#assassination
1 messages · Page 3787 of 1
pandemic is 30% or less remaining according to the time of the dot that is to be applied
18 second garrote means you can refresh the current garrote at 18(0.3) = 5.4 or less
ahhh ok, so as long as I pop TB with at least 10-11 seconds left on bleeds im fine
yes
There is WA for that.
Or you can make tmw showing pandemic refreshing time.
I will be honest and I'm using Luxthor's WA for rotation and specs. I only add empowered garrote to it because sometimes I got distracted and can't track it. But still gotta remember that Exsngnt bleeds must be not refreshed.
@static sky with tb you sometimes want to refresh outside of pandemic
don't remember the exact timings but you used to do it once or twice during a fight
what is the best covendent for SIn?
catholic assassins are pretty decent
but who fucking knows
or so i've heard
There is WA for that.
@strange python yeah was asking bc im using a variation of luxthos auras but im tryin to adjust them to be more optimal
like to only glow when its best to cast, etc. training wheels while i learn
I'm too lazy for going through WA settings. I just add someoneelse empowered garrote there on separate place and get rid of extra stuff.
Cz WA makes ppl stupid sometimes.

@crimson palm NO clue if it a joke or you mean kyrain
@balmy condor does wow analyzer accurately account for bleeds refreshed too early
it will count it as a mistake when in reality it's beter to do so
wow analyzer isnt uptodate for assa
It's just not working correctly with current meta build.
It's completely fine for x3 DD build.
Since it's straight forward.
^
which spec is king right now and which corruption pieces should they try to get?
sin in raids
outlaw in m+
making corruption sets this late is kinda difficult though
there's pins in each channel
Difficult or no point? 
both
yes

which spec is easiest for horrific visions
outlaw probably
ty
although if you have shrouded
sin is really strong
so
really depends on your gear
Stuff just melts with 3x shrouded. If you kill mage tower boss on lower mask runs before he teleports there will be no portal back to cathedral.
i don't think it really matters what spec you run in visions anymore
all three of them become op
Boss has to be lowest DPS
My carapace parse sucks
If boss isn’t bottom, you should maybe get good and pad harder
the small adds don't count right
But that's because we have buyers and we hold dps mainly I guess
I got charged bonds 4 times in a row last night on raden, rip parse
That's the end of my story
Whispr when is your raid or is raid ded til SL?
I'm new to WoW and I'm trying to build my assassin rouge. I'm lvl 49 now.
I have my hotkey bar set
Garrote, mutilate, Rupture, Envenom, Poisioned Knife, shadow step, deadly poison, Evasion, Cheap Shot,
I habe my talents at
Elaborate planning, master assassin, Vigor, and that's all I can do for now lol
Im trying to build this character for dungeons or raids?
If you're levelling theres no like builds really just level
Okay, thanks
whats stat prio order for sin?
Depends on content
Also going to change into next expac
But right now raids is haste>haste>haste
And m+ is either the same build, or crit/Vers with EB
Whispr when is your raid or is raid ded til SL?
@Whispyr
Everything ded
We key push

Officer got butthurty, snatched his crew and dipped, so we down to like 1.5 tanks, 3 heals, and 5-6 dps
But we were shit to begin with
I’ve never been huge dick
For fights when lust timing doesnt line up with cds, when do we second pot? do we save for cds or use during lust without cds
Np
I’ve never been huge dick
@balmy condor you are to me bro <3

lol pretty sure they reversed the parameters on Doomblade
Mutilate does an extra 5% DoT and Envenom gets 20% per bleed on the target 🤣
I think I'll take the extra 45% damage on Envenom over an extra 15% of Mutilate....
haha
All these changes are going to get very interesting over the next month
Gonna be all over the place
@zenith tiger Reminder there will be a Heroic Ny'alotha run tonight. Be on at 8!
!stats
Its very hard to make statements about stat trends in the current patch.
Please use a simulation to generate results for your personal gear situation.
Gottem 
Best covenant to try out on beta atm ?
Does stance macro works for Subterfuge?
Necro
Ok it works with bonusbar:1
any guide on what talents they think are the go to for ass atm ?
in the beta that is
I'm testing on PTR with Alacity and Poison bomb coz dont have same haste as on live
Maybe I'll use Exa coz of SS
Level 65 assassination got the single target rotation pretty well but struggling with AOE. is it literally just a knife spam then envemon & rupture on 5?
yep, pretty much it
but dont worry too much about your damage or whatever at lv 65, just get to 120 and then u can start exploring builds n different stuff
becomes a lot more interesting:p
how do people play ass rogues with high corruption? my vers is 3% only and even with elusiveness i take tons of damage :/
you'll get used to it 
pray for rng
oh man hahaha
do rogues even need like some % of vers?
i'm having a hard time trying to hit 80% haste with 34% crit and maintaining 40+% mastery. not sure if i'm balancing it correctly
you don't need 34% crit
or the mastery necessarily
just equip what the sims tell you
oh okay
around the 80% haste mark, sometimes earlier, sims will probably want you to swap out some haste gems for some other stat
it changes per character
the actual percentages themselves don't matter
there's no breakpoints or anything


maybe you didnt roll the right bones
ETlol, some people already think that assassination does better overall. They prefer outlaw for utility.
yeah, damage is not the reason outlaw is more popular, both do similiar AoE damage
Outlaw is also a lot easier to gear up in comparison imo.
it's boss damage is bad, but being able to use vanish as a utility instead of damage CD and having gauge is really good
yeah p much
I also think about decisions you make mid-fights it's less punishing to play outlaw
ah so true i guess for places where your team really needs you to have a lot of interrupts then outlaw would be better
would you say for sin aoe you should stack the fok azerite trait 2 times or more?
@balmy condor do i qualify for the nice club now?
also should i gem for mastery or haste?
re: Echoing blades - it really depends on your stat set up
short answer: if you're running crit/strikethrough, yes
else stats will probably carry you further outside of the big dumb aoe dungeons
EB's major benefit is that it stops you from being completely worthless if you cant get your restealth
So your milage out if it is super dependent on how and what you're pulling
I run crit and 3eb 3ss is my gold standard for everything that isnt Workshop kR and Siege; where i run my raid set up instead
that said, <--- 3k shitter so grains of salt
hey sin player just returning, outside of pins anything cool i should look at for beta?
@wary ice why siege? I feel like there's a lot of shitmobs there, like in shrine.
Most cleavy Dungeons at 18-22 Keys are temple, kr, workshop and underrot.
That Said, 3k shitter here aswell haha
So in siege a solid 70+% of any given pull is non-elite trash; and basically everything you do to it is pointless padding. Your overall will look better by taking EB and cleaving them, but in reality if you remove all non-elites froma given pull you're looking at 2-3 mobs, in which 3xSS + haste cleave REALLY shines
So basically Im just saying "hey hunter plz do your thing and kill the garbage and I'll just dump all my damage into the things that need to die
Its sort of punishing near 3rd ob; where you start fighting real packs; and while clearing the 3rd boss room
but again those pulls are like 4-5 at most and EB doesnt REALLY turn on till 6+. Basically let the classes with passive cleave kill things that are non-threats and put your damage where it matters.
@wary ice gotcha!
Btw, I go 3ss 3eb mostly, from about a week ago, except yard where its just a haste fest.
Anyway, hidden blades sim less than 1% worse than poison bomb for me. And I feel like HB is so much more fun to play with.
Have around 55% base crit and a couple strikethroughs. Crit versa with versa socketed.
Eb is bad in siege literally just play raid build
Dont remember my point, but I never see anyone play with HB.
U not only senseless pad but by killing the smallies faster
Talking general now, not siege
You essentially rip hunter dps
If you play with one
And hb is just weaker than ct so
i stil lthink the old combat specc is better than outlaw
i dnt like the pirate theme of outlaw
i might try sub in SL, cos of mage tower appearances being specc wide and poisons also
Sub has some nice looking changes but I'm waiting to see the tuning. A lot of the Legion legendaries making a return for Assass is making the decision hard, though.
the priate themes pretty dead, tbh
with saber slash now being sinister strike
anything left is mostly a hang over from the fact that their artifact was the dread blades
so i need to change what ?
sorry i was talking to someone else I'm looking now
oh okey x) that's why i didn't get it lol
breath major probably isnt as good as BotE or CLF
obiously upgrading azerite to 480s will probably get you there but your traits are fine
should i go for expedient build ?
in ST you'll get more value out of actually all your essences are wrong
both ST builds like high haste so
if you're building for raid; yes the expedient build will be beneficial
What do you mean by BotE or CLF ?
blood of the enemy/condensed life force
I dont know what they are in french; but blood of the enemy and condensed life force
oh okey
bote is the Battle grounds honor one; CLF is Eternal Palace if i remember right
IMO bis essences are Blood of the enemy major; Breath of the dying + iris + lucid dreams/formless void (depending on your natural haste)
alright going to work on it
Yeah improve your haste - your rings may benefit from being haste enchanted until you start getting more expedients
Also: if you're not using Galecaller trinket on cooldown, and are able to sit in it for most of it: I'd suggest using your scale instead
Since you're using DD you cant snap shot the benefit of the haste circle so you really need to be able to sit in it to make it worth the slot
as high as you can
i think my ST set rests at around 58% and im missing 3x exp3's
yep
you will definitely wnat to slot in a Lucid minor
that alone will help a lot even at rank 1
so more expedient and more haste and then go for expedient build
probably the single best thing you can do foryourself right now
ok thanks mate
hey boys, anyone here that logged mythic nzoth 97+?
whisper me please if you got free minute
@plain warren your gear is just lacking. No sockets, corruptions, low azerite, missing all rank 3 essences, especially lucid since you dont have expedient yet
you have a 15 ilvl difference in your weapon, so switch those around, mainhand is always higher ilvl
no coral/vita/plum/anything higher ilvl
you can just talk in here roodi what do you need
pad in psychopages whenever you can mostly after psychus realms when theres lots on 1 place
spam fan CT?
when all are in 1 place near tentacle y
well yeah i think thats the issue for me
check what tentacle mage/warlock is on
cause on most kills im in top3 damage done on the boss
so u dont waste your cd on the one they blast away
so i guess thats not the case
your killtime's quite slow compared to most logs nowadays, doesn't seem like you go insane for the full duration
after immunity soaks
use garrote1 garrote 2 on harvester
and garrote 3 on boss
for extra pad
and thats a cool idea
ok what about bashers and corruptors
cause i see
that most people dont even bleed em up
it differs very depending on your roster
personally I try to garrote rup garrote vendetta exsang right at the start
and pray that warlocks and mages have some honor
yeah im getting like 250k opener on the first set
any bit of uptime is useful on pull, you'll never get full value out of cds there
ah good he's here
nope clocking out 
Smh
just need to try and be faster than our warlock and mages enemies
well yeah
and about the roster
its nothing special i think that may be a little % of the issue
but im sure i can improve
last kill
can multidot both tent sets if they live the full duration
and multidot on spikes too if they dont get killed too quickly
when u go in psychus ignore synapses(if u dont need the dmg) and just pump psychus
yeah thats what im doing
should i burn psychus?
or at least just exsang it
or its no difference for logs
i suppose its not
stop overcapping cp on mut btw
u mean dd on 5?
you don't get a big dmg boost by psychus anymore
em excuse me sir, what is thots
but dotting synpases that die within few sec is dps loss
so dont do it
better of envenoming them
Thought harvesters
@balmy condor is a thot

Oh tru
psychus 2 is kinda
as well
why tho?
i can ask rl to go to the first one cause im not intterrupting just sitting on psychus
ok so i guess the biggest thing is to try subterfugeing every harvester later on vanishes
and what about getting the buff in the end
or debuff lol

well yeah but that was only the last pull
i mean
previous pull
when we had boss at 5% and i was before my last CD
it was good for me
we also didnt get the shield on before so it was a good one
but yeah on the kill its just a shitty 63 log :c
Anyone happen to know pandemic remaining times for CT and Garrote?
yeah
30% of the duration of the newly applied dot
Garrote that’s 5.4
CT, like rupture, depends on CP
So 6 cp CT would pandemic at 4.2 seconds?
y
What does the conduit "Lethal Poisons" increase dmg on? What counts as non-periodic lethal poisons, is it just Deadly Poison?
Probably the instant poison portion of deadly poison
the fuck yall pinging me for with your lame ass dumb shit

Wasn’t me this time either dad I promise
@crimson palm that shadhar log you didnt beat the rogue who had quadrillion tendie dmg
sorry try again
does he have a 69 rank though
that is true
well played
holy shit i actually didnt notice
that tendie guy is insane
@young vessel just make sure that u pop all your stuff after secret phase with when u get mced
and make sure u use focused resolve pot there not unbridled
sick gamer
run all tents wait for triple tent to proc press blood
Nefariûs
whispyr nice rmter
thats his name
idk all star is worth nothing
it updates once per 24h
they should give all star points by median performance
nowhere
just pump boss?
if you dont break the membranes the dmg doesnt count on logs
yes but #1 log is 23rd on boss damage 12k behind top 1 so it still is true
wdym you do no damage without vanish
I mean you can just look at the log and clearly see what he did
im pulling the boss atm so dont have much time to analyze
just wanna know if its full pump boss and step to 3 tumors bleed em up and pad a bit
in our kills I couldnt do solo boils in p2 so I do cds on pull, cds right at the start of p3 and the I get one more round before it dies
okio
largest overall dmg is using cds in intermission
largest boss dmg is using all 3 on boss
idc tbh about whether i do this or this just wanna do logs on it cause mine are shitty
My log is 85k overall 77k boss dam which is a 95. Top 100 on boss damage, good enough for me
I dont like the boss and people play really greedy in p3 with bombs, my drop is furthest out. Pretty annoying in general
well last two bosses is a joke to log
but after pretty long i'd like to do this as a little souvenir :p
2 more mutilates wont make or break your parse during bombs
nah, not much
if I'm on first xanesh group do I hold vanish until after?
no
hey guys, do you guys spread dots on all targets during raden mythic? or only with crimson tempest?
Depends on the comp these days. If you have 7 fire mages and warlocks, adds die in a matter of seconds, lol. But if your group is less optimal, then yeah you would.
cara is just a weird fight
when i say weird it just means i odnt like it
vexiona is the only fight you're allowed to hate
@edgy ginkgo u want to use 3x garrote on the adds and boss y
By all means. I’m just saying Better the comp, the less uptime on adds because they melt.
hi there, i'm a returning player (about 1 year hiatus) , i'm trying to figure out what to re-gear for my assassin, is the crit build vs the bleed build, are they about the same ? i was trying to start getting some gear close to the bleed build.
bleed build is bis, and also way superior on multi target
crit build is somewhat behind
but since addon is almost over just get your hands on everything you can get
our mages comboost when adds spawn on raden, I dont touch them
alright ty, i'll try to shoot for it , still have i guess 4 weeks for it.. it'll be hopefully be useful for SL anyway hehe
just get any gear you can now don't worry about corruption lol
by the time you get what you want it's all over
"since addon is almost over" thats what we call expasion now?
we can actually call wow "addon" and it would be accurate

guys, about mythic il'gynoth with no-dispel strat, how do you guys kite the laser? can we feint inside the boss and just shadowstep back?
I feel naked without being able to cloak lol
we use lock portals
and carefully go back to your position after the laser is over
either warlock gate or shadowstep to a guy opposite of you
you can also sprint kite it to the other side while it's till channeling
i know the laser follows your previous locations, but does it starts tracking your location immediately when the mark on the ground appears or only after the laser appeared?
i.e if i see the mark on the ground, lock gate > shadowstep instantly back before the laser appears or just a few moments after it appears, what's going to happen?
after laser
it starts following u until laser is gone again
so when u see its on you, you can just run around the boss to other side or gate or step or get gripped or w/e
then u wait there until lasers are over and go back
perfect, thanks for the explanation guys. I was worried about bursting blood exploding on other players which is why i was looking for an optimal solution
people usually wont die if you get 1 or 2 overlaps if it's not on last phase
just bomb the others so they learn to move
its super easy fight by just standing on same positions 100% of the time
what will be the best legendary in shadowlands
the one where raz steps on me
wait for infexious to release video on it
the one that gives you 34% crit the fastest
Hey, on the 2nd rupture of the exsang opener (before exsang), if you only get a 5 cp rupture do you mut again?
okk ty ❤️


any assa logs from tonight?
This sim game is so weird...at what point does haste become relevant? Does it happen when I finally get my nothing personal trait? I have my three x double dose and stat weights is still putting haste at the bare bottom of my priority :/
stats are kinda really janky this patch
because of corruptions
unless you really understand whats going on, I wouldn't bother with stat weights
3 double dose ? 🤔
haste becomes relevant always in raids tbh if you're stacking expedients
with a poison build though, you'll see a lot of people with mindflays and crit and stuff
Ohhhhhh damn is that why? Because of my mind flay corruptions?
That would make sense
you could also be at a point in your build where currently the other stats are more important
stats sort of ebb and flow depending on your gear
at least currently
all our stats are pretty good
Yeah, that’s why I’m so confused as to the sim game, once you re-enchant one thing, something else becomes valuable
Bleh
shouldn't happen with top gear
that's why you only ever use top gear
but if you're using pawn and stat weights
that shit will troll the hell out of you
or gear compare i guess, if it's something you don't have
you can read this post about it
Thank you @balmy condor
no problemo
So I was looking at logs for Mythic Xanesh and I see people doing the standard garrote, rupture, garrote opening
but they refresh the rupture and use exsanguinate
arent you not suppose to use in on an empowered garrote?
sounds like a standard opener
garrote rupture garrote, full extend the rupture, then exsang
whats weird about that
maybe I'm not understanding
isn't that garrote still empowered
I thought the guide here said never use exsang on an empowered garrote
if you don't touch the garrote, it's still empowered

that's 100% not true
exsanging empowered garrotes is our biggest source of damage
Im an idiot
and since exsang is 45 seconds
you have to exsang unempowered garrotes
unless you found a way to get 45 second vanish cds
in which case pls share
:P
I totally read the guide wrong where it says do not refresh exsanguinate/empowered bleeds
3/8 t1 set bonus 
thanks you man
np
theres no ineffable truth vanish nonsense you can do?
racing pulse 3...it sims about 4k dps higher than no corruption (mythic wrath dagger)...does that seem right?
youre comparing a corrupted item to a non corrupted item?
well i'm comparing a bunch, but purified dagger does about 4k less dps but rp3 uptime is about only 30% of the time, i worded it badly, i meant does it seem right that racing pulse 3 adds about 4k dps by itself
i'm debating whether to purify it for 2x expedient 2s
yeah that seems fine
ok ty
Just confused with m+ build, do I stack crit/mastery or crit/Vers not doing anything higher than +17
depends heavily on azerit
if you're EB stacking, definitely crit/vers
crit/mastery is never the play
3 ss /2 echo
crit/vers
Ok ty
@normal olive haha yep it's the only dungeon I run sin high for this reason
Yeah same here just bored, I’m trying a crit/verse build, I was always haste build, hard part is getting Azerite equip lol
I basically always play crit
I don’t really do higher than +18 haste build is, I think good enough for damage lol
yeah I mean sub is good enough
I'm playing both M+ and arena, and I have 16k echos that I intend on using on corruption. However, I don't know what to get.
Any advice?
UH
severe and strikethrough are up next week
which is the "M+ build"
and gushing wounds is the week after that
which is the pvp one
whichever you want to play more, I'd save and get
I woulda liked something in the middle
I guess it's not possible
Oh well, they'll be gone in 2-3 weeks anyway
😂
That's true
gushing isn't awful for pve content, but it's also not nearly as good as crit % and strikethrough
man, forget getting this hidden artifact appearance now. every rare in the sewers get one shotted
Whispr do you macro trinkets
Depending on builds
And trinkets ofc
Ie. Gcb and kr trinket
ye
Any recommendations for a fun legendary to test on the beta for dungeons? ^^
You're holding your 2nd exsang for gcb right @balmy condor
def not
Macroing gcb 
Why would you not just have a seperate button for it when you hit it twice as often as vendetta
you just press the vendetta button again
Yes but you don't always want to use it the exact gcd as vendetta
Like this
Frequently you do not want to
like when
Why are you delaying exsang like that tho
like when
@balmy condor mid fight I vend way before I gcb for burst combo
but why
like when
@balmy condor if you wanna preplace your gcb to get max value on current bleeds before you exsang
Why are you delaying exsang like that tho
@fathom swift you don't get a second vend
kinda whatever dps wise imo
unless its like a 9 minute fight where that happens a billion times
Sure if you dont care its whatever its just better to have them on different buttons so you have more control over how you use them
you don't get a second vend
@fallow otter whats your kill time
Sub 2mins if you want to parse
So why not hold gcb for 3rd exsang instead of losing an exsang cast
Ok thats why i asked the kill time
Yeh
Sub 2 min and 1.20 are very different obv
Yeh pot gcb exsang
There is a big Korean log
Let me just see if that's from IS bs
Nah its IS
So anyway what getting to is that
If it's a fight where you get 3rd vendetta
Well be delaying it for exsang for the 3rd right
Slightly
there used to be a pin detailing how to use gcb
back in uldir when gbc and exsang were popular
but then the toxic blade/ma nation attacked
There are situations where you want to delay exsang and use with gcb I guess it's my point
Depending on kill timers etc
Ok ta @vital haven thought so
Its usually only your very last one that you would delay one of them
Would not recommend to macro GCB and Exsg because of some wierd lag/server interaction You absolutely need to have that haste the moment you press exsg because of snapshot
if an wierd server tick shit lag make so that you haste is update 0.2sec after Exsg, you fuckd
True
Also because of it's snapshotting nature you probably want to press exsg at very last sec of GCB. Old Uldir opener used GCB on the pull with Exsg pressed like 7-8sec after oponer
Ya exactly
Mmm that's interesting
Is it somehow bad to bind LGP to Vendetta?
no idea what LGP is
no that's fine
"no idea what that is" lol I feel that way everytime I switch Disc channels here
True
so I have a question
I'm trying to improve DPS, and I use the standard Exsang opener
My next exsang is in 45s but generally there's nothing to empower that one
yes
so let's say timeline is opening exsang 0, unempowered exsang 45, next exsang 90, vendetta/vanish/garrote 120, exsang 135
I know this sounds dumb but I just want to make sure I'm getting it right
I would delay exsang 90 to line up with vvg 120
right?
you hold vendetta/vanish 120 for exsang 135
kk
See that's where I was misunderstanding then
so I would delay vvg for 15s, not vendetta for 30s
yes that's what i meant
thank you
I think that lines up better with the delayed Vanish too
since my vanish is often like 8s behind Vendetta
you hold vendetta/vanish 120 for exsang 135
@balmy condor yeah this is what we were just discussing basically, this one line up because you are delaying vend for vanish so exsang comes up also
But the next one... Not that this comes up these days with kill timers
We use vanish at the start
Instead of after exsang
So instead of being like 10s after exsang it's like 5s before
Which is what i was asking about
So I was asking about delaying the first exsang after this to line up with gcb
But wouldn't that interfere with the initial SS empowered garrotes?
@manic harness which?
You mean vanish gar in opener?
You only do this after it falls off
Garrote, Rupture, Garrote, Vendetta, Mut, 6cp rupture, Exsang, when Empowered Garrote falls, I vanish for re-stealth empowered Garrote
Am I doing something abnormal here?
no
Where would you Vanish in your opener, Stunkei?
But the next vendetta
Thank you @balmy condor
he's talking about weird kill times
Nah not even weird
I mean yeah
The next vend
but just short
I mean I guess I'll just take what I've learned then
@balmy condor thank you for the guidance
np
So vend2
So for me it's opener, exsang, exsang, cooldowns exsang
You vend vanish gar etc
not opener, exsang, delay til cooldowns and exsang
What kill time are you talking about specifically stunkei
Well the one was discussing with you earlier was 1.20
But this is a bit different now
That one is pretty easy decision
So vend2 and vanish line up
Right
So 120s
135s for 3 exsangs
But you gotta add like 5s to that
To get to exsang
So let's say perfect world 140s
So we hold CDs for 20s perfect world
My question is should we hold an exsang and line it up with gcb instead of holding vend/vanish
Which means one less exsang but no holding cd and we gain snap shotting exsang with gcb
Am I missing something here
For Deeper Strategem, does the 5% increased damage to finishers only apply to 6 CP finishers? Or is the increased damage independent of the combo points spent?
In fact I'm pretty sure I've tried simming holding exsang for gcb and it wasnt a gain
So unless you can't get the next vend off and use the duration it's not a gain
Ie. You can't delay and use it
@manic harness all finishers at all CP
Ok sim that then
See if it is
But the fight length youd need would have to be incredibly specific
It would only be for after vend2
so I think a major improvement I can make it to always make sure my Rupture is 6 CP applied before using Vendetta
Makes me feel better that you tried simming it already
that's outdated
Is that still correct?
I have nfi how to sim that tho sadly
Okay
so iirc Rupture's full Pandemic duration is 33s, what about Garrote?
Do you know off the top of your head?
23?
kk
Man this is gonna be hard to make a change before next raid week
TO THE DUMMY I GO THIS WEEKEND
isn't rupture full pandemic 36.4
Depending on crits
yes it's 36
So...if my opener was correct, is there a way to ensure opening Garrote is still empowered but also full pandemic?
wdym
Cause I think we just have to make a sacrifice for the first Exsang?
hmm
Yes which puts it at 23s
Vendetta, Mut, Rupture, Exsang is 4 seconds
so it only comes out to 19
Exactly
so the first one is just gonna end up at 19s before Exsang
that's what I'm trying to clarify
yeah
Robbing Peter to pay Paul
Right, I figured that was just kind of sacrificed
but I'm trying to think about how to ensure next two exsangs ensure full pandemiced
Let me beat on dummy for a min
@fathom swift you know anyone else might have done the math on this question
not sure what the question is
This is surprisingly hard to visualize without just trying lol
Just using advanced sim?
@balmy condor, what I meant was that to ensure that my Garrote applied right before Exsang gets full pandemic, I need X amount of seconds left on garrote already applied to target
Answer seems to be 6 seconds
yep
as long as its more than that
Nice, already seeing a damage difference from my Exsang damage macro
Thank you again Whispyr
uhh
Macro that calculates damage done during Exsang
I'm not sure how smart it is but it seems to work
Err meant WA
not macro
so
sorry LOL
its just a dps meter
nah I'm good
kk
I have details and logs
ye but its also kinda just clutter
at the end of the day, I guess
I used to like that for purifying stagger
On monk
And legion artifact weapon minigame
For sin
whats better for mythic nnzoth , sin or outlaw
which do you prefer
sin
Then play that
They each are strong at their own thing thing
Generally though, I think outlaw is the preferred spec
depens on how many op classes you have in your group
I would never go outlaw, id do nothing in my group
3 dhs 2 fire mages 2 locks
any hunters?
crit build sin with reaping flames carries psychus phases for my guild
me and another rogue run crit build and 2man the tendy's, everyone else pumps psychus
Sorry
Np
https://www.wowhead.com/news=317580/diminishing-returns-in-secondary-stat-ratings-in-shadowlands
have you seen this? this sounds like gearing choices will be a pain in the ass
you'll just sim like you always do anyways. APL will implement any scaling issues.
so far imho you could in most cases identify an upgrade without simming, if it had higher ilvl and bis stats, you were usually fine.
New seasonal affix: Reflection: When a direct damaging ability is used, every yard you are away from an enemy, reflect 6% damage dealt to that enemy to every party member, stacking up to 40 times. Doesn't apply to targets in melee range. wtf have you guys seen this?
@zenith tiger sent it to me

Oh, Im sure we've all had ideas for dumb affixes when we were intoxicated. Unless you got a source, however...
https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/96mCR5ro4QN8TErz2Piixq
Can someone help me read this? It looks like Wristwraps of Volatile Power and Hound-Jowel Waistband would both be upgrades if they had sockets, but because it can't sim with both it isn't showing them like that? Also, I'm assuming the socketed GCB would continue to be an improvement over a socketed Feather?
i think gcb gains a lot of value from nelf
the seasonal affix is Prideful its already on beta?
cause you can smeld ur garrote for the galecallers>xsang
<am undead, but that's good to know
id always run feather in that case
I gear for gcb sim and just switch in feather for fights with movement
would a gm refund my bought 475 azerite piece if its the same one back to back?

sots shoulders back to back 
roll better lol.
is stacking gushing wound is the best corruption for pvp?
Yes, but also #pvp
@ruby ibex little late here, but generally gale will always sim higher than a plumage given similar ilvl/sockets. Your socket/gear questions are exactly the kind of thing gear compare is used for. If you don’t want to do that, you can also just add sockets to gear but adding gem id’s to the ends of the gear strings. You’re correct in saying that both pieces would be upgrades with sockets compared to their current equipped counterparts. Especially with wrists, sockets are kinda huge. While a 465 set of legs can have 300-350 secondary stat and a ton of agi, 475 Skitra bracers for example are under 200 secondary, and have less agi. They both take up a slot, but the comparison from X bracer to Y bracer with a socket is going to naturally tend more towards that socket because it’s a big boost
Righteous!
both crippling and mind-numbing poison has been available to apply on shadowlands for months now, could it be we don't have to choose anymore?
then it means shiv is a massive slow + enrage dispel in the same button
for outlaw + sub atleast
😄
i dont think i'll dispel enrage as assa xd
Not sure about the implications of shiv tbh
Because to me, and for most PVE, it’s just toxic blade with a different name
it is
But yeah, it does dispel enrage, and I assume it adds a sick slow too
That's an actual Shadowlands thing though, because it doesn't on PTR yet (the PvP one does, but that's also on live)
but it isn't right to chain utility to a dps cooldown
I don’t think it’s inherently a problem
I think there’s places where it becomes problematic
Like between the eyes being a kidney replacement, but also a core DPS cooldown
That’s an issue
But I think the niche of an enrage dispel is rare enough to warrant the thought of “do I use now for 100% dps, or is there an enrage in the next X seconds”
I think the slow portion isn’t really that major
So that’s kinda whatever
hmm I agree kinda
In the situations where the slow from shiv is counter-acting what you want, you wouldn’t want crippling anyway
So you would take crippling off to begin with
atleast we can join the few classes that can dispel enrage
Like on sanguine weeks for example
Crippling in general, having a perma slow
Kinda blows
Yeah
But there’s a lot of harder Aoe cc obviously that’s usually more effective
Soft CC like slows have their place but usually aren’t as omegapog
only if the tanks knows when to run 😄
Well even then
Something like rop, vortex, binding shot, leg sweep, grips, stuns
To drop necrotic stacks for example
wdym?
Diminishing returns on secondary stats.
Probably not much of a difference
Just blizzard jank trying to tune down end of expansion power creep
if they don't bring back some type of stat boost system like corruption I don't think DR would be a problem
I mean if you have any stat over 25%, you're immediately losing 10% of it.
damn that's a huge nerf to 34% crit
hopefully 33.9% is still viable
Since it’s only on points above 25%

You’ll not notice anything much
It might add back some breakpoints here or there
But it’s nothing that current stats aren’t experiencing either tbh
Currently you’re seeing some crazy stat scaling because of how corruptions and just massive amounts of raw stats skew stat plotting
It’s gonna be less bad in shadowlands because no corruption
and no 3k stats from 3x azerite stack
But it just means that you’ll have stats ebb and flow into and out of being you’re “best” stat
Which is exactly the same as it works now
Yeah, the main thing I'm taking from this is that it just means we'll be looking at switching to other secondary stats beyond a certain threshold.
Not necessarily tbh
Since this only affects stat points on your character, and not stat% gains like alacrity
how is assasination on beta comparing with other specs, gameplay wise - are You guys enjoying it ?
You only need haste to be 10% better than everything else past that 25% bracket
Yes the 40% bracket will get nuts
After switching to alacrity tbh assa feels fine.
But generally speaking, it’s actually not that bad
For a lot of classes where stats aren’t as close together
And they want to full stack one stat and one stat only
I mean
This hits those guys a lot harder
Isn't that basically fire mage.
Fire mage is one of those at the moment, yes
blizzard introduces diminishing stat returns fire mages wish to know your location
i guess alacrity is talent to go til last patch
But with how strong mastery is for them
Even with a 20%,30% reduction
It’s still competitive
I'd say Alacrity is the only real viable pick in that row atm anyway @open reef
So in practicality, the scaling change actually doesn’t do all that much
In fact, this is basically the same thing they do with secondary stat scaling according to item level
I think back in mop
They made it so that 5 ilvl isn’t the same increase
470-475 is different from 405-410
In terms of the stats you gain
And that’s sort of hidden tech that people forget about, cause it doesn’t really impact all that much
unless i'm thinking of a different change, that happened in bfa
where secondary's increase via item level was massively reduced
Diminishing returns on secondaries doesnt mean shit if one stat severely outpaces another though

there might have been a curve before that, but yeah bfa it was squished real hard
Either way
It’s a similar thing
And that ilvl scaling curve doesn’t affect us that much
You still see things like cara boots
Not ideal stats, but it’s 10 ilvl higher, so I guess it’s just better forever
It’s not really something we think about
And unless blizzard makes it insanely crazy with the reductions
I don’t think this will be an issue either
It’s basically just soft caps
It’ll feel basically the same to how at some point in expedient, you’ll want to ditch the haste gems/chants for a couple vers gems, and maybe a couple crit gems, and a masterful enchant
Or something like that
Idk
It’s one of those changes you read about and it scares you
A lot
That doesn't sound very good
And also the antithesis of what Ion has talked about wanting, but that shouldn't be a surprise at this point.
ur important
aww
Gearing to be simpler and require less outside simulation to figure out what's good
Less simming, but this probably leads to more sims and more gear in bags
that idea was already dead with covenants and soulbinds
These aren’t hard caps
So in theory
We’re actually moving more towards main stat
Which means more towards ilvl
I agree there’s some outliers
And some specs will have breakpoints
we gonna be sim monkeys anyways
But this change in particular doesn’t actually make it more or less sim heavy imo
Imagine not being able to equip higher ilevel boots because they put you to shallowly into the next stat bracket.

doesnt change a thing
Imagine equipping boots and only getting 115 crit rather than your promised 118
Unplayable
#CritLivesMatter
And to the “you’ll need to sim less” ion quote or whatever





