#assassination

1 messages · Page 2087 of 1

golden loom
#

I mean its just completely passive

royal lantern
#

huh

lofty mango
#

I just think it’s a boring concept

nova kelp
#

I'd go so far as to say I actually preferred the old version

#

where it was a random point

#

"random"

balmy condor
#

that's the worst thing?

nova kelp
#

the worst

balmy condor
#

out of all the things you could think of

royal lantern
#

i mean, yeha it is kinda boring, but a boring "next 2 finishers are stronger" passive is not problematic lol

lofty mango
#

I’m saying it’s boring

balmy condor
#

it is

nova kelp
#

yeah it BECAME boring because people complained that the "random point" version was too complex lol

lofty mango
#

That’s that I mean I just think it could be better concept around the stronger finishers like feral has

haughty flicker
#

imagine if supercharger was a button you could press

balmy condor
#

but that's not really a problem

marsh fjord
#

But supercharger just adds other combo point on top of your finisher right? i dont need to think about it?

spice surge
#

Idk theres a bunch of very small things they could do to sub that would alleviate most of the issues people have with sub without actually changing the flexibility and fun aspect of it

haughty flicker
#

and then you had a minigame where you land on certain combo points to use them

haughty flicker
#

that would be cool

fallow canopy
royal lantern
#

you ignore it exists and just play

spice surge
#

But the least played spec in the game aint getting much development time

golden loom
#

Echoing repreimand was also just kinda boring cause you just pressed it on cd anyways

spice surge
#

Which makes sense but it is what it is

balmy condor
#

people been bitching about rogue having too much going on for well over a decade, blizzard makes boring passives and we go "its boring"

haughty flicker
#

mfw different people have different opinions

fallow canopy
balmy condor
#

I mean yeah but what are they supposed to do

lofty mango
#

It is boring it’s not engaging at all 🤣

haughty flicker
#

would never happen

fallow canopy
#

never ever ever

nova kelp
#

it took 20 years to finally not have to maintain slice n dice

#

lol

golden loom
#

Dw that will come back any day now

lofty mango
#

lol that is so true

fallow canopy
#

snd removed meant that the cat bongo gif is not canon anymore so that's sad

royal lantern
haughty flicker
#

we could make a new cat bongo gif

golden loom
haughty flicker
#

it would be pretty easy atm

lofty mango
#

What if they did an empowerment style rupture, then you can choose to use how many CP you want, I would love that

#

More brain needed more engaging

nova kelp
#

would it though?

nova kelp
#

we'd just number out what the best method was and force that single style

lofty mango
#

For me because you would actually need to think about it rather than oh nice bam bam 2 finishers empowered

royal lantern
fallow canopy
lofty mango
#

But that could vary depending on 1, 2 3 etc targets I think that would be cool personally

nova kelp
#

we had a version of induction that had a simple minigame
but that minigame was too complex apparently, because chilling out till your cp hit that random cp node was more worthwhile complaining about than just being able to change target quickly

#

but w/e

balmy condor
#

more complex aoe, just what sin needs

royal lantern
#

mate sorry but, you just say random words rn

lofty mango
#

I really like the roll the bones concept for outlaw something similar for the other 2 would be cool

golden loom
#

Atleast we are not in cancelaura darkest night hell

#

Thank god

nova kelp
#

idk if this is a hot take or not
but
OLD spam the bones dice factory rogue > roll the bones long CD rogue

haughty flicker
#

speaking of darkest night

#

i wonder if we ctw in vv build again in st with tier set

#

it buffs ctw right

lofty mango
#

Like with sin possibly throw 6 vials they randomly proc haste mastery increase or decrease depending on the amount of green vs red

haughty flicker
#

oh its only during shiv though i reread it

#

still

#

also answered already so

thorn thorn
haughty flicker
#

-100 social credit for not remembering pins

nova kelp
#

honestly, as boring as it would be, I kinda wish DSM was just a button at this point lol

#

you press it again when you wana switch, or pop your DN

golden loom
#

Yeah fuck it just make it like hunters mark

haughty flicker
#

yeah you could name it something cool

#

like marked for death

#

and it would reset if the target died

nova kelp
#

I mean thematically that's all it is, but the mechanical use of it is just janky

lofty mango
#

You know what at this point just make it boomie but melee

nova kelp
#

bring back dot sin - turn DSM into a stacked dot that you can only put on one target at a time

#

idfk

#

I just know the current one makes me smh sometimes

nova kelp
#

actually though down with envenom, up with dots

#

mate, it's kinda true though right, so often a lot of wish lists have a habit of kinda matching a lot of legion shit

#

it might be like they were onto something there

lofty mango
#

Because legion was amazingly done for rogue and other specs

thorn thorn
#

Legion was pretty peak for quite a few specs

nova kelp
#

whispyr would hate this, but the best 2 weeks rogue ever had...
throw knife FoK sin during the bug in antorus lolololol

royal lantern
lofty mango
#

Every raid had minimum 3 rogues they rolled every other spec and they got taken to 90% of mythic CE guild if they were half decent because of cloak

royal lantern
#

🙂

terse brook
#

When playing bleed build is it really important to focus on big envenoms from deathstalker? I find myself loosing track of it often as I recently switched back to rogue

royal lantern
#

like srsly

thorn thorn
lofty mango
nova kelp
royal lantern
thorn thorn
#

We did get some pretty bomb spec designs from legion

nova kelp
#

the reason every raid had 3 rogues was less because of direct POWER and more because every boss had 44234242345235253 soaks needed to be done

lofty mango
royal lantern
#

rogue was dumb strong in tomb and that was kinda it

#

and even there you didnt stack 3 rogues lol

lofty mango
#

Because of the immune ability

nova kelp
#

there was a lot of bad parts of legion
eg nearly the whole xpac prior to the QoL patch even

#

and the arcano crystal

thorn thorn
#

Double Pet BM and Kingsbane for Sin some of my favorite things to come from legion

nova kelp
#

THE FUCKING ARCANO CRYSTAL

#

they removed hunter traps...

#

fucking lol

thorn thorn
#

Plenty of bad parts

nova kelp
#

noone remembers when I bring it up, they fucking COMPLETELY removed traps
and shortly after were like "hmmm yeah soz that was an oversight during "the prune", we'll bring those back"

royal lantern
thorn thorn
#

Like in the DF beta when they said priest healers werent getting a kick because a kick is not something they view as essential for every spec to have

#

Not essential for every spec to have, only 2 specs in the game dont get one

nova kelp
thorn thorn
#

And they are on the same class

golden loom
#

Having done the class order hall stuff recently for apperances and whatever that shit is cool as fuck

royal lantern
lofty mango
#

Legion was cool the raids were great and the specs were fun just the raids dragged for too long that’s the bad part

nova kelp
#

I will still argue though that some of the good things that they had in legion they didn't maintain, SEEMINGLY (?) because of a desire to maintain the whole "this is just an xpac thing" design cycle

thorn thorn
haughty flicker
#

shining force got removed because a dev's key was trolled by a priest

nova kelp
#

legion and mop kinda get MOST peoples flowers for the "best gameplay" trophies, there's got to be something behind that feelycraft

lofty mango
#

Surrender to madness still hands down the coolest thing for any spec to have

#

So broken with they kept it

thorn thorn
royal lantern
golden loom
#

Yeah I mean idk about any of that

nova kelp
royal lantern
golden loom
#

Just like the places and the vibes and stories of them are sick

lofty mango
#

But maw of souls was good dungeon and the grind was stopped once blizzard fixed the legendary drops in nighthold

nova kelp
#

but then, that could also just be anecdote

nova kelp
#

I do

royal lantern
#

like srsly, just do it

haughty flicker
#

topping details

#

is when i have fun

#

every other time i quit the game

nova kelp
#

I'm not much for the whole "so stronk" comments

golden loom
#

I've been playing arms warrior a bit on mop prepatch, that shit does feel good to play

nova kelp
#

I care about gameplay feel

#

whenever I'm having those chats with people I focus hard on that

#

and people still mention those xpacs the most

golden loom
#

But its also new content for me so idk, its fun

nova kelp
#

by a fucking landslide

royal lantern
#

the answer is most of the time either a form of "i was top dps" or "i liked doing X thing that still exists in the game under a different name"

nova kelp
#

thats why I refer to it as feelycraft

#

because it is

#

I'm not referring to power

#

or numbers

thorn thorn
nova kelp
#

just "how did doing your shit feel?"

thorn thorn
#

Everything else ranged from notably mid to just terrible

nova kelp
#

and peeps instantly shoot for legion or mop

#

like every time

thorn thorn
#

The leggo system at the start was just inexcusably bad design

#

Imagine having your main bricked for prog because you got the wrong leggo and you had to make a new one

#

A+ design lads gg

nova kelp
#

well... except my current raid lead, he raves about slands...
it's not his fault, that's where he started playing

thorn thorn
nova kelp
#

I used to think that, but I'm not sure

thorn thorn
#

I was playing since legion extremely casually but I didnt play the game in any real capacity until DF

#

And I still think DF was a lot better than people gave it credit for

nova kelp
#

I feel like among the classic peeps, there's a significant portion of WRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATH

thorn thorn
#

So long as we pretend S2 didnt happen

marble nebula
#

hey mates, do the assa st tree change on the ptr?

nova kelp
#

and for people who went longer it's mop

#

then for people who made it through wod it's legion

royal lantern
nova kelp
#

personally I look back really fondly on WoD - it for SUUUUUUUUUUURE had it's issues but man the raiding was sick

haughty flicker
#

rip dreadblades

thorn thorn
#

most

nova kelp
thorn thorn
#

I liked most of the artifact abilities and their mechanics

#

Like KB for sin

golden loom
#

Vanilla = TWW >> MoP classic pre-patch >>>> cata dungeon finder is my non-biased ranking of wow

royal lantern
#

actual burst spec

nova kelp
#

ranged

#

sv

#

but yeah I played rogue a bunch as my "alt prime"

royal lantern
#

ranged sv us the Ultimate "people talk about it and cant even tell you what it was" ever, ngl

like bro, what spec was survival even back then, it was literally just "dark arrow+explosive shot" and thats it

#

its like the OMG COMBAT SO GOOD OUTLAW BAD guS

#

combat was sinester strike+SnD+eviscerate lol

nova kelp
#

it had such a good feeling combat loop

#

a constantly altering cadence, with an intuitive reaction loop

#

some maintenance

#

some raction

#

some pacing

#

that all moved about

thorn thorn
#

raction

royal lantern
#

i can gurantee you 100% if it would exist like that today, you would not say that lol

nova kelp
#

you had slow down and planning in steady time

#

I do still

royal lantern
#

like, this is again nostalgia

nova kelp
#

I've been fucking with it in the ptrs and such

#

it's still the best imo

#

current marks is CLOSEish

#

but the static aimed shots etc have a different form of break up

#

you spend your downtime in your dumps instead

#

ranged sv was a thing of beauty though

#

numbers reflected it - BM was on par and everyone played sv

#

mind... BM at that time had a fucking busted complex opener

royal lantern
nova kelp
#

fucking lol

#

it is weird playing for so long though and seeing the iterations have such a heavy impact on the playerbase

once upon a time the BM complaint was "the opener is like playing mozart on your keyboard"
NOW the BM complaint is "you can't play the game so you play bm with the one working hand you have"

worthy rose
#

i have just realized dk's are largely one button specs

#

unholy sanlayn is vamp striking and frost is obliterating

nova kelp
#

CURRENT unh dk

#

yeah

worthy rose
#

other specs are suboptimal

nova kelp
#

it's VERY simple

worthy rose
#

oh yeah current is

royal lantern
worthy rose
#

i remember in cata unholy was more complex

#

the only tricky part of frost is if you play breath build

#

and you need longer living mobs to make it work

humble verge
#

can someone tell me how 4th raid tier/season 4 works when Blizzass is not doing 4 raid anymore

nova kelp
#

we don't know

#

noone knows

#

no blizzcon this year either

#

hells frozen over

#

everyone hates bungie

haughty flicker
#

i mean we either have fated again or we just dont have a s4

nova kelp
#

dragon age has no story

humble verge
#

wtf

#

is fated

#

🤨

haughty flicker
#

...the thing we've had for s4 two expansions in a row?

nova kelp
#

I actually think

#

we might get the next story install mid year

#

and they just skip a fated season

royal lantern
#

@worthy rose memes like that are 13+ years old btw

#

frost dk is like destro lock

#

people ask for braindead Specs and everyone repeats BM/Ret, and they are happy that they get ignored

nova kelp
#

maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaate remeber that time when the caster trinket in ulduar reduced the cost of frost strike to 1?

royal lantern
#

so they can act as if they are nit braindead specs

nova kelp
#

and all you did for a boss fight was stack your runic

#

then 100 frost strikes

#

gods we were strong

#

HAHAHAHAHAHA

royal lantern
nova kelp
#

I THINK they did? but I wasn't able to find an actual STATEMENT when I was trying to find it for someone the other day

#

just an "Ion-like" kinda maybe but maybe not ripcord statement

haughty flicker
#

if enough people believe they said it then it becomes reality

#

(i have no idea if they said it or not)

nova kelp
#

if we're NOT getting one, then s3 is eitherr CRAZY long or we're getting a very early xpac

#

"xpac"

#

whatever the fuck they're calling them now

haughty flicker
#

they did say they want faster expac cadence

nova kelp
#

chapter?

#

fucking

#

idk

thorn thorn
#

But aberrus Demo was complete cancer to play

nova kelp
#

maaannnnnnn I liked aberrus demo lol

#

I understand I'm wrong

main bridge
#

Was it worse than Nether Portal?

nova kelp
#

I also liked nether portal...

#

lol

thorn thorn
#

Nether Portal was aberrus Demo

main bridge
#

Ah ok

thorn thorn
#

Omega cringe opener and if you messed up a single global it was like a 10% loss minimum

nova kelp
#

I enjoyed it man

main bridge
#

I took a break during Razagath

thorn thorn
#

PI was also 12% value for demo because pitlord was so strong

main bridge
#

So I missed all that

nova kelp
#

every single warlock tells me I'm OBJECTIVELY incorrect though

#

so

#

I must be lol

thorn thorn
#

Yes

#

Cuz you are

#

Nether Portal in the way it was made was like the worst omega cringe gameplay possible

#

Imagine if KB was a 3m cd and instead of poison applications it was the amount of envenoms you used during it

nova kelp
#

PI is a problem

#

honestly

thorn thorn
#

And it was tuned so strong that literally nothing else mattered

nova kelp
#

PI should just be removed from the game

main bridge
#

I agree it was cringe because it was like a 10 step opener and if you fucked up any part you were owned

nova kelp
#

if I ever talk to someone again and they say the sentence "you need PI for the spec to function as it's intended"

#

I will fucking

#

kick a baby

haughty flicker
#

Do it coward

nova kelp
#

imagine legitimately unironically thinking taht they balance certain specs as if they INTEND pi to be stacked on that spec

thorn thorn
#

So every 3 minutes for 14 seconds you would instead just do FoK and envenom at 1 combo point

#

And it would be omega cringe

haughty flicker
thorn thorn
haughty flicker
#

I doubt blizzard intended sub to rely so much on skyfury but it does

nova kelp
thorn thorn
#

Also Dev got a nerf to its CD and PI was specifically referenced in the bluepost for why it was nerfed

nova kelp
#

nah aberrus demo got massive boosts from pi, like you wouldn't NOT give it to them because of the sheer power
but the spec FUNCTIONED as intended without pi

#

it just felt better with

#

but feeling better doesn't dictate that it was crafted TO have it

thorn thorn
#

Debatable at best

#

Your opener was unironically different with PI

#

Just because the extra haste would change a bit how you could optimize the opener

#

it was mega cringe

#

And Nether Portal never needs to come back until they redesign it

#

Why they didnt make it based on soul shards spent instead of how many spenders you use during it is beyond all of us

nova kelp
#

they don't craft a spec with the intention that it works correctly every 2 mins when a completely separate class gives you specifically a buff

thorn thorn
#

They obviously dont design around that but it doesnt mean it doesnt happen by accident

nova kelp
#

like, that particular interaction had an insane throughput that we as a playerbase optimised the fuck out of

#

but the spec, like any spec, literally functions as intended, or attempts to in some cases lol

thorn thorn
#

Thats also part of the reason they are trying to kill the omega haste stacking in specs that are traditionally PI specs

#

Unholy got its haste stacking killed

#

And going into 11.2 it gets actually decent crit scaling

worthy rose
#

so what youre syaing is seaforium can actualy be a good trinket?

thorn thorn
worthy rose
#

and not a cope for unholy

thorn thorn
#

Yes

#

I havent been keeping up to date on what Taz has been saying

#

But his initial numbers said that with a decent amount of mastery crit will become very good

worthy rose
#

interesting

#

will we be crit mastery'ing in general as both unholy and frost

#

this would be excellent if i can gear both specs at the same time

#

with one set of gera

#

very based

thorn thorn
#

Unholy becomes a spec thats just a "wants everything" spec instead of just wanting only one or 2 stats

#

Haste probably still better a bit cuz pet spec

#

But ill let you discuss that with the people who actually play unholy

worthy rose
#

ive been starign to main frost

humble verge
#

so what the fuck

worthy rose
#

since that seesm to be the meta

humble verge
#

we are 37 raiders combined of officers, core and trials

#

💀

thorn thorn
#

?

humble verge
#

we are 37 raiders for next tier

#

somehow

haughty flicker
#

So uh

#

Does your guild expect 17 people to just sit on the bench without like

humble verge
#

no idea

haughty flicker
#

Just doing their own thing instead

humble verge
#

i have no idea

haughty flicker
#

Lmao

humble verge
#

i assume some of them have quit for next tier

#

well atleast i know

worthy rose
#

why would you ahve 17 people sit out

humble verge
#

2 of them

worthy rose
#

just pug 3 people to have two fully formed groups

haughty flicker
#

Maybe it's so you can do 10m and 25m

humble verge
#

out of all the 37 raiders

#

theres only like 4-5 healers

#

and 2 tanks

worthy rose
#

time to pull straws

#

the short straws have to respec blood

#

and whatever heal spec

haughty flicker
humble verge
#

lmao

haughty flicker
#

Which is kind of a core purpose of a bench

worthy rose
#

17 bench warmers is kinda wild tho

#

but i suppose guilds gotta do what a guild gotta do

humble verge
#

the thing is

worthy rose
#

i dont raid for that exact reason

humble verge
#

im the only rogue

#

:3

#

but idk why we've recruited so many wtf

#

:D

worthy rose
#

based

humble verge
#

weve had a lot of people join mid tier

worthy rose
#

raiding is such a huge commitment tho ngl

humble verge
#

this tier

worthy rose
#

some of us got stuff to do

#

haram to commit

humble verge
#

yeah

worthy rose
#

i cant sit there raiding for who knows how long

humble verge
#

i get that

haughty flicker
#

Why does the largest bench warmer not simply eat the smaller, weaker bench warmers

humble verge
#

thats manslaugther

haughty flicker
#

Don't leave evidence?

thorn thorn
#

But real talk tho raiding is a big commitment

#

I would love to do mythic or even CE raiding but no time to do it

worthy rose
#

same

#

i was super tempted to pay a guild to carry me just to kill oab for killscore

#

so i could dinar a bestinslot and hoc

#

but then i realized it wont be worthit for the minor dps increase

#

hope next season dk and rogue dont need raid gear

humble verge
#

are EU harunie

worthy rose
#

oce/na

humble verge
#

tough luck

worthy rose
#

unfortunate

thorn thorn
#

In the past when I tried to find an actual mythic team my availability being only tuesdays was understandably a massive deal breaker

worthy rose
#

if i had to make a concious choice between hitting up my fwb or raiding in wow and wiping for hours on end

#

yall know what id be choosing

thorn thorn
#

Im not sure what a fwb is

worthy rose
#

friend with benefits

thorn thorn
#

I think most of us would be making a similar choice

cursive frost
#

what talent should you drop if wanting to take iron wire?

humble verge
storm forum
#

same

#

and i think something has gone wrong if im saying that

thorn thorn
#

Right most of us would be choosing to raid

#

Cuz we got bosses to kill

haughty flicker
#

Sorry no fucking on Tuesdays or Thursdays I need to reclear

humble verge
#

i loved this beam

haughty flicker
#

That's a nice beam

humble verge
#

it was fun watching pugs die to it

#

:3

worthy rose
#

you know whats the funniest wipes

#

when ur doing gally

#

and the group gets gally to the last 5%

#

then you watch everyone forget what mechanics are and try greed fo rit

#

and wipe

#

no bombs done no nothing

#

just wipe

main bridge
#

hard not to find that frustrating tbh

humble verge
#

average pug

haughty flicker
#

incredibly based

#

everyone else shouldve done mechanics i need to parse in execute

humble verge
#

who in their right mind needs this

main bridge
#

probably people who fix PCs

humble verge
#

wtf is this supposed to mean

#

argussy

worthy rose
#

did you insert yourself somewhere u shouldnt have

haughty flicker
#

gussy up = dress up

humble verge
#

idk

haughty flicker
#

it aged a bit poorly

#

lmao

thorn thorn
#

Extremely poorly

worthy rose
#

nah nah

#

uber definitely inserted himself somewhere he shouldnt

thorn thorn
#

He always is

thorn thorn
#

Have you not been keeping up on the boost raid lore

worthy rose
#

boost raids?

worthy rose
#

how do i sign up to be a booster for raids

#

i need a group to actually raid gud with

humble verge
#

i am the boost raid lore

thorn thorn
#

Yes

worthy rose
#

i also found out outlaw is the single most boosted spec

#

holy shit

#

mythics and raids

#

so many dogshit outlaws

thorn thorn
#

Uber is always finding himself in groups he shouldnt be in

thorn thorn
worthy rose
#

yeah

#

we were all looking at the stats

#

and were like holy shit

marsh fjord
#

If lingering darkness isn't up and we get a clear the witness proc because we just consumed darkess night do we still use FOK in ST?

sharp turtle
#

do we know if rogue got any updates in the past week? or still looking the same

humble verge
#

see pins

#

if u ever need an answer

sharp turtle
#

i always forget the check pins, rogue updates theirs fairly frequently

#

do we know if sin is looking to be the play over outlaw

#

currently on ptr

marsh fjord
#

!fok

prisma monolithBOT
#

Fok Conditions Post-Buff
Fan of Knives as a generator to replace ambush/mutilate:

  • Baseline 3+ targets, -1 if talented into momentum of despair and thrown precision, +1 if talented into vicious venoms, +1 if talented into blindside. (Generally 5 with raid build, 3 with Bleed m+, 2 with Hybrid m+)
    Fan of Knives with Clear the Witnesses Up:
  • Baseline 2+ targets, -1 if lingering darkness is up or you aren't talented into vicious venoms. With Vicious Venoms casting during lingering darkness is dps neutral.
    Fan of Knives with Darkest Night Up:
  • Only on 2+ targets, or without Vicious Venoms talented. This is also a very very minor optimization

The most important to remember is the generator rules, clear the witnesses and darkest night optimizations can be effectively ignored as they are not meaningful DPS improvements

humble verge
#

i have 3 assa rogues

sharp turtle
#

does that mean sin shits on outlaw

drifting cloud
#

whens the last time you saw outlaw on high end prog

humble verge
#

no

#

i just have 3 assa rogues

pure moth
haughty flicker
pure moth
#

Still weeks away from live

haughty flicker
#

its pretty neat

sharp turtle
humble verge
haughty flicker
thorn thorn
#

Pixel machine 🅱️ roke

haughty flicker
humble verge
thorn thorn
#

Damn wtf

#

I want my sin rogue 🅱️oneless

humble verge
#

man

#

sethical still makes videos

#

wtf

thorn thorn
#

Incredibly deep fried meme

humble verge
#

what in the hell is this hella sword

#

how have i not seen it before

#

he holdin nothin ❗

haughty flicker
#

yeah its dumb as fuck

#

which sucks because it would otherwise be awesome

humble verge
#

nah i bought it

haughty flicker
#

also you havent seen it before because it wasnt added until this week

humble verge
#

fuk de haters

#

ohlol

#

do people even spend TW shit on this

humble verge
#

man

#

its like

#

over 1,5m to fully upgrade all the heirlooms(that you can get from the heirloom vendor) what in the hell

#

its probably 2m if you count the quests and rewards heirloom

main bridge
#

i don't think it's really worth especially with the XP event and timewalking

#

just a massive goldsink

humble verge
#

yeah

#

i didnt imply it was ever worth it

#

even just grinding df dungeons

#

outside TW is worth i txd

#

if u want to

shy creek
#

!fok

prisma monolithBOT
#

Fok Conditions Post-Buff
Fan of Knives as a generator to replace ambush/mutilate:

  • Baseline 3+ targets, -1 if talented into momentum of despair and thrown precision, +1 if talented into vicious venoms, +1 if talented into blindside. (Generally 5 with raid build, 3 with Bleed m+, 2 with Hybrid m+)
    Fan of Knives with Clear the Witnesses Up:
  • Baseline 2+ targets, -1 if lingering darkness is up or you aren't talented into vicious venoms. With Vicious Venoms casting during lingering darkness is dps neutral.
    Fan of Knives with Darkest Night Up:
  • Only on 2+ targets, or without Vicious Venoms talented. This is also a very very minor optimization

The most important to remember is the generator rules, clear the witnesses and darkest night optimizations can be effectively ignored as they are not meaningful DPS improvements

humble verge
#

prayge

#

no fucking mount

runic hinge
humble verge
humble verge
static glacier
#

lowkey

#

I just thought about the whole assassin trope

#

in rpgs

#

I swear rogue should have amazing dmg on target swap thematically speaking

#

how did this happen

thorn thorn
#

"DoT" class

haughty flicker
#

i never really understood how bleeds made sense anyway

#

poisons absolutely

#

but you dont really think of an assassin shanking someone and hoping they bleed out

main bridge
#

if you watch any show about prison you'll see it works quite well

haughty flicker
#

like the name garrote is thematic but not the game mechanic

cinder geode
#

I just realized looking at m+ rotation for next season are we just going to have to farm another pacemaker and another signet

haughty flicker
#

depends on the tuning of the new trinkets

#

but its certainly a possibility

amber brook
#

Atleast its not the same chance of getting a skardyns

main bridge
#

i won't miss Rookery

nova kelp
#

we will probably use completely different dungeon trinkets to those tbh

#

our trinkets this season were kinda ass compared to others

true rapids
amber brook
#

we all share the trauma

rotund oak
haughty flicker
#

!wa

prisma monolithBOT
zenith elm
#

If i need to get a signet, i just wont ☠️

#

I hated having to skew my stats for it

thorn thorn
worthy rose
#

just keep running the dungeon nonstop

#

until you get a hero track

#

and then youre bing chilling

#

then prayge to the rngesus of teh welfare vault

#

would be crackup if rogues use signet and seaforium again in s3

humble verge
#

why tho

waxen oyster
#

i had ib talented on bandit

#

and ofc we dont wipe

humble verge
#

lmao

waxen oyster
#

also we kill gally too fast now

#

7min adds not spawning

thorn thorn
native escarp
#

yea that was it

#

ty

rotund oak
humble verge
#

lol

rotund oak
#

so i had to lvl up a rogue on every possible race it can be

humble verge
#

its around

#

a bit under 19k

#

per piece of armour

#

might do that myself icl

#

xD

#

esp now that its the uh

#

exp thing too

rotund oak
#

yup

humble verge
#

but im doing the darkfuse stuff

rotund oak
#

im not playing retail atm,prepin' for mop launch

humble verge
#

670 more

native escarp
#

also with blindside

#

do we cast ambush -> mutilate if we have the proc

waxen oyster
#

You’re implying you have a choice.

balmy condor
#

yeh, there is simply no way to cast mutilate if you have the proc

native escarp
#

oh ok

#

so i can just press the same keybind?

#

or it wont let u

balmy condor
#

it overrides mutilate, yes

quiet oar
#

Took them only more than a year to figure out the tech garf_sit

runic hinge
#

assa was better when you had to do it manually

#

And I had a seperate ambush keybind

quiet oar
#

Assa was also better when Tea wasnt used automatically

waxen oyster
#

assa was better when it wasnt poison themed sub

#

wtf is this env spam

runic hinge
#

bring back exs_uwu

quiet oar
#

Kind of true

#

Well

#

Bleed Build isnt

#

so

waxen oyster
#

Yeah but that requires you to minigame

quiet oar
#

???

waxen oyster
#

aka m+

quiet oar
#

Yeah

#

Remember when KIngsbane was good

waxen oyster
#

i do like the people who choose to play assa

quiet oar
#

like in S3 DF

waxen oyster
#

then complain the spec is slow

#

when its the fastest its ever been

quiet oar
#

i remember

waxen oyster
#

yeah depending on PI

#

no thank you

#

but make kb real again

quiet oar
#

You could play without

#

it wasnt mandatory

waxen oyster
#

Idk i had to do cauldron this week

#

without warrior on monk buff

quiet oar
#

I couldnt care less so deep in farm about this

waxen oyster
#

idk raid buffs are dumb

#

but they’re stopping 10 mage comps

misty holly
#

Then no one would have to be upset that their parse was bad because no warrior in the group.

#

Then Blizzard could also balance the classes who don't bring a raid buff up to match the real output of those who do bring one.

quiet oar
#

Nah bro

#

Thats

#

cooked

#

like cooked cooked

misty holly
#

Nah its just a different way of looking at the situation. Classes who bring a buff are way stronger than parses will show the way it is now. Especially if you are looking at smaller raid sizes where the choice between a monk or a rogue could be a massive amount of lost output for the team.

#

that doesnt show up on the personal monk or the rogues log

#

Historically there was no good way to display that difference. But blizzard's api and warcraft logs had to do a lot of work to make it so aug evokers contribution could be shown.

#

Now that the work is done, why not also show the contribution from other raid buffs?

quiet oar
#

Im sorry thats cooked. You cant really attribute that. Like Skyfury is the first Problem

normal mist
#

The skyfury might be the first problem, but the real problem is even caring about it at all

red schooner
#

It'd be interesting as a toggle, just to see how valuable the buff is to the raid as a whole. For some fights last season our only options were no warrior buff or a floortank warrior so, knowing the numbers in order to decide what was best would have been nice

humble verge
#

man, actually getting new earpads is literally night and day, never gonna delay fixing that shit again Xd

balmy condor
#

biggest issue is that the math doesn't add up

#

like it's REALLY difficult to reverse the buffs out with the way that blizzard set them up

#

near impossible tbh

hearty seal
#

is this because some are additive and some are multiplicative?

balmy condor
#

yeah that's always the comparison

#

bUt FiNaL fAnTaSy CaN dO iT wHy NoT wOw

#

but then you look at the actual like

#

"raid buffs" from ffxiv

#

and it's straight up like

subtle tundra
#

6% DAM

balmy condor
#

5% damage for 20 seconds

#

reversing out 5% damage is VERY easy

subtle tundra
#

me when complex things are complex

balmy condor
#

reversing out a chance for your auto attacks to double attack during kingsbane when to apply a doubled poison

#

is not easy

hearty seal
#

yeah they introduced that kind of separation the very same expac as FFXIV lost any kind of complex buff

#

and made everything into a +% damage (one +% critchance, I think?)

normal mist
#

They know how to keep it simple

hearty seal
#

too simple tbh

#

I miss old Astro cards

#

yes 30% of them were pretty useless, not a good enough reason to make them all into flat damage boosts

royal lantern
hearty seal
royal lantern
#

i mean, wow also has a 2min or 90sec focus

#

the difference is

#

that there is a actual difference bettwen the specs

#

some are more cd focused, others less, playstyles are different

hearty seal
#

and there's outlaw who has like IDK
no actual burst, maybe a 30 second one if that counts lmao

royal lantern
#

ff just has the problem that everytning is literally a reskin of eachother

hearty seal
#

yeah it used to be different enough, then ShB started

#

DRK had like
a 40s/80s burst but not a big one

normal mist
#

I enjoyed FF more when I didn't need to play piano on some jobs to do the openings

#

Like ninja p.e

royal lantern
#

even if people dont like it

hearty seal
#

when was NIN not a piano job for an opener
like back in ARR?...

royal lantern
#

ff has this weird thing where almost always you just get new abilitys, but there is no depth

#

so its just another button you press in your 100% static cd window

hearty seal
#

StB it was a hilarious level of piano because of oGCD mudras

jade maple
#

Hi - Anyone who has a 1 bottom poison macro?

normal mist
#

Above that holy moly

hearty seal
#

80 got super chill after they made mudras GCD (in like, 5.07 or 5.1, don't recall the exact patch, but before second savage tier)
then apparently someone said "hey wtf NIN is chill? who did this, make it not chill, stat" for EW

quiet oar
#

Isnt the gcd higher

#

In ff

hearty seal
#

yes but some classes compensate by having a lot of off-GCD abilities to weave

#

NIN basically had, at some point, a 2.2 GCD but during burst they had to weave four 0.5s buttons into those GCDs

royal lantern
royal lantern
hearty seal
#

currently, ye

grim jay
#

And even funnier is, that wow specs are slow aswell

royal lantern
#

like, back in ShB, ninja was the highest apm job in ff, and it had the same apm as assa rogue lol

grim jay
#

So its snail vs turtle

royal lantern
#

its like league players talking about high apm because they click the same spot 30x

hearty seal
#

there was a point during which NIN was like
60-65 APM even with 2.2 GCD, just due to their burst being very intense

hearty seal
grim jay
#

And they have actual Inputs to remember

#

Not 1 2 3 4 5 6

#
  • Animation cancels and no gcd
royal lantern
#

animation cancels are a sing of failed game Design tbh

#

like, its the most obvious "we didnt actually want this" thing possible

hearty seal
#

ESO has them
and guess what's the worst part of ESO, the combat

#

they spent 10 years covering for LA cancelling

grim jay
#

So big games like LoL and most Action combat games fail in game Design. garf

hearty seal
#

as if it was not obviously a bug

royal lantern
#

no game makes animations with the intended gameplay being you not seeing them dracthyr_kek

hearty seal
#

like DMC pretty much assumes you will anim cancel at some skill level

#

but in an MMO, eh

grim jay
#

As they had the chance to fix it but embraced it

royal lantern
hearty seal
royal lantern
#

and didnt do it cus of "MUH SKILL EXPRESSION ON RIVEN" outcry

grim jay
#

And they found a way, but kept it in

#

Ye

#

Because its actually legit

hearty seal
#

(I have not played LoL for 5 years now and thank God for that every day)

grim jay
#

Anyways, no matter how you look at it, even the high apm specs in WoW are only high apm specs in WoW, not anything insanely fast in the grand scheme

hearty seal
#

dunno, they're fast enough in actual encounters
that is, they'd get unpleasant if they were noticeably faster for the most part, like anything above 80-90 APM would likely be oof

royal lantern
#

it often feels like as if people saw the "starcraft players have 3056702025070206882 APM" 15years ago, and then decided that its some meassurement for serious competitive gameplay

grim jay
#

65yo Hildegard on her last weeks of work at a secretary could manage any specs apm just fine without breaking a sweat

Ye its a dumb thing, dunno why people always think it has any value or brings difficulty at all

#

Or the whole "cant play bcs it hurts" topic. If thats the case you either cant because you know you have an illness or you should get a check up

royal lantern
#

like jfc

#

get a checkup or stop

#

you literally fuck your wrist into permanent dmg at that point, thats not funny, thats a serious issue

#

pain means something is wrong

grim jay
#

Its insane ngl

hearty seal
#

the moment Outlaw migrates to just two guns, forever, I will find out if I have any wrist problems (doesn't look like it so far)

grim jay
#

Making it a close range gunslinger would actually be better than what it is now

#

Or remove the gun and make it a duelist

hearty seal
earnest remnant
grim jay
#

And then the whole duelist theme

#

Close to the fencing stuff

earnest remnant
#

if its like a how do i put it, similar to soreness and it gets a bit tight, you are more than likely very fine and just got fuck all for support muscles in your wrists/hands

grim jay
#

Ye at that point its just being physically underdeveloped

#

Which sounds worse than I mean it

earnest remnant
#

if seen alot of people complain about wrist pain when it wasent actually "pain" if that makes sense

#

just muscles going for a run

hearty seal
earnest remnant
#

that to me without knowing anything about you, sounds like poor bloodflow

grim jay
grim jay
#

Or you let your wrist rest badly

earnest remnant
#

to be fair that could literally happen cuz of bad hand position or putting to much force down onto your table when playing

hearty seal
#

hmmm
if I think about it, I only started getting it a month ago or so, close to when I got a new table

#

oh well, time for a checkup anyway

earnest remnant
#

i had the same issue in my old apartment cuz my desk was too high

#

without realizing i was using a bit of froce to press down my arms on the table

#
  • got shoulder pains from the desk being to high
iron carbon
#

Next purchase is an adaptative desk

grim jay
#

Adjustable desks, even up to standing height, got surprisingly cheap

#

Mine luckily had a good manual adjustment and I have a decently expensive chair thats fine-tunable, but I will certainly get one of those desks in the next years

red schooner
#

Good morning Royal

normal mist
#

Good morning my friend

iron carbon
normal mist
#

I'm in need of my annual vacations but this year I'm pretty fucked

#

All of it will be me spending money and working on the new room

#

Working in a factory is good and bad

iron carbon
#

I got the feeling

#

Renovating my appartement

#

Every free day is spending money or time working

livid folio
#

Whats the generell opinion on assa for 11.2? Good bad dumpsterfire?

#

Would Like to go back to my old main from Classic to Cata but IF assa nor sub are decent… dont wanna play outlaw 😂

normal mist
#

Did you play this patch?

#

Next patch will be similar basically

#

Unless ptr changes happen

livid folio
#

I played my rogue in keys to like 2k something, dont think i got to raide with it yet

normal mist
#

Wait

iron carbon
#

If you play at this level, don't care about the numbers

normal mist
#

LOL

iron carbon
#

Just care about the feeling

normal mist
#

Exactly

#

@livid folio if you ain't a mythic raider rwf nor a top 1% mythic plus player, spec does not matter

#

If you like it, play it

worthy rose
#

royal D flux becoming royal DAD flux

normal mist
#

D was already for daddy

#

:3

worthy rose
iron carbon
#

Even for 1%, you can play what you want

#

I mean, if you don't try hard title or RWF

worthy rose
#

realistically like 80% of wow players could just use the one button rotation and do better than they would themselves

#

the remaining 20% are capped by skill issue than build issue

#

then the top 1% are the pioneers leading whatever fuckin around theyr doing

#

like when zeross comes in with a cooked build but makes it work and makes a meme about it

#

wow just aint that competitive

#

just have a good time

iron carbon
#

Can't be more accurate

worthy rose
#

people who try to competitize the game are braindeadge

normal mist
worthy rose
#

memes be memes

iron carbon
#

Unless you pvp prolly

midnight mist
iron carbon
#

Oh no, he's awake

midnight mist
#

he thinks, and is probably right, that his build is better and more competitive

#

litteraly r1 try harder

normal mist
#

He's french, it's almost 11:30 pm for him, or is it 12:30?

iron carbon
#

IT's 11:30 AM

midnight mist
#

and you take him as an example zerossthinking

#

ye

#

11:23

iron carbon
#

Same hour than here

worthy rose
#

but im sayin even at rank 1 builds dont quite matter coz zeross and other players racing for r1 can make it work

#

coz its still skill issue based even at the top end

#

and sometimes even team issue based

#

some team comps work better with some builds etc

normal mist
#

10:24 here in Portugal, that's why I assumed 1 hour later there

iron carbon
#

You right buddy

#

Portugal is like UK isn't?

normal mist
#

Yes

iron carbon
#

France is like half of Europe

#

Hey Zac, where you come from in France?

#

Sunny or rainy side?

midnight mist
midnight mist
iron carbon
#

Ocean or Sea?

midnight mist
#

sea

#

im close to marseille

iron carbon
#

Montpellier or Marseille?

#

Oh too slow

#

Really close to Marseille? Or close like Toulon/Aix-En-Provence?

livid folio
normal mist
#

I said rwf

midnight mist
normal mist
#

You got rwl

livid folio
normal mist
livid folio
normal mist
#

If you enjoy assa, you Will do good

livid folio
midnight mist
normal mist
#

Yes, but we are rogues, we've accepted that long time ago

iron carbon
#

Or be #1 liek Zac

#

And just get into everykey

#

I've seen a lot of keys asking for outlaw in 20/21

#

I wonder why "outlaw" and not "rogue"

livid folio
#

Bleed build should profit from monk Buff in a phys comp no?

iron carbon
#

Correct

midnight mist
#

im actually surprised the top rogues all stayed assa still

#

didnt care

iron carbon
#

I think the permanent feint/Evasion helps, yes

#

Easier to play

#

I could give a shot bac kto outlaw

#

Didn't touch since TWW

normal mist
#

Bunch of OTPs having fun

livid folio
#

He only plays outlaw for whatever reason

iron carbon
#

Outlaw is fun

#

I mean, I enjoy everyspec equally

#

I swap between tier depending of feature

livid folio
#

I dont like the fantasy behind it

iron carbon
#

You're a Pirate

craggy folio
#

also a weird excuse not to play one of the best feeling specs in the game

normal mist
#

I don't like pirates

livid folio
#

A rogue is daggers and SHADOW ASSSASIB KILLER DEATH NOOB DESTROYER

normal mist
#

Millen gets it

craggy folio
#

a rogue is a "a dishonest or unprincipled person." nothing about daggers

normal mist
#

Be gone, yellow pirate!

#

🦜

#

Freehold is an amazing dungeon tho

earnest remnant
#

in BFA it was a shithole

grim jay
rotund oak
earnest remnant
#

it was not fine

#

maybe if you only did your weekly key in it

rotund oak
#

u are hatin'

earnest remnant
#

no

#

the dungeon design was absolutely horseshit

rotund oak
#

yeah i did push higher keys in BFA

grim jay
earnest remnant
#

having to line of sight 2/4 bosses

#

or get 1 tapped

#

is not a good dungeon

#

design

rotund oak
#

imagine not having 2nd gear set vers stacked

worthy rose
normal mist
#

I did it +15 and it seemed fine

worthy rose
#

but i recall him doing some meme builds here and there

earnest remnant
#

i still killed you

#

-.-

rotund oak
#

yeah it might

warm vortex
#

Rogue is a scallywag

#

A real scoundrel

earnest remnant
#

not might

#

it did

warm vortex
#

Miscreant, even

rotund oak
#

it wasnt always certain

earnest remnant
#

or you pull first boss

#

and he decided

#

you dont get to live

#

and shoots you 3 times in a row

rotund oak
#

and u could vanish/evasion/clos stuff

earnest remnant
#

you could not

rotund oak
#

u are insane

earnest remnant
#

the frontal shot killed you

rotund oak
#

if u got hit by the frontal

#

u suckd

#

sry to tell u

earnest remnant
#

thats why you LoS'd

#

ffs

#

nah cba

rotund oak
#

yeah so u wouldnt get hit

midnight mist
warm vortex
midnight mist
#

im unsure if outlaw is better than assa even

warm vortex
#

Ohhhhh

normal mist
#

Also omg hi ven

warm vortex
#

I’m stupid

normal mist
#

No your ven

warm vortex
#

Hi (soon to be dad) royallll

rotund oak
warm vortex
rotund oak
#

RoyalDaddy

normal mist
#

D stands for Daddy yes :3

grim jay
normal mist
normal mist
#

XD

grim jay
#

I guess

normal mist
#

Hello davyn, how have you been?

jade maple
#

In AOE then spreading garrot and rupture during Indiscriminate Carnage window. Do I just stick to my main target with Deathstalkers mark from my main target or do i want swap around and try find my main target after? I really hope that i can stay on my main target and spread it like "ignite".

normal mist
#

You choose your main target and that's it

#

Once he dies or you gain DN you can swap it to another target

#

DSMis only applied to 1 target

livid folio
#

Well you can spread it to 6 targets instead of 5 and then go back to your main Target. Use a mouseover macro

#

IF you garotte and rupture on a target which doesnt have it yet

#

But you open on your main Target to Apply your mark

jade maple
#

Okay - So I can "minmax" a bit with that or just keep is simple and stick to my main target.

livid folio
#

You loose 1 garrote and 1 rupture if you dont swap

jade maple
#

Do you by any chance have that marco? 🙂

frosty nebula
#

why do zeros and shin play without crimson talent? dont they miss to much on aoe dmg?

winter prairie
#

Poison build is still the best in 11.2?

livid folio
jade maple
#

Thanks for the help.

earnest remnant
# rotund oak yeah so u wouldnt get hit

thats why its a shit design being forced to LoS it is not good boss design, 2/4 bosses having a straight up 1 tap targeted shot was rediculously garbage it just straight up is and the fact that on first boss not all races could LoS it so you had to use fcking toys or while on the bird he could back2back2back shoot the same guy and there was nothing you could do to live that piss rng, you have to have serious rose tinted glasses on to not see that as bad design

winter prairie
#

Bleed build is still the best in 11.2?*

earnest remnant
#

its like calling legion the best wow expansion when it was the absolute worst for over half of it

#

cuz people only remember the last half

livid folio
warm vortex
winter prairie
#

In m+ I mean

red schooner
warm vortex
#

???

#

The bleed build and poison builds are only a thing in M+

#

Ofc

grim jay
winter prairie
#

Ahh nice ty

red schooner
normal mist
prisma monolithBOT
#

Bleed vs Hybrid vs Cleave/FI builds
Broad rules and Section in Guide:

  1. If you have to ask, you should play bleed
  2. If you're not doing +17's or higher (or rookery), you should play bleed

Some general concepts as to why people play different things:

  • Ease of play: Bleed build is simply the easiest to play due to subterfuge/no kingsbane/less need for giant prio targets
  • Boss damage: The cleave/zeross build is mainly for boss damage. Assa single target in keys is pretty bad, and the bosses would not be possible otherwise
  • Specific Dungeons: Rookery as an example is very boss-heavy, especially the last boss, making bleed less ideal.
  • Where the damage is: Bleed spreads out its damage and does great overall due to sudden demise and powerful 3-8 target damage. Hybrid is competitve but doesn't pull ahead until bigger AoE. Cleave is for single target damage and insanely large aoe because of how much caustic and crimson tempest carry aoe damage.
normal mist
warm vortex
normal mist
#

You can

warm vortex
#

On hight keys

livid folio
warm vortex
#

No use doing it on a 12 or smth

#

i was moreso talking like, super high keys

normal mist
warm vortex
normal mist
#

Not just because of shin

grim jay
normal mist
grim jay
normal mist
#

SAME

warm vortex
#

I have a battery filled with silly juice

livid folio
warm vortex
#

sometimes it works, sometimes it doesnt

normal mist
#

People used to swap in necrotic wake too

warm vortex
normal mist
#

For the last boss

warm vortex
#

Tried DR and it's really fun

#

I remember trying MM earlier in the season and not liking it, but it feels more fun now
Even if there haven't been any changes lol

grim jay
#

DR?

warm vortex
#

Dark ranger

#

Hunter thingies

#

Think of sub rogue but with a gun

#

Like it even has black bleak powder

royal lantern