#Coro buff/rework idea

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

quartz star
#

Coroner should be able to check a group of people at night, and know whether or not a killer (That they've autopsied) is in that group. This would allow coroners to go from having to look through everyone who's sus, just to find 1 person, to being able to slowly narrow it down through groups. I think its a decently ballance idea considering not only will it make coroner more likely to find evils in a game, especially since theres roles like seer which can find an evil a night if your lucky, and even when not finding an evil your instead confirming town or grouping evils together. I think this would add more skill to the role as well as making it more enjoyable.

quaint hull
#

How many would this be

#

In these groups

quartz star
#

Im not sure possibly between 3-5

#

than you got to narrow it down once you find a group that has the killer your looking for

quaint hull
#

What would be the feedback

#

“One of the people is a killer”

quartz star
#

ye

quaint hull
#

Or like “9 is the killer”

#

oh ok

quartz star
#

on is a killer

#

and which killer

#

so if you have multiple killers autopsyied

#

you could find a group of people that has an sk ww and pois involved, but that would be unlikley

#

as long as you autopsied those killers

cinder cairn
#

no

hollow pilot
#

I actually

#

Don't think this is a bad idea?

#

Like genuinely

#

Maybe 5 is a broad range but like

#

Idk I think being able to find more broad info early game isn't a bad idea?

#

I suppose the issue is that if you get a "no" on 5 people that's gonna be quite strong though

quartz star
#

Ye 5 might be a bit too much, but tbf even if you get a no with 5 people it only means their not a killer you've autopsied

hollow pilot
#

That can be quite strong though because that eliminates about a third of the town

#

Stack that with the fact there’s probably tpows and more, and you’d basically be able to narrow the killer down to one or two people

#

But then again, even with this change Coroner is the slowest TI, so it being stronger like that may be alright

flat nest
#

This idea is actually hella cool except for the fact that it fucks NKs

#

If sk kills n1 you can literally confirm half the town as not SK by start of day 3

#

Coven is whatever it’s a faction but this would destroy nks unfairly compared to the factional killers

#

Also would you visit each of the people in your group? Could a coroner visit 5 people in a night?

quartz star
#

I guess it is guite strong against nks being able to find alot of people as not that nk, as for the visiting I'm not quite sure how that would work, maybe you only visit the person you autopsy (the dead one) and than the rest are astral. Also how many people you can visit could be changed if it's too unbalanced, I just think corner needs a buff in some way or another.

quaint hull
#

I’d prefer if this was 3 players chosen at once

#

5 is a whole lot of info

quartz star
#

Fair, I did say it could be between 3 to 5 depending on how strong it is, compaired to other tis.

obtuse temple
#

This is way too strong

#

Coroner suffers because of how fast the game is and that other TIs are op

#

In secret killers, Coroner gets much more utility

hollow pilot
#

I genuinely think coroner is too slow, period

#

Even if the rest of the game was slowed down

#

It’s not suiting games that last 15 minutes

obtuse temple
#

A way to counteract this is just to make autopsy work automatically instead of as a day ability.

#

It would deal with mass killers much better and punish bluffs harder.

#

Granted that's still worse invest but it deals with secret killers as an upside.