#Town Role Balancing II

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

gleaming talon
#

Veteran is just a 3 shot better Sheriff in Town vs Cov/Apoc no?

#

I dont like the Psychic one
Choosing a Town is just way worse than choosing an Evil

#

Otherwise meh its fine ig

rocky trout
#

tbh, the vigi change is unnecessary

#

because vigi 3 bullets keeps coven from being blatantly evil and winning the game

#

but if they misfire

#

they get punished hard

#

like it should be

#

and jailor already losing his keys if he kills town is punishment good enough

#

no need to make him only have 2 exes

gleaming talon
#

Vigi change is necessary

#

Vigi either fucks up bad and gives evils 2 kills (which is a LOT)
Or goes full berserk and kills most of evils

rocky trout
#

also the BG change is kinda bad

gleaming talon
#

Plus it makes TT Hunt more interesting as Vigicide isnt a thing

rocky trout
#

because I don't wanna die to some dumbass BG who got a protect off as sheriff

gleaming talon
rocky trout
#

I'm still wondering how smite is supposed to work

reef dune
#

i love how town killing is blank on buffs

rocky trout
#

and I feel the psychic results should be swapped, because you're basically finding nothing if you get an evil or a town

gleaming talon
reef dune
#

Paragon

rocky trout
#

yeah but smite is kinda supposed to be a direct attack

reef dune
#

I made that role wait

gleaming talon
rocky trout
#

but you dont know who is supposed to get smited

reef dune
#

it just knows their target was visited by evil

gleaming talon
#

Mhm

rocky trout
#

smite is confusing

reef dune
#

and if visit the evil who visited their target

#

you kill them

gleaming talon
#

This is Para but Protect and no Info

reef dune
gleaming talon
#

Its much different

reef dune
gleaming talon
reef dune
#

i will sue you now

rocky trout
#

also

#

NO TOWN RITUALISTS

#

dont make deputy a town rit

#

please

reef dune
gleaming talon
#

Town Rit and Town Rit2 be like

rocky trout
#

but every other change is good.

#

so crus needs to be clarified

reef dune
#

you know what

rocky trout
#

because it's straight up confusing

reef dune
rocky trout
#

BG is just no

#

deputy is just no

#

I think that current vig is fine, but that's my opinion

#

same goes for jailor

reef dune
#

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAa

#

WAVE

dusk pulsar
#

Sheriff's buff is fine, I think Neutrals might need some limited safety from Sheriff but it's a fine change

reef dune
dusk pulsar
#

Mayor gaining defense as any other Town role normally could would be good, I don't think the Basic Defense limit is necessary

dusk pulsar
rocky trout
#

what if neutrals are only immune to sheriffs until d3

#

after that they appear sus

dusk pulsar
#

I'd rather Detection Immunity only last on a normally-immune role until checked by a Sheriff or something

gleaming talon
reef dune
#

like SK non cautious

#

being inno

dusk pulsar
reef dune
#

and Arso being sus after ignite/when dousing more than 1 person at night

reef dune
#

fight english not me

rocky trout
#

would SK be inno if they are cautious

dusk pulsar
rocky trout
#

and not the other way around

reef dune
reef dune
#

ADHD

#

it happens some times

rocky trout
#

what if shroud is sus if they posess someone

reef dune
#

but fair yeah

rocky trout
#

and ww is obvious

reef dune
#

and NP should be sus

rocky trout
#

true

reef dune
#

and NE

#

except jester

rocky trout
#

I was about to bring that up

dusk pulsar
#

Prosecutor's buff is okay I think? If Prosecutions are limited to once per day that is

rocky trout
#

rn pros just ends the day in BTOS2

#

pros should consume to trials not 1

#

so you can't pros twice it one day

dusk pulsar
#

Yeah that's what I meant

#

Monarch's change is fine

#

I don't think Seer's change will affect much

#

Vigilante's change is good

#

I don't think Jailor's will affect much but I'm not sure, it's a good change regardless

reef dune
#

ok but what if

#

we

#

all

#

played ultrakill

#

i gave you a mid

gleaming talon
#

I would give you could be worse

dusk pulsar
#

I think most of these are pretty good so far

#

Nerf: Retributionist now can only use town power roles and town killing roles once.
I think this is unncessary, the other change is fine and accomplishes what this is trying to solve

#

Veteran's is weird, 99% of the time you're not gonna have an instance where your target is evil and someone visiting your target is evil

#

Crusader's is really gimmicky, I don't like it

#

I think so

#

But let me read the rest

#

Amnesiac's I'm indifferent about

#

I don't get how Psychic works

#

I prefer the Deputy rework Curtis suggested

#

And that's it

#

#bettertos2-updates message

#

Why make a third one?

#

I mean you posted it an hour ago

#

Give it time