REMOVE 4 DEPS LIST

[mint kestrel]

NO ONE LIKES IT!

[warped zinc]

Atleast call wild west by its name

[mint kestrel]

No.

it doesn't deserve it

angry noises

[warped zinc]

Also this feels like a rant post because you just lost in it

[mint kestrel]

Nah, I was complaining at the start of the game

[fathom bramble]

If nobody likes it then it won’t ever be voted

[warped zinc]

Why do you even dislike it?

[mint kestrel]

Its a clusterfuck/"funni" list that has overstayed its welcome

[mint kestrel]

It was wildcard voted

[fathom bramble]

that’s pretty funny honestly

[mint kestrel]

I'll dislike Ritual-list in a bit too

but at least its more tame

and doesn't have 8 conjes

[warped zinc]

It's existed for a very short amount of time

Also couldn't you say the same for pp

[mint kestrel]

Its existed long enough to leave rotation, and atp I think it can just be removed and not be missed

[warped zinc]

Long enough to leave rotation is the lowest bar imaginable

[mint kestrel]

Pariah Party in its current form also is in a similar state, but at least it has a semblence of a good idea

(Uninformed minority evil)

[warped zinc]

I think wild west is interesting and fun

[mint kestrel]

N1 no kills
D2 8 town to 6 evil
N2 7 town to 6 evil
D3 6 town to 6 evil, evil wins

[warped zinc]

I think it's fair to say pp has more issues than wild west considering two hangs and it's done

[mint kestrel]

unless a kill is stopped N2, or an evil is lynched D2, Wild west will always result in an evil win

[warped zinc]

If your issue is it's to evil sided than just rebalance the list

Swap out a dep for smth

[mint kestrel]

Same thing could be done to PP
(PP don't need a jackal IMO)

[warped zinc]

It's a lot harder to do in pp

If you remove jackal what are you replacing jackal with?

[ivory star]

Can the deputies please shoot this man?

[warped zinc]

Also, you're lowering the amount of uninformed evil gimmick

[manic lava]

Wild? Like wildling?

[mint kestrel]

I'm not sure, but definitly smth.

[warped zinc]

I might be a little biased considering my reg name is western wildling but yes

[hot rivet]

switch this out and add teams

[warped zinc]

now that i can get behind

[faint bane]

yee haw

[lethal ingot]

Frick no

[warped zinc]

i dont agree with it overstaying its welcome im just saying the same arguement applies

[dry dome]

Wildwest is one of those lists where you just vibe on it don't take it too seriously

[hollow prism]

Why is this being skulled? Guy is right, this shouldnt still be in rotation what the fuck

Is this specifically a wildcard problem or is this actually somehow still in rotation

[hollow prism]

Oh yeah that's just another wildcard problem

Wildcard is ass

Rotated out? Stay out .

[mint kestrel]

ESPECIALLY lists where evils autowin D3

[tawdry mesa]

just swap a dep for a conj

no but wild west if it had like 3 deps and 1 cc

or maybe just 3 deps

it might be fine

[mint kestrel]

Its auto d3 win even with 2 deps

[tawdry mesa]

does it have grace?

[mint kestrel]

Yes, but grace doesnt actually fix it

In order for town to win, they either have to:

• Hang an evil D2
• kill an evil N2 (vigilante/jailor)
• kill an evil d3 (dep/pros/marshal)
  And thats just for a CHANCE to win

[tawdry mesa]

isnt that most decks anyway

like if you mislynch d2/d3

you kinda cooked ngl

yeah i understand wild west magnifies that

[mint kestrel]

I'm not talking about mislynches. Even without a SINGLE mislynch, you still have to meet at least 1 of the mentioned requirements in order to have a chance of winning

[tawdry mesa]

what is the list?

is it just 4 grape deputies and 11 town

or is it more evil sided than that

[mint kestrel]

Plus 2 more evils

[tawdry mesa]

what are they

Lemme just pull it up actually

[fair quail]

Truth supernova lowkey

It was a fun gimmick to play like 2 times

[tawdry mesa]

Random suggestions

Remove the np, maybe for an ne, bring it to 3 deps

make it 2 deps and a cc?