umbral swallow
Attack: None
Defense: Powerful Ethereal
Abilities
You may confess your feelings to your Target, letting them know who you are.
You may share your love to your Target, Granting them Permanent Basic Etheral Defense.
If you confess to a Townie, you will instead learn what they are. They won't know what you are.
Evils that have Basic Attack cannot kill a Cherished Target.
Once you leave, Cherish wears off.
umbral swallow
???
hollow bramble
too weak
hollow bramble
yes you just literally protect one person from shroud, sk without bloodlust and coven
umbral swallow
Why would I give it Powerful in a Ranked List?
umbral swallow
The Quality it has for Lists.
hollow bramble
please elaborate
umbral swallow
Ranked, Jackal's Return, Pariah Party, Town Traitor, etc...;
hollow bramble
Ranked, Jackal's Return, Pariah Party, Town Traitor, etc...;
how is it useful in ANY of these exactly
umbral swallow
For the Most Part, Very Few Roles provide Powerful Attack.
hollow bramble
For the Most Part, Very Few Roles provide Powerful Attack.
town traitor: either just an extra vote for coven or forced to side apoc
pariah party: everything already has defense
jackal returns: can only save a coven from shroud/sk/inquisitor or a NE from coven (why)
ranked: idk I never saw ranked
hollow bramble
^
quaint adder
Confess is basically subponea + evil just auto learn you
which is bad
Because I suggest custom neutral pariah in the past with similar thing like this and the feedback i got is, evil shouldn't just learn your role for free
theres need to be effort or risk to communicate it (like whispering), since auto confirming you as well remove the potential way of townie faking being the NP to lure evil and accidentally reveal all their teammate
bright copper
town traitor: either just an extra vote for coven or forced to side apoc
pariah ...
thing about jackal returns: you will be the RN slot, so there won't be any of those other neutral roles to block. legit the only thing u can do is save a non-rec coven from the rec with book
hollow bramble
even better
umbral swallow
Then just Natural Defense?
torpid jackal
Providing defense is really only situationally valuable. This role is not great from the concept standpoint. Why would I provide defense instead of ANY of the other NPs? The utility is too limited to be basing an entire role around
Against town (which remember, NPs are anti town and are not interested in the evil faction power struggle) your current role concept does literally nothing at all. If you extended it to be basic defense, you’d only be fucking 3 TK roles. Not useful enough as utility to be considered competitive for the NP slot
fair tapir
What the bloodily fuck is that
So we have a role that outs itself to other players for no reason
Give defence that ONLY PROTECTS AGAINST EVILS
And is NEUTRAL PARIAH??
Its a nothing bagel role
A fucking egotist cleric got more utility than that
gaunt perch
# Damsel - Neutral Pariah
Attack: None
Defense: Powerful Ethereal
**Abilities*...
yeah this is incredibly weak
unlike PM it can't even save you from attacks like vigi
which, as town is the biggest faction, is one of PMs most useful strategies
If you were to put this in a ranked setting it would basically be a sitting duck
excluding the fact that you just reveal yourself to an evil or reveal someone's role
this has no utility
other NPs have utility while still having abilities that help them find other evils
this just wastes a NK's or Conjurer's time
or stalls the game out
distant locust