Officer

[nimble snow]

pointless

[lunar pulsar]

Why

[nimble snow]

We already have Deceiver and Vigilante

[lunar pulsar]

This role is very different tho from them

[restive island]

I think it’s pretty good

Yeah vigi and deceiver they don’t become mad mate they just kill and also vigi has one kill

[lunar pulsar]

They can become madmates

[nimble snow]

The only difference is that Officer can become Madmate, and Deceiver doesn't have such a disadvantage.

[restive island]

Yeah but I mean if they got killed they don’t

[lunar pulsar]

What about the NK twist

[restive island]

Yeah but deceiver doesn’t kill

[lunar pulsar]

Deceiver can kill just they kill is more indirect

[nimble snow]

It forbids Evil roles to kill. This is tantamount to killing, since Crew can simply complete tasks and win by doing so.

[nimble snow]

Worse than Deceiver. That's all this twist gives.

[lunar pulsar]

Deceiver is op anyway :p

[restive island]

I think what would be better that if he kills an evil role he becomes madmate

[nimble snow]

No, because he kills Crewmates, and only forbids Evil roles to kill. That is, in theory, Deceiver can ruin game for Crew.

[nimble snow]

Pointless

[restive island]

Is everything pointless

[lunar pulsar]

Officer makes the game interesting because you never know if they become imp sided or not

[nimble snow]

This only makes sense if Officer will be Neutral. Something like Thief from TOR.

[lunar pulsar]

Also I think we are lacking CK roles tbh

[restive island]

Ok if he kills crew he dies and if he kills imposter he becomes mad mate

But I don’t think gamer will like that

[lunar pulsar]

Then it will become a imp special role then crewmetes

[nimble snow]

We have a fair number of Crew roles that have a kill button. It makes no sense to guess if Officer is on Imp side, if in this case he can NOT kill.

[restive island]

If it’s a crew role then why is it does it become madmate

Like he can make someone kill him and boom madmate

[nimble snow]

That is, it will be Crew role, which can't benefit Crew? After all, if he kills Evil, he himself becomes Evil.

[restive island]

No gamer Said if evil kills him he becomes madmate

[lunar pulsar]

Only imps

[restive island]

The it’s a troll role

[lunar pulsar]

Neutral can kill officer

[nimble snow]

Gamer said it, but you suggested something else.

[restive island]

Like he can kill anyone ez

There is gonna be a lot of trolls

[lunar pulsar]

Trolling is fun tho

[restive island]

Or public players thinking there imp

It’s like a random sheriff shot

[lunar pulsar]

That's a rando issue not ours

[nimble snow]

Just make it a Neutral role that joins the team if it kills the killing member of that team.
Kill Sheriff = Crew side
Kill Disperser = Imp side
Kill Jackal = Jackal side

[restive island]

But you can’t die

[lunar pulsar]

You can die smh

[restive island]

Yeah but it’s hard

You can t die from imposters or sheriff

[lunar pulsar]

Sheriff can kill you after you become mad

[restive island]

Yeah but what if are not

You*

[lunar pulsar]

How about if they have the trickster effect where mad officer will be shown as good to crew roles to make it different

[restive island]

I think what would be good is like he’s goal is to win as madmate

[nimble snow]

Okay, you're still debating this role, which is just useless for Crew. I suggested the perfect solution, and now I can only wish you good luck and leave. Bye

[restive island]

If he wins as crew he doesn’t win

[lunar pulsar]

Wth are you even suggesting

[restive island]

I think what would be good is he tries to find the imposter and kill him so he becomes madmate and win with imp

Or any natural you can add that setting if you want

[naive ingot]

sounds like unlimited shot vigilante

[lunar pulsar]

Smh its a bit different then just unlimited shots vigilante

[worldly latch]

._.