#Jester - Rework

165 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

fathom folio
#

Jester - Neutral Evil

  • As the Jester your goal is to be lynched.
  • Tribunal's will not activate your Ability.

Attack: None
Defense: Basic on Night 1
Other: Unique | Innocent to a Sheriff | No Immunities

Jester's pity - 1

  • Upon being lynched this Ability will trigger.
  • The next Day/Night are affected by Fast Mode and Hidden Roles

Feedback:

Upon being lynched:

" The Jester will do a cruel prank! "

#

Jester is not a fun role so i just threw something together

teal geyser
#

ok so lets see

#

doesnt win during a tribunal

fathom folio
#

i tried to balance it

minor coral
#

This is interesting especially since i get killed as jester alot n1 lol

fathom folio
teal geyser
#

why

fathom folio
#

there needs to be a safe way to get rid of the jester

minor coral
#

yeah tribunal is free win

fathom folio
#

since evils wont kill it

teal geyser
#

exactly why jester sucks

#

you sometimes cant get rid of it

fathom folio
#

the lynching effect is harmful to everyone

teal geyser
#

the tribunal only difference is janky though

minor coral
fathom folio
#

idk if it was a bug

teal geyser
#

it was

#

jesters supposed to be able to haunt anyone in tribunal

fathom folio
#

this can be killed by vigi and jailor too but with a cost

#

jester as a whole was unhealthy

teal geyser
#

revenge is kinda dumb

#

because you could be punishing the berserker who had to take the risk you were real

fathom folio
#

evils need to scumread too

#

not just kill everyone they see

#

💀

teal geyser
wooden juniper
fathom folio
#

evil can try to mislynch it IF they know its the jester

fathom folio
wooden juniper
#

besides no tk wants to waste their shot on a jester

#

unless youre vigilante and you have 50 shots then youre fine

fathom folio
#

i mean its not that harmful for the attacker, just attempts to roleblock them

#

it doesnt bypass immunity and admirer also exists

teal geyser
pseudo salmon
#

revenge is so unnecessary

teal geyser
#

otherwise its just a vizier that exists solely as an evil vote

#

since town isnt gonna kill it

fathom folio
#

okay i sorta changed it

#

better?

#

or worse

teal geyser
wooden juniper
#

what did you change

fathom folio
#

Roleblocking the attacker -> Hiding feedback from the attacker the next night

pseudo salmon
#

that's so??? useless????

wooden juniper
#

tbh i dont really think revenge is much needed

pseudo salmon
#

just drop revenge

fathom folio
#

but thanks for the feedback

pseudo salmon
#

i'm just calling it how i see it

fathom folio
#

there

wooden juniper
#

unfortunately no matter how much you try to poke jester it will always have glaring flaws

#

undoubtedly this is better then jest just outright killing someone though

fathom folio
#

imagine dying because you guiltied a sus person

#

how is that good

pseudo salmon
#

as long as trickster is in the TK slot, jester is a role town can't consistently counter

wooden juniper
#

dying from mislynch

#

womp womp

fathom folio
#

well i removed the revenge thing, should be better now

wooden juniper
#

i think its funny cause how i see it punishing town for lynching evil feels like punishing evils for killing town

fathom folio
#

the issue with the old jester is that it punishes town for even finding it
AND
jester mostly rides a faction's dick in the hope that they lynch them if it benefits to their win

teal geyser
#

delete jester

fathom folio
#
  • it isnt even unique so in a bad situation it causes multiple kills
teal geyser
#

🔥✍️

wooden juniper
#

and now jester can win as easily as dont claim anything on stand during vfa and haunt the coven leader the next night

#

👏

fathom folio
#

jester as itself is a fine concept

#

almost all deduction games have it

#

just the execution is wrong

wooden juniper
#

it just doesnt work here

teal geyser
#

jesters concept is always dumb

#

the issues are less glaring in other games though

fathom folio
#

NE are supposed to be harmful and jester just plays an extra kill for whoever they want

teal geyser
#

due to how numbers work

wooden juniper
#

this is why so many people just prefer witchcon from og tos

#

and why so many people like np

fathom folio
#

the modifiers this adds when being hung is fine, it adds confusion since roles arent shown and gives town/factional evil less time to coordinate

teal geyser
#

neutral evil are just hard anti everyone right now

#

and they really shouldnt be

fathom folio
#

pariah are basically witch wincon from ToS1

teal geyser
fathom folio
#

i mean exe is anti town

#

in 2 ways ig

#

gets only town targets and disables trials

wooden juniper
#

being anti everyone usually fucks over coven more then it does town

#

just because of sheer numbers

fathom folio
#

this jester is sort of anti-everyone but mostly hurts town

#

town has barely any time to vote

wooden juniper
#

doom kills 3 town itll hurt but they can probably buff it out if they have a reliable tpow

fathom folio
#

it doesnt disable the trials but makes it harder

wooden juniper
#

doom kills 3 coven

#

game over

fathom folio
#

doom itself is flawed

#

inquis = mostly balanced and fun
doom = absolute horseshit for Tpow or 1 faction
jester = hehe funny kill cuz sheriff found me
exe = isnt TOO harmful but harmful enough

wooden juniper
#

inquis is ok

#

i dont like how it can get neutrals

fathom folio
#

neutrals should be immune to being heretics ig

#

and 2 town targets and 1 evil target atleast

#

or?

#

like town needs a reason to hang it

wooden juniper
#

that kinda does have the same problem with doom though

fathom folio
#

currently its "guys i have -, - and - as heretics"

wooden juniper
#

town will obv want to hang it but even if they cant catch the inq in time they can buff it out

#

cov still loses 1/4

fathom folio
#

it completely fucks over enchanters or gamealtering roles too

#

"guys i have enchanter as a heretic" blablabla

wooden juniper
#

i saw an inq rework but it was pretty much just exe+

fathom folio
#

oh

teal geyser
#

instead they should be mainly anti town, but anti everyone in some way

#

otherwise they’re np lite

fathom folio
#

this isnt fully anti-everyone

#

but hardly

#

it prevents full coordination and factional evil have to plan fast

#

NK dont have that issue since they usually have a target in mind

teal geyser
#

well now its not anti evil if they happen to kill an ally

#

but before with the roleblock

#

it punishes roles for killing their allies

fathom folio
#

yeah i admit the rb was stupid

#

i sometimes have shitty ideas lmao

#

dont attack me instantly VampireAttack

wooden juniper
fathom folio
#

sounds like a threat fr fr

pseudo salmon
wooden juniper
#

digital bandidos threatens town of salem community with vampire hunter

fathom folio
#

most of my concept/ideas are well received since i take a lot of feedback and take my time rereading it to make sure it makes sense

#

i have like 3 active well received roles and then my maniac concept which isnt active rn

#

but 4 well received suggestions is good imo

lyric knoll
#

I wonder if activating secret killers also would be too much

fathom folio
#

for 1 night its useless

lyric knoll
#

could help coven side kills like rit/pois/jinx if they happen to be claiming a tk

#

though that is very niche

fathom folio
#

even if

#

its 1 night

#

meaning if poisoner poisons, itll still take a night

#

and an extra kill with someone claiming "poisoned" is pretty obvious

lyric knoll
#

right

fathom folio
#

jinx is also pretty wanky

#

since it isnt confirmed if u even get a kill

#

i could add no last wills since seeing the will of a hidden role is sorta shitty

#

imagine if u kill someone quiet and their will says they were marshal, it should be completely hidden or smth during this

wooden juniper
#

pois shouldnt even be able to kill

#

thats crazy how they just slapped kp onto a random cu and called it a day

clear talon
#

Why not just apply the Executioner torment change to Jester?

fathom folio
#

no need to have it on both

clear talon
#

no need to make a separate mechanic when a good one already exists

fathom folio
#

well its unique to executioner, no need to ruin it and give it to other NE

clear talon
#

why would that ruin it?

fathom folio
#

because its exclusive to exe? other roles dont need it

teal geyser
#

ok but

#

exe and jest sharing a punishment

#

wouldnt be terrible

#

since they’re the same concept but different routes of executing it

fathom folio
#

i personally dont like it, so stop arguing with me about it please

teal geyser
#

💀

minor coral
#

i thought it was cool lol

fathom folio
#

the torment stuff should stay exclusive to exe imo