#add a different scope render system

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

mystic dome
#

scope in scope eats up my gpu, ruins my frametimes, fcks up my latency. it doesent matter how good you optimize your game if your core system ruins it again.

burnt fable
#

Pip rendering is a standard in nowadays realistic FPS games. Devs do not plan to change it, sorry. Upgrade your rig or lower the settings.

mystic dome
#

there are no ue5 games with good performance using pip.

#

look at the frametimes. if thats standart iam lost

burnt fable
mystic dome
#

4070 super btw

#

i can play remnant 2 on ultra with 260 fps

#

and many other titles. greyzone is by far the worst optimized in scope

burnt fable
mystic dome
#

dont use pip cuz its shit. thats it.

#

i cant tell a single game where its useful

burnt fable
#

Pip means reduced FPS, there's no way to have pip and do not have reduced FPS.

mystic dome
#

yes exactly. thats why we need an alternative

burnt fable
mystic dome
#

i mean i play on a pretty solid system. a 4070 super is pretty high nowadays. how do you expect the player counter to stay up if nobody can run the game properly. thats not logical. inefficient and wasted potential

#

if they fix this issue they are one of the first. multiframegen can save pip. but for cards under 5xxx series. absolute clownfiesta

burnt fable
mystic dome
#

you tell me to upgrade from a 4070 cuz of a stupid unefficient render system that forces me to render a ue5 game twice ? thats madness

burnt fable
#

How's pip "unefficient"? It works as intended - rendering a camera view within a camera view. .4 even further optimises it. Anyway I see there's no point to discuss further cuz you'll still demand a change which is not gonna happen as stated clearly by MFG many months ago

mystic dome
#

there is something incredibly wrong with it

#

a normal frametime is 20-30 nowadays with asynchronus rendering

#

but thats just absolutely terrible

#

a 6x multiframegen is 44-50 btw. so a single framegen crashing up to 60-80 is absolutely unefficient

#

cuz the gpu load spikes. wich leads to bad frame timing wich leads to bad visiual and input feeling. its not about frames. its about latencys and drops

#

and thats unacceptable on a 4070 super gpu on lowest settings

wind zephyr
mystic dome
dim wigeon
#

first, you are upset you are dropping from 70 to 62?

wind zephyr
mystic dome
#

70 ms is inacceptable

dim wigeon
#

There is no other way to do it, and still keep the scopes in their own render plane.

wind zephyr
#

Anyways, yes, as melsy said, there's no other way to do it and still keep the scopes in their own render plane.

mystic dome
#

thats why it needs an alternative way to use the scope. pip is simply bad

dim wigeon
#

If you lose the PIP, than you have to force the the views on the same render plane with one camera, which means blacking out the non scoped view, losing the way the optics work

mystic dome
dim wigeon
#

Arma actually does do it as well.
But they have an option for 2d scopes, that takes away the pip, and puts a black filter over screen around the scope

wind zephyr
#

PiP is resource-intensive, yes, but as was mentioned earlier the devs aren't going to swap away from it.

There's also certain advantages you don't get without PiP, such as the peripherals being visible.

dim wigeon
#

Any game that has a second camera, by definition, uses pip

#

They have made drastic optimizations to it since .1.
In .1, it was about a 40% frame drop when you scoped with zoomed optics.

mystic dome
#

gl optimizing that shit 😄

dim wigeon
mystic dome
dim wigeon
#

this is not a 180 FPS twitch shooter

wind zephyr
dim wigeon
#

70ms is not enough time for anything to make you miss

mystic dome
#

it doesent matter what kind of game it is

#

70 ms is not acceptable

#

you dont have to argue about something thats not done properly

#

and the performance is a massiv issue

dim wigeon
#

There is litterally no other way to do it

#

without 2d scopes

mystic dome
#

latencys are all over the board

#

add 2d scopes then

dim wigeon
#

Nope

mystic dome
#

see there we got a fix that actually works

dim wigeon
#

never going to happen

#

this is not COD or battlefield

mystic dome
#

nobody said that

#

insurgency is also no cod and it got alternatives

#

without blackening out the edges

dim wigeon
#

adding 2d scopes would destroy the entire idea of what the game is

wind zephyr
mystic dome
#

it got pip but nobody uses it

#

cuz it kills performance

dim wigeon
#

not nobody.
I use it

#

I use pip in arma as well, a few extra ms does not matter to me.

#

That is not how multiplayer games work

mystic dome
#

your the first person i ever met then using pip on choice congratulation

#

pip in arma is the same. useless and kills performance

dim wigeon
#

Negative, i would venturemost players on arma do

mystic dome
#

a trade iam not willing to take

dim wigeon
#

but anyway

#

They are not going to do 2d scopes here, it removes the realism element to much

mystic dome
#

just a little push for the long run. how you gonna keep players if a big circle is getting forced out by bad performance cuz of such mechanics

#

they need a fix over long run

#

and no game ever fixed the intense fps costs of pip

dim wigeon
#

it is nowhere near as bad as you are making it out to be.
70ms is nothing in terms of multiplayer games.
The server only renders 30 or 60 FPS on the delta time anyway, and everything else is interpolation.

#

There are people that are playing this game at 30 - 40 FPS and having no issues

mystic dome
#

for me its that bad

#

and that wont change

dim wigeon
#

Hell Arma runs at 30 - 45 frames in most rigs

mystic dome
#

and thats a shame

dim wigeon
#

Im sorry it is that much of an issue for you.
Maybe they will have it more optimised later, you can always try again after .5, and see if it is better

mystic dome
#

i also have the feeling i lost massiv fps on this udpate

dim wigeon
#

try a reinstall, and clear out the shader cache.
I had that happen after .3.5

#

It was supposed to be better, but I lost performance.
Cleared it all out, and it ran great again

mystic dome
#

since i updated drivers i cleared the shaders as well

#

also dlss is a mess right now in this game. xess looks better. and dlss smooth motion runs better then the internal frame gen

#

no clue what they messed up

#

maybe iam just incredibly unlucky and my gpu dies and these are the first symptoms

dim wigeon
#

I was looking at the screen shots again.
The overlay is showing different than the in game fps.
Do you use frame gen?

mystic dome
#

like an absolute mess. but my latencys are higher then my mate with 6x framegen

#

i use 1x

dim wigeon
#

What is "terrible" for you?

mystic dome
#

wich is.... interesting

mystic dome
dim wigeon
#

but I mean Frame wise.
Frame time is all fine, but it is not accurate when you use frame gen

#

is 60 fps terrible for you?

mystic dome
#

yes

#

makes me even motion sick

#

my brain cant handle 60 fps well

dim wigeon
#

what res?

mystic dome
#

cant play on consoles

#

2k but performance mode in dlss

#

modell K since M gives 20% less fps

#

even if its ugly as hell

dim wigeon
#

That gpu is underpowered for that.
This game is one of the most graphicially demanding game out right now

mystic dome
#

my gpu cooks at 90 degree in some spots

mystic dome
#

a bad optimized ue5 game is brutal

dim wigeon
#

it is extremely demanding.

mystic dome
#

when remnant 2 was launched it was the same but they fixed it completely

#

its an engine issue

#

also latencys are an ue5 problem

dim wigeon
#

I agree UE is not great now adays.

mystic dome
#

it got its moments for some games

#

it can be really good

dim wigeon
#

They have done amazing on it so far though

#

There is no game out there that is this intense.
This is this generations Crysis

mystic dome
#

on lowest settings, low dlss it looks like shit tho

dim wigeon
#

It took 10 years for a lot of gamers to be able to play Crysis.
And that is real, I built the best possible PC i could back then, and it still took a full upgrade 4 years later to even run it on high

#

dlss always looks like shit to me

#

I cant stand FSR and DLSS, they are blurry messes

mystic dome
#

iam from the crysis generation also. i know about it and saw it live. but greyzone looks like poopoo if its lowest settings etc and runs like shit in combination

#

its an unoptimized mess still. i mean its early access and prealpha so its normal

dim wigeon
#

have you tried TSR?

mystic dome
#

but you cant say they done well while its still a mess. they need tons of work to do still. and not giving an alternative until its fixed cuz it breaks immersion is a wild call. they could remove it once they fixed peroformance.

dim wigeon
#

Much better for me
I have a 7900xtx with a ryzen 5900x, and I run on high to keep > 60 frames.

mystic dome
#

tsr looks weird

#

like alot of wild grey/dark spots

#

like these ugly ue5 shadow render spots

#

thats just ugly

#

xess gives me best results

#

to be honest

#

iam amazed by intel right now

dim wigeon
#

xess as good for me in .1, and in .2 it changed to TSR working best.
FSR is to blurry to read the specter for me.

rain lion
coral furnace
fluid dove
rain lion
#

And let me clarify, devs did stunning work with PIP being "workable".
Its just that POS tech cant be made into something smooth, responsive and reliable on current gen of HW. It simply CANT.
Hence why there should be option with blacked out surroudings for those who prefer it that way. Hell its not even PVP cheeze advantage, you literally nerf yourself.

arctic gale
#

I'm not sure how this is such a debate. It's a simple fact that Gray Zone has a very serious performance issue that is potentially gate keeping this game from reaching a larger audience that can sustain it into the future.

PiP is not the sole reason for this, but it is related to larger game wide performance issues. I have faith that moving forward MFG will squeeze more optimization out of the game. In the grand scheme of things, this game is early on still. The game is literally pre-alpha still.

hollow spear
#

try this one

mystic dome
#

i mean logicly. not as an insult but think wider then 1 or 2 steps.

my 4070 super cant handle pip
so we have a problem for 80% of the players trying this game.

  1. if its a design choice why ue5 ? games are demanding as hell in this engine and you force my gpu to render it twice ? thats illogical inefficient and not smart. optimization can help but that choice throws them 3 steps back. everytime they optimize something and they achieve 4 frames more. i loose 60 when i zoom in.

3.it turns my gpu up to 86 degree celcius. what will happen with a 3xxx gpu or a 2xxx, 1xxx and so on gpu. it propably will stutter, crash or just wont work well.

my system is above average and you tell me a bit scoping immersion is worth trashing the performance ? your delusional

#

and nobody forces you to remove if from the game. we need alternatives, that works instead of this slop. so we can choose by ourself instead of being forced to use unoptimized, old not properly working tech

arctic gale
#

UE5 has the capacity to be highly demanding, but it's not an inherent universal quality of the engine. MFG needs more time to try more optimization techniques for the rendering system. The game is in pre-alpha.

I guarantee MFG aren't happy with the game's performance in the grand scheme of things. If it's difficult for you to play at the moment, come back in a year or two.

#

You funded an early access game, that basically released as a proof of concept. It's going to take time for it to reach the quality standards of a finished product.

rain lion
#

realistically, outside of the optics, it runs relatively well already, they did massive job with 0.4

#

But the PIP is simply bad tech and on UE5, its not doing well. I would run the game without frame gen happily at 70-90 fps.
But the second i go ADS, its 40-50 and choppy AF.

#

i would rather have blackedout screen than reticle thats ghosting, or lasers at night

wind zephyr
tired sleet
mystic dome
tired sleet
#

You are asking for something that already has been confirmed is not happening so good luck I guess

rain lion
# tired sleet On my 5700 xt I normally get FPS up into the 90s and have never gone below 60 ev...

Lmao, if you want to play choppy game, go for it. I want to use my 144hz monitor as much as possible and there is MASSIVE... absolutely HUMONGOUS difference between 144fps. Then 70-90 i get without frame gen and then disgusting difference in PIP when it drops to 40-50 range without frame gen.
Game doing this on latest gen GPUs is not excusable as long as there is no other option to get rid of such drops and so far, there is not, iam forced to use pip.

tired sleet
#

I'm not sure how you are getting these massive drops. I drop 10-15 frames max

#

It's really not that bad for me personally

hollow spear
mystic dome
hollow spear
mystic dome
#

sry i wanted to tag the other guy

hollow spear
#

oh haha

mystic dome
#

hes delusional protecting this pip shit

hollow spear
#

yea ngl either my settings are fucked or he hasnt tried any of the big scopes yet

mystic dome
#

sometimes triple

#

cuz the renderpipline of pip is just slow as shit

hollow spear
#

whats frametimes?

mystic dome
#

70-80 sometimes

#

20 without scope

hollow spear
#

my game feels like its going to crash when i do some scopes

hollow spear
mystic dome
#

70ms until your mouse input gets used

hollow spear
#

ohhh

mystic dome
#

so basicly its like being drunk

hollow spear
#

i mean my shit gets so bad it freezes for multiple seconds at a time

#

with that scope i posted

mystic dome
#

20-40ms is okay but 70-80 is unacceptable but people in this forum sweettalk that shit

hollow spear
#

if i scope in with some scopes im prettty much frozen for 5+ seconds

mystic dome
#

and since the scope sense is also desynced and far too fast the input delay doesent help

hollow spear
#

others i have no issues

wind zephyr
mystic dome
#

modern games got like 10

#

in valorant i got 2

#

in cs i got 8

hollow spear
#

do yall not just freeze lol? If people saw what im seeing no one would be arguing against an alternative

mystic dome
#

even in arena breakout i got 15

#

and you tell me 70 is fine ? stop doing drugs

wind zephyr
#

I used to play games with around 150 lmao, 70-80 is fine.

mystic dome
#

what you used to do is absolutely not important. 70 is far above standart and average your experience doesent matter here

#

40 is standart for 6x framegen

quiet oxide
#

I think you’re just being a deva. I’ve never had issues gaming below the “ultra gamer” setups. Literally never had issues when I was on xbox getting 30fps and shit.

mystic dome
#

and this game doubles it becouse it sucks

quiet oxide
#

It’s like this, either accept less than perfect or don’t.

mystic dome
#

we talk about an pc title with modern tech

#

not an old apu console

#

HOW THE FUCK DO I GET 80 ? i am missing competence right here

quiet oxide
#

AI is an unreliable source, literally sourced reddit

mystic dome
#

thats math you dumbass

quiet oxide
#

And gen ai isn’t a calculator

mystic dome
#

frames per second = latency between frames. becouse a second is defined. you monkey

quiet oxide
#

I know, I’m a dev dumbass

mystic dome
#

still a monkey

chilly narwhal
quiet oxide
#

Not of this game btw

mystic dome
#

i guess ill move on to red river since that works fluently

wind zephyr
mystic dome
#

thats what suggestions and feedback is here for

hollow spear
mystic dome
#

yes

#

with best ai on the market

quiet oxide
#

Pvp creates issues with different rendering options

mystic dome
hollow spear
#

looks cool but i cant do pve-only bruh, straight up fighting 1s and 0s is how i feel playing pve

mystic dome
hollow spear
#

thats pretty cool ngl

#

for me the perfect game would be if GZW was designed with PVP first but ill take what i can get

quiet oxide
mystic dome
#

so more fps or a better scope

#

i would choose 1.

hollow spear
mystic dome
#

and just becouse you cant accept the fact that people want alternatives and being nazi about it it would be great if a competent discussion would happen

quiet oxide
#

Or one system could cause foliage to render different for example and give a concealment issue for players

mystic dome
#

if they cant play they gonna leave ill remind you of the last drop of players going down to 1000

#

thats not future proof like that

#

most ppl cant play properly

#

and most people are not willing to play on potato fps

quiet oxide
#

Then leave dude, comparing games like every dev has to be the same and an early access game needs to be AAA finished material

mystic dome
quiet oxide
#

Cuz you’re whining

#

Game plays fine

mystic dome
#

no iam giving construktive feedback with proofs

#

your taking it personal and shittalk

#

just get lost if you cant give proper feedback

#

high frametimes are bad fact. no matter what your shitty opinion is.

chilly narwhal
# mystic dome frametimes not fps. putting letters to a sentence is hard

I think the point you are missing is that I use the exact same GPU, and I have absolutely no issue.

Sure, I'm not running it at 4k, or even 2k, but you need to make the choice - run lower settings, or accept you're asking too much of your card.

Either way, I would say you need to cool your heels a little.

mystic dome
#

maybe you dont realize your having that issue

hollow spear
mystic dome
#

thats a fact

chilly narwhal
mystic dome
#

this will happen again

#

you talking nonsense again

quiet oxide
#

I’d also like to mention your complaint is that you have problems with cutting edge tech, which you do not have. You’re a series behind and 2 tiers lower than the max. My point, you can’t claim that you deserve better on the basis of hardware when you don’t have the best hardware. Like I said, you’re being a deva, not to mention the game isn’t even finished. Working on optimizing and churning out more game is tough. Most games aren’t done optimizing until v1.2-1.5

mystic dome
#

your talking shit again

chilly narwhal
quiet oxide
#

They put system specs in the store page, you agreed to them. And fragile feelings aren’t my problem, I’m calling it as it is

mystic dome
hollow spear
mystic dome
#

not forgetting the ai issues right now and not dying npcs

tired sleet
mystic dome
vital grove
tired sleet
mystic dome
#

thats not even helping in the topic

mental leaf
#

You lads are getting very worked up over a rendering method for optics.

hollow spear
#

lmao its getting busy in here now

quiet oxide
#

My understanding is non-PIP just zooms the camera (in most systems) and throws a UI scope over it. My point is, in some implementations the different systems could render things like foliage or lighting differently causing a potential situational advantage to one player or the other. For a PVP game with gear loss it’s a risk.

mystic dome
tired sleet
#

I'm not for or against anything. I'm just astonished that people with supposedly super computers are doing worse than my shitbox lol

mystic dome
#

and "iam a dev" isnt a free pass to talk nonsense

#

or ill tell a mod wont help the argue

quiet oxide
#

I was saying I know what the stuff means, cuz I work on game engines

hollow spear
ruby plaza
#

i am also running this game on 4070super. and pip breaks things a lot. devs do not have to refuse or cancel pip, but let player decide in settings, which way he wants to play. i'd prefer no pip. in 99% areas i have solid 120 fps. in voodoo and other alike i have drops to 60 with nvidia double fps. thats just bad. scope is swiming, not moving.

mystic dome
#

if you dont iam right calling out your competence

tired sleet
#

Why are you so worried about frametimes in a slowpaced mainly PVE tactical FPS

#

This isn't csgo

mystic dome
#

a game wants to be fun

#

thats killing it

chilly narwhal
#

sighs There isn't a massive issue. I'm running a 4070 Super, using mostly high setting at 1920x1080, and average a reasonably good frame rate when in PiP.

If you're suffering a drop, it's not because the card can't handle it. It absolutely can. You just need to either set your settings right, or suffer accordingly.

ruby plaza
mystic dome
rain lion
# quiet oxide They put system specs in the store page, you agreed to them. And fragile feeling...

Sorry but if only beefy PCs can run this game on average without issues, you can say good bye to finished game because sales will drop down massively and there wont be money stream to support it and so far, it seems really far from being done if ground zero is intended late game and not even fraction of it is in so far.
You NEED alternatives to things that drop FPS like PIP scopes so even average or below average rigs can run it reliably on decent FPS. Just because some people here have no issue because they are used from 30fps xbox, doesnt mean everyone else should be forced to do same. A lot of people will notice difference between 50 and 70 FPS. Let alone 80-90 and 50 if you ADS into scope. Then throw in frametime, forced smoothing that you have to forcibly turn off by adding lines into config, ADS sense thats not scaling with zoom levels and you end up with game that will push off a lot of newcomers because they cant even aim properly.
This is already niche game, it needs better optimalization or simply ability to choose from certain options to make game run better. Even if it means having black bars around scopes.

mystic dome
#

stop adding context thats not here

quiet oxide
#

Average human reaction time is 250ms, anything under that is no different either way

ruby plaza
hollow spear
#

Guys I think we all on the same side.

Obviously no one is against giving player more freedom if there is no inherent advantage to making that choice (I hope at least lol).

Obviously no one wants a setting that makes you have a big advantage over others in PVP.

Use these 2 rationales to evaluate the possibilities and make a decision. That's all MFG can do.

mystic dome
#

learn to read

mystic dome
#

thanks for being competent

ruby plaza
#

pvp and pip are bad. agree

mystic dome
rain lion
# quiet oxide Average human reaction time is 250ms, anything under that is no different either...

Its not about reaction time, its about what the inputs do. Combine frame time, low fps in pip scope, propably even frame gen issues because they have to use it in this game, forced mouse smoothing and then mouse sens being all over the place in zoomed scope and bam, you end up with optics that can be used against stationary targets only. I cant hit moving target thats more than 50-70 meters away... I have no such issues in any other game. And i forced mouse smoothing off.

dim wigeon
#

I am just gonna say it.
PC gaming has always been about chasing performance.
I am all for devs pushing boundaries to the limit and if the players do not upgrade, then they are left out.
Yes that is an elite thing to say, but this is PC gaming. Always has been this way.
It is only been the last year years that devs have had to dumb down games for people, since they won't learn on their own.

mystic dome
vital grove
rain lion
#

and the second i turn off frame gen, the scope drops +-40-50% of my FPS and is choppy AF

mystic dome
rain lion
#

i do like how PIP scopes looks, i dont like how much my performance is hit by them in GZW

mystic dome
#

its value feedback. fact based. like it or not thats not for me to decide its your choice how much value the playerbase got for you.

#

since i stand in for a selfmade problem by the point of gamedesign and pip is a problem

quiet oxide
#

I’ve never had issues with inputs and I’m sure my latency is high, I wouldn’t know because I don’t track it. End of the day is, be up to spec, have your settings match your hardware, and play the game. It’s not just an art piece, it’s entertainment.

mystic dome
quiet oxide
#

And there is truth in the sentiment that if you want to play high end games, expect high demands. There are games for lower end pcs coming out even today.

mystic dome
#

and sweettalking it by your opinion wont help the people having it

#

4070 super a lower end pc

quiet oxide
#

My point is if you have an issue it’s most likely a you problem

mystic dome
#

wtf

#

so far from reality

#

so damn far away

quiet oxide
#

I have a 3070 and I have no issue

#

Doesn’t even run hot

mystic dome
#

since you dont expect much i gues

#

30 fps gamer

quiet oxide
#

Setting match your hardware

mental leaf
#

Well. Yeah, actually. a $599 card is on the lower end these days.

quiet oxide
#

60 actually, at 1080

chilly narwhal
quiet oxide
#

No point chasing something that realistically makes no difference

mystic dome
#

^different systems different issues thats not how to fix the problem of high frametimes

#

your again just talking nonsense that helps nobody

#

iam damn sure alot of people experience that