#Hidden rolelist

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

sly knoll
#

Basically wildcard (modes in rotation), but the list remains hidden, all roles/mods/and bans are not shown in game

Why? I understand wanting a balenced list but knowing what the list is is so punishing for evils, they get to claim space

My problem with BTos2 (lists) is if your a solo evil you can’t win which is why you hate NK, so based on like the first 2 nights and what’s in the graveyard you practically know who is going to win, it’s either a town win with like at least 6 town left or evil win with probably 3 evils left, never a close game, never have I seen a 2v1 finish

The problem boils down to everyone getting confirmed yes, but also knowing the list removes the chance of winning, you can’t hope for another evil popping out or a doom wiping town, you just slowly wait while the final couple town that aren’t confirmed get hung while there’s 4 conf town and no chance of winning

This hidden mode I think will give balanced without actually knowing the list, so it won’t feel entirely hopeless, and without town slots a NK might be able to slip threw the gaps, this will include TAA and April (when on rotation) so you can have hectic, but most of the time you’ll get a normal list but wound get punished for having the list shown

(If ppl memorize town slots on lists I will murder you)

#

If you say this is a game of majority shut up you should be able to win solo

zenith frost
#

I like this

sacred vale
#

Orrr u could buff nk for btos2

torpid iris
#

hidden rolelist is pretty unsolvable unless you know if something special like a jackal dies

sly knoll
#

its suppost to be unsolvable thats the point

#

and buffing NK doesnt solve the issue of solo cov

torpid iris
#

glad coven arent balanced around spawning solo

sly knoll
#

when a cov becomes solo should it adamatically lose?

torpid iris
#

it can still win lol

sly knoll
#

technically

torpid iris
#

especially since it will have other coven in the match to have helped it

#

unless they just never spawned (unprobable) or they died early (also unprobable)

sly knoll
#

7 ppl 6 town 1 cov, 4 conf town what do you do?

torpid iris
#

fyi

#

(even though town confirmability justifying this is wild)

sly knoll
#

so you have marsh, hard conf crus, soft conf spy, and smth cleric that protected

torpid iris
#

and use your words to get people mislynched

#

crazy right

sly knoll
#

theres not enough ppl to mislinch to win i think

fleet chasm
#

whats the issue with this again?

torpid iris
torpid iris
#

90% of lists are identical and town has no real way of knowing the evil lineup

sly knoll
#

Your not suppost to solve the rolelist

torpid iris
#

then its bad

sly knoll
#

its a balenced list but its hidden

fleet chasm
#

Idk why this is bad

torpid iris
#

it could be jackal returns and town was fucked or its fucking vanilla town

fleet chasm
#

Also wait

#

isnt this just taa

torpid iris
fleet chasm
#

but list organized

#

Anyway sure 👍

sly knoll
#

this is to lists
as TAA is to APRIL

#

how did you become Doom?

raw coyote