Make it so recs can't kill each other

[little gazelle]

I don't know what else to say about this. Just make recs immune to the attacks of recs.

[delicate hemlock]

There is a very niche case where this is a bad thing. You should make it so that horsemen can still kill Recs

I do agree in most cases though

The reason a horseman should be able to is, for example, if you're war you can make yourself look really good by killing your rec

[weak ferry]

people will question why the other rec isnt dead

[delicate hemlock]

True but among the transformed horseman you will look good

Assuming they're like transformed

[little gazelle]

there's like, not many lists with jackal and enough apoc to have multiple transformed at once 90% of the time

But like for example, yesterday I had recs die N2 because rec trapper and rec sk accidentally went on the same person

[kindred prairie]

then thats a miscommunitcation more than anything. Rec townie usually wont claim outside their claimspace and sk knowing their alignment should somewhat guess how the other will play

also you have whispering

if the recruited townie is fakeclaiming then they should know the risk of doing so

[delicate hemlock]

I agree there isn't many but I feel like there should probably be a clause for it

[weak ferry]

it feels weird but i do agree with heric

[little gazelle]

the recruited townie actually full claimed their role, since no rit/doom could sawn.

[topaz lance]

baker already doesn't kill other rec/jackal

iirc

[kindred prairie]

That's just straight up a skill issue

[little gazelle]

imo its more RNG, sinec whispering your rec is frowned upon in jackal modes because it makes both of you sus

[slim pumice]

Nothing else to add

[little gazelle]

THATS THE GAME I WAS TALKING ABOUT

[kindred prairie]

They literally openly claimed their role. They know that the town rec may go on a high value role

The SK risked for no reason and got themselves killed

Also frowned upon doesn't mean anything. If you don't whisper and gamble on a high value target, then it's straight up a skill issue

[slim pumice]

Well I was the trapper that did an oopsie

Tbf with wildling in play we had no way of coordinatin

[kindred prairie]

Well you did an oopsie I cannot say that it was unavoidable regardless of hindsight

[slim pumice]

Yeah, I played like I would as a townie and predicted the coven kill too hard

[little gazelle]

Counterpoint, Wildling

[slim pumice]

Suffering from success

[little gazelle]

Knew it

[slim pumice]

If only I was a tad worse at trapper

I wouldnt have predicted the kill so hard

[kindred prairie]

Counterpoint just say who you're trapping in all chat. That isnt too sus to say

[slim pumice]

I mean I tried to do that but everyone refused to mass conf

So I was forced to predict the kill to conf myself

[kindred prairie]

Or another counterpoint, stop gambling on high value targets as evil or low value targets as tp

[kindred prairie]

I don't know why people avoid mass like the plague tbh. Confirming 3 people is still huge

[slim pumice]

Nah the real way to fix the issue is to remove bg and trapper kills

[kindred prairie]

Not really? These results are like 1 in 100 and could easily be avoided

[slim pumice]

Tps havin kill isnt really healthy

[kindred prairie]

Yes tp killpower might be an issue but rec shenanigans shouldn't be considered in this argument

[slim pumice]

Yeah but tp having kill is the biggest reason why this argument is takin place

[kindred prairie]

Yeah but that scenario of recs could easily be avoided in other ways

Having killpower isn't an issue. Y'all just fucked up

[little gazelle]

So you think BG should be able to just FU Neutrals?

[kindred prairie]

Don't strawman me. I admitted that tp having killpower is an issue but it shouldn't be regarded in consideration of recruits killing each other

Also neutral killings should just not exist

[little gazelle]

you literally said it WASNT an issue

[kindred prairie]

In terms of this argument

The argument of recruits being able to kill each other

Sure it could've been avoided if trapper/bg didn't have killpower. But both recruits fucked up if they targeted the same person

I should reword my comment. It's AN issue but not THE issue

[little gazelle]

only 3 roles as recruit can kill the other rec

actually 5

I forgot about jinx/crus

[kindred prairie]

BG, trapper, ww, bers rampage, vet, jinx not to mention necro and witch.

Arso douse too

Shroud if it wasn't banned

Being able to kill your partner is fine IMO

Just be smart about your abilities