#assassination
1 messages · Page 4823 of 1
Sins key weak point right now is less control and is a wet noodle
Outlaw is another story, but it does need better burst damage in pvp to be fair
havoc in particular has always just felt... bland to me, after getting over the novelty of the mobility
rogue pvp without elusiveness 
i think id be lying if i said that i care about DH very much
DH basically needs a rework IMO. The complete class was designed with the artefact in mind instead of it being added later as with basically every other spec. DH has been limping along ever since the removal. These trees provide the perfect opportunity for that.
only change i want for DH is to make immo aura unable to be used out of combat. im sick of DHs prepulling and dying when the timer hits 1

yeah this is pretty much what i was getting at
Immo aura CC breaks 
smells good
@gusty mirage you want some drama juice?
DH was designed during the peak of borrowed power, pruning and spec > class identity
all of which we've gone away from
https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/wow/t/magerogue-needs-meaningful-nerfs/1269967
think this thread is funny
Mage/Rogue needs to be seriously looked at. Mage- Dragon’s Breath and Ring of Frost. One of these needs to go in Dragonflight. But until then these need to share DR. There isnt enough counterplay to this. Iceblock heal needs to be brought more in line with pure DPS class heals. 30% should be it. This is a class that conjures food and doesn’t n...
pvper crying on an alt
never change wow forums, never change
is it a lot?
Yeah this is just someone that’s 1200CR on main
Means nothing in reality
67 people out of at least a million isn't really that many
i just find these threads amusing
mf said burst meta while referring to a new expansion 💀
A lot of the player base don’t like rogue mage/RMP and yet-who is terrorizing the ladder right now? Demo/DK
though i kind of do agree about subter
you can't gut subterfuge without gutting assassination's ability to do dungeons
DF fixes that
subter isn't needed
so a more broken version of subterfuge fixes this guy's complaint?
another talent makes you garrote for a few seconds out of stealth
well that doesn't fix it does it
it just cakes in subterfuge into the assassination tree

they are separate talents
so you gut subterfuge
There’s no silence on the assa tree talent iirc?
and the sin rogue just takes that one in the DF tree
how does that fix anything
which sub rogue is playing subterfuge above 1600 CR?
and how much did they pay for their carry?
There’s a few glads that play it oxi
people who actually care about pvp dont play wow. change my mind.
A lot of the ones complaining on forums do not play at a high level
They’re too busy complaining about things
I have a hard time pinning down if palumor is really smart or he's a pvp brain
he's a pvp brain
theyre not mutually exclusive
nice guy fwiw
yeah that's what throws me off
like he's nice and everything
which is already a red flag
my cat is meowing at me but i dont understand her
Don’t you need a pvp brain to pvp at a high level 
you can't be smart and nice
not really
oxi is right here bro
what are you saying
after a certain amount of reps it's just a mindless script
Just understand her
shut your whore mouth
@ me

just look at foreverguy, he's both 
lorentz is smart and nice
How much brain power does it take to play a frost dk in pvp?
FOR NOTHING?
Lorentz is 1 in a billion
Unless you play rogue mirrors
An international treasure
play unholy, slappy hands double dips into mastery
win the game
that's because lok's smart enough to build a buffer between RH and himself
takes it in smol doses
very based, seli
dadsen is smart and nice
otp is derogatory ... specialist is better 
outlaw is a cult
its more like a disease
glad to see you cured
well technically its a virus
you can cure a disease or poison
outlaw is more like... herpes. it comes and goes, sometimes it flares up, sometimes its barely noticeable. but you can never get rid of it. and you only get it by doing weird things with people who already got it.
stop it
wasn't seli like the first dude to kill sire as sin?
i played sin
He was
He wasn’t a DEVOUT though
I legit don’t think you could kill many bosses in CN with 9.0 sin on prog
ye
and i beat our WLs in p3 damage so
worth
Where there’s a will, there’s a way, pal
i mean
was there?
playing assa in early CN prog was like eating soup with a fork. sure, you can do it, but you do it by yourself because when other people are around and see you do it, they wanna punch you in the face - and theyd be right.
pre-9.0.5 assassination?
is it worth crafting my second legendary with haste and mastery instead of hast and crit as long as my simmulation is saying that mastery is the best stat for me at this moment ? im at 273 ilvl
I mean if you have gold to blow, sure
otherwise the ~10-30 dps difference probably isn't worth the gold investment
whens the zoomer episode
oxi!

hi best friend
how r u!
I'm a-okay, how are you?
p good, glad ur ok

yeah this sucks
needed maybe a week
next one is guy + koji
but koji cancels out guy's zoomer
YUGE
wym
early 20s- not 20
Oh you’re talking skip + dekai + agreon + idk man name another zoomer
yeah dude
flower skip dekai agreon deeny (?)
tf
yeah bro for sure
WHAT
we want to hear you idiots talking about stuff
Yeah deeny is like mid 20s isn’t he?
damn
deeny is like 27 i think
Pause
mb
uhhhh
deeny is late 20's yeh
get warcieft? varas?
Silence 30s
Varas is a banger
hop in the trees and get me some first buddy



I'll make them the way you like them
fried with butter & brown sugar and cinnamon
on strapon?
minalape

I ain’t ever had knee pain in my life
Stop projecting
My acl is just
Uh
Wonky 🙂
wait until I show up to the wedding and I take my 9 iron to the back of your knees
I am going to avoid pantheon forever
Weird thing to call your member, man
guild can't force me, THEY CAN'T
God damn
Going back to the discussions we had with Realz regarding Shiv being 2 charges, i don't recall someone talking about the fact that if you use TTB as last talent row you will definately use the 2 charges due to dmg amplificaiton and not want to keep one charge to disenrage...
ok missed it then
I tried 😦
yeah for sure
send him 20 on venmo
20 what?
like if it made shiv always give you a poison bomb or something
it makes your short cooldown do damage
reals?
now we're talking
fuck no, send a real currency
none of the shitcoins (real, euro, lira)
bro what if ttb just made your envenoms always pop poison bomb in shiv
bro what if you pressed ttb, and a dagger dropped from the sky
and just insta killed whatever you were targeting
what if death from above
./target [@player] ttb
what if you pressed ttb, the talent disapear and gets changed to something more appealing?
what if ttb is an amp on 0 that you press every 25s
it took us 2 expacs to get rid of hidden blades, I wouldn't hold my breath

How to use TTB:
Move your tree around and pick a real talent 
like i dunno i dont think passives are bad but they should at least be interesting
ah yeah that.... i nearly doomed us to a 8 mins cd ICarnage so i dont talk aoe assa anymore with realz
me scared
still a red name
other passives in the tree are kinda cool
don't insult our new friend
poor daps
was DK in there?
ya
he's always got crazy ideas up in that noggin of his
realz being a savage will never get old
blue or red, i like both gameplay and despise the yellow one
you can ban me from wow?
oh
no I don't have that power
just pull a mavv
and delete yourself from the internet
im just a fan of shit you notice without looking at the meters
spreading misinformation
or shit with flavor
he just said something that I went haha irl and assimilated as a 30 sec card
but that's me being an ape
gargleon
I think it's spelled galakrond
ill take it gladly
Damn Minal
sounds better than ttb on my bars
I didn’t know you were about all this when I recruited you

a little crumb of content
BOY I GOT SOME NEWS
Tylerr doesn’t even know of minalbas addiction
Not yet, we got talents to burn !
Yikes
Exsang the actual ability is fine
I have news as well
Because you only do it once

Minalbuilder
Mage in our guild only plays arcane so I’m only playing envenom mutilate rogue
just like bob the builder
rank 1 arcane!!!!!
You know he used to actually be cracked
Rank 1 of 3? 

Ever since I swapped keyboards I can't do damage 
haven't adapted to this shit format 
At least you didn’t die to every mechanic
100% too much?
yes
But I’m also swapping keyboards this weekend
but hey I wiped us on a frame perfect fuckup!
Haven’t had a keyboard that I haven’t had to literally punch to work in years 
@balmy condor lmfao
Rygelon was a bit rough
I'll take your raidbot monkey spot

can't sim APL either
might want to start by shipping keyboards to the right address

He can only do 60% of the apl 
I got tons of shipment issue stories
me and the national postal service company are enemies
I'm not scared of the Brazilian government
I already told you I'd adopt you
call biden and give me a visa

if unity breaks for me 1 more time im gonna 1g my monitor
!cache
Cache of Acquired Treasures usage:
Axe is always the strongest weapon.
Note: The Weapon rotates every 12 seconds in the order Sword -> Axe -> Wand
I M P O S S I B L E
MUST HAVE CP
mut env mut instead of mut snd mut
that's potent
A fatty 3cp envenom to warm the soul
Haven't played rogue much this expac, aside from sylv dagger, what should we be looking to buy in season 4?
I did a quick scroll but couldn't find anything
trinket probably
or an outlaw weapon
good trinkets could be fusion amplifier titanic ocular gland or dreadfire vessel
wait for sims unless they already exist
Not worth dual wielding the dagger? Or is it unique?
yeah you dual wield the dagger on sub and sin
but you can buy 3 items
so
gonna need to pick up either a trinket or an outlaw weapon which i think is veinripper
Perfect!
I wasn't sure if the rygelon dagger would be worth also if you couldn't get multiple price from EON
yeah you should be running double eon if possible
unless you could get like a 6-7 ilvl upgrade eon is bis for sin
unlocking the rygelon dagger transmog is tempting...
the damn thing has never dropped for me, not in normal, not in hc, not in mythic, not in vault.
in fact, not a single dagger that i needed dropped for me in raid
weapon aquisition for rogues is a mess
anyone got a possible ST build with the new talents? havent played assa in a long while so having a hard time theorycrafting one
check pins
guess i was better than i thought
raid build isnt exactly for pure st its more like what you would go on most raid fights that have an add every once in a while or a couple adds or whatever
but its a nice general build
yeah i see, i didnt spec crimson into my st build, but i guess you might take crimson on full ST.
crimson is mostly for the assumption that adds could be present but its definitely possible with tuning etc that we could see it in st again too
i think the m+ is a bit wierd you dont take nightstalker
30% increased dmg on the burst looks juicy
well, we couldve made 10 more trees for any situation, really
true
this is like the most likely thing that you could plug and play based on what the tree looks like atm
the trees that we put into the pins or suggested in some videos/talks, are really just a baseline to give people a better idea of some of the more basic synergies and possibilities
there are so many possible trees
whats your idea of rotation inside dance? just spam fok/crimson(after inital carnage etc)
best case is that its well balanced and can play multiple builds and do similar damage
(my er no seal fate build, amen!)
did
you get rc
resounding clarity
the leggo
!
work with me folyr
i got some curiosity
havent made a tree
m+
Ok
If Shiv cooldown gets reduced by Restless Crew maybe a TTB build would work!
Just go to sleep
No gotta apply for a volunteering thing and then probably watch better call saul
you better call emergency cause you so stoopid
yeah varas
uh
its hard to make a good build with both dance and er
for sin
have to drop either deadly precision or virulent poisons
1 point in it
you have to drop
🤨
no
huh
sub thingy
thats sucky
ye
and outlaw reduces its cd, right? cause cringe game
thats getting changed
sub is supposed to be the only spec with a shitload of dance uptime
according to designer man
yeah
i want to be able to not take shiv in m+ tbf

but the current tree makes it mandatory cause dogshit aoe talent positioning
thats what im saying
i think not having shiv for bosses would suck
i think what the talent tree will do is make it so the difference in our ST between m+ and raid be big
bcs there's so many aoe nodes
and yea, you can just not take some
but thats 
i want to do big overall
this is the likely one
so many patches of last on dps meters
yea, the build in case there's another season with destro and survival to carry the whole group
Kinda weird how top left and bottom right is the aoe parts
think thats to force you to take shiv talents actually
like
very intentionaly
intentionally
its a core button on the spec
they probably want us to have it for all content
The more complicated the spec, the worse it is for me
i used to watch movies during sylvanas prog, cant do that anymore with 4pc since i actually have to play the game :(((((
i do find MA and improved garrote one after the other a little contradictory still
true
i honestly wouldnt mind those 2 as a choice node
yea babe take this garrote spam after stealth and also this crit you wont be able to use ;3
it only makes sense if you talent shadow dance
yep
but not every build will be shadow dance
spam realz with this
surely if you annoy him enough he will change it
i literally didnt even think about that until today tho
I used to get yelled at cuz I vanished with vendetta and the adds in p1 were killing padding melees
is whispyr awake
😎
ok gym time
@balmy condor what do you think about MA and improved garrote(current subterfuge) being right by each other
hf
Gym into pushing
or you can make the 2 a choice node and throw something else in MA's spot
my guess is that its there to force you to take shiv in aoe builds
but idk
Could make it green tempest and poison instead idk
you wont play flying daggers for m+ build
why wouldnt you
cause its shit?
Fok does big dam
Poison bomb and double poisons better imo

did a utility build
is that why we never played poisoned katar in m+?
I mean this patch
theres almost no chance in hell that you wouldnt be taking double poisons for an m+ build
They buffed fok
Nah in big aoe it does decent dmg
define "decent"
Fok is cp and poison application more than own dmg
whats the percentage were talking about here
Like 2nd or 3rd on my dmg breakdown
those are weird percent
i mean a ballpark would be helpful
10%, 20? 30?
id be surprised if its more than 20
Like 15 without katar
dont understand why you want to shit on me for just fucking around and throwing something together man
im not making actual bis builds
I hate when math disproves my opinion
if you scroll up like 40 messages i made varas a dance er build
where did i shit on you?
i thought it was implied but if you didnt you didnt
im sure that people here expect you to make the best build, and if you make a meme build you say that
i shit on the talent. i also just said theres no way youll play flying daggers.
why would they expect anything like that from me
I'm just another nobody
not just from you, from everyone. And since im not a good assa theorycrafter, i would listen when seli says something is shiet
tbf
i literally said
"utility build"
as in
the we do no damage
there for stuns
build
but yes, flying daggers is wrong
my bad
understandable, id say that coutns as a meme haha
the problem with the "current" m+ build is that you have exactly 0 talentpoints you can allocate elsewhere
as "flex" points
dont worry when they add another trait in the middle to remove double capstone we'll have plenty
I'll play it in fortified dos and halls. Ok?
cause like
in the class tree you need like
sealfate, dance
that leaves little room for alternative routes
in the spec tree you need ct/dtb/carnage
fortified return to dragon soul and vault of deathwing
you cant play dtb if you go flying daggers
and even if fok somehow has its damage increased by 100%
dtb is still a better damage gain due to lethal dose
Lethal dose will be nerfed bozo
even if it gets nerfed by 50% its still better value
I hate math
ofc you can still play a worse talent if you want
but flying daggers provides nothing meaningful besides damage on smth that will end up being 10-15% of our damage (and it shouldnt ever be more than that)
where in the tree is lethal dose?
Right of deathmark
im so tired i looked in my tree and realised it does not look like this
like a choice node. something like
Choose:
- Removes CT Initial damage. Improves its damage over time
- Lowers DoT damage by 50%. Increases initial damage by 100%
we dont know (as far as im aware)
basically, all the benefits that come with choosing a spec
we dont know if we keep those or not
im sad that outlaw looses 15% movementspeed
i.e. we dont know if mfd will be 30sec cd or 60 for assa
cause rn assa has a modifier that reduces mfd cd by 30sec
does sub not have that?
will we keep that? we dont know yet. its part of the aura-buff spell ID, same as the increase to max energy etc.
theres a bunch of others, including the aura% for pvp and pve
I also don't like having mfd as a must pick if you want cheat death
theyre all part of the same spell ID, and we can assume that they stay
Which you want
imma go ahead and say assa will still have all that
ye probably
Realz was talking about swapping MFD and CB on the general tree
which would make more sense for sub
and for assa in fairness, since u can smooth out openers and energy pooling etc.
So what choice nodes would you guys like to see? Personally i think many would appreciate mfd being a choice.
Also find it kinda weird theres no bleed st capstone, could maybe have a choice on bottom right for a st/cleave talent
well, as I mentioned, MFD not being above Cheat potentially would make it more optional if u dont wanna drop down to Seal Fate
Still the same problem, only sf isnt as strong as dance now
Forced into mfd playstyle because you want sf isnt ideal either
I like mfd personally, but hear a lot of ppl not liking it
I thought this version of Sinister calling would be pretty fun as a choice node.
Obviously not with multistrike, but someway to advance bleeds (for sub / outlaw it can be whenever Weaponmaster procs) and for assa it could be whenever muti crits with both or something
But yeah, things like MfD and CB should probably become choice nodes
Also gonna be a lot of buttons from the looks of it, having a passive choice would be perfect imo
with some other spells
thats why i like the wod sinister 
i honestly think there are gonna be way too many buttons
Its also a problem with tea, such a minor effect but an extra button to manage makes it even worse
I like the idea of it, but cds gives so much energy already you dont need it during them
shadow dance, cb, mfd, tea
i believe it was said they will look for a way to buff tea
yeah, in the pins u can see
Ye its getting looked at
Also think nodes that buff mut should also work for ambush
Or a seperate synergy for ambush, like advance bleeds etc
we got sublaw, now there is subsin, asslaw time about to start 
He did mention making garrote better didnt he?
Having so much of outlaw improve ss ps and ambush and then still have garrote worth is gonna be a challenge
mentions of iron wire buff/cb on garrote/taking imp garrote out the class tree and baking in the sin talent
yeah making garrote pressable for outlaw seems difficult
And i dont want it to just be so strong that you just keep it up for the bleed despite no synergy
00:58] Realz: This is something I've been thinking about, but you're one of the first to bring it up. If Garrote is going to remain an option to click in the main tree, I'm likely to find at least 1 or 2 talents (each) for Outlaw and Sub to select that give it some extra flavor and power to occasionally be worth using. Need to find the right amount of 'oomph' so that it's a cool deviation but not a huge intrusion to normal rotations
well the mention was for it to have some flavour but i have no idea what that could be
I wonder if it would be better to have rupture as the available bleed, not as much conflict with the ol tree at least
Just cto and dispatcher
rupture there would be even worse for outlaw yeah
Worse?
yeah, atleast garrote silence has a use here and there. rupture you'd never press (unless added to cto/dispatcher) and its finisher bloat
i liked the discussion of 2 shiv charges, 1 shiv where garrote is and garrote where improved garotte is, imp garrote rolled into the sin talent
true garrote would need the silence on the spec tree
but yeah it should only be for the utility for outlaw imo
when you need to assist getting a caster mob into a pull
outlaw has a lot of builders+spenders... i'm fairly certain rupture is completely off the table
2 damage spenders isnt a lot
hey guys newbie here what tree looks the mos tfull for df?
Full? As in finished?
yeah not catching that question
i think he means useful mh
priest generic is bonkus imo
Rogue in general looks great, and would be fun even in current state
Not 100% sure on sub tho
yeah sub is just too wide
assa looks poggers even if it deals dog dam i'll play that
what is better for you at the moment just an outlook. outlaw or assassi? jsut in terms of talent outlook
Honestly they are both really good trees that look very fun while allowing multiple builds
I wouldnt be able to pick a favourite without trying them out
Assassin is uncapped tho, which would be very nice if there are a lot of huge pulls
Being capped when half the dungeon gets pulled just feels bad
i have to disagree
there is nothing wrong with being caped
it an issue of lacking damage
let say you deal 3 times WL damage to 5 target
it would be fun
you would be blastin
you wouldn't care
there was a really good conversation yesterday about this topic
Its much less likely having a class be so much stronger at cleave
Well I’ll tell you right now; target cap is irrelevant if your damage is tuned like shit
look at ww monk this expac
It’s a meme in the outlaw community perpetuated by some top mythic plusers who have no idea how numbers actually work and thought that target cap was why outlaw was mediocre
And people saw them say it and ran with it
Uncapping outlaw in its current state would be obscenely broken
Every class works on 5t, huge difference appears when a capped class competes vs an uncapped in huge target counts
Well they fixed that with tuning didn’t they?
Outlaw cranks now
Uncapping wasn’t going to magically make outlaw do monk damage
It was tuned like shit
what if current state outlaw gets uncapped
It’d get nerfed
Currently? Probably not still
Ww’s schtick is shit ST godlike aoe
Outlaw has fantastic ST
And great 5T cleave
so just the way outlaw is designed does not allow it to be gigabroken even if uncapped
it just fits a different niche
Yeah outlaw isn’t going to oopsie daisy delete a pack like ww monk or survival or destro
I understand ty
Thing is gathering a big pull for the group to pop off is fun, and some classes just cant join in
That’s just the remnant of a shit idea they introduced in SL. They uncapped sin and sub, what did it do for aoe?
If it wasn’t for the xymox trinket sub’s aoe would be mediocre at best
Im fine with classes having different strengths, but its just a whole part of the game you get excluded from
I haven't played before SL but it looks like almost all of SL dungeons are designed for large pulls
was that the case with bfa and legion
Legion less so, because they never designed them around keystones
But the strat in m+ was always pull as big as possible and kill them before they kill you
They tried limiting that this expac and everyone hated it
and that is good, for me it means there are difference between classes. what i would like to see is more diversion like burst/sutain/ramp ST/5T/8T/uncapped, ofc how like m+ works it wont happen cuz from my own experience you have either a team or burst into delete pack into huge aoe int wow amazing pug player (kappa)
Blizzard are masters of implementing shit no one asks for ever
Yeah, it would be fine if they fixed the outliers IMO. I think outlaw’s in a great spot right now. It’s just overshadowed by 3 obscenely strong m+ classes
so if they introduce a different type of a dungeons next expac that favours cleave over massive AOE wouldn't that remove the issue of classes being excluded due to their dmg profile
top, street, spires even mist are already dg like that
If rogue did 15% more on 5t than wl but wl did 15% more on 12t
so true. my most fun key was with a comp of fmage surv assa rdudu veng tank it played so well
top and streets I agree but ppl still are able to stack multiple packs on mists and spires that require massive aoe input
I just want shrouded suffocation back 
its quite a chonky buff to bf dmg in lower targets
Which is super necessary considering they’re hell bent on keeping outlaw capped
yeah, what I mean is its already something they are designing dg around, they want different dmg profile to be good in different dgs
well i think its close to mandatory in m+ to go as far as precise cuts atm
oh yeah I get that 100%
Like you want to keep it 5T? Fine. But you better make sure that it’s not overshadowed by anyone else in that target count
Because at that point it’s not a niche
It’s just bad design
i'd just accept its 8T in dragonflight though
it will always be overshadowed when cds classes pop their cds, I dont think thats so much of an issue
did i open the wrong channel?
Yes
conductor we have a problem
it's target cap time
This is also a very good point
poison bomb should be fun with aoe rupture
probably 0% chance
yeah. 50 mob pull, apply 50 ruptures, get 50 poisonbombs, do key 1 level lower cause you crash the server
it should be a carnage spell not 5-8 ruptures
So are we going to have Poison bomb and say crimson tempest or blade flurry in dragon flught?
fairly certain it will be ruptures... otherwise you get to stack additional ruptures after and get even more from lethal dose
also scent of blood before it makes it need to be rupture or its so upsetting
Its ruptures, but not seperate casts for bomb i think
true i dont know why i was thinking it was on tick and not on cp spend
feral have this has a talent. i am pretty sure it will work the same
it wouldn't make any sense to have it cast X ruptures at one global
yeah but their procs are off rip ticks (apex) and not from the cp spent.. i was getting the styles mixed. i agree it will only count as 5cp once etc
also CT has an instant dam component and dot application just in carnage's case the dam component is 0
Ferals works different, it doesnt copy rip casts on extra targets
Thats what i call copy
Not an existing but next cast
Either way, safe to assume they wont allow busted interactions
that is not copy for me copy is like if i press a button on the target and that has a rupture that lasts 3 sec it will be 3 sec of ruptures
Like multi bomb or cb apply to all ruptures
this is copy
this
also don't know if anybody asked for clarification on carnage it says AND so can you spread garrote and rupture in 2 globals?
Yeah can do both on aoe
Actual quick good aoe damage on sin rogue
5cp - carnage rupture - mfd ct - garrote
vanis garrote or SD garrote
i was thinking that some degen aoe build
with carnage rup and garote while in dance and spam fok
with 30% crit damage amp
and SD amp
and find weaknes amp
DS: Carnage Vanish (NS), Cold Blood, Rupture Garrote Mut CT
also you have 30 % crit while SD
Feel like Carnage will have to be tuned to not spread all Cold Blood/NS bleeds
It said replicate
Also cold blood may not even work on bleeds
It’s at most 1/3 of the CD with uptime
so foks should have baseline 10+3+30+5 = 48% base crit
On mobile, every talent is additive not multiplied?
Believe realz said it’d be difficult to make it work on bleeds as it’d be busted to hit an improved bleed+CB+NS+SD+Deathmark
good question from experience i would say MA and poision katar is additive
lethality is on your char
If it were me id let cb only work on the specific bleed you cast, so carnage cb is main target only
And deathmark extra bleed doesnt cb either
Pretty sure that’s how it will have to be tuned
(If you can CB bleeds at all)
Ofc
Could NS them tho ofc
Not sure what he’ll have it work on. If it even stays where it is on tree
Yep
no dude no
Won’t be allowed to buff the bleed I’d assume
Dunno about everyone else but I’d like to have good base ability damage tuning so we’re not fully dependent on all these amps
Nah. Love amps
get amps -> go bonkus -> get nerfed -> lose amp -> die
it's very familiar to me...
bfa sub 
alpha will be broken on a lot of levels
so if alpha comes out, you will see people come from all places
do we expect to get alfa into rog TC-s hand?
probably not early
i am hoping
streamers spread the idea that alpha starts today
so first invite wave might be today
for tcs, its hard to predict who gets in
guy, whispyr and me will get in at a later state due to wowhead
(likely)
how do you approach giving feedback to devs? i think i wanna do it, but never done that expect when beta was live i did in game
So streamers like asmon/toweliee get in the first wave I suppose to show some type of gameplay mostly more casual stuff
and also dunno if i wanna await for alfa to see.
yep i have seen that
it is about attention
isnt there usually an alpha forum where you can make posts about stuff
basically tcs do have a high impact on the community
but thats not seen as reach because unlike on twitter/youtube/twitch
you can't measure it
hence there is not a big incentive to consider them for alpha
as they at least for the marketing team are "useless"
but alpha shouldn't be for marketing (i know idealist)
lol
alpha is for testing
and feedback
i did talk about it last alpha a bit more in detail
And marketing 
the problem with streamers is that they do mostly engage with the system that will get attention
so for 10.0 it will be talent trees
the new flying stuff
and professions
for 9.0 it was torghast
you had basically 3 weeks of constant torghast content
and then a complete fallout of alpha content
feedback about gameplay was also leaning a lot towards what was OP
not what played good
makes sense
in the same sense that you will get a lot of influx of people joing the discord servers
to learn the new spec if they are op
on alpha
yeah
also, i don't want to try to make a statement that streamers are better/worse at anything
its usually just that e.g. if you have people that like me worked for hundreds, potentially by no thousands of hours on optimizing gameplay for rogue, you get a different perspective
i remember joining a popular streamer who did test rogue in twitch chat
on alpha, and he seemed super confident that rogue is op
because black powder (back then called shadow vault) did negate fall damage
the 0.5 sec global lock was not precived as bad at all
and it is hard, if you are a generalized content creator, you possibly don't have the time to dive that much into each class
and in my opinion you shouldn't need to. i get that ppl don't like streamers getting alpha, but for me i always regarded as that they only see that streamers get the alpha access, but in fairness they are usually the ppl that you can see bc they stream it. so it's like a circle of comformation bias
yes
i think this is where you should invite people to join you
there are experts, why not utialize it
I would not understand if people like you whispyr or seli dont get prio on alpha & similar persons for other classes.
The point of alpha is getting feedback
Bêta is for hyping shit up & where you want big streamer name
the first wave of alpha invites etc. are typically going out to content creators and other people that will drive a lot of traffic and hype to the game
It depends what they want feedback on. Big TCers like Fuu and Whispyr will do numbers testing regardless of access to alpha/beta. Do they want feedback on gameplay feel, quests, dungeon design etc? Or other motives entirely
but yeah, it sucked that in SL beta none of us got alpha, and few of us got beta before they removed most of the testable stuff from the servers
You could also assume that a content creator more closely resembles the largest mass of players...that's to say anywhere in the skill level between 10% and 90%.
It's safe to assume that most other folks you're talking about are in the top 10% if not the top 1%.
That's not to say that their feedback isn't super valuable - and helps the community a ton...
Just that, no matter what, if they create a playable game for the 10-90% of people, those top 10% (1%) will do their thing either way.
But yeah i do agree with what you are saying
I dunno, that sounded good before I typed it out
they are not providing feedback though
they are playing alpha for a few days cause it gets lots of viewers, and then they move on
most of the "big streamers" that got alpha in SL were not regular wow players at all, they just got paid to hype up the alpha and game
Can we possibly assume that for example thé feedback from seli on assa m+ is more valuable than streamer#45 ?
Thats how you make the hype also
I'm not sure that's true Kah
Streamer Just go through stuff for content
i.e. a bunch of highrated m+ players got alpha pretty early. they played it for a few days, then they went back to retail and pushed highkeys again. not exactly high value feedback
I'm not sure how you'd 'quantify' the value of one's feedback versus another honestly. I'd like to assume that good feedback from a 30% parser is just as valuable as good feedback from a 95% parser, honestly.
They dont have a real critical minds et when looking at things or system
Most of thel are Just happy to have access
Yeah - they would tend to feedback more on "feel" i agree
exactly. once the content runs out, they have no vested interest in continuing to play. so people like sloot spammed torghast on basically every class and really tried to play it as much as they could, while others logged onto their main, checked out some quests and talents, and then forget about alpha/beta until raid testing
But we all feel the game as we're playing
Generally, streamers will get content from alpha by offering that as an option. “WoW DF Alpha - Questing in Zone 1” is much more engaging and the streamer will get content played, feedback provided and then it allows people who didn’t get alpha a chance to see, hype and offer their own feedback
bruh how much revenue do you think selis feedback generates
honestly how much
Wdlle their vestes intérêt would be to not have a shit extension/class design for the next 2 years....
But that does not drive viewership...
Easy billi
cause i guarantee its less than people watching max fuck around in the new hub city for 2 hours
and thats all that blizzard cares about
Blizzard can have the big names and the likes of seli
Their are thé one handling the invites
Its not X or Y
but if they invite seli, theyre skipping on someone else with potentially bigger viewership
Can be And
potentially someone in a market that they are trying to tap
this isnt throwing shade at seli at all
but they will only go after people who make them the most money
What makes them money is keeping their playerbase
If Seli did a hot tub stream of alpha, twitch would break
ROI is now return on invite rather than investment
that makes them money is keeping the portion of the playerbase that spends the most money
its a very small portion of the playerbase that keeps the revenue flowing
as long as they keep those guys hooked theyre golden
True then they should Just sell mount and tmog and stop reworking talents or systems on expansion.
of course they cant let the game completely die but they will do w.e they can to squeeze the rest
have you seen how many mounts theyve sold?
every time a new one comes out some whale is standing in oribos for 12 hours a day using it
For higher margin
they didnt bother fixing the covenant system until 9.1.5 and even then it wasnt fixed
because it doesnt generate them a single fucking penny
Chris Wilson, the POE main man just did a very good interview with Josh Strife Hayes about all this kind of stuff (not specifically about alpha/betas) but game dev and retention, etc
And what cause the change on covenant ?
people get hyped when a new expansion releases and they get hyped at the end cause a new one is coming
all they have to do is make sure people come back to the game near the end so that they overlap with the new expansion release
which is why all the QOL changes come out near the end of the expansions life cycle
I guess the low à mount of subs has played a part in that decision
theyve had a low amount of subs for a while
all that matters is that they have the right people subscribing
Yeah but that is not all otherwise they would not spe d si much internal ressources for systems reworks.
And as i said blizzard is fixing their invites and nothing stops them to invite whoever the big target streamer is and People who are most likely to give them constructive feedback on key elements of the expansion.
youre assuming that people who get thousands of viewers actually spend the time to provide meaningful feedback after theyre done playing the alpha after a few days.
few people that get alpha/beta actually write multiple pages worth of feedback in documents they pass forward, or on the official forums, or using the bug report feature on the alpha
but they dont spend a lot of money on system reworks
everything they have done is stuff that has been suggested by the community since alpha
they just drip feed it to us
remember conduit energy?
Depends what you call lots.
But they still allocate ressources for them
Talent reworking in DF would not be essentiel for the game to keep running
it is a feature of the new expansion
they need something to draw people in
something for the streamers to advertise
you are being too naïve
Nah dont worry about that working in finance for years with the high executives who make these kind of decisions made me lose that behaviour long time ago.
Your reasoning is based on the fact that their is an arbitrary limit on alpha invites. Fixing shit up is an investment for the future, especially after such à huge revamp
its not a feature
and calling wow "keeping the game running" just makes you look like an idiot because they literally hired an entire devteam for wow alone 










