastes too many unseen blades
Waaaay easier
I mean its like 4 globals or something
!wa
Flawless lasts for most of the downtime anyway
But yes its technically better to bp when flawless isnt up
But the downtime is so short and infrequent that it practically doesnt matter
makes sense
@hazy breach any data about thousands cuts buff?
Rppm went from 4 to 4.5
So no more evisc on AoE (unless form is already up and you don’t have to fish for it).
Just storm + BP like in the early DF days
I love it. Outside CD we can basically do whatever we want, just press buttons lmao
Yeah outside cds I’ll be sounding

Sounding out words to increase your vocabulary I'm going to assume. Anything else would be a sin.
@twilit phoenix titan main hero leave Cayde be.
Where did they confirm no m0 today?
Blizz EU CS twitter account
I think we’re just questing and capping valorstones this week
u missed the 5 hour long training dummy sessions
Ty haptics
why is there a deathstalkers mark icon
can you still farm wax globs for stones
is the alc trinket good for sub
Think so
not that its very efficient but u can
Ye
do we have a compendium of cloak able and feint-able abilities for the raid yet?
aweful stuff
thatd be sick
and for dungeons too
was there even one for last tier
someone said that everyone was to cba to do it
haha
basically trial and error in the raid and dungeons but if someone already documented it not gonna reinvent the wheel
that just tells you if you will survive 1 shots based on key level and vers
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vQQCkBEkOadsvO4sTphB1RwzC6Z_3kq00IFaBrCk5Eagz2Jeoox7D7Rk3XwXMINbh4lUg9Vr-3RgoB2/pubhtml# im just going through the abilities and seeing if they are aoe or not my buddies have this for spell reflect and block
our tc's are great in here as well
It wasnt a spreadsheet but i wrote down pretty much all of the relevant feint/evasion/cloakable things down in the m+ section of the icy veins guid
Practically nobody cared about it 
lol i care deeply
the last convo on this matter involved the need for money to do it
iirc
i would have
!fuu
Rogue Spreadsheet - Light Version / Dark Version
the big things are probably obvious but its the minor cheesy things that im interested in
shadowstepping stuff on queen for example
the pulls
Cant do much of that until people have really played the raid
People would have to actually play the class. 
Fair fair
Give it another 2 weeks itll be back to 5 people in here
If you made a hunter guide as good as the sub rogue guide on YT you’d have so many more views

It’d be lonely otherwise
trickster or deathstalker for the dungeons in s2 m+?
Sounds like a good time to me.
We're totally getting a poison toggle in 11.2
right, I did click the pins but said there was nothign there, now there is all of a sudden. Lol.
My money is on you dreaming of that feature in 12.0 still
Probably.
Would be epic
But I commend you keeping your spirits up 😄
Doggo picts as well. There are 2 in this one.
Never going to give up until we have it and then I'll find something else to be dumb about.
At least you weren't as delusional as some others who really thought we'd get away with not getting nerfed before the patch hit 
Lol 30% dmg increase no copium here
we’re not even close to truly pumping
but idk. Eleem has 
I’ll hold judgment until start
When they destroy transmitter
Sub is going to be real good this tier, imo. Not meta, but very strong as it always is. Probably better in keys than S1.
I truly have no clue about relative class performance right now
That's my gut feeling and guess, anyway
I dont think we'll do top pure ST damage no
Dagger specs are bottom 30% of “st sims”
I only hear arms is pumping. And that mage is giga in keys.
But i think the burst we are doing is useful anyway
No doubt, just lack of ST is worrysome
Like we'll be helpful to the raid because the way we do damage, not because the damage we do is huge
always felt like the rogue niche
There's multiple amp phases this tier, right?
Were st sims ever really that close to actual raid performance?
Niche, in what way?
And a whole lot of cleave iirc, so that's nice.
One 2 min one, first boss. 
so kinda whatever
Ye
Doesn't sin sim even worse than sub rn?
He(?) shows nicely on the blanket
Haven't checked that yet
Yes. They at least have 2 execute phases on bosses that matter

So they sim worse but have execute?
worse is relative
Of course
We’re both dumpster
Team rogue
2.56 and 2.52?
Honestly might be alt arms or mage time
By our powers combined, we're 5m
Just not sure which flavor to pick
Are other melee that far ahead?
Its really just warrior
I think Warrior is up around 2.9?
Big outlier
Can't imagine them not getting clapped tbh
My fury warrior, 4 ilvl lower sims higher ST than my rogue with a queen aoe talent build
Warriors always on that high to get kicked in the balls last minute
that 5% wasnt nearly enough
just gonna make them feel worse when they kick em again
Aye
the shit part is they flattened everything on fury and now capstones are useless
Arms as well, but arms is juiced execute and 2T as well
If they leave warrior as is, rwf will become quite hilarious
Which means after week 2, they're going to get gutted
All three mage specs are good
I would be fine with that if they didnt also bring us down a notch while warrior is 800k above us 
Both dk specs good
I wanna play fire/frost
enhance still doing enhance things
I really enjoyed big gs frost in dragonflight
We got nerfed, assa got bleed aoe and outlaw a 6% buff. 
Realz is a real one
That patch post is hilarious. I think the intro paragraph is longer than all the rogue notes
He’s on Havoc arc
buff our whole kit 70%, call us black powder
that sounds racist
I'm still coping they'll do another round of balance changes
Absolutely will imo
(but don't buff black powder anymore)
Will we get any? Who knows.
Not sure what data they'd base that on but
But I am betting two whole gold on a big tuning pass on the 4th
yeah they'll throw out half-cooked balance changes after the race
Hope dies last
we’re going to get a buff that offsets the destruction of transmitter. So net zero gain
and a BP buff
And then probably another tuning pass on the 2/3rd week of the season
Transmitter is what keeps us alive rn haha
because deathstalker isn’t played.
good, let it die
or they can buff it like precise cuts for outlaw so it looks cool but we don't take it
We’re not seeing anything until midnight
nah maybe 11.1.5 we get something about changes SoonTm
just dangle a carrot until 12.0
"We just remembered yall exist so we're having some kindergarteners tell us their favorite ninja moves and you'll get those"
Really a massive missed opportunity if we dont get cool stuff in midnight
!sims
Simulations:
Bloodmallet: https://bloodmallet.com/index.html
I'm half agreeing with that. I still think there's a chance but.. With the way it's all gone? 11.1 would've been a good rework point but, nope.
So we'll have to see.
Does anyone have a Internal Weakaura for Fazed being procced by backstab and shadowstrike ?
Just dangling the string, no carrot, and it looks like a noose.
and they help us slip it on
It’s not live yet
Yep, plus a few other things
Isn't US up?
They definitely know we exist considering the rs/blades fixes
Nope not for like 2.5 hours
Damn.
unless they extend it
nA beta test maybe starts in 2.5 hours
I can't believe someone went on the internet and lied to me that it was up.
Who would do such a thing

they couldn't be bothered to tell anyone about them though
Its not possible to track it
So no unfortunately
The resets from Thousand Cuts cannot be tracked
Not documenting it is kinda crazy ngl seems even passive aggressive 
Yeah, especially with the quantity of bugs they fixed too
if it was one or two, sure whatever
Like ugh fine we fixed ur shit
but its like 9
two of which were quite large
They don't post a lot of bug fixes, though. Like, it makes sense they wouldn't but it would'v ebeen nice if they did
Hey mates, do we prep stuff before going into new pulls? Like Dumping CPs because we almost Always Start with Strike?
people literally quit the spec over RS bug
they feel shame to have that many unfixed bugs, so they didnt document them and pretend they never existed
so throwing that in the notes would be big
It would, yep
Sure just pop a bp or snd before stealthing and going into a new pull
I think part of it is ego part of it is time. I’m a little convinced one of the devs doesn’t want to actually admit mistakes have impacted anything. Just a vibe with our lack of notes.
It doesnt matter that much, byt why not
But I don't think there's malice behind it. Or anything, really. It's just how they push bug fixes.
lil extra cdr and then don't waste premed buff
Yeah ive kinda felt the same
i can believe that
some people really struggle with seeing mistakes listed
like I try to help fuu with some of the guide proofing. I’ll dm it most of the time, unless it’s really good for a laugh.
I really appreciate the clear communication
Valid 
The shadow parts of rupture from replicating shadows was considered as a "finisher" for shadowcraft
It also invites the "why don't you fix xyz?!?!?"
I can at least give him one stupid American that can try to translate what intent was in text
So you could get refunds mid gcds
I'd also say that, for the vast majority of players, they won't even know it's an issue.
In some cases, sure
Duh. Look at sub’s playrate. 
oh my god thats what that was, ive barely played this spec for a week and hated when i was getting a refund without any reason and messing me up
I think the vast majority of sub players are in this conversation lmao
Good news: it's hopefully fixed!
lmao, yeah
coup one is just a slight delay tho, rupture would be mid builder
im going to master sub by days end and will be the one asnwering the questions
The last tick of coup is 1s after the initial hit so its about the same but ye
I wonder if coup will change with the removal of the charge. I didn’t notice it on ptr
Oh yeah, rupture one was quite tilting a lot of the time
but the rupture is painfully obvious
Ye it rules
RS bug made you feel like you were playing wrong such an annoying bug
Some very needed change / fixes so, small positives.
I think this week I farm transmitter toy
It was super tilting being in dance and getting that refund only for it to be 5cp and not 7
yea true, but it def happens way less, u have to get a sht prock just at the right time right?
That's a good idea, Scath
I'm a big surprised they didn't take on Mark bug since they tackled some of our biggest bugs
but it might just be too spaghetti atm
Ye if you go to 7 sht mid coup
Arent s1 items now locked at the item level they were prior to season launch?
They are not working on mark bug because they are working on hero talent reworks 
Peak of shit development is to create an coup bug, make people suffer for entire season and than fix it so people are happy “we don’t get changes but at least coupe charge gone and RS bug fixed after 2 years”
@shell willow I think so, I think you can only catalyze them
bc you can't get marks to upgrade them
The charge wasn't a bug, though.
Many thanks or they could just remove RS like dust
Idk. Peak was not finishing the rework.
downhill since then
Random win
But then need a replacement omg too much work
Now coasting
Stuck with my heroic 626 transmitter ggs
us mid-10.2 ptr
I'd personally rather just look at the positives 'cos there's enough negative stuff. We can't change it either, so. Let's just blast'n stab
I only have a normal one. 

