#balance

1 messages · Page 343 of 1

lofty depot
#

Well it is, if u talent out of jt

#

It will say "a more powerful spell is active"

#

It also won't update ur stats.

#

So make sure ur using it

nimble tangle
#

So does it matter now I have to surge first 3 ascendant stacks?

dry compass
indigo barn
#

Does convoke + rattle build for single target and incarn + weaver build for cleave make sense now? I want to have just a couple of builds ready for raid.

lofty depot
lofty depot
nimble tangle
#

feel so slow and not on track with rotation

ruby badger
#

With the opener on wowhead feels pretty consistent

livid jay
#

so we cast big one and respec or what

lofty depot
#

U cant

#

It updates down, not up

#

Iirc

#

Or actually hmm

#

Team how do u do the funny timestamp thing in discord

#

Please help

jaunty blaze
#

what timestamp

wintry ruin
#

Hey guys I raided last night for the first time as boomy and had some rotation questions. How are we supposed to optimize our rotation for adds that spawn that arent stacked up? for example if we have 4 adds up but not stacked, the only value we get from lunar eclipse is via starfall, but we cant starfire them, but I feel if I stay in lunar eclipse with wrath/starsurge I have less aoe value. Do I save an cds for this moment so I can CA/incarn and wrath and starfall?

lofty depot
normal pilot
#

so lunar/solar eclipse doesn't matter, you don't need to think about it

lofty depot
#

It work shrely

normal pilot
#

it's just 'eclipse'

leaden birch
#

was I supposed to convert coffer key shards last week or smth

normal pilot
#

if you're in a situation where you can starfire, then you starfire and press eclipse

leaden birch
#

why am I only able to get 6 keys so far

lofty depot
#

They weren't a thing last week

dire osprey
normal pilot
#

if you're in a sitation where you can't starfire then you wrath and press eclipse

leaden birch
#

am I supposed to get 6 or 8 this week?

lofty depot
#

U should be able to get 8, but 200 from a quest?

#

I can't remember someone say

#

Maybe larias guide?

lofty depot
leaden birch
#

I'm doing the weeklies now and I'm just stuck at 600/600 shards

#

and these stupid weeklies give shards

lofty depot
#

Well the 200 extra is from a quest iirc

leaden birch
#

hmm

lofty depot
#

Doesn't count towards cap

#

But u can only get 600 a week

wintry ruin
normal pilot
#

no

lofty depot
#

Both eclipse increase both spenders

normal pilot
#

there should be a faq in compendium about astral damage

#

maybe or maybe gamz nixed it i forget

lofty depot
#

It's not "I need lunar to cast starfall"

#

The astral damage is there

wintry ruin
#

Damn im just dumb then lol. I was only doing starsurge during solar and starfall during lunar eclipse

normal pilot
#

oh god it's in the discord faq channel

lofty depot
#

Yeeee

normal pilot
#

why this is so annoying

jolly delta
#

I agree

#

Idk why the choice

#

I'll put it back

#

Sorry gamz

lofty depot
#

Hmm I wonder who said I hate forums

lucid olive
normal pilot
#

yeah discord forums suck

lucid olive
#

theyre different

jolly delta
lucid olive
normal pilot
#

i wonder if you can make a bot to just copy the github changes onto the forum post

jolly delta
jolly delta
#

I wanted to do it for the pins

#

When stuff gets updated etc

normal pilot
#

i assume the reverse is a giant pain since dicsord api is prolly pretty shoddy?

#

but auto updating pin/posts via github actions prolly smoother to maintain

jolly delta
lofty depot
#

Make a bot post change logs to discord

jolly delta
#

You can listen for messages for sure, idk about any hooks

lofty depot
#

Oh wait GitHub exists gogogogo

jolly delta
#

So you're left to guess "is this ptr? Is this coming? Is this new or just a recap?"

#

While parsing garbage html

lofty depot
#

Yea, and then funny blue poster is wrong anyway

jolly delta
#

This can probably be done with spelldata parsing but would require upkeep and lots of custom stuff

normal pilot
#

one day(tm)

jolly delta
#

Or probably doable with LLMs now but ehhh

#

Not getting paid enough

normal pilot
#

there's a long term project to write a tooltip parser off the data so we don't have to rely on wowhead

#

and that'll properly parse values/show changes etc.

lofty depot
#

2030 or

normal pilot
#

prolly never ppl get interested in it then quit for better game

jolly delta
#

im in

#

(jk the game sucks so I barely have the motivation)

#

one day(tm)

normal pilot
#

simc used to have a tooltip parser way back in mop/wod era but it's pretty much abandoned

#

right now i think it throws a shit ton of exceptiosn but it's at the very end of the execution so nobody bothered to clean it up

#

like there's some vestigial stuff to parse and fill in these tooltip tokens so theoretically you can build a tooltip straight off data with all the parsed modifiers/etc. built in

wintry ruin
#

So just to confirm, I can pop wrath and solar eclipse, but then spam starfall? And I should starfall on 2+ targets? But if im in solar eclipse and the adds stack up i should finish out wrath/eclipse before starfall/eclipse?

jolly delta
#

I guess decompiling it is fine but not serving it? What about tooltips? What about wowhead?

timber ermine
#

quick question.
i managed to get heroic weapon from Delve Map... i did not craft.
Do i send crafts now on Wirst Waist Boots etc. or save for myth craft?

sleek dirge
#

Hello,
I haven't played since start of TWW and have forgotten everything about crafts and sparks.

The WoWHead BiS guide says that this season, the BiS are a raid dagger and off hand lantern (craft).
HOWEVER, the recommended craft section seperates the Early Crafts and the BiS Crafts.
In the Early part, they say that we should first get the 2H Staff.

I'm not sure how that's gonna play out later on. Are we expect to just toss the Staff away when we get our hands on the dagger ?
It feels like a lot of money is getting tossed aside for something that we will not keep.

Shouldn't we just get the Crafted Lantern now and wait for a dagger from either M0/M+ while waiting for the Raid dagger ?

lucid olive
jolly delta
unborn haven
#

I have a probably dumb balance question, I am new to Druid and I noticed that sometimes my sun and moon dot hit 1 target and sometimes it applies to multiple. Does anyone know the reason for that or what skill/passive causes this? Thanks in advance ❤️

sleek dirge
#

why ? was there something i didnt understand ?

timber ermine
lucid olive
viscid ermine
#

2h staff is our best craft atm?

lucid olive
#

early on yes

normal pilot
#

You can make a public tooltips service better than wowhead and ppl would just use that

#

back when DF introduced the trees we were considering using wowhead to display them but they insisted on including links to their own 'bis build' page on every talent tree so we said no and seri developed the raidbots talent render that we use instead

lucid olive
#

think DG used the raidbots one at one point before vinter made his own

normal pilot
#

yeah it was wowhead at the very start then we swapped that out too

latent trout
#

Has the compendium for Midnight Season 1 been updated?

lucid olive
#

pins

normal pilot
#

can't blame 'em they need clicks to pay gamz and ccp social credits can't be redeemed in norway

jolly delta
#

But I don't speak legalese so

latent trout
normal pilot
#

yeah datamining isn't explicitly covered

#

but also lol eula blizz can c&d all of this wheenver they want

jolly delta
#

Wouldn't be my first c&d I'm ready to fight MoonkaGun

lucid olive
slender island
#

anyone knows if the Primal Spore Binding embellish is bugged? it seemed pretty well for me but just did a m0 tour and in most fights it did not proc at all (according to details, that is); so either the dmg is there just not showing correclty, or I've made an expensive mistake...

normal pilot
#

coudl be the damage is being eaten up by the heal proc

#

do you have a log

slender island
#

let me see...

#

ah, only m+ was enabled for logging, so no :/

cosmic elbow
#

checked pins do we have any sims

lucid olive
#

idk i have loads of sims of my own character

cosmic elbow
#

what are you getting for yours

jolly delta
#

yeah I think I'll get 3 runes thanks

normal pilot
#

it's the only liquid option

#

cash is king

rain jetty
#

I mean we should craft next week

#

When mythic plus is out

#

for Mythic crest no?

lucid olive
#

yeah but you can just use your sparks to craft a weapon now if you want to be more powerful for heroic week

#

but the value of that just depends on what level you play

rain jetty
#

Is crafted gear lower il than mythic raid?

lucid olive
#

its 3 ilvl less than max myth

#

made up for with embellishment effects

rain jetty
#

so same

#

ish

lucid olive
#

crafted gear good enough to be worth it

#

and then some more on top of that

rain jetty
#

So what do you suggest?

#

Based on preference

#

?

lucid olive
#

do your tier 8+ delve with a map to fish for hero item

#

if you get a staff in there then you can hold craft for next week

rain jetty
#

I got helmet

lucid olive
#

if not then just send your 4 sparks on a staff that youll send myth crests on next week

rain jetty
#

If I craft the staff now with hero crest

#

can I upgrade it later or na?

lucid olive
#

dont craft with hero crests

#

possibly biggest waste of crests

rain jetty
#

what do i craft with then

#

?

ripe slate
#

nothing

lucid olive
#

no crests

#

just slam the sparks

#

item is 259

bitter sun
#

So i got a 1 handed wep from the delve map. For crafting should i go for the offhand and a wrist?

rain jetty
#

And then

#

NExt week I can add crests to it

#

?

#

To make it higher?

lucid olive
#

your 2nd craft early should probably also not be wrists/belt

lofty depot
#

HOLY IM JUICED

true viper
#

67

rain jetty
#

@lucid olive ?

maiden lantern
#

should i stack Fury of Elune with Sundered Firmament or it doesnt matter and just press it off cooldown?

slender island
lucid olive
#

the two lasers are independent of each other

lofty depot
#

if u have the CD foe, u press it regardless

maiden lantern
#

👍

lofty depot
#

u shouldnt be holding it

normal pilot
#

you need to test way longer than that

#

it's only 2 rppm

rain jetty
#

If I craft staff now without crests can I add crests next week or how does it work?

lofty depot
#

yes

#

thats the point

normal pilot
#

if you were gonna test at least an hour

lucid olive
normal pilot
#

or just run a few dungeons

lofty depot
slender island
#

but still, based on what i saw during a full m0 tour, and how infrequently it seems to proc, im losing all faith in it :p

lucid olive
lofty depot
#

i am very powerful... havent sent champ yet either

lucid olive
#

theres a "you need to be this height" barrier in front of the voidspire and youre too short

slender island
#

i'll do a follower dungeon, have a quest to finish, would that be a decent enough test?

lofty depot
normal pilot
#

prolly not it is really low rppm so you're gonna hvae a lot of variance but i guess it's better than nothing

lucid olive
lofty depot
#

I have that too

ripe slate
gentle edge
#

hi guys, in single target convoke + keeper do i pool astral power then eclipse or how do i approach eclipse ?

lofty depot
#

As a general rule, pooling asp to dump is good

gentle edge
#

thanks alot ❤️

lofty depot
#

That rule doesn't have to do with keeper convoke tho

gentle edge
#

when shouldnt i pool ? is there an exception ?

lofty depot
#

U do it regardless, it's good to have asp to spend

lucid olive
lofty depot
#

If u would overcapp on charges of eclipse

lucid olive
#

which should only be on pull

gentle edge
lofty depot
#

Wasn't there some funny line about asp for surge + procs to dump

maiden pasture
lofty depot
#

Essentially having 2-3 surges to dump

lucid olive
viscid ermine
#

so, if i craft staff with darkmoon sigil embelish, 2nd one i can make a common hands with veteran crest and arcanoweave lining ye?

lucid olive
#

the veteran craft you can send on a low stat budget slot

maiden pasture
lofty depot
#

Does common hands me bracer

#

U should craft 2nd embell on ur lowest ilvl piece

#

That isn't a tier slot, likely

viscid ermine
#

my lowest ilv piece rn are hands

lofty depot
#

At least til later

lucid olive
#

yeah your next 2 sparks can go on your off-tier piece since you won't outgrow them until a lot later in the season

lofty depot
#

It won't matter too much but if u get tier hands u just lose the embell

lucid olive
#

yurr

carmine acorn
#

is there any repeatable way to get veteran gear right now for the free upgrades?

plucky valley
#

Yurr

lucid olive
lofty depot
#

Veteran gear, assume heroics?

viscid ermine
#

ok, so i will make staff with embell, and 246 hands with arcanoweave, thanks guys for help

lofty depot
#

Or is that adventurer?

carmine acorn
#

i think heroics is adventurer

lofty depot
#

So delves?

#

Maybe

lucid olive
#

veteran is in delves i guess

carmine acorn
#

delves adventurer aswell

carmine acorn
#

at least up to 9 xD

#

which is what i tried

lucid olive
#

but glad you decided on something

lofty depot
#

Well that's not true cuz bountiful 8 is chanp

maiden pasture
lofty depot
#

Use coffee key ezpz

carmine acorn
#

yeah but what i need is veteran ahah

#

to get free upgrade to 250

lofty depot
#

Why do u need veteran

#

Ah

lucid olive
#

just gonna go back with more gear later and collect the crests

carmine acorn
#

i did the boss on tank, didnt understand it, but was easy

lofty depot
#

Uhhh, get lucky with a champ 2/6 drop lol

carmine acorn
lucid olive
#

at least on kyveza i knew i died because i suck at dodging the lines

#

that new guy just white swings for over half my hp

lofty depot
#

Don't worry, tettles didn't get it either?

lucid olive
#

gg

carmine acorn
#

i tanked it with valeera as dps

#

but yeah not doing that on ??

lofty depot
#

He got off before raid or something

lucid olive
#

the ? difficulty is fake

#

doesnt exist

lofty depot
carmine acorn
#

drops the map :d

bitter sun
#

oh btw when crafting staff, missive with mastery/crit or mastery/haste?

lucid olive
#

sim

carmine acorn
#

sim it 😄

lofty depot
#

Sim it 🙂

#

Or just make a decision and vibe

carmine acorn
#

which is a great advice since you'll trade all your gear in a day or 2

lofty depot
#

I did Crit mastery

carmine acorn
#

i made a decision and vibe

bitter sun
#

ah okay 😛

carmine acorn
#

went for haste mastery

#

I'll have to recraft it next week for mythic anyway

unborn haven
#

I got 2 questions I’m hoping yall can help me with, up to how many enemies in a pack am I supposed to keep moonfire and sunfire up on?

carmine acorn
#

all of them?

viscid ermine
lofty depot
#

For now, if they live long enough u dot them

lofty depot
#

Like 6 seconds or some shit

unborn haven
#

So even if there’s 10 just take a min to dot them all?

lofty depot
carmine acorn
#

crap

lofty depot
#

Yes

gentle edge
#

do i wait starlord to drop before eclipsing ?

unborn haven
#

Thanks for answers, 2nd question sometimes moonfire/sun hit multiple targets. Do you know what causes that?

lofty depot
#

If u won't overcap on asp or eclipse charges sure

lucid olive
lucid olive
#

Type in Moonfire and you will see every talent that has the word Moonfire

#

then do the same for Sunfire

unborn haven
#

Kk, appreciate it

lucid olive
#

(also read Sunfire tooltip cause that spell is AoE by default)

gentle edge
#

really appreciate u guys thanks a bunch ❤️

covert coyote
#

do I really need to take FoE as KOTG PepePain

lucid olive
#

you dont need to do anything you dont want to

#

its a free world

lilac citrus
#

Should we just craft 2hand staff right now with sigil hunt

lofty depot
#

"just", yes

lilac citrus
#

No reason not too I guess

lofty depot
#

Plenty of funny reasons not to

#

They just as little value

slender island
normal pilot
#

hm actually it proced 28 times just 27 were heals unlucky

#

i wonder if they bugged it like they did with bronze grip wrappings

lofty depot
#

Rekt lol

slender island
#

yeah, either way, it's an interesting embellish on paper, but just doesnt seem to work in practice, shame

#

thx for the assistance!

fast finch
#

Is it possible to solo the delve boss as a balance druid or I shouldn't bother and go as guardian?

lofty depot
#

U can

#

It's just a lot of running around

normal pilot
#

i guess if you want to responsible you can bug report it maybe eventually they'll fix it

lofty depot
#

Surely they fix the renown trinket

sick arch
#

is there a list somewhere of cheaper enchants? the bis ones are insanely expensive

#

I dont do M progress si spending that much is kinda overkill 😄

normal pilot
jagged haven
#

we doing the 4part pvp weekly?

pastel onyx
#

For KotG, do you use FoE on cd or hold to use with Force of Nature ?

lucid olive
#

either hold to use right before treants or use inside treants

#

they should ideally line up somewhat naturally

lucid olive
#

and if they dont then you misplayed somewhere previously

lofty depot
#

U can filter on the AH for this expansion and see them all

lucid olive
pastel onyx
#

Got it. Thanks !

slender island
kindred token
#

Why Fury of Elune? :/

lofty depot
#

Cuz it does damage

#

I'm sure uve asked this question every day for a week

kindred token
#

lol

normal pilot
#

one day the answer will change

sharp lantern
#

Hi! How do we simulate our damage in dungeons now without the dungeon route WeakAura string? And Dungeon Slice isn’t allowed for Moonkins.

jaunty blaze
#

1t5min works fine for that

#

stats wont change drastically in aoe situations

#

hunt

normal pilot
nimble tangle
#

Do not ask do not think

#

Just do the flow chart

#

Be the sheep

#

Be the chicken

unkempt tree
#

if I craft boots, what emblishment I need to put it?

lucid olive
lofty depot
drowsy cape
#

Are we looking a lot heavier crit now? I know mast is king but seems like the bis list is heavy on crit over haste

lofty depot
#

It's not heavy on crit

#

They're about equal

lucid olive
#

ye

lofty depot
#

Last tier was heavy crit

lucid olive
#

it just looks heavy on crit cause of the ring and weapon

unkempt tree
kindred token
# lofty depot Cuz it does damage

I don’t think it would be a necessary to add extra cooldown spell even if it does damage, I think its clunky way of playing it, that’s just my opinion though

slender island
lofty depot
slender island
#

Primal Spore Binding embellishment is not working as intended: i've just done an m0 tour and combed through my dps logs and only found a handful of dmg procs, under 0.1% contribution. Digged into it a bit more with the help of folks from dreamgrove discord, turns out the embellish is proccing more often than what I'm seeing, but with the HEALING effect, which is obviously not what a dps spec would want. See https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/DbTfg1GrhNjJPyAH (enough to give an idea).

lucid olive
#

huge

slender island
#

thats what i put in the report

lucid olive
#

I am pretty sure Gastank asked more just for Raidbots functionality as well

#

to get more data on the proc

unkempt tree
lofty depot
#

Engineering

#

Go look for the leatherworking one prob

lucid olive
#

engineering boots HUH

unkempt tree
lofty depot
#

I go by arctic, but thanks

lucid olive
lofty depot
slender island
narrow granite
#

Is fury of elune bugged or does it not benefit from both eclipse and treants at the same time?

lofty depot
#

Have u tried not losing hp

lucid olive
#

do you have a log to prove it doesnt

narrow granite
#

If I eclipse it does 26k treants it does 26k both 25k

#

I was just sitting here on training dummy so no

nimble tangle
#

i am having 11% crit and 16% haste

#

feels like crit and haste both needed

lofty depot
#

Why u got low stats big dawg

nimble tangle
#

cuz i am only 245

#

ONLY 245

nimble tangle
lofty depot
#

245, ur already behind

nimble tangle
#

i am behind

#

eveyday

#

all day

lofty depot
#

Nah, locken

nimble tangle
#

actually i can craft 272 staff now

#

i think

#

110 crests

lofty depot
#

Don't do that

fast finch
#

Stupid question here but I feel lost, if I can't do the delve boss, should I send normal tier crests for staff ?

lucid olive
#

why would the delve boss matter

#

and no

lofty depot
#

U should not send crests on staff, and that has no condition towards the delve boss

lucid olive
#

also you can not craft with champion crests

fast finch
lofty depot
#

DO NOT

lucid olive
#

dont craft with hero crests

lofty depot
#

wasting crests for something u can kill in a few weeks if it's a problem

nimble tangle
narrow granite
#

First is just eclipse 2nd is both treant and eclipse

#

Should be another like 8k dmg there

fast finch
#

Ok ok that's why i asked thanks guys, so I should do my daily m0s to get gear this week or not worth it too

lofty depot
#

Yea

#

Nightmare preys, bountiful delves, m0s

fast finch
#

Ty a lot ❤️

pseudo merlin
#

@royal zenith mark rutte said "please be silender"

narrow granite
#

I think my dmg with fury of elune actually goes down if I cast treants before it

normal pilot
#

maybe character bricked unlucky time to boost new druid

tiny tendon
#

I craft agi staff? garf

lofty depot
#

Ew don't let ur gm gaslight u

latent trout
#

Does it even make sense to craft a weapon if you're only raiding HC at most? Because if so, I'd go ahead and do that for tonight.

tiny tendon
#

I’m assuming it’s a belt+bracer (or adjacent) kind of craft season innit

dense steeple
#

If youre only planning on doing HC and you think it doesn't matter, why are you asking if you should craft

kindred token
#

How come Gamz isn't using Fury of Elune in his talents then?

tiny tendon
#

Built diffy

lofty depot
#

What else u want to craft

craggy sonnet
lofty depot
#

Some shit bracer?

narrow granite
craggy sonnet
#

oh

narrow granite
#

I want full naked to check for procs of trinkets etc

#

The difference

#

First was both 2nd was just eclipse

#

So its for sure not calculating the 16%

lofty depot
tacit sky
#

do u starfall lightblinded vanguard

kindred token
latent trout
lofty depot
neat cairn
#

why is moonkinfrom bugged as nightelf i have the owl cast animations is this adjustable?

drifting nova
#

zzz trying to do anything in the world boss zones is so fucked

#

runestone broke shrugeg

kindred token
#

The guy from liquid team did 114k dps

#

on Druid Balance

royal zenith
#

damn that's very valuable info without context!

lofty depot
#

There's like 6 in said guild that can play balancr

#

Pick one

ocean atlas
#

the cd rotation in a ST boss fight is Eclipse> incarn>eclipse >incarn?

lofty depot
#

Yes

#

I think there's 2 eclipses in there between the incarns

#

What r u asking

ocean atlas
lofty depot
#

Ye

glacial ridge
#

Can I just do an @player macro for my treants so I dont have to place them ??? 😆

round field
#

no

lofty depot
#

@cursor

#

U wouldn't want @player anyway

leaden birch
#

where the shits do I get these last 2 coffer keys

ocean atlas
#

i got @cursor an placed it anywhere

lofty depot
#

What if ur not stacked on boss

leaden birch
#

I'm gonna need a wowhead news article i stg

glacial ridge
lofty depot
leaden birch
#

😭

#

there's too many of those

glacial ridge
#

OK next question... feral supremacy or balance after all these changes?

lofty depot
#

Feral has no supremacy

glacial ridge
#

🤣

craggy sonnet
craggy sonnet
leaden birch
#

other than buying keys with the delve currency

royal zenith
#

holy moly!

bronze topaz
#

you get the last 2 from the delve vendor

#

she has a bag that has 200 fragments that dont count towards the cap

leaden birch
leaden birch
#

ooo the starter kit

#

god bless

#

more loot here I come

craggy sonnet
#

oh, sorry. didnt read proper. thought you meant how to fill weekly cap

leaden birch
#

ya nw

#

thats the easy part

indigo barn
#

is there some single target dummy in silvermoon or do you go back to valdrakken?

lofty depot
#

Or dorngol

eternal acorn
#

When recrafting weapon enchants will stay as they are right?

lofty depot
#

Yes

pure zephyr
#

hows vessel of tortured souls? cant see it in dreamgrove

lofty depot
#

It's good, but hard to see orbs

pure zephyr
delicate perch
#

Just look for em

wintry umbra
#

suprising how much droptimizser for the dungeons seems to like the algathars healer trinker

normal pilot
#

it was bugged as proccing off damage spells for balance in df

#

idk if it's still bugged you'd prolly have to test

wintry umbra
#

cant imagine it touches the raid trinkets but was #2 in a droptimizer done as full mythic to make sure everything would be an upgrade regardless of my current

#

probably not the right way to sim trinkets like that lol

normal pilot
#

idk it was good back in DF just cuz of this bug

#

i dobut they've fixed it but maybe who knows

harsh jungle
#

wowhead talents or dreamgrove?

stoic grotto
#

is there an innervate popup on whisper addon

tender elbow
#

Anyone know what this count down bar is called and how I can remove it?

rotund sedge
#

The thing kind of in the middle of the screenshot? Isn't that the boss warnings thing?

#

Also, I'm embarrassed to ask this question but I haven't played boomkin since Cataclysm. Does Starfall have the massive aoe centered around the caster still?

stoic grotto
#

si

clear pulsar
stoic grotto
rotund sedge
fading cape
stoic grotto
rotund sedge
#

Okay that was where I was going. I have so many memories of hitting it in a dungeon and pulling things from four rooms over.

#

Funny, but also really annoying

#

Thank you!

fading cape
tender elbow
lusty echo
#

Hello there, I'd love some advice. I looted https://www.wowhead.com/item=251787/sealed-chaos-urn in heroic in delve. Is it any good for us ? I suppose it is on MM+ only, but would love a confirmation.

I also got https://www.wowhead.com/item=250258/vessel-of-tortured-souls, I find it hard to spot when the "souls" you have to gather pop. Is it possible by any means to have an alert ? With an addon, or maybe the GCD manager etc ?

lofty depot
#

u can sim it if u want

#

but yea tortured souls kinda tuff

lusty echo
#

The sim doesn't consider the fear I guess

tight pendant
#

Noob question. Wife and I both play Balance but with the new Eclipse, we are unsure if we should enter Eclipse at max AP or enter Eclipse at low AP?

Does Eclipse buff Starsurge/Starfall damage?

thin yacht
#

it depends on st/aoe/talent selected. Check pins for more info.

lofty depot
#

u also dont want to overcap charges of eclipse, and yes both eclipse buff both spenders

tight pendant
#

Thank you so much! 🩵

frail crescent
#

Just checking out the updated compendium, and have a question regarding playing fury of elune with keeper:
The only condition (in ST) to press fury is just before pressing force of nature.
But then, since they are kept synced, what is the reason for playing Control of the Dream?

lofty depot
#

it will likely be a timing think in raid

delicate perch
#

I am not playing balance Druid to think

craggy sonnet
#

it gives you the option to go into your burst a tad sooner and then FoE during ecl without desyncing them longterm

#

it also at the very least nets you 15s cdr on ca, fon, convoke for the end of the fight

frail crescent
#

Alright thank you 👍

frosty grotto
#

If I got Final Grade from M0, should I be crafting something else instead of weapon? Or, should I craft weapon still?

lofty depot
#

do u like having a mythic weapon and not a champion one

ivory barn
#

the tier set on veteran is better to use vs having a champ pices?

lofty depot
#

probably

#

but thats just a sim question

craggy sonnet
#

surely any bonus is better than one track diff

ivory barn
#

Probably

glacial steeple
#

off Piece for tier is hands correct?

craggy sonnet
#

very likely

#

though you dont really have a choice the first two weeks

glacial steeple
#

True, got two piece from RF and was checking to see what to hit with the catalyst

pale dome
#

Am I missing something here. I thought we were supposed to get as much mastery as possible, but when I sim, it pretty much takes Crit gear over mastery... Is that just because I have enough Mastery as is or?

indigo barn
#

We are so back, the fights with random adds spawning actually feel good to play as balance? lets go

vital hound
cunning basin
#

is balance op now

glacial steeple
#

It's real good

cunning basin
#

:OOO

dull skiff
lofty depot
#

sim ur gear

lofty depot
#

post of the time ur just gonna take gear with mastery + x

#

u can run a droptimizer to figure out what pieces are better and go for them

dull skiff
#

ok i got a 246 cape but its got vers instead of haste mast and raidbots has a red circle on the +55 dps upgrade cape

#

was curious if everyone has that type of issue

#

in que with cape again ill post to show

lofty depot
#

ok so....... first raw numbers are giga useless

#

second...... +55 isnt worth swapping

#

third vers is beans

dull skiff
#

says +75 now

#

jk i lied

#

has bs rings in there

dull dust
#

low precision

dull skiff
#

does boomy usually have this issue?

#

first time seeing with raid bots

dense steeple
#

The issue we normally have is our sims mean nothing because we do ass dam

dense steeple
#

Just because assassinations at the bottom it doesn't count the same

lucid olive
#

sorry that was rude, i appreciate you

dull dust
#

no idea but its usually a pretty safe bet to either ignore low precision or sim the item on its own separate and see if ur woried

dense steeple
#

We finished normal splits last night and saw 0 leather tokens

dull skiff
#

so i should wear the vet cloak instead of champ

dense steeple
#

I mean you have a fake Sim running anyway

dull skiff
#

scratches head

dull dust
#

what's a fake sim

dull skiff
dense steeple
#

Ec talents for st wojack_withered

#

Low precision

dull dust
#

why does it have 400 error

lucid olive
# dull dust what's a fake sim

a sim that tells you that you just need to hit them up and you can hang, but when you hit them up to hang they ignore you

dull dust
#

0.69 nice

lofty depot
#

255!!

dense steeple
#

Wtf they gave you gear

lofty depot
#

gear fed

stone ledge
#

big tier drops

dull dust
#

get him

vital hound
#

they gave him 2pc

#

goofy

stone ledge
#

2x 2p

dull skiff
#

how u get all the champ crests

#

got 139 rn lol

vital hound
#

play the video game

proven rampart
#

nightmare preys give 15 each and theyre quick

stone ledge
#

doing 16 m0's 6 bountiful delves, like 6 nightmare preys and full normal clear

dull dust
vital hound
stone ledge
#

dragon trinket dropped too imagine if i got that too

#

we dont even have a on use

#

well i have the cursed af urn

glacial steeple
#

Vessel of I can't see where tf you spawned?

stone ledge
#

no the stare

vital hound
#

yea we got two stares on heroic

#

and a ribbon

dull skiff
#

so on this sim i should be wearing the lower ilvl helm

#

got st tal;ents now

lofty depot
#

although ec sims the highest

#

if u play that i prey for u

#

u also need to change this to lates

wet crow
#

Never played balance before, raiding tonight, what spec do I play, is there an actual good rotation guide that someone could link me please?

lofty depot
#

did u read the pin

wet crow
grizzled imp
#

Good afternoon, I’d like to know which stats are used for the raid.

lofty depot
#

the ones that sim the best

#

generally u want everything but vers, but a sim will tell u that

wet crow
#

is kotg easier than ec?

trying to not overwhelm myself

grizzled imp
#

ty guy

lofty depot
obtuse jungle
#

for anyone that played the raid, what felt better so far since i am going into it in like 2 hours i was wondering what to go for atm ? convoke or no ?

hardy nimbus
#

Hi, i got a question regarding the rotation for balance druid and the eclipse cooldown. What do i do if i don't have procs of Starweaver or Touch of the Cosmos and i can't align with Force of Nature while having both eclipse cooldowns. Do i just raw send an eclipse or continue fishing for Starweaver or Touch of the Cosmos.

proven rampart
#

but citation needed

obtuse jungle
hardy nimbus
#

okay i found the compendium that has the situations better explained so i'll refer to it if i have questions.

lofty depot
glacial steeple
#

To put it kindly

dull dust
#

this spec feels so mobile

obtuse jungle
glacial steeple
#

KoTg feels more like you're planning around cds to me

normal pilot
#

it is yeah

#

maybe you don't like the extra cd button and are ok with the longer cast time on starfire

raw prairie
#

Is it better to run Incarn or Convoke in raid? I haven't seen a consensus anywhere

glacial steeple
#

Depends on the fight tbh

#

I prefer incarn most of the time

lofty depot
#

u can go look at the logs and copy top logs tho

versed jasper
#

is raid bots broken for boomkin???

normal pilot
#

if you just copy the top you'll always be second but if you do the opposite maybe you'll be first

shut trench
#

any talents for the triple boss fight?

#

EC or KOTG?

hollow panther
#

Is null hard for balance ?

sudden flame
#

tettles did it but you hgave to do some kiting bullshit cause the boss hits so hard

hollow panther
#

I got him to 45% but died to melee swings. I was just trying to stand in the healing puddles or take orbs at very low HP like 5%. But every time I'd randomly die. Is it easier as resto? Don't wanna get tank gear

lofty depot
#

melees do be annoying

lusty karma
#

what trinkets do you guys want going into raid?

lofty depot
#

theres a list of them in all the guides

lusty karma
#

yes and dreamgrove, wowhead & maxroll all saying different things

lofty depot
#

so then u can take all those trinkets in the list and sim them

hollow panther
#

The main thing that fucks me over on his fight is the void zones make me run out of the healing orbs. I assume that's when I have to "kite him" but he's fast af lol

#

Works best

lofty depot
#

this is balance chat

#

the fuck

hollow panther
#

Yeh u right

delicate perch
#

you heard him

hollow panther
#

Usually I'm resto chat

#

But I was doing balance for this null boss

#

Assumed it would be easier than resto

proven rampart
#

fwiw i pulled the guardian delve build off of wowhead and did the ? difficulty in one shot with moonkin trinkets, haven't tried ?? yet but i'd imagine guardian is still the path of least resistance

delicate perch
#

balance too difficult for healers to play

#

heard it here first

hollow panther
#

Balance easiest spec ever wym lol

#

Blizzard removed so much shit

indigo barn
delicate perch
#

you didn't even kill the boss

hollow panther
#

Did you kill it on ?? As balance?

#

Assume not

delicate perch
#

why would I care about a shitty title

#

tettles did it as balance didn't he

#

300 pull count kyveza does the new one day 1

hollow panther
#

Parasocial andy

delicate perch
#

gg

novel socket
#

Hey all. never really been active on here but i am coming back to playing balance after a long time off. I am just wondering about a few things that you are all doing.. 1) when do you hold fury of elune and when do you cast on cd? 2) from looking at parses it seems like people are casting there eclipse early in the fight and then casting celestial alignment before eclipse wears off? is that correct? 3) do you hold trees for use with just celestial or do you burn it with eclipse?

proven rampart
lofty depot
#

i also dont know if double on use works

indigo barn
#

its reccomending 0 on use now, but the vers stat stick is strong i guess and the haste on use is meh

lofty depot
#

for further context u should read the guide in the pins

#

im afk for 3 hours have fun

novel socket
blazing karma
#

This has probably been asked 1000 times, but 2H weapon craft stats are haste/mastery? Or are we doing crit/mastery?

glacial steeple
#

haste mastery but sim it is going to be the answer

jade jacinth
#

Should i use crests to upgrade?

glossy jungle
#

yes

#

or perhaps check with the robot

jade jacinth
#

can i happily spend my champion crests?

delicate perch
#

you can only unhappily spend them

jade jacinth
#

Lol

wind garnet
#

upgrade to 6/6 or no??

vital hound
#

most efficient is to wait for next week farm m+ and get free upgrades

#

but shrugeg

dense steeple
ebon sail
#

Presuming everyone knows the crest saving method for Midnight?

In case you don't.

Don't forget that you can change your crests into different crests (with some requirements).

If you have lots of veteran crests. If you upgrade to 6/6 that is the same as 2/6 Champion (Ilvl 250).

Therefore try to upgrade to 6/6 veteran and save yourself 20 champion crests going from 1/6 champion to 2/6 champion.

I've saved 80 champion crests by using up veteran crests first so far.

If done for all gear slots, ONLY if going 1/6 Champion to 2/6 Champion, you save 260 Champion crests.

This also works for other gear tiers too e.g. 6/6 adventurers will save veteran's 1/6-2/6, 6/6 champion will save you hero 1/6 hero to 2/6 hero and myth crests for going 1/6 myth to 2/6 myth.

jolly delta
#

Compendium has been: updated

#

(mostly graphical changes so don't look for new tech)

vital hound
jolly delta
#

(but some stuff has been fixed)

dense steeple
#

thanks boss

#

appareciate you as always

normal pilot
#

wait what language does it default the code blocks to it's highlightning 'of'

jolly delta
#

js

lucid olive
#

shrinking everything a bit so we can fit all the ads

normal pilot
#

smh ads are old tech

#

new tech is about mining personal data with AI

lucid olive
#

real

#

selling information is a lucrative business

loud kettle
#

New font detected

spice roost
#

do we know 100% if this works in raid or not

normal pilot
#

it's supposed to

#

if it doesn't then eventually they'll fix it

loud kettle
#

Even fully buffed its not exactly transcending ilvl

jade flume
#

Anyone has a 4 set

#

or has a homie with 4 set

#

how farmable are catalyst charges?

sudden matrix
#

What

#

charges are capped, doubt anyone has a 4 set first week

jolly delta
delicate perch
jolly delta
#

Getting 4p allows you to drop catalyst charges from world activities

jade flume
#

was just curious what the drop rate is on catalyst

dense steeple
normal pilot
#

i'd watch if it said fail but fall sounds less entertaining

dense steeple
#

we didnt do anything wrong

plucky valley
#

Every time I read somaloria I think of the skeletal pirate spell from wizard101

dense steeple
#

never played

plucky valley
#

As a child it was fun

#

It’s a terrible gacha game now

teal sphinx
#

@delicate perch boost me LITERALLY any other class

#

i think imma lose my mind playing arms

delicate perch
teal sphinx
#

BROTHER WTF

wild dune
#

ded spec

teal sphinx
#

6 people for dragons

#

wtf

delicate perch
#

That’s 6 guilds without a prot warrior

jolly delta
#

"Player-cast long term raid buffs can no longer be canceled while the player is in combat." pepeclown

#

I wonder why

#

Blizzard give me back my add-ons

#

Or else....

jade void
#

hello!

brave turret
#

Hello gamers. I’m trying to practice single target oration on balance and starfall is hitting all kinds of dummies so I’m not getting a good idea of my single target dps. Is there an actual lone target dummy in mf Azeroth?

lofty depot
#

on top of the towers

jade void
#

have the buffs to balance been implemented?

#

i cant find confirmation anywhere

lofty depot
#

the confirmation is in the post saying next reset

normal pilot
#

well 'confirmation'

#

it does looke like they correctly implemented all the tuning for balance this time tho

leaden seal
rough marten
#

grieftorch acquired

jolly delta
brave turret
jolly delta
#

They're called training dummies for a reason

true viper
#

Who gave the green light on 2 different buffs same icon

midnight sierra
#

Anyone have a macro to combine wrath and starsurge?

pseudo merlin
#

HUH??????

#

Yes actually I have one

#

/cast One Button Rotation

teal sphinx
#

i was 12th

exotic perch
#

man this p1 of alleria fight is annoying for mk

#

cant just stand in middle and hit starfall

lofty depot
#

gatekeep

fleet furnace
#

So we using both Treants and Fury in KotG spec?

lofty depot
#

u can yes

vital hound
outer oasis
jade void
#

great thanks!

leaden birch
#

damn, EC convoke raid talents are simming 1% higher

#

I guess that doesn't mean much when 1% is only like 600 dps though

lofty depot
leaden birch
#

yeah I did hear in here people talking about EC simming the highest but I dunno how I feel about starfiring in raid

maiden pasture
#

EC needs to sim more than 1% higher for it to be realistically worth playing

#

You dont get to turret for free

delicate perch
#

I do (I died 5s after pull)

lofty depot
#

its about to do more

jolly delta
#

And that won't happen until the druid council decides to release the hidden tech

normal pilot
#

don't give in to big sim

jaunty blaze
spice roost
#

@lofty depotlockin in

#

i need 4p so bad

lofty depot
#

(we had 1 leather tier drop)

#

were cooked

spice roost
#

i got 1 p of tier a waist piece and trinket so far

lofty depot
#

no tier til tuesday

spice roost
#

oh i raid again on friday

sour rampart
#

First split finished

lofty depot
#

he got a bunch of leather off pieces

#

but shrug

spice roost
#

damn i wish i did splits

lofty depot
#

larias giving himself 2 tier pieces

#

thats crazy

sour rampart
#

We had 5 mail tier pieces drop lmao

lofty depot
#

gear fed

spice roost
#

we had 4 leather ones

sour rampart
#

I was lowest prio on my team

lofty depot
#

sureeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

sour rampart
#

I can't share my sheet because I don't want @frosty raven to know he was below healer in prio

#

But I was literally last in DPS prio on my run lmao

tiny urchin
#

gib loot 🙁

sour rampart
#

He doesn't believe me

tiny urchin
#

lol

tardy hare
#

Can I craft 246 item without spark?

indigo barn
#

Ye 246 is the base blue item with 80 veteran crests

tardy hare
#

Oh it's the blue one. Thanks!

rough shadow
#

I have to ask, is anyone else like brain really struggling to get the new eclipse mechanic?

delicate perch
#

what part are you struggling with

rough shadow
#

I have played every iteration of balance and this is the first time I feel like the rotations feels off

rough shadow
delicate perch
#

you just kinda never want to cap eclipse charges and the rest plays itself pending timers/damage requirements

#

theres probably enough logs out to look at when people press stuff now too if that helps at all

rough shadow
#

I think I just need to rework my UI to make eclipse charges to be more clear

delicate perch
#

oh ya defs

#

idk if his new ui is public but the gamzui using bcdm is good

rough shadow
#

Who?

#

(googling got me nothing)

jaunty blaze
#

Who 😭

fossil sedge
#

how do i sim for m+

delicate perch
fossil sedge
#

patchwork 1 boss 5 mins ?

jaunty blaze
#

Ye

delicate perch
#

wowhead boomy ui guide should have the links I think

rough shadow
delicate perch
#

nah who was correct

rough shadow
#

Gamz Cdm is on the Wowhead guide

delicate perch
#

ya I'm sure it's all there

#

good tracking of stuff

indigo barn
#

"(googling got me nothing)" is also good dis 💀

delicate perch
#

tbh gamz ui did, gamzui did not

vital swift
#

TF is this, this guy got 100 parse and he uses eclipse and not waiting for it to run out uses CA. Is this really correct rotation?

indigo barn
#

Yes you just want to spend the charge before ca

rough shadow
#

I even tried to be a discord user and search before asking

indigo barn
#

It will be back up

vital swift
#

you reset your starlord

rough shadow
vital swift
#

im so confused

#

why dont he just pop CA after 2 wraths

indigo barn
#

Because then you lose one eclipse charge. Eclipse is big dam with bolt+ first three buffed surges

fossil sedge
#

did someone reply to me befroe how do we sim for m+ just patchwork 1 boss or is there another way

vital swift
#

google it

#

and you ll figure out

#

watch shadarek video

#

for mdt sims

#

its not perfect but really close to real m+ route

jolly delta
#

does this help

rough shadow
#

Not really

jolly delta
#

Was worth a try

rough shadow
#

I think I just need a couple of hours to get used to it and retrain the muscle memory

fossil sedge
#

@vital swift When i google it, it says sim dungeon slice and i was told to never do that

jolly delta
#

Thanks for betatesting CHATGERS

vital swift
#

WHATS THIS are you a computer or something ??????

#

AI

vital swift
fossil sedge
#

how do u do that

jolly delta
vital swift
fossil sedge
#

is there a string u can link me for mdt route or something

vital swift
#

i dunno you can make it yourself

#

with whatever dung you want

#

and whatever route

fossil sedge
#

if i jsut sim patchwork 1 boss 5 mins will it be good enough for m+ basically same gear right

vital swift
#

5 min patchwerk is just ST training dummy simulation

fossil sedge
#

ya i dont kno how to make a route or do that so i wouldnt kno how to sim for m+ then

#

unless dslice is good enough

jolly delta
#

I am not 100% updated on the details so I'm not sure if MDT has now a route export built in that doesnt require WAs

#

But the genereal idea is the same

#

That said, you are correct. Simming 1t 5m should be absolutely fine for almost all gearing decisions

round field
#

Youll be fine if thats the only sim you ever do

fossil sedge
#

ty

acoustic flicker
nimble tangle
#

After today Normal run, I realized use eclipse first then CA is way higher on damage

jolly delta
#

I would recommend reading the KOTG ST rotation

#

And making sure to understand how treants + incarn + convoke interact

#

Feel free to ask any questions you might have

#

But this already covers quite a lot

#

Also this should never happen

haughty sparrow
#

Do we hold Fury of Elune for treants? It is desynced on 2nd cast

#

Fury of Elune is the only confusing part for me how to handle it

haughty sparrow
#

Yeah sorry but they desync when playing control of the dream talent

#

Unless its a target dummy only problem

round field
#

you can just

#

hold treants for 15 seconds?

haughty sparrow
#

Ok I was just ensuring if i should. this talent is a little confusing when someone never played Balance before. Thanks 👌

round field
#

oh ye its super weird to understand

#

not very intuitive

#

its just basically

#

You can hold the cds for 15 seconds without losing any casts since the cd starts ticking as soon as they are up

#

in a way

split talon
#

does crucible of erratic energies proc outside of voidstorm?

jolly delta
#

(for what it's worth the current APL just sends both treants and foe ~on cooldown)

acoustic flicker
jolly delta
jolly delta
acoustic flicker
#

thnx

jolly delta
#

So basically the first eclipse line applies only if you have two charges
The second line if you have 1 charge and any of the other conditions applies

round field
#

im technically right

#

easier to explain as

#

"cd starts ticking for 15 sec when it comes off cooldown"

#

than whatever the fuck blizzards explanation is

jolly delta
#

you know whats easier to explain

#

lock in

round field
#

truee but that thing is kinda dookie

delicate perch
#

cut it out

round field
#

FUCK

#

im sorry

delicate perch
acoustic flicker
#

okay I get it now. Huge help! Thanks man!

round field
#

time to play a league game to get back into a grumpy mood

delicate perch
#

speed run a chat ban to get back in the mood

round field
#

actually

#

i play league

#

with chat off

#

beacuse i cant behave

#

oops

acoustic flicker
# jolly delta

Regarding this, when there are multiple targets and i need to dot them all. What should i do jst wait for them to group up and use AOE?

jolly delta
#

You first moonfire everyone, then you sunfire

#

If you miss someone with sunfire then unlucky you'll get them next time

acoustic flicker
#

Yoo you're the best!

#

I'll try that tomorrow

lyric crystal
#

anyone kn ows what r the bis trinkets?? is there sims ??

jaunty blaze
#

Should always sim your own character to know which are best for you

round field
#

not yet

#

wait for @lucid olive to update the bloodmallet profile

royal zenith
#

bis trinkets are usually best in slot trinkets

#

to answer your question

jaunty blaze
#

Best in slots is a 2hand weapon tho

#

What now

royal zenith
#

hence the 'usually'

#

all my bases covered

jaunty blaze
dawn surge
#

Hey sorry if this is a stupid question, but in this screenshot from the compendium it only stipulates to use starfall if youre below 3 starlord stacks or have the proc for first 3 in eclipse dmg buff, otherwise use starfire

#

does this mean you just use starfire even if youre capping AP?

#

or is that implied

jaunty blaze
#

No

dawn surge
#

just wanna be 100% sure

jaunty blaze
#

You never overcap

dawn surge
#

thought that was the case just wanted to be 100% since it said to not overcap in st but didnt here so wasnt sure if it was an oversight or intentional

#

ty

jaunty blaze
#

It's also the 3rd point on the screenshot

dawn surge
#

yeah you right

#

reading isnt my strong suit

#

gg

jaunty blaze