#balance

1 messages · Page 13 of 1

digital berry
#

this is a random rookery 18 from dwilkz

#

if you dont play properly and cap asp you will loose a lot of dmg

lofty depot
#

What if he was playing poorly and capping

frozen locust
#

im never capping really, but i do overlap starfalls sometimes

lofty depot
#

Sometimes?

frozen locust
#

like refresh at 3 stacks

digital berry
#

oh no

frozen locust
#

during lust etc

digital berry
#

baby no

#

that's now how it works

frozen locust
#

surge better?

lofty depot
#

It doesn't refresh

digital berry
#

you cannot "Overlap" starfall

#

you stack them

frozen locust
#

I know but it only goes to 3 right

lofty depot
#

No

digital berry
#

nope

lofty depot
#

It can go to 20

frozen locust
#

0.0

digital berry
#

you live and you learn

frozen locust
#

why do I have this in my head 😂

lofty depot
#

Shrug

#

Go look at funny stix log where we soam 20 in an incarn window

digital berry
#

theres no universe in which i lost dps on stix because i capped starfall surely right

#

the gcd on pressing starfall 20 times is higher then duration no?

tawdry geyser
#

Bare in mind sims don’t include the part that interacts when more members in party have it

earnest sage
#

whats the best weapons enchantment?

tawdry geyser
#

So idk I think myth priory is pretty close to hc cards imo

#

Get the extra int from ilvl too

digital berry
tawdry geyser
#

Or w/e stat it has idk lol

frozen locust
digital berry
#

That’s starlord

frozen locust
#

This one

plush prairie
#

thats the haste buff aint it

frozen locust
#

starlord is a diff one I think

plush prairie
#

it stacks to 3 but doesnt refresh timer

frozen locust
#

this is why I thought you can only have 3 starfalls out at once

#

I assumed the buff told me how many were active

plush prairie
#

ah

frozen locust
#

Actually I just got it to go to 4 so I think this is a brain cell issue for sure

lofty depot
#

Hm

frozen locust
#

last time I played boomie in m+ was shadowlands and I think it capped then so

lofty depot
#

Was gonna ask if uve ever tried pressing it a 4th time

frozen locust
#

you would have thought so 😂

#

anyway, so is there any difference between starfireing a bunch then doing 3 starfalls or starfall as soon as you can. I assume they are the same and you should optimize for movement?

tawdry geyser
#

StarLord stacks

#

If it is going to drop off you can hold abit of ap to insta stack star Lord back up

lucid olive
#

you want to maximize the amount of time you spend 3 stacks of Starlord

frozen locust
#

ah yup, true

lucid olive
#

but not if its at the expense of movement

frozen locust
#

thanks all!

#

one more quick q - starsurge on ST only? Starfall in 2+?

digital berry
#

In m+ yeah

frozen locust
#

yup

digital berry
#

In raid you surge on 2 if you have st talents

frozen locust
#

Thanks ❤️

deft rain
#

balance gear question -- balance is my alt atm, and dont plan on stepping into mythic raid but high m+ potentially --

is it better to get the best-in-slots weapon at hero, or crafted weapon

teal sphinx
#

10 ilvls on a weapon

deft rain
#

just didnt know if the cantrips had higher value than ilvl

dense steeple
#

Love you super

dense steeple
lucid olive
dense steeple
#

@digital berry jealous of you

teal sphinx
frozen locust
digital berry
obtuse flume
#

is hekili good to follow ? im really low dps versus other

#

in part with tank sometime.
i wonder what i do badly

obtuse flume
#

im trying to understand why im bad

#

uploading some og

#

log

lucid olive
#

this is from a 10 rookery you did a month ago

#

are you able to see what you did wrong here

#

cause there's a lot

#

okay nvm

lucid olive
#

this is from 11 Cinderbrew you did yesterday

teal sphinx
lucid olive
#

Moonfire before you press Incarn

teal sphinx
#

goes SOOO HARD

lucid olive
#

don't double press Incarn

#

Fury of Elune right before you press Incarn

#

I would go watch a guide or something

#

I do not mean to sound rude, but it seems very obvious that you are lacking some very core fundamentals on how the spec works

obtuse flume
#

you not rude i know im doing wrong, hence my presence here

lucid olive
obtuse flume
lucid olive
#

you should do that

#

Moonfire all mobs
Sunfire when mobs are stacked
Finish spreading Moonfire if there are mobs without it
Fury of Elune
Incarn+Starfall
Starfire
Starfire
Warrior of Elune

teal sphinx
lucid olive
#

thats basically the order you wanna do in

lucid olive
teal sphinx
lucid olive
#

Pressing Incarnation twice is a very bad habit that you should stop doing

#

The duration does not stack

#

so you are effectively losing over 14 seconds of Incarnation uptime consistently

obtuse flume
#

do you chain them ?

lucid olive
#

you just press them independently when you feel you need damage

#

sometimes I save the 2nd Incarnation charge for the 2nd pull

obtuse flume
#

warrior of elune on cd ?

lucid olive
#

you're also spending a lot of time spreading Moonfire when you're in cooldowns and that's very bad

lucid olive
#

but you can worry about that after you've practiced and learned the fundamentals

#

Fury of Elune you press on CD as much as possible

obtuse flume
#

when do you cast warth

crimson spade
#

only to eclipse

verbal iris
lofty depot
teal sphinx
lucid olive
#

or casting Wrath when the tank is walking towards a pack

#

theres a few places where you have a couple second gaps between spreading Moonfire and using your cooldowns

#

you're also using Fury of Elune and Incarn on the same global and you should try to avoid that

#

idk only feedback I got from that are just minor tidbits really

lucid olive
#

if you're going to use both charges on first pull, which you probably should on a 16, you want to wait for it to end so you get Dreamstate again

lofty depot
#

52-40 is not 15

plush prairie
#

Well looks like i'm not getting mythic bandit killed, what's my next best options? assuming just mythic signet

lofty depot
#

Just do maff

maiden pasture
#

Shrugeg this is just as easy

plush prairie
dense steeple
lofty depot
#

Took u 10 minutes to reply

#

Me do maff instantly

maiden pasture
#

i was looking for 10 minutes for sure

lofty depot
#

Type shit

lofty depot
maiden pasture
#

he's just playing like the goat

plush prairie
maiden pasture
#

damn he refreshed with 0.3s left

lofty depot
#

L

dense steeple
#

dwilkz goated

verbal iris
lucid olive
#

Usually that means you finish spreading dots, use Fury of Elune and then you Incarn+Starfall in the same global

#

Instead of spreading dots and then FoE + Incarn on the same global

#

if that makes sense

verbal iris
#

Yeah yeah got it ty

verbal iris
thorny sparrow
#

working on Rik Reverb, my add damage is really low (me, the other balance druid and 2 hunters) is that just how the spec is gonna be, or is there something I can do to optimize add damage?

verbal iris
lucid olive
verbal iris
#

k im stupid😐

#

got it

craggy sonnet
maiden pasture
#

If your raid struggles a LOT on raid damage you can go incarn build and only pop in adds, but as long as you have ASP ready for starfall when the adds spawn you should be fine

craggy sonnet
#

If you are playing a 1:30 trinket, you can go for the CA on pull route.. with a 2:00 trinket I found its better to use first CDs with first add spawns

maiden pasture
digital berry
dense steeple
green brook
#

@lucid olive can you clarify the us of incarn with Fury being bad? from what I understood you wanted to maximize fury uptime with the crit bonus

#

or are you suggesting you use fury and then hit the next global cast with incarn after the gcd

#

I joined late, so apologies if I missed it

lucid olive
#

FoE damage updates dynamically

#

you dont want to spend your first global in cooldowns on it

pallid bay
#

-1s foe +1 gcd in incarn

green brook
#

is there somewhere I can see the math on that, I don't doubt the vailidty of the claim I am just interested now in seeing how much of an optimization 1 more gcd of incarn is at the cost of 1 gcd of Fury getting the crit bonus

lucid olive
#

you can probably edit the APL to show the difference

#

but its all in the 0.2% range likely

green brook
#

if only I was competent in that language :p

green brook
maiden pasture
#

Fury of elune starts scaling above 2 targets right? Or did they change that?

#

Like the soft target cap thing

pallid bay
#

unfortunately gamz ignored my dm and i havnt bothered looking at it thoroughly

lucid olive
#

yeah its a risky game DMing me at 1pm

maiden pasture
pallid bay
#

maybe that sim is unrelated..

maiden pasture
#

I had to DM him 4 times before he replied

loud kettle
#

gamz has never ignored my dm

lucid olive
#

yet

loud kettle
#

if i ever finish boomy cds he will ignore my dm

pallid bay
#

i deserve it..

loud kettle
#

because itll be cursed

green brook
lucid olive
#

was a cookie somewhere

loud kettle
#

i want a cookie..

lucid olive
#

but didn't matter cause they added the enchant box the day after anyway

pallid bay
lucid olive
#

yeah that bug annoyed me

#

for like a week all my sims used the corruption enchant and it was never selected or part of the addon input

#

was a cookie leftover from mimiron or something

pallid bay
#

but gamz showed no interest..

lucid olive
#

unfortunate..

loud kettle
#

birdbrains i tell u

pallid bay
#

before = better

#

fix apl?

#

is there an mdt route i can use

#

somewhere

loud kettle
#

yea

#

somewhere

pallid bay
cloud plover
#

why is this discord so much about sims

lucid olive
#

Clecia was in here yesterday saying we should have separate EC and KOTG apls..

dry compass
#

what wow class discord isnt about sims

cloud plover
#

shadow

dry compass
#

well yeah no one sims ded spec

cloud plover
#

okay buddy

#

fight me

#

rn

#

behind aldi

lucid olive
#

thats what I thought too..

hidden plaza
#

Hi guys, i read the pins but im still confused and would like to have your opinion.

Do you purchase a mythic m+ trinket or raid hc trinket with dinars?

loud kettle
#

they apparently left the 'cord

hidden plaza
#

my trinkets are both giga garbage so far

pallid bay
#

real based true

#

you're the only maintainer..

dry compass
#

just because he suggested it doesn't mean he accepted the suggestion

slim iris
lucid olive
slim iris
#

This guy just can’t stay away from crunching the numbers

#

He must optimize the code

pallid bay
#

US ranks is so funny man

slim iris
#

???

#

I agree

pallid bay
#

i had to look up clecia

#

and then went to his guilds page

slim iris
#

Oh

#

I mean it’s fine if it’s from the perspective of like

#

We’re only recruiting NA players so that’s what’s relevant to applications

pallid bay
#

is oceanic just included in US LOLW

slim iris
#

Ye

eager raft
#

us guilds use us ranks cuz that's who their recruiting pool is

#

hope that helps

slim iris
#

NA OCE

pallid bay
eager raft
#

us 50 also looks better than world 300

#

😎

fervent merlin
#

Us 10 is world 39 this tier

#

But ye

pallid bay
#

top 10

#

😎

slim iris
#

Hey who cares

#

!

pallid bay
#

idk its just funny

#

we're only competing nationally!

slim iris
#

You are just pixels on my screen @pallid bay

thin sky
#

When running with House of Cards + Best-in-Slots, you just want to macro them both (with prio on house of cards) into CA? Or macro best-in-slots into FoN?

slim iris
#

That’s what we do

eager raft
#

europoors dont get it

slim iris
#

Just have it on a separate keybind

dry compass
#

if you're not first you're last and NA is first 😎

slim iris
lucid olive
slim iris
#

Surely not

eager raft
#

you should be thanking the usa for your freedom

thin sky
exotic perch
lucid olive
eager raft
#

💀

pallid bay
#

canada is also just US on wlogs

dry compass
#

we're used to it

jolly delta
slim iris
pallid bay
jolly delta
#

no

#

of the timeline?

#

or of the buttons

#

of the timeline kinda

pallid bay
#

timeline

#

not a big deal but Shrug

#

it just has this look of not being precise

jolly delta
#

cause its not

#

in the screen

pallid bay
#

thats not what i mean

eager raft
#

oops my control of the dream bugged and now my cooldowns dont match the timers

jolly delta
eager raft
#

i dunno i cant remember if they fixed that yet

jolly delta
#

oh i thought you meant on my timeline

#

should I replicate the bug on the website as well?

pallid bay
#

naah

eager raft
#

i don't think so

jolly delta
#

20% of the time it randomly doesnt work

fossil shard
pallid bay
#

always assume its working

fossil shard
#

it still happens

jolly delta
pallid bay
#

i mean use the WA

fossil shard
#

ya WA goated

#

one time I did sprocket without control

#

it was NOT fun

eager raft
#

probably doesnt hurt to link the WA again there with a disclaimer that the timeline assumes control working

fossil shard
#

ya ^

#

but also I feel like once in a while the WA doesnt change it back to control @pallid bay

#

not sure if thats just a bug on my end

eager raft
#

think it could just be u moving before the talent change finishes

digital berry
eager raft
#

do you not use trees at 75s if u have hoc?

digital berry
#

on some bosses you hold third trees but generally yeah youd do that and delay convoke by like 10 seconds

eager raft
# jolly delta

the timings on here dont seem to match what is happening in sim

digital berry
dense steeple
#

i dont wanna do more crest farming this week 😦

digital berry
#

well you're almost done

dense steeple
#

problem is im gonna have to do keys next week anyway

#

so why bother

wet lark
#

Especially vs the mythic prio trinket

exotic perch
#

i mean its just a good trinket dont know what to tell you

safe kite
#

Simming single target chosen of elune is also incredibly pointless.

meager storm
#

What happened to echo awaree

scarlet tapir
#

as it should

#

after what they did to zaelia

digital berry
#

ain't no way

meager storm
#

Isn’t he still banned from competitive

lucid olive
#

rwf is not a blizzard sponsored tournament

maiden pasture
#

from official stuff like mdi he is

#

and he said h's gonna appeal it

meager storm
#

Nah I mean mdi

#

Method world 2nd next tier PauseChamp ?

maiden pasture
#

yeah i think

#

liquid too ahead

eager raft
#

Prob liquid

maiden pasture
#

but maybe in 1 or 2 tiers

lucid olive
#

more like echo and method gonna fight for 2nd

meager storm
#

Nah I meant 2nd

maiden pasture
#

it becomes a 3 horse race

meager storm
#

I just woke up

eager raft
#

gm

meager storm
#

Got the recruitie schedule going on

maiden pasture
#

method got world 2nd jailer

#

when liquid just stopped going for it after not getting first

meager storm
#

I will be there when ID gets world 3rd

eager raft
twilit shard
#

Any good plater profiles for managing dots?

digital berry
#

jundies is the one most people use afaik

scarlet tapir
scarlet tapir
#

and they went home to celebrate and finished after

twilit shard
digital berry
#

should be in the compoendium

#

check pins

glossy slate
#

Do you cast wrath on single target if ur in incarn, with the EC m+ build?

fossil shard
#

source trust me bro

north acorn
#

How much haste should you aim for as keeper of the grove. I have 21% haste and 21% mastery but it keeps wanting me to aim for more versatility

delicate perch
fossil shard
#

bless be with you

delicate perch
fossil shard
delicate perch
glossy slate
#

@people cheers

steady raptor
#

What does it mean? Why so little uprtime?

lucid olive
#

it means you are spending time inside your CD windows not casting

lofty depot
#

ur also not using a 2nd ca

#

what fight is that for

steady raptor
#

One handed bandit

plush prairie
steady raptor
spice pelican
#

hey yall, was wondering if yall had some advice on the add phase on mythic rik? i feel like it takes too long for me to actually do damage to them. currently i just send a moonfire on the far ones and single target the entire time, since the grouped ones usually die fast

fossil shard
delicate perch
meager storm
#

goty and it is not even close

#

they will win every single category

#

the soundtrack

delicate perch
#

ya banger music

#

esquie/monoco such goated characters

proud hinge
#

so it looks like the crafted ring bug on sims is gone, but 681 crafted ring is still simming more than hero track jastors.. anyone elses sims show crafted to be better than jastors?

modest otter
#

Regarding simming for crafted items...Is it better to use droptimizer and run a sim of each stat pair to find the next crafted you should get or adding the crafted item to Top Gear with all the combinations of stats (IE adding consecrated cloak and doing every variation)?

meager storm
#

top gear

proud hinge
#

Damn didn’t realize I didn’t have jastors socketed

digital berry
#

its also a 30k dps loss for me personally to use 681 ring over heroic jastor so idk

lucid olive
#

@vital hound log in alt raid

vague crescent
#

hello all, i am deciding on what to buy with my chips, i currently have hc wax and signet, i am considering to get hc HoC or Mug's or should i get Mythic signet or Wax

lucid olive
#

@delicate perch log in alt raid

vague crescent
#

i simmed it and its simming the mug's jug hc and signet hc is simming better the n mythic signet and wax, is that normal?

meager storm
#

jug is very good

delicate perch
lucid olive
meager storm
#

locked on all toons

#

saved

#

same sht

lucid olive
#

unfortunate

#

afraid of getting beaten on the meters by @lofty depot

meager storm
#

totally

vague crescent
meager storm
#

soacks?

#

if u already have heroic signet, mythic signet and heroic hoc will be a lower increase than not having jug and getting one

jolly delta
#

if you have heroic signet mythic signet and heroic hoc go touch grass

digital berry
#

am i really supposed to focus on the adds on ipa boss?

craggy sonnet
#

kinda yea

digital berry
#

ive been just starfalling without a care in the world

#

so like dot and fire the adds?

craggy sonnet
#

depends what the rest of the group is doing, they dont have to die insta

#

so you could potentially still starfire boss

#

but usually you get some kinda grip/chains on them

#

and then you can dot and starfall ye

digital berry
#

yeah this last 13 i was doing we wiped to it but tbh the warlocks overall was 2.7 mill idk if my starfalling was the culprit, i could have dotted and starfired them for sure tho

glossy jungle
#

cant believe @lyric stag cheated. smh my head. he was meant to be one of the good ones SAD

lyric stag
#

sigh...

#

dirty cheater just like the rest of them...

#

followed EU too hard now NA is infected...

pallid bay
#

Dorki cheater..

craggy sonnet
#

context ples

maiden pasture
#

used shocking disclosure potion

#

which is from dragonflight

#

rules dont explicitly say its not allowd

#

but blizzard decided this v inconsequential thing should DQ them

craggy sonnet
#

huh

#

did shocking disclosure scale well or why is that a thing

maiden pasture
#

just tags mobs

#

good for aggro

normal pilot
#

were the pots on the vendors

maiden pasture
#

no, but the rules say you can craft

craggy sonnet
#

oh, dorki used em

#

ok

maiden pasture
#

and they were craftable

#

just from the vendors that blizzard left in valdrakken

normal pilot
#

seems like a poor gamble to take

maiden pasture
#

echo apparently asked and got told they arent allowed

#

but no one else knew that they said they arent allowed to echo

normal pilot
#

that would've been the smart thing ya

craggy sonnet
#

yea, guess the better question would be why you wouldnt ask

normal pilot
#

well you should've asked

lethal imp
#

Isn’t the procedure to message the mods with any weird strat stuff you are using ahead of time? Did they not do that?

maiden pasture
#

i feel like they should have just

#

said its not allowed from the first dungeon

#

and they would have stopped

#

but to wait until the final dungeon of the day is done

#

and then say yeah but it doesnt count lol

#

seems a bit od

lethal imp
#

It’s kinda on them if they just didn’t ping the mods before using an expansion old item

normal pilot
#

or they should've just asked

#

next time they'll know better

lethal imp
#

I mean sounds like the mods handled it kinda poorly. But ultimately they have the tools to make sure any weird crap they are doing is okay ahead of time

#

And they didn’t use them

craggy sonnet
#

rules dont specify anything about crafting consumables at all, no?

maiden pasture
#

rules werent explicit but implied about this

normal pilot
#

it's old xpac stuff

craggy sonnet
#

what implies it?

normal pilot
#
  • you've been playing wow long enough you know the quality blizz brings
craggy sonnet
#

yea no .. for sure should have asked

normal pilot
#

no reason not to be extra dilligent

craggy sonnet
#

just wondering what they based this DQ on

#

seems a bit weak

lucid olive
#

they broke the rules innit

normal pilot
#

if they used vendors from vald, prolly wrong vendors

craggy sonnet
#

what rule

lucid olive
#

filthy NA cheaters yet again

maiden pasture
#

dorki was tryna do the same and find the exact rule they broke, they couldnt find

normal pilot
#

they're supposed to only use provided vendors

maiden pasture
#

the blizzard admin kept referencing this rule in particular to dorki but wouldnt clarify further and told him "if you have anything further, email us"

craggy sonnet
#

sounds like blizz should have taken the L on this one

normal pilot
#

didn't you say they used vald vendor and not dorn one

fluid perch
#

ideally, what should the uptime on Starlord be for mythic+?

craggy sonnet
#

gear is not consumables

normal pilot
#

that doesn't relaly matter

fluid perch
#

i'm averaging around 75-80% atm

craggy sonnet
#

the profession section says they can craft gear and there are consumables available on vendoirs

normal pilot
#

ya, i assume the tww consuambles can be crafted from tww mats on tww vendors

#

did they go out of the way to vald to get mats from vald vendors?

maiden pasture
craggy sonnet
craggy sonnet
#

but since its a stack based buff, thats not really the deciding factor either

normal pilot
#

ok ya, that could be seen by blizz as violating that rule then.

maiden pasture
#

but again, why wait till the end of the day instead of telling them from the start, they did it in their 16 which was 3 hours before the end of day

#

and they waited until they finished their final dungeon of the day to say anything

normal pilot
#

maybe they were deciding it over, who knows

#

it's blizzard esports

craggy sonnet
#

probably whoever is spectating them during the run thought it was fine

#

and it actually was fine

#

but because someone told another team it wasnt fine

#

they had to turn

maiden pasture
#

its also such an insignificant thing too

lethal imp
# craggy sonnet sounds like blizz should have taken the L on this one

I’m on the side of blizz here tbh. It’s kind of unreasonable to expect them to have perfect ironclad rules that cover every edge case in an open world game with 20 years of content. Putting the onus on the players to pre-approve anything not immediately obvious is the best solution to not having mdis ruined by people finding little tricks from old content that give them a leg up

#

As the viewer, it’s a disaster when a team gets a competitive advantage by using some weird old content trick

#

It feels wrong and illegitimate

mental plover
#

Cheaters get stitches

lethal imp
#

Like that sort of thing makes me not take this serious immediately

#

Because instead of a competition of what it’s suppose to be about, it becomes a competition of who can find the most holes in blizzs rules which is not fun or interesting

craggy sonnet
#

or you are only allowed to use stuff from current expansion or whatever

#

like if you do not provide rigid rules

#

how are things decided on an individual basis

#

if some team asks about something

lethal imp
#

I mean I do agree this is a BIG hole and blizz deserves some smoke for making this mistake. However the solution isn’t to throw your hands up and say “screw it anything goes I guess our bad”

normal pilot
#

on a case by case basis up to blizzard discretion

craggy sonnet
#

are they sure to get the same answer depending on the person asked

normal pilot
#

like how the rules say

maiden pasture
#

the issue is that they didnt remove those vendors when they should have. blizzard rules would cover it fine if they cleaned up the old vendors which they just forgot to do clearly

#

which does make it a gray area

#

which yeah should just be talked about with blizzard

#

as echo did

craggy sonnet
lethal imp
#

I’m not trying to let blizz off the hook for having a gigantic, obvious hole in their rules. I just don’t want them to reward abusing it

normal pilot
#

ya should've known better they've all been dealing with blizz long enough

craggy sonnet
#

it is an obvious blunder to not ask

maiden pasture
#

i think this being not allowed but the perma MD snapping plagueborers being fine is weird lol

craggy sonnet
#

but the rules clearly do not state anything about consumable restrictions

gleaming crown
#

The perma MD snapping was what cause the "you must check with the admins if you plan on using a strat" thing, cause before it was the wild west

dense steeple
#

i just did 3.14mil overall in an 11

lyric stag
#

i replied to the wrong msg but oh well

craggy sonnet
#

haha, just watching the final bits of the yt stream .. and tettles is talking about the workshop dog rooting thing

lyric stag
#

HOLY MOLY there are some takes in here i gotta go

craggy sonnet
#

didnt even realize that was also an mdi used strat. that sounds like it shouldnt be a thing for example

dense steeple
#

no wait

lucid olive
#

yeah bad timing

dense steeple
#

we love you tarisant stay

lyric stag
#

bro i just read

#

"i'm on the side of blizz here tbh. it's kind of unreasonable to expect them to have perfect ironclad rules"

lucid olive
#

love cory

dense steeple
#

80% of the hot takes in here is a meme

lyric stag
#

if that's unreasonable i have zero good things to say LOL

lyric stag
#

i did.

dense steeple
#

also no one even knows who that guy is

lyric stag
#

u are a clown LOL

lethal imp
#

You sure?

#

Kinda sounds like you are

lyric stag
#

"that sort of thing makes me not take this seriously immediately"

maiden pasture
#

i think the idea that a team can ask, get something that is now allowed confirmed and that not get announced to everyone as something thats not allowed is stupid

dense steeple
#

banewlf over here acting like he wouldve played better than tarisant

lethal imp
#

Yeah. Idk what to tell you I don’t give a single shit about who can dig up esoteric old items to gain 30s on their timer

lyric stag
#

SHINU 30 SECONDS LMFAO

lethal imp
#

Like could not possibly care less about that

lyric stag
#

it did 0.000167% of dorki's overall dmg in the key btw

#

706k out of 4.23 billion

lucid olive
#

big cheater !!

maiden pasture
#

all it did was make him tag some mobs in a dungeon they had minutes left on the timer

dense steeple
#

brother dont waste your breath with random white name #124768

maiden pasture
meager storm
lyric stag
#

we brought the scourge of EU cheating to NA...

#

disgusting...

lyric stag
dense steeple
#

fair

#

pull up his parses drag him

lethal imp
#

Well the claim is it is for pulling? Idk I’m making a general claim here. Maybe this was a super mild case. But in general I do not want people “cleverly” finding old shit to exploit. It’s really not interesting and diminishes the part I actually care about

dense steeple
#

full throttle

lucid olive
#

well you could say the closure of this day of MDI was shocking

lyric stag
#

so i would love to hear what random white name #124768 has to say about my runs being DQd yea

#

omg we're already backpedalling YES

dense steeple
craggy sonnet
lethal imp
#

Granted blizzard deserves some heat for this too. I just don’t want to say “well we didn’t tell you NOT to do this so I guess we’ll let it slide”

lyric stag
#

we asked about that dog rooting btw they told us no then came back and said "we don't know how to fix it yet so till we do u can do it"

lethal imp
#

I heard tettles explain it

lyric stag
#

dude i don't know how to nicely tell u this

lucid olive
#

then dont

#

let it rip

lyric stag
#

this is the harshest punishment they've ever given for the most minor "exploit" tgp has ever seen

gleaming crown
#

Vendors exist in tournament realm = free real estate
It is on blizzard to remove the vendors

lethal imp
#

Okay. I agree this punishment might be way too harsh

lyric stag
#

blizz can't even be fucked to remove your old characters

craggy sonnet
#

do you think thats a "strat" you like to watch for the integrity of the competition?

lyric stag
#

u think they are gonna turn off old zones?

#

which btw

lethal imp
#

Like I’d like if they could just rerun their day or something

lyric stag
#

if u go out of where ur SUPPOSED TO BE

#

on TR

#

they port u back to the city

#

i flew around for like 20 mins on TR

craggy sonnet
lethal imp
#

I don’t really want them dqed over this

lyric stag
#

just going diff places

#

then showing what happens if u go out of bounds

#

the rules state that u can't go get old gear, or gear from dungeons/raids

#

you're not allowed to take your vault etc

#

the rules also say

maiden pasture
#

they jsut dont clean up their old shit its stupid.
old vendors left in
old space still in bounds

lyric stag
#

(e) Professions:
Players will be able to craft gear utilizing profession vendors on the servers. Certain profession consumables will also be available including Algari Repair Bot 11O, Irresistible Red Button, and Convincingly Realistic Jumper Cables

lethal imp
#

I’m just saying that it’s an unreasonable ask to make sure they have rules that cover every weird thing you can find in a 20 year old game. Sometimes they just have to say “okay just let us know if you’re doing anything weird beforehand and we’ll tell you if it’s okay or not”

lyric stag
#

the vendors are still in valdrakken and u get all the stuff to craft it by using those vendors

#

the vendors are on the servers

#

it is not an unreasonable ask if they have a "serious esport"

craggy sonnet
#

this isnt anything weird tho really

lyric stag
#

to outline rules.

#

LOL

maiden pasture
#

theyre blaming you for using shit that they shouldnt have left in because technically it fits the rules but they shouldnt have left them in

craggy sonnet
#

its a niche potion

lyric stag
#

ppl use plagueborers, people pull thru walls, people skip RPs

#

nothing ever happens

craggy sonnet
#

that doesnt do anything crazy

lyric stag
#

use a pot to get threat on menial laborers

lethal imp
#

I mean for a proposed rule I do think they should just say “you can ONLY get shit from mdi vendors” and then have an avenue for players to request stuff added mdi vendors

lyric stag
#

dq

lethal imp
#

That would most cleanly solve this issue

lethal imp
#

The vendors they specifically add

gleaming crown
#

Dude the fucking item is in an "MDI vendor"

maiden pasture
lucid olive
lyric stag
gleaming crown
#

The vendor is in fucking valdraken its not a "normal NPC"

lucid olive
#

do you think the vendors in valdrakken are there on the base game or

lyric stag
#

if other teams asked about shockings and got told no, they should have made the same announcement and said don't do this

maiden pasture
#

+1

lethal imp
#

I mean sure. They need to do more to mark what is and is not a vendor. So like “random vendor in veldrakken that we didn’t remove” doesn’t count. Maybe use some sort of naming scheme or something

lyric stag
#

last season they made multiple announcements such as "don't use icy pres" and "don't use this particular MC tech" and "don't make vantus runes for dawnbreaker"

lucid olive
#

just remove the fucking vendor instead lmfao

#

its just 4 layers of blizzard incompetence leading to team getting DQd

lyric stag
#

i lied i don't have time to argue with random white name #124768 this guy is a moron (disrespectfully)

lucid olive
#

joke company

lyric stag
#

it's your $15 please enjoy it how u want tho

lethal imp
#

That would be my proposal. Again I’m not saying they are completely in the right here. And I also don’t necessarily think a full dq is called for (although maybe this is unavoidable due to broadcast scheduling reasons or something?)

craggy sonnet
#

yea, i think they should announce everything they already claimed as "illegal" to other teams

exotic perch
#

oh is there drama in the mdi

gleaming crown
#

They either DQ or dont DQ there is no replay here. DQ is stupid though

lucid olive
#

method recruiting abusers and drama in the MDI

dense steeple
lucid olive
#

its been a saturday for sure

lethal imp
craggy sonnet
lethal imp
#

As unfortunate and unfair as it may feel

#

I would have preferred they just give them some extra time to redo the runs without the potion

dense steeple
#

nah dq wrong play

lyric stag
#

pls i am begging u to go put in hundreds of hours practicing for mdi and then get dq'd and tell me u have the same feeling of how it's the right play

#

u are a moron

exotic perch
#

classic drama saturday

lethal imp
#

But again, they also have a broadcast schedule to maintain

dense steeple
#

the play is the other team lost GG fuck em

exotic perch
#

it isnt a big deal guys EU gonna lose to NA again anyway

gleaming crown
#

I mean how is it possible to craft and item bought from NPCs that were placed in the realm by blizzard (not in this xpac, but they are not in the default game) and say this item is invalid

lucid olive
#

nah yarrgi team gonna win the whole thing

exotic perch
#

(im talking about method here)

craggy sonnet
#

im pretty sure the only reason this "escalated" the way it did, was that another team already asked about it and was told "no"

exotic perch
#

who cares about mdi

dense steeple
#

Tarisant: 1
white name #124768: 0

gleaming crown
#

Also how is it possible to say to team A "Cant use this item" and not make it a general fucking announcement in the MDI discord

dense steeple
craggy sonnet
gleaming crown
#

The lack of a proper fucking workflow is incredible

craggy sonnet
#

and the vendors potentially cleaned up prior to the finals

lethal imp
dense steeple
#

like yeah if someone asks and you go "oh shit yeah you cant do that sorry man"

maybe you turn around as your next move to announce to everyone "hey btw dont do this thing"

lethal imp
#

This is ultimately how all sports and esports work

craggy sonnet
lethal imp
#

So you always favor the viewer experience over the competitor experience when they are at odds

gleaming crown
#

So for the viewers pleasure u give them a worse product by allowing worse teams to qualify and have a lower quality sunday

craggy sonnet
#

your viewer experience did not get affected in the slightest tho

gleaming crown
#

On something that according to the written rules is allowed, but got denied to one team (no other teams had info though)

lucid olive
#

viewer experience

#

are people watching this

lyric stag
#

bro if they didn't DQ us would u have even known that we used the pot?

craggy sonnet
#

idc about them using a potion in two spots in a dungeon for niche reasoning

lyric stag
#

does 706k dmg in the first 15 seconds of the key affect your viewer xp?

#

be so for real rn

lucid olive
lethal imp
#

I mean yeah you’re probably right

craggy sonnet
#

i care way more about that workshop root thing for example

dense steeple
craggy sonnet
#

which completely breaks that area

maiden pasture
#

what happened at blizzard that they didnt tell you off 3 hours prior to the ending, but right after you finished your final key

#

xdd

lethal imp
#

I would have likely never heard of it. Maybe the right play is blizz to keep it quiet

#

And just correct you behind the scenes

loud kettle
#

Why do they even care if people use silly dps pot

#

Its not like an exploit

lethal imp
#

But also what happens if one of your salty competition posted it on Twitter afterwards?

craggy sonnet
#

because they told another team not to

lyric stag
#

yea man we won that key (2mins30 left btw) cause of that 700k dmg

gleaming crown
#

They care cause some guy told some other team they couldnt

lyric stag
#

get real man

#

u are acting like we pulled a boss thru a wall 15 mins before it's accessible

craggy sonnet
#

and that guy did not tell anyone else in the team

gleaming crown
#

And that guy forgot to tell the fucking rest of tournaments admins or mods or whatever
Hey I made a call gamers

craggy sonnet
#

so the blizz spectator that was present IN THE KEYS in question had no clue either that something was going on

loud kettle
#

I wouldn't have even thought to ask about it

lyric stag
#

neither did we

loud kettle
#

Its just a potion man

dense steeple
craggy sonnet
#

i wonder who even spotted it in the end

lyric stag
#

"another competitor"

craggy sonnet
#

and was like WAIIIIIIIIIIIT A MINUTE

#

that would be so funny

dense steeple
#

someone from the team that got told no for sure

craggy sonnet
#

if true

maiden pasture
craggy sonnet
#

well, not funny

#

but

#

yk yk

lethal imp
gleaming crown
#

Some1 going through logs filtering damage done by that pot on all runs xDD

dense steeple
#

"hey blizz you told us we couldnt use it but look dorki is doin it"

lethal imp
#

Which, at least for me, is absolutely not something I want to see

dense steeple
#

if the vendor is there

craggy sonnet
dense steeple
#

its allowed

exotic perch
#

im so confused

craggy sonnet
#

whats the diff

exotic perch
#

isnt mdi supposed to be who can 'cheat' the most

dense steeple
#

take the fucking vendor off if you dont want people using it

#

or, adjust the TR to port you out if you get to vald

lyric stag
craggy sonnet
exotic perch
#

i wanna see the cooked strats man

lethal imp
exotic perch
#

let me see the wild shit yall come up with

gleaming crown
#

You are allowed to go to valdrakken
The vendor is still there in Valdrakken (mdi vendor not normal vendor)
You craft the potion
DQ

lyric stag
#

u keep saying the old world

#

u know it was from last xpac

#

where there were still vendors right

#

like the vendors they add specifically for MDI/TGP

#

u just talk to the tauren and tell him u wanna learn alchemy then buy the brain item from him and it maxes out ur profs and gives u all the recipes

#

then u tell him u want profession knowledge and he gives u a book to give u 1k points

#

ur acting like we flew to val'sharah and killed a rare to get a toy that keeps u in combat for a minute to extend your eye of kezan stacks on long downtimes

#

(which they pinged for and said do not use this)

lyric stag
#

everybody LOL

craggy sonnet
#

hahaha

lyric stag
#

all of the top teams all own the toy

#

but they told us not to use it and said they weren't putting it on the vendor

craggy sonnet
#

yea kezan minmax was obviously something that would come up

loud kettle
#

Worn doll right? Thats been done forever now

gleaming crown
dense steeple
#

that wouldve been siiick

lyric stag
#

yea worn doll

loud kettle
#

For other trinkets too in the past

lyric stag
lyric stag
#

is it wild? cause it's been done for multiple tgps in the past

dense steeple
exotic perch
#

thats pretty awesome tho

#

using toys to keep eye of kezan

lyric stag
#

does that diminish your viewer experience now that u know people were doing that for years?

exotic perch
#

brilliant

lethal imp
#

I appreciate the comedy/novelty of this stuff but yeah I’m happy people aren’t actually getting edges by being allowed to do it

lyric stag
#

i cba

#

LOL

lethal imp
#

However small or large those edges are

exotic perch
#

lets the viewers see what stuff everyone comes up with to shave off 10seconds

lyric stag
#

@dense steeple u win man i shouldnt have

exotic perch
#

please that is the best viewership

dense steeple
#

this is why im orange

#

i know when its a lost cause

#

its okay buddy, youre still green in my book

loud kettle
#

I think everything should go if it works on live, fix ur game blizzard

lethal imp
#

Idk I just don’t want the competition to be “about” finding that stuff, even if it’s only a 0.0000000001% advantage

exotic perch
lethal imp
#

Every sport is about finding items from old ex pacs on wow?

exotic perch
#

if its there use it

delicate perch
#

I do not want people to find better ways to do stuff!!!!!

exotic perch
#

if an old NFL play from 60 years ago works use it (andy reid style)

lethal imp
#

Some things are in bound and some aren’t. Sometimes the line is fuzzy. In this case seems kind of clear to me. Not current content = not okay

loud kettle
#

They were talking about the tush push ban wording and coaches asks if its ok if the qb lines up behind the guard instead of the center

dense steeple
#

this mans never seen an MDI before

exotic perch
loud kettle
#

If there is a way around the rules people will do it regardless of sport

delicate perch
#

yea true that 100 damage zap is insane advantage

exotic perch
#

then tush push is way less effective

delicate perch
#

glad blizz sorted em out!!!!

lethal imp
#

If you found a novel position on a boss that gave you more up time, even if it’s only a tiny damage increase, that would be fine. If you find some old item from tbc that gives you that exact same increase, that would not be fine imo

exotic perch
#

(also fuck philly)

lyric stag
#

ok, i can accept that argument, but if the rules don't state that, then imo that's kind of ridiculous. the admins told us that the rule states vendors that aren't in dornogal aren't allowed to be used, but if u search for "in dornogal" in the rules, one thing comes up - purposefully dropping your key during time trials

#

they cited specifically this rule:
During the full duration of the Mythic Dungeon International, you are only permitted to use the gear provided by the special MDI vendors (you can also use any of the pieces of gear already equipped when you create your character). Acquiring gear on the Tournament Realm from dungeons, raids, or other sources to gain an advantage may result in disciplinary action.

craggy sonnet
lyric stag
#

gear is ambiguous. if that is meant to include consumables, then it should be explicit.

exotic perch
#

im always for abusing anything and everything that you find, fuck it if blizz can balance or see it all

#

like the cheese zskarn strat

lyric stag
#

see how easy it is to be explicit in the rules?

delicate perch
dense steeple
#

anyone remember when echo won an mdi because they snapped the whole dungeon onto a pillar in plaguefall

loud kettle
#

2 healer strat yep

#

That was incredibly based

gleaming crown
#

2 healer 1 tank 1 afk hunter 1 dpser

lethal imp
gleaming crown
#

god tier content

dense steeple
#

imagine teleporting the entire trash count into one easily aoe spot and just get free dam on it

maiden pasture
#

It literally comes down to, blizzard only really want you to use the vendors they put for the current mdi season. They just forgot to remove the old vendors and so the wording allowed you to go to old zones

#

They fucked up and punished you for using their fuck up

dense steeple
#

heres another wild thing though

craggy sonnet
dense steeple
#

you get teleported back to dorn if you go where youre not allowed

lyric stag
#

hey buddy did u pick up that the competitors themselves is me

dense steeple
#

why are you allowed in valdrakken

lyric stag
#

u keep avoiding calling me my name

lethal imp
#

Of course like everyone else if they could just let them do another run in place of a dq, I would be completely happy for that

#

And would prefer it

dense steeple
#

hes being professional

lyric stag
dense steeple
#

referring to you as the competitors

lyric stag
#

sorry my caps lock got stuck

delicate perch
#

sometimes I can hear the competitors still typing here

gleaming crown
delicate perch
#

🕊️

lyric stag
#

LOL

dense steeple
#

🕊️

craggy sonnet
maiden pasture
loud kettle
lyric stag
#

again if we found some insanely broken tech and abused it without asking obviously i'd be like yea we deserve that

#

but DQd over 700k dmg potion when historically everybody gets a slap on the wrist for way worse shit

#

just feels bad i dunno how to explain it to u anymore

lethal imp
maiden pasture
#

DQing a team that won by over 2 mins when the pot probably saved them like 2 seconds of not having to wait for aggro is stupid

lyric stag
#

bro just take all our remaining time and say we timed 21 with 0 seconds left for all i care

#

they took our 18 20 and 21 and left us the 16 OME

#

just take the 16 too bro

#

u can have it

craggy sonnet
#

they would really like it .. actually

#

now that you are offering

dense steeple
#

blizzard cant time 10s

#

ofc they would take the 16

loud kettle
#

They can time 10s, just gotta turn on god mode

lyric stag
#

i think this might be the most i've typed in here in years

#

my bad team

dense steeple
#

dont apologize

dense steeple
gleaming crown
#

So you guys got steamrolled not from 2nd to 3rd but from 2nd to 4th. Actually insane shit

lucid olive
loud kettle
#

That 6 was hard

#

They had uh motion sickness

dense steeple
#

how do you FAIL A 6

lethal imp
lyric stag
#

sorry for calling you names

drifting nova
lyric stag
#

that one is on me

dense steeple
#

proud of you

lethal imp
#

It’s okay. Like I really get it I’m new here, no one, and I’m spouting opinions about philosophy of viewership while you had something you worked for taken away from you for bullshit reasons

loud kettle
#

If they caught u using a pot, imagine all the things they missed tarisant....

lyric stag
#

bro u would not believe

#

the exploiting that is going on rn

lucid olive
#

i hate it when i get caught for using pot

#

fuck the five-o

lyric stag
#

amen

gleaming crown
#

Some1 got turbo boosted shit they shouldnt ???

loud kettle
#

I would believe all the exploiting, but I dont watch mdi unlucky

lucid olive
#

📸

dense steeple
#

honestly it would be WAAY cooler of a viewer experience if you did tarisant

lyric stag
#

LOL

#

it's not gamebreaking it's just something that anyone with a pulse is gonna do

dense steeple
#

can you imagine you just rapid fire exploit tattle on all the teams

#

and blizzard has to either DQ everyone or bring you back

gleaming crown
#

Nah they will just ignore cause it would look bad

#

Its that easy

delicate perch
#

someone being a rat has already opened that up kappa

slim iris
#

Keep exploiting

#

Never stop

#

Don’t let them take that from you

craggy sonnet
#

btw

#

just realized

#

their reason for allowing the workshop thing is that its in the game and they cant fix it right now

#

but these vendors being in the game seemingly not being on them

lofty depot
#

they could fix those vendors not being there

#

so that argument is shit

lyric stag
#

that argument makes perfect sense to me

#

takes 1 second to remove the vendors

#

not hours of dev time to fix the bug

#

if its allowed cause it takes too long to remove, then pots are allowed

#

or?

dense steeple
#

could also just add valdrakken to the no fly list that teleports you back to dorn

lyric stag
#

all they have to do is flag valdrakken outside of the portal room as out of bounds

lofty depot
#

but apparently theyre lazy

#

or obtuse

craggy sonnet
#

could have removed it if its something they dont want in the game

#

they didnt

digital berry
#

Let’s not pretend the people participating in the MDI do not know what they should or shouldn’t be doing

lofty depot
#

then yea, i mean adding and removing vendors is ez

digital berry
#

The fair play logic is so weird cause just because you can doesn’t mean you should

dense steeple
lyric stag
#

holy shit hello white name #124769

dense steeple
#

nono emnithy is normally good take guy

#

we like him

craggy sonnet
#

no .. but telling a team they can in that one case but then essentially DQing another

digital berry
dense steeple
#

hes just coming in late

lyric stag
#

i'm rdy to argue again

lofty depot
#

oh boy

craggy sonnet
#

for something that is on blizzards end to be the way they want it to be

digital berry
#

Nah I’m watching a movie with the husband I ain’t got time to argue

lofty depot
#

nah i need both of u to roll d20s

delicate perch
lyric stag
#

LOL

lofty depot
#

for initiiative

lethal imp
# craggy sonnet for something that is on blizzards end to be the way they want it to be

I mean the unfortunate reality is when blizz makes a mistake like this, the competitors kind of have to pay for it. I know it seems fair to say “blizz fucked up so they should just eat the loss” but usually it’s not their loss (or at least not JUST their loss) but the viewers loss. At least that’s the argument I was trying (and failing) to make

#

And yeah between the competitors and viewers you always must choose the viewers

lucid olive
#

its a huge loss for the viewers cause i cant watch my goat play

delicate perch
#

yeah I love watching people compete then get nitpicked dq'd insane viewing

sacred oracle
jolly delta
#

@lucid olive find me a UI/UX designer

half fern
#

when playing the elune build. do i only cast 2 wrath to get back in eclipse. and then i use starfire even in ST?

jolly delta
#

I'm sure at one point you got a DM from someone that does it

half fern
#

alright thats why im like bruh why is my ST dog water. cause i was doing the wrath in ST

runic onyx
#

The key to getting away with exploiting is being on one of the teams that blizzard is afraid to actually punish, actually. (White name reporting in)

merry crow
#

if echo did it they wouldnt have been dq'd

#

change my mind

half fern
#

wait how we getting DQ i missed something

verbal basin
lyric stag
#

yes

drifting nova
normal pilot
#

can't wait for mdi to require one button usage only to maintain competitive integrity

quiet drift
#

You get given a character template w fixed gear and talents

#

And one button rotation

#

Get em champ

mighty mica
#

f1 vs indy typeshit

proud hinge
#

bc i dont have it rn.. what i have equipped is crafted and cyrces

#

debating on if i should buy hero track jastors

delicate perch
#

if you won't kill mythic bosses your buys are pretty limited

flint sandal
#

Hey lovely boomkins,

#

Resto main here

I've been asked to go Boom for M OAB prog since we only 3 heal and my other healers can't DPS 😛 I haven't DPS'd in raids since I mained Hunter in Cataclysm :p

Would any of you have tips on my talent build/gear/enchants to optimize for OAB?

in addition to the trinkets equipped on my raider IO I also have a Heroic Skardyn core, Heroic Eye of kezan, Mythic Geargrinder's keys. Sadly no HOC of any level.

https://raider.io/characters/us/proudmoore/Leafcast

lofty depot
#

your gear is fine, can sim enchants if u want. build u could run incarn, but most people paly convoke cuz the adds are piss easy now

#

can look at lorrgs for when to save cds

#

u dont run kezan cuz the fight is short

naive fox
#

how is the skardyn core since the changes to it? worth running hero skardyn over champ energy drink?

lofty depot
#

sim it

shy solstice
#

so im seeing in the sim it not casting moonfire?

lofty depot
#

trees

shy solstice
#

its leaving it upto the treant but the uptime is so low

#

should i refresh it even though the sim says not to?

lofty depot
#

press the tree drop down

#

the sim refreshes it

#

those are the moonfire casts

shy solstice
#

oooooo

#

ok!

#

hell yeah

vital hound
#

sundays are actually shit

cerulean summit
#

I'd like to push keys and I play with a havoc dh, what is the ideal comp with havoc dh and boomie?

scarlet tapir
#

Tell ur havoc to spec vdh

verbal basin
#

this person is likely asking a genuine question

#

but you insist on replying with some absolute garbage

#

this is why WoW will die, we do not let those trying to learn, learn.

quiet drift
vital hound
verbal basin
verbal basin
vital hound
#

if you care about comp you're not playing havoc

verbal basin
#

I feel you have less IO than it takes to be a top 50 havoc.

wild dune
verbal basin
#

and i can tell you, they care about comp.

scarlet tapir
#

Not hard being top 50 havoc barely anyone plays that spec

verbal basin
#

I would also bet you do not fall in that range.

scarlet tapir
#

I do dont worry

#

Wouldn't expect someone to be called ilovewoman and have a kpop group in the pfp to do tho

verbal basin
#

I am top 50, also my region clears yours in M+

vital hound
quiet drift
scarlet tapir
#

Bro is NOT EU

verbal basin
#

You're right

#

thank God

#

Chinese

quiet drift
#

Take it to dms brocachos

digital berry
#

No no this is entertaining continue

lofty depot
#

so ur region doesnt clear his