#assassination

1 messages · Page 4708 of 1

balmy condor
#

and echoing blades from bfa

#

and the conduit from shadowlands

#

and we might be able to do half the aoe of destro

limber swallow
#

this is quite the rube goldberg machine you've assembled.

bleak sky
#

half? huff more copium

timid cloud
#

PAIN

#

||Hidden Blades FOK in ST was the darkest tech of all.||

kindred oriole
#

I think we may be able to bait Devs into buffing assassination if you rename the channel # Fire Mage

limber swallow
signal pier
#

Lowkey make FoK off gcd and cost no energy and then we can probably do like one fourth of destro

#

With hidden blades

kindred oriole
#

What I have to say about hidden blades:

signal pier
#

Its hidden so its greyed out

#

It has "hidden" potential that guides are unable to see

#

At this point just buff CT

#

Id take anything

kindred oriole
#

So one question I had: why would shuriken storm generate 1CP per target, but FoK generates 1CP overall if you do not crit?

timid cloud
#

Because class design.

bleak sky
timid cloud
#

EvErY SpeC HAsS To BE UnuQie

storm onyx
#

Need to check the history of Shuriken Storm actually

#

If it was like that at 1st iteration or was it buffed when Bliz decided to bring Sub up at some point

signal pier
#

I just wonder what has made them to buff FoK, what kind of next level sims or tests are they performing to reach the conclusion that the FoK buff can be called "tuning"

balmy condor
#

they don't

kindred oriole
#

^^this

signal pier
#

I am trying to put myself in their shoes, like why would their brain work like this then?

balmy condor
#

the way they have buffed shit over the years leaves the only conclusion that they might glance at a warcraftlogs chart and hit a dummy for 5 minutes, blindfold themselves, spin until they're dizzy and then throw a dart at a board

bleak sky
signal pier
#

That too

#

Those changes are not tuning

signal pier
#

They are meaningless and we would probably feel better without them since now that we know they consider these changes "tuning" I am even more hopeless than before

balmy condor
#

if they wanted to talk about numbers and tuning, they could reach out and talk to theorycrafters and actual people running numbers, guide writers, hell, I would even take just reaching out to top players even though they say some incredibly dumb shit sometimes

#

but they don't

signal pier
#

^

balmy condor
#

we were reached out to by scarizard in order to talk about tier set tuning and bonuses

#

and we're eternally grateful for that

bleak sky
#

and look at outlaw now starege

balmy condor
#

but he's one man

#

doing 9 tier sets

signal pier
#

They need to reach you about design before expansion

balmy condor
#

and he's not a class designer

signal pier
#

Yep

#

It just feels like they don't play the same game

balmy condor
#

and in the legion days sephuz had backchannels to theorycrafters

#

which was helpful sometimes

marble hemlock
#

*a lot of times

balmy condor
#

but those are the only two times the rogue theorycrafting community has gotten actual direct contact

signal pier
#

Pretty sure rwf guilds have connections to blizz, might be a somewhat reliable way to communicate or at least throw something at them

balmy condor
#

the best we do now is just cry about stuff in wowhead posts, submit endless bug reports in game, cry on twitter, pray someone lurks in discord, and just hope

marble hemlock
#

But the biggest boon was that he was actually a main rogue. No non rogue is ever gonna be able to use the compiled or individual feedback we give unless they actually have a decent understanding of what we're actually talking about

balmy condor
#

I mean frankly from what I hear, they just need more class devs

kindred oriole
#

No but you know what's dumb? They spend time and probably money trying to figure out damage profiles by themselves, when the community is developing better and more reliable resources FOR FREE. That's how dumb they are.

balmy condor
#

they had 1 dev for 9 specs for tier sets

#

I don't really understand why they don't have at least 1 dev just assigned to each class

bleak sky
#

SO MUCH MORE

balmy condor
marble hemlock
#

And he got assigned to most of these, didn't he? From what i understood it wasn't a "i wanna design these" situation for all of those 9

balmy condor
#

yeah

#

he was assigned

signal pier
#

They probably think its a waste of money considering we ate still playing their game

kindred oriole
#

They have ALL this data. And they could get it worked on FOR FREE.

marble hemlock
#

It's not that simple

kindred oriole
#

I would look at their fucking data.

bleak sky
#

ok

balmy condor
bleak sky
#

What would you do, NaEj?

marble hemlock
#

There isn't a whole lot of competent programmers or developers with work experience who also happen to play the game that much

signal pier
#

Class*

bleak sky
#

How would you fix sin's M+ problem without bufffing the ever living shit out of sin in ST

marble hemlock
#

And working on the game typically kills the desire to also play it

marble hemlock
marble hemlock
#

Buff rupture, nerf mutilate. Done.

kindred oriole
bleak sky
kindred oriole
#

Ha ha

marble hemlock
#

One you use in AOE and st, one you only use in st.

signal pier
kindred oriole
#

I was a fire mage for 15 years, I'm allowed these jokes 😛

marble hemlock
#

So any st gained from buffing rupture you offset by nerfing st-only abilities

kindred oriole
#

^^this literally took 5 seconds to fix

marble hemlock
#

Assa has abilities you only use in st, AOE, or both. That gives you enough knobs to tune it where you want it to be

signal pier
#

But can you really call manually spreading rupture an AoE?

#

Considering our current kit

kindred oriole
marble hemlock
#

Most classes operate like this, still. But they're not tuning in this way. Which is weird.

#

Instead they're mostly using aura buffs

signal pier
#

Spriest worked like that, but had misery and that new sl aoe

marble hemlock
#

Which are terrible

signal pier
#

What other classes work like this

slow marsh
#

How come I leave for like 5 hours and come back to the same topic. I'm gonna start malding

marble hemlock
#

Almost every spec has abilities that are only used in st, some that are only used in aoe, and some that are used in both

signal pier
marble hemlock
#

That is more than enough tools to buff a class by 10% in aoe, realize it deals 3% more st damage now aswell, and since you dont want that, you nerf the st abilities accordingly so its a +/- 0dps change on st

signal pier
#

Boomy, spriest, aff lock

marble hemlock
#

I hate to break your illusion

#

But none of those 3 specs are DoT specs

#

Not anymore

signal pier
#

So what dot specs are left

marble hemlock
#

Assa

#

There

#

Thats all of them

balmy condor
# bleak sky How would you fix sin's M+ problem without bufffing the ever living shit out of ...

HmmHmmHmm I mean....
buff fok more
buff pk
buff CT
buff hidden blades to not be a stupid design
make ruptures give you a stacking buff for the amount of bleeds out
make CT do bonus damage to poisoned targets
add a poison that does aoe
rework venom rush to allow envenom to cleave targets
rework venom rush to make fok apply poisons more often
make fok give 2 cp or even 3cp baseline
fok now advances bleeds by 1 tick on crit
make CT deal increased damage per target

slow marsh
#

I'm gonna just be the broken record about it cuz it's easy. Just buff fok +100% damage and we can work with it at least

marble hemlock
#

Yeah

#

Lets buff builders more

signal pier
#

You say "all classes work like this" you have only 1 dot class so yeah your statement is true

marble hemlock
#

Cause that wasnt the problem

#

For the last 3 expansions

#

Oh wait it was

balmy condor
#

there's literally thousands of ways

slow marsh
#

It's not a final solution but they can't fix our issues in a hotfix apparently

marble hemlock
#

They can

#

Theyre just not doing it

slow marsh
#

I mean I agree they can but they won't

marble hemlock
#

Blizzard can fix a lot of issues with a hotfix, if they wanted to

#

But they dont

slow marsh
#

I was malding about it earlier

marble hemlock
#

Unless you play mage, ofc

marble hemlock
#

I mean

signal pier
#

They cant anymore, they would break the tradition of not changing skills mid patch

marble hemlock
#

Countless of people have posted suggestions and given feedback in a myriad of ways for years

signal pier
#

They cant change tooltip lines mid patch, best case is 9.2.5

#

They wont change*

marble hemlock
#

Im surprised we got "class tuning" at all

#

Fully expected there to be none until 10.0

#

Since we didnt really have any in SoD

#

Idk

slow marsh
signal pier
#

Id rather not have half assed tuning, and keep inhaling hopium that it might happen

marble hemlock
#

It's the same stupid discussion all the time. Blizzard has all the tools available, and can get all the help needed, to make long-lasting and good changes to individual classes to make them feel interesting and balance them better. They just don't.

balmy condor
#

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1qGsZILbtH5OKH-s8ZpNcFIJTW0hOffjy7UrP4KaNj4w/edit

^ literally free ideas take them all some of them are radical as fuck but at least they're new

#

sin hasn't changed in like

#

10 years

#

please

#

anything

#

a crumb of change

marble hemlock
#

Whispyr selfpromoting his list

#

For the 500th time

#

Still not banned

balmy condor
#

I will

#

until things change

#

fuck it

signal pier
#

Yo let me read this

balmy condor
#

I'll make a second one

#

Idc

slow marsh
#

Do it

balmy condor
#

that ones a year and a half old

marble hemlock
#

We should compile all of ours

#

And mail it to Ion

#

Every week

balmy condor
#

I can rework sin 15 times

slow marsh
#

We should collab

#

The official RH sin rework proposal

storm onyx
#

there was a change of dmg profiles being swapped with Sub, but play style didnt change yea

signal pier
#

Can u pin this pepelaugh

marble hemlock
#

No

balmy condor
#

no

signal pier
#

Okay

#

Thanks for your quick response

marble hemlock
#

No

balmy condor
#

seli disagrees with half my takes as well

marble hemlock
#

Yeah

#

But it's mostly just

slow marsh
#

Same but at least it's something

signal pier
#

Selia do you have your own list?

balmy condor
#

I'm sure every sin community figure + has their own list of changes

marble hemlock
#

Not in a format like that, no

#

I did have some beta feedback shit somewhere

#

Wrote a big feedback piece on IV etc.

#

Wrote a bunch of shit about Valor too

#

But at the end of the day, it's not for lack of ideas that no changes are happening.

balmy condor
#

one that basically every theorycrafter in the last 6 years has agreed on has been swap venomous wounds to be poison tick on bleed target not bleed tick on poison target

slow marsh
#

Ye

#

Or just remove it

marble hemlock
#

No

balmy condor
#

I don't think that's the solution

marble hemlock
#

VW is one of the best tools they have

balmy condor
#

venomous wounds is cool

marble hemlock
#

To balance the class

balmy condor
#

slow single target to fast aoe

#

and feeling the change

#

is very sick

#

best part of sin

marble hemlock
#

Any ability that scales better in AoE, to an almost unlimited extent, is a great thing to have

#

We need more of that, not less

#

VW not dealing damage anymore is one of the bigger tragedies that has befallen the spec

slow marsh
#

I mean I was gonna say just remove VW / rework it to be a stacking haste buff instead of direct energy gain but

marble hemlock
#

God no

#

Stop it with the Haste shit

#

Haste for classes with static GCD is the least interesting stat imaginable

#

Well thats not true, versatility exists

#

But still

signal pier
#

Vers is an awful excuse of we dont have anything else for u

marble hemlock
#

Frankly, I think the static GCD for Rogues/Ferals needs to go

balmy condor
#

okay well all stats are really boring

#

that's a problem game wide

#

lets not kid ourselves

#

that's a bigger problem

signal pier
#

Crit interactions are better than vers

#

Mastery is more interesting than vers

marble hemlock
#

The fact were still sitting at 1 sec GCD while most classes start with 1.5sec, but typically go below 1sec during BL/CDs, is a major balancing issue that cannot be remedied

slow marsh
#

False

signal pier
#

Vers is just more agility in disguise

marble hemlock
#

Crit dependancy for Assa needs to go

slow marsh
#

Dependency true

marble hemlock
#

There is nothing interesting about crit-dependacies in any spec

slow marsh
#

Seal fate is iconic tho

marble hemlock
#

Its also shit

balmy condor
#

haste makes your spec go faster and increases your casts which is all your damage
crit is a % damage buff to all abilities, and there's some interactions with some specs
vers is a % damage buff to all abilities, and it reduces damage taken
mastery is % damage buff to some abilities

#

they all do the same shit

slow marsh
#

I mean true but you can make it better

balmy condor
#

just different flavors

signal pier
balmy condor
#

you can have the lemon flavored stat or the lime flavored stat

marble hemlock
#

You cannot have one without the other

balmy condor
#

it's still all citrus

signal pier
#

You can have mild bonuses

#

Not 5% dps increase

marble hemlock
#

Then theyre not meaningful enough to build an identity around

signal pier
#

Yep

marble hemlock
#

Firemage didnt work with crit interactions until they basically gave them abilities that had 100% crit

#

Didn't work well for warriors either

#

Doesnt work well for Assa

signal pier
#

Cant argue with that, yeah

marble hemlock
#

Didnt work well for Frost either

#

Or holypaladin

slow marsh
#

Stats would be better if things interacted with them more

marble hemlock
#

All the "get x on crit" specs were basically unplayable until you hit certain levels of crit

slow marsh
#

There's not any real meaningful choice in stats anymore which is the real issue imo

marble hemlock
#

There never was

#

There isnt, in any game

#

Name me one game with meaningful choices when it comes to stat allocations?

bleak sky
#

ragnarok online starege

signal pier
#

Putting that one point in crit, that you might deal more dmg in lost ark pvp

kindred oriole
#

Maybe you guys will hate me, but among all things, the most annoying is the Alacrity talent.

#

What
a
boring
talent.

cobalt pelican
#

stat make number go up to make you do more damage than person with less stat

slow marsh
#

League of Legends old rune system

cobalt pelican
#

thats the only reason they exist

slow marsh
#

When you take 1 crit rune for 1% crit to win 1v1s

signal pier
#

Trueee

marble hemlock
#

The problem with stats is that theyre basically just an illusion of choice. You just play whatever turns out to be best for whatever scenario, and figuring that out is really easy in any game.

signal pier
#

Game changer for lvl 1 fights

slow marsh
#

9.1 frost shard build where you needed certain crit before it was viable

marble hemlock
#

More games recently have just opted to remove stats entirely and instead focus on skill-based design. The only games where stats typically matter, are the ones with rulesets running in the background that decide over whether or not you will succeed in dealing damage or avoiding a blow

slow marsh
#

I mean true because things don't interact with stats any more. Like things aren't enabled because you have x this stat or that stat

#

Skill based designs where everyone is on even playing fields is dull and boring

cobalt pelican
#

lol

marble hemlock
#

Depends entirely on the way the combat is set up

slow marsh
#

True

marble hemlock
#

But in a game like WoW, yes, that's true

#

A game with barely any skillshots and namelocked combat

#

You cant make meaningful skill-design

signal pier
#

I mean dh

#

Is kinda cool

#

His blade dancr

#

Or whatever

marble hemlock
#

But yeah anyway, time to sleep

signal pier
#

Gn

kindred oriole
#

Who cares about stats though.

#

I mean whatever, lets have stats in the game, remove them, rework them 5 times, it's not gameplay.

#

Give me meaningful gameplay choices.

marble hemlock
#

Assa has those. On AoE.

#

They just dont matter next to the class pressing the same button 10times in a row and doing 5times your DPS.

bleak sky
slow marsh
#

It's a skill based ability

kindred oriole
#

I guess you can play Subterfuge or Premeditation if you feel wild.

marble hemlock
#

You have choice in every GCD you press

versed cobalt
#

NF viable in m+ Srry to break this riveting convo

marble hemlock
#

Whether you wanna spend your resources on more prio damage or more AoE

kindred oriole
#

No ok you didn't get what I was saying.

versed cobalt
#

Simple Y or N will suffice

marble hemlock
#

Theres no meaningful choices on a meta-level like talents, covenants, legendaries etc.

#

Those will always have 1 best choice

kindred oriole
#

I meant, give me options of different setups.

marble hemlock
#

Unless you bring back gearswapping, there will be no meaningful gameplay choices related to gearing, for example

slow marsh
bleak sky
versed cobalt
#

Does the sepsis add any boom boom in AOE?

#

Oh ok

#

And I guess sub dumpsters sin 😦

slow marsh
#

Ofc

versed cobalt
#

5 cp Insta

#

Feels bad

slow marsh
#

2 buttons

versed cobalt
#

Yeah 😦

#

Honestly

#

Nameplates

#

Are my biggest enemy

#

Large trash packs

#

Shits bouncing everywhere

#

Can’t click or mouse over a damn thing

#

Camera angle all fucked up

slow marsh
#

Then just press shs powder problem solved grats you're playing the big aoe meta spec gg wp no re

kindred oriole
storm onyx
#

Sub/Assa cps generation/spending for aoe is just day/night

versed cobalt
#

Yeah 😦

marble hemlock
#

Theyll always be locked

#

I dont think theres any class, besides healers and tanks, that have meaningful choice

slow marsh
#

Blizz doesn't tune often enough or accurately enough to not have that be the case

versed cobalt
#

I mean I get that sub is strong for AOE in M+ but then atleast make sun pump just as hard in ST

marble hemlock
#

Imo talents just shouldnt have dps options at all, and should only allow you to choose between differetn kinds of utility/mobility/survivability

versed cobalt
#

Sin* like give it a defining m+ niche

bleak sky
#

you don't really care for a ST only class in M+ though

versed cobalt
#

I misspoke

bleak sky
#

it's useless 80% of the dungeon

marble hemlock
#

The only other alternative is to have talent-rows that all alter one specific spell in different ways, akin to "skilltrees" for abilities

slow marsh
#

It does it just doesn't matter when you can press 2 buttons to do aoe and still have good st

kindred oriole
marble hemlock
#

I.e. you could have one talnet row dedicated to rupture and make it behave differently based on talent, and usable differnetly

versed cobalt
#

Ice blades said it better

#

That’s what I was trying to say lol

marble hemlock
#

But thats a lot of work

slow marsh
#

It is

marble hemlock
#

Cause youd have to do it for every talent row for every spec in the game

#

I do like skilltrees for abilities though

#

Last epoch is really cool because of that

versed cobalt
#

Honestly at this point

marble hemlock
#

One of the main features I enjoy the most about it

versed cobalt
#

I’d throw the towel and wait for 10.0

slow marsh
#

It would mean they'd have to have more than 2 people working 40 hours a week sorting through graphs to buff fok by 30%

versed cobalt
#

Sub will get nerfed

slow marsh
#

No it won't

versed cobalt
#

Sin or outlaw will get buffed

slow marsh
#

It shouldn't

kindred oriole
#

I doubt that

versed cobalt
#

I feel like they don’t keep rogues specs meta for more than 1 tier

slow marsh
#

Sub is annoying from our perspective but it's still rogue

marble hemlock
#

Sub will get another rework, assa will stay the same, theyll remove another RTB buff. Oh and we will have an announcement about pickpocketing things from mobs that allows us to make feint act in different ways, theyll nerf feint, and then forget about the pickpocket stuff. There, thats 10.0 rogue for you.

versed cobalt
#

Fire mage fury warrior and holy pally are the only metas they maintain tier after tier

#

I’m sure they’ll make some comment about returning to the Fantasy of being hidden in the shadows and also hidden on the meters

slow marsh
#

Hidden from guilds

kindred oriole
tidal gorge
#

10.0: You can pickpocket bosses. This gives you an item you can right click to distract the boss for 5 seconds at any point of the fight

versed cobalt
#

Bruh read that back to yourself

#

“A full three weeks”

kindred oriole
#

Yeah 😛

versed cobalt
#

Outlaw been out here waiting in bikini bottom for 2 years now

kindred oriole
#

I was mostly trying sarcasm, apparently I failed badly.

versed cobalt
#

Oh I see

#

Well said then

kindred oriole
#

Imagine if they have to play Frost...

#

FOr one full tier?

versed cobalt
#

Honestly would love to see an absolute meta change next patch

slow marsh
#

God forbid mages have to play arcane for a fight

versed cobalt
#

Arcane, Sin Rogue, Arms Warrior

slow marsh
#

Arms war is meta wut

versed cobalt
#

I mean

#

Relative to fury

slow marsh
#

Warrior is almost never bad either

#

Relative to fury or not

kindred oriole
#

Arcane mage felt great at the end of BfA. Then they gave them 4 completely dumb legendary. That was the end of it.

storm onyx
#

Some root of the problem is linked to when they decided to swap Assasin/Sub
niche I think

versed cobalt
#

Arcane still feels good in high keys

#

And it’s a fun off spec

kindred oriole
#

Look.

versed cobalt
#

Can 3 button after a long day of carpal tunnel rupture

versed cobalt
#

Sub has no niche atm

#

It pumps AoE and ST

slow marsh
#

Sub has all the niches

storm onyx
#

Long ago, Sub was the bleed spec, Assain was the fast hard finisher

versed cobalt
#

sin also has no niche

#

In that it does mediocre AoE and relatively inoffensive St

#

But it’s not an ST god in M+ by any means

slow marsh
#

Long ago sub wasn't the bleed spec it was the PvP spec

versed cobalt
#

Now In raid thi

#

Sin put in that work boi

kindred oriole
#

Sin is super fun I think. By far the most fun spec to play. It's fun to play in keys. Just unrewarding AF.

versed cobalt
#

@kindred oriole you have a nameplates add on or something you use to spread ruptures?

slow marsh
#

Now imagine playing outlaw

versed cobalt
#

I’m serious

storm onyx
#

Yea pvp too, but dots was its area

tidal gorge
#

My wrists glare angrily in my direction after keys 😄

willow eagle
#

What made assa so good in season 1 m+?

#

Of bfa

versed cobalt
#

Like I lose so much downtime mousing or clocking over to another target

kindred oriole
#

You are out there, you are like "YES I NAILED THIS". -> 9k dps

versed cobalt
#

In large trash

versed cobalt
#

Pls share ur wisdom w me

#

I’m going to bed

tidal gorge
#

Part of why our aoe feels bad is we have primarily tunnel cooldowns, and tab target dot aoe damage, so using them together just doesn't feel good. I wish there was some way to combine those things like most other classes can

kindred oriole
versed cobalt
#

I will take this information and let it marinate

#

Like I use plater

#

Let’s say gambit right

#

Giant trash pull

#

How TF are u effectively garroting or rupturing

kindred oriole
#

AH

versed cobalt
#

It’s near impossible to tab or swap targets w the nameplates going everywhere

kindred oriole
#

Well no one likes my setup I think.

#

But I track with weakauras.

versed cobalt
#

Or even like spires

#

Where some mobs are like 1 meter out of range

slow marsh
versed cobalt
#

And then u waste empowered garrote

kindred oriole
#

To know 1) if the current target has a rupture, and 2) how many ruptures I have out.

versed cobalt
#

Yeah it’s mainly that I can track that info fine

#

It’s the actual execution

bleak sky
#

just tab target

#

idk

versed cobalt
#

Like in my mind I know ok swap and rupture

kindred oriole
#

Yeah I tab target a lot.

versed cobalt
#

Fair

kindred oriole
#

Yeah that's what you are doing wrong Holy

#

You swap and rupture.

#

You need to rupture and swap

versed cobalt
#

Huh?

kindred oriole
#

Rupture, then swap and build CP on your next target.

versed cobalt
#

I see

bleak sky
versed cobalt
#

I guess positioning could also better

kindred oriole
#

He asked I do it.

#

That's how I do it.

bleak sky
#

yeah but it's not >wrong<

versed cobalt
#

I’m always like just outside of melee range for some of the mobs lol

#

Or like keep dancing away

bleak sky
#

just spread bleeds, kill prio, keep ct up, be energy saturated

versed cobalt
#

Cause I have jumpy fingers

#

And like to move side to side

#

Feels unnatural to stand still

kindred oriole
#

It's more like my mindset is, once a target has rupture, then it doesn't matter for 24 seconds unless it's priority.

#

I never move from side to side, but again I guess it legit doesn't matter.

versed cobalt
#

Fair

#

Sin for raid only lads

#

Ggs

kindred oriole
#

LOL

#

Really they should just swap things around. Let us Shadowstrike 5 targets for free and give them 40% dmg on bleeds or something.

bleak sky
#

...why

kindred oriole
#

It's called a joke.

bleak sky
kindred oriole
#

_>

signal pier
#

Ngl the sub 4 set can fit neatly with assa

#

Due to cp gen

#

U can just spread rupture faster

thin trout
bleak sun
#

With the buff of fok will echoing blade be the go to talents m+ ?

limber lion
#

No

scenic osprey
#

why do ppl dont play sin in MDI compare to sub

#

i think sin has better ultility in keys

thin trout
#

why dont poeple do double deny them sentences

bleak sky
hexed frost
bleak sun
#

Iron wire is stonk for ur tank too but it doesnt appeared on the meter for mitigation

bleak sky
#

it's not that big of a deal

#

it's just nice to have

rocky ruin
#

+guide

#

!guide

lunar otter
#

im guessin the fok buff wont do much ? 😦

balmy condor
#

1% overall in m+

lunar otter
#

ye lol

balmy condor
#

INSANE

#

MASSIVE HUGE OMEGA BUFF

lunar otter
#

LOOK OUT

#

FOK ME

balmy condor
#

17% behind sub in 6 target

#

ONLY 17

timid cloud
#

Merely a flesh wound.

wicked mist
#

Hey guys trying to learn rogues

#

First time playing once serious since vanilla wow

#

Slice n dice , do assassin rogues keep it up as priority ? Or it’s a meh spell?

#

I know for sub it’s a MUST

zinc frost
#

You definitely want to keep up snd, but envenom refreshes it. So just cast it at the start of an encounter and you are good to go as long as you refresh it with envenom

wicked mist
#

Ok so rupture then slice n dice then envenom

#

Or slice n dice first then rupture?

zinc frost
#

I recommend you check out the guides for rotational stuff, just covers the basics.

#

!guides

wicked mist
#

Wowhead outdated info, ima use method for sure

#

Thank you though I appreciate it

zinc frost
#

What’s outdated about it?

balmy condor
#

@wicked mist still waiting to know what’s outdated

wicked mist
#

I forgot it was either wowhead or icy ribs

#

I can’t remember

balmy condor
wicked mist
#

I’m looking at patch 9.1 info I’m like wtf

#

And this was recent

#

Maybe icyveijs

zinc frost
#

Noxxic is usually the notoriously outdated stuff or just incorrect info altogether

wicked mist
#

Yeah I can’t remember honestly, it could be noxxic

#

Grey website looks same to me

zinc frost
#

Wowhead was written by this cute e-boy so must be good quality too

balmy condor
#

Because I wrote both

limber lion
#

@balmy condor your guide sucks, Ima just stick to the other one you wrote

balmy condor
#

Damn

limber lion
#

Smh

balmy condor
#

Fucking true

wicked mist
#

I hate icy ribs

#

Icyveins

#

On my damn phone website gives issues

#

Method and wowhead everything works

subtle tundra
#

Maybe write a comprehensive guide on how the buffs will affect our m+ performance?

limber lion
spice spire
balmy condor
#

0

spice spire
#

AMEN

wicked mist
#

So whisper

#

You made guides for wowhead and method?

#

Make*

balmy condor
#

I do

subtle tundra
#

Man but my 100 dps increase will for sure make us good!

wicked mist
#

interesting

subtle tundra
#

He is a decent guy

#

(we now kiss)

balmy condor
#

Pretend I look exactly like my pfp

spice spire
tight ginkgo
wicked mist
#

so slice n dice before rupture

balmy condor
#

Yes

wicked mist
#

Got my answer from your guide

#

Ty

balmy condor
#

Banger

zinc frost
#

Great guide

balmy condor
#

Did it’s job

spice spire
#

4 am whispyr hit diff

balmy condor
#

That’s why they pay me the big bucks

spice spire
#

Dam

wicked mist
#

You only do rogue?

spice spire
#

This is what I’m missing during the week

balmy condor
wicked mist
#

Ah ok only assassin

balmy condor
#

Yeah, they have other people doing the other ones

wicked mist
#

ok cool, trying to learn both assassin and sub

balmy condor
#

Fuu for wowhead sub pushnoir for method sub and foreverguy for outlaw for both

slow marsh
wicked mist
#

Ah ok

balmy condor
#

But is aight

#

I play sub mostly

spice spire
#

Howdy mister iceblades and gn

balmy condor
#

Cause this spec sucks

wicked mist
#

Yeah my bad earlier for saying wowhead, it’s noxxic

spice spire
#

Don’t make me @ Brian homie

slow marsh
#

He's not wrong

balmy condor
#

He knows it sucks too

slow marsh
#

After today I'm done dudes

balmy condor
#

Assassination is the lords of dread spec

#

Gottem

wicked mist
#

I like assassin though it’s the dot effects are cool

slow marsh
#

I threw my hands up about it

empty hinge
balmy condor
#

Exactly

slow marsh
#

I hard malded and ranted then leveled in classic and decided I'm just playing sub f it

spice spire
#

This channel has been sussy for a while tbf

balmy condor
#

You only play it to be sus

slow marsh
#

What's the point anymore

spice spire
#

Classic

slow marsh
#

I'm having more fun in classic than retail that's how bad sin feels rn

spice spire
#

This is when the OTP buff kicks in Sinscheme

#

I don’t mind it tbh

balmy condor
#

Did you know sin and outlaw are neck and neck on wcl overall

#

That’s a Sunday fun fact

tight ginkgo
#

:)

spice spire
#

Like damage numbers

slow marsh
#

And did you know that ww is better than outlaw in st now

spice spire
#

Or player base?

balmy condor
#

Damage numbers

spice spire
balmy condor
#

At least it was yesterday when I checked

wicked mist
#

Oh gosh Kyrian rogue ability tool tip, so confusing

slow marsh
#

Well hey our 30% fan buff will surely bump us down a spot or two

balmy condor
slow marsh
#

Ww and feral gonna bump us down so we're almost back to 9.0 gaming

wicked mist
#

Oh so if I have two powered

#

I do 2 combo points of my own

#

And I get 7 effect

balmy condor
#

Yeah

wicked mist
#

Ah sounds tricky but I get it

balmy condor
#

You finish on the value that’s empowered

#

So you hit er

#

It empowers 2-3-4-5

#

You finish on 2, it’s 7cp

#

You finish on 4, it’s 7cp

#

You finish on 3, you get the point

tight ginkgo
wicked mist
#

Oh ok I thought I literally cast the skill and it gives me a random amount then I have to match it

#

I was about to say lol

slow marsh
#

Sorry ww already above us. Fire mage and feral bumping us down . Maybe even ret pal gets ahead now too

balmy condor
#

It is random but the kyrian lego (and unity) turns it into always 2-3-4-5

#

Without unity it’s only a single empowered slot

#

And that’s random

wicked mist
#

Ah ok

#

Deciding what covenant I want to be when I turn 60

#

Well 50

balmy condor
#

All of them

clear finch
#

All of em 🤣

#

Literally

slow marsh
#

Na

#

Just kyrian venth

clear finch
#

Nah broooooo

slow marsh
#

Since you'll be stuck on sub

cobalt pelican
#

🙄

wicked mist
#

Oh I can switch freely and not have a huge grind?

clear finch
#

I've been rocking Fae Sin pretty decently 🤣 although I'm not a mythic raider so I have free reign

slow marsh
#

I'm hard dooming this spec now ig @spice spire save me

balmy condor
#

And honestly that’s basically all you need

spice spire
#

Stop being cringe.
It’s fine to be middle of the pack.
If we were always the best rogue spec we’d be no different than the true evil of the world, ranged specs.

balmy condor
#

Obviously empowered conduits and shit with more renown

#

But all of our conduits kinda blow

#

So

wicked mist
#

Ahh ok

spice spire
#

That’s My speech kekl

balmy condor
#

You’ll be missing like 120 dps or whatever

#

Just slow grind it

clear finch
#

Whisp is the advocate for our spec and always talks mad shit about it. I love it.

balmy condor
#

No reason to push it giga hard

balmy condor
wicked mist
#

What’s wrong with assassin? Opinions pls

#

I thought it’s go to spec

clear finch
#

It's not Sub

balmy condor
#

No one ever recovered from cancer by saying “nah I’ll be aight”

cobalt pelican
#

can't believe an ORANGE person just equated playing assassination to having cancer

#

unacceptable

balmy condor
slow marsh
#

And the other underperforming specs are getting decent buffs while we get a 30% buff to fan

balmy condor
#

The only arguments you can make for sin is “it’s better in 2-3 target so it’s good on dreadlords” and “I want to play it”

wicked mist
#

Shit that’s true , I was leveling and noticed I do way more work AOE with assassin

balmy condor
#

Close to sub on what

umbral rapids
#

On st

wicked mist
#

Sub rogue does knives and black power two button easy down right

balmy condor
#

On st? Kinda not really

wicked mist
#

So sub is now the go to pvp spec oh shit

balmy condor
#

Sin is better in pvp I think

#

But I don’t pvp often

ancient rain
#

I just hope the 30% FoK buff will make Hidden Blades the best st talent

cobalt pelican
#

you can play both

#

depends on comp and how crong you are

balmy condor
#

So

stiff garden
#

Outlaw bis pvp now

balmy condor
wicked mist
#

The issue I have with sub is is I fuck up my shadow dance then I know I goofed hard

balmy condor
#

Idk how close it means to say “close”

balmy condor
#

Yeah just checked

#

It’s almost 1k on halondrus

#

Over 1k on heroic

wicked mist
#

I want to do outlaw rogue but roll the bones F thy

#

F that, I hate that random BS

balmy condor
#

Sub tier is more rng

#

So

#

If that’s not your jive

#

Sub’s downside atm is it’s one of the most rng specs in the game

wicked mist
#

I don’t like roll the bones picking my buffs though

cobalt pelican
#

statistics will always kinda be warped more aggressively in favor of the better spec though

balmy condor
#

But if you look past that rng

umbral rapids
cobalt pelican
#

like it's mostly only boomers and poop brains playing sin still

balmy condor
#

Yeah but it’s also cracked sin players like cev and seli and ice and oxi

wicked mist
#

I don’t mind RNG kind of like elemental shaman and that maelstrom talent

#

But when you pick my buff from a pool and it’s random, you got me geeked up

balmy condor
#

Idk how much the sway is on logs for good specs everyone plays vs bad specs that otp’s play

wicked mist
#

Fuked*

balmy condor
#

It’s hard to pin that down

stiff garden
#

RtB rng isnt bad since we have CtO

subtle tundra
#

our relationship is over. pack your stuff

stiff garden
#

Getting bad rolls wont kill your dps

balmy condor
#

I was beginning to wonder where you were

subtle tundra
#

im just here, collecting Ls

stiff garden
#

Whispyr why are you so fkng cute

balmy condor
lunar otter
#

with cacheguys whats best one to get the axe for bleed?

pseudo hamlet
#

We still prioritize Envenom in the TB window during ST? Even with 2/4PC?

steel ridge
#

shiv buffs CT aswell

prisma monolithBOT
#

Cache of Acquired Treasures usage:
Axe is always the strongest weapon.
Note: The Weapon rotates every 12 seconds in the order Sword -> Axe -> Wand

limber lion
#

Jk there's new cracked parses, assa is trash lmao

#

Cheaters

pseudo hamlet
steel ridge
#

not quite sure, you want to maximize CT uptime, but no idea about envenom uptime

vestal wren
#

cev plays assassination tho, he might have the highest parse

untold mortar
#

but private log

frosty cedar
#

sin is big poggers no cap vent tech op

karmic crystal
#

That’s the power of actually useful spec legendaries

#

And a lot of fight timings work for assassination pretty well

vestal wren
#

it is not the power of spec legendary items

#

it is the power of a problematic interaction that was left in as a design choice

#

that conveniently works rly well with one of the legendary powers

shrewd iron
#

i thought u always synced vendetta with flag? but looking at the assassination faq i see this '' generally you can sync every other flag to a vendetta'' so ig u sync every other flag to vendetta now?

peak bobcat
#

With 4P and dusk you sync every one

#

Holding vendetta for flag every time

shrewd iron
#

ok i see, thanks!

brazen zodiac
#

good morning

ebon notch
#

@balmy condor Susge

viscid spear
#

Full Send after holding for them all to be up

unborn olive
#

Hello guys in m+ When im multi dotting i often get to a point where SnD is about to run out and im struggling to make a decision wether i envenom to extend SnD or Keep dotting
Also do we Use shaded sharpening stones as sin?

bleak sky
#

envenom to refresh snd

#

stones, yes

unborn olive
#

Tanks a lot

lyric crater
#

so bis raid is vamp or NF im 3/5 on T want to make sure once i get 4set i pick the right one

vestal wren
#

venthyr has a theoretical higher output

#

nf is however more comfortable to play

#

and not that far behind

#

necro is the best for multi target

lyric crater
#

really how comfortable havnt play it much i see it really good in pvp once u have 4 set

#

on postive note fan of knife geting a 30% buff to damage i saw on post yesurday

lyric crater
#

better then nothing aoe sucks as is haha

#

qustion is pb better in tyr weeks? i feel it might

subtle tundra
#

LMAO

#

no.

lyric crater
#

damn lol my mind said yes but my gut said hell no lol

subtle tundra
#

assa aoe is already so extremely bad you cant play without the main aoe ability

limber lion
#

Fuu doesn't even play the spec.

#

But you always go Necro on Lords

#

:')

bleak sky
#

Oh look it's ceverion

#

been missing for the past few days, we had a weird new green guy

ebon notch
bleak sky
#

something like that, ye

brazen zodiac
#

brian missing? cev back? something seems awfully fishy here

sonic schooner
#

Did anyone seen bryan and ceverion in the same room together? peepostudy

river frost
#

@frosty cedar gratz to rank 1

frosty cedar
#

doesnt count got externals

river frost
spice spire
#

Ethical gaming only

frosty cedar
#
  • heroic + public log only kinda weak man
thick sable
verbal radish
#

With 4piece and new leg, what's the approximate vendetta cooldown?

limber lion
#

50-55s

verbal radish
#

If playing with subt/NF, would you hold anything to sync with vanish on every other vendetta?

limber lion
#

You should have Shiv for every Vendetta window

#

But that's about it

#

You send Sepsis/Vendetta on cooldown and Shiv together with cds whenever possible

verbal radish
#

Thank you. And Vanish/Subterfuge?

limber lion
#

You just use it normally with the Vendetta windows

#

together with the Shiv that you should be using there as well

verbal radish
#

Won't they be off their 2 minute sync by about 10 to 20 seconds? You just catch it at any point I take it during vendetta window no aim to hold and direct sync?

limber lion
#

You do do some syncing up because you want to Sync every other Sepsis

#

We play the spec in 1 minute intervals, even if Vendetta is up 5-10s prior

verbal radish
#

Gotcha. Cool thank you for answering my questions.

limber lion
#

Same goes for Venthyr and Flagellation, except there you sync every single cast

#

No worries

wide ridge
#

fok buff.. huh

#

better than nothing i guess

vestal wren
#

small damage increase in dungeons

#

not super bad

#

(tho its more a joke because its like 1% dps in dungeon slice, if even)

winter vapor
#

do we hold vend for heroic Pantheon for after adds or?

#

only got 2 piece rn

limber lion
#

No

#

Send it on pull

winter vapor
viscid spear
#

I should ask Quake for tips on Necro Zoldyck next time we do HC Panth

solid venture
#

got r1 on heroic skolex pog me

limber lion
#

gz

bleak sky
#

yuuge

limber lion
bleak sky
#

external abuser smh my head

solid venture
#

hell no brother

#

private logging Sadge

bleak sky
#

oh

#

private sadgers

scenic kelp
#

is faulty countermeasure nerfed and not good anymore?

bleak sky
#

if it sims well for you, use it

#

else, don't

limber lion
solid venture
#

pretty sure you've done more than that though :p

#

wouldn't surprise me at all

limber lion
#

Def got me beat

ebon notch
solid venture
#

monkaHmm am i running into a deez nuts joke here

bleak sky
#

no

#

natty = no externals

solid venture
#

ah xD

#

im clean af boii

#

dont need drugs to perform

silent tinsel
#

Just put of curiosity, could assa apply banshees blight with one dagger then swap out to normal daggers?

#

Or do you need 2 and of the item is completely gone the debuff goes too?

fleet whale
#

So i figured out the new M+ "meta" after this FoK buff:
Run hidden blades + Poison Katar conduit+ General Draven soulbind
gonna be op /s

craggy oak
#

no

#

or you memeing?

fleet whale
#

yeah, hence we i put /s at the end

violet hemlock
#

Just cause u understand what /s means doesnt mean everyone does.

brazen zodiac
#

lol

winter vapor
#

is Necro reasonble on heroic Lihivum?

stable apex
subtle tundra
#

no he didnt

#

because he was ironic

#

you cant ironically swap to sub

slow marsh
#

If adds, Necro is more than reasonable

tribal spear
#

is the suggestion from the assa guide here to play NF ST outdated? i checkd the mythic logs and everybody is playing VENT

zenith yarrow
#

Should I still aim for haste and crit for ST?

zinc frost
tribal spear
violet jackal
#

It doesn’t explain that mastery is your new best friend after 4 piece kekw

obtuse robin
#

my two best stats atm r crit and mastery

pure moth
#

Weird. But if sims say so, then so be it.

heavy skiff
#

do u line up vend and flag every time? or just send it?

wide bolt
heavy skiff
#

yea srue but it feels weird, missing like 6 - 10 sec on flag cd when vendetta is up

#

maybe im just bad and need to get more flag stacks

zenith yarrow
#

When is it safe to refresh my bleeds while in vendetta with 4 pieces?

#

Do I still refresh rupture à <7.2sec?

#

or <3.6sec?

pure moth
#

In vendetta its 3.6

zenith yarrow
#

tyty

oak sky
leaden finch
#

hi for mythic plus is better heimir or marileth?

oak sky
#

marileth

normal mist
#

We still stacking haste crit even at 4set right? Just to be sure I'm gearing right

slow marsh
#

whatever top gear says

glass tulip
#

agreon and ib on fire rn

viscid spear
balmy condor
#

M..mastery?

viscid spear
#

Armor Pen
Makes it's return in Dragonflight PeepoYes

pure moth
#

Really

proud salmon
#

do you ever press ambush?

viscid spear
balmy condor
#

With sepsis, or subt

proud salmon
#

but you also have to be able to mutilate from stealth right? just trying to sort out binds so it's kinda awkward

#

ty tho

balmy condor
#

Mut from stealth with MA

#

I honestly suggest just getting rid of stealth bar

#

Having your bar swap back and forth is just annoying

#

And on sub it’s an actual hinderance

proud salmon
#

fair

viscid spear
balmy condor
#

Need a spec to play on lords of dread

#

And then a spec to play on everything else

viscid spear
#

Kyrian though Cring

oak sky
#

the sauce

#

the extra

#

the je ne sais quoi

#

the tier set

slow marsh
#

trade you mine

oak sky
#

at this point i think i would rather have gold than tier

strange python
#

I feel like even with mfd and energy pooling I'm only hitting 25-28 stacks every flag

obtuse robin
#

thats normal

strange python
#

Our other rogue says he's 28-30 every time

obtuse robin
#

is he sub

hybrid sage
#

Can we soak Rygelon soak with cloak?

oak sky
#

ngl with vendetta every time it shouldnt be extremely difficult to hit 28-30 at least most of the time

obtuse robin
pure bridge
#

Lust and some timely crits from MA, its very likely.

obtuse robin
#

in ven sure

#

but homie said everytime

pure bridge
#

Yeah' thatd require many things to go right.

strange python
strange python
pure bridge
#

Its MA and the near guaranteed crits where I can see 28-30, but every other flag will be without.

obtuse robin
#

do you both have 4pc

lunar otter
#

Will we see assa in mythic logs or still behind ?

rapid prism
#

if im using the first sigil and IQD as my trinkets. What would be the better one to use in the opener? Can i sim for this? Venthyr bleed build

oak sky
#

Put each one in the first slot on raidbots

#

It should use that one first

#

Then you can compare them

rapid prism
#

interesting ok thank you

oak sky
#

Like within 50ish

lunar otter
#

Yeah i see the sims just not showing up in logs , or is it all the private sadges like me ahha altho i dont do mythic yet :( not even 4pc

#

Just a 2pc chad

oak sky
#

Theres a lot of private logs yeah

#

I dont have my 4p yet either ive been very unlucky

lunar otter
#

Sad bros :(

oak sky
#

I should either get it today or reset day

lunar otter
#

I wish u the rng gods my homie

oak sky
#

Thanks

peak bobcat
#

I believe in you agreon

oak sky
#

I dont brk

#

Bro

strange python
# oak sky Like within 50ish

Sin also catches up with more gear, since sub won't replace main hand till higher ilvls, and doesn't replace offhand

#

So in early prog there's an argument for sub that's stronger. Also all pre-double leggo was favored for sub

oak sky
#

Early prog is over

#

Nothing matters anymore

strange python
#

I mean sure, but he was asking about logs

#

The first 3 weeks were heavily sub favored

#

So a lot of logs will be skewed that way

hollow river
#

I mean even now with double legendaries etc sub is doing more damage

#

Still sims over 1k more than sin for me

#

Early prog or not that’s a big difference

strange python
#

Yeah it'll depend on your gear.

#

Sin is simming within 500 of sub for me now and I could optimize that with some m+ target farming

#

But I'm really tired of playing sub on halondrus and waiting 85 minutes for a dispell during symbols.

hollow river
#

Just don’t run off boss until symbols is over/almost over

strange python
#

They're yelling at people who don't get out ASAP

hollow river
#

Hmm

#

I mean you can cloak it off yourself

#

So that doesn’t make a lot of sense

strange python
#

Tracking it for reclaim since our ranged refuse to soak motes

#

Need it in case it comes through a planetcracker

hollow river
#

Ahh

#

Why are the ranged refusing logs

#

To do the mechanics dead

strange python
#

Because ranged think halondrus is an easy melee and hard ranged fight

#

Because ranged players are privileged babies who have never had to do mechanics before

hollow river
#

Sounds like ego

strange python
#

Ranged players get Painsmith Chains and Halondrus Bombs and panic

hollow river
#

Are you swapping bombs at all

strange python
#

I'm filling in when one of them does

#

Dies

#

So...yes. Every pull.

hollow river
#

Idk how we’re going to do it

viscid spear
#

I've played both ranged and melee on Hal

#

||And I agree||

hollow river
#

We started on pantheon this week and I’m out for it so I’m just in Halondrus waiting room

cloud nacelle
#

Are there any videos/twitch of a sin rogue playing either NF or "new" venthyr build?

strange python
#

Also yeah this shit is cooked, I'm getting 27 stacks of flag in opener even with vanish and mfd

#

Are y'all holding till max energy before first rupture? Cause even with belf racial I'm just twiddling my thumbs for garrote energy

obtuse robin
#

again thats normal

#

are u flaggin with no energy

#

impossible with opener

#

so nvm

#

unless

strange python
#

I mean I'm not trying to settle for normal. If people are routinely hitting 30 I want to be hitting 30.

#

After I sit around idling for garrote energy I'm flagging with 60 ish and not feeling starved but I'm still not hitting 30. Not sure what I could do without just slamming a finisher after every Mut regardless of crit

obtuse robin
#

brother

#

30 stacks everytime is not normal

#

25-28 is normal

#

ur rogue friend is lieing

#

or he is sub

#

ill even qoute whispyr

#

"It’s actually incredibly difficult to get 30 stack flags"

strange python
#

P sure agreon said 28-30 was more normal as well

obtuse robin
#

28 and 30 are not the same

#

i know they seem close

oak sky
#

you definitely get lower stacks sometimes

#

i wasnt trying to say you should always get 28

strange python
#

I mean if people are hitting 28 on non-vanish ones and I'm hitting 24 I wanna troubleshoot.

potent dagger
#

Depends on your crit basicaly

safe barn
#

damn

#

i bet all of this parses are from agreon and cev

#

seli and whisp too

potent dagger
#

i'm kinda surprise no one speaks about that

safe barn
#

it was talked about it

limber swallow
#

no one talks about things that won't make a difference.

safe barn
#

and it doesnt matter

potent dagger
#

Ha missed it ^^

#

Every up as little as it is , is good to have ^^

glass tulip
#

I normally am getting 27-29 by not using MFD in MA window

#

vanish mut env mut env mfd env

ebon notch
#

Getting 30 is literally rng on hitting back to back to back 4cp mutilates @strange python

glass tulip
#

is how I do flag stacks for opener, only way im consistently getting that close to 30

ebon notch
#

Instead of focusing on something out of your control focus on things that actually make you play better

#

Missing 3 stacks of flag on an opener doesn't make you do 1k more DPS

balmy condor
#

I'm flexing

#

higher rank than my sub

#

who the fuck still plays this spec bro on god

ebon notch
#

@balmy condor I'm being guilt tripped off of assa on halondrus

balmy condor
#

good

#

why would you play sin on halondrus

#

that sounds miserable

#

knowing you're legit 1k behind for free

limber swallow
balmy condor
#

like

#

on heroic where theres actual sin parses

#

its a blood bath

#

it's top 4

#

but I mean

#

is it really