Generalizing WDAH

[terse bramble]

If a player is attacked by a role ability that is not a generic factional kill, the target will appear to have died due to collateral damage.

Not collateral damage:

• Necronomicon kills
• Direct Neutral Killing kills/rampages + Ignites
• All apocalypse roles
• Any other evil role who has killed directly

Collateral damage:

• All town roles except for Deputy
• Jinx
• Ritualist

I’m aware Secret Killers exists but considering this is not default, there should at least be a middle ground for casual lobbies. Getting your role outted beyond all doubt is not fun, neither for you or for the other players. (in town’s case, it gives ritualist/doomsayer free dinner/in coven’s case, the CK slot is confirmed)

(The picture is not a good example, I just chose it to choose it lol)

[nova rain]

It's not my glorious goat SecK but it's something 😭

[frank fractal]

It's general killers. I feel like this could be a good middle ground. The second jinx gets a kill "FULL CLAIM FULL CLAIM"

[next gyro]

Good.

[low mountain]

as a modifier ofc

[terse bramble]

If it becomes a modifier, it's almost never being used.

I could distinguish between town and coven kills but that does too little for coven hiding their identities imo

and then inadvertently becomes a massive town buff

[frank fractal]

This is fine as is

[nova rain]

One thing i do want to say is that instead of collateral damage i'd prefer "Unknown Assailant" (from T.I.S.) for theming

[round meteor]

True, since I doubt jailor exing you or vigi shooting you would be considered "collateral damage"

[main solar]

Me when I pour my blood sweat and tears into creating a destructive ritual that rips the life force out of someone only for it to be called “collateral damage”