#pvp

1 messages · Page 128 of 1

uneven grove
#

tbh i would love only more posion damage, cus i feel like especially next patch, assa playstyle will go around only bleeds

#

dot up and run away until kidney back

#

assa is not really rewarded for staying on target that much

peak agate
#

Envenom is kind of shot

vocal surge
#

You have enough energy to sustain 20 seconds of opening on your target

peak agate
#

the moon has to align with other planets to hit hard with that ablitiy

vocal surge
#

instead of using SnD to buff your melee attacks from sources like HO Ambush or Improved AR you spam Crackshot BTE

uneven grove
#

it should increase posion damage too

#

ofc you do more damage if you stay in fight, but considering the tankiness of assa and bleed damage on PTR

#

you just better off dot up multiple targets and chill above 100 energy

peak agate
#

alternatively they can leave us squishy but let us keep the damage.

#

we can be a fire mage that can't kite

vocal surge
potent pivot
#

No

shadow creek
peak agate
#

For our Asassination mains, how would you feel about turning Ambush into our version of Colossus Smash? Fits thematically with an Assassination surpirsing a opponent and making them vulnerable to extra damage for a period. If you have dispatch talent, makes our execute windows crazy. Would mean Ambush loses its poison damage from talent. Can nerfed the percentage pretty easily. Sort of get vendetta back but not really.

vocal surge
#

Another thing to note, Crackshot windows make it extremely punishing to players who overextend and LOS their healer which I see as an absolute win

jolly sierra
#

like dispatch in former xps

#

but having a safe use, like warr one, rather than procs

peak agate
jolly sierra
#

just about their execute

#

our colossus smash is shiv, if u wanna to compare

peak agate
#

then our excute would be zoldyck would be our "execute"

jolly sierra
#

something like that

#

when AP appeared ppl was trying to use it a lot in SS alongside zoldyck but was ending being dropped

#

very few ppl in high rating used it

#

maybe will be good again now w rework cuz u have kingsbane

#

also DTB is nerfed, so

#

(btw how tf i drop DTB in my discord name i wanna switch it to exsang lol)

peak agate
jolly sierra
#

maybe in aoe, but not in single

peak agate
#

I don't think so either, I'm just thinking of thematic improvements. We both agree its more of defensive problem for pvp.

sour charm
#

Damage is always the problem
Class bad? Give more damage
Suddenly class good!

#

I mean it worked for WW for multiple xpacs in a row lmao

#

The thing I am confused about is the change to indiscriminate carnage

#

in PvE it took the niche of a nice aoe silence for packs, and it still keeps assa with the issue of needing to restealth to do any damage in m+

waxen meteor
#

Well in a way everything can be fixed by dmg

sour charm
#

I like what they did with Crimson Tempest though from a design standpoint.
Altho I still think the heavy bleed focus of Assa is weird and should lean more into poisons

peak agate
potent pivot
#

I think the new exsanguinates are going to lead to some interesting new play

#

The IC changes does irk me a little bit, but I don’t think it was that crazy good in 3s anyway. Mostly just rbg’s

sour charm
#

I fully believe that anyone who took an assa to zerg in an RBG was kinda griefing to begin with
Not that it couldn't do good numbers of course, but its just very fragile compared to other melees.

Now sitting at a base with the 2set that makes every rupture tick stop capping? Thats meme worthy

peak agate
jolly sierra
#

that is the biggest rock in the boot game has right now

#

since that shit was prominent in legion everything went to downfall in playstyle

halcyon timber
#

I don’t remember hearing that much over the years till legion

sour charm
#

Hot Take: Give me WoD assa back

halcyon timber
#

We asked lol

jolly sierra
#

would rather bring wod sub back

halcyon timber
#

Early legion and lessons from the past that made things work inspired this talent revamp

peak agate
halcyon timber
#

So in a way, it is without going back in time

peak agate
#

Garrote was only useable in stealth when i stop playing

#

lol

halcyon timber
#

Yeah lots of stuff changed , some good and some not so nice but yeah

#

Im happy we can do different stuff in the trees and customize stuff. Yeah it takes a little more input on stuff but that feels rewarding and engaging

sour charm
halcyon timber
#

Aint no way they would let ambush do 1/3 of someone’s life again

#

As an example

#

Shit wasn’t balanced and that’s why things hit as hard as they did

peak agate
halcyon timber
#

Didn’t have all we have today and alot of that wouldn’t fly

#

Yeah envenom used to be the do buster

peak agate
#

nothing about this game is truly balance

halcyon timber
#

Dk*

#

“Balance” is relative and subjective

#

If we smoke someone in a kidney we are happy and others are not

#

If we don’t then it sucks because that’s our thing

#

It is what it is

jolly sierra
#

that is another issue about assa

halcyon timber
#

I don’t ever wanna creep the ridiculously strong line, nerfs gotta happen

jolly sierra
#

envenom is fkn lackluster as a finisher

#

and u need to rely in ER to make it hit decently

halcyon timber
#

Either too strong or jack crap isn’t good and what we have on ptr is great

sour charm
#

Yeah but who cares about finisher damage when the target dies at 35% in the next patch.

#

I am sure that will stay for 1 week and then gets dumpstered

halcyon timber
#

Its not ridiculous ( a few outliers before tuning) but our kits feel solid

jolly sierra
#

that is being fixed according to blues

#

right now

sour charm
#

Ah

jolly sierra
#

in next build

sour charm
#

I mean it makes sense

halcyon timber
#

Yeah lots of changes next build

#

For us

peak agate
# halcyon timber “Balance” is relative and subjective

its a general thing I notice because I have played every class at some point. The amount of cheese and modifers abuse is on another level and to be honest thats what I love about pvp in this game. If you can still win after all the BS you are truly good lol

sour charm
#

I wonder if "fixed" means its a dead talent in pvp

#

Cause then we just play DTB again

halcyon timber
#

Shouldn’t be based around an ability or successful only because of X as an example

#

Like heaven forbid they tune assassination around the execute bleed and hur hur thats it foe you guys

#

That aint fun or cool

zealous sand
#

blunt question, will honor transfer into s3 as it did to s2?

halcyon timber
#

Yes but not conquest

zealous sand
#

aite cool, saving honor then instead of gearing now+stacking honor

halcyon timber
#

Unless the announce other wise

#

They

zealous sand
#

ye

peak agate
peak agate
vocal surge
#

hmm
reading the forums and seeing people say RTB feels bad is weird

jolly sierra
#

the problem with gimmick playstyle

vocal surge
#

considering RTB is a lot better with 4p in ptr than in retail

jolly sierra
#

is noticed in sub

#

and shadow dance

#

if it gets tuned hard

#

it become shit

#

that is the reason we asked to not having gimmicks in reworks

#

or will happen the same later

halcyon timber
#

But my point is , they shouldn’t base you guys around that at all

#

Hur hur it strong got mah 2k and logged b4 da nurfs

sour charm
#

Demise tuning for PvP is quite volatile though

#

Since without bleeds up we do basically negative damage

halcyon timber
#

Yeah its gotta be toned down for sure

#

Core focus has to be the play

sour charm
#

So if they nerf it too hard, its a self sabotage to pick it

#

like, enemy drops below 35%, takes like 80k damage, and all bleeds are then gone

#

what are you gonna do, spam mutilate them to death?

halcyon timber
#

So lets talk poisons, whats the deal and your thoughts on that for you assassination kids

jolly sierra
#

don't be so fatalist, maybe they won't nerf it too much

sour charm
#

Deadly Poison should be a passive that applies from every lethal poison

jolly sierra
#

well, im not picking DTB if the proc rate is so shitty

halcyon timber
#

Well what additional effcts can mutilate do? Anything cool like the ambush one doing filthy hits?

jolly sierra
#

if they wanna make us use it well

#

just give us back deadly brew

sour charm
#

There should also be SOME form of dot protection

#

not just poisons, but bleeds too

halcyon timber
#

Isn’t that what dtb does essentially but more?

#

Deadly was just throwing in wound on top

#

Db*

sour charm
#

DTB feels like an "essential" pick for PvP even though it should not be

#

Because if you dont run deadly you lose a lot of free damage

peak agate
#

Poison bomb should be an active ablitiy that changes based on the poison you have.

halcyon timber
#

So did amplifying kick the bucket?

sour charm
#

Wound already does half of the dmg instant poison does on application

sour charm
#

Amplifying has not seen active play in idk how long

halcyon timber
#

Yeah wound was never a heavy hitter , aint supposed to be

sour charm
#

Mostly because Envenom does no damage

jolly sierra
#

amp was tested in early season

sour charm
#

Envenom also doesn't scale from out mastery

jolly sierra
#

but ended being dropped after we discovered wound poison effect stacked hard with deathmark

sour charm
#

Which is the go-to stat in pvp

jolly sierra
halcyon timber
#

Ok what buffs envenom on ptr ( bc f live)
-shiv and ?

sour charm
#

I am 99% sure it doesnt

peak agate
#

it does

sour charm
#

since mastery buffs poison damage, and envenom is classified as nature

halcyon timber
#

What talents add up to make envenom do more?

peak agate
#

just amp

#

and i guess zoldyck

sour charm
#

Shiv technically

jolly sierra
#

wht the heck

sour charm
#

do you count that as a talent?

jolly sierra
#

yeah true

halcyon timber
#

Shiv and z

jolly sierra
#

though was all ur nature dmg

#

rather than poisons

halcyon timber
#

So what 35% + 20% from shiv

#

And what else?

jolly sierra
#

ER

sour charm
#

I mean

halcyon timber
#

Wouldn’t count er

sour charm
#

And MFD

#

in the rework

halcyon timber
#

Nature wise

sour charm
#

is 15%?

halcyon timber
#

Teag mfd is sick

jolly sierra
#

count it, is in the staple playstyle sadly

halcyon timber
#

Yeah *

#

Yeah but nature wise

sour charm
#

The thing with Envenom is, in PvE it is balanced as an upkeep buff

#

since it gives you more crit on your poisons, more application rate, poison crits give energy

#

But in PvP you can't just stay in as Assa

#

since you obviously die

halcyon timber
#

Didn’t they talk about it in the pve channel too recently?

#

About how they “want “ to be rotty

jolly sierra
#

i don't go there anymore

halcyon timber
#

And unfortunately pvp gets no say / limited input

sour charm
#

Rotty is fine, but rotty + needing uptime is death in pve

#

Look at other rot specs

halcyon timber
#

Because what they push us > directly spills into our world

sour charm
#

Feral was Bleed and Run

peak agate
jolly sierra
#

last time basically deleted all my comments and then later said i would be muted if i come back

sour charm
#

Affli was Dot and Run

halcyon timber
#

Uncool man

sour charm
#

We are dot and..... auto attack poison procs?

halcyon timber
#

Youre a rogue

#

You have a voice

sour charm
#

It just doesn't work very well as a concept

halcyon timber
#

Didn’t know they own it .. funny

jolly sierra
#

u dot cc and run a lot

#

cuz ur defensives are shit

sour charm
#

Not on a class that is squishy

peak agate
#

and no frontloaded damage

sour charm
#

It feels very similar to how UH was?

#

You sit on someone and they just rot to unhealable damage

#

just that we don't survive like DKs

#

and our damage is not unhealable

peak agate
#

cause for me to get a 100k envenom I have to get lucky

sour charm
#

The new design of Assa being heavily built on dumping energy in a go, even in pve, should help with that

#

But then we are in the niche of "oh they only do damage during Exsang"

jolly sierra
#

dk has death strike

#

had spellwarding too

halcyon timber
#

Pp strike

jolly sierra
#

and the benefit of plate armor

#

can dispell the stuns

#

the fears

#

and shit like that

halcyon timber
#

rOzgUeS hAv BubBlE

#

No we don’t shaddup nerd

jolly sierra
#

yesterday was arguing w my healer

#

he was saying assa defensives were good enough

#

i said to him "then why assa is known as the squishiest pvp rog spec across all 3?"

halcyon timber
#

Dunno healers should be doung pretty dang well if they aren’t cc’d

#

They all just got buffs on ptr too

#

Doing *

sour charm
#

Also, I stand corrected. Mastery does indeed Scale envenoms damage.
Even though the Mastery states Poison damage only.

Which makes Envenom doing negative damage in a full mastery build even funnier honestly.

halcyon timber
#

It was changed in bfa to poisons and bleeds no?

jolly sierra
#

no its the typo

#

rechecked again

#

it is indeed modified by mastery

waxen meteor
#

I feel playing marksman and sub rogue at sub2100 are entirely different games

peak agate
halcyon timber
#

Ptr?

peak agate
#

no thats live

jolly sierra
#

in the list of modifiers

sour charm
#

Is that against a Dummy or a player

halcyon timber
#

Ah mk

peak agate
#

i do see 120k crits here and there

halcyon timber
#

Yeah matches up

sour charm
#

With deathmark Amp poison yeah?

peak agate
#

its not often

peak agate
jolly sierra
#

imo they just buff the dmg by 10/20% talented

#

i don't wanna rely in too much gimmicks

halcyon timber
#

Need to pull up a talent tree

#

And plot this shit out like we did a few weeks ago

sour charm
#

I mean having to have: Trinket/Proc up, Shiv up, 2x 10stack AMP in Vendetta, and then hope for a crit, on someone with no defensives up

#

for "Eh" damage compared to other finishers/big hits

halcyon timber
#

Realz said he would be back in a week or 2 because hes working on dh now w his team

sour charm
#

is still pretty funny

peak agate
sour charm
#

With how Assa is currently designed it is not supposed to be a big nuke.
And that is fine

#

Just feels bad

#

if you set up a double envenom, which was once the "go to" burst window for Assa

#

and you see like

#

40 + 30 k

halcyon timber
#

Yeah different kit and emphasis

peak agate
#

its fine but everything else needs to hit moderate amounts so it accumlates better.

halcyon timber
#

Any alternatives on ptr to get poison improved then?

#

Yeah sounds like poking damage more than anything

jolly sierra
#

poison improved?

#

emm

#

reverting the DTB nerf

#

maybe

sour charm
#

They can't

halcyon timber
#

Yeah like other talents to help emphasize that?

sour charm
#

If they revert DTB then Kingsbane is going to rinse people

halcyon timber
#

Yeah agreed

sour charm
#

Like assas "pressure" profile will be fine I bet

jolly sierra
#

then add back deadly brew

sour charm
#

with DTB

#

Then rotate between Exsang and Kingsbane gos

jolly sierra
#

as a pvp talent

sour charm
#

Do you really want another PvP talent you cant pick?

peak agate
#

Vicious Venoms buff is pretty good. Maybe have it amp mut a little more

jolly sierra
#

why wouldn't pick it?

#

i would replace it for hemotoxin

#

if they needs to remove something

halcyon timber
#

V V does what again?

sour charm
halcyon timber
#

That’s valuable feedback for when the main man gets back

#

But it has to be presented well

sour charm
#

On the grand topic of poisons: Remove Hemotoxin.
Bake its "improved wound" into Shiv.

jolly sierra
sour charm
#

Basically: Make shiv apply improved versions of your deadly poison as well

#

For Wound it would be Hemotoxin, deadly could be a stronger dot etc

halcyon timber
#

Old deadly?

#

Old deadly did work like that

sour charm
#

But that would mean a lot more PvE balancing

halcyon timber
#

5 stacker fat envenom and each deadly psn stack did more dmg

#

Yeah and that aint gonna fly

sour charm
#

Yeah

#

So for PvP: Make shiv give dispel protection to poisons

halcyon timber
#

Which seems to be what amplifying wanted to mimic

jolly sierra
#

why u would want protection for poisons if u reapply them fast af?

halcyon timber
#

Envenom window is that

jolly sierra
#

or w snd

halcyon timber
#

Plus they aint gonna let that fly

jolly sierra
#

dude just fkn buff envenom w flat dmg

sour charm
#

Because it gives at least some protection, and asking for bleed protection is too much

jolly sierra
#

poisons protection isnt a concern

sour charm
#

People would tilt they can't just press mending bandage on every single go anymore

halcyon timber
#

XD

sour charm
#

Give active exsang something like this: "If your bleeds get removed while exsang is up, they deal their remaining damage instantly"

#

It works for Locks right? :^)

#

Also the thing about poison protection was mostly so people can't dispel your MS effect if you have shiv up

#

Effectively mimicking Hemotoxin

halcyon timber
#

Cleansing totem says hi

sour charm
#

since it was on the topic of removing Hemo as a talent

halcyon timber
#

Yeah it sucks

waxen meteor
fallow rune
#

Fleet footed or improved wound poison?

sour charm
#

Both?

halcyon timber
#

Both

#

Both is good meme

sour charm
#

Granted I am not running fleet footed if I play Subterfuge atm

#

But with the new trees both is always the way

jolly sierra
#

if u wanna make it like that with an compensation

fallow rune
#

Can't afford both without removing something.

jolly sierra
#

just reduce the CD a minute or so

halcyon timber
#

Agreed , always a trade. Especially w us

jolly sierra
#

the problem is with that crap of mending bandage

sour charm
jolly sierra
#

with a 25s cd dispell

halcyon timber
#

New tree is fkexible af

#

Its solid

fallow rune
#

Well, current one that is live.

jolly sierra
#

dunno how realz is redesigning DM right now

halcyon timber
#

Live isnt

sour charm
jolly sierra
#

but don't think will be a good idea to keep deathmark a a big burst

halcyon timber
#

Prob the “karma” way

peak agate
#

so I just spamed mut on the ptr average like 20k with extra poison (mostly with poison crits). Buff it a little bit more where we can finish something off if they dispel our poisons and i'll be ok with that

sour charm
#

I hold the firm beliefe that DTB should be a "core" of the skill tree, and Kingsbane should be Assas big burst button

peak agate
#

is mut nerfed in pvp btw?

jolly sierra
#

if it would work as karma

halcyon timber
#

That makes sense

jolly sierra
#

would apply a DM buff on u

#

to keep the bleeding up

#

in that case

halcyon timber
#

I mean they could give it the outlaw fix for bte

#

On dm

jolly sierra
#

if is dispelled could reapply

sour charm
#

But here is an even better idea: Just bring back vendetta, have two splitting paths in the skill tree, one poison heavy, one bleed heavy. Have Exsang and Kingsbane as either capstone.
(this is never happening)

jolly sierra
#

the thing is vendetta

#

that is always better than fucking deathmark

#

if tuning for that fucking spell is always volatile

sour charm
#

I mean it dupes wounds effect

#

for some god forsaken reason

#

and that landed us in the mess we are in

peak agate
jolly sierra
#

it doesn't anymore

sour charm
#

yeah

jolly sierra
#

and can confirm it

sour charm
#

I meant "duped" not dupes

#

my bad

jolly sierra
#

cuz i recall when it was nerfed

sour charm
#

But it DID in s1

#

Which took them a long while to fix

languid ravine
#

Back in my days rogues were crying about Vendetta being the most boring main CD in the game

halcyon timber
#

Would argue that 30% in varying talents > vendetta giving 30% during only the cd

sour charm
#

and we got nerfed a lot before that

halcyon timber
#

Like if base kit can always produce 30%+ as an example

sour charm
peak agate
#

improv vendetta gets that bfa trait

halcyon timber
#

Rat packing cds isn’t healthy

sour charm
#

I agree

#

Assa just has too many CDs already

languid ravine
#

done

halcyon timber
#

Agreed

sour charm
#

Doesn't work with Assas "class fantasy" I believe

#

All our CDs are target bound

#

Literally all of them

languid ravine
#

okay it gives you a buff: "your target.."

halcyon timber
#

I lt makes sense to fixate and smoke this one guy but yeah

#

Turn and burn as you please w dm wouldn’t be outta the question

sour charm
#

I don't even want them to change that, let assa have its niche of being a danger if it actually targets you

jolly sierra
#

pve player would never understand

#

than "funny stuff"

#

is also volatile

halcyon timber
languid ravine
#

ooor "the last enemy you attacked../hit with mutilate/whatever gets its debuffs duplicated"

jolly sierra
#

and any tuning in that

peak agate
jolly sierra
#

would just screw their formula

#

and just will fall apart

jolly sierra
halcyon timber
#

Yeah and pvp we do 25% less

#

Crit damage value

sour charm
#

Back to the poison topic.
Being the master poisoner spec, and having the grand choice of "use deadly poison or do bad dps" in every scenario without DTB
And also the majority of your damage being from bleeds ( in pvp ) just feels

#

Not very thematic

jolly sierra
#

deadly brew

sour charm
#

isn't it 50% less nowdays

#

Or did you mean crits doing 150 instead of 200 which is technically 25% less

#

than 200

halcyon timber
#

It was 175 and now we are at 150

#

Was 200 in pandaria

#

And -5% off the pvp trinket sets

sour charm
#

That is ANOTHER issue with Assa imo.
Crit being bad makes the spec flow worse

#

Mostly due to seal fate and dashing scoundrel

peak agate
jolly sierra
#

in pvp

#

assa doesn't care for crit

sour charm
#

Yes

jolly sierra
#

ngl

sour charm
#

which makes the spec flow worse

jolly sierra
#

why so?

halcyon timber
#

Colon bomb - new talent

sour charm
#

Because you have less energy and combo points than you have in pve
IF you are able to sit on a target and do damage

#

that is a big IF

jolly sierra
#

u have no issues with energy in assa actually

halcyon timber
#

Passive exsanguinate on ptr dupes hits now too yeah?

jolly sierra
#

is still the most efficient spec in energy management

sour charm
peak agate
sour charm
#

I didn't say there are issues.
I said that the difference between playing it with high crit and low crit is very noticeable

jolly sierra
#

venomous wounds is the thing than make u regen energy the most

#

doesn't matter crit w that

jolly sierra
#

that is the reason u go w mastery

#

in pvp

halcyon timber
#

So what realistically can be modified w/o breaking current design to improve psn dmg?

sour charm
#

The reason you go with mastery in pvp is because A: You don't have the uptime to justify crit, and B crits don't do shit for damage.

#

Not because "oh our energy is fine we dont need it"

halcyon timber
#

Ie additional effects on existing ptr talent

jolly sierra
#

even when crit was a thing

#

in shadowlands

fallow rune
#

Anyone got a good sub build for battlegrounds?

jolly sierra
#

it wasn't used

#

as stat

#

just mastery

#

cuz dmg was more consistent w mastery

halcyon timber
#

Shidderlans

sour charm
#

Sorry I quit that xpac halfway through s1

#

And I don't regret it one bit.

halcyon timber
peak agate
#

Haste is also not scaling well with the spec

sour charm
#

Assa is technically the best haste scaling Rogue spec isn't it?

#

Thats why people play Assa on the final boss in the raid to abuse the haste buff?

jolly sierra
#

haste isn't used too much

#

in pvp

sour charm
#

Doesn't mean it scales well

jolly sierra
#

cuz u use thistle tea

sour charm
#

Also, you are very dead set on stuff "not being used" and thus being irrelevant to the discussion

#

When the discussion is about a rework that could make thats useable

halcyon timber
#

Tea causes a bigger headache now

#

Tea needs nerfs or removed at this point so you aren’t “dependent “ on it

halcyon timber
#

And base kit looked at in return

jolly sierra
#

assa damage is not the issue right now in single target

sour charm
#

Nobody here is talking about the damage

jolly sierra
#

u are talking about poison damage

#

is that different?

halcyon timber
#

That’s a mechanical shift

#

Ie talents to augment

sour charm
#

I am talking about the spec being focussed on poisons

#

Not bleeds

#

Not the actual damage numbers

jolly sierra
#

isn't kingsbane enough with poisons?

sour charm
#

The entire topic here was about "what can we do to make the spec feel better"

#

Not "what can we do to make the spec do more damage"

jolly sierra
#

wat

#

rlly

sour charm
#

because a flat % buff would do that

halcyon timber
#

So what can be improved here to provide more poison focus realistically?

sour charm
#

Which is effective, yet boring

jolly sierra
#

if was just the topic

#

then just make the spec die less

sour charm
halcyon timber
#

Kek

#

Jeeze

sour charm
#

But that aside, all my ideas are too much of a big mechanical change

#

to happen now

peak agate
#

going back on topic, I just kingsbane the dummy for 140k so for poison focus build ya know its a good start

halcyon timber
#

Feral is odd because it CAN do big bites as well as bleed

sour charm
#

Oh yeah Kingsbane being back as an actual option is nice

#

It does however not help with the "cd bloat" that assa has

#

most of which are on the GCD ontop of that

halcyon timber
#

So what would you suggest to improve that?

sour charm
#

Remove ER.

#

Which is uhh, also very unlikely

jolly sierra
#

with the cd bloat

#

i had enough

halcyon timber
#

Si primo

jolly sierra
#

u have enough tools back in the day

#

just to cc

#

if u wanna use few buttons

#

just go dh

sour charm
#

Yes. Few buttons is exactly what I asked for.

halcyon timber
#

Dh can do heavy dots too

sour charm
#

That's why I loved playing SV in Legion, because it lacked buttons.

halcyon timber
#

Just mentioning

peak agate
#

Ok we can agree poisons should have bigger focus. Right now they are sort of just been the same shit we had since the begaining. What else comes to mind when you think Assassination rogue?

sour charm
#

I still think they went a bit overboard with Assa however. Since we have Kingsbane, Exsang, ER, MFD, Shiv (if you wanna count that), Tea (same here) and Deathmark.
And we COULD have Dance and Sepsis ontop of that.

Do we really need 3 seperate single target damage CDs?
Does ER have to exist?

#

Having a lot of CDs and Multipliers usually means that gameplay leads to stacking them, since on their own they do less damage

halcyon timber
#

That comes down to what an individual deems necessary

#

Min maxing shoelaces for the sake of it is draining

#

But yeah your point has validity

peak agate
#

I like pressing buttons but I see your point, it becomes a game of modifiers stacking.

wary spire
sour charm
#

Jokes on you I already have it on my bar

halcyon timber
#

Same time, that is IF someone talents into it

wary spire
#

I've been joked pepeclown

sour charm
#

I don't want them to remove the complexity or anything like that

#

But I also don't think that having multiple cds that do effectively the same thing

#

Is needed

jolly sierra
#

button bloat issue is cuz an excess of gimmicks

#

u say playstyle is boring when flat damage is increased

#

but when u rely too much in gimmicks balance become a nightmare

#

and this happens

halcyon timber
#

Well look at who wanted that , honestly. Not even being condescending

wary spire
#

I wanted to like the passive exxag, but as it's implemented it limits your resources way too much.

jolly sierra
#

button bloat isn't a concern neither rn

halcyon timber
#

That being said, id rather have and not need than need and not have

#

Don’t need / want —> don’t talent into

sour charm
#

Correct, but then you need to consider if the spec is balanced around having it

jolly sierra
#

then u have sub as example

#

u cant rely too much in shit

halcyon timber
#

Agreed then as realz already said. A pendulum shift AWAY from an ability being the main hero is the intent on ptr

wary spire
halcyon timber
#

Which is focused on restoring the kit a whole

jolly sierra
#

im pretty extreme to talk, but always is with reasons

jolly sierra
#

played this spec since bfa as competitive pvp

haughty tinsel
#

If cast sectech->mfd->death from above->shadowstrike will dmg come all at once ?

jolly sierra
#

i knew what is missing the spec

#

in this branch

halcyon timber
sour charm
haughty tinsel
#

So i assume awnser is no

halcyon timber
halcyon timber
wary spire
#

I like shiv, vendetta, mfd and the new active exxag. Don't really care for ER, KB or tea.

halcyon timber
#

Yeah mfd is sick af

#

Fun mini game in that window

wary spire
#

I like how versatile it is.

sour charm
#

MFD feels great and is versatile

halcyon timber
#

Yeah me too

#

Hate 7 pts

sour charm
#

ER feels meh, looks meh and is boring

wary spire
#

Duck spelled it wrong

halcyon timber
#

Love recupe being accessible as well

minor cape
#

7pts is awesome and i hate it being a choice node with mfd

halcyon timber
#

That is why its a choice!!!! Dum dum dummmm

#

Healthy for the game

minor cape
#

but since we will be cold blooding goremaw now maybe it doesnt matter

#

oh wait nah

sour charm
#

remove SnD (never happening)
remove ER
give back recoup as a finisher

#

(non of this is ever going to happen)

minor cape
#

we will be rotenning goremaw

halcyon timber
#

Booe

minor cape
#

and cold blooding an eviscerate

#

😎

halcyon timber
#

Snd stays

sour charm
#

I know

halcyon timber
#

Being slow af is crap

#

Rogues generate resources through being active

sour charm
#

I don't even disagree with it. Feels nice to use it to spend your points and I still like the sound of it

wary spire
halcyon timber
#

Losing a non target finisher also sucks

wary spire
#

Nyo!

minor cape
#

oh boi cant wait to use my cp on a finisher that is made only to proc premed 😎

sour charm
#

I mean you would get a non target finisher from recoup in return

wary spire
#

I don't like et

halcyon timber
#

Yep count your stars premed even does that

sour charm
#

Would a buffed recouperator in the Assa tree fix its survivability I wonder

halcyon timber
#

Id make our asses go back to actually pressing premed

minor cape
#

honeslty once goremaw is there im playing the shit out of it

#

😎

halcyon timber
sour charm
#

I know

halcyon timber
#

Agreed, love goremaws and i hate tech

sour charm
#

(no I dont want cata recup back, that shit was busted)

halcyon timber
#

Always have

minor cape
#

i dont even care what goremaw does after the damage

peak agate
#

buff recup doesnt stop us from getting hit hard

#

plus damp

minor cape
#

i just want an autocrit bullshit button

halcyon timber
minor cape
#

that is not sectech

#

🫡

halcyon timber
#

I love goremaws effects too

#

I pushed really hard for it in pve channel lol

minor cape
#

it makes some finishers free, maybe with that shadowcraft thing?

halcyon timber
#

Talked it up a lottt

#

Yeah i love shadow craft

#

Some don’t, i do

#

I have my uses

minor cape
#

yeah its just located in a weird spot where you have to drop some important things

halcyon timber
#

That’s good

sour charm
halcyon timber
#

Its a choice and is intended

minor cape
#

no way im getting shadowcraft over finality or macab or rotten

#

😭

halcyon timber
#

That’s good, that’s a choice

#

Difficult choices are good choices

minor cape
#

yeah true

halcyon timber
#

Part of game design is saving players from themselves

jolly sierra
halcyon timber
#

Whether its a good or “bad” thing

minor cape
#

there will be so many builds for like a month then we will be back to a single build that devs will leave us

haughty tinsel
#

So what build will be most similar to bfa sub rogue?

halcyon timber
#

Realz has done a great job saying yes and no instead of giving in to whims

minor cape
wary spire
halcyon timber
#

Finality is filthy

#

And next week when the double dipping is fixed

#

Lots of cheesey shit making us look like we are doing more

minor cape
#

well y know macab is like a weird thing where we have to use it while its there

halcyon timber
#

Macabre should be nerfed across the game

#

Shouldn’t base us on that

wary spire
#

Will macab it feels like I'm playing a monk.

halcyon timber
#

It is ww hit combo

#

Pve channel makes fun but its true

jolly sierra
halcyon timber
#

Its master of subtlety with extra steps

#

Which is fine but

minor cape
#

well what do we know as scrubs

#

i bet devs did a good job

halcyon timber
#

Devs did a great job

minor cape
#

and sub will be awesome

halcyon timber
#

All rogues will be awesome together

minor cape
peak agate
#

I kid..

halcyon timber
#

Yeah dunno because they argue thats why veil exists

#

Veil was their attempt to help all rogues

jolly sierra
minor cape
#

or is it assa?

halcyon timber
minor cape
#

yeah i thought that this would fuck up all my kidneys lol

halcyon timber
#

Was cool but effed you all the time

peak agate
halcyon timber
#

I do

#

I was there gandalf 1000 years ago

minor cape
# peak agate I kid..

imagine entering a shuffle as sub, get thrown into a team with assa and you see him applying this

jolly sierra
#

REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

halcyon timber
#

It stacked randomly (as advertised) and woukd stun your target at dumb times and DR yoy

wary spire
#

Sounds cool in brackets where people don't care about drs.

halcyon timber
#

You

peak agate
#

jokes on you I dont cc in ss

halcyon timber
#

Lol

#

PARSEEEEE

minor cape
#

how do you win on rogue

#

in ss

jolly sierra
#

LOL

minor cape
#

without cc

peak agate
#

i zerg with everyone else

minor cape
#

i guess assa is built different

wary spire
#

My man

jolly sierra
#

u are not a rogue

minor cape
#

🤪

minor cape
halcyon timber
#

Finesse is our trait, not mental handicaps .. thats warrior and dh

jolly sierra
#

but i cc

#

KEK

peak agate
#

in reality I dont play ss for that reason people just dr all my shit and dont stop tunnel vision

halcyon timber
#

Ss shows why rogues need to be better

#

Just as a kit in general

minor cape
#

idk since bg3 came out i havent seen sunlight or any other game and i dont even know what gamemode im playing next season

jolly sierra
minor cape
#

hopefully we can destroy 2s on sub ret again panda

halcyon timber
#

Count up all the “potential” DRs you can get please

jolly sierra
#

maybe would be fine too lol

minor cape
#

heh should try

jolly sierra
#

i wasn't using crusade

#

or ret autoattack

#

bruh

minor cape
#

always feels good to stunlock a healer for 8 years and kill a marksman hunter

#

through turtle

minor cape
halcyon timber
#

Someone would say he got …. Shell shocked

minor cape
#

mm hunters when he pressed turtle after ret threw the hammer

peak agate
jolly sierra
halcyon timber
# minor cape

Grandfather panda mining fel iron (2007) colorized

jolly sierra
#

KEK

minor cape
#

assa rogue getting into a 3 ret shuffle circa end of df s1 colorized

wary spire
#

Call it shadow teleport and send it.

#

Or decoy.

halcyon timber
#

You mean distracting mirage?

#

XD

wary spire
#

Ffs.

halcyon timber
#

Ability has veryyy veryyyy niche uses

wary spire
#

Don't remind me of this shit.

halcyon timber
#

Like miraging idiots who trinket sap

peak agate
halcyon timber
#

Had a guy swinging at it open world

wary spire
halcyon timber
#

I pulled an obi won hologram on him

wary spire
#

Casual bgs?

jolly sierra
halcyon timber
#

Ive used it in arena

#

You can use it to track people as it follows mages in invis

#

Hunters etc

#

And you can teleport with it

#

It USED to be usable while stunned / rooted so you could teleport like transcendence

#

Had to have the clone out and time it well

wary spire
#

It can only be used while the target is ooc, no?

halcyon timber
#

Ie— stormbolt coming and you tele

#

Yes

#

Only OOC and your ghost must be up first

minor cape
#

imagine if like assa had an ability similar to obliterate ɓut that was boosted by another damage ability, but also had an ability to spin like a beyblade and also if assa shadowstepped to someone any spell to that person would be redirected to rogue. Also would be cool if assa had an evasion but better, i would call it "parry" that would be an awesome rework

halcyon timber
#

Or no dice

#

I think from what our assassin brethren are getting at is zoldyk might be worth revisiting

halcyon timber
#

So instead of “only” the execute window w psns.. how about it expands to more than jsut that threshold?

#

Ex: punishment / condemn from warrior but through zoldyck?

#

Thresholds where the assassin could easily augment their stuff?

peak agate
#

whatcha mean like the ablity changes to something?

halcyon timber
#

Maybe

#

Like panda brought up old dispatch

#

What if — that applied through something like that? Instead of rng?

#

Too strong? Or just lame? I dunno i just want to see my friends happy

peak agate
#

something along the lines of below 30% you attempt to assasinate the target, your envenom turns into an empower version of itself with increase damage etc

halcyon timber
#

Instead of zoldyck applying 30% to all nature dmg?

#

Dunno if im even spelling that correctly sorry

#

Not trying to meme

peak agate
halcyon timber
#

Hmm right on

#

So a 30% amp in that threshold does do it

#

Tough to say man

#

Well outside of KB what else “could be done” ?

#

Shiv + Zoldyck is 50%

#

Add in Mfd for 65%

#

Total that is

peak agate
#

I think if we want a front load execute they can do the dot class thing were it consumes your remaining dot damage. They would just need need to limit it to like 20% of your remaining dots

halcyon timber
#

Who does that on lock?

peak agate
#

they had it

halcyon timber
#

Destruction and affliction no?

#

Des was with conflag or some shit adding into chaos bolt or something?

#

Oh what about the priest talent

peak agate
#

yeah but conflag dot damage isnt that ssstrong

halcyon timber
#

Consuming dots to make swd amp more

peak agate
#

logs into warlock

halcyon timber
#

Dunno what it is those pajama wearers do

#

But its like swp and solace?

#

8 sec is eaten off to empower swd

peak agate
#

yeah that ablitiy no longer exist for warlocks

halcyon timber
#

So say an optional talent to eat garrote ticks

#

For more env dmg

jolly sierra
#

make dispatch with mop iteration back

#

the one with like 200% ap in formula or so

halcyon timber
#

Yeah or that

#

Whats the 70% nature amp doing atm?

#

Like 60k ?

#

Prob 45 or so on players

jolly sierra
#

like 80k or so

peak agate
jolly sierra
#

oh that shit was nerfed hard

#

back in the day lol

halcyon timber
#

Yeah thst is oblivion now

#

Oblivion is juiced harder

peak agate
#

it used to crit, then no then it was deleted

halcyon timber
peak agate
#

yeah I see I have it on my lock

halcyon timber
#

So how to make that work for assassins?

#

Realistically ***

wary spire
#

Sounds p close to Kingsbane.

halcyon timber
#

True

#

Kb is what? 45s cd?

peak agate
#

1 min

halcyon timber
#

Mk so good short cd

jolly sierra
#

i recall this shit in bfa

peak agate
#

no one used it lol

halcyon timber
#

Kept getting nerfed that is why

jolly sierra
wary spire
#

I miss my shield from bfa so much...

halcyon timber
#

Oh lying in wait?

#

That ws the heal nvm

jolly sierra
#

yeah is like KB

halcyon timber
#

Kb > warlock filth

#

Pajama Harry Potters can get bent

#

XD

wary spire
peak agate
#

you can have an amp up kb as pvp talent that increases its talent but like mage said I rather have og dispatch

halcyon timber
#

Let me see

peak agate
#

but im guessing it would need a new name

jolly sierra
#

was an azerite one

#

i recall

wary spire
#

No random unstealths from Itty bitty dots.

jolly sierra
#

has the icon of a yellow shell

wary spire
#

Ye.

#

Defensive matrix?

#

I don't member.

halcyon timber
#

Resounding protection

#

Was a general non specific trait

#

30s refresh on shields

wary spire
#

Yep that's the one.

halcyon timber
#

Honestly i do that with a crafted necklace now

#

When i realllly want to stealth

peak agate
#

we got a few azerite traits as talents...just need nothings personal

jolly sierra
#

pshhh nothing personnel kid

halcyon timber
#

XD was filthy

#

I do love my inevitability being back

#

My… PrEcIouS

jolly sierra
halcyon timber
#

That meth sonic?

#

Not even once!

#

2 feints > all that shit

jolly sierra
#

longstrider was funny af

halcyon timber
#

Made up for low enchants

#

You guys test the new embellishments yet?

#

Nothing crazy but def curious

haughty tinsel
#

Any ideas for assass dance build for pvp ?

halcyon timber
#

Plate boys might be a problem

halcyon timber
#

Memes aside, i have zero clue man sorry

halcyon timber
#

Kek

jolly sierra
#

god dammit

#

got fucking trolled with shuffle

#

50m queue

#

the guys never used cds in my rounds

#

then got dced

#

and lose like 180 CR

#

big deal

#

glad was with the warrior

#

he ate all the shit there

halcyon timber
#

ROguE sTUn sOmeThinG

jolly sierra
#

no

#

i was playing

#

with MY warrior

halcyon timber
#

Ohhh

peak agate
#

lol 50 mins

halcyon timber
#

For a queue?

jolly sierra
#

yes

#

im going for food

#

got a deserter

#

lol

#

this is one of my biggest mid fingers in season

peak agate
#

When my 2s partner took a wow break, I tired some solo shuffle. I watch the warlock run for his life for 6 rounds, he only won 1 round because I was ccing the war who was talking shit to everyone in each round. Good times. Never again.

halcyon timber
#

Yeah lots of rogue cc trash talk but no one likes it when they are getting trained so its like pick one ?

#

You want help or are you a responsible adult to watch your own butt and use cds?

wanton breach
#

I just got bullied by two rogues on my fresh mage besad can't ever have a cast go off, only spam instants

halcyon timber
#

Blast wave like team rocket boyyyy

#

That must of stunk dude

wanton breach
#

I'm too bad to do that properly

#

still learning pew pew

halcyon timber
#

I wouldn’t know man xD

jolly sierra
#

going again

halcyon timber
#

I just stab

wanton breach
#

i still won when there only one rogue on the enemy team, train the yellow is the good old reliable strat

halcyon timber
#

XD XD

#

roGUeS nEvER dIE

#

My favorite forum post “rOgzuEs aRe imMorTaL”

#

Absolutely nonsense

wanton breach
jolly sierra
halcyon timber
#

Shark bait who ha ha!

jolly sierra
#

so i'll go merciless this time

wanton breach
#

friend started pvp a few weeks ago and got over 1k solo shuffle rounds, i don't even have that on all my characters in season 1

jolly sierra
#

tell him to go to sleep

wanton breach
jolly sierra
wanton breach
#

and disarm mages!

halcyon timber
#

Sap drd targets too

jolly sierra
#

zap smash to the extreme

wanton breach
#

i got disarmed three times today as mage in 2s, once by a rogue, once by a warrior and once by a sv hunter

halcyon timber
jolly sierra
#

yeah they knew u need ur staff

wanton breach
#

can't bonk em without my staff, that's true

wanton breach
halcyon timber
surreal barn
halcyon timber
#

Ha

surreal barn
#

But then so is our opponent

halcyon timber
#

Agreed

#

“I didn’t prevent re stealth but it’s not my fault “

jolly sierra
#

what the heck

#

i didn't dropped that hard with the dc

halcyon timber
#

Meanwhile us

surreal barn
#

I want glass cannon sub back

#

Make me restealth blizz

#

I dare you

halcyon timber
#

-_-

surreal barn
#

Lol I just enjoy the gameplay, it’s why I was assa bfa

halcyon timber
#

Can still rat it up but on your own terms

surreal barn
#

Vendetta and committing your defensive cds as offensive ones separated the boys from the men

halcyon timber
#

I don’t enjoy 5 seconds of playing 45s of effin off and being tuned around that

surreal barn
#

Yup

#

Once we get pvp ptr tuning we can see which builds our playstyle will hover towards

halcyon timber
#

Yeah ptr is great

surreal barn
#

You think that is this week?

halcyon timber
#

Def multiple styles

#

And i love it

fallow rune
#

Which one of the pvp builds from the faq is recommended for battlegrounds?

halcyon timber
#

Hopefully no dumb knee jerk nerfs

#

Yeah this week new build realz said

#

W tuning

surreal barn
fallow rune
#

Well its just random bg's and open world stuff.

potent pivot
#

Also depends on spec

fallow rune
#

Playing Sub.

#

I'll just be doing random battlegrounds/ open world pvp with my friend who plays ench shaman.

potent pivot
#

Any of them should be fine for regular bg’s and wpvp

halcyon timber
#

Just stun stuff for him to tab target kill people

fallow rune
#

Havent played rogue for years so trying to find a build that's decent enough for random battlegrounds.

potent pivot
#

Build is hardly going to matter for that, dw

#

Try em out til you find the one you prefer

surreal barn
#

I’d go 2pc rotten for what you said

#

I’m gonna miss this playstyle after 10.2 😢

fallow rune
#

That one?

surreal barn
#

That one can work, but for team fights subterfuge comes in handy

potent pivot
surreal barn
#

BUQAAWulQAmRd/c4Iy2r7VOUFAAABAAAAAAAESSSikISikkgkAkERSSgkk0QkUSSCQEAAAA

#

This is what I run but some don’t lika da gloom lol

fallow rune
#

I've been leveling with gloom.

surreal barn
#

For this since you’re missing the second of dance you have to be quick on the sectech

fallow rune
#

Atm my build looks like this.

#

BUQAAWulQAmRd/c4Iy2r7VOUFAAABAAAAAAAESSSikAJkkAJAJJJJJRKkk0QkUSSCQEAAAA

surreal barn
#

So you’d dance >cheap > SS> sectech> symbols> gloom> evisc

#

Your sectec goes off same time as the 100k gloom which rips

#

Not a huge fan of the first dance since you get the combo points from rotten

#

A lot of people use it though 🤷‍♂️

fallow rune
#

Why gloom over another SS?

#

Not enough time?

surreal barn
#

Gloom hits really hard after a couple shadow strikes

halcyon timber
#

Me likey da gloom

surreal barn
#

Harder than the SS

halcyon timber
#

Slightly less according to the pve kids upstairs

jolly sierra
#

won 5

#

this time

fallow rune
#

Dance, stunn, shadowstrike, secret technique, the symbols and a gloom attack.

surreal barn
#

Yeah

surreal barn
halcyon timber
#

Hopefully tuning is kind and they take their time with it. The raid starts next week too

fallow rune
#

And fleet footed over improved wound poison for battlegrounds?

halcyon timber
#

Yes in dance

#

Up to you spyre

surreal barn
#

So if you want to swap the sectec later it will be harder but I kind of like to make sure they take it

fallow rune
#

So its either 27% healing reduction..

#

or 45%

halcyon timber
#

Eh? Its halved in pvp

#

We don’t do 45% healing reduction in pvp

#

And blackjack + wound don’t stack either

surreal barn
#

Those were the days

halcyon timber
#

Yeah they were

#

Blackjack was 70% then, no idea how but yeah

fallow rune
#

Blackjack?

surreal barn
#

I felt much squishier then

halcyon timber
#

Yes sir back in the day

#

Before the clone wars

#

Well we didn’t have elusiveness

#

And had a lot less

surreal barn
#

Before the every move giving 7cp days

halcyon timber
#

And recuperating was slow (3sec)

#

Healed us for 4.5% every 3 i think

#

Could be upgraded to 5 or so

#

Can’t remember

fallow rune
#

So how do I open up on someone in pvp? Stunn, SS, SS, Rupture?

surreal barn
#

Don’t dr your stun

halcyon timber
#

I do like vial over recupe though won’t lie. Same amount of healing just on demand . Recuperator is a nice bonus as well.

#

And a shorter amount of time

fallow rune
surreal barn
#

I mean maybe open with cheap on another but I wouldnt cheap the kill target unless you are bursting

fallow rune
#

Wait with the cheap shot until I do my shadow dance?

halcyon timber
#

Depends

wary spire
#

🛌 💤

halcyon timber
surreal barn
#

You can just dance from stealth and go ham if you feel like it is time to party

fallow rune
#

But you do put up rupture as one of the first things, right?

surreal barn
#

It is nice to have if you have a healer behind you

halcyon timber
#

Like engineering azerite from bfa . Was wacky and yet they held off for whatever reason to nerf it but def nerfed rogues instead

wary spire
#

But like what's the point of doing embellishments that are just fancy gems?

halcyon timber
#

Exactly that, fancy gems for slight bonuses instead of effing up peoples kits

#

Like wrist rocket back in wrath, shit was dumb

surreal barn
#

Them haste gloves tho

#

Boom

halcyon timber
#

Sum of the parts for bonuses > big goofy stuff thst gets nerfed

wary spire
#

But I play the game for big goofy stuff...

halcyon timber
#

Yeah back when cogs were a thing too

#

And giant ass gems

jolly sierra
#

i still recall the gloves enchant from mop

halcyon timber
#

Yeah but then they tune us all around big goofy stuff and we do zip for damage because of that

#

Stuff should be bonuses and such, not x does 50000 more than everything else

wary spire
#

Wonder if Engineering will get a blink this patch...

halcyon timber
#

Maybe, datamining started again today

surreal barn
#

The shadowflame sled gets you across the whole wsg map in randoms

halcyon timber
#

Lol jeeze

surreal barn
#

In stealth too