#guardian

1 messages · Page 23 of 1

left lantern
#

also blobs on pull 7 are giga sus if it overlaps with aoes from riftwarden monakS idk when you pull those

lucid arrow
#

blobs?

left lantern
#

the smallies that explode on death

#

idk what theyre called

lucid arrow
#

the broken?

left lantern
#

those yeah

lucid arrow
#

everythin in 7 is pulled together

left lantern
#

so explo overlaps with aoe then hmmge

hazy mural
#

how do u pull em quick?

lucid arrow
#

pull broken, go riftwarden, pull the other pack

hazy mural
#

cause they a bit far and if u go go too qick, ur getting some gapclosers from the champions

left lantern
#

stealth technologia

half surge
#

do they do dam on death too>

#

?

left lantern
#

no they also do an aoe

#

like 50-60k or so

hazy mural
#

the adept pack in the way tho

left lantern
#

per

hazy mural
#

if u stealth then ur wasting time gathering smadge

left lantern
lucid arrow
#

no

left lantern
#

either way i dont think its a good pull Shrugeg ppl just play the broken with the subjugator after the rift warden is dead

lucid arrow
#

oh like from 6?

#

u can just walk there from 6

hazy mural
#

ah u kill sub

#

fair

#

still seems tight

#

this was just to test the route but im a big fan of chains

#

u save so much time if ur always fighting, esp if u have ppl in group that need to keep their resources active by dpsing all the time

half surge
#

i just dont know what to remove there

#

or add

#

gathering all the mobs in 1st area takes too much imo

#

if mobs went straight back

trim plaza
#

Why pull 14 is separated

half surge
#

dont pay too much attention to that

#

i just marked mobs for the count

trim plaza
#

Also wtf is that pull 5

violet holly
#

why are you avoiding the voidcaller packs?

half surge
#

im pulling these with other

trim plaza
#

Jeez bro

half surge
#

its not hard for group

trim plaza
#

Not for group

half surge
#

and the adept is not scary if played right

trim plaza
#

For u it is kinda horror

half surge
#

gotta use charge in time

#

to not get kicked for champs

#

if i mess the timing

trim plaza
#

Y but u wanna take that gamba?

half surge
#

im dead

half surge
trim plaza
#

Up to you i guess

half surge
#

for the sake of group i must suffer

trim plaza
sharp gale
#

The group will suffer when the tank is dead too tho

half surge
#

well i had no problems with adept last try

#

only if ppl didnt wipe on 3rd boss

#

we oculd have +2 18 seat

#

how.. bad is subjugator with riftwarden?..

trim plaza
#

I was about to say doesnt matter what u pull, 3rd boss is the real wall

trim plaza
violet holly
#

very

half surge
#

all the packs here sooo cursed fucking hell.

violet holly
half surge
#

this pull is possible?

violet holly
#

if you hav aug skip and/or you dont want to get the last pack at the top

half surge
violet holly
#

then you can pull more back to compensate for 13 and the double voidcaller pack

sharp gale
#

How do u skip the destroyer guys even

trim plaza
violet holly
trim plaza
half surge
#

maybe

#

im losing hope already

trim plaza
#

Nah take way yoo much timr

half surge
#

u either do additional pull or

half surge
#

here i mean

trim plaza
#

Brutalhoof

#

Most classic one

half surge
#

either do this pull or make a little wait for casters

olive compass
#

we did it

#

my ret paladin died

violet holly
olive compass
#

THREE TIMES on third boss

trim plaza
#

Ret paladins did not spawn with brain

violet holly
#

gotta spend the free bres, right?

olive compass
#

bro even apologized at the end of the key lmao

#

i did not expect to time 2 keys today

#

good day so far

half surge
#

wish me luck

#

im gonna test route in 16

#

seat

#

esp this one

olive compass
#

what is this

#

thats not the pull you usually do

half surge
#

i know..

#

need the count

violet holly
#

if you really want count I would suggest this

half surge
#

to skip subjugator pull

olive compass
half surge
#

to skip pull 8 below

#

i go with pack 11 and pull 1 more pack into boss

#

1st boss

olive compass
#

why would you skip that

half surge
olive compass
#

its fast and its there to let you get cds back for the harder pulls right after

#

you're gonna get away with it in a 16 but in high keys you'll be punished

left lantern
half surge
#

but now its a bit overcount so... some loss of efficiency here

olive compass
#

this is what timed my 21 with 5 deaths

half surge
#

so... u say im overdoing it about timer?

#

should care less

olive compass
#

its pretty efficient and if you skip the big pack above 3rd boss you just make some of these pulls bigger

olive compass
#

plus, the weirder your route, the less experience your pugs will have with it and that just increases the chances of them bricking the key because they're not prepared

half surge
#

so this will do for now..

olive compass
#

one pull

half surge
#

maybe 2+2?

olive compass
#

why

half surge
#

12-13 and 14 15

lucid arrow
#

12 pull dangerous af wouldnt add more on it

olive compass
#

its perfectly fine

#

just take 13-14-15

half surge
olive compass
#

12 is a pure standalone

half surge
#

and focus right targets

olive compass
half surge
olive compass
#

thats 3 kicks

#

its fine

#

thats the standard pull

half surge
#

6 kicks if we talk ur pull

#

2 perma casters and 4 important kicks

olive compass
#

you worry about time but splitting this is actually pure insanity and you'll lose maybe 2-3 mins there and it wont make the pull safer

olive compass
half surge
#

im not saying im gonna split them like that

olive compass
#

thats pull 12

#

do this

trim plaza
half surge
#

ish

olive compass
#

and do the pack above AFTER so you can deal with the patrol beforehand

violet holly
#

I would chain like this

olive compass
#

thats useless

#

literally just grab it all

#

and sit where 13 is

violet holly
#

bring 14 to 15 and then chain to 13 and after to 12

olive compass
#

dont chain just take it all in one go

violet holly
#

just be aware that after killing 15 the boss gets active

left lantern
#

just pull all of it and group somewhere betwen 13 and 15 catHuh

olive compass
#

^

violet holly
#

I would take 14 15 13 in one go but my teammates yelled at me

olive compass
#

if your group cant get past this pack they werent making it past 3 boss anyway

violet holly
#

but its perfectly doable

left lantern
#

and then watch ppl die to soaking orbs because reasons

olive compass
trim plaza
#

Lol

violet holly
#

they tend to soak all the orbs seems like

#

sometimes

#

kind of a proc

olive compass
#

what key level are we talking about

trim plaza
#

U see from miles awat where orbs comes

#

Eyes are useful

violet holly
#

I know, right

wary hearth
#

Do you have any good for MT 20+?

#

As for seat I use the one you are discussing

clear atlas
#

tbf there is more than just the orbs in those packs in Seat if you do it all at once. It's 4 kicks + 3 channels, which is not impossible but can lead to some damage if not managed correctly. On top of balls ofc.

violet holly
#

I think there's room to optimize in other packs if you wanna do it safer there

trim plaza
#

Go hard or go home

forest flume
#

there's a ton of things that can go wrong if your worst player is your healer in that boss room

quartz valve
devout sage
#

Do we always run the talents without Wild Guardian? Or is there an alternative build to the recommended one from WowHead?

wary hearth
# trim plaza Go hard or go home

Pug life is go hard and wipe, of course sometimes there are groups that it just click and you can push hard when star aligns and everyone gets inspired to play better than the others in the team. Sometimes it is beatiful to see.

trim plaza
#

Tbh if u cant pull those 3rd boss room mobs together, u are not going through boss either

#

Or not all but

#

In 2 pulls total

forest flume
olive compass
wary hearth
olive compass
#

we dont need anyone, we can skip for others

hazy mural
wary hearth
#

What saddens me is that I would parse at 98% and now I parse at 94%, and the only change is that everyone is playing the meme spec and I keep with apex. I just lose interest and stop paying attention, so I cant play meme.

devout sage
#

Thanks, that makes sense - so the Apex-less variant would be a good entry point for a new Guardian, and then swap to apex when routes, not dying, and the different pulls are more second nature?

trim plaza
#

Yes but if people cant kick its cooked already

trim plaza
forest flume
#

most people at the top end at the moment are sticking to the no-apex build because it doesnt require any brain power and works very well

olive compass
#

quick guys, guess which spec i fotm rerolled one reset ago and which spec i played for the rest of the season

wary hearth
stiff phoenix
#

What are the main issues with macroing IF to thrash? Is it that you want to be able to pool rage for specific fights to use FR, and also that more than one stack of IF isn’t that useful? Anything im missing?

devout sage
#

Wait, the apex-less variant never uses rage offensively? Or is it just a noob-friendly recommendation to not do in the beginning? ^^

rustic kestrel
stiff phoenix
#

Oh I didn’t even notice the conversation was about that already

odd cave
#

because of input lag

stiff phoenix
#

Yeah I think I e noticed a few of these issues already. I’m just entering 14s and a few times not that it’s bricked the key but it’s clearly going to be a challenge moving forward. Un macro time

#

Brez one happened a few keys ago

unborn dock
odd cave
#

you can get around this by just having mangle bound in case you need instant rage for bres

stiff phoenix
#

Yeah when I stopped lizard braining I mangled

#

People didn’t know second last boss on maisara

lucid arrow
#

i have mangle bound and addoned it to not glow when it procs gore so i dont press it because it's shiny Prayge

forest flume
#

(they won't)

rustic kestrel
#

I mean its locked till 12.1

odd cave
#

i dont bind ironfur to thrash because I play at 180ms and this causes thrash to be delayed quite often, i macro ironfur to moonfire instead because I care less if moonfire gets delayed

rustic kestrel
#

they aint doing anything else

lucid arrow
#

do you really want them to fix it?

forest flume
#

can still nerf thrash again

#

(please nerf thrash again)

rustic kestrel
#

lmao yes they should

#

this playstyle is ass

lucid arrow
#

i can already imagine it
-50% thresh dmg
reworked apex to do something stupid
bear is F tier tank

stiff phoenix
#

I would like mangle, apex and raze to be viable

unborn dock
#

25% thrash nerf, raze up by 15% I won't see a DPS change on my side

lucid arrow
#

like when they buffed off meta tank auto attack dmg

rustic kestrel
#

drooling should not be optimal play

forest flume
#

Nerf thrash, revert raze/ravage nerf, and I'm happy

#

that does not require waiting until 12.1

odd cave
#

tbh im enjoying the no mangle/raze build mostly because I never got used to losing the extra range from balance affinity, I once again no longer have to care about being in melee range with mobs (paladin doesn't care about this either)

lucid arrow
#

id rather drool and be a good spec than have a fun rotation and be in the trash bin

forest flume
#

then go play monk

stiff phoenix
#

Apex: your bear now poops when you press incarn for a second time, enemies hit by the poop deal 200% increased damage

lucid arrow
#

new apex: incarn makes you give birth to bear cubs to follow you around for 5 mins (non battle pet)

unborn dock
#

Apex is fine as it is, just raze feels underwhelming

stiff phoenix
#

I feel like apex should feel cool and powerful, doubling your abilities is just eh to me

forest flume
#

Raze didn't need to get nerfed, seems they were just lazy and nerfed maul and it was a "eh might as well nerf raze while we're at it"

stiff phoenix
#

Like bear poop

lucid arrow
#

yeah the double your abilities once every 2-3 min is kinda meh

unborn dock
#

And when I play DPS, and I see the new bears in my keys I'm low-key scared they have no idea what they are doing, they just press their 3 buttons and hope for the best

forest flume
rustic kestrel
#

Yeah apex should be cool. Like an extremely flexible ability that can be used for prio damage, or as a strong defensive whenever you want

#

what a crazy idea

trim plaza
stiff phoenix
#

Like what if instead of echoing the abilities, it upgraded raze/maul and iron fur to like supercharged versions with new visuals and sounds and icon

lucid arrow
clear atlas
#

This dumb ass build is the price we need to pay to get our awful Apex changed.

lucid arrow
#

they'll do something beyond stupid like they usually do and touch a bunch of unrelated abilities

wary hearth
rose latch
#

Are most people running EC for raid now too? I looked at logs and top damage parses are EC but I love dotc play style.

lucid arrow
#

they're kinda 50-50

olive hare
#

Apex EC and DOTC play 99% the same.

trim plaza
lucid arrow
stiff phoenix
#

Ironfur becomes steel fur, raze/maul become something idk cool visuals

lucid arrow
#

like they'll make it worse before they make it better

rustic kestrel
rose latch
rustic kestrel
#

thats just too much thinking in a competitive video game :/

forest flume
#

I changed my name, it will happen next monday at 7:28PM est right?

unborn dock
forest flume
#

I was off by a couple of hours last time they nerfed it

wary hearth
trim plaza
#

also our dmg profile was way better before no apex circus

lucid arrow
#

what ever happened to kittyweaving

trim plaza
#

i would not be surprised if they change lunation to flat cd reduction

forest flume
unborn dock
#

I would never recommend someone to macro ironfur tbh, it just makes you worse. The build is already just 3 keybinds, if you can't handle 4 use the 1 button rotation

rustic kestrel
olive hare
#

Overbuffed thrash and overnerfed maul/raze/ravage, those are bears two current struggles.

trim plaza
#

oxez might remember it

#

XD

forest flume
odd cave
trim plaza
olive hare
#

Yeah raid balancing f'ed us up hard this season. And thats why I think current state will stay that way for the remaining season.

olive hare
unborn dock
trim plaza
#

they will either go full raze when they fix apex, or just be lazy and change apex to trash focused

clear atlas
#

how exactly would that be “lazy”

trim plaza
#

cause it will buff even more this degen gameplay? xdd

clear atlas
#

uh

#

no?

#

Please tell me your imagination isnt so limited to only see this as a binary case

trim plaza
#

trash should never be ur top dmg in any situation, especially single target LOL

olive hare
# trim plaza myself too

I'm torn apart. I think bdk opener rocket launch sequence needed some pruning. But as a flat 90s cd - which is bdks major offensive/defensive cooldown - drw doesnt cut it. Feels like it should be 60s.

rustic kestrel
#

Setting Lunar Beam to a flat 30s just solves so many issues.

trim plaza
#

^

hazy mural
#

would still have same playstyle

#

except its swipe xD

trim plaza
forest flume
#

tons of ways to tweak apex to make it interesting and useable more often than it is now in a pull - simple and quick example: they could do stuff like every time you thrash you increase your maul/raze damage by %, and then add an effect to those empowered spenders when you use them - anything not being locked to incarn will be a good thing

clear atlas
#

i dunno if you played BDK since the recent buffs but you have a solid amount of DRW uptime

olive hare
rustic kestrel
clear atlas
#

no shit

trim plaza
#

so the change is bad

#

LOL ur point?

rustic kestrel
#

Without Moonfire giving so much Lunar beam priority, now rage spent on raze damage matters

hazy mural
#

I just wanna be strong, idc how that happens

unborn dock
#

I mean BDK feels great since they buffed it, only issue I have is that low hp pool, even though you have a good uptime on VB

olive hare
clear atlas
#

b/c comparing to last expac is moronic when the entire design paradigm has shifted

trim plaza
hazy mural
unborn dock
#

Did they actually announce another thrash nerf ?

trim plaza
#

no

#

just apex fix in future

olive hare
#

I think maul/raze/ravage primary damage cant receive any reverts/buffs. But what they could do is upping the secondary target portion. Thats what makes feel raze/ravage shit to press in AoE outside of apex.

hazy mural
#

personally, I hope they rework the apex to TnC rng and call it a day

forest flume
#

Sepulcher 2-set thanks

rustic kestrel
#

god i miss tnc

hazy mural
forest flume
hazy mural
#

not getting barkcarn back

forest flume
#

says the betrayer

hazy mural
#

do I look like Illidan?

#

im not that hot

flat magnet
#

Can someone explain the lunar beam bug to me? Something about pulling mob the second I target it and haven't cast any abilities.

sharp gale
#

why would that be a bug? in midnight when u press lunar beam u basically make it appear over the target

rustic kestrel
#

Thats not Lunar beam, its from Waking Nightmare proccing

sharp gale
#

or u mean if ur inside lunar beam and target someone from afar it gets pulled?

#

oh

olive compass
#

we did it again

flat magnet
#

We don't know what pulled it.

#

All I did was target the mob to get ready to root it with entangling

rustic kestrel
#

waking nightmare

#

there he is

#

right there to the left of the health bar

wary hearth
flat magnet
#

Can you explain how this interaction works? I thought it replicates my thrashes only tho?

#

I'm not sure what bug it is? Or how it is working?

rustic kestrel
#

If waking nightmare is up and you target something

#

It becomes the nightmares primary target

#

and puts it in combat

#

despite not even hitting it

flat magnet
odd cave
#

can you use this to pull stuff through walls

flat magnet
#

im not home rn, is it possible to track waking nightmare and whether he is up right now?

#

in cdm?

rustic kestrel
#

I dont think theres any way to track him

olive hare
flat magnet
odd cave
fierce plaza
#

Hey guys, quick question, how do you manage your aggro while gathering a pack ? I often lose aggro to DPS while I am moving, do I do something wrong ?

olive compass
fierce plaza
#

Okay this is what I do, but still losing aggro to DPS full sending it

rustic kestrel
#

Packs with distance start with moonkin Hotw. Make sure youre getting to packs and actually hitting them, letting them slowly come to you will slow you down and your group wont wait

lucid arrow
#

sometimes it's just dps being too jumpy

#

if your dps is blasting right away realistically not much you can do

brazen laurel
#

if you lose threat while stablishing the pull, thats on the dps.

ideally you use cat sprint to get ahead of dps. then bear charge and moonfire as you go, as soon as you have like 2 packs you thrash. and you use that 1minute cooldown spell to reset thrash CD if you gather the 3rd pack and thrash isnt off cooldown yet,

you keep spamming moonfire until your health drops, then you use frenzy and keep spamming thrash and moonfire

if you still lose threat idk

olive compass
#

you should pre-incarn beginning of the key which is the time where you're most likely to lose aggro

fierce plaza
#

Not under incarn, out of incarn is complex for me, specifically with Devourer

olive compass
#

dev is a special thing

lucid arrow
#

devourers love to press their big dmg cd

#

on pull

olive compass
#

they will rip if they send a bomb instantly

lucid arrow
#

and die

#

it's their thing

fierce plaza
#

Yeah that's what happens

#

but I would guess on 17-18 they learned to wait a bit

trim plaza
#

dont invite devourers, solved

olive compass
rustic kestrel
#

There is no key level where dps learn how to not me stupid

#

Youd think "oh yeah i bet in title range dps players actually know whats going on"

#

Its not true

olive compass
#

if anything

rustic kestrel
#

Dps players are morons and always will be

olive compass
#

certain traits become exacerbated

#

like in higher keys they REALLY dont wait because they want to minmax 0.1s

fierce plaza
#

And for me it's a loss of DPS to full send on 3 moving target than 10 static one, i don't know

olive compass
#

realistically our dps loss matters way less

rustic kestrel
#

Im still not conviced any dps player in 21+ even knows how the first boss of pit works

olive compass
#

the real issue is

#

timer being changed because you have to fix something

#

which fucks our cds

#

SEAT 1st pull is very important to get right if you do triple subjugator because if the chains get desynced then your team will die

shut jasper
olive compass
#

²so if your team is being dumb then you're fucked

shut jasper
#

professional moron

lucid arrow
#

you reckon dps would eventually learn

#

starting too early gets you smacked and dead

#

idk it's not some niche time saving trick

#

it's instant feedback

#

but ig they never learn

olive compass
#

Shadowmeld on dh lets them get away with it too much

lucid arrow
#

you could attach dev bomb to an electric chair and they'd still press it

olive compass
#

They dont have to learn

hazy mural
rustic kestrel
#

Demon hunters wouldrather fucking DIE then cancel a collapsing star

#

and they prove it again and again

lucid arrow
#

they'd rather brick a key than cancel it

rustic kestrel
#

"oh i thought i had more time"

#

bitch i dont play your spec and knew you didnt you fucking degen

#

devourer is single handedly the worst spec ever introduced I hate those players man

olive compass
#

Aug is

#

Fucking boosted

#

All of them

rustic kestrel
#

Aug worst for the game, Devorer worst players

dense latch
#

no i like auggies. they make numbers go up

lucid arrow
#

AA 1st pack is the worst

dense latch
#

numbers go up, dopamine go brrr

lucid arrow
#

it's the hardest to get aggro on everything while gathering

#

and dps never know this and start way too early and die

rustic kestrel
#

one starfall should basically guarentee aggro

lucid arrow
#

i dont play with moonkin anymore

odd cave
#

guy in our guild parses low single digits on every class and got to 3450 in 1 day on aug

rustic kestrel
#

oh well thats just a poor choice then

hazy mural
#

why not?

#

its good

dense latch
shut jasper
lucid arrow
#

most people don't take it in high keys and im trying to wean off it

#

so i can have better threat out of it

rustic kestrel
#

Squish has a rogue and a hunter in his group

hazy mural
#

they are also coordinated

rustic kestrel
#

do you have a rogue and hunter in all your groups

hazy mural
#

u gotta play to ur audience

dense latch
rustic kestrel
#

Not everything top players do is correct all the time, also theres instances where stuff is specifically different to how you would play with your groups

lucid arrow
#

not just squish group it's not a popular talent

forest flume
#

can be friends

dense latch
#

what talent?

hazy mural
#

moonkin

dense latch
#

i just got here and will not be scrolling up

hazy mural
#

for starfall hotw

dense latch
#

oh. i like it. gives me a good spike of adrenaline when i hit boomy mid pull

rustic kestrel
lucid arrow
#

idk feels bad to drop other points to get hotw starfall because of devourers who can't wait

hazy mural
#

sometimes u just wanna pad more thrash

#

or its super useful for gathering

rustic kestrel
#

but like, what points are you dropping realistically

hazy mural
#

like start of seat too

lucid arrow
#

prolly symbiotic and forestwalk

rustic kestrel
#

no

#

those are different tiers

#

they dont fight with each other

hazy mural
#

they sometimes do tbf

rustic kestrel
#

You might lose the 4% healing node which is nothing

lucid arrow
#

huh? they give you the talent point

olive hare
hazy mural
#

since u have an abundance

rustic kestrel
#

matted fur 😵‍💫

lucid arrow
#

the 6% healing you mean

#

oh no you mean natural recovery

#

4% really isn't nothing

#

and then what's the other point

olive hare
lucid arrow
#

matted fur

#

4% healing and matted fur because devourers can't wait a few seconds

#

Just brick my shit up

dense latch
#

i'm gonna make a devourer dh specifically to terrorize other tanks

hazy mural
rustic kestrel
#

random log check, ortemist does 35,385 hps on Squish, with 33% overhealing. take away the 4% its 33,969

olive hare
#

Terrorizing slow tanks you should add. If your devourer is craving uptime it might also indicate you just being bad at transitioning.

dense latch
forest flume
#

gl with that, I stopped bothering picking up agro against pug devourers

dense latch
#

it's not about you. it's about you taking the blame 🙂

solar spruce
#

So we dont mangle anymore in the apexless build right?

dense latch
solar spruce
white sentinel
#

Say I have a weapon that is not BIS but mythic and a trinket that is BIS. Should I use the voidcore on weapon or trinket?

hazy mural
dense latch
hazy mural
#

or else u just use it for a quick rage fix

white sentinel
rustic kestrel
#

matted fur is actually doing a bit more than I realized

dense latch
trim plaza
#

exactly

dense latch
#

i have like 6 just sitting in my bags

rustic kestrel
#

probably buffed by lunar beam quite a bit

white sentinel
#

Both it is

hazy mural
olive hare
hazy mural
#

usually near 10 pct of my pre mitigation healing

lucid arrow
rustic kestrel
#

You cant control your random devouerers

#

but you can control how you play

hazy mural
trim plaza
#

boomkin starfall not neccessary to all dungeons, but i like it in AA first pull

lucid arrow
#

im just explaining my reasoning for not taking it

#

but yes

#

I'll likely start taking it only for AA

#

since 90% of devourer slaps are on that

trim plaza
#

but lets say dungeon like magister, absolute useless

hazy mural
trim plaza
#

ohh cmon man

hazy mural
#

uselessly good there!

trim plaza
#

xdd

lucid arrow
#

i also take symbiotic relationship

hazy mural
#

or pad after 3rd boss too

trim plaza
#

not like we do pad dmg already only with no apex

lucid arrow
#

put it on whoevers shit at their defensives

#

pop FR when they should be using defensives

hazy mural
#

shameless pad is why I play this game

trim plaza
#

tbh symbiotic will not save ur dps

#

if they cant press buttons

solar spruce
#

I see the top builds are taking sundering roar, but damn that talent feels so awkward

olive hare
#

stop violating the term pad damage please

hazy mural
lucid arrow
lucid arrow
#

and don't wait for 5 stacks

#

i was waiting for 5 stacks and shit makes it awkward

odd cave
unborn dock
hazy mural
hazy mural
unborn dock
#

I don't either

trim plaza
#

u have moonkin things?

solar spruce
#

Is it generally considered worth it to run Moonless Night and SotF in keys? Or is it better overall to just drop mangle altogther like the top builds are doing?

hazy mural
lucid arrow
hazy mural
#

theres a lot of fluff there u can remove normally

trim plaza
hazy mural
lucid arrow
hazy mural
#

and still have leftover to get UW even tho its almost useless

odd cave
# hazy mural u get to have both e asily

then you give up the magix dmg reduction or nature's resilience. Whether or not those are any good, it's what the top log builds are playing. They aren't playing brambles though. If you can't be bothered with sundering roar you can just take those builds and direct swap SR for brambles

lucid arrow
#

i wonder what the dps loss would be

trim plaza
lucid arrow
#

drop sr for brambles

solar spruce
hazy mural
#

not on retail atm, but this is what I run

unborn dock
trim plaza
unborn dock
#

Maybe I drop rejuv and mangle crit

lucid arrow
#

wrong reply

lucid arrow
hazy mural
# unborn dock

u dont need the maul amp btw, unless ur maul/razing a lot

hazy mural
lucid arrow
#

DG?

hazy mural
#

it will use up DG without the benefit

lucid arrow
#

explain

hazy mural
#

Dreamguide

solar spruce
lucid arrow
#

oh

oblique adder
#

how do I deal with annihilate for kruul on mage tower 2nd phase

lucid arrow
#

but everyone takes 1 point in it instead of 2

hazy mural
#

so it only works if u choose DOC

lucid arrow
#

is 2p bugged or both points

hazy mural
#

any point

lucid arrow
#

cus i see everyone takes DG and 1p reinvig

hazy mural
#

dreamguide buffs ur regrowth

#

it steals it but dosent buff the regrowth

lucid arrow
solar spruce
#

Does casting Frenzied with Reinvig consume the DoC buff?

hazy mural
#

yes

lethal elbow
#

oh dear, didn't realise that

solar spruce
#

so its good combo then?

hazy mural
#

and the doc talent works properly at least

#

so if u go reinv, u need DOC

unborn dock
#

Isn't doc the one you have to cast yourself ?

lucid arrow
#

why do ppl take it then?

#

reinvig

hazy mural
#

yes

hazy mural
solar spruce
forest flume
hazy mural
#

they just assume it works, as they should

lucid arrow
#

there's no way the top aren't nerds

lethal elbow
#

so you could take DOC and never cast regrowth but still gain benefit from the 130% proc?

lucid arrow
#

surely they knows it's bugged

solar spruce
#

yes with Reinvig

lethal elbow
#

I haven't tkaen it because of the awkwardness and potential issue with changing out by error, but that is interesting then 😄

#

thanks!

hazy mural
#

its what we used to do... aint no body got time to help friends at the cost of a GCD Surprised

lethal elbow
#

I would never have realised that XD

lucid arrow
#

doesn't reinvig healing outweigh DG anw?

#

even if it eats it

hazy mural
#

testing minute stuff of specs is a different kind of nerdism

#

they are more dungeon mechanic nerds

trim plaza
lucid arrow
#

idk im not sold

#

i like my FR

#

love me fr

#

simple as

trim plaza
#

reinvi just feels so weak without DoC

odd cave
#

if you cast FR at 80% do you get the regrowth heal first and then get the FR as a shield or does it not apply that way

#

with reinvi I mean

trim plaza
#

regrowth will be instantly casted when u press FR

hazy mural
odd cave
#

maybe that is why they are still taking it then

hazy mural
#

or its supposed to

#

but it only just eats it

lucid arrow
#

yeah im saying even tho it eats it it's a net gain

hazy mural
#

on DoC, it just adds to it

#

no

#

its a net loss for DG

#

u just waste a talent point on DG then

trim plaza
#

DG it wont do anything

#

its bugged

hazy mural
#

so its better to just run DOC in that case

trim plaza
#

if u want Reinvi, go DoC

lucid arrow
#

won't DG still be fine when it procs without FR?

odd cave
#

Dreamguide won't work at all if you take reinvigoration?

rustic kestrel
#

It just doesnt boost the reinvig heal

hazy mural
#

except DG is automatic on whomever drops below 40 pct hp

lucid arrow
#

yes

#

so if it procs without reinvig

#

it won't eat it

odd cave
#

one takes a GCD one doesn't?

lucid arrow
#

if regrowth automatically casts without FR

hazy mural
#

but anytime u use regrowth somehow, DG gets used and wont give u the healing amp on the regrowth it is supposed to give

lucid arrow
#

then it's just a normal DG no?

trim plaza
#

when u have reinvi

hazy mural
forest flume
#

The point is if you are using FR it will cast regrowth and you will lose a stack of DG for absolutely nothing

odd cave
#

right but it does if you want to regrowth someone else right

lucid arrow
hazy mural
#

because its bugged

lucid arrow
#

but it's bugged only when reinvig casts it, no?

#

the bug is with reinvig

#

or am i not understanding

hazy mural
#

when any regrowth is casted that wasnt made by the DG ability

trim plaza
#

it will not boost ur regrowth

odd cave
#

yeah but they are saying reinv will cast regrowth every time you FR so it's eating a lot of DG procs

trim plaza
#

urself i mean

lucid arrow
#

yes but even if you have reinvig, DG is still casting regrowth

hazy mural
#

so if u purposely use regrowth urself, it uses up a DG stack but wont boost the healing

trim plaza
#

so that regrow heal is liek what, 0?

hazy mural
#

if u use FR reinv it uses up a stack but wont boost the healing

lucid arrow
#

you're wasting its procs through reinvig, but whenever it procs without it it's fine

trim plaza
rustic kestrel
#

yes

lucid arrow
#

ok so i understand correctly

hazy mural
odd cave
#

you could easily eat all the procs yourself though during incarn, then DG did nothing

hazy mural
#

because u get much better value

rustic kestrel
#

Reinvigoration is just significantly weaker if you run dream guide, because the consumed regrowth stack doesnt buff it properly

lucid arrow
#

but sometimes u want it on ur allies

trim plaza
hazy mural
#

which defeats the point of it

trim plaza
#

u dont wanna start thinking when to use FR cause losing group healing then

hazy mural
#

if u want regrowth very bad on ur allies, u can DOC and cast it on em

trim plaza
#

thats harder than playing apex build

lucid arrow
#

but you can hold more than one charge no?

#

4 charges was it?

hazy mural
#

same as DOC yh

odd cave
#

if you dont take reinvitg then no point taking forestwalk either right

lucid arrow
#

so you're only eating them all up in incarn

hazy mural
lucid arrow
#

full talent name pls

#

i dont remember them all

trim plaza
hazy mural
#

the FR shield

lucid arrow
#

yes

hazy mural
#

and u try to keep 1 stack on cd, right?

lucid arrow
#

yes

hazy mural
#

so then ur naturally using the DG stacks up even outside incarn

lucid arrow
#

what's FR cd per stack?

hazy mural
#

not all of em, but ur devaluing the talent

lucid arrow
#

defo devaluing

#

my point is just

hazy mural
#

20 secs now iirc

#

or about that

lucid arrow
#

maybe in the end having those regrowth on low hp allies is worth it

#

even if you're eating a large portion of them

#

as compared to boosting your own rg which isn't as valuable

hazy mural
rustic kestrel
#

except DoC lets you target heal people who are about to die

lucid arrow
trim plaza
#

^this

forest flume
#

I like how we are doing mental gymnastics against math and facts, just because someone doing high keys is picking a bugged talent

trim plaza
#

ye but u want to heal person who is ACTUALLY dying

forest flume
#

can we nerf thrash so we can go back to fighting how to use apex correctly instead

odd cave
#

i mean it's usually just a moonfire global, saving your team is better than 3s cdr on lunar beam

hazy mural
lucid arrow
#

im just trying to figure out why they're taking it lmao

hazy mural
trim plaza
forest flume
#

they just don't know its bugged

hazy mural
#

they dont know the bug

rustic kestrel
#

most people probably dont even realize its a bug. Most of these bears are fotm

#

We didnt even realize it was bugged until recently

trim plaza
#

lazy people

lucid arrow
#

wouldn't ppl take it regardless?

#

it heals more even if it wasn't bugged

#

and lets u cast on low hp ppl who are in danger

odd cave
#

he's saying if they knew about the bug they would take DoC instead of dream guide

hazy mural
rustic kestrel
#

Dg just casts on people under 40%, you are not always in danger under 40%

hazy mural
#

if they knew, they would either go DOC, or just remove reinv

lucid arrow
#

that's what I'm asking

hazy mural
#

simple as that

lucid arrow
#

even if it wasn't for the bug, wouldn't top players take it for the 30% more hp + casting on prio targets not automatic?

hazy mural
#

taking dg and reinv is the worst of both worlds whilst it is bugged

lucid arrow
#

im trying to understand why they don't take it

#

can't just be lazy

trim plaza
#

95% of Fotm watches 1 video talent build, slams the talents and goes to do keys

forest flume
lucid arrow
#

im talking about the top players

hazy mural
rustic kestrel
#

You would have to ask them

trim plaza
hazy mural
#

tryna be patient but ur literally ignoring what I said twice now xD

lucid arrow
#

im saying even if it isn't bugged, it doesn't make sense to me why they take it

#

since the other allows for manual prio casting and 30% more heal

hazy mural
#

but it is bugged...

lucid arrow
#

ok..

forest flume
#

because they are good at dungeons doesn't mean they are smart and know everything, it's ok to question what they do

lucid arrow
#

it's bugged, and ppl take it

#

i get that

#

cus they think it isn't bugged

#

however, if you think it's not bugged, and you're a top player, why do you take dg over doc?

#

since dg has poorer prio healing and less healing in general

hazy mural
forest flume
#

because it lets you not have to think about casting regrowth

hazy mural
#

its just strictly better

forest flume
#

and removes the risk of casting it right before proc ends and end up shifting out of bear

#

ie: can be lazy

hazy mural
lucid arrow
#

so ya I'm just saying maybe taking it with reinvig still is worth it cus of these benefits despite the bug

forest flume
#

Yeah, not lazy in a bad way

#

but the good kind of lazy

#

They might think "Well crap that sucks if I lose stacks for no reason, but if it saves one person without me having to think about it, worth"

trim plaza
#

lets u focus what happens around u

#

what tanks want

hazy mural
#

ur basically cutting the usage of DG

lucid arrow
#

ye but how do u quantify

#

the benefit

#

like obviously it's worth it even tho it does 30% less healing cus ppl take the (presumably) unbugged dg over doc

#

when does the pendulum swing

#

50? 60? 70?

trim plaza
#

tbh i would just not play reinvi if i have DG

hazy mural
#

when u FR more, u use DG less, when u need to FR more, thats also when party damage is usually highest

odd cave
#

reinvig also consumes DoC 🙁

hazy mural
#

so the times it would be used the most is also when ur gonna eat into it with FR the most

trim plaza
rustic kestrel
#

I mean its preference right? If you feel like you can help with manual offhealing, you take DoC. If you feel like you cant spare the globals or brainpower, then its not as worth it.

trim plaza
#

DG doesnt do shit for us

rustic kestrel
#

I pug a lot, so Im perma DoC, because it literally can save keys

hazy mural
forest flume
#

you press FR and get a huge heal right off the bat

hazy mural
#

but im playing a minigame with nameplates when fighting enough adds

rustic kestrel
#

...raid frames?

still locust
forest flume
hazy mural
rustic kestrel
#

why click, mouseover

lucid arrow
#

click mobs?

rustic kestrel
#

arent you a healer

hazy mural
#

they have some spasm and just dont wanna be clicked properly, asnd then they also arent lined up well

lucid arrow
#

for what? not like you have any st abilities

trim plaza
odd cave
#

its just annoying that DOC doesnt stack at all, any time you use FR you are using all charges, dream guide stacking to 4 is sweet

still locust
#

They both stack the same

lucid arrow
#

surely u can check a log to see what final dg healing is when accounting for reinvig eating it

still locust
#

Last I checked you can't really FR enough to consume all charges out of incarn

lucid arrow
#

and go from there

still locust
odd cave
#

DOC absolutely not stackingfor me

hazy mural
rustic kestrel
#

The stacks stack up and consume in the exact same way

odd cave
#

oh now it is

#

weird

lucid arrow
odd cave
#

before it didnt just RNG i guess

lucid arrow
#

doc has 130% more healing dg has 100

still locust
hazy mural
#

thrash nerfs all over again KEKW

forest flume
#

I'm looking at a 23 windrunner parse, Andy's regrowth did 7.4m with DG, and I'm looking at 21 windrunner by our very own Bulok (who's playing a dotc he's a legend), his regrowth did 13m with DoC

With this sample size of 2 keys, I think the case is settled

rustic kestrel
#

HUGE SAMPLE SIZE

lucid arrow
#

in each case

forest flume
#

Although Bulok's overhealed by a fair bit, he likes to pad

#

not a lot xd

#

He is selfish

lucid arrow
#

id take a huge self healing hit to heal allies tbh

#

not like I'm the one dying

trim plaza
#

What u value more

#

U are already immortal

rustic kestrel
#

Random DG healing can be usesless, where when im looking at healthbars on say first boss of Windrunner, I can specifically choose whos getting heals

#

Thats why I Like it with pugging

#

If I save a person even 1/5 keys, thats 30 mins i just saved

lucid arrow
#

mby ill try it out but if it shifts me out of bear ill crash out

forest flume
#

Yeah group rotting down to 40% you know the healer will heal everyone in a second, someone getting hit by a random ability and goes to 15% with aoe incoming, you can snipe someone to full

rustic kestrel
#

You don't have to run it

still locust
hazy mural
rustic kestrel
#

its just showing you the option is there

rustic kestrel
#

its not always

hazy mural
#

a good healer lets ppl get low anyways and if ppl are getting to 40 pct and not gonna die soon, more time to dps pog

rustic kestrel
#

But like I said, if i save a person even 1/5 keys, its worth it to me

still locust
rustic kestrel
#

ur right

hazy mural
#

I do agree it sucks when it runs out of time

violet holly
#

haha get rekt

hazy mural
#

but DOC does the same too

still locust
#

Yeah you hit the same issue with DoC

#

If you plan to save someone with DoC right as your healer does a big pop

hazy mural
#

make it 2 mins DAMMIT

still locust
#

Then DoC is wasted too (or healer pop is wasted)

odd cave
#

i doubt my ability to cast regrowth better than a robot can tbh

hazy mural
lucid arrow
#

ye i think id end up doing it too suboptimally

violet holly
#

generally having control over stuff is better than not, but in this case I feel like having it auto proc is mostly fine

odd cave
#

i would rather run DG even if its less optimal because i think manually pressing regrowth would be even less optimal

hazy mural
#

they at minimum kinda become the same value when u look at gcds and brainpower spent on doc

odd cave
#

because I am not good enough to watch party health bars carefully enough, while also doing all other tank things

rustic kestrel
#

(I do)

rustic spade
#

what is the fastest viod light marl farm?

still locust
#

My advice continues to be this, in order of recommendation:

If you have reinvig, you SHOULD be DoC always
If you don't have reinvig, and don't care about off-healing, you should be DG
If you don't have reinvig, and you want to off-heal manually, you should be DoC

violet holly
#

you either choose to hold a DoC for the correct time(and not have it because time ran out) or have DG auto proc a number of times where you might not need it and then dont have when you need it most

hazy mural
#

if DG bug was fixed, u just run DG even more

lucid arrow
#

weird flex but ok

still locust
hazy mural
rustic kestrel
#

People use these brain power arguments all the time like NOBODY could possibly do these things

hazy mural
#

must be nice having brainpower

still locust
#

The downside of DoC is also that to get max benefit you might have to manually cast it when you could have cast a thrash or a ravage

#

Which is the correct choice

#

But a loss nonetheless

lucid arrow
#

well bro obviously it's not easy to do these things

summer hatch
lucid arrow
#

otherwise we'd all be 22 gamers

rustic kestrel
#

Like last night I saved a dude on first pull of Skyreach because eagle aoe lined up with 2nd eagles target wind blast... i regrowthed him mid tick and he lived 10%

odd cave
lucid arrow
summer hatch
#

fair

#

i honestly don’t think i live some things playing doc

hazy mural
summer hatch
#

dg is pretty cute

hazy mural
#

and tanks have it the worst

rustic kestrel
hazy mural
#

and now they have taken my beloved BW thrash away from me

rustic kestrel
#

But people like to yap about brain globals and act like no gamer in the world can focus on more than 1 thing at once

violet holly
#

what is BW

hazy mural
rustic kestrel
#

22

violet holly
#

ah I knew you were inventing new acronyms

summer hatch
#

gg

hazy mural
#

I miss having the thrash mechanics on voice

summer hatch
#

ur a wild gamer

#

wcyd

rustic kestrel
#

the 22 didnt make it to boss 2

#

😵‍💫

summer hatch
#

i’m a pitiful dg player

still locust
rustic kestrel
#

TRUE

rustic kestrel
#

theres nothing wrong with playing dream guide

hazy mural
#

1 pot?

forest flume
#

Bulok is the anti-anti-apex bear, respect, even in 22s

rustic kestrel
#

IM NOT SAYING THERE IS

hazy mural
violet holly
#

bad tank didnt pull correctly so the whatever mob synced the whatever skill and killed the dps

still locust
#

Bulok fucking HATES DG

rustic kestrel
hazy mural
#

ur called before the court to answer for ur crimes

still locust
#

You heard it here first

forest flume
lucid arrow
#

but it is very difficult for a lot of people

rustic kestrel
#

yes it is

still locust
#

Bulok is a known auto-heal hater

#

He hates DG

#

He hates AtW

#

He hates MoY

#

Nothing but a hater

hazy mural
#

bet he hates healers too

#

they auto heal ppl

forest flume
still locust
#

Yeah, healers steal his cool moments to snipe with DoC

rustic kestrel
odd cave
#

then they complain they had to heal

lucid arrow
#

maybe if u look deep inside u bulok

#

u can find out why u hate auto heals

#

maybe it stems from childhood auto heal trauma

forest flume
#

I think this no-apex build becoming the "norm" broke Bulok

#

it will take time to recover

clear atlas
#

Man I miss DF AtW

hazy mural
forest flume
rustic kestrel
#

i dont hate atw, i hate how much lesser it is now

still locust
forest flume
#

Holding resources for a well timed AtW was 10/10 gameplay

clear atlas
#

LOVED that

rustic kestrel
#

make atw do like 30% more, and make it a button press

#

and oh pappy we are so back

forest flume
#

Use 2 SI to not die, BUT top everyone, easy

violet holly
hazy mural
#

I remember telling ranged to come closer for h eals

forest flume
#

and that brings us to the 2-SI war, we lost soldiers that day

violet holly
hazy mural
#

remember the blueberry mobs in Shadowmoon? Gladge

#

or Khajin in Halls

clear atlas
#

shadowmoon

#

ooooooof

hazy mural
#

ATW heaven in those places

clear atlas
#

wild how much more balanced dungeons are now

forest flume
hazy mural
forest flume
#

hp bars going down and up non-stop

hazy mural
#

rdruids can go die in a tree fire

forest flume
#

thats me about moonkins

hazy mural
jaunty dragon
#

Are you guys having a hard time with AA? Doing +20 with pugs the timer just feels insane and big pulls just causes wipe on vexus with triple pulls

sonic quest
#

What m+ key is the easiest to tank for bear and what one is hardest ?

late basin
#

Both ends of the bell curve in two posts. ^

forest flume
rough quartz
#

I think I might be challenged, but how do I use heart of the wild correctly? I've tried using it while in bear, and also shifting to cat form then casting ff. Still doesn't show that I used it on logs.

clear atlas
#

casting that FF IS hotw

sonic quest
#

Nexus point . Felt on edge of death . WR felt like a god

clear atlas
#

the ability turns form depending on your shapeshift.

rough quartz
#

That's what I thought

clear atlas
#

Defenders in Nexus are criminal

still locust
#

No clue why

#

Blizz issue

rough quartz
#

Like I swapped to cat, pressed FF, then no FF on logs

still locust
forest flume
daring nymph
#

boomies be like

#

my steak is to juicy

#

and my lobster is to buttery

marble wraith
#

Obvs harder with pugs that they'll do it but yea letting books cast then cancelling is so much better than cancelling the cast BC they just recast

#

Just need to sync up the casts with cc first

vapid forum
stoic marsh
#

o/

#

guys that one

#

is there a way to let it proc more

#

or my luck in ground 🙁

#

every 10 casts or 15 casts only proc one

pearl dew
#

its better to be lucky than to be right, so go get some more luck

rustic kestrel
#

its probably casting way more than you realize

stoic marsh
#

but nothing to let it proc more right

olive hare
# hazy mural true... they all need to die

Flashing claws is super rng heavy since it doesnt have any bad luck protection baked in. You can have a 10 thrash straight and no proc, or 1 cast proccing 4 thrashes.

rustic kestrel
pearl dew
#

if you want we can start a rumor that if you shift in and out of bear form it resets the rng so it procs more

forest flume
rustic kestrel
#

technically possible

#

my max chain is 6

gilded ridge
#

Bros i need help with Skyreach
how do you mitigate the damage from the fiery talon debuff from the adepts mobs?

rustic kestrel
#

by walking away

#

Typhoon/Ursols/Incap roar

gilded ridge
#

just like that huh

#

aight

olive hare
#

Yeah literally, just dont facetank those as soon as your stack counter reaches 4-5.

gilded ridge
#

and the shear debuff?

rustic kestrel
#

panic

#

(hit a defensive)

gilded ridge
#

figured

olive hare
#

Doesnt even feel that bad as bear

gilded ridge
#

aight

rustic kestrel
#

Youll need to live without a defensive during the pack and have one for it, as the tankbuster wil hit you for 60% of your max health on higher keys

#

and will overlap with things to kill you

forest flume
#

I died to Shear on SR-20, it was not a pleasant pull (the one after bird boss)

rustic kestrel
#

yup

forest flume
#

I think it hit for 500k, i was not ready

#

may have played badly (prob did)

rustic kestrel
#

any other source of damage + that buster is death without a defensive

olive hare
#

Having a dps comp with a couple spare braincells also makes those two pulls so much easier to live.

#

just weave in a couple of AoE ccs, slows or whatever makes such a difference