putting up the rag

[thin ember]

ok

👍

[regal cave]

wow

[toxic osprey]

the reason i am doing this is..... theres no reasonable way to continue suggestions, all good ones are taken
i try to do sensible ones but they say its to close to real jokers
i try to make something fun and people hate it cause its fun but unbalanced

only thing left to suggest is just meme jokers which to be frank are useless to suggest in the first place cause they wont get in the game or balance patches which i don't have enough experience to make judgement calls on

[dreamy magnet]

A) no need to make an announcement about this

B) giving up is equivalent to saying you don't want to learn how to balance them better, the point of people commenting is to point you in the right direction because your Joker idea is interesting

Alot of suggestions here go unanswered because they're either not seen, or people don't find them interesting

[cobalt glacier]

obviously your choice, but I'll just say that if you want to get better at game design and balance, this is probably one of the less painful ways to do so(beats having to watch a playtest that goes wrong, anyway)

[acoustic hill]

the thing is when you rebalance your joker, no one really cares about it after that point, so you have to get it right the first time in order for anyone to say anything good about the joker/concept in the first place. No one wants to see another post about the same joker/concept again, so after that set of feedback, you've now reached the pinnacle of it's design! (woohoo).

[dreamy magnet]

I cam say that's wrong gladly, I've often had full discussions about ideas and had 3-4 different iterations made

Idea quality, how fast you respond, how much you taker redesigning into your own hands, they all play a part

[lost arrow]

same here, I've had so many ideas I've posted multiple times and I've gotten feedback from people every time, and I eventually created good versions of the jokers.

[toxic osprey]

been there done that

[thin ember]

i say this with the most respect possible, but idk who you are and i dont think 95% of the people here do either

[toxic osprey]

exactly, im a nobody who is trying to change the game in some big way but has learned that's not possible

[thin ember]

ok so why are you announcing this

[toxic osprey]

cant a person vent in peace?

[mortal quest]

I think the comments in the top said it nicely, the point of suggestions is to improve the game, and while unbalanced and fun jokers are great as a mod (ahem cryptid), they actively make the base game worse. Your ideas are interesting and fun, but if you don't take balance into consideration it would make it less fun.

If you're going to give up, then that's okay, but saying it for pity isn't really all that necessary

[cobalt glacier]

If it makes you feel any better, there’s no way in hell any of these suggestions are making it in(if they do, it’ll be purely out of coincidence)