Review Board!

[frosty copper]

In the cws there would be a new board next to the fuel, and that is the Review board.

Here, u can write down reviews of the cw and rate it up to 5 stars, and give a description kn why u like/dislike it

And before anyone gets any bad ideas like review bombing, or biased reviewing toxmod and swear n slur restrictions is enabled in this board so it'll log the reviews and see whether or not ur doing that, basically if u dont understand a moderation system would be in this so u can't do stuff like that. And u can report reviews so that if a review gets past moderation somehow, u can always report it

The Popular tab in yhe cws board would be Revamped to "Popular And Good", making it so that u need a good rating and a high visits count to be on Popular, so this would be like a fix for the cws problem we have, and there would also be a new tab called "Good Quality" which is like popular but instead of it basing on visits its based on high reviews, so id you wanted to see cool and good cws without it being flooded with codes like "OnlyUp2917" then this is for u

U can only have one review, but u can edit that one review if u wanna rate like a new version of the cw

Featured would remain unchanged though

[frosty copper]

What do we think?

[slate hazel]

Actually sick

[unreal lion]

This would work WELL with thumbnails, this should be added

[frosty copper]

It’s also be a great fix for bad cws that lil timmies made with 0 effort

[fluid wyvern]

We need this! NOW!!!!

[frosty copper]

Updated it a bit

[stoic ridge]

I feel like -- even with a moderation system -- this would still inevitably lead to toxicity, but also I think it would strengthen the sense of community within yeeps

maybe just make it so you cant attach a written review to any rating 2 stars and below?

[frosty copper]

I mwqn if ur gonna make it 2 stars or below u have to write why

So they can improve

[tulip sphinx]

Yea

[stoic ridge]

ehhh i get that

but im worried the toxicity will outweigh the constructive critisism

[frosty copper]

I mean i bet that there would also be a button to report toxic reviews

[stoic ridge]

yeah that'll probably work

[tall rivet]

It would be silly and goofy if this gets added with the "is this review funny" button from steam

[frosty copper]

Not rlly

This is some sort of community feedback

Urs is more of a permissions tab but for pw

[frosty copper]

Why'd u post a video of u playing mario 64

[fluid wyvern]

Idk

[placid elm]

I had the same idea but with a mail box idea

[frosty copper]

My name is David

[minor raptor]

Emotional damage if they get to see the reviews

[frosty copper]

Heck yeah

Yeah

Well 3 - 5 stars would be on Popular

2 and below wouldnt

[frosty copper]

Yeag

[half elbow]

🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯

[lusty tartan]

A wiring Port at the back would be evil

[frosty copper]

This wouldn't have one itd be next to the fuel in ur cw

Like gh permissions n staff board

[faint thunder]

There should be moderation to the board because… well you know

[frosty copper]

...I said there is

[frosty copper]

E

[unreal lion]

E

[novel cypress]

It should be possible to enable and disable so that it won’t affect the sensitive yeepers (Like me) if you know what I mean

[outer needle]

i love this so much

this is a rly cool idea

i like the fact that they can comment what they liked/disliked about the cw but it might end up with ppl hating and harrassing this way

[frosty copper]

🍞

[frosty copper]

Again

Moderation n reporting system

[languid moss]

Top tier suggestion

[wraith gulch]

It could show the rating and some reviews before joining the world.

[outer needle]

true

[frosty copper]

Reviv

[frosty copper]

Yeah

[quick thorn]

YES WE NEED THIS BRO😭🙏

[cunning cedar]

Yes

[toxic crow]

ABSOLUTELY

[atomic ether]

i think this would be a really good idea since some guy said he made the hardest only up to beat and i decided to try it out and he added a 15 block jump and you just have to jump normally and over spikes normally yeeps can barely jump 11 blocks let alone 15, and he got like over 500 visits with this trick, with reviews it could prevent things like these from happening

[cunning cedar]

This should be added to the game it will help a lot the community worlds

[verbal rover]

Fire idea

[thorn wigeon]

YES

Perfect Idea

[half wigeon]

I would love for this to get added

[frosty copper]

Yeah

[timber berry]

This would be sick! And good reviews could help the map get on featured!

[slim arch]

This would become way too toxic

[timber berry]

Yeah probably😔

[slim arch]

Things like Only Ups would get review bombed which would have positives and negatives but its not worth the hurt

[timber berry]

🍟

[frosty copper]

Dawg did u read the suggestion

[slim arch]

Yes but that's hard to do, even now there are work arounds that allow you to type slurs and other bad stuff

[frosty copper]

Again

Reporting reviews

[barren ginkgo]

Yes

[frosty copper]

R

[umbral gorge]

I guarantee you there would be children that report every single slightly negative/criticizing review without hesitation, just like the ones that report the lobby for griefing their inappropriate pillow statue, only much harder to stop, as they're able to sit by their board and report all the negatives with no consequences. And if they get banned for reporting too many times, what if there are some people that actually are getting toxic reviews that need to be reported? How are moderators supposed to justly put a stop to review bombing without being unfair? "We banned everyone that left a one-star review on this CW in this 24-hour period because we have reason to belive they were 'review bombing'." There would be no way to differentiate between people that "review bomb" to lower the ratings and people that genuinely think things in the world could be worked on.
Feel free to prove me wrong, though.

I see the concept of how this would be awesome, but there are drawbacks.

[wild steppe]

Bro this amazing and should definitely get added

[frosty copper]

There is something called common sense

And I'm pretty sure people can tell the difference

WAIT WE ARE ALMOST AT 100 SPARKLES

[balmy patrol]

This is a good idea

[supple agate]

This would make community worlds so much better

[frosty copper]

Revive

[nocturne flower]

This would be so cool!!! Revive man!

[nocturne flower]

Ima help Revive it!

[nocturne flower]

What app did you use to make the image?

[icy temple]

Only bad thing is that I feel like there would just be unfair reviews because of rage quitting in only ups or something 😭

[nocturne flower]

Fr!

[nocturne flower]

Could I also remake this with the app you used? Ill give credits in the photo!

[frosty copper]

PICSART

It’s my craft

[frosty copper]

I mean u can but like

Why make another when u already have one? If ur gonna rework n remaster it then that’s fine

[nocturne flower]

Its ai? Oh i didn't know lol

Its fine tho.

I aint gonna complain

[plush mesa]

yeessss

finally ill get the recognization i need

[nocturne flower]

I asked chatgpt and this is what she made..... its very similar even tho i said make it really difficult uhm... ill give credit in the image and text lmao! Is that okay? I'll draw over it if ye want

Edit: im not gonna make one. But could you change the title to
"📄┇Review Board!"

[stone ingot]

It’s seems good, but I have a feeling little kids when they crash out or whatever there gonna leave a bad review. Or I have a feeling Most of the reviews are gonna be “they didn’t get me staff” or something stupid. Seems cool though

[nocturne flower]

I'm gonna change it big time

It would look cooler if it was called

📄┇Review Board!

Could ye change it to that!

[frosty copper]

…what.

[frosty copper]

Did u feed my art into ai?

[nocturne flower]

no silly

[frosty copper]

Thank god

Bc when I saw the ChatGPT part I was gonna be like this

Oop

Chat send links

[nocturne flower]

Could ye

[nocturne flower]

Lol

[frosty copper]

But i was gonna be that one star lord meme where he goes “what” and the other guy goes “I know that sounds bad”

[nocturne flower]

Lol!

[frosty copper]

Maybe

[nocturne flower]

Alr!

[frosty copper]

.

[nocturne flower]

Revive

[acoustic viper]

10/10 idea

[acoustic viper]

🖐️ 🗿 🖐️

One of the rules for this system tbh could be no review manipulation. What I mean is no telling players to leave a positive review in exchange for something.

[crystal jacinth]

yes pleas this is great I've wished this was in the game foresver now

[visual scaffold]

Yo this NEEDS to be added (Ik I’m late to the party)

[prime glen]

Join cw THESKYBASE2 and give me a review here

Except axolotl would just put ❌ on every cw

[nocturne flower]

#🗺️・share-your-world-code

[prime glen]

Ik

But I have want someone to review it

Here

[nocturne flower]

Delete the message. You have to put it in #🗺️・share-your-world-code . This is a suggestion.

[prime glen]

Am I getting reported for this

I’m not being bad

[nocturne flower]

What?

[prime glen]

Why do I have to delete it???

[nocturne flower]

I just told you

[tawdry stag]

gng it’s not that deep

[tawdry stag]

you don’t have too he’s just being a big nerd

[nocturne flower]

No ik lol. I'm just saying as it's a suggestion

[nocturne flower]

Don't call me that

Omg drama!

[crisp kelp]

I wanna be involved

[tight elm]

Awesome

[nocturne flower]

Lol

[nocturne flower]

@silk sky

Haha

[tight elm]

Rude 😭

[tawdry stag]

shiver me timbers

[nocturne flower]

Wydm?

[tawdry stag]

yea that’s toxic

[nocturne flower]

What????

[nocturne flower]

[nocturne flower]

How is that rude? Is this rage bait...

How is saying haha toxic

Why are we arguing in this guy's suggestion!

Why

[dim wraith]

"haha" can be used in a toxic way, but in this context it ain't too bad

[nocturne flower]

He called me a nerd now I say haha and I'm being called out!!!!!!

Nerd*

[dim wraith]

okay, calm down

[nocturne flower]

Wha

[dim wraith]

you're not being called out

[nocturne flower]

What is happening

[crisp kelp]

Guys is this suggestion really that bad?

I think it’s good

[dim wraith]

no, just some people are arguing cus some guy posted his cw here

idk what the fuss is about

[nocturne flower]

No a guy promoted his code and I told him to remove it and everyone is acting like I just broke every rule

I'm not spending my time arguing with random strangers looking for trouble.

[nocturne flower]

He called me a nerd, nothing happened. I said haha and now I'm getting called out?

I'm done cya

Not responding.

[supple helm]

This whoud be a good update.

[frosty copper]

Nono waffles has a point

[frosty copper]

Dude please Just delete it

The review board isn’t added.

[mild badge]

We need this

[tight elm]

it was a joke ;-; mb I should have made it clearer

[prime glen]

Why

I don’t want to tho

[frosty copper]

Because this isn't yhe place to promote ur cw.

[prime glen]

Who cares?

[prime glen]

Cool

I can see ya know

[frosty copper]

Go to #🗺️・share-your-world-code if u want to promote there

Ot #1216797006169636915

Not here.

[prime glen]

But nobody can review it cuz by the time they are done playing they can’t find the message to review it

[frosty copper]

Still. This is a suggestion.

Not a place to promote.

Delete it or i will report this.

[prime glen]

I’m suggesting for people to join this cw

[frosty copper]

That's promoting.

Not suggesting.

Last chance.

Delete it.

[prime glen]

What did I say that’s so bad

You can’t report me for that

[prime glen]

No ur acting like im breaking every rule

[frosty copper]

?rule 2

It says “You can share your stuff in the right channels”

[prime glen]

I’m not over promoting or spamming am I?

[frosty copper]

For ur situation it’s again #1216797006169636915 #🗺️・share-your-world-code

Not here.

[prime glen]

Fine I didn’t know that before but I’m not deleting it

[prime glen]

I didn’t know using the wrong channel was so bad

[frosty copper]

Its breaking the rules

[prime glen]

I just said 1 thing in the wrong channel

But it was in a thread

People are talking about home life in some of them

Atleast this has a channel for it

[frosty copper]

This is for suggestions for the game
Not to promote cws

What part of that is hard to understand??

[prime glen]

Listen, your right and I’m wrong
But I’m not deleting it

I’m not going to delete it tho

[frosty copper]

U said that twice

[prime glen]

Ik but you aren’t listening

[frosty copper]

Dude I can read

And also I’ve already reported this to support to take down that message

[prime glen]

And I’ve reported you for false reporting

[prime glen]

I didn’t say the n word or somthing like that

[frosty copper]

U posted in the wrong channel

[prime glen]

Ok, cool

[frosty copper]

That’s breaking the rules what is there to not understand??

[prime glen]

The least bad rule

[frosty copper]

Ur not listening to me.

U need to delete the message. This isn’t the right place to promote ur cw.

[prime glen]

And I’m getting banned for this????

[frosty copper]

I want the message taken down.

I said that in the report.

Not to ban u

Or anything like that.

[prime glen]

But reporting me in the big 25 for promoting my 2 visits cw is crazy

[frosty copper]

Oh my gosh

#1216797006169636915

#🗺️・share-your-world-code

These channels are right here to promote ur cw

Just use those

[prime glen]

I’m not deleting it for the 100000000th time but I will relocate it if you care so much

[frosty copper]

Delete the message n put it somewhere else.

That’s all I ask.

[prime glen]

It’s staying right here

But it will spread

[frosty copper]

Fine.

Let’s let the mods decide.

[prime glen]

The kids???????????

[frosty copper]

It’s mods

Autocorrect corrected it

[warm prawn]

This is mad entertaining to watch ngl

[frosty copper]

U STAY OUTTA THIS /j idc if ya watch

[prime glen]

#1398285111035691079

Here is this so bad

I put it in the right channel

[warm prawn]

Why tho

its 2 person argument

and a resolved one at that

It's still a resolved argument tho💀

[prime glen]

This suggestion is great but not when the owner of it is forcing me to take down a message that isn’t insulting anybody

[warm prawn]

Yo you're a great guy and all, but I was lowk on the OP's side

Glad you got ur ad in the proper channels tho🥳🥳🥳

[prime glen]

I’d delete it if he took down the report

[warm prawn]

Yo the beef is over dawg🙏

[frosty copper]

Look I’m not gonna continue this argument I’m just Gonna see what the mods do

[prime glen]

Ok

[nocturne flower]

Oh lol!

No promotion

[prime glen]

Dude, it’s already been resolved

[nocturne flower]

I think that's the rule

[prime glen]

Did you look

[prime glen]

I can do it, but not here

It’s been 2 days

[quiet olive]

I like this idea but if someone leaves a very toxic review the world owner could report that review idk if someone said this already just an idea I had

[nocturne flower]

Ye mb I didn't see the other messages lol.

[prime glen]

Ok

[nocturne flower]

[acoustic viper]

Still a w idea

[acoustic viper]

E

[frosty copper]

Re

[frosty copper]

Viv

[hard stag]

Dude this is a very good idea, but what if the little Timmy’s put bad reviews to make the community world fail?

[elfin stag]

see we need updates on CW's, last one was the popular page & stuff

but this is a awesome idea

[frosty copper]

Report button

N moderation system

[exotic bramble]

This would be cool bc people would have more insentive to make more unique and higher quality community worlds

[exotic bramble]

There should be an option to make anonymous reviews, so you don’t get unfairly reported

[winter kayak]

yess

[lusty osprey]

Please add this Yeeps

[wraith gulch]

If you become staff your review should be hidden so staff can't make misleading reviews

[exotic bramble]

Except for moderators, so they can report bad reviews

[wraith gulch]

Reports wouldn't be sent to mods as anonymous

[exotic bramble]

That sounds good, this way they can report any bad reviews

[somber spire]

Idk, some people could just say they dont like because of the person that made it and more.

[wraith gulch]

/,\

[night peak]

We need this

[frosty copper]

Ok yeah sure

[night peak]

and make a report CW button, and also have a report CW channel in the discord

[digital sluice]

This is awesome I have basically nothing bad to say about this the only issues I can think of is crowding and people writing unkind things to the creators

[true tulip]

yea if its like vip where you can have it or not this is also a way to here suggestions

[frosty copper]

How many times do i gotta say rhis man?

Moderation system n report reviews

[frosty copper]

Tremble perry the platypus

I have made the revive-inator

[frosty copper]

Re vive

[nocturne flower]

I

Here

To

Revive

Okie

[barren ginkgo]

e

e

revi

[distant island]

I love the idea of leaving feedback, but I can also see your suggestion turning into a really toxic situation. Moderation would be very difficult, and all current moderation systems already seem overtaxed.

But maybe it would be useful to just have a board or a mailbox full of letters with reviews/feedback that the CW owner could read? I don't know how well something like that would work. What I do know is that it's risky to create a situation where people can elevate or sabotage CWs using reviews.

[minor basin]

I like the idea, but someone could attempt to get other people to review bomb a cw

and moderation could be hard due to people possibly bypassing the moderation

[frosty copper]

Report reviews

[minor basin]

i mean, having hundreds of false bad reviews would be really hard to get off

[neat dragon]

Yes

[cunning cedar]

Revive

[frosty copper]

E

[acoustic viper]

E

[brazen walrus]

This is an amazing idea, I can finally rate all the unoriginal run maps 1 star!!!!!

[dusk timber]

I think this is a very good idea. I’ve been wanting to make a community world forever but I haven’t because I don’t want to spend all those butcoins and hours of hard work for some 6 year olds run map to get on popular, then I go bankrupt.

[dusk timber]

Bro is so excited

[dusk timber]

Bump

[keen lantern]

It's cool

[balmy patrol]

🦆

[night peak]

E

[frosty copper]

E

[night peak]

E

[urban ermine]

i feel like kids will use this as blackmail like "if u dont give me a grappler im rating 1 star"

i hope this dosent get added because of this

[elfin swift]

dub

[night peak]

BrainRot

[barren ginkgo]

ai slop but im downloading

[frosty copper]

Report button

[urban ermine]

they could lie

[night peak]

Norp

[frosty copper]

E

[night peak]

E

[frosty copper]

https://discord.com/channels/1197017602292207666/1406050933565034608

Please.

Give this a read.

[winter kayak]

yrs

[acoustic viper]

[inner pendant]

[uncut elbow]

made a 3d model for this

[frosty copper]

OH

OH OK

THATS SICK

[uncut elbow]

i forgor the up and down arrow buttons and the create review button imma make it rq

[uncut elbow]

Added the up and down buttons and the create review button. tweaked some stuff like the text and size.

[frosty copper]

THATS PERFECT

Tho uhh the stars should be 2d

[uncut elbow]

ye i couldnt figure out how to 2d-ify stuff

[frosty copper]

The internet: ahem

Just grab like star icons form there lol

[frosty copper]

Revive

[blazing kestrel]

They could add a "most liked" section of cws too

[frosty copper]

Like when a cw has the most favourites?

[blazing kestrel]

No when it has the best reviews

[frosty copper]

Thats litteraly the "Good Quality" Tab its litterally in the post

[blazing kestrel]

That part wasnt there when I first read it

[opal bridge]

This seems like a cool idea to give community world staff members a better way to gain community engagement.

Great suggestion!

[humble pewter]

I give this suggestion a 5 star review just would need to make sure it had a good moderation system lol

[frosty copper]

One more sparkle

And we'd get to 200

[frosty copper]

WE HIT 200

[frosty copper]

Uhh

[frosty copper]

E

[uncut elbow]

What do i choose

[frosty copper]

2

[night peak]

1

[cerulean vessel]

aight

[frosty copper]

E

[humble pewter]

Rev

[frosty copper]

E

[humble pewter]

R

[frosty copper]

E

[hearty mason]

Yes

[frosty copper]

Tbh I think this is my most well received suggestion of all time

[celest forge]

but ppl can just spam negative reviews to make the cw die off

[humble pewter]

So u think an organized groupnof ppl are jus gonna spam 1 stars because they dont like a map also that wont kill it off it will kill it off of the best reviews tab

[frosty copper]

Each person can't do more than one

[celest forge]

okie :)

[frosty copper]

E

[frosty copper]

E 2

[frosty copper]

E 3

[plush mesa]

A: season 2 episode 1

[frosty copper]

E 4

[formal coral]

Yeah good Idea!

[drifting crag]

This is like the best idea I've seen on suggestions

[slim arch]

Ima review bomb all only ups, run maps, and tower maps

[hearty mason]

Your review “they are all the same map”

[frosty copper]

U can't bc like moderation system n 1 review limit

[slim arch]

I'll make multiple accounts...

[slim arch]

My review "Unoriginal."

[frosty copper]

E

[frosty copper]

E 2

[frosty copper]

E 3

[frosty copper]

E 4

[wraith gulch]

This is necessary.

[night peak]

E 5

[wraith gulch]

Half confirmed

[night peak]

What?

[frosty copper]

E

[acoustic viper]

I still like this

[teal ember]

Can't wait for false reviews 😭

[frosty copper]

Well they added this in the new survey

So there is a chance that this could be added

[night peak]

I think the Drop?

But idk

[frosty copper]

Omg i remember this

Old but gold

[wraith gulch]

Maybe 2.15.0 seems like it might be a major update if lab applications are open

[outer needle]

wait... what survey?

[wraith gulch]

the desert survey

[loud nest]

nice

suggestion

[frosty copper]

Imma revive this regarding the featured systems thing that's going on

[tall rivet]

Old arse suggestion

I still agree with it tho

To this day

[frosty copper]

Very old

[night peak]

Old is this suggestion

[viscid ibex]

They should make it so staff can’t leave reviews so there aren’t paid reviews

[frosty copper]

True

[south gorge]

Dude, I've been wanting this for so long. Making maps in Yeeps is so fun but when it take hours to advertise your map, most people are not willing to do that. So natural, most the time it leads to bad maps on featured.

[crystal edge]

lucky tower :0

[frosty copper]

Hmm