Anyone know why this won NOTHING in the pop up?

[real agate]

genuinely mad at the judges

“too long!”
is your attention span that bad?

“boring!”
better than the monotonous “heres how i built it. heres the finished thing”

“the card is not yeeps-related!”
it said based on the yeeps 2nd anniversary, and that is a trading card, almost none of the winners had nothing to do with the anniversary (other than it being a card)

“not detailed enough!”
i feel like i shouldn’t have to make it a giant fully 3d card that uses foam, cardboard, paint, paper, and have it glaze the judges for even a SHOT at winning. give other people a chance at winning, i swear every pop up there is at least 1 submission that i feel like does not deserve top 10

“not enough editing!”
is it this hard to stimulate you? the whole video does not need to me slimed with absolute top-notch editing

again, this did not even get top 150

(if you are gonna say “stop whining” or “sore loser” or something along those lines genuinely just leave this post.

[real agate]

why

Its showing my art/video

with a question

so whats the point of pinging discord support?

if they close this i swear

[proper olive]

This is actually kinda fire 🔥

keep cookin' gang 💟

Also NEVER GIVE UP

i bet you'll get 1st or near one day

[gentle sable]

must be under a minute

it’s not really on theme

[silk karma]

Under two minutes

[real agate]

its 2 minutes

[real agate]

half of the winners arent related to the 2nd anniversary

besides, trading cards themselfves sre related to the anniversary

[real agate]

thank you bto

[tired cypress]

I genuinely FLINCHED at the loading thing thinking the Spiderman polyester edit was gonna pop up😭😭😭😭

[earnest flower]

should've won

[halcyon wyvern]

Editing 10/10 the actual creation 2/10 creativity 3/10

[sick timber]

Dude, don't get mad at the judges just because you didn't win. Also I don't think you even made that. I'm pretty sure you just printed it

[sick timber]

Yeah that's what I'm saying. This guy is kind of just hating on the judges for no reason

[silk karma]

How did you deep fry the audio

[real agate]

no i can show the file

[sick timber]

That's not what I mean. I mean all you did is put a few pieces of text and stars on a piece of paper and printed. That's not really very skillful and artist like

It just doesn't seem like something it would win cuz it's not full of creativity. It's creative but it's not full of creativity

I'm also not saying it's bad. It's decent but a lot of the cards are much better

[real agate]

keep in mind, the editing is also considered in the thing

[sick timber]

The editing is just a side note. I hope you know that you will never win just because of your editing. Your thing has to be pretty good too

[real agate]

“actual creation 2/10” “thats what im saying”

[real agate]

keep in mind some of the cards were just ripped straight from the game

[sick timber]

No I say that rating is accurate I'm not trying to be mean but it's just not full of creativity

[sick timber]

Yeah that doesn't change anything. They still recreated it themselves. They drew it on a flat platform. You just put a PNG on something

[real agate]

at least 2 of the winners were just cards ripped out of the game

[real agate]

i made that png

[sick timber]

That doesn't matter if they're ripped out of the game. They're still amazing because it took a lot of effort to do. They drew them themselves just because you put a PNG and printed it doesn't mean yours is better than theirs

[dire lantern]

hello

[shrewd scroll]

hello

how are you?

[real agate]

what do you mean it doesnt matter? it isnt creative at all

[dire lantern]

good

[real agate]

good

[dire lantern]

how are you?

[shrewd scroll]

good

[real agate]

so how is it creative if its just ripped out of the game

[sick timber]

It is if they recreated it. They used their hands to fully recreate a thing from the game. That's still better than just making it on a flat screen

[real agate]

they didnt tho, they just rebuilt it

[sick timber]

It takes creativity to make stuff. Yours takes very little creativity and effort. Most of the winners made really big cards out of cardboard with lots of depth and different paints. Would you please stop like filling up the art channel just because you're mad you didn't win.

[real agate]

how are you typing so fast

ai?

[sick timber]

Speech to text

I think it would take longer for an AI to generate a sentence than speech to text

[shrewd scroll]

ai is not

[dire lantern]

relavant

[sick timber]

I don't use AI slop ever

[real agate]

filling up? its one post

could you stop filling up this post

[dire lantern]

we do not like ai

[shrewd scroll]

we do not like ai

[real agate]

i get your point

you dont need to keep talking

[sick timber]

Could you please close and lock the post cuz it's still just going to sit people and people are going to keep talking in it and arguing with you so I think it would be better if the post was closed and locked

[real agate]

also

if LOTS of people made it out of cardboard and paint, then they are all basically the same

[real agate]

you do it

listen

i was trying to ask a question ok?

[sick timber]

Okay that doesn't change anything. They're all amazing and they're all full of their different differences

[sick timber]

The art channel isn't made for questions

It's for art not questions

[real agate]

it is a presentation of my art with a question attached

[shrewd scroll]

then post the art

[real agate]

did you submit anything?

[dire lantern]

by itself

[real agate]

i did, its the first message

[sick timber]

Not this time but I do occasionally if I like the challenge

But the times that I did lose I did not do this. This is just not okay. You can't just rant about you not winning. If you didn't win, you didn't win for a reason

[austere marten]

hello

[sick timber]

Can you please close this forum and lock it

[austere marten]

true this is not supposed to be here

[real agate]

maybe sometimes if i put actual effort into stuff i get disappointed if i dont even get top 150

[real agate]

its art with a question

[austere marten]

ig

[sick timber]

Well what you got to do then is you got to keep trying. If you have talent you have talent don't just give up on it and suck the creativity out of your work

[real agate]

maybe perhaps that is what ive been doing

wdym suck the creativity out of your work

[sick timber]

You went digital digital is so much easier to do and it's not very creative, especially cuz you didn't make half of the assets on that thing

So it wasn't really made by you

Most of it was but it was only put together by you

[real agate]

i made the bird asset, and what am i supossed to do about the card itself? its just basic shapes

[sick timber]

Exactly basic shapes. You didn't make yourself draw the shapes. It's just not really creative

And the bird asset is literally just one thing

[real agate]

and what about the video itself?

is the video good?

[sick timber]

The video itself is I'd say a 8 out of 10. Great editing and you did very well overall

[real agate]

good now go away

[sick timber]

Not until you close this post and lock it so that no one else argues

[real agate]

i posted a video with a question, and it turned into an argument. both of our faults, dont just throw the blame on me

[sick timber]

Did I say it was your fault?

Just close the post man

Or other people are going to start arguing with you

[real agate]

audio settings

im not gonna close the post until you look at some of the winners for this pop up and last one, some of them were just ripped straight out of something else and just dont have much creativity

or if you say that it is somewhat unfair on the judging

[sick timber]

I just checked and most of these are hella creative. I don't know what you're on about

[real agate]

then im not closing the post

[sick timber]

That's it. I'm sorry to say this but it's what you need to hear

[real agate]

im not closing it

[sick timber]

Honestly, I think you might just need to suck it up. We don't always get to win and I don't think we should complain when we don't. It's not that the challenge is unfair. It's that the judges didn't like your thing. Just please stop complaining and leave everyone alone

[real agate]

please leave

[sick timber]

I don't care. You don't need to close it

[sick timber]

I'm already going to leave anyway. I said what I needed to say you need to suck it up. We don't always get to win

[real agate]

thank you good bye

[sick timber]

No

[halcyon wyvern]

Yeh bro the card was made out of a computer software prob taking 10min max to make and print

[real agate]

i thought we ended this are you just trying to bring the argument back up

[magic nymph]

I think you slightly didn’t follow some rules…

[strange cipher]

1. It said Design + Draw. All you did was design it and then print it, it was supposed to be drawn.

2. The Video had to be publicly uploaded to either YouTube or TikTok.

3. The Video must be under 2 minutes.

4. You needed to draw/paint/craft it, not print it.

[real agate]

ok got what i needed

[strange cipher]

Huh

[real agate]

how do i close this

[strange cipher]

Idk.

[real agate]

@dim crest gonna be honest idk any other online discord mods so can u close this

[sick timber]

He has a point

[sick timber]

@gilded mortar he wants post to be closed

[gilded mortar]